25 ms·
How Silicon Valley CEOs conspired to drive down tech engineer wages
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- scrabble 13y agoGoogle’s “People Ops” department kept overall compensation essentially equitable by making sure that lower-paid employees who performed well got higher salary increases than higher-paid employees who also performed well. Serious question, is this generally considered a bad thing? Every company I've worked for has had salary bands that work like this. They don't make it a secret. Generally you know which band you're in and the range of that band. I've recently been told in a company meeting at my current workplace that they are mainly working to bring people to the middle of their bands. So if you're above the middle, expect a low raise. On the other side, I can't help but feel underpaid since I've been told by people who know that the work I've done personally has allowed us to bring in more than 100 times my salary in recurring revenue.
- codeonfire 13y agoSalary is unimportant. Its like allowance from your parents. "Here's a little cash so you don't starve or freeze during wage slavery" It does not matter if its $50k or $102.5k, the goal is going to be the same for me.
- michaelochurch 13y agoI am so glad this is being revealed now. It's not exactly new, but this is the perfect time. Why? Because Google Bus Protests, that's why. This is a chance for the people and the engineers to line up, shoulder to shoulder, on the same side and take down the fuckers who've become the elite of this system. The resistance begins.
- tsax 13y agoEr yeah. The 'people' i.e. astroturfed left-wing activists are protesting the employees, not the CEOs.
- wildgift 13y agoPlease. I know activists like the Google bus protesters. I'd call them protest enthusiasts, and usually less than half work for professional activist outfits. Most have regular jobs and just love to protest. The "astroturf" is fwd.us and peers.org are pure astroturf. You can't even get a political position out of them until their lobbyists have written the legislation and tried to insert it into some bill.
- tsax 13y agoFalse dichotomy. Both are astroturf.
- sbisker 13y agoNow that this is exposed and (presumably) not as present, has anyone done any work to see if salaries at Apple, Google, etc have since risen higher than salaries at companies who weren't involved with such activity? This sort of shenanigans went on 100 years ago, but we couldn't study the consequences so tightly back then...it seems that Glassdoor's data, H1B data, etc provides a unique opportunity to study the effectiveness (or lack thereof) of such federal intervention.
- spamizbad 13y agoHard to say since the hiring boom has mostly passed. There's still demand for tech talent but you don't have multiple companies trying to hire thousands of engineers at once anymore. We'll have to wait for another "boom" to see.
- wouldprefernot2 13y agoAt least at Google, there was a 10% raise at the start of 2011.
- nostrademons 13y agoAnecdotally salaries at the major tech companies just shot up in early 2011, which was soon after the DOJ started its investigation. It's hard to infer causation though, as this could have been because of rising competition from Facebook for employees, or it could have been because of the large amount of seed capital sloshing around in the startup world then, or it could have been because of the Fed's easy-money policies. Connecting this to current events, this was also the start of SF's rent-and-eviction crisis. 2011 was when new grads started getting 6-figure salaries to work in tech, and experienced senior engineers started getting up to $250K/year in total comp. Turns out that when a large number of workers start getting big salaries in a region where the housing supply is basically fixed, much of that money goes into rent.
- aliston 13y agoFacebook was the company that broke the cabal based on everything I've heard from friends at these companies. I think it actually started a little before 2011, more like the end of 2009, early 2010. Facebook was (obviously) not averse to poaching employees of other companies, and was particularly good at hiring ex-Googlers by offering large stock grants and relatively high salaries (~150k + 100k+ in options) for someone with 2-3 years of experience out of school. Google made some jaw dropping counteroffers to those who left and gave everyone a large raise and bonus at the end of 2010 as a result of the increased competition.
- wouldprefernot 13y agoI'm curious. Are the executives who make these illegal agreements to restrain trade ever personally held liable? It seems that would be more effective than fining the companies, or the usual "We don't admit to doing anything wrong, but here's some money anyways." Apologies for the green account, but I would prefer not to have my real name attached to such a discussion.
- raganwald 13y agoAnd therein lies the problem. Although these companies are being prosecuted, nobody wants to run afoul of them or anybody else. I'm not saying that any one individual or company is presently a bullying wrongdoer, but what I am saying is that there is an culture of fear around speaking out or rubbing people the wrong way. This atmosphere--along with the kind of proprietary shenanigans that make it difficult or impossible to truly own your own hardware and software stack--is the very opposite of the hacker ethos that created much of the value these barons robbed from the economy.
- auctiontheory 13y agoIt's US culture - people are easily and often fired. Very different other places, even in tech, e.g. Israel, Germany.
- pille 13y agoAnd in Germany I'd be hard-pressed to find you a non-management tech job that makes north of 90k USD/year. It would be great if someone could prove me wrong.
- larholm 13y ago90k USD ist just shy of 66k Euro, which is by no means unheard of for an experienced developer. I know personal anecdotes doesn't count for much, but I turned down several 80k offers in Berlin. I would expect salaries in Munich to be 10-15% higher due to cost of living.
- warble 13y agoThis seems like it takes some basic facts and then jumps to a lot of conclusions without any data (like sbisker mentions) - I'm not suggesting it's BS, but it's not clear their obvious conclusions are so obvious. I'd love to see actual wage data.
- talmand 13y agoWhat could the wage data show you? That everyone in all these companies were being paid much the same for similar positions? Doesn't seem like that would prove much of anything. You would have to somehow compare data from these companies with companies outside the group. But even then, I'm willing to bet it would show little because these companies were the big guns in the area. Very few companies would be able to outbid them in wages in the first place. Wage data is probably not really needed here. From what I understand of the law, the mere fact that they had the agreement was illegal. Meaning they didn't even have to implement the agreement, just that they made it. That they seemed to have implemented it and attempted to hide it only adds to their problems.
- billnguyen 13y agoThe price of anything is a function of its supply versus its demand. A non open (or not truly open in this case) kills demand. Without demand for a finite supply (high quality engineers) the supply's worth can never fully be realized.
- dasil003 13y agoAs a programmer sure this annoys me, but I find it a bit disingenuous to tie it to growing societal inequality. Tech workers are definitely on the beneficiary side of the inequality gap, so I don't see how these conspiracies to indirectly keep tech workers salaries down to 2x to 5x of median American household income is really germane.
- fidotron 13y agoSo the money that would have gone to the programmers goes to the upper executive layers instead. This merely moves things around slightly, and if anything further squeezes wealth into the top 1% as opposed to top 10%. This whole story looks fairly damning, especially to Jobs and Schmidt, though that is probably the intent. Faced with a hiring war with 2005 era Jobs you'd have to have serious guts to refuse - like apparently the Palm CEO did.
- benihana 13y ago>So the money that would have gone to the programmers goes to the upper executive layers instead. This merely moves things around slightly, and if anything further squeezes wealth into the top 1% as opposed to top 10%. Citation needed. Where do you see that it went to the people at the top and wasn't invested back into the company?
- talmand 13y agoEven re-investment back into the company could lead to increased revenues for the people at the top. Regardless, I find it doubtful you could possibly prove such a thing, even if it were true. One just has to assume that such things helps the company, which in turn helps the people who profit from the company doing well.
- hkmurakami 13y ago>Even re-investment back into the company could lead to increased revenues for the people at the top. I think the best comparison is Wall Street firms, where a disprportionate chunk of revenues are paid out as compensation to employees. There's longstanding criticism by shareholders that this outsized compensation should be reduced in favor of giving back that value to shareholders. "re-investment" back into Google likely benefits such shareholders (the majority of whom are not employees of the company) than employees.
- gress 13y agoIt may be that the consequences of the 'conspiracy' was to depress wages, and it should clearly be prosecuted if the legal case can be made. However does anyone think that this was the intention behind these agreements? Isn't it more likely that they wanted to stop an insane war on one another's businesses by buying off key employees to disrupt one another's operations? It would seem as though companies with a giant stockpile of cash - I.e. MS, Google, and Apple, could stifle competitors by just taking out key employees of their opponents with large signing bonuses, regardless of whether they intend to put them to work or not. The result would be a destruction of value.
- tdees40 13y agoThis is probably true. Competition is sometimes destructive. But these business practices are still completely illegal.
- talmand 13y agoI would say that since the idea apparently started with Lucas and he specifically stated it was done to prevent bidding wars because they simply couldn't afford it at the time supports the thought. I don't think it was the sole intention. But two things stand out to me that was part of the deal. The fact that the HR departments would inform each other if their employees were applying for a job at a company within the group; which by the way should be considered a huge privacy issue. Also that when an employee was made an offer, they only received a "final offer" to specifically avoid a bidding war. Those two things directly relate to wage suppression to me. As for your example, that's quite true. But in the end it still stifles those employees' ability to increase their income because these companies directly conspired to not recruit from each other. It is not in the employee's interest to worry over if Company A wants to give them a pile of money to simply leave Company B but not work. Two companies coming to such an agreement for their benefit is a detriment to the employee, which is what the lawsuit is about. Never mind the fact that the whole thing is clearly illegal under multiple federal and state laws. Therefore, their intentions are irrelevant.
- bps4484 13y agoThe solution here is the same as the solution when Zuckerberg complained about employees leaving their jobs too quickly[1]: Pay your employees more. Figure out what kind of value they bring, and the amount of cost if they were to leave, and adjust their wages accordingly. Make no mistake about it, the ultimate goal of stifling competition is to depress wages. While maybe described as "disrupting operation", it is really just allowing a company to not pay an employee what they are worth. Analogously, if 2 companies sold widgets, one in state A and one in state B, and they each had a near monopoly in each state, if they each made a closed door agreement not to enter into each others' states so they could each maintain their near monopoly, I think people, and courts, would certainly cry foul. Certainly competing would disrupt each others' operations, but the competition would bring better products and better prices to both states, and that's the point. [1] http://techcrunch.com/2011/10/30/facebooks-zuckerberg-if-i-were-starting-a-company-now-i-would-have-stayed-in-boston/ http://techcrunch.com/2011/10/30/facebooks-zuckerberg-if-i-w...
- rll 13y agoI was at Yahoo during the years in question and must have been approached 50+ times by Google recruiters. I wonder if Yahoo refused to play along or perhaps they were never invited.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sounds 13y agoTo anyone just starting their tech career in the US, pay attention to the parent comment. Edit: parent deleted the comment, so here it is: (I sincerely hope the parent is not getting hauled off in handcuffs as we speak.) As a former Intel engineer the only thing that surprised me is how high up these abuses went. These companies and their leaders are scum to the highest degree. Between refusing to consider american candidates, mandatority never ending "crunch" time and suppressed wages I can only warn others to stay as far away from the companies listed in this article as possible, especially if you have an engineering degree. If you don't actually do anything its can be a pretty rewarding career assuming you have a knack for abusing others... such actions are highly rewarded at these companies. The number of H1-B visas I saw pleading for relief would astound even the Foxconn taskmasters. H1-B visas are one of the major motivations behind the "immigration reform" being talked about in Washington DC. The purpose is to drive down tech salaries. Don't believe them when they claim they are trying to improve labor conditions for minorities or something. To truly help non-US-citizens they would be requesting more green cards and US citizenship. H1-B leaves a person in a limbo world where they are essentially an indentured servant of the company. And the result is lower wages for everyone. Intel's hiring and HR fiasco has been a running joke in the industry for decades now. Read iWoz (by Steve Wozniak) to find out about Jobs' behavior at Apple. Intuit appears to be at the center of this class action suit. The real surprise is that Google joined them. Good thing Facebook didn't!
- gboudrias 13y ago> The real surprise is that Google joined them. They've acquired a company that builds military robots [1]. I think it's safe to say their sense of ethics is all but gone. The only question here is when exactly they became "evil" (in their own terms). [1]: http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-12-16/google-just-bought-some-really-creepy-military-robots http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-12-16/google-just-...
- 13y ago
- pbreit 13y agoEvery time I read an article about this I fell like I'm at The Onion. Drive ++down++ engineer wages? Really? Does anyone on planet earth feel like engineer wages are/were artificially low?
- beachstartup 13y agoYES. based on anecdotal evidence, top engineer salaries start capping out at 150k, when in reality this should go into the 300, 400, 500k range like lawyers and finance people make. it's already starting to turn, so i'm hopeful.
- United857 13y agoAt many companies, both startups and established, if you're a top performer and/or joined early enough, stock grants can easily propel you into this range (and beyond).
- beachstartup 13y agoi'm talking about cash compensation on an annual basis. this is what matters when you are working for a living. i.e., not the stock lottery which doesn't apply to 99% of people.
- pyrrhotech 13y agothe figures he referenced are straight salary. A typical 30 year old investment banker at top firms will make 400k salary, but could easily be over 7 figures with bonus. Startup equity is rarely, if ever, worth that much on a risk-adjusted basis.
- United857 13y agoNot just startups, but even big companies like Google and Facebook have seen significant stock growth that have resulted in 2-3x compensation increases -- even if you joined post-IPO.
- aspensmonster 13y agoJobs' comments: >OK, I’ll tell our recruiters they are free to approach any Adobe employee who is not a Sr. Director or VP. Am I understanding your position correctly? >if you [Brin] hire a single one of these people that means war. Chizen's comment: >if I tell Steve [Jobs] it’s open season (other than senior managers), he will deliberately poach Adobe just to prove a point. Knowing Steve, he will go after some of our top Mac talent… Jobs sounds like a Grade-A Asshole, along with every other player involved in this mess. Makes me even less likely to relocate to SV than I already was. Though now I'm curious to know whether these wage-theft pacts extend beyond SV, perhaps to Austin... Many of the same players have a significant presence here. Seriously. If you've got info, hit me up.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zaidf 13y agoThis is where he crosses the asshole line over to scumbag and crook territory. I say this as someone who respects Jobs deeply for his product vision.
- kirubakaran 13y agoHe has always been there. "Jobs told him that Atari gave them only $700 (instead of the offered $5,000), and that Wozniak's share was thus $350. Wozniak did not learn about the actual bonus until ten years later, but said that if Jobs had told him about it and had said he needed the money, Wozniak would have given it to him." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Wozniak http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Wozniak
- wellboy 13y agoIsn't this good, because it kept the insane rents in Silicon Valley down a bit at least?
- msoad 13y agoEngineers should make more money than what they are making now. The largest number I heard lately is $240k for a data scientist from Apple. That's too low! That person can make Siri better and make millions for Apple. Why aren't we getting paid like lawyers? If they win $20M they will get paid at least $2M. But if we make a product that generates $20M profit, at best we get $20K bonus. This has to change!
- crazy1van 13y ago> Why aren't we getting paid like lawyers? If they win $20M they will get paid at least $2M. But if we make a product that generates $20M profit, at best we get $20K bonus. This has to change! Is that really true? Their firm might get 2M. But in a big case, I imagine there are many lawyers and assistants involved. Sure the partners are going to do quite well. But, the founders of a tech firm also do quite well when their company receives a windfall of cash.
- GBond 13y agoThis is because a programmer's contribution to the "20M profit" is not easily quantifiable and measurable being that he is mostly likely part of a team working on a feature that is a part of a whole. However a lawyer who wins a case or a sale person who sells a big deal can easily point to the quantifiable win to a specific dollar amount.
- sjg007 13y agoThey way you change it is by starting your own company.
- hkmurakami 13y agoExcept for the fact that startup founders by in large perpetuate the owner-employee inequity that they themselves were a victim of. Really, it reminds me of fraternities/athletics and hazing.
- sjg007 13y agoSo choose to work for a startup that doesn't do that. There are plenty of profit sharing companies out there. Or become a quant where you can eat what you kill. Inequity, really has nothing to do with fairness. If the startup can't hire, they will offer more until they do hire (or go out of business or worse never achieve). What you can negotiate is based on your position. If you are ex-Google or Facebook you can make bank at a more established tech company looking to turnaround (cough.. cough.. Yahoo) or at a startup looking for "top talent" or get access to VC funding. It is the same dynamics you see in professional sports.
- parennoob 13y ago[Tangential] This is going to be a heavily unpopular opinion, but I bet the whole drive of "Teach everyone to code" broadly comes under the same umbrella. Shortage of tech workers? Well, there is a predicted massive shortage of doctors and nurses in the US too [0] (huge healthcare expenses, anyone?), but there is no drive to teach everyone to learn basic nursing / medical skills. Why? Because doctors are very careful to promote the worldview, "This is very important, it can't be done by just anyone, can it?" even for minor things like coughs and colds; while completely glossing over stuff like community health. Ever seen your doctor friend volunteer for a "Let's teach everyone basic emergency responder skills!" campaign? Why not a "Let's teach everyone basic vaccine administration" project; so we can stop paying through the nose for, say, birth control shots? Because nurses and doctors are heavily unionized, unlike, say, software devs or sysadmins -- and such initiatives would be strongly discouraged by the unions. So, when you participate enthusiastically in that "Let's teach everyone to code!" event sponsored by $BIG_CORPORATION, be aware that you are slowly but surely driving down wages for tech workers. [0] http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702304506904575180331528424238 http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405270230450690...
- talmand 13y agoWhat astounds me by all this is the idea that the HR people in all these companies seemed to have no issues with going along with these highly illegal schemes. Must make for an interesting work environment to know that your HR people were willing to screw you over for little or no personal gain.
- wutbrodo 13y agoThere's a couple of examples of them getting fired for not going along with it. I don't think "following instructions so as to keep your job" is as bad as "willing to screw you over".
- talmand 13y agoIf you are threatened with firing or fired for not going along with an illegal activity I would think the proper thing to do would be to report the illegal activity. If the law was structured in a slightly different way they could have been dragged into the court case for going along with the scheme.
- firstOrder 13y agoThe typical response I hear to the idea of more widespread labor unions or AMA-like professional associations for programmers and network/systems/storage/database administrators is that if someone is really talented, they can negotiate a good salary, and that labor organizing together would just protect the lazy and the slackers. You hear this same thing when someone is lowballed a salary number, or has to put up with some other annoying workplace condition, it's said the person should negotiate this all up front with the employer, and that the person's lawyer should get involved in the negotiation. As if one person has any chance negotiating against a Fortune 500 company's HR department, legal department etc. (or the equivalent forms coming from some venture backed firm whose VC's lawyer's help with the HR legal forms). Especially when the heads of tech companies are united ( http://www.fwd.us http://www.fwd.us ) to trying to flood the Valley with low-paid workers chained to the H1-B visa, driving down wages and shortening the careers of programmers ( http://heather.cs.ucdavis.edu/h1b.html http://heather.cs.ucdavis.edu/h1b.html ). Now on top of that, we see that the companies are united in trying to drive down wages. It's not just one Fortune 500 company doing this, it's the management of all of them doing it together. Yet the idea of programmers and admins organizing to defend their interests? Well only complainers do that. Steve Jobs and Eric Schmidt organize for their collective interests, but any tech who did that must have something wrong with him - he's a complainer, lazy, whatever. We shouldn't be organized to have our interests defended. It's a zero-sum issue with two potential beneficiary sides. There are those of us who work, and create wealth being screwed by this. There are those on this board who benefit from this exploitation and thus will pick at points in this article, in this post and so on. Why wouldn't they, they're the ones who parasitically benefit from this expropriation and exploitation.
- joyeuse6701 13y agoEveryone held the anti union position because of the now proven illusion of meritocracy. You may well get your wish, all aspects of unions included.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoTech engineers get pushed around by upper management and have failed to professionalize like doctors because too many of them lack social and political savvy. It's a clear personality trait in the profession. Look at the way so many programmers choose to dress and groom. Can you imagine a top lawyer looking like that? The importance of projecting a serious professional image to the broader society doesn't seem to even occur to most software people.
- trysomething 13y agoThis conduct is obviously despicable, though certainly not out-of-character for Steve Jobs (all due respect for his talents). However, I generally believe this will resolve (and has been resolving) itself via market mechanisms. The mistaken assumption is that the only competition here is between Apple, Google etc and that it is focused primarily on income. The market is a lot more subtle than that: 1. Hackers are not simply mercenaries, esp. the best. 2. A decent % of the best are involved in startups, either as founders or early hires. 3. "Acquihires" are a mechanism for the best engineers to get paid more "outside" the system. 4. Aside from industry, there is competition from academia etc.
- sounds 13y agoYour points are well thought out, but I'd like to play devil's advocate to get you to expand on them, if I may... 1. Isn't this why large companies target the inexperienced, the recent college grad who is scrambling to make rent, or exploit people who can only live and work in the US if they get that job? 2. Some would say once you're a successful startup founder, you're "one of them" and the incentives become reversed. Do you think hackers who become founders still retain the hacker ethos? Why? 3. Because acquihires aren't fully disclosed, wouldn't the market function more efficiently if the compensation came through more normal means (salary and stock grants)? 4. Do you really feel like an academic path has competitive compensation to industry?
- trysomething 13y ago1. Absolutely, they do target these people, particularly through internships which are essentially recruiting tools. The BigCo advantage is that any decent salary will seem like a lot to people who've never had one before. However, they are not the only players in the game, particularly recently. Y-Combinator itself started as a recognition of this paradox: while recent grads may be "struggling" to make rent (and in need of income), they are good at struggling (scrappy, risk-tolerant etc) and therefore ideally suited to starting a startup. That said, I believe this particular lawsuit is more relevant to "proven" talent than students. 2. I think "hackers" will generally retain the "hacker" ethos, which I don't think is particularly tied to how they behave as founders or executives. I don't see "hackers" as any more or less benevolent or idealistic than the general population in the long run. In the short run, however, they are more likely to feel empathy since they were in the same shoes as their early employees more recently. From a more pragmatic standpoint, they realize more acutely that it will take a lot to get the best people to stay and contribute to someone else's dream. Finally until they are formidable enough to engage in strategic discourse with the likes of Google and Apple, they don't have the ability to attempt such collusion. 3. Perhaps, but not necessarily. Acquihires might be a particularly good tool for talent discovery. There's also the potential threat that acquihires represent (if you treat us (engineers) too badly we'll just leave and you will have to buy us back 10x). Your argument here is a good one, acquihires may reduce information available to all parties. However, this information asymmetry may work against the acquirer more than the acquired (or vice versa). I don't think there is enough data to confirm either possibility. 4. It depends on what you mean by compensation. In many cases (not all), the work may be more interesting and more importantly you (may) have more freedom in choosing what to work on. I qualify these statements because to get all the way to this utopia you need to get tenure, which is hard. Regardless, you get to work with the best and most interesting people, which is a form of compensation. Also, plenty of startups come out of academia simply because it's like an extension of student life* (particularly grad students, post-docs and other non-tenured people). * discussed in #1
- smoyer 13y agoI don't agree that these agreements are ethical, but can someone explain how they're different from the way a professional sports team manages the rules for players transitioning from team to team? Perhaps the leagues should have more oversight too? Note that this completely ignores the NFL's non-profit status ... why was that ever granted?
- maxerickson 13y agoNFL players are all members of a union and collectively negotiate those rules. (I doubt the league especially factors into the terms of the contracts between teams and players, but the non-profit status is probably granted because the team owners extract profits and the league just keeps the wheels turning, there isn't an owner that makes money on the league itself)
- staunch 13y agoSomething that I think gets forgotten in tech salary discussions is inflation. Consider that a $122k salary in 2001 would be $160k/yr in 2013, adjusted for inflation.
- wyclif 13y agoMark Ames loves overusing the word "dreary" and its variants: three consecutive times in as many short paragraphs. PandoDaily needs a copy editor rather badly.
- alooPotato 13y agoI remember reading that these pacts don't apply if an employee initiates contact with another company. Seems like that would be the best way to get salaries closer to market rates - simply be proactive and always talk to other companies and get your company to increase your salary to stay.
- josho 13y agoYou missed the part where salary ranges are shared, that before an offer is made the current employer is made aware of what is about to happen, and more... I suggest you read the article it is quite comprehensive the measures taken to decrease pressure on rising wages.
- acslater00 13y agoYeah hate to spoil the party, but this is not 'wage theft'. Wage theft is very specifically the act of withholding wages that an employee is entitled to according to the terms of his or her employment agreement. What happened here is not even 'price-fixing', it's a fairly weak attempt at 'collusion'. Yes, it seems improper at first blush and the email exchanges are almost comically incriminating, but my guess is that it didn't really have a substantial effect on the engineer salaries write large (or even executive salaries). Agreeing not to cold-call employees is not the same thing as refusing to hire them; that latter would have had a major depressing effect on wages (kind of like if all MLB teams had a handshake agreement to never sign another team's free agent) but that clearly isn't what happened here. It seems to me like the proof is in the pudding. If big tech companies are colluding to depress engineer wages, they're pretty obviously failing. Anyway, I have no idea how this lawsuit will shake out, but I know that Pando Daily is doing a shit-ass job of reporting, and I regret clicking on the link and giving them the additional pageview.
- coralreef 13y agoIf big tech companies are colluding to depress engineer wages, they're pretty obviously failing. How do you conclude that they're failing?
- polyomino 13y agoAstroturfing
- skj 13y agoI assume that the poster was being genuine, but is also suffering wage-shock - the wages that tech workers get are so much higher than what he/she was used to getting, and for far less (apparent) effort than people who make peanuts. It seems unfair, until you realize how much money the company is getting for these services.
- zaidf 13y agoIf big tech companies are colluding to depress engineer wages, they're pretty obviously failing. If crooks are trying to rob retailers, I don't see empty shelves at walmart so the crooks are obviously failing. (I don't think it matters if Jobs failed or succeeded. The appalling thing here is that Steve Jobs attempted an extremely scummy and potentially illegal move.)
- worldsoup 13y agothe leaders of Apple and Google are greedy crooks...they are just way better at PR than most other corporate bigwigs
- hoboerectus 13y agoMaybe it goes back further than that - maybe in the late '80s lobby Congress to get the "Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1990" - a.k.a. the H-1B - to get some cheap immigrant headcount up, then maybe come up with the Java programming language to get a simplified base point where they would be at equal state, or something like that, maybe ship some of them back home to train more, and then recurse. Maybe. Maybe people other than engineers do engineering.
- quesera 13y agoThe article claims that a "no-poach" agreement constitutes "wage theft". I lost count at how many times that phrase was used in the article, but it was probably fifteen times. It's completely incorrect, dishonest, and overdramatic to the point of being insulting. I accuse pandodaily of brain theft. HN needs a kill file, I have truly never read an intelligent article from them.
- wpietri 13y agoI get why you are upset about that, in that it's a term of art that is being misused. But given that the goal was to keep wages lower so that companies could pocket the money, it's not an unreasonable way to describe it casually.
- d23 13y ago> These secret conversations and agreements between some of the biggest names in Silicon Valley were first exposed in a Department of Justice antitrust investigation launched by the Obama Administration in 2010. Why is it that lines like this never quite make it into the comments section here?
- dfraser992 13y agoAll of the excuses and rationalizations I see posted here make me ill. It's like very few "peons" understand the mentality of those who are "in charge" - e.g. the Clueless, Loser, Sociopath hierarchy of how businesses are structured. There has been a recent spate of stories across the web about how wealth affects people's mentality and behavior - I am reminded now of a story about India and how the stark class differences there motivate those at the upper end to treat those not in their own class as even human.... it is more subtle, but just as bad here in the UK. Why would it be any different in the West? How in the world is Silicon Valley, or IT in general, any much different than any other business sector? It is a fundamental characteristic of capitalism that capital will try to exploit labor as much as possible and by any means available. Engineers getting $250K a year is irrelevant - those people are still just "house niggers"... As a middle class American, admittedly clueless, the education I've gotten over the past decade has been eye opening. And a bit late; I wish I'd learned this stuff years ago. But that is the dark side of being an engineer - the work and the creative aspects can swamp everything else. Other creative professions have this same basic problem, with the business major types exploiting them as much as possible. And basic Marxist theory is even more forbidden than rational thought about drugs in America... i am not a raving Marxist, but after the last 4 years of my life getting shafted by one of the new crop of robber barons (an out and out sociopath) (yes, I have finally graduated from the Loser class (or been expelled)) it's... christ. Humanity is so tiresome. I've had some great bosses, mind you, and worked for some good companies. But the capital-labor relationship is fundamentally deteriorating and with the coming rise of automation and increased population and refusal to raise taxes and all these other social forces I see, the future looks very dystopian over the next 20 years. Things are getting such that the only logical position to take is that you incorporate yourself and thus you can act as sociopathic as you need to, given everyone else is acting the same. Does anyone with any sense want to live in such a world? I'd like to just do a good day's work, get paid fairly for it and not have to spend more time figuring out how to protect myself from getting screwed over - or figuring out how to screw over the next guy. I can't do my best possible work otherwise. I've got better things to do than play social games. This is something Ayn Rand touched upon in Altas Shrugged, as reviled as that book might be. Lots of capitalists these days are nothing but the social leeches that she railed against, despite their hypocritical protests to the contrary. I guess I am a Marxist, or at least see the slice of truth about life and society that it reveals. There is a value in honest work, in creating something useful for society - that is something fundamental to being a real engineer. IT likes to claim that is a fundamental value of the profession, but I don't see that anymore (in general). There is too much money sloshing around. Things are getting out of balance. I can only hope the social strife prevalent in the 30s (go read some American history) comes about again - OWS and the protests in the Bay Area now are only the beginning. Then again, the resurgence of the fundamental social forces motivating the 60s that happened in the very early days of the rave scene got explicitly squashed by the authoritarian parts of the power structures in society.... Yes, I do have some stories. Fortunately, climate change will smack humanity upside the head and force us to start thinking differently.
- zgm 13y agoAs a new grad about to enter the workforce, I find this more than a little disconcerting. Do any experienced engineers have any advice on how to avoid this kind of mistreatment?
- josho 13y agoKnow your market value. You can find this out by doing occasional job interviews and receiving offers. Don't view this as wasting your time or theirs, if a truly exceptional offer is made you would take it, and you often don't know if they are exceptional until late in the process. (e.g. my second job out of school nearly didn't happen because after the second interview I thought the role wasn't interesting, fortunately the hiring manager persisted and found a role in the company that I enjoyed, I stayed at that company for 5 successful years) Learn how to negotiate, use those job offers from above to practice countering on an offer. Realize that raises are negotiations too, and in negotiations before the raise comes you need to prepare your boss properly. E.g. Weeks/months before raise season remind your boss about your accomplishments. Remind your boss about your accomplishments, it's not bragging if you do it right. Finally, just as you manage your career by learning technical skills you need to manage your career by learning soft skills, and other career advancing techniques. I wish I had books to recommend, but my lessons were all learned through mistakes.
- zgm 13y agoThanks, josho! I appreciate the concrete, actionable advice.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThere are five courses of action: ⚫ Be ownership. Start your own company. You'll rapidly find that the same numerical collusion advantages which apply to large employers are even more applicable to VC and funders, and that the game they play is for control. Even Jobs got screwed out of his own company. ⚫ Opt out of the game. Welcome to the world of post-growth economics and the impact that has for wages everywhere. ⚫ Move to where hiring is growing. I've quoted Smith above on collusion. He also has advice for where to find rising wages: "It is not the actual greatness of national wealth, but its continual increase, which occasions a rise in the wages of labour. It is not, accordingly, in the richest countries, but in the most thriving, or in those which are growing rich the fastest, that the wages of labour are highest." (Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter VII, http://www.gutenberg.org/files/3300/3300-h/3300-h.htm#link2HCH0008 http://www.gutenberg.org/files/3300/3300-h/3300-h.htm#link2H...) So, if you can emigrate somewhere with rising employment, you'll do better. The problem of course is the same as for the 3rd option: growth is flattening everywhere. ⚫ Unionize. Good luck with that, as Silicon Valley has been hugely resistant to union organization, in no small part due to the contrary-to-their-own interests brainwashing of Libertarian indoctrination. Even if you don't believe it, I can all but guarantee that the suggestion of forming a union will bring the denouncers out of the woodwork. If you do want to proceed, find ways of removing them from the conversation. There are publications from civil rights, unionization, and nonviolent revolutionary movements detailing derailing tactics and how to respond to them. The Albert Einstein Institution's book list is a good start: http://www.aeinstein.org/english/ http://www.aeinstein.org/english/ . In particular, From Dictatorship to Democracy. Studying how opposition movements are disrupted is also helpful. For these, go to the source. FBI's COINTELPRO and HOODWINK documents (the YELLCASING is their thing), the Lewis Powell memo: http://reclaimdemocracy.org/powell_memo_lewis/ http://reclaimdemocracy.org/powell_memo_lewis/ http://billmoyers.com/content/the-powell-memo-a-call-to-arms-for-corporations/ http://billmoyers.com/content/the-powell-memo-a-call-to-arms... ⚫ Suck it up and accept it. You'll be making better bank than most salaried workers, at least while you're working. The rare superstar may do significantly better. Odds are good you'll work in startup serfdom for 10-20 years, then find yourself on the aged side of hip, or whatever the cool kids are calling it then. Assuming there is a Silicon Valley in another 10-20 years. There are a few bigger epochal changes on the horizon. At least having read this you'll begin to understand where you stand and how the game works.
- pg 13y agoIt seems like we should be able to measure whatever effect there was. There must be sources of data about salaries in the Bay Area. Has anyone tried looking to see if there is a depression in tech workers' salaries, relative to people in other fields, during the time this agreement was in force?
- vasilipupkin 13y agoLook at a typical software developer salary in SF vs a typical software developer salary in Chicago, adjust for cost of living, the difference between SF salary and adjusted Chicago salary is the depression For example, demand in SF is much higher than Chicago so SF salary should be >> Chicago * cost of living adjustment. My guess is it's lower
- 100k 13y agoI looked at this calculation for Minneapolis versus SF a while back, and salaries were definitely lower in SF than Minneapolis * cost of living.
- stbtrax 13y agoI've done this same calculation and I found the opposite. And after I moved I realized that you have to also factor in how much more awesome the Bay Area is. I've been able to be outside most days this winter hiking and doing other outdoor activities. I can't imagine going back to winters where I'm trapped indoors.
- vasilipupkin 13y agoThat's not entirely valid, that's a subjective judgement. I live in Chicago and I hate the outdoors. Just a simple back of the envelope calculation tells you Chicago software developers make about the same or more ( because trading companies pay more ) as SF developers yet cost of living is 2.5-3 times higher in SF. It's hard to explain this as a mere correlation with the known fact of illegal collusion.
- abalone 13y agoI think I've read anecdotal stories about companies like google paying huge sums to hold onto engineers, like 6 and 7 figures. Does anyone know what I'm talking about and is this a result of recruitment pressure by startups.. Who obviously don't have the same agreements in place? If so that would seem to support what the plaintiffs are saying.
- PythonicAlpha 13y agoSomebody already complained, that the wage possibilities of software engineers are limited. I would take it further: In all industry, the trend goes one way: The wages of working people (including white-collar, I hope, that is the right word) have to go down, and the earnings from investments (pure money makes money business) have to climb. There are only very few exceptions: One are lawyers, as mentioned in an other thread, and the other are people that work in the investment business (investment bankers, traders, ...). The reason for the second exception is obvious: their work is needed to make even more money from the money and every trick is played, to have the smartest, best guys getting the job done ... and get it done better and better. Problem is: The whole thing breaks our society. Middle classes are already melting massively in many countries. The possessions of the worlds are concentrating in the hands of very few people more and more. Those people make our laws! The other people become poorer, even in the situation that the overall worlds possessions expand massively. The countries are already so much in dept, that many of them can not pay even the interest. Even the US is so much in dept, that there seems to be no possibility to get ever rid of it. Nobody seems to realize, that while we are talking, investment companies are roaming the world for land, for houses, for companies to buy them, exploit them and throw it away when not needed (and not useful) any more. The wealth of the world gets accumulated in the hand of investment companies and the super-rich. By rising the value of pure money investments, the value of human labor (to a more and more extend even high-paid and high-value labor) is degrading.
- cranklin 13y agowell, we can play that same game and form an engineers' union
- bnolsen 13y agodefense contractors did the same to stop engineers from bouncing around as well.
- rajesht 13y agoThe site seems to be down, here is google cached copy http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:s-e6m0J17tAJ:pando.com/2014/01/23/the-techtopus-how-silicon-valleys-most-celebrated-ceos-conspired-to-drive-down-100000-tech-engineers-wages/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:s-e6m0J...
- shawn-butler 13y agoPower-mad, short-sighted CEOs are par for the course. What is really sad is to see are references to the extent that Board members not only were aware but actually facilitated.
- cconroy 13y agoDoes anyone know more about how the institutions which these men and women are perched at the top of, affect there attitudes about workers and their labor? I just can't understand what their motivations are, is it really just about maximizing the bottom line? Do they look at workers as just machines, which are fungible; instead of as human beings that are indispensable from their individuality? Is the institution the sole cause of this, or are these powerful positions in a electric field, only attracting particular forms of matter (and repelling others), or a combination thereof?
- gaius 13y agoAt that level it's a game and money is the score.
- dredmorbius 13y agoOne thing that strikes me as curious is why none of the companies involved broke the story at the time or reported the situation to the Feds. I can think of numerous reasons why, none of them particularly reassuring: ⚫ They all thought they could get away with it. The idea that there were no defectors on this basis makes me question the integrity of the entire tech industry leadership. ⚫ Nobody had faith in the DoJ's ability to to investigate, or a court's ability to place injuctions, on this behavior and/or retaliatory actions. ⚫ Everyone had dirt on everyone else, at least in iteration. It was an n-way Mexican Standoff. Every player felt at least one other had the drop on them. http://fixyt.com/watch?v=HzF_TbmDH5s http://fixyt.com/watch?v=HzF_TbmDH5s http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Mexican%20standoff http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Mexican%20sta... As with the first instance, this does little for establishing trust with the industry. ⚫ The threat of encroaching action was too great. Any defector would be destroyed before the practice could be halted. There's one slim glimmer of hope here: It suggests that the threat of union action would be similarly disruptive and that a concerted action on the part of employees would in fact tend to succeed. The Achilles heel of the tech industry is that its capital walks out the door every night. If it realizes it can not come back, or merely threaten to not come back, it will have gained a great deal of leverage. ⚫ They simply didn't care. Arrogance, psychopathy, delusion. It doesn't particularly matter. Again, trust and reassurance are not promoted.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deepGem 13y agoSo what if Google/Apple/Intel and everyone under the sun poached each other's talent. How high can the salaries go and how high can the money drain affect. After a certain number of years, things are bound to normalise isn't it ? Why fret over 5 - 10 billion when all of these companies put together have something like $500 billion collectively in cash. I seriously do not get this.
- OldSchool 13y agoSteve Jobs said it well, "this means war." The engineering profession as a whole needs to play "war" like adults. This is going to cost money like anything. A permanent PR company that at least gets the engineering profession a louder voice than Marissa Mayer would be a start. A permanent lobbying budget to slowly but continually chip away at domestic and international threats to the buying power of your talent with changes in law is the other half of how grown ups play "war." No need to act like laborers and form a union or have strikes. Real change today happens via PR and lobbying. A well-funded and run professional organization formed with this as its sole agenda would do wonders for all of us.
- joyeuse6701 13y agoI wonder: could the recruiters that were fired sue based on wrongful termination?
- cromwellian 13y agoAmazing how just a day ago, the media is carrying stories about wealthy techies hurting poor people, driving up prices, living in lavish palaces, and enjoying huge unfair perks like free shuttles to the office. Now the story is, they should have had even more money.
- pja 13y agoAh yes, "Don't be evil": illegally colluding to line your own pockets at the expense of your employees is clearly perfectly acceptable behaviour as far as Google execs are concerned however. Makes you wonder in what other ways Google has "not been evil" doesn't it.
- nice1 13y agoHey, this is just like the big guys forming a trade union, right? Trade unions are legal, no? :^)
- ABS 13y agointeresting that no one (of the CEOs involved or here in the comments) thought about the natural thing to do when faced by an abuse: to report it. That would be too much I guess :-)
- laichzeit0 13y agoI don't really feel sorry for the employees. There's this fascination between geeks to work at one of these "prestigious" companies, Google, Microsoft, Apple, etc. yet at the end of they day you are burning all your time, effort, essentially your life, to make a few guys rich. They pay you enough to keep you happy, give you a few "interesting" problems to work on if you're lucky, maybe a couple of perks at the office. Why are you selling your soul to these guys in the first place? I just don't get why you'd be interested in making someone else rich for some geek-cred.
- cdeonier 13y agoThat's pretty pessimistic. Sometimes there actually are interesting problems at those companies. Larger companies can also offer benefits that aren't available at some other companies-- sometimes security, sometimes work-life balance, greater access to resources or talented people. Not everyone's tradeoffs will be the same when evaluating where to work or what to do. And in the end, pretty much everyone is working for someone to "make a few guys rich". Unless you're a completely self-funded founder or investor.
- bitL 13y agoKids, this is why you should strive to become your own bosses and bootstrap your own businesses!
- AnneTheAgile 13y agoSince CA is one of the few states that bars non-competes, I doubt this lawsuit could have been brought forth in any other state. Lawyers out there, am I right? In NYC for example, the non-competes are draconian, and there is far less movement between companies. In SiV, fortunately, movement is the norm.
- sarojt 13y agoI thought anti poaching pacts were legal, arent they?Big tech companies like Facebook and Microsoft have them.
- lucasisola 13y agoAnd now they conspired to bring down the site that hosted this article...
- presspot 13y agoMy personal experience is that the pay structure at Google has not depressed wages at all. It's not unusual to encounter a mid-tier engineering lead pulling down $650k+/yr (with stock), working 40 hours a week. Try hiring that person away from Google. It's nearly impossible to match that kind of take-home without turning your business completely upside down.
- kv85s 13y agoI blame the spineless executives, who peed themselves and folded at the words "this means war". WTF did that hippy salesman Jobs know about war? Oh, you'll go and hurt someone's feelings at a meeting? Give me a F-ing break. That shitbag Jobs wasn't fit to scrape the muck off a real veteran's boot.
- nathanvanfleet 13y agoI'm not sure why no one is talking about Schmidt in regards to this article? He is also a famous dick and even a sex creep. Neither of those two were known as being a nice guy.
- jfasi 13y agoDoes anyone else find it amusing that the author is trying to put an "income inequality" spin on an article about tech employees being forced to take low to mid six figure salaries?
- jazzyk 13y agoNo, I don't find it amusing. I think you missed the point. What is being discussed is _relative_compensation. Relative to additional revenue generated, or relative to what other professionals (doctors/lawyers) make. Keep thinking like a slave, you will be one for life.
- leterter 13y agoThe war on the middle class! And they are winning.
- brosco45 13y agoWe lose.
- yuhong 13y agoI remember another thread suggesting that Eric Schmidt be fired for this.
- known 13y agoUnlike Capitalism, Globalization is Zero-Sum.