5 ms·
Led by Stanford’s 5%, Top Colleges’ Acceptance Rates Hit New Low
- egillie 13y agoCrazy -- it's already halved from 2006, when it was 10.8%
- not_paul_graham 13y agoIt is likely to keep hitting new lows unless these colleges drastically increase the number of seats that they have on offer (which is unlikely if they want to maintain the aurora of attracting and educating the best and brightest). More students want to attend college than ever. The ease of the common app takes the pain out of requesting "paper applications" from colleges individually and college ranking lists are available for all to see. Most students have colleges segregated into: 1.) top choices; 2.) middle of the pile; 3.) safety schools and it is mostly always the case that a lot of students are qualified enough to be at these institutions, so it is likely that this group will apply to the top 5 or 10 colleges because he fits the profile of the student most likely to attend these institutions. Almost 30% of applicants are applying to 7 or more colleges and these low acceptance rates will only perpetuate the increase in this ~30% figure because students are afraid that they won't get into the top two college categories. From the article: > Students applying to seven or more colleges made up just 9 percent of the applicant pool in 1990, but accounted for 29 percent in 2011. > ..students send more applications than they once did, abetted by the electronic forms that have become nearly universal, and uniform applications that can make adding one more college to the list just a matter of a mouse click. On another note I was recently talking with a CS professor and he mentioned that rankings are highly correlated with the years that an institution has been in existence which is worth thinking about.
- markdown 13y ago> which is unlikely if they want to maintain the aurora of attracting and educating the best and brightest aura
- akgerber 13y ago>On another note I was recently talking with a CS professor and he mentioned that rankings are highly correlated with the years that an institution has been in existence which is worth thinking about. Compound interest over 300+ years buys very good professors.
- guyzero 13y agoPer the article, this is really an increase in number of applications per student rather than any other change. There hasn't been a net reduction in the number of students accepted somewhere.
- michaelochurch 13y agoSure, but the effect of that is to make everything more random and a lot less meritocratic. Pedigree travels everywhere and is legible. Merit is impossible to demonstrate. Merit plus a noise term is easy to demonstrate. The noisier the process, the more of an advantage pedigree has over merit. For example, a blue-blooded asshat like Evan Spiegel will be able to get into every college no matter what happens, even though he's (by Ivy/Stanford standards) a joke. On the other hand, I've heard of IMO medalists getting turned away in this (after 2006 or so) brave new world. Any system that has Evan Spiegels outranking IMO medalists is completely broken.
- ForHackernews 13y agoTop schools are always looking for "leaders" (by which they mostly mean people who go on to be prominently successful in business and/or politics). Speigel certainly fits this mold, far more than a math prodigy who'd be more likely to wind up an anonymous quant in some financial firm.
- michaelochurch 13y agoTop schools are always looking for "leaders" (by which they mostly mean people who go on to be prominently successful in business and/or politics). Corrected: kids whose parents know how to play the game and have the resources to make sure their kids win it. For all the complaints people make about the SAT, that's actually the most meritocratic component of the admissions process by far. The "leadership" stuff might give middle-class clueless a warm/fuzzy feeling, but it's designed specifically to keep them out. Speigel certainly fits this mold He's a product, not a leader. Someone saw him and said, "he seems like a douchebag". Right now, douchebags are in style in the VC-funded/spider-pooping circuit. If you're looking to produce someone and sell him to your VC friends in order to sway the herd, douchebags are the least risky choice right now. far more than a math prodigy who'd be more likely to wind up an anonymous quant in some financial firm. IMO medalists have the talent to do much more. The Spiegels, on the other hand, are useless unless lifted/"produced". They create nothing, but what they are told to make. Of course, some very smart people get lazy and complacent later in life-- it happens to all sorts of people for all kinds of reasons-- but there's no way to forecast that for teenagers.
- gradstudent 13y ago> Stanford received 42,167 applications for the class of 2018 and sent 2,138 acceptance notices, for a first-year class that, ultimately, will number about 1,700. 2018? What?
- devindotcom 13y agoIf you go to school in the fall of 2014, it's likely you'll graduate in 2018.
- DanAndersen 13y agoIf the students are expected to start in 2014 and do 4 years of university, then they would be the class of 2018.
- nathannecro 13y agoThey'll join in the Fall of 2014. Graduate in the Spring of 2018. Thus. Class of 2018.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- michaelochurch 13y agoIn the US, college classes are numbered by graduation year, presumed to be 4 years after the start. So Fall 2014 starters would be class of 2018.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoIt's an American thing: your class is the expected year you will graduate, not the year you entered as in other parts of the world (like China).
- dpeck 13y agoThere has been a seemingly endless number of articles the last few years about how "affordable" top tier schools can be for kids coming from lower/middle income families. This is the natural progression from that.
- duaneb 13y agoIt's also actively driven downward by the colleges themselves—no value in accepting more people!
- scarmig 13y agoColleges have low admission rates. Students send out more applications. Colleges lower admission rates. Etc. What's the stable equilibrium here? It's a complicated matching problem that's driving up costs, stress, and randomness for everyone. Maybe something like how medical residencies are doled out? The question is how to keep costs under control...
- rkuykendall-com 13y agoProbably a single app, or a few "single apps" for similar colleges. Texas has a single website for applying to all the public universities, and each application only requires the information you didn't supply in the previous applications. https://www.applytexas.org/ https://www.applytexas.org/
- guyzero 13y agoGiven that a 4-year degree costs from $40K to $100K with all the costs, it's pretty trivial to spend $1K on applications. And application fees are probably self-funding. I doubt there's any incentive for schools to try to limit the number of applicants.
- harvestmoon 13y agoDon't you mean from 0-$200,000? (It's even possible to make money from going to college, oddly enough. A college acquaintance of mine posted how she got more scholarships than school cost.)
- noobermin 13y agoOne of the relevant issues here is that the top colleges have are essentially a better bet wrt prestige vs. other colleges. The fact that the college educated adult in the US is not as capable as the average college educated adult in a developed country world-wide (in OECD countries, see[1]) to me tells me how there is some truth to this perception. There is no denying that a physicist from Harvard is far above the average in the world, the problem is that if you're not from Harvard, statistics like these seem to imply that you aren't even prepared to be average. The problem here is that the Ivys suck up all the intelligent people and professors and the rest of us are left with less bright people (bright no doubt, but not "Ivy" material). Unless you can make it into the club, you won't be as prepared as your smarter and/or luckier peers. The problem is that we in the US are doing fantastic in raising up the best of us (those who get into Harvard) but the average has obviously fucking languished. Personally, one way I think we can help at least somewhat is for government not to exclusively fund only these Ivys, but to cut off some for the rest of us (you know, judge research by its merit). Other than that, I'm at a loss for ideas It wouldn't be too bad to not go to Harvard if the local state uni wasn't that much worse. [1] http://www.oecd.org/statistics/datalab/skills-outlook.htm http://www.oecd.org/statistics/datalab/skills-outlook.htm
- noobermin 13y agoNot sure why I was downrated. A rebuttal would be nice.