9 ms·
All the claims about Iceland doing things differently are useless and I am quite sick of hearing them. Like the US, Iceland provided financial support for its
by joe_the_user 13y ago
All the claims about Iceland doing things differently are useless and I am quite sick of hearing them.
Like the US, Iceland provided financial support for its ailing bank system when the crisis appeared. That Iceland officially nationalized banks and the US left the banks officially in private hands is really a trivial detail. Iceland supported their banks and ultimately returned them to the control of their previous owners, the same effective strategy as the US.
And some unsecured creditors lost in Iceland and in the US, depending on the circumstances. Again, a detail, not the main picture, which wasn't really that different than here.
Just stop with the "Iceland's different" baloney, just stop.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008%E2%80%9311_Icelandic_financial_crisis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008%E2%80%9311_Icelandic_finan...
- jcampbell1 13y agoLet's not forget that Iceland's banks were bailed out by foreign governments. All those UK "Icesave" high interest savings accounts were bailed out by the Bank of England. If Iceland had more than 300,000 people, you can be damn sure the debt wouldn't have been forgiven, and there would be tariffs on cod and aluminium until it was paid back.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoIt was UK investments, UK investors, and UK depositors. The only thing Icelandic in this case was the flag of the bank.
- peteretep 13y agoAnd where the profits went too.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoRight, it was UK capital, UK profit, UK risk, they were just using the Icelandic banks for more favorable tax and trading conditions. I swear, it sometimes seems like the whole of UK is in finance and looking at screwing the system globally.
- hugi 13y agoIndeed. Now excuse me while I go bathe in my ill gotten Irish funds with my fellow Icelanders.
- netcan 13y agoThis is the important point: 'It's where the customers went, UK customers. Freely." If you go to a foreign bank for tax, interest or other benefits you are exercising a high degree of financial autonomy, choosing a banking system to be a part of. It's not a default decision by someone who needed somewhere to deposit their £438 per week salary. I really don't think you can make the same argument about guaranteeing deposits in these cases, especially without a (low) cap of £10,000 or so. The Bank of England bailout transferred money from future middle class workers in the UK to wealthy and upper-middle class people, maybe 2 generations apart. I think it was immoral.
- walshemj 13y agoNot going to go down to well with a UK pensioner who lost their savings. And UK tax payers like my self who are effectively bailing out Icelandic debts.
- arethuza 13y agoNot really - we are bailing out people from the UK who chose to deposit their money in an Icelandic bank to get higher returns ignoring the fact that higher returns almost certainly implies higher risk. If someone is daft enough to deposit their cash abroad to get higher returns without doing enough due diligence as to where they are depositing their money that's their problem - not mine or any other taxpayers.
- netcan 13y agoto add to that, it is important that they be held accountable for the outcomes of that decision. There are 2 options: (1)depositors are guaranteed by taxpayers (2)depositors are not guaranteed by taxpayers. The EU is trying to implement a 3rd option: banks never lose depositors' deposits. The 3rd option is nonsensical. At some point banks will fail. The market works better when the decision maker has skin in the game but there will still be failures and we (nations and individuals including pensioners cannot be shielded from reality completely.
- walshemj 13y ago
- relate 13y agoThe "debt" wasn't "forgiven", the Icesave dispute went for the EFTA court, where Iceland was cleared of all charges: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icesave_dispute#EFTA_Court_clears_Iceland_of_all_charges http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icesave_dispute#EFTA_Court_clea...
- venus 13y ago> All the claims about Iceland doing things differently are useless I don't understand your comment. What Iceland did - allow its banks to default on their debts - is completely different from what eg. Ireland did, ie. nationalise the debt. That it then nationalised the bankrupt banks is a different matter. It nationalised them, sure, after they defaulted on the debt.
- joe_the_user 13y agoNo, Iceland banks didn't collapse, the government nationalized them to prevent their collapse. (Edit: as another poster mentions a portion of the debt was paid down by other states too. Again, that's a detail, not a fundamental difference). Some foreign-deposit operations did collapse but the bulk of the banks, their shares and national operations, were protected by the state. "The Financial Supervisory Authority (FME) has acted to "ring-fence" the Icelandic operations of Landsbanki and Glitnir, stating its aim of "continued banking operations for Icelandic families and businesses."[126] NBI (originally known as Nýi Landsbanki) was set up on 9 October with 200 billion krónur in equity and 2,300 billion krónur of assets.[127] Nýi Glitnir was set up on 15 October with 110 billion krónur in equity and 1,200 billion krónur of assets.[128] Talks with Icelandic pension funds to sell Kaupthing as a going concern broke down on 17 October,[129] and Nýja Kaupþing was set up on 22 October with 75 billion krónur in equity and 700 billion krónur of assets.[130] The equity in all three new banks was supplied by the Icelandic government, and amounted to 30% of Iceland's GDP...." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008%E2%80%9311_Icelandic_financial_crisis#Bank_restructuring http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008%E2%80%9311_Icelandic_finan...
- hessenwolf 13y agoThat a portion of their debt was paid by other states is the key. Ireland swallowed all of the bank debt, and Iceland did not. There is not a day that goes by in which that is not considered in Ireland.
- levosmetalo 13y agoNo, it's not Icelands debt paid by other states, it is a debt of Icelandic private bank that is paid out by other states. Why do you think that Iceland has more obligation to pay up a debt of icelandic _private_ bank than, say, Romania or Zimbabwe? Iceland never claimed any kind of insurance of foreign deposits, so was not in any way obliged to pay them up.
- randomafrican 13y agoI think Iceland is used as a coutner-example to Greece, Ireland or Spain and not the US. Notice as they keep comparing the Icelandic unemployment rate to the EU average unemployment rate ?
- ddebernardy 13y agoIt's part of a trade zone with the EU, so that mostly makes sense. (There's more to the EU than PIIGS, brw.) Comparing its unemployment rate with that of the US would seem as bizarre as comparing Ohio's with that of the EU.
- randomafrican 13y agoYes. But the biggest point is that Iceland has taken a very different path from Ireland, Spain or Greece with very different outcomes. (of course, the situations were not exactly similar at the beginning but comparable enough to draw those comparisions)
- jackgavigan 13y agoThere are key differences. Ireland, Spain and Greece are members of both the EU and the Eurozone. Iceland is a member of neither. IANAL but I understand that what Iceland did would not have been permissible under EU law. That is part of the reason why Ireland, for example, took the path it did, in relation to the bank bail-outs.
- randomafrican 13y agoI'll give you the Eurozone... Makes it impossible to devaluate and much harder to put capital controls in place (though Cyprius manage to do so while being in the Eurozone). However, what Iceland did was still unilateral. They didn't ask for anybody's permission and didn't expect their decision to be accepted. Laws and treaties still need to be enforced and those countries are still sovereign. What happens if a country does something that is against EU law ? At worst, they may be expelled from the EU. So it's really a matter of comparing the advantages of EU membership to the cost of the path of action that was taken. It's still a political decision.
- easytiger 13y agoI agree. This has been happening for years and it drives me mad. There are individuals all over the world worth as much as icelands gdp and there are small towns in china with a greater population
- netcan 13y agoI'm far from an expert. In a lot of cases, what you say seems true. The Nationalization angle is BS for sure. But, there are some differences that are important. Foreign depositors did not get bailed out, not by Iceland. That in itself is a big deal. That's a clearer definition at least of what a bailout is. The banks went bust and deposits were lost. Then foreign central banks returned some despots to their own citizens. Iceland paid out its own citizens and some depositors were not guaranteed by anyone. It's clear for instance that UK public money went to UK depositors. The UK is entitled (though maybe unwise) to do this and it sets up a framework for explicit guarantees. In Ireland's case, god knows who really got bailed out. The EU loaned Ireland money to loan to their banks to pay back depositors who were other banks..etc. There was pressure from Germany as both the source of much of the financing and the destination of much of it (Irish banks owed money to German banks). No one went bankrupt, for a normal definition of the term. It amounts (in my limited understanding) to a few important difference that leave the system far more robust. (1) there is some transparency. It is knowable who is getting bailed out and where the money is coming from. (2) Some long tail risk is put onto depositors, especially foreign/large depositors so it can be priced in. A Hayekian sort of systemic risk reduction. (3) It appears to have reduced the flow of money from poorer future people to current rich people. (4) It clearly defines depositor bailouts as depositor bailouts. Money goes from the public purse to Ms Gunnarsdotter's. In other bailouts (Ireland) the public was driven to fear that banks would collapse and their savings wiped out unless some unknown quantity of money was put into an unknown funnel from where it would flow (among other places) back into their deposit accounts. IMO we need to come to a long term setup that is simple enough for a first year economics student to understand and first year finance student to price. A guarantee is fine, if we can set it to an affordable level (say, deposits up to €25k) payable directly from the government to qualifying depositors with potential recovery by a bankruptcy court.
- arethuza 13y ago"No one went bankrupt, for a normal definition of the term." A lot of people who borrowed from the Irish banks were forced to go bankrupt - apparently mostly those who had borrowed relatively small sums (less than 20 million or so).
- jezfromfuture 13y agoWhat they did different was actually send some people to jail , unlike the isa who sent no one to jail.
- marcosdumay 13y ago> That Iceland officially nationalized banks and the US left the banks officially in private hands is really a trivial detail. That detail is anything but trivial. It's the difference between giving the assets of a company to creditors during bankrupcy, or just clearing the debts, and keeping the assets as company possessions (and keeping the company owners). To tell you the truth, I still can not understand how the US (out of all countries, the one where people do not trust the State) accepted that bank bailout.