13 ms·
Computer-driven cars will convulse the automotive industry
- manmal 13y agoI imagine that this would make the modularization of cars more feasible, or even necessary. E.g. a long-distance travel power train module could provide enough juice for driving cross-country (e.g. on holidays), while the commuter power train module would be lighter and less costly to rent. The car could drive itself to a hotspot where such modules are interchanged on demand. This would of course only make sense if there still is something like car ownership - if cars are only rented from central entities, then this entity would just send out specialized vehicles instead. However, I'm not quite sold that people will give up on car ownership. Yes, there's public utilities and public transport, which is not up for individual ownership. But a car in the sense that we have it now is something more personal than a train cabin - a car's body is very close to us and we touch it all the time; we leave personal belongings there; and there is something to the fact that this car is always in front of my house/appartment, especially in emergency situations. This last point could be amended with emergency cars which are available to each apartment block, with which driving is just more expensive. Imagine crying "Help! I need a car!" and an emergency unit comes right around the corner and takes you wherever you want.
- trafficlight 13y agoI don't think we'll willingly give up on owning cars. Rather, it'll become way too expensive for the average person to own one. Once self-driving cars show a marked decrease in road accidents, insurance prices will rise. Car-as-a-Service companies will be created, making the cost of riding in a private car much cheaper than outright owning one. I'm already intending to start a car service as soon as the first cars are available.
- alexeisadeski3 13y ago>Once self-driving cars show a marked decrease in road accidents, insurance prices will rise. Huh? Edit: Just to be clear: The world you describe should see incuranse rates for self-driving cars markedly lower, with rates for driver-driven cars probably a bit lower (than current).
- goldenkey 13y agoHe means insurance prices will rise for those who choose to remain self-drivers. However, you bring up a good point, incidentally, that even if the insurance costs more for a self-driver versus auto-pilot, rates will go down for _both_ either way due to much safer roads.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoInsurance costs for human-driven vehicles will rise.
- cortesoft 13y agoI don't think that is necessarily true.. The cost of insurance is based on the average expected payout per customer... I don't think the average payout will increase, as being a human driver won't suddenly become MORE dangerous, at worst it will stay the same.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoBut what happens when the average expected payout is expected to go down? Insurance companies will expect lower loss ratios from self-driven cars, so doing something as dangerous as driving your own vehicle will carry a premium. Its very similar to how your health insurance premiums are much higher if you're a smoker. You can smoke, but you're going to be charged for this unnecessary, harmful action.
- cortesoft 13y agoOh, I have no doubt that driving your own car will be more expensive than taking a self-driving car. My point was that it wouldn't be more expensive than it currently is to have insurance (when everyone is driving their own car)
- Namrog84 13y agoI am sure lots of people said. I'll never give up rising my horse for this weirs automobile. While I agree with you a lot and I love driving. You have to think that while we will continue to enjoy driving. Think of the next generation of children who grow up in a world where they never have to start learning to drive in first place. Where they don't appreciate it the same way. And instead they go to some random driving course for a fun day of driving. Like some people go to a stables or ranch to ride horses occasionally
- philwelch 13y agoSomeone already beat you. They're called Zipcar and Uber.
- trafficlight 13y agoNot the same. At all. And I highly doubt they are coming to Montana anytime soon.
- philwelch 13y agoYou think those companies won't try and close down on that market once the technology is available? I don't think breaking the Montana market is the key to success, either.
- hershel 13y agoI don't think it's that personal in principle. There were plenty of news articles about the current generation not caring much for car ownership.
- tossmeup 13y agoI'm not sure why there wouldn't be conversion vehicles that could pull second duty on rails. For rail-less areas, it's a car on roads. When long haul/high density travel is required, merge onto rail to reduce friction and road costs. Also, we will all have subscriptions to car services that drive a car scaled to fit your current trip need to your door. Some enthusiasts will still own a manual drive car. The costs of building and maintaining roads will then be shifted to auto service conglomerates - which might end up being manufacturers as well. This will, in turn, optimize around profit margins for the services. Instead of construction firms blowing politicians, they'll be blowing the car service companies. Feasibly, you could see private spans of road. Cars can stop looking like jet cabins and will look more like mass transit or RV's. Think more like European trains. I'd be interested to see if you don't end up with multi-compartment buses that operate a bit like an elevator. Reduced cost subscriptions could involve multiple pickups along a route. Again - optimizing the bottom line of transport services. Auto brands shift market focus from consumers to fleet operators. Expect final conglomeration into verfy few brands, each with very utilitarian lines of vehicles. Interiors become focused on amenities, but also minimization of cost of ownership - more hotel than home. People will own an array of accessories to provide comfort lost from the lack of ownership. People will be guided to see those not making use as anti-social or self-centered. What will happen to shipping? Could we not bring/send autonomous service vehicles to warehouses to pick up and deliver large goods? Does this change the consumer experience from warehouse retailers and monster SUVs to smaller strips of showcase stores and/or mobile retailers that can use excess capacity of delivery vehicles to increase the value of their shopping experience? Say, ship multiple options, accessories, etc. which can be used to up-sell consumers at their home... And what about cruising? People riding around in autonomous vehicles hooking up? Need a lift? What about transport of illicit materials? Load a service car up with some goods and send it on its way. Who gets the blame? Subscription holder? Service?
- infinotize 13y agoI don't want a computer driven car.
- nakedrobot2 13y agoThere is a hint of what a full society of self-driven cars will be like in Rainbows End by Vernor Vinge: there are no traffic lights. The cars all weave through an intersection much like pedestrians do while walking. The future, at least in terms of the dangers of driving, is bright. I look forward to the day when every car is a taxi, and the only cars parked on the side of the road are the ones owned by the very few people who can still be bothered at all to own a car full-time, which will hopefully be very few people.
- saraid216 13y agoIs the implication here that pedestrians will simply walk into the street at random and the AIs will handle that? I find myself a little uncomfortable at the thought, and I'm fairly enthusiastic about driverless cars for most of the reasons you stated.
- jaggederest 13y agoYes, that's precisely what happens. You'll be given a safe berth, with cars stopping or avoiding you by at least the distance you could conceivably fall over. Personally that's already how I cross the street, and my confidence in human drivers isn't anywhere near so great.
- saraid216 13y agoHm. There is a thing currently where it's socially unacceptable not to cross at a crosswalk, and also to stop in the middle of the road. Some people are still jerks, but they're rare. I could easily see a bunch of kids deciding they'll go challenge the AI by dancing in the middle of a crowded street. Admittedly a millionth chance occurrence though. "Computer, take a picture, get me facial recognition, and report them to their parents."
- 001sky 13y agocivil disobedience will be met with ruthless violence. other than that, i have no concerns.
- salient 13y agoRight now the scariest part about self-driving cars is the corporations making them or governments having access to remotely-controlled "kill-switches" for these cars. In such a future you wouldn't need to "cut the breaks" to "make it look like an accident" anymore, and doing it like this would be far easier, if strong security measures aren't considered from the start.
- MichaelApproved 13y agoYours is a paranoid theory. This future you're worried about is just as possible with elevators and yet we don't see it happening. It'll be just as difficult to get away with because of how unusual accidents will be with self driving cars.
- wavefunction 13y agoThe difference, I think, is that the majority of elevators today rely on mechanical systems for control. Sabotaging a mechanical system in secret is a lot harder than sabotaging a computer-controlled system that is networked to the rest of the world.
- dredmorbius 13y agoElevator accidents are rare (hence: suspicious), people transit them for brief periods of time, usually in the company of others, and it's difficult to known when your intended target is in the elevator to attack them. If you're going to target someone via an elevator attack, you've likely got far more effective and specific vectors which would work. Cars tend to be assigned to specific individuals (permanently, on an ongoing occasional basis for car-share programs, or for a trip duration in the case of dispatched livery) and, well, accidents happen, even with automation (other vehicles, mechanical failures, road or environmental conditions). Moreover, if your intent is to convey someone somewhere, it's a lot easier to do this via an automobile (which can travel anywhere on a paved road and non inconsiderable options on unpaved roads) than in an elevator, which, with the exception of Mr. Wonka's design, tend to follow a rather predictable and limited course. If I were in charge of threat assessment for a VIP/HNWI, I'd very much take this threat into consideration.
- quertaciousness 13y agoImagine having your car drive off and park itself somewhere. You don't even need to know where. And there are wider and more fundamental social benefits. City centres will become pleasant places to walk in. Cleaner air, less noise and less chance of being run over. Another example, children will play outside more, rather than being confined indoors as they increasingly have been.
- wavefunction 13y agoLess wasted of 3d space for parking structures, parking lots, etc. is a huge one for me.
- krapp 13y ago>Imagine having your car drive off and park itself somewhere. You don't even need to know where. Sounds like a car thief's dream.
- VLM 13y agoOr just the average meth head doing smash and grabs.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoWhy park it. You'd surely want it to earn it's keep ferrying your "friends" to work [depending how restrictive laws are on temporary rental of autonomous vehicles], dropping-off the kids, popping to the drive-thru to get your lunch, picking up your washing, getting your supermarket shopping and such.
- ricardobeat 13y ago> Railroads, bus companies and short-haul airlines will suffer. If you can move from your home to your destination, door-to-door in the comfort of your car, who’s going to take the train, bus or plane? Would that be significant? Costs, travel times, risk of accidents/theft, failures, would still be much higher. Not to mention it is absurdly less efficient to travel alone in a car. I imagine hopping onto a car to the train station, and having another one waiting for you right at the arrivals gate will be the preferred mode of travel.
- drivingmissm 13y agoThe problem in the U.S. is that the labor unions control rail, and stifle all innovation.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoThe US rail system is excellent, actually. At moving cargo. Rail for moving humans is extremely inefficient almost everywhere on earth.
- Someone 13y agoI would think that is only true for 'rail designed for cargo' or 'rail in not too densely populated areas'. Isn't rail designed for humans as used in subways efficient almost everywhere? I would think it definitely beats private cars. I think that one reason for that is that, for reliable connections, one needs a multiple-connected graph. Users must be able to 'go around' any disturbance that arises.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoCities with high auto use tend to have lower commutes, cities with high metro use tend to have longer commutes. Of course in this case more than any other causation =/= correlation, but just anecdotally you'll find loads of people in Manhattan and Queens with 45+min subway+foot commutes to go a few miles. NY, the most subway-centric city, has the longest commutes in the US. LA, "the most car centric city" (probably not literally true) tends to have amongst the shortest. Decommission those NYC subways and replace with private shuttles and busses. Bet you'll see dramatic drops in commute times for NYC. And it'll save incredible, incredible amounts of money. Edit: Citation: http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/new-yorkers-havelongest-commute-times-article-1.1426047 http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/new-yorkers-havelongest-...
- sfbsfbsfb 13y agoIt seems like these cars will have to be operable in both the manual and self driving modes. Otherwise the car will become much less flexible. Examples: 1) immediate unplanned stop at a yard sale 2) drive "off road" to get around an obstruction 3) dealing with unstructured parking situations 4) avoiding emergency stops in unsafe locations 5) driving through puddles (is it 2 inches or 2 feet deep?) 6) etc. And for some significant transition period the road will be populated by both manual and computer driven cars. How does the hybrid system work? Won't many people take advantage of "dumb" cars. How would you drive if you knew many cars were computer controlled. Would people figure out how to "game" the known computer driving rules? I don't pull out in front of cars that are too close because the human might not stop and hit me. Maybe I don't worry about it if I know the computer is in control of the other car. Long haul freeway driving does not seem too complicated. But what about high density suburban and city driving?
- icebraining 13y ago1 is just a matter of allowing the user to issue real-time commands ("Car, stop here", "Car, go park"). 3 is less of an issue when you can get off and let the car park itself wherever it wants. 2, 4 and 5 are a matter of smarter algorithms, but I doubt they won't be able to do all that way before they become commonplace. Particularly 4, since you can't reasonably expect people to have to take control to avoid an accident. Even professional pilots can struggle with that, let alone regular drivers.
- ams6110 13y agoThere is currently a lot of talk in the professional pilot community that automation has reached the point where pilots are increasingly unable to fly manually. So when the automation fails, they can't handle it.
- tobiasu 13y agoSomething completely lost on tons of nerds seems to be that people genuinely enjoy operating their cars (and motorcycles).
- lamby 13y agoAnd as status symbols go, they pretty much tick all the required boxes.
- tluyben2 13y agoPeople who enjoy that are also a kind of nerds; I was one and the feeling was about the same as I get now when I switch on one of my 70s/80s computers. I changed nerd-ness as an awful lot of people died around me on motorcycles and in cars. It's not important though; you are a menace to society if you drive yourself once robot cars are commonplace and thus you need to take your driving pleasures/status symbol to the track.
- mgw 13y agoI don't think it's lost on people discussing the subject, but it won't be able to stop this technological trend for several reasons. Autonomous cars will be safer than human operated ones so they will at some point be cheaper to insure. This will continue until it is either unaffordable for the average person to operate their own car or outright prohibited because of safety concerns. Driving will become a hobby which people will be able to pursue on dedicated (race)tracks.
- crusso 13y agoOnce Congress is shown that at least 20,000 of the 30,000 deaths per year could be eliminated by forcing autonomous vehicles on everyone, it will be illegal to operate a vehicle manually on first the Interstates, then eventually on every public road.
- saraid216 13y agoRemember when people genuinely enjoyed riding horses?
- swayvil 13y agofta : "The avoidance of accidents will cut insurance costs". Ha ha. No. Any freed-up cash will result in an increase in gas-prices, taxes or whatever. The cost living will continue to be just a bit more than you can afford no matter what. Any "avoidance of accidents" will just translate into profits for somebody, not you. The cost-environment is entirely artificial and is designed to exploit you right down to the bones and gristle. You don't get to enjoy the fruits of progress except in ways that make you a more efficient worker. Sorry.
- cortesoft 13y agoMy cost of living is quite a bit less than I can afford. I am not sure what you mean.
- alan_cx 13y agoLet them eat cake, right?
- cortesoft 13y agoNo, but the comment above made it sound like the situation he described applies to everyone. I am not crazy wealthy, but by being smart with my money and forgoing some things I can live within my means comfortably. I am sure there are many people in my situation, contrary to the statement I was responding to.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tspike 13y agoAs pointed out elsewhere in the thread, if computer driven cars become ubiquitous, insurance rates on person driven cars will become prohibitively high or the act of driving a car on public roads will be banned outright. As someone who enjoys nothing more than riding my motorcycle on mountain road trips, I can't help but dread that. The privacy and liberty implications make me uneasy as well, in much the same way as the NSA's overreach.
- nja 13y agoSomeone recently mentioned horses as a good analogy. Cars replaced horses; now horses are mostly not allowed on roads, and most people do not own horses. However, horse enthusiasts are still able to own horses and ride them, albeit in certain areas. As someone who enjoys driving, I can definitely see this same sort of thing happening with cars. Fortunately, it gives me hope that manually-driven cars won't become completely extinct.
- throwaway0094 13y agoI don't think liability insurance on motorcycles goes up very much. You still can't cause too much damage to a car, even if a human driver is much more likely to crash than computer.
- shalmanese 13y agoWhy would insurance become prohibitively high? Insurance is priced at the mean probability of getting into an accident * mean cost of restitution from an accident + insurance risk premium. I can't see self driving cars measurably affecting any of these numbers upwards significantly. Especially not by the factor of 10 it would require to make insurance prohibitively expensive.
- dredmorbius 13y agoLow-n probabilities become harder to assess, so if human-controlled vehicles are really rare, risks might be hard to assess. How human drivers interact with otherwise automated traffic flows might similarly increase risks. Much as largely horse-drawn or bicycle traffic is generally pretty safe, but mixed-mode traffic with cars, trucks, busses, etc., tends to produce (often fatal) accidents.
- frogpelt 13y agoConvulse = disrupt, right?
- 001sky 13y agoI think the market for trucks will be far more disrupted. The idea of having "drone" containers seems far more easily realized and higher value added than civilian passenger autos. The average A->B distances are longer (miles/trip), the routes simpler (turns/mile) and the roads are less complex (fewer on-grade intersections). It seems an automated "carpool lane" would be a huge benefit. As would the avoidance of speeding and drowsy driving by semi/lorry drivers. Furthermore, removing this rolling stock from passenger car rights of way would itself be an improvement in safety (if for no other reason than > visibility).
- VLM 13y agoAn interesting side issue you didn't consider is at least in the initial roll out phase you simply make an automated "train" with ten trucks, and the lead truck driven by human (or at least has a human on board).
- huherto 13y agoThis will save a lot of energy since the drag of the truck in front will suck the truck behind. Sorry, I lack the technical terms to describe it.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThe term is "drafting" or "slipstreaming". The concept has been part of the allure of autonomous vehicle engineering for decades, and is already praticed by human truck drivers (though they cannot follow as closely as automated systems would be able to). I've done it myself in a passenger car on long trips -- once covered most of a state at high speeds behind a truck who seemed bent on making his schedule. 75+ MPH and my fuel consumption was well below typical for that leg of the trip.
- tfigment 13y agoI thought they have already been doing this in Australia[1] to some degree. I suppose they are not independent trucks but then I'm not sure what the new advantages are if a person is still involved. With the Powertrain, they can split the trailers apart at destination and use normal cabs for distribution I guess. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_train https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_train
- huevosabio 13y agoThere seems to be a lot of excitement about self-driven cars, but somehow, except for a handful of local lines, there has been no real automation on the operation of trains, even if they are much easier to make completely autonomous. How are self-driven cars not going to face the same fate as self-driven trains?
- ghaff 13y agoThere are fairly automated trains but only in very controlled and low-speed environments. (e.g. "people movers" at airports). But, to the broader point, I can't help but feel that a lot of people are conflating "able to tool down 280 with a human on board who is fully capable of taking over control--albeit not instantaneously" (or a next gen cruise control, if you would) with "a robot chauffeur who can drop the kids off at soccer practice." The second problem--which includes dealing with all the unpredictable things that happen on secondary roads--would seem to be enormously more difficult than the first.
- hrkristian 13y agoExcept trains are largely autonomous, it's about wanting a human element in the operation, not requiring them. I see the same applying to a self-driven car, the human element is always present there in the form of passengers, who undoubtedly will be able to assume control if need be, that is how the Google cars are designed.
- loup-vaillant 13y agoI have discussed with guys doing train software for a living: http://prover.com/ http://prover.com/ From their experience, automating trains in an otherwise human environment is very hard. Probably as hard as automating cars. I expect the ubiquitous automation of trains at around the same time at the ubiquitous automation of cars.
- picea 13y agoThe control of the train itself is easy. Simulations abound for this purpose. The GE's and Siemons of this world wouldn't hesitate to implement them if there weren't other significant rail context specific issues, such as the human environment comment above. The difference is that it's not a human vs human driver problem but a schedule design and human making bad scheduling decisions now that the trains are running late, implementation problem. Furthermore, train drivers are cheap (compared with other infrastructure investments) and relatively efficient as they can be skilfully taught to drive according to a plan (compared with your fellow road commuters). Without other investments to tell the driver or the computer that they can drive faster/closer to the train in front at most railways are only likely to see efficiency gains (lower power/diesel usage) but struggle to drive those trains to denser schedules. It will happen for non-capacity reasons such as inter network usage, and safety to prevent trains from speeding around curves and falling off. I expect the challenge will ease partly due to implementing automation of the management to provide safety at increased traffic densities and provide online decision support analysis. Later versions of ETCS could an example of part of that: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Train_Control_System http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Train_Control_System Example of some of the budgets involved: http://ec.europa.eu/transport/themes/infrastructure/news/ten-t-corridors_en.htm http://ec.europa.eu/transport/themes/infrastructure/news/ten...) Once a future version of that is done (ATMS in Australia for example), driverless tech will be much closer to being the low hanging fruit.
- conductor 13y agoComputer-driven cars will introduce tons of new hacking possibilites from the malicious actors, some possible news headlines: The car unexpectedly accelerated and killed 5 people, an accident or a murder? A new ransomware demands 1 BTC to start your car Google keeps all the history of your car's movements LAPD is testing a special device to remotely stop cars instead of chasing them
- vl 13y ago> LAPD is testing a special device to remotely stop cars instead of chasing them This is already a reality, watch commercial for OnStar, this is exactly what they do.
- ihsw 13y agoCan't forget insurance fraud. I foresee a future where insurance companies will impose additional fees to cars that are "assisted" rather than fully autonomous. What is assisted? A car fitted with the self-driving computer, but rather than driving the car it instead compares your actions with one the computer would normally do. What is this comparison for? To determine whether you are a safe driver -- a Safe Driver Rating (SDR). Self-driving cars will become the new gold standard for determining who is a safe driver -- and failing to meet that standard will result in higher insurance rates. What does this have to do with malicious hackers? They can fudge the self-driving computer to silently and gradually increase your insurance rates by misreporting your SDR. What about cars that are neither fully autonomous nor "assisted"? Simple: they don't get built/sold anymore due to being unsafe.
- VLM 13y agoOne interesting side effect of a safe driver rating is you need to balance the cost of having to pay higher insurance with having to find a new job. Or another interesting problem is how do you push a self driving car beyond its performance boundaries to save your life? "I'm sorry dave, but I can't let you drive during a hurricane/tsunami warning" "hey car, shut up and drive, the storm surge is rising and unless you get moving you're about to transform into a submarine" If you get fired from your job because your self driving car decided its not going out in 1 inch of snow, how much do you sue the manufacturer? Or the other way around, your self driving car permitted you to go out in a 24 inch blizzard and it got stuck and you died, how much does your estate and survivors get to sue the manufacturer?" Obviously the proud american tradition of screw the little guy means the mfgrs can do anything they want, but the PR implications mean all self driving cars will shut off whenever the chance of precip is above 0%, or the temp is below 32F, etc. And THATs why I don't want a self driving car, it'll be useless in order to be legally intrinsically safe (only valid operating conditions will be 70 degrees, sunny, daytime, etc, which is about 2 weeks per year where I live.)
- vl 13y ago>Congestion avoidance will speed traffic and save fuel too. Perhaps we live in different worlds, in my world self-driving cars will create more traffic jam, lead to higher road-use taxes and to harsher economic times due to people in trucking/delivery/cab driving losing jobs.
- loup-vaillant 13y agoTraffic jam: the infrastructure may eventually change. Have a first car drive to to a nearby train or subway station, and a second car to your destination from the train. In the meantime, you may have more traffic jam. Energy: when you don't need to own your car, you can use the best car for the job. A commuting car doesn't need to be able to carry 5 people around. It can be much smaller. Again, the transition period likely won't look good. Harsher economic times: this is good old technological employment, where productivity rises faster than demand. My 2 cents: self-driving cars will significantly contribute to technological unemployment, and that's good, provided we manage it well. An obvious measure would be to generalize a 32 hours work-week, over 4 days. It would mean less unemployment and less overwork. Workload will reduce anyway. We might as well share this reduction, instead of giving it all to the unemployed.
- maxerickson 13y agoYou just bill people (more) for driving into a congested area. It would work just fine (as long as the rates were adaptable). But that is orthogonal to whether people will appreciate it.
- richforrester 13y ago>and they will be ubiquitous by 2025. aaaand you've lost me. Apologies for the snide remark, but there's no way we'll be there by that time. The industry won't let us. Apologies for not having much reason in this post, and only stating a personal opinion without much detail to back it up, but I'm just curious to see if there's anyone that feels the same.
- loup-vaillant 13y ago> The industry won't let us. How? Because the way I see it, they will have to form a cartel to prevent one of their own from selling self-driving cars and make a huge profit at the expense of everyone else. The various legal obstacles look bigger.
- dsugarman 13y agothat's what they said about PCs
- richforrester 13y agoI know, and it's also what they said about holograms, personal flying machines etc. Teleporting. And yes, some of those have happened or will happen sooner or later. I'm not saying it's not going to happen, I'm just saying that this particular thing, I don't believe in. But fair enough, I didn't provide any decent information to back up my statement, so I won't ask you to either.
- enko 13y agoHolograms and personal flying machines required huge technological breakthroughs to make them possible. Those breakthroughs still haven't occurred. Teleporting - questionable it's even possible. Self-driving cars are already on the streets in certain cities. Did you see the recent S-class test in Germany?[1] They're here right now, maybe not quite production-ready, but certainly in beta. There's no comparison at all. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CKqJccK_EkM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CKqJccK_EkM
- vincie 13y agoYeah, but they are still just cars. They will still need valuable real-estate for roads and parking and storage. What these are starting to sound like are trains and buses, which have existed for hundreds of years.
- discodave 13y agoNo. A self driving car can move itself somewhere where real estate and parking are freely available and cheap. Also, if people can utilize them like taxis then the total number of cars registered at any one time can drop dramatically. The difference between a self-driving car and a bus/train is that the car goes wherever you want, just like a manual car.
- krapp 13y agoWhat leads you to believe the owners of those properties or law enforcement will allow self-driving cars to park themselves just anywhere?
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoThe cost for parking will of course be limited as otherwise you could simply send the car out to drive around the block until you're ready to leave. That may not provide a restrictive limitation but it will be a limit in some way. I'm now imagining huge traffic jams caused on purpose to enable electric vehicles to crawl around the city for several hours to avoid paying massive parking costs.
- krapp 13y agoI can easily imagine cities mandating autonomous vehicles having to pay (automatically I guess) some kind of 'congestion' fee after driving a certain number of miles without a passenger or without covering any real distance.
- vincie 13y agoIf the most significant difference between a bus/train and a self driving car is the ability to deliver you to your doorstep, I will take the bus/train. Think of the benefits - you don't need to buy and maintain the self-driving car, and hence all the other things like insurance, parking etc. The city doesn't have to build more and more roads. Get a bit of exercise walking to your door. Really, I think these self-driving cars are just the auto manufacturers trying to extend the lifetime of their products.
- michaelfeathers 13y agoThe thing that the article didn't touch on was the fact that many municipalities derive significant income from fines related to parking and traffic violations. It will be a big transition for them also.
- dsugarman 13y agoI wonder how the economics of owning cars will change when everything is computerized. In logistics (specifically trucks), it would incredibly reduce the total cost of shipping if you eliminate Less-than Truck Loads (LTLs) and empty back hauls. I imagine it is similar with transporting people, if there was a "taxi" like company that could maximize the use of an automated car, the total amount of cars necessary in the world would go dramatically down. Right now most cars spend most of their lives idle. Great side effects include no auto insurance and much less emitted greenhouse gasses. The number of millennials buying cars is already extremely low, computerized cars would most likely continue to reduce the number of new car owners.
- jdhendrickson 13y agoAn aspect of this that I have yet to see examined is the rapid decrease in paint and body repair, as well as replacement parts needed on both a mechanical and cosmetic front. Many mechanical failures are due to driver error. Once again shrinking the pool of skilled manual labor with no new industry for the workers to transition into.
- jleyank 13y agoUnless these car systems are programmed at the level of rigor of the Space Shuttle or other "screw up and they all die" environments, the only group that's going to "convulse" from computer-driven cars will be lawyers. And they'll convulse laughing. Is this how it should be, no. But it's how it is in the US at the moment, possibly in other countries as well. As people mention, if they don't behave as the rider wants or if they can't deal with unexpected situations (or mechanical failures) or if they're required to be always-connected and the net goes down… And I'm sure all sorts of privacy types would love being carted about with no control on their environment. Unless the net connection's also amazingly robust, the computer-driven kidnapping possibilities are endless. Oh, I didn't think computer vision's a solved problem… It's easy to lose the GPS signal in cities, and you can probably jam or spoof it without too much difficulty. Doubt cities are going to spend lots of $$ installing all sorts of "helpers" to deal with all that rebar.