14 ms·
Is the Supreme Court about to rule software ineligible for patent protection?
- rayiner 13y agoNo, because Section 101 states that the subject matter of patent is extremely broad, and there is no statutory basis for creating an categorical distinction for software. They may, however, rule in a way that makes it harder to get particular kinds of software patents.
- WildUtah 13y ago35 USC §101: "Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title." Yes, rayiner, that's pretty broad but I don't see software in the list. Maybe I copied it out wrong?
- res0nat0r 13y agoThat statement includes software, not explicitly excludes it, unless I'm missing something.
- Glyptodon 13y agoSoftware is math. Math is not eligible. Should be pretty clear.
- alaaibrahim 13y agoOr software could be a process, which is eligible.
- nitrogen 13y agoAIUI (as a layman), a "process" should refer to a physical process for transforming a physical product. Thus, an algorithm is not a process. I've read arguments that software is a "process" because it changes the physical state of transistors and magnetic particles within a physical computer, but I don't find that argument even slightly convincing.
- hackinthebochs 13y agoBut software does change a physical product, irrespective of transistor states. If I create an algorithm that allows a robot to balance on two legs, that algorithm is directly affecting the real world. This is no different than if I constructed a difference engine that through purely mechanical means had the same result. The math is the algorithms effect on purely mathematical objects. The patent is the algorithm plus a mapping between the mathematical objects and real-world entities. This is how it should be. The problem we currently get wrong is the "non-obvious" term.
- nitrogen 13y agoSoftware is different because it is a direct representation of the math, while the mechanical computer would have considerable amounts of engineering involved to create mechanical analogs for the desired computations. In software, an implementation of an algorithm, a description of an algorithm, and the algorithm itself can all be the same thing.
- hackinthebochs 13y agoBut software also has an interface to the physical units in question, which ultimately makes it useful in the real world. Mathematical truths are not useful in the real world until there is an application of a truth to a particular scenario. It is this "application + scenario" that is patented, not the mathematical truth. People are way too stuck on the "software is math" bit, it is not nearly as meaningful as people think. In fact, I think it is decidedly lacking in any meaning as everything in the universe can be abstracted to "math".
- Crito 13y agoTo head off the inevitable responses, you can describe a Wankel engine with mathematical expressions, but a Wankel engine is not itself a mathematical expression. Blueprints are mere descriptions of Wankel engines. However a "description" of an algorithm is the algorithm. An algorithm is a mathematical expression, not merely something that can be described with mathematical expressions. Consider my "method/process patent" for finding the length of a hypotenuse. It is easy to see why that is straight up math, and therefore should not be patentable. However just because they don't teach the notation used for expressing algorithms in primary school does not mean that it is not math. The Pythagorean Theorem is ancient so it was never in any danger, but consider FFTs. FFT algorithms were not patented, but imagine what a shame it would be if they were. These type of patents have no business existing.
- hackinthebochs 13y ago> FFT algorithms were not patented, but imagine what a shame it would be if they were. The only way this conclusion follows is if you're judging patentability of an idea by the impact the idea has had. This is plainly absurd. Lets consider the opposite, what if it were invented but the algorithm kept secret because patent protection didn't exist. Would humanity have been better off in that scenario? Processes like the FFT are exactly the types of software that are reasonable to patent, and yet you want to claim the opposite precisely because it was non-obvious and so important?
- Crito 13y agoFFT algorithms were not patented and were not kept secret for lack of a patent. Supposing that FFTs may have been kept secret for lack of patents is absurd because we already know what happened with FFTs without patents. Even if they had been kept secret, FFTs would have been reinvented at minimal cost to society. Had IBM patented them, society would have been fucked out of them for two decades. FFT, and things like it, are exactly the sort of software that should not be patented. Patent your minimal-clicking checkout process or bouncy kinetic scrolling all you want, I don't like those patents but they are reasonable. Those ideas aren't algorithms, they only use them; if I hold the patent for kinetic scrolling in my hand, I am not holding kinetic scrolling itself in my hand. If I hold an FFT algorithm patent in my hand, I am holding an FFT algorithm itself in my hand. Patenting algorithms themselves is patently absurd. Would you be okay with the Pythagorean Theorem being patented as well? Mathematics does not currently suffer a trade-secret problem. Introducing patents would do nothing but harm to society, while enriching corporations. What else do you believe to be patentable? Should Newton and Leibniz have escalated their conflict to an all-out patent war? Calculus is non-obvious and wildly important; would society be better off if it were patented? Or hell, maybe Feynman should have patented Feynman Diagrams! If we are patenting mathematical expressions, why not throw in novel and useful notations for mathematical expressions as well! Any mathematician, physicist, or engineer will have to join the Mathematics Patents Experts Group in order to get any useful work done without being sued into homelessness, but at least all of those people won't be keeping their creations and discoveries secret, right? Edit: Response: Patents are for the benefit of society, not for the benefit of the creators. You cannot evaluate the merit of patentablity without considering the benefit to society. We are sure as shit better off in a society where anyone doing ML research doesn't have to license ideas from IBM.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoI'd have thought it is probably covered by 'process', now what I see as the problem in many software patents is that they sometimes treat software as a component in a process, leading to overly broad claims that effectively cover any attempt to solve something in software rather than drilling down into the mechanics of a particular solution. Of course, if you did force specifics, then software patents would be pretty toothless as you can always find another process that ends up with the same result. However, if the patent office and courts had decided to take that approach, they wouldn't have had such a valuable income stream to play with, and I suspect they value that over consistency of approach.
- Guvante 13y agoAlgorithms are not patentable but yet software is. Since any software package describes an algorithm (albeit an incredibly complex on potentially) that puts software at an odd spot. An example of a solution would be to say that you can't go after someone for implementing an algorithm (so by extension any software). Rather than eliminating the patent eliminate that ability to enforce it. They likely wouldn't go for something so simple, but it is an example of the potential train of thought.
- dctoedt 13y ago> I don't see software in the list. Software is usually claimed as a method, commonly accepted as a synonym for the statutory term process. Some patents include claims directed to machines programmed to perform a stated method. The Federal Circuit held 20 years ago that a general-purpose that is programmed to perform a new method programming becomes a new, special-purpose computer that as such can be patented if otherwise eligible [1]. Another type of claim in a software patent is the so-called Beauregard claim. [2] That type of claim is directed to an "article of manufacture," one of the statutory categories, along the lines of the following: "15. A program storage device tangibly embodying a program of instructions for performing the method of a specified one of claims 1 through 14." That type of claim allows the patent owner to sue not just the end user for using the patented method, but also to sue the software vendor for having sold the patented article of manufacture. (For clarity, Beauregard claims to program storage devices, etc., are unpatentable if the underlying software methods are themselves unpatentable. [3].) [1] In re Alappat, http://digital-law-online.info/cases/31PQ2D1545.htm http://digital-law-online.info/cases/31PQ2D1545.htm [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_patent_claim_types#Beauregard http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_patent_claim_types#Beau... [3] http://inventivestep.net/2011/08/22/federal-circuit-rules-beauregard-claims-are-unpatentable/ http://inventivestep.net/2011/08/22/federal-circuit-rules-be...
- bhitov 13y agoAgreed. It would be entirely uncharacteristic of the supreme court to make such a broad ruling.
- WildUtah 13y agoBetterdige's Law Of Headlines: "Any headline which ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no." Unfortunately here, as it would be great to have a wise and effective Supreme Court. The last time there was thought to be a chance to abolish software patents before the court, four conservative justices were against abolition and Scalia refused to join any opinion fully. (Scalia, comfortable knowing that he's the smartest, is often willing to be humble when he isn't sure and says so.) That situation is likely to repeat itself. This is a much better article, incidentally: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2014/02/26/will-the-supreme-court-save-us-from-software-patents/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2014/02/26...
- ars 13y agoThat law may not apply here. The basis for this law is that if the reporter can answer the question with a "yes" they would simply report that. However, this can't be done with a future event. So for a future event the law doesn't apply - the reporter isn't being lazy or trying to make something out of nothing - the information is truly not available yet.
- majika 13y agoAlso, this "reporter" is the Associate Dean of Faculty and Professor of Law, at the Emory University School of Law. This is actually a pretty good article.
- lambda 13y agoThe writer of the headline and of the article are often not the same person; this may be a fine article which had a poor headline attached by someone else.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoHN should have a bot that deletes any comment that refers to this "law".
- 13y ago
- korethr 13y agoWhile I would love to see software patents go away, I don't think we'll see such happen through the courts. I think our best chance of that is through Congress. From my understanding of what the constitution says about patents, it's Congress' job anyway. However, there'd be massive lobbying against such, from both patent trolls who derive all of their revenue from such, and big powerful firms like Google, Oracle, and IBM, who would lose legal cudgels against upstarts with the temerity to be a (pontential) competitive threat. So, while worth doing, getting Congress to invalidate software patents will not be easy.
- higherpurpose 13y ago> In 2010, the Court found a method of hedging risk, a business method, was not eligible for patent protection because it was an abstract idea. And yet, Microsoft and IBM still managed press Congress to keep it in the latest patent reform. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/11/20/software-patent-reform-just-died-in-the-house-thanks-to-ibm-and-microsoft/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/11/20... This is what pisses me off about the US system. There's no Constitutionality check prior to "enabling" a new law (and after the president signs it). So even if the Supreme Court declares something outright unconstitutional, Congress could still pass a law allowing that. That seems pretty crazy to me. There needs to be a Constitutional Court, who's much like the Supreme Court, but who's job is not to take lawsuits, but to verify bills for constitutionality before becoming laws. This is how it's done in other countries, and the chance for passing something unconstitutional is much lower. The Supreme Court would still have the final word, if one law does get through the Constitutional Court (either because the CC judges weren't on their game, or they became more corrupt due to more direct pressure from the government to allow a certain law), and then that law ends up at the Supreme Court through lawsuits.
- gamblor956 13y agoThey already have that. It's called every single Federal court, ever. The proper means for determining the constitutionality of a law is after it has been passed, but before it takes effect. There is no reason to determine the constitutionality of a bill before the bill has been passed, as it might not become law. Thousands of bills are considered every year. Wasting court resources on those bills, and especially the multitude of bills that would never even become law, would preclude the courts from handling anything else. Bills never become effective immediately--there is always at least a few days of delay. If the constitutionality of a law is at issue, someone will challenge it in federal court, at which time the courts will review it. Generally, at that point the law is suspended so that it does not take effect until the constitutional review is completed.
- SmallBets 13y agoFirst software, next seeds.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoI was thinking about gene patents recently and was wondering, if a genetic therapy was patented and an enthusiastic virus managed to carry it into your germ cells and then you had kids, what would happen to the claim of ownership on the patented genetics?
- jamiesonbecker 13y agoYou might enjoy the novel Next, by Michael Crichton (Harvard M.D., author of E.R., Jurassic Park, etc.) Aside from the fact that most of his novels were pretty well written, the scary part is how much ahead of his time his ideas consistently were. (His later novels, including Next, did drop slightly in quality as time went on, but Next is still a really interesting look at almost precisely the legal issue that you describe.) The incredibly complete bibliography that you find in his novels of hundreds of citations just tends to prove out that frequently truth really is stranger than fiction. (For example, what if someone genetically engineered advertisements into the backs of sea turtles on barrier reefs?)
- Dylan16807 13y agoSo far the rulings have been that you can have the genes from accidental contamination but you cannot go out of your way to take advantage of them. Which I think is stupid, but it's a consistent and workable rule.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoUnder that ruling, if you found out that you were passing on a gene therapy, you would be disallowed from having children with a partner where the gene is likely to be therapeutic in the children.
- Dylan16807 13y ago
- NextUserName 13y agoNope, too much money/power involved.
- jseliger 13y agoI sent this article to a friend who is a patent attorney, and he hasn't followed the case but based on this: http://patentlyo.com/patent/2014/03/software-patent-eligibility.html http://patentlyo.com/patent/2014/03/software-patent-eligibil... the Forbes article's claims are unlikely.
- magicalist 13y agoHmm, I don't understand. This is a summary of briefs filed for this case, so you're going to get opinions all over the map.
- batoure 13y agoThe article begs an interesting question ignoring its link bating headline. Mainly is the supreme court over reaching when it comes to patent law and if so why. >The United States has an expert “patent court,”the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, that hears every appeal from around the country in cases that arise under the country’s patent laws. From California to Florida, any patent appeal goes to the Federal Circuit. Unlike areas of the law, the Federal Circuit creates nationally uniform legal standards for patent law. One of the key reasons the Supreme Court will take a case is when lower courts disagree on a legal issue. But, with patent law’s single appellate court, no such splits arise. I get the reason why the court would want to not hear these cases based on this but I feel like it isn't clear why they would, and by that i mean a legal basis besides the obvious a philosophical wish to dismantle patent law (after an appropriate amount of googling I still have no answer) any lawyers or law-school dropouts turned programmers around who might explain this?
- WildUtah 13y agoThe CAFC is less an "expert" patent court than a notoriously corrupt patent court. [0] The corruption isn't the furtively-passing sacks of cash kind but the kind where unaccountable people are put in charge of their own power and prestige and ignore the rules that place limits on their power. [1] The Supreme Court naturally feels somewhat offended when lower courts overturn their decisions. [1 again] [0] http://www.patentprogress.org/systemic-problems/how-we-got-here/ http://www.patentprogress.org/systemic-problems/how-we-got-h... [1] read the fourth paragraph from the end of this otherwise execrable article starting with "How long will it take" http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2012/03/20/supreme-court-mayo-v-prometheus/id=22920/ http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2012/03/20/supreme-court-mayo-v-pr...
- batoure 13y agoThis is very cool and much better insight than the forbes article... I think it can still be summed up as "they angry" being the reason they take these cases. >One of the key reasons the Supreme Court will take a case is when lower courts disagree on a legal issue. But, with patent law’s single appellate court, no such splits arise. This was the question that I think that I was trying to understand better, if there is no ambiguity of opinion from lower courts is the only reason they take patent cases because they just happen to disagree?
- Jach 13y agoThe Supreme Court already ruled against software patents in Gottschalk v. Benson. So much for what the Supreme Court says. If anyone is interested in the establishment's freakout that 2012's ruling caused, look no further than here: http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2012/03/20/supreme-court-mayo-v-prometheus/id=22920/ http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2012/03/20/supreme-court-mayo-v-pr... Here is an excerpt: How long will it take the Federal Circuit to overrule this inexplicable nonsense? The novice reader may find that question to be ignorant, since the Supreme Court is the highest court of the United States. Those well acquainted with the industry know that the Supreme Court is not the final word on patentability, and while the claims at issue in this particular case are unfortunately lost, the Federal Circuit will work to moderate (and eventually overturn) this embarrassing display by the Supreme Court. This will eventually be accomplished the same as it was after the Supreme Court definitively ruled software is not patentable in Gottschalk v. Benson, and the same as the ruling in KSR v. Teleflex will be overruled. I have taken issue with Chief Judge Rader’s statements that nothing has changed in Federal Circuit jurisprudence as a result of KSR, which is not technically true. What is true, however, is that the Federal Circuit continues to refine the KSR “common sense test,” narrowing the applicability in case after case and tightening the ability for “common sense” to be used against an application. We are almost 5 years post KSR and there is still a lot of work left to be done by the Federal Circuit to finally overrule the Supreme Court’s KSR decision. It took almost 10 years to overrule Gottschalk v. Benson, so we are likely in for a decade of work to moderate the nonsense thrust upon the industry this morning. Indeed, Breyer’s decision is the most intellectually dishonest decision I have ever read, which is saying a lot given the utter contemptuous understanding of patent law displayed by the Supreme Court over the years. It is truly troubling that all 9 of the Justices concurred in what history will regard as one of the worst decisions in the patent space EVER! Yes, Congress will be asked to step in and rectify this absurd ruling, and they should. Knowing how the legislative branch operates I cringe at the thought of Congress coming to the rescue. The only thing that gives me solace is that the industries summarily executed this morning have an A+ lobbying game, which in Washington, DC means everything. (By the way, I remembered this from the comment and discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3732894 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3732894)
- dctoedt 13y ago
- spiralpolitik 13y agoLet's rephrase the question. Will a right leaning supreme court make a decision that will potentially cost big business millions if not billions of dollars per year ? I don't think you need a magic eight ball to answer that one.
- marcosdumay 13y agoAnd what decision is that one costing billions of dollars per year?
- spiralpolitik 13y agoLicensing of the IBM patent portfolio is routinely reported as being in excess of $1 billion annually. If Software Patents get thrown out then so will a chunk of that billion. The sad reality about software patents is while they are a terrible thing, there is too much power and money involved for a right leaning Supreme Court to throw them out, and while in the short term you might see some meaningful patent reform proposed, once the lobbyists get their way it certainly won't be in favor of the the little guy.
- hrjet 13y agoBig companies are on both ends of patent protection. Have we forgotten the Oracle+MS+Apple v/s Android sagas already?
- transfire 13y agoSoftware patents might not be so bad if 1) Patents didn't cost much nor required renewals and expedited service fees, and all that crap; 2) were first to invent, not first to file; and 3) officers at the USPTO actually had a clue and didn't hand out patents for trivial things like wildcard matching with a `*` character (yes, that happened just a few years ago).
- tbrownaw 13y ago2) were first to invent, not first to file; The bar for not being obvious should be high enough for this to not make a difference. If two people (or teams, companies, whatever) independently invent the same thing within... say, a year of eachother, that should be taken as proof that it's too obvious to be patentable.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoThe logic here is fairly appalling; look at Newton vs Leibniz.
- Dylan16807 13y agoWhat do you feel about the idea that math had developed to the point that such a calculus was now incremental and immediately inevitable? Though patents are rather specific and coming at a problem from two different directions can easily lead to two valid patents. Wait, what am I talking about, you can't patent math period.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoI think my most basic problem with that idea is this: I think that, if some process is patentable, then no matter how you divide it into components, at least one of those components should be patentable too. > you can't patent math period Of course, but I'm just responding to the idea that if two people independently develop something at the same time, it was obvious by definition. That isn't true.
- chenster 13y agoAMEN!
- Kiro 13y agoI'm glad I live outside the US where software patents don't exist. I can ship whatever I want without being worried.
- todd8 13y agoI certainly hope so, and I have (around) fifteen myself including one that covers the internet cookie and another which I think covers the Galois Counter Mode for encryption or at least certain applications of GCM. I filed for these as a part of my employment for IBM a long time ago (around 1988), and by now all of my IBM patents have expired. When I left IBM to start my own company I invented more than I did at IBM, but I chose to license our technology to the Open Software Foundation instead of patenting it. Part of my thinking in not filing for patents was that the big companies that were our biggest competitors (IBM, HP, Sun, DEC) wouldn't be slowed down by patents. They had armies of lawyers and big portfolios of patents and inventions that would be used against us if we tried to enforce any of our patents against them. Whether or not any of their claims were valid, we would not have been able to afford the legal battle and would have been forced to cross-license with them anyway. Patent protection for software has always bothered me. Patents that made sense in the days of steam engines just don't work well for software. Patents give too much protection (preventing independent discovery of some idea from being used) and last too long, way too long for the software industry (I think 4 years is plenty of time to get exclusive use for an idea in software). Ideally, I would like to see patent protection to software eliminated and replaced with a much easier to obtain protection for a couple of years. Or, use copyright protection for software. Copyright protection is sensible since it protects the programs from being stolen while allowing the ideas to be used by others if they do an independent implementation.
- TheMagicHorsey 13y agoYou speak good sense. You are a liability to the Patent Industry (the Patent Litigators, the Patent Prosecutors, the Patent Trolls, the Patent Courts). Watch now as some fucking moron, who has never built software in his entire life, drops in to say that only with Software Patents does Silicon Valley exist.