14 ms·
Edward Snowden, after months of NSA revelations, says his mission’s accomplished
- tokenadult 13y agoI wish Snowden would roll up his sleeves and start working on the same problem in Russia, where he now lives, and in China, where he stayed briefly on his way to Russia. His mission has hardly begun.
- quesera 13y agoHis mission to save the world from itself? He wasn't born tomorrow.
- visakanv 13y agoThat really sounds like a lot to ask of one person!
- flyinglizard 13y agoBy his revelations, Snowden made the NSA activities a matter of political debate. That was his mission. In both Russia and China, citizens are very well aware of shady government practices. Their problem is already political, not one of awareness.
- Zigurd 13y agoIf you feel so strongly, you do it.
- tokenadult 13y agoI've been telling people about the problems in China for a very long time. The Chinese embassy staff may have been videotaping out the window when I joined a large public protest outside the embassy.
- mladenkovacevic 13y agoOh so you're working on fixing China already then! Good. I'll handle Uganda, we'll find a Russian on here to take care of Russia and let's leave the US to Snowden then.. Deal.
- barry-cotter 13y agoOf course the Chinese embassy was videotaping you. The American embassy in Dublin does it, and Ireland is a political irrelevance from a US perspective.
- woah 13y agoThe whole argument about Russia being way worse than the US, and Snowden staying there is ridiculous. He isn't staying there as some sort of celebrity endorsement for the tourism program. He's staying there because it is the only place he was able to reach in time, as Russia is one of the few countries too big to be invaded by the US military.
- Grue3 13y agoHe's there because he's a coward with no backbone. If he is so sure of his innocence, he'd be facing the court instead of propping up a government with terrible human rights record.
- malandrew 13y agoFirst, Daniel Ellsberg on why Snowden made the right call [0]. Second, if he were being charged in the correct jurisdiction, i.e. Hawaii, where he committed his crimes, I would agree with this sentiment. But no, he's been charged with crimes in Virginia, the backyard of the intelligence community. His peers are the American people, not the intelligence community. The government had no business bringing charges against him in another jurisdiction than the one he committed the crimes in. Doing so, shows incredibly poor faith, and a clear intention to get a conviction and harsh sentence by any means necessary, even if it means subverting how our justice system is supposed to work. [0] http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/daniel-ellsberg-nsa-leaker-snowden-made-the-right-call/2013/07/07/0b46d96c-e5b7-11e2-aef3-339619eab080_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/daniel-ellsberg-nsa-l...
- Peaker 13y agoDo you really believe the court system works to determine innocence? Do you believe he would be guaranteed a fair trial? Do you think Manning got a fair trial? Do you believe that by taking refuge in Russia he's "propping up" their government? How? Do you believe that giving up a 6-figure salary and life to expose violations of the US constitution is an act of a coward? Are these opinions harbored by real people, or is this a troll?
- 13y ago
- mc32 13y agoThe real problem with that wish is that neither of those gov'ts would trust him with any of their methods or secrets. The best you can hope for is that people in analogous positions within those countries' surveillance agencies are moved by his example and follow it. In any event, he's mixed up in realpolitik but that was his only choice, if he wanted to avoid the domestic repercussions of his actions.
- recursive 13y agoI wish someone would roll up their sleeves and make me dinner! I'm hungry already.
- mladenkovacevic 13y agoYour comment makes no sense to me. He was born and raised in United States, not in China and/or Russia. Why would he be trying to fix those countries?
- gruseom 13y agoPerhaps he will, if he ever swears an oath to defend the Russian or Chinese constitutions.
- eru 13y agoDepends on whether he wants to take on more than civic duty.
- HCIdivision17 13y agoIs there a way to incubate people like Snowden? I suspect Snowden could be a spokesman or figurehead for movements in other countries, but I have a hard time thinking he could ever repeat another data dump without becoming a real spy. Could someone as public and recognizable be effective in getting inconvenient intelligence from other countries?
- malandrew 13y agoDoubt it, but we could incubate people like Greenwald in every country. Find someone articulate, savvy and train them in tradecraft so that people in every country have someone they can safely approach. Citizens of many countries don't have the luxury of knowing which journalists they can approach with their leak.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoHow? Just apply to one of their secret agencies and promise he will never ever leak anything? He doesn't have superpowers. Even when it comes to the NSA, let's make the most of what Snowden did do -- he might be the last whistleblower we've seen in a while, seeing how the NSA said they would seek to replace as human system administrators with automation where possible.
- cabbeer 13y agoThis came to mind when I read the title: http://i.imgur.com/bPn53M1.jpg?1 http://i.imgur.com/bPn53M1.jpg?1
- aggie 13y agoOk, but did you read the article? Snowden is talking about the mission of starting the conversation, which he has done. “'For me, in terms of personal satisfaction, the mission’s already accomplished,' he said. 'I already won. As soon as the journalists were able to work, everything that I had been trying to do was validated. Because, remember, I didn’t want to change society. I wanted to give society a chance to determine if it should change itself.'”
- beedogs 13y agoThis was basically his stated goal when he started this whole thing: getting the public informed and starting the conversation about how much government intrusion into our private lives is too much.
- quesera 13y ago> “If I defected at all,” Snowden said, “I defected from the government to the public.” He can't run til 2020, but I'll cast an early vote now.
- mattkrea 13y agoIf that isn't a quotable quote I don't know what is. I second that vote.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- morganherlocker 13y agoI do not know if I would vote for him necessarily (not knowing much about the rest of his views), but a candidate who promised to pardon Snowden would receive a couple "get-out-of-terrible-policy-suggestion free cards" in my book.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- eru 13y agoThey'll probably make him a felon, won't they? (Can you vote for felons in the US?)
- gonzo 13y agoYup. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President_of_the_United_States#Eligibility http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President_of_the_United_States#...
- jasomill 13y agoSpeaking of which, if he were convicted and then elected President, one could make a reasonable argument that he could then pardon himself.
- jliechti1 13y agoIf the "terrorists" are following this whole story, wouldn't now be a prime time for another attack? This could have the effect of validating the NSA's activities in many Americans' eyes ("see, the NSA is unable to its job without invading our privacy") and we would see a whole new round of new laws capitalizing on Americans' fears of terrorists (which means their terrorism succeeded).
- visakanv 13y agoTrue. Which might suggest that "the terrorists" aren't nearly the perfect, rational villains we paint them out to be.
- jessedhillon 13y agoAssumption #1 in your comment: NSA activities have not and are unable to stop arbitrary terror attacks at all. Assumption #2: That successful attacks in this scenario would lead (reasonable or otherwise) people to demand less surveillance. Assumption #3: Terrorists want to the NSA programs ended, which would not make sense if #1 is true. So I'm not sure why this would be a good strategy for anyone.
- visakanv 13y agoI think you misinterpreted the comment. It's arguing that now would be the optimal time for terrorists to strike, validating the NSA.
- sitkack 13y agoAnd strengthening the NSA would directly cause the further fall of the USA. The cheapest way to to attack the USA as an institution is to attack the USA in way the gives the most radical factions power in the short term.
- d0ugie 13y agoFarther, not further, when referring to distance, even if that distance is figurative.
- eliteraspberrie 13y agoThe Washington Post sat on the Collateral Murder video. [1,2] The New York Times sat on the warrantless wiretapping scandal at the request of the White House. [3] CBS sat on the Abu Ghraib torture scandal at the request of the Pentagon. [4] What is the Washington Post not telling us? [1] https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/15617022129 https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/15617022129 [2] http://www.cjr.org/the_kicker/wapo_denies_allegation_it_sat.php http://www.cjr.org/the_kicker/wapo_denies_allegation_it_sat.... [3] http://fair.org/take-action/action-alerts/the-scoop-that-got-spiked/ http://fair.org/take-action/action-alerts/the-scoop-that-got... [4] http://www.nieman.harvard.edu/reports/article/100787/CBS-Lets-the-Pentagon-Taint-Its-News-Process.aspx http://www.nieman.harvard.edu/reports/article/100787/CBS-Let...
- marze 13y agoWhat's your point? They are telling us a lot of things that Edward Snowden said recently that are interesting. Why whine?
- visakanv 13y agoI don't see it as "whining" as much as a reminder of the "what we see is all there is" bias. We may never know what's being hidden from us, but it's worth remembering that we can be near-certain of the existence of unknown-unknowns. The point is that all of this may be the tip of the iceberg. It's intellectually interesting to think about, with potentially grave consequences for day-to-day life.
- marze 13y ago"near-certain of the existence of unknown-unknowns. The point is that all of this may be the tip of the iceberg." True enough, but I think everyone already knows that. The content of the recent Snowden interview, not so much.
- lvs 13y agoYour point is generally valid, if a bit tinfoiled, but their hand was particularly forced this time by Snowden. If you'll recall the recent history, Snowden was spooked by his interaction with Gellman -- particularly regarding publishing timeline -- and went to Greenwald instead [1]. There's some debate about the exact sequence of events, but regardless, Greenwald put the story out first, and the Post had no choice but to follow suit. NYT was left red-faced and could only -- shamelessly -- ask Snowden why he didn't choose them [2]. [1] http://www.politico.com/story/2013/06/edward-snowden-nsa-leaker-glenn-greenwald-barton-gellman-92505.html http://www.politico.com/story/2013/06/edward-snowden-nsa-lea... [2] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/18/magazine/snowden-maass-transcript.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/18/magazine/snowden-maass-tra...
- yetanotherphd 13y agoI am in awe of this man. We all owe him our thanks for bringing this information to the public, at considerable risk to himself.
- mladenkovacevic 13y agoJesus Christ some of the comments on that article. I wonder if there was some way to analyse what percentage of it is astro-turfing and what percentage is real red-blooded Americans just brainwashed into thinking government knows best. Americans you are lost. It's been nice knowing you.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- krapp 13y ago>Americans you are lost. It's been nice knowing you. There are fewer than 500 comments on that site as of right now, that doesn't mean anything about anything. Sometimes I wonder if people are actually aware that the United States has more people in it than can fit into a single room.
- mladenkovacevic 13y agoIt's what would in most industries be considered a reasonable sized sampling. When you then look at this poll then, things start to look grim indeed: http://www.people-press.org/2013/06/10/majority-views-nsa-phone-tracking-as-acceptable-anti-terror-tactic/ http://www.people-press.org/2013/06/10/majority-views-nsa-ph...
- aagha 13y agoA reasonable sample is a function of the size of the overall population. Assuming you're talking a few million visitors in some fixed period of time, at 500 comments, you're still a little ways off from a 95 percent confidence interval and a +/-3 margin of error.
- caf 13y agoFor large populations it's not strongly a function of population size - a 500 sample is almost as good for a 100,000 population as it is for a 100,000,000 population (which is not very good at all).
- memracom 13y agoAmazing that for so many decades under so many leaders, the American intelligence services have relied on the oath of allegiance to the Constitution to preserve secrecy. The Brits do it right by making people sign the Official Secrets Act which both binds the agent to keep secrets and educates them in full detail what that means.
- gobakhan 13y agoKind of like the Non-disclosure agreement everyone with a security clearance has to sign. http://www.archives.gov/isoo/security-forms/sf312.pdf http://www.archives.gov/isoo/security-forms/sf312.pdf
- suprgeek 13y agoHis mission yes - giving up the comforts of a stable paying job in Hawaii and exposing himself to tremendous danger from a variety of nation-state level adversaries for life - in the bargain. Amazingly commendable - all for the sake of preserving core Liberty and Freedom as we know it. What happens next ? Will things go back to businesses as usual?
- randomfool 13y agoHis job is done, now it's up to the rest of us.
- d0ugie 13y agoI wonder if Snowden were aware when planning his mission that his actions would only yield some isolated populist outcrying, a few more people using Tor, some political awkwardness and pretty much nothing else, as appears to be case.
- znowi 13y agoI didn’t want to change society. I wanted to give society a chance to determine if it should change itself. Despite a fair amount of indignation from the public, it seems to me that the majority has accepted the new surveillance reality.
- samstave 13y agoThe weird invasive thought I keep having is if Snowden could, if at all, be a limited hang-out-OP/MISO (PsyOp) to gauge just how much the public would accept. There have been enough revelations to see that the NSA got to keep what it is in entirety; mission accomplished.
- cstavish 13y agoThat's one of the most thought-provoking comments I've seen in some time. Some of the revelations involving spying on allies seem pretty harmful...Either a lot of nations were in on the operation or a big risk was taken in conducting it the first place. Further, why would they include information on spying on allies if they just wanted to gauge the reaction on domestic surveillance?
- samstave 13y ago>Further, why would they include information on spying on allies if they just wanted to gauge the reaction on domestic surveillance? A global psyop; it was a show of complete dominance?
- john_b 13y agoThis is definitely tinfoil hat territory. Some very high level people in the intelligence community may lose their jobs or (if things go very well) face charges in the next year or two. If the whole Snowden affair is an inside job then those high level people must have been ignorant of it since they would never accept the personal risk of the shitstorm that has resulted.
- samstave 13y ago
- stevewillows 13y agoI just hope at this point that we don't see a high-budget movie starring Justin Timberlake or Jesse Eisenberg playing Snowden.
- codex 13y agoThe world, especially the intelligence world, is more than black and white. A myriad hues exist, some of them dark and dirty, some grey. Here is a portrait of a man who is color blind. Experiencing the world only through a computer, he lacks the judgement to jump to the right conclusions, and goes thermonuclear only to find that mainstream Americans don't share his disability. He wants to be another Assange, but in the end he is another Manning.
- wmt 13y agoYou cannot seriously believe that an NSA contractor would be morally colourblind. He was expecting those shades of grey but instead found an agency more focused on spying it's citizens than Stasi.
- Grue3 13y ago>more focused on spying it's citizens than Stasi How in the world is it possible to post something as ridiculous as this? Is this what you kids truly believe? Snowden might be colour blind, but you sure are tone deaf.
- Peaker 13y agoWell, the NSA collected more data on US citizens than the Stasi ever collected on Germans.
- lhnz 13y ago>> only to find that mainstream Americans don't share his disability. It looks like you just got down-voted by almost everybody that read your comment. I guess when you look at yourself you should now say "here is a man that went thermonuclear only to find nobody else shared their disability." (When a man makes one judgment upon another, he should keep the ability to judge himself likewise.) FYI the article I read had him expecting to see grey and finding an ever blackening black - so in contrast to your own comment, you need to realise that you are communing with people that aren't color blind and believe that these shades of reality are complex and require discussion.
- hooande 13y agoBut what has really changed? The NSA is under pressure from the public, less so from the intelligence and defense communities. If anything Snowden has caused those areas of government to close ranks even tighter. There's nothing a leader wants more than a highly visible enemy to unite his or her people. There are orders of magnitude more people who hate General Alexander now than there were two years ago. But his own people love him even harder. The NSA may or may not lose some funding in the coming years. It will probably just transfer over to the NRO or the Office of Intelligence and Analysis or one of the dozen other agencies that we haven't come to know and hate yet. If there's one thing government is good at, it's maintaining the status quo. Public support has never meant much to the intelligence community. These are people who signed up to serve in secret, who have dedicated their lives to what they believe to be just causes. They won't pay a thought to a year or so of bad press. Snowden's future is unclear. He'll probably be in russia for several more years, if he doesn't overstay his welcome. It's possible that some future president will see pardoning him as a free goodwill card. Or perhaps he'll be able to start a life as an overseas media personality, reaping the benefits of what many see as a heroic action. One thing is for certain: US intelligence agencies will continue business as usual. Edward Snowden has shown the light, and his work is indeed done. It's up to us to effect real change and shape our government in our own image. Maybe things will change, maybe they won't. But those who dislike what he has revealed have their work cut out for them.
- MysticFear 13y agoPolitical change isn't fast. There is also a legal process underway as well. Both are very slow moving, but can bring a lot of changes.
- RexRollman 13y agoUnless something happens to ramp up the fear again, like some kind of attack.
- jonsleet 13y agoYes, apparently that is the go-to sales pitch.
- amoxibos 13y agoI believe this Snowden case is orchestrated by the NSA itself. It might be to show its power and to intimidate opponents. Just a display of what we did and what we are able to do. Standard Sun Tzu tactics. It is dumb to think that there is not a single CIA agent to take him out inside of Moscow or anywhere else in the world.
- Fuxy 13y agoYou have to admire his willingness to risk everything to give the people a chance to change this broken system. He is right though the system is broken it gives too much power with too little oversight.
- notdonspaulding 13y agoAt the same time, this is exactly what we should expect of every American put in his position. And others were in his position before him, so you kind of have to shake your head that this wasn't disclosed sooner. What I find admirable is the way he's gone about disclosing these documents in such a responsible and controlled manner.
- acqq 13y agoIt's a good moment to think again about the words uttered by, at that moment, vice president Cheney on September 16, 2001: (at that time published on whitehouse.gov) http://web.archive.org/web/20011116191708/http://www.whitehouse.gov/vicepresident/news-speeches/speeches/vp20010916.html http://web.archive.org/web/20011116191708/http://www.whiteho... "We also have to work, though, sort of the dark side, if you will. We've got to spend time in the shadows in the intelligence world. A lot of what needs to be done here will have to be done quietly, without any discussion, using sources and methods that are available to our intelligence agencies, if we're going to be successful." And, for the opposing view, also to think about the 2006 speech of then senator Obama: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfX7RI7DGI8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfX7RI7DGI8 "No President is above the law. I am voting against Mr. Hayden in the hope that he will be more humble before the great weight of responsibility that he has not only to protect our lives but to protect our democracy. Americans fought a Revolution in part over the right to be free from unreasonable searches -- to ensure that our Government could not come knocking in the middle of the night for no reason. We need to find a way forward to make sure we can stop terrorists while protecting the privacy and liberty of innocent Americans. We have to find a way to give the President the power he needs to protect us, while making sure he does not abuse that power. It is possible to do that. We have done it before. We could do it again." And as Snowden mentions, the oath the President makes is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oath_of_office_of_the_President_of_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oath_of_office_of_the_President... "I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will faithfully execute the Office of President of the United States, and will to the best of my Ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States." The Constitution. It's the end of 2013.
- jonhohle 13y ago> We need to find a way forward to make sure we can stop terrorists Why is this such a trumping goal (or even a goal at all)? It's an impossible task without singnificant imposition on everyone's lives (we're no where close to being able to stop anything, and things are already leaning too far away from the people). A disproportionate amount of time and resources are already being dedicated to "fighting" terrorism, with diminishing returns and uncountable atrocities done by our government.
- w_t_payne 13y agoSorry, Ed, but we are nowhere near "mission accomplished". This debate may have begun with worries about the risks posed by NSA overreach, but it does not end with them. As Bruce Schneier pointed out, the tools of today's spies are the same as the tools of tomorrow's criminals. Whilst I am not exactly comfortable with the idea of persistent, intimate state surveillance, this discomfort fades into paltry insignificance when I consider the implications of criminal entities controlling the computing devices that I use to analyse and understand issues, make decisions and interact with the world. I studied Artificial Intelligence as a student. I buy (somewhat) into Kurzweil's view of the future. Today, my computer may be a "bicycle for the mind", but tomorrow, we may have difficulty distinguishing between rider and vehicle. The security of today's internet; today's computing devices, profoundly affects how securely, how effectively, and how independently I will be able to think in 20 or 30 years time. We need to start talking more (much more) about the weaknesses and security vulnerabilities inherent in the architecture and design of our public communications and computing infrastructure. This debate has to get detailed and has to get technical. Fast.
- tinfoil007 13y agoThank you, Edward Snowden. You're true hero. It's a shame, that your leaders can see in technology only surveillance, war machinery and ways to humiliate and subjugate others. It's a shame, that USA's participation in computing is still a "donkey work", as tortured (and probably killed) Alan Turing once said.
- Grue3 13y agoHopefully he'll stop hogging the frontpage then. Just like nobody remembers Julian Assange anymore.
- Peaker 13y agoDo you want the NSA to keep on spying on US citizens without oversight, to turn over its data to US law enforcement for "parallel reconstruction"? Do you want to live in a total-surveillance society?
- marquis 13y ago"All I wanted was for the public to be able to have a say in how they are governed". If these are his words to be remembered by, history will have kind thoughts for him.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ck2 13y agoNSA must be thrilled. Like the TSA, the mainstream public has become completely complacent. Bet they were worried for a whole minute there. I won't be surprised if like Homeland Security Theater their funding will increase and not decrease after the exposure. Well at least gitmo was closed. Oh wait. Guess we accomplished less than nothing.
- jokoon 13y agoI wonder what will happen when his 1 year thing with russia will end... Maybe canada or south america ?
- kochb 13y ago> "Until you’ve got to pull the trigger, until you’ve had to bury your people, you don’t have a clue." Falling to the "you don't know what it's like" argument is never a good sign. You're acting out of pain and so emotionally invested in justifying your actions that you're incapable of communicating an evidence based rationale to an outsider. You can't reach a reasoned resolution like that.
- nicholassmith 13y agoHis mission is done, our mission isn't. He gave us the information we need to start banging on doors and saying to our elected representatives, 'is this right? Is this reasonable?'. Some won't listen, some will, some won't rock the boat, some will. But unless you push you'll never know.
- NN88 13y agoI just can't help but think most people already knew this before he revealed it...but then I remember...so many people are just under a rock
- frozenport 13y agoMaybe Snowden was a trial balloon? They wanted to see how far the American public could be pushed? :-)
- mrobot 13y agoI didn't see anyone ask. Does "mission accomplished" mean no more leaks from the Snowden pool? What was the last leak, then, RSA security? "By the way, RSA sucks! Mission accomplished."