19 ms·
Smoking is Worse Than You Imagined
- stevewillows 13y agoAs a smoker who is constantly in the 'I'm quitting..' phase, is there a reason that cigarettes are so bad? Is the burning of tobacco itself lethal or are the additives the principal killers?
- Synaesthesia 13y agoIt's just the burning of any plant material and inhaling the smoke, that's bad. Smoke is little particles of ash and soot that clog up your lungs. Smoking weed also messes up your lungs.
- stevewillows 13y agoSeems logical. I don't touch weed at all. I vape part-time and have found that it helps with the nicotine craving, but man... I love smoking. Reading articles like this push me further and further away from 'analogs', as we say. Addictions aside, vaping is a better alternative for days when I have meetings and have to work around others.
- Synaesthesia 13y agoI know, one gets accustomed to the action of smoking. It's very satisfying. I'm also gonna switch to vaping though
- stevewillows 13y agoI mentioned this in other comments, but I've found a decent replacement in the iTaste variable voltage battery with a dual-coil pro-tank. I've been vaping with 'Toblacco' which is a black honey tobacco --- most tobacco flavoured e-liquids taste like shit, but this one is well balanced. I also enjoyed Blackberry quite a bit.
- BugBrother 13y agoSnus is a relevant data point to support Synaesthesia's claim. It is (non smoke) tobacco, but won't give you cancer or destroy your lungs (still not healthy with nicotine, of course, but many times less bad). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snus
- stevewillows 13y agogood Lord.. that's not for me.
- BugBrother 13y agoThe variants in small bags are easy to use. I smoke/snus when drinking, so I use nicotine ~ once a month. I feel better the day after with snus.
- stevewillows 13y agoIf you have a desire for nicotine, you should look into a good vaping option. I mentioned what I'm using in a comment above (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7088395 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7088395).
- russelldavis 13y ago> won't give you cancer. Untrue. "Smokeless tobacco is a major cause of oral cancer, pancreatic cancer, and esophageal cancer." http://www.webmd.com/smoking-cessation/features/snus-tobacco-health-risks http://www.webmd.com/smoking-cessation/features/snus-tobacco...
- BugBrother 13y agoA better reference than Wikipedia? :-) E.g., Wikipedia says: Thus far, the evidence specifically implicating snus in pancreatic cancer is only suggestive.[25][26] Your link say: [Scandinavian] snus users have a significantly higher risk of pancreatic cancer. That is a contradiction. Wikipedia has references. And snus, according to both references, is less bad than snuff. Your quote ("Smokeless tobacco") generalizes over the same group.
- schainks 13y agoI think it's safe to say that the burning of something that you directly inhale is the principal killer, regardless of what's in it. When burning organic matter, there tend to be many byproducts produced. Often more harmful than not. Odds are we didn't evolve to breathe them on a constant basis. If we had, this stuff wouldn't give us mouth and lung diseases so much, would it? If we had evolved to tolerate doing this to ourselves, then we wouldn't be arguing about this. IMHO, some people do seem to adapt better to burning things and inhaling them. BUT I'm not going to test that out on myself for 20 years only come out the other side with lung cancer (or worse). It's a crapshoot, really. Your call. Plus, I like the fact my sense of taste and smell works better than it did when I was a smoker. If the nicotine in tobacco didn't give you the high you feel when smoking, would people still be smoking and getting cancer? Probably not. People like getting high. Take that away and what reason is there to smoke? But I digress... So, to answer your question, "all of the above". You smoke to get high from the nicotine, but the other shit in the smoke is what your body can't tolerate (generally speaking, as yes I agree there are many instances of people living perfectly normal lives smoking the whole time). I'd take up smoking e-cigarettes if you feel it's safer to you (long term) than smoking cigarettes.
- stevewillows 13y agoyeah, I'm progressing toward vaping full time -- but it's the habit. I could set my watch to it. haha When I quit last year (no vaping), the first thing I noticed was how incredibly salty restaurant food was. After years of working with essential oils (for soap making and such), my nose leaves much to be desired. If you do try vaping, try an iTaste variable voltage battery with a dual-coil pro-tank. Also get an e-liquid that's 50/50 between vegetable glycerine (good vapor -- 'clouds') and propylene glycol (throat hit). This is what I'm using now, and as a result I've lowered my 'analog' intake by half.
- DanBC 13y agoThe tar is pretty harmful. This youtube video is interesting. I'm not sure how accurate it is. http://youtu.be/k-MRkC5DqFQ http://youtu.be/k-MRkC5DqFQ
- agumonkey 13y agoThe sad synergy between the two...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jessedhillon 13y agoHow long will it be until we can definitive statements about e-cigarettes? I hate being in a bar or club, or fucking anywhere really, and seeing people smoking those things indoors. But if asked whether that smoke is actually harming me, I couldn't say.
- MichaelGG 13y agoWhat exactly do you hate about it? You're unsure of the harm, and quick searches seem to indicate no harm, so is it just the aesthetic?
- jessedhillon 13y agoMostly psychological and irrational. I don't like the feel of the vapor in my face, it definitely feels and smells off-putting. It's the unseemliness, the (my Wikipedia-level understanding) lack of scientific evidence backing up claims of non-harm. And if you do it in a theater it's distracting.
- hueving 13y agoWould it help to know that it isn't smoke? There is no reason at this point to assume there is harm from them (i.e. give them the benefit of the doubt). The vapor is propylene glycol, which is the same thing used to generate 'fog' at concerts, etc. It's too bad they are calling them e-cigarettes because it triggers responses like yours where people apply their notions of regular cigarettes to them. The only thing they actually have in common is nicotine, which is not the harmful part of regular tobacco products.
- stevewillows 13y agoOn the hobby side of the vape scene, there's a concerted effort to remove the 'cigarette' from the equation. A lot of the original modders started with flashlights (as far as I am told). Years ago I participated in a study to test the effects of smoke machines. I was working at a large arcade that threw huge parties with DJs and such on the weekend. Naturally, we had smoke machines. The researchers found that the PG had no effect on our respiratory system, which was actually what concluded that vaping would be a good alternative to smoking.
- r-s 13y agoIve often wondered the same. I occasionally chew on some nicotine gum (usually 1mg, then an hour later another 1mg) as I find it helps me focus. I suspect its better then smoking, but by how much seems fairly unknown.
- MichaelGG 13y agoHow on earth could chewing gum be anywhere nearly as harmful as actually smoking tobacco-based products? Nicotine is as close to harmless as any effective medication. So the "by how much" is as large as possible.
- scott_karana 13y ago> Nicotine is as close to harmless as any effective medication Yes, the smoking is worse than the nicotine, but how many other over-the-counter medications have an LD50 potentially as low as 30mg/kg? That's insanely high toxicity. Spilling nicotine on yourself causes death. That should be sobering.
- jasomill 13y agoSo concentrated nicotine in liquid form is potentially dangerous and should be treated with caution. But how does the ratio of quantity ingested in the course of ordinary use to lethal dose compare to OTC meds?
- hmsimha 13y agoAn LD50 of 30 mg/kg means that for a roughly average 60-kg adult, a lethal dose would be 1.8 g of pure nicotine. Were you suggesting you would have to bring a vat of it to scalding temperatures and pour it over yourself to kill yourself with it?
- hmsimha 13y agoOut of interest in the topic, I had to look into this further. It appears the current oral LD50 in humans for nicotine is assumed to be 6.5-13 mg/kg (perhaps even as low as 1 mg/kg in children). Nicotine is also said to be very readily absorbed through the skin. There is one[1] case I could find documented, from a 1933 publication of the British Medical Journal, of a patient nearly dying from spilling two 'drachms' (or roughly 1.5 tsp) of 95% nicotine on her arm. I'd say there's not enough information to be conclusive, but it's possible that nicotine could be lethal in doses absorbed through skin contact, though this seems unlikely to me given practical concentrations of nicotine solutions, and higher concentrations should be handled in a lab with proper safety equipment anyway. Ideally, pure nicotine would be labelled as the dangerous drug that it is, just as dangerous household cleaners are. [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2368002/pdf/brmedj07321-0034d.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2368002/pdf/brme...
- hansy 13y agoSo smoking tobacco is bad. Got it. Now what about marijuana? Less bad? I don't think I've ever read a report on marijuana yellow-taped with as many warnings and dangers as those found in tobacco reports. Is this because not enough evidence has been gathered around the dangers of weed?
- spand 13y agoThe substance is one thing, but volume is another. Are people smoking 'a pack' or two of marijuana every day for decades?
- alan_cx 13y agoYes. Assuming a "pack" is 20 joints. Easily. I know by name plenty of people who treat joints like cigarettes. Personally, I think a big part of the problem is the tobacco in the joint. I'd like to see a safe or safer tobacco replacement for rolling joints with. I know they are other ways to consume pot, a joint is the most convenient. All the things you can do with a ciggy on the go, you can do with a joint on the go. <HNHumourbypasstag>Driving for example.....</HNHumourbypasstag>
- andyhmltn 13y ago> I'd like to see a safe or safer tobacco replacement for rolling joints with There already is one: Marijuana. The fact is you don't have to mix it with tobacco :) It's commonplace here in the UK but you can just smoke it on its own or you can use a vapourizer. You can even cook it with butter but that increases the effects
- jasomill 13y agoWhy not just roll a pure marijuana joint, perhaps using weaker pot than you've been mixing with tobacco? In my experience (US), mixing tobacco into joints is mostly a European thing.
- swombat 13y agoWeed is just as bad to smoke as tobacco, especially since it's often (though not always) mixed with tobacco. One big difference, though, is that weed itself is only very mildly physically addictive, and in a small percentage of the population. This is as compared with tobacco, which is more addictive than heroin, for pretty much everyone. Also, weed contains chemicals, like THC, which are not so harmful, and can be ingested in ways other than smoking (e.g. inhalers). And unlike cigarettes it has benefits as a painkiller for people for whom other painkillers no longer work (e.g. terminal cancer patients, who probably don't need to worry about getting lung cancer 20 years from now). Overall the scorecard seems to be: Smoking weed is probably just as bad as smoking cigarettes, but has a number of benefits over cigarettes and is nowhere near as addictive. That makes it less harmful overall.
- timonv 13y agoSmoking costs billions? Productivity? An 'even higher' increase in risk of lungcancer? And there are no other factors at play at all? So now it's going to be a war on smokers again, is it? What a terrible causation-correlation fuck up. ftr, I quit smoking a year ago. And happy I did.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoYeah the article sucks. It also takes pains to throw blame around with no citation and no logic. Its apparently the fault of tobacco companies alone, because they are evil. Not for instance the smokers. Or those dang filters that apparently are just as bad as tobacco. Who's fault are those?
- Joona 13y agoSo why is no country banning smoking? If the current smokers are a problem, maybe you could give out "smoking licenses"... (Yes, I hate it.)
- pmr_ 13y agoWhere I live (Europe) tax income through cigarette sales is substantive. Some countries even have refrained from further increasing taxes or lowered the planned increases on cigarettes because the last raises have caused a drop in tax income. I imagine prohibiting cigarettes would lead to a huge outcry on all sides of the political spectrum fueled by lobbyist decrying the end of the free world. There also would be a large economic impact on all the retailers, logistics companies, promoters, distributors, and addiction management industries (nicotine patches, e-cigarettes, and what not). By "large impact" I mean that they would be gone for good. I guess this would still mean a net win for society and health care costs at large, but those measures are always hard to justify and not a very popular decision to make. That's why politicians tend to refrain from making them.
- cromulent 13y agoTasmania proposed something similar, basically that anyone born after 2000 would not be able to purchase cigarettes. Singapore proposed the same thing. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-08-23/tas-smoking-ban-facing-lower-house-hurdle/4217022 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-08-23/tas-smoking-ban-facing... However, I think neither proposal has been accepted.
- vacri 13y agoBecause smoking is still a powerful political issue, both in terms of smokers and lobbyists. Cigarettes here in Australia are nearly $1 each, and all cigarettes must be sold in an olive drab box with a graphic picture of a diseased body part and health warning - plus the packages must now be hidden from view by the vendor. The rather wealthy tobacco companies fight it all the way, right up to petitioning the UN trade bodies on their own dime. Sometimes it's quite amusing - the argument against the olive drab packaging was "it's a waste of time, the colour of the packaging won't change tobacco sales", to which the only sane response is "then why are you taking out multiple full-page ads in every paper?". You also can't just make it illegal overnight, since it's a notoriously difficult drug to give up. Hence it's being gradually phased out.
- anon1385 13y ago>The report newly identifies exposure to secondhand smoke as a cause of strokes. How long do we have to wait till the tobacco industry funded Cato Institute finds some shills to wheel out to deny this? And how long do we have to wait for them to apologise for decades of spreading FUD and undermining the science that demonstrated the risks of smoking.
- jokoon 13y agoMy mother smoked when I was growing up and when she was pregnant. Each time I inhale a tiny bit of cigaret smoke, I immediatly feel bad and start coughing. Really feels like a poison. Here in france, a pack of cigaret will soon cost 7 euros. I'm glad. It's a great way to penalize people while reducing the deficit, and encouraging them to stop smoking. Each time I hear someone complaining about the cost of cigaret in france, I tell them "well it's a great way to finance chemotherapies". Smoking is a luxury. When you feels you don't have a sharp mind or enough energy at work, and you boosts yourself with a coffee and a cigaret, okay, but I don't think you really need to have those boosts. I'd prefer getting fired instead than competing with drug addicts.
- hamax 13y ago> "well it's a great way to finance chemotherapies" That's not how it works. Cigarette tax doesn't go directly to the healthcare budget. At least in most countries. > Smoking is a luxury. And a very strong addiction.
- jokoon 13y ago> That's not how it works. Cigarette tax doesn't go directly to the healthcare budget. At least in most countries. French healthcare system always finances 2/3 of most cares. I think chemotherpy is included. I don't know about how things happen in the US though. > At least in most countries. Most developed country have a pretty socialist healthcare system.
- contingencies 13y agoMost developed country have a pretty socialist healthcare system. This. US readers take note. Of course, it's going away pretty quickly ... almost everywhere.
- ajtaylor 13y agoIn Australia, a pack of smokes costs something like $20. No idea where the tax revenue goes, but the cost alone seems like it would be a great disincentive to smoke.
- bromagosa 13y agoSo, briefing: «There is no doubt who is to blame for this mess, the report says. It is the tobacco industry» And then: «The new report rightly calls for more vigorous tobacco-control efforts, including an increase in cigarette taxes to drive up the average price of cigarettes to at least $10 a pack to prevent young people from starting to smoke; an antismoking mass media campaign by government agencies that would run year-round; and new rules extending smoke-free indoor protection to the entire population, double the current level.» Let me understand... the solution is not to punish the ones who undoubtedly are to blame for this mess, but the general tax-paying public and the smokers themselves?
- argonaut 13y agoHow does that punish the general tax-paying public? The burden of taxes falls on both consumer and supplier.
- goblin89 13y agoCan that anti-smoking campaign be guaranteed to be financed exclusively by the taxes collected from cigarette purchases?
- argonaut 13y agoAh. Regarding the mass media campaign, it may be possible that the money spent is recouped in healthcare savings. It's very much up in the air the net economic effect of something like that. You can't guarantee that it's going to have a positive/neutral effect, but neither can you guarantee it's going to have a negative effect on the public, either.
- bromagosa 13y agoStill wouldn't sound good enough to me... if it's so clear cigarrette companies are to blame, they should be the ones paying for the damage.
- pmr_ 13y agoAs a smoker I highly support fair taxes on tobacco. I would welcome the additional incentive to finally stop smoking and I believe that every individual has the right to hurt itself as long as it paying for the damage and not dropping the bill on others (I also think this applies to driving cars, eating unhealthy food, and so on). One problem in Europe is that tobacco taxes are not bound to be used to bolster the health care systems or smoking prevention programs (In Germany the 2002 and 2003 tax raises have been used for funding the War on Terror). Another problem is, as shown by the article, that our damage estimates are very likely to have a large error margin. If think if we could improve our damage estimates, use the estimates to continuously adapt taxes, use the tax income to pay for the damage and to prevent spread of the problem the problem could be solved. To me it seems there is a gap for technology to make those things possible.
- aw3c2 13y ago> In Germany the 2002 and 2003 tax raises have been used for funding the War on Terror Citation please!
- pmr_ 13y agoIn http://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/aenderungen-2003-oekosteuer-tabaksteuer-zinssteuer-a-228905.html http://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/aenderungen-2003-o... see the second heading. I have further news articles from FAZ and Süddeutsche claiming the same. Unfortunately I cannot find an English source, I hope Google Translate is enough.
- aw3c2 13y agohaha, thanks!
- netcan 13y agoI disagree with this type of thinking. I think we need to be careful of mandates begetting mandates. I agree with public health spending. I think it's a good thing. But I don't think it should (morally) cost us personal freedoms like that. Paying for health does not give the public mandate over the private's eating/exercise/smoking habits. That is the road to totalitarianism and I don't think there is any reason to travel down it. Said another way: A public responsibility towards the private person's health care is not a wide responsibility for their health and it does not translate into a right to make an individual's health decisions for them.
- tsotha 13y ago>The new report rightly calls for more vigorous tobacco-control efforts, including an increase in cigarette taxes to drive up the average price of cigarettes to at least $10 a pack... Will that really work? My suspicion is at those prices you're going to see a hell of a lot of smuggling.
- rartichoke 13y agoI smoked a pack a day for about 10 years and have quit for 2 years without using anything special or e-cigs. The quitting process took 3 days. If anyone who wants to try and quit here's what I did: 1) Make sure you want to quit because if you don't seriously want to quit then you won't no matter what. 2) Smoke less and less every day until you get to zero. This will vary for everyone, I personally did it as fast as I could handle it which mainly consisted of only smoking after meals after I went from 1 pack a day down to half a pack a day. That's seriously all there is to it. It'll be a little difficult for about a week but then it's pretty much smooth sailing with minor urges. You'll likely end up creating other habits in the process and afterwards because at the end of the day smoking was a habit to you. Try to pick a less destructive habit this time!
- Zigurd 13y agoThere is a surprising amount of prudishness about naturally occurring and long-used psychoactive substances here. Once the harm from some traditional ways of ingesting them are ameliorated, the prudishness is irrational. What if nicotine is "better" than caffeine, which I'd wager most readers here have ingested this morning, at boosting cognitive function? If nicotine, or cannabis, or whatever isn't seen rationally, it will be left to some packaging genius to create the equivalent of a Nepresso pod for vaping it, or consuming it in whatever way is convenient and stylish. That seems weak-minded for a crowd that pats themselves on the back for rationality.
- contingencies 13y agoAgreed. I recently quit smoking, it sucked. Nicotine gum was how I kept the ability to work. Nontrivial abstract reasoning such as most programming is impossible when you are having nicotine withdrawls. If people want to try nicotine, buy some gum. Honestly, as far as stimulants go, I've probably tried a serious amount of what's out there from the natural (chewed coca leaves, betel nuts, chewing tobacco, raw tobacco, ephedrine, etc.) to legal and less legal drugs that shall not be enumerated, and I think adequate sleep, exercise and good eating, possibly in combination with some meditation are the lowest hassle and most sustainable productivity enhancers.