11 ms·
Whatever goes up, that’s what we do
- mikeg8 13y agoIf that quote at the end is accurate, that would be a very disappointing culture to be apart of.
- cliveowen 13y agoFacebook stopped innovating 4 years ago, it's become boring. I only use the Messenger app now.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- swombat 13y agoOf course, because money is the only criteria that is important to any business. There couldn't possibly be anything else, like a sense of mission or purpose, that could inform decisions.
- kordless 13y agoCognitive dissonance at its finest, folks.
- res0nat0r 13y agoHard to have a sense of mission or purpose when your company goes out of business and you can't pay the bills.
- mathattack 13y agoOnce you take outside money, you have to give up the sense of purpose if it conflicts with collecting money. This is more an issue of optimization versus long term vision. Some firms can act like Apple, ignore feedback, and invent the future. That's very rare. The rest must react to feedback.
- hpriebe 13y agoThis is interesting in respect to @harrf's comment above. He says, "Given an existing user base, on average 30% will hate any given change to their user experience, independent of whether the that experience is actually worse or better." I wonder how @harrf's number would play out over time as users adjust, get used to, and accept changes the way many Apple users do. I'm not convinced that designers always know what's best for users, but I do think it sometimes takes a little while for users to catch on to the long-term benefits designers are designing for.
- snowwrestler 13y agoFacebook was very carefully structured so that investors cannot oust Zuckerberg.
- mathattack 13y agoYes. Google too. That's very rare though. Even still, you have to expect those investors to demand attention to the current value of their investment.
- wrongc0ntinent 13y agoThere is only one core product that Facebook has. It's not a platform for anything other than that. Any new features must pass that test, and the implementation of this one didn't.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mtgentry 13y agoZuck is brilliant at many things. But when someone says he's great at product, I raise an eyebrow. Seems to me they A/B tested their way to the top. FB today reminds me of Google 5 years ago. Their 41-shades-of-blue-testing days. But Google learned to listen to more right-brain arguments so maybe FB can too.
- pbreit 13y agoFacebook's biggest shortcoming is that it appears to have no ability to roll out a new product. I would be much more impressed if Facebook were able to crush Instagram, Whats App or SnapChat. It certainly has the resources but apparently not the know-how.
- elwell 13y agoIt's not just about "known-how". Many people downloaded Instagram because it was cool and precisely because it wasn't Facebook.
- sharkweek 13y agoI think you're definitely right that a non-arbitrary number of people fit that description, but I think most are likely similar to me in that I downloaded Instagram because my friends were on Instagram - If Facebook had created a photo sharing/editing app this good directly into their news feed, I kind of assume it would have been a hit. Who knows though...
- jklp 13y agoThey tried to, with Facebook Camera - https://itunes.apple.com/au/app/facebook-camera/id525898024?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/au/app/facebook-camera/id525898024?...
- cemregr 13y agoMessenger?
- thisishugo 13y agoIt baffles me that businesses such as Facebook seem to be driven so heavily by the numbers. If I were the FB product manager given the choice between a News Feed that is pleasant to use, or one that at times feels actively user-hostile but provides better metrics, I would want to have the freedom to pick user happiness over the bottom line, in no small part because I would (I assume) be one of those users. I can't help but feel that something has gone wrong when Facebook - or any company - will deliver its users a worse product for the sake of few more dollars.
- nemothekid 13y ago>will deliver its users a worse product for the sake of few more dollars Its hard - we don't know if its a "few" more dollars, the article and facebook doesn't share this info. If it possibly meant that each user was spending half as much time on facebook, which could possibly meant half as much revenue for the company - what choice do you have? As a product manager, are you willing to graze half of company because a new feature that is pretty, but costs the company a fortune? Arguably there are those who have considered the iPhone a worse product because of its locked down nature. Does Apple deliver a worse product for the sake of a "few more dollars?" Even then you have to consider is the App Store ecosystem, the relatively high quality of iPhone Apps, and ease-of-use-through-handcuffs just worth a few more dollars?
- oneeyedpigeon 13y agoOf course, you have to take into account advertising performance. I don't have any figures to back this up, but I haven't seen any to the contrary so I'm going to hypothesise that ads on a really nice site that people enjoy using are going to do better than on a site that's horrible and pisses people off. Plus, the former gives people more spare time to click ads and buy stuff. I don't think the 'more time viewing pages with ads on = more money' is the full story.
- incompatible 13y agoI suppose Facebook can get away with it as long as the barriers to competition are high enough. If competition was possible then users would presumably use the site with the best interface.
- pbreit 13y agoMaking something easier to glance at doesn't necessarily mean it's better. I think a better design for something like Facebook is something that's more engaging. This isn't search.
- roc 13y agoWhich is just begging the question of whether more time/more hits == more engagement.
- mkbrody 13y agoCulture is internal marketing. The numbers are what really matters.
- mikeg8 13y ago> The numbers are what really matters. To survive, yes. To make the the deepest impact, no.
- mkbrody 13y agoAmazon's UI will never be considered beautiful, but it's core strategy of focusing on the numbers has allowed it to accomplish more than 99.9% of companies ever formed. I'm sure they've sacrificed many redesigns in the name of numbers to get to where they are. FB could implement a redesign, look cool for another 15 minutes, and then have ad revenue dry up, less money for R&D and acquisitions, look bad in the press & on Wall Street, and then blip out after another "cool" redesign. To also back up my point, if Zuckerberg and the upper echelon of Facebook think this way, they're probably right, considering they have a proven track record of making good decisions and more insider knowledge than anyone else on the subject.
- k-mcgrady 13y agoA depressing thought but important especially if you are running a startup. It's ok for Facebook to take a hit like this and revert but if you spend 6 months at your startup redesigning your product and even though people like it your revenues suffer massively you might not even have time to test and revert back.
- higherpurpose 13y agoIt seems Facebook really is going through the Google phases, and they've always wanted to "be Google" anyway. Right now they're in the Google phase of 5-7 years or so ago, when Google was still doing everything by the numbers, even at the expense of UI and UX. Just like Google of 5-7 years ago, they're also spreading their focus on many projects, and in a few years probably forgetting about them and ignoring them, if they don't turn into big cash cows for them almost immediately. Then expect Facebook to kill a lot of services, just like Google did.
- coppolaemilio 13y agoThe've already killed the mailing service :(
- waterlesscloud 13y agoWhat I take from this is that Dustin Curtis plays Farmville and is a member of a shadowy group named "secret group". Actually, the question of the piece is a good one. It's really about what you're optimizing for. As every halfway decent manager knows, you get what you measure. Which means deciding what to measure is one of the most important decisions you can make. So, in this case, do you measure user engagement time for individual sessions? Or is there some sort of "engagement longevity" which might show a better timeline keeps people visiting more often over a longer period of time? The other possible approach would be to see what could be done to make events and profile pages more appealing to spend time on. There may not be a way to do that if the timeline satisfies people, but it would be worth investigating.
- pavel_lishin 13y ago> Which means deciding what to measure is one of the most important decisions you can make. Sounds like we should be measuring our decisions about what to measure!
- jessaustin 13y agoHaha pretty soon we'll be measuring something new every week!
- ampersandy 13y agoIt seems like you said that disdainfully/sarcastically, but if you had metadata about thousands of experiments and the ability to do a meta-analysis on that data; wouldn't you? It seems like a great opportunity to identify potentially destructive trends in the way your company runs experiments.
- ploxiln 13y agoAnd there's things you can't measure, like long-term reputation and habit forming. I think long-term reputation is how a lot of good startups become successful against big, organized, optimizing companies.
- 13y ago
- elleferrer 13y agoAt the end of the day, data and numbers are powerful. They scream credibility. They shout, "you did your homework!" But they won’t be as effective as they could be if you don't use them wisely.
- pjaspers 13y agoThis reminds me of the RealNetworks [0] story a few weeks back. [0] https://medium.com/launching-ux-launchpad/385ff833f9c8 https://medium.com/launching-ux-launchpad/385ff833f9c8
- grey-area 13y agoThis really reminds me of the depressing way that Google optimised the blue colour of a button, while ignoring all other considerations: http://stopdesign.com/archive/2009/03/20/goodbye-google.html http://stopdesign.com/archive/2009/03/20/goodbye-google.html If you trust your metrics and nothing else, you have to be very sure that your metrics encompass every aspect of the reality you are modelling. If they just tell you about clicks and sales, they might be missing longer-term objectives like user satisfaction and retention.
- harryf 13y agoMeanwhile another interesting read - http://jeffdechambeau.com/friending-fast-and-slow.html http://jeffdechambeau.com/friending-fast-and-slow.html
- grey-area 13y agoThanks, that's really interesting.
- gfodor 13y agoI've never worked at Google and I can respect the sentiment, but it seems to me that if you are a skilled designer that Google's massive audience and experimental capabilities can cut both ways. It means that you have to prove even the most minor design changes, but it also means that you have the ability to really prove your work is helpful and not fool yourself. If you make a few small wins you surely can build up the credibility to take bigger steps -- the catch is though in my experience bigger steps never improve metrics anyway and are a waste of time since you end up having to throw more work out. I would kill to be able to run a 0.1% test on a large change and not disrupt things too much, while still getting statistical significance. Few places other than Google seem to have the traffic to do that.
- grey-area 13y agoI'd dispute that many design changes can be proven in any meaningful way. There are too many variables, and optimising for clicks on one button might affect all others on a page. It's very hard to measure everything at once, and it doesn't sound like Google tried in this instance.
- corresation 13y agoThis sounds contrived. Being the skeptical sort we should all be, there is no reason to believe the sources (if you believe they exist) regarding supposed cynical reasons they didn't proceed with a considered UI. Maybe Facebook found that people really actually liked the other variant better? Or maybe they were just ambivalent about it, and if we've learned anything about widely deployed social media sites, it's that you need a really, really good reason to change things. And to add just a bit more on the "contrived" notion: My Facebook feed looks very similar to the first page, with big, colourful pictures dominating my news food. If my network had people posting short twitter-like missives, I suppose it would look like that. Outside of trivial CSS differences, the only real variation is that I don't have the confusing iconography down the left, instead using that massive area of white space for descriptive text.
- addMitt 13y agoIt wasn't just the style. It would separate content into easy to digest categories. You could pull up a picture feed (from that top-right section) and just see new pictures. It would filter stuff like music/pictures/game shit/etc into categories, and deliver more focused content in each category. The primary News Feed wasn't as cluttered with bullshit. It made it easier to ignore things like game notifications. Accordingly, we could see the content we wanted to, faster. Which is bad, because we don't forcefully digest as much undesired content as before. Meaning we leave the site faster and don't look at as many ads. And thus, it's more profitable to stick with the shitty News Feed that is essentially your only source of compiled information from your network, outside of group/list feeds that filter content by user, but not type of content. I was really looking forward to the filter-by-type-of-content direction, but I'm sure it's now something they'll leave in their back pocket, should they start losing numbers directly due to user experience.
- goshx 13y agoFacebook's new design is looking a lot like the very old Orkut's design.
- akamaka 13y agoNice theory, but I think Dustin's conclusions are wrong. I got to use this alternative design on my second Facebook account that I used for app development, while my personal account didn't have it enabled. I really disliked like the new sidebar design. The concept was similar to what GMail has done lately, with text links replaced by only graphical icons. I found it really difficult to remember what each icon linked to, and I'd have to go through and hover over each icon one by one. My theory (which I think has as much evidence to back it up as Dustin's) is that if the feed performed better in this design, it was because the poorly designed menu made it more difficult to navigate the rest of the site!
- colmvp 13y agoI wouldn't be surprised if a lot of people (including myself) just need the feed. I personally preferred the clean approach because outside of Events, I never need the left navigation. Now it obnoxiously takes up a segment of the page and the main content in the center feels tight especially with the bigger typography.
- Geee 13y agoOn the contrary, I don't need the feed at all. I use just the messaging features. I never post on the feed and everything I share is in the private or group messages.
- gumby 13y agoIf you don't need the feed you don't even need the web browser since the message system is bog standard jabber. I do my FB messaging through Messages on my Mac and the FB Messages app on my phone. Works great.
- batiudrami 13y agoBog standard Jabber except for the changes they make - group messaging, 'seen' notifications, in line attachments, 'stickers' are all proprietary stuff which a standard jabber client doesn't support, unfortunately. Their Facebook Messenger for Windows client was discontinued earlier this month unfortuntaely, so I'm back using Trillian and boy do I miss the group messaging feature.
- apalmer 13y agoThere are metrics and then their are metrics. If a new design causes the amount of money the company makes to go down... then its not a 'good' design by business standards. And its more rational to say here are concrete numbers clearly affecting the bottomline vs well our 5 experts think this design is better so we are sticking with it.
- colmvp 13y agoThere can be a difference between good design that users prefer vs. good design that aligns with business goals.
- Soarez 13y agoIt's ok as long as you're sure you're looking at the right numbers.
- nedwin 13y agoSpeaking of numbers going up, I'd love to hear how Svbtle is going these days. Don't seem to hear much from the inside since the funding announcement over 12 months ago...
- calbear81 13y ago... or that beauty doesn't necessarily convert better. We've seen this time and time again with sites like Craigslist and Ebay and recently 42Floors wrote about a similar experience when experimenting with radically different search result treatments. I really do like the new treatment and I think they should have gone with this and figured out how to recover the revenue stream later. Given how much Facebook traffic is going to mobile instead of desktop, this wouldn't have a large impact over the long run.
- modeless 13y agoThis article makes one big unstated assumption: that users wanted the news feed to change. In fact, users didn't want the news feed to change. Users hate change. And when I say that I don't mean that users are stupid and hate good things. Users have good reasons for hating change that's forced on them: it reduces the value of their previous experience and requires extra time and effort on their part; effort that they'd rather be spending on things they actually care about. Users didn't want the news feed to change, and the users were right.
- Mz 13y agoYou make me think of QWERTY keyboards and how they remain the most common format globally in spite of being intentionally designed to be inefficient. Some people seem to believe in an "ideal world" and let that interfere with interacting with actual reality in a practical way. Things need to be backwards compatible with user experience to succeed. New designs sometimes simply are not that.
- ForrestN 13y agoOn the contrary, QWERTY is a great example to contradict the above comment. If things worked as we want them to, we should have moved to more efficient layouts a long time ago, right? Net productivity would be dramatically higher even if there was an initial lull, and the earlier we had done that the better off we'd be in aggregate. In other words, the ubiquity of QWERTY represents a failure of the current mode, where "the market" is behaving with an irrational obsession with the short term. Likewise, preserving a worse facebook design indefinitely because it might require effort to adapt to seems obviously misguided. I suspect that the issue here is what is and isn't better. I don't know if I buy that previous changes that sparked outrage were improvements, and I think it's possible that people really were reacting to liking the new system less, not just that it was unfamiliar.
- greyskull 13y agoQWERTY was intentionally designed to be inefficient? I thought it was based on statistics of common letters or something. Care to shed some light?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 13y agoThe alternate design isn't "performing too well" by not telling you which of your friends are online to chat with, like the current version does. It's just decluttering, and relegating that important function to one of many miniscule, unlabelled icons. It's not "performing too well" by rendering links in the same colour as body text, and making the search function look like a header: it's just making them subtly less obvious, which matters when your users are in the hundreds of millions and some of them really aren't that savvy. (Possibly it matters even more with casual users who are web-savvy, in that you're missing an opportunity to encourage them to search by prominently positioning the sort of medium white box that makes them think about searching) Whatever is cleanest and most elegant is not necessarily the most user-friendly design, never mind the optimal design from the point of view of user engagement.
- jbaskette 13y agoVery good observations. You made obvious to me most of what I did not like in that new design. My first reaction to the look of the new design is that is made each entry much larger filling the screen making the text less noticeable and having fewer posts on a page. A useful design for me will be concise so I can scan more quickly.
- wpietri 13y agoThe thing that makes me really insane about this approach is how mindless it ends up being. If you're going to abdicate all responsibility to some set of metrics, it's the opposite of thinking. The numbers become a capitalist lullaby that switches everybody's brains off. If you're going to work strictly by the short-term numbers, you might as well be the bubonic plague. "Good news! We're up 32% in London! Quarterly bonuses for all the fleas, and gift cards for the rats at the all-hands!"
- dudus 13y ago[citation needed]
- adw 13y agoThe assumption here is that we know, because we're geniuses, what a good user experience looks like. That's aggressive.
- dhawalhs 13y agoFB could probably do an open graph search to figure out who gave him that information "Friends of Drew Curtis who work at Facebook"
- eldude 13y agoThis is the result of placing the burden of proof on vision and innovation. Companies optimize for local maxima at the expense of global maxima because proving that both the mountain exists in the distance and that you can reach it, turns out to be extremely difficult. And so, in companies like Facebook and Google, it doesn't matter what you know, it only matters what you can prove. Meanwhile your competitors in the market are unburdened by the need for proof and shout down at you from the mountain in the distance when they arrive.
- bqe 13y agoI also thought of local maxima and hill climbing algorithms. How do you encourage finding a global maxima within your company?
- eldude 13y agoI think the human subconcious mind is capable of levels of pattern-matching and intuitions that manifest as vision: aka something you "know" but can't necessarily explain. Visions aren't always correct, but they're enhanced by immersing yourself in the relevant context and data to provide your subconscious mind ample time and information to make those connections to generate those "Aha" moments called inspiration. Richard Feynman described in one of his books the best way to appear like a genius is to always be actively learning at least 3 new unrelated topics, and you will glean patterns and details from everywhere to constantly increase you understanding of these topics, leading to inspiration.
- xg15 13y agoIf we assume that the "UI design by metrics" approach actually works, I wonder, why would we need designers at all? Shouldn't then the most rational choice be to start with a crude initial design an use a reinforcement learning algorithm to optimize it according to the metrics?
- weixiyen 13y agoTheoretically that is possible if you could somehow actually show all the possible permutations of a design and throw it at enough users, but there simply are not enough users where you can get very far with such a test. Thus we still need people in this world who can design with empathy for the average user.
- steven2012 13y agoThis is essentially what happened in my group when I was at Yahoo. Our group spent several months on a redesign that made it significantly more modern and easier to use. After it went live, though, this decreased the number of ad clicks by a significant number, and the people in charge hurriedly reverted all the changes back, since they needed to make their revenue numbers in order to make their bonus. When you are stuck in a company that can't innovate because a shitty site leads to more money due to inertia, then you know you are on your way down. This leads to your best developers thinking "what the fuck did I waste all my time for?" and they will leave in no uncertain terms.
- ignostic 13y agoI've actually faced a similar situation, and let me tell you it was hard. Companies like Yahoo exist to make money - or, at least, they must continue to make money in order to continue existing. Like Dustin said, > "This is truly a nightmare scenario for any CEO: do you take the risk and proceed with the better user experience/product at the expense of short term numbers–with no promise that the better design will actually lead to long-term benefits–or do you scrap the new design and start over?" Would the simplified, modern design have led Yahoo into a new era of profitability? Maybe. Or maybe they'd just have a nicer site that made less money for a year. Our team made a site that made less per visitor, but we felt like it was a better-looking and more useful site. We decided to stick with it and work out the kinks, but ~6 months went by without reaching our old sites' benchmark. There was a ton of pressure on me to make it work or admit defeat and revert. I nearly gave in as the stress built, but eventually revenue surpassed the old site. I later learned that I was almost fired over it. My story has a happy ending, but just barely. I have sympathy for the people making these decisions.
- ignostic 13y ago> "We're blind." ... "Everything must be tested." And your solution is to do LESS TESTING? We don't know what we're doing, so let's cut back on the amount of data we can use to inform our decisions? > "We are slaves to the numbers. We don’t operate around innovation. We only optimize." I don't see why numbers should ever stop you from innovating. The difference between "innovating" and "optimizing" is just a difference of scale. You can make a huge change to your layout or site function and look at the numbers it the same way you'd look at a font and color change. The quote above seems to say that people shouldn't make decisions based on numbers, and that's absurd for a company like Facebook. What should be the basis of their decisions then? Management's gut reaction? Whoever feels the strongest about a change wins? Customer surveys and user metrics matter - both are often numbers. The real issue here isn't that Facebook uses numbers too much. If they made the wrong choice, it's because they put too much emphasis on the wrong numbers.
- exodust 13y agoThe point is about design being held back or distorted by numbers - which are often a false prophesy when it comes to UX improvements. Nobody is suggesting that numbers don't matter, but if you can't decide on a border thickness of 1 or 2 pixels without numbers to tell you which to go with, you've lost your mojo. And that matters in the long term. When the aim is to increase length of time on the site or in the app, the numbers will "tell you" to make the interface more complicated, to hide the sign-out button (common practice), to hide the exit button (like Dropbox did on the desktop application), to force dependencies between unrelated services (Google does this a lot). When the aim is to increase clicks on Ads, the numbers will tell you to make ads look like normal posts. The numbers will tell you to autoplay videos on tabloid news article pages. But all these "optimizations" are not unlike speed cameras placed at the bottom of the hill where lots of people can't help bumping over the speed limit for a couple of seconds. Good for revenue, bad vibes in every other way.
- ignostic 13y ago> "design being held back or distorted by numbers - which are often a false prophesy when it comes to UX improvements." > "the numbers will "tell you" to make the interface more complicated, to hide the sign-out button" Oh yes, I definitely understand that we misinterpret what the numbers mean. My point is that this isn't the numbers' fault - it's our fault for not understanding what we're measuring and what the numbers mean. Often additional tests can even help resolve the "what should we do" question. We run tests all the time, but when we see something like, "pageviews are up x%" that's just a starting place. We begin to ask why and continue to develop a hypothesis and proof for it. It might be that users are confused so they start clicking around, or it could be because we've grabbed their attention and enticed them to learn more. Without the numbers we wouldn't even know where to start. If Dustin's point is just to think critically about test numbers that seems to go without saying.
- _wesley_ 13y agoFunny thing - FADC (one of Dustin's groups seen in the screenshot) is getting a ton of requests today.
- tomasien 13y agoThis isn't exactly right - optimizing the NewsFeed and eliminating exploration may be a more efficient UX in a way, but that doesn't mean it's better. I don't hear "reduced exploration" and think "that's way better". I'm not saying that's why FB made the decision, but Dustin doesn't know why they made it either. I'd have made the same decision as a UX focused CEO though is all I'm saying.
- tomphoolery 13y agoI would have much preferred the proposed layout as seen in this photo. In fact, it is (almost scary) similar to the most recent Diaspora single-page view that was just rolled out no more than a year ago. We designed our single-page view to focus on content, and unlike Facebook, we don't care about ad revenue, so we don't have these problems. :)
- mcgwiz 13y agoFacebook can afford not to provide an better user experience because it has no competition. Should Google Plus one day threaten Facebook's usage, Facebook may pull this design out of it's archives. Until then, they will provide the minimal user experience that keeps them on top of the hill with as much ad inventory as possible.
- jfoster 13y agoThis is a weakness of ad-supported business models. When users are buying or subscribing to a product, you want them to love it as much as possible so that they will always buy more. Ad-supported models untie the relationship between UX and revenue. In an ad-supported model, you do need users to like the product enough to keep coming back, but small decreases in utility that generate more impressions could be great for revenue. The people at Facebook are extremely talented. It's a shame they're stuck with this business model. It would be awesome to see how good they could make Facebook if this wasn't tying them down.
- babesh 13y agoIsn't that what the Instagram, Whatsapp, and Occulus purchases are for? None of them are yet tied down to an advertising based business model.
- jfoster 13y agoPotentially they can even untie the Facebook product from the ad model. They could introduce "Facebook Premium" whereby you would pay a small monthly fee and have a different interface due to the space freed up from deciding to not show you ads.
- jcampbell1 13y agoI agree, this is primarily a consequence of being ad-supported. The same problem happens at Google, it is just less noticeable. Google is in the fortunate position of getting to do the best things for users for 99.5% of searches, it is the other .5% that they compromise on. At times, they have tried to do the best thing for customers on searches like "best morgage refinance rate", but in the end, they cancel the experiments because it would crush their revenues, and all the other good they are doing: http://www.seroundtable.com/mortgages-google-advisor-14813.html http://www.seroundtable.com/mortgages-google-advisor-14813.h... Google advisor was an amazing product that super beneficial to Google users, but the problem was it displaced $20/click ads.
- abimaelmartell 13y agoI hate the new design, the content row is really small, it looks ugly.
- dennyubedz 13y agohttp://obatirematikdanasamuratherbal.wordpress.com/ http://obatirematikdanasamuratherbal.wordpress.com/ Obat Rematik Dan Asam Urat Penyembuhan penyakit rematik dan asam urat dengan obat herbal Jelly Gamat Gold G berkhasiat penuh tuntaskan secara maksimal Obat,Rematik,Asam Urat,herbal,
- yyyooolll 13y agowho honestly gives a fuck what you think? waste of everybody's time. am I right, am I right?
- hipaulshi 13y agowhich, like the FB employee said, is exactly, what a data-driven company should do to maximize profit. However, Dustin has a good point. CEO needs to make that very risky call if he vouched for the better design. The customer may or may not come. Short term loss is inevitable. One would need strong belief, again, needs to be backed by data, to make that call.
- atmosx 13y agoI am not sure if there's any take-away from this article. There are too many assumptions.
- dsjoerg 13y agoThe core of Dustin's argument is that Facebook may not have been patient enough; they should have trusted in their beautiful new design and waited long enough for the benefits to bear fruit. However, it's a cheap argument to make, because the Hard Thing is to decide how many months of crappy numbers are you going to withstand before you admit that your Beautiful New Design in fact isn't any good? Six months? Two years? And it's not just revenue you look at. How's overall engagement? Sharing rates? Communication? Discovery? The article is a shallow snipe; the real issues here are hard, interesting, and unexplored by this piece.
- loceng 13y ago"We only optimize. We do what goes up." Deciding what you want to facilitate going up comes down to governance. If you want to give the user a shittier experience in order to earn more profits, then you can do that. But you leave yourself open to someone providing the better experience and losing them altogether.
- pixelcort 13y agoOne fear I think about is choosing a good UI/UX for an MVP. Users might get used to it and it could be hard to significantly change it later on.
- dreamfactory2 13y agoIf a better UX turns out to make less money I'd say the problem to be solved is with the monetisation, not the UX
- tinganho 13y agoDurtis didn't the "left navigation" made that they browsed the feed more than other parts. I have never thought that the left navigation was any good. Since navigation navigation is a big part of UX and hiding it in the left is not good.
- programminggeek 13y agoI'll give another way to look at it. Good design is by no means the same as optimal design. A lot of beautiful designs done by talented designers end up being worse than what was before. They might be prettier, but they are very likely worse by many conversion metrics. Don't think of it in terms of pure design. Think of it in terms of cost. Everything has a cost and sometimes good design's real cost is in user behavior. Pageviews and time on site could go down because people aren't going through so many steps to get to what they want. There are a lot of metrics that aren't that useful without the context of the ultimate conversion numbers for your site/app/product/project. Facebook and Google are advertising companies. The financial metric they care about is advertising revenue per user and number of users. It's not much different than a SAAS app in that way. Other metrics are important, but that is the metric that pays the bills. A beautiful design that doesn't improve the core metrics is like a multi million dollar super bowl commercial that flops. Sure, it might be really cool and well produced, but if it doesn't sell your product, you might as well light that money on fire. The net effect is the same.
- droopyEyelids 13y agoThe underlying assumption being something like "If you're not increasing the amount of money you make, you are of no value" Facebook says it's values are connecting people and other helpful ideas for a reason. If they created a design that helped people connect more fluidly, it'd still be valuable, even if it didn't increase their revenue. I find your comment a bit cynical and oversimplified.
- programminggeek 13y agoWell, I don't think it's a completely binary money or UX type decision, but I do know that working at a larger scale of users shifts your priorities significantly. For example, I worked on a website that would sometimes process as much as a million dollars in donations in a single day for a nonprofit. If the site went down for even a half hour, that could be tens of thousands of dollars in missed donations. That is like someone not getting paid for almost a year. We had a cool autocomplete feature that went out and due to a bug that made it past QA caused a on of DB queries and took down the server. It was maybe a better user experience, but the way it was implemented would cost too much in reliability for it to be worth it. The team reengineered the concept until it worked at scale. A lot of hackers I know who aren't working on that scale don't worry about QA or bugs so much because hardly anybody is using their software and it's not mission critical. When you have millions of people touching your software and it is processing millions of dollars in transactions, the metrics that matter are different. I am sure Facebook cares about UX, but they are a publicly traded company and if a slightly better UX delivers a significantly worse ad revenue number, that isn't just sort of bad for investors, it's bad for the employees job security (and stock value), it's bad for the advertisers who can't get the same ROI on their ad spend, and ultimately it's a little bit bad for the end users because if "good UX" doesn't make money, then over the long haul, Facebook will learn to not invest in "good UX". I think the scale that Facebook's engineers are working at is a lot bigger than most of us can easily appreciate.
- imjk 13y agoBrings new meaning to the adage, "What goes up, must come down."
- sidcool 13y agoI might be acting like a devil's advocate, but don't the metrics reflect user behavior? And it's perfectly fine if they tune their UI for revenue. They are not missionaries, but they are visionaries. They need money to keep the innovation going. I am not a facebook fan or an affiliate, and I do resent few of their design decisions, but earning money is well within their framework of morality.
- joulee 13y agoI worked on the design of the desktop Facebook News Feed. Just posted a response to the article here: https://medium.com/p/ed75a0ee7641 https://medium.com/p/ed75a0ee7641 Actually, the older version of the design we tested would have been positive for revenue had we shipped it. But there were a number of other issues that made it harder for people to use (which also resulted in them liking it less.)
- richforrester 13y agoI did some design and coding work for the adult industry for a while. The company I worked for had one large members area with all kinds of niches, with thousands of sites acting as doorways into it. Instead of a nice overview, and a smooth experience, they had built in tons of tricky ways to delay the user getting to the content. From loading delays to tricky dropdowns instead of simple buttons. Users had access to the site as long as they stayed on the phone to our special 2 dollar per minute phone line. It worked, but it was a pain to work for a company like that. I was fresh out of school and just wanted to get better at my trade, but wasn't allowed to do the best I could. Frustrating. Needless to say, things have changed in that industry, gotten a lot trickier, and the company has had to switch into different avenues. They now offer payment solutions and run a huge dating site.
- brandonhsiao 13y agoThis is really an instance of the general phenomenon that the eminent tend to take fewer risks. A change that decreases revenue isn't necessarily bad; it may even yield a net profit in the long run. It's just perceived as a risk because things like user happiness and product culture (a) can't be as easily measured and (b) don't yield results for a while. I think this is actually a rational-- or at least natural-- course of action. As you get more eminent, the stakes are also higher, and when you have more to lose you tend to take less risk. In fact, it'd be surprising if a big company continued taking risks by trusting non-structural decisions. This is probably related to the phenomenon that large organizations tend to fall into bureaucracy. In fact the two questions are probably overlapping, if not identical. How can you grow big and famous and take on big responsibilities without losing your ability to trust your intuition and care about the feel and usability of the product? How can you stop yourself from degenerating into bureaucracy? I'm pretty confident it's possible. Steve Jobs managed it. My own hunch is that the trick is to hire people who don't care about money too much. The kind of people who think, if we lose a bit of revenue, who cares? Which is paradoxical, my hunch continues, because people like this will eventually make better products in the long run, and end up increasing revenue in a thousand different little ways.
- kybernetyk 13y ago> This is truly a nightmare scenario for any CEO: do you take the risk and proceed with the better user experience/product at the expense of short term numbers–with no promise that the better design will actually lead to long-term benefits–or do you scrap the new design and start over? Doesn't this only apply to CEOs who run companies that give away their products to indirectly monetize it? If you had a product you sold to your customers wouldn't this improvement in usability/product quality be a no-brainer because better product = more sales = more revenue?
- TeMPOraL 13y ago> If you had a product you sold to your customers wouldn't this improvement in usability/product quality be a no-brainer because better product = more sales = more revenue? Not really, because again, "better product" is only a proxy for the real goal of many companies, i.e. "more revenue". Even earning money directly on the product won't stop sales people from inserting various money extracting tricks that abuse people's cognitive biases and heuristics. Just look at Badoo. Or Zynga.
- wtracy 13y agoI can think of lots of counter-examples. What if your product is licensed per-seat, and your change allows your customer to achieve their goals with fewer employees using your product, reducing the number of licenses purchased? What if your change allows your customer to complete their task more quickly, and they stop paying for your SaaS product as soon as they complete said task? What if your improvement improves interoperability, and your customer's partners decide not to purchase your product because they no longer need it to work together? What if your change reduces the need for your customer to later purchase an upgrade?
- adrianhoward 13y agoAm I the only person on the planet who vastly prefers the newer design? Yes, the larger images were nice to look at - but they got in the way of actually viewing the content for me. My personal viewing habits of the newsfeed are to give facebook a glance over once a day with my morning coffee. The purpose is to get an overview - quickly. The newer look got in the way of that, especially when viewing in smaller windows. There are also all the folk who aren't looking at it on large displays, and maybe consistency of experience is important too. Sure - maybe there's a metrics issue too. But I've seen more than my fair share of usability tests where things that my "design" persona like end up being disliked by the people who actually use the site.
- nakedrobot2 13y agoThis anecdote perfectly illustrates how Facebook is not playing the long game. Facebook will erode any trust and loyalty that they did have in favor of short-term gains. We see it again and again. The last thing was the "pay to access your fans" bait-and-switch that to me was rather abhorrent. Without any "higher mission" at all, Facebook has to resort to these lowest-common-denominator values. I only hope that someone with better values can gain an edge someday, and refuses to be acquired/neutralized by Facebook.
- crazychrome 13y agoInteresting read. it proves one of my arguments against fb: there is not too much real value to end users. there is no such thing in the world like "performing too well". if a better design led to less user engagements, it means the product, in its bare bone, not valuable to users.
- buckmower 13y agoBeyond, Beside or Within The following in response to Facebook’s Newsfeed Redesign: Why do what makes everyone else do what you want them to do if doing so isn’t right? If we all can determine what’s right and what’s wrong as a community of equals then doing what’s right is a matter of doing what everyone else, for the most part, wants you to do. As is the case with Facebook and most other companies that offer products to consumers, when it comes to offering their product they aren’t exactly equal with the rest of us; because, they have control over the products we so willingly consume; thus, they are faced with the conundrum of what to do about product design and consumer retention. Dustin seems to be saying that Facebook does what makes Facebook users do what Facebook wants its users to do. The numbers that go up and down, it seems, are numbers related to people spending time on other people’s pages rather than just on the news feed. What’s wrong with that?
- sharemywin 13y agoPrefect example of the innovator's dilemma.
- roymckenzie 13y agoWhile it does flex, I won't be spending that kind of money on something like that until it folds up in my pocket.
- joubert 13y agoIt seems to me that if the company's goals are the same as that of their users, then innovation will lead to profits. But if your users are not also your customers, then you are likely to run into these counter-innnovation corners.