7 ms·
Almost all of this is excellent advice, except for one point: "save 20% of your money". That's a bare minimum, which will let you retire after about 37 years o
by JoshTriplett 13y ago
Almost all of this is excellent advice, except for one point: "save 20% of your money". That's a bare minimum, which will let you retire after about 37 years of working. Bump it to 35% and you'll retire after 25 years. Bump it to 50% and retire in 17. Bump it to two-thirds and retire in 10 years.
That's one of the most important factors in your personal finances: not how much you make off your investments, not whether you max your 401k, but how much of your income you save and how much you spend. The only more important factor is "never borrow money", and in particular "never carry a balance on a credit card".
- muzz 13y agoThe savings part sounds like advice from Mr. Money Mustache, there was discussion about his advice here before. "Never borrow money" would include never having a mortgage, which would be a huge lost opportunity for many. Not to mention borrowing money to invest in oneself, start a business, etc.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoA mortgage is one of the few exceptions, and even then you should carefully consider whether renting or buying makes more sense. A car, notably, is not a good exception. Education depends heavily on return on investment; you'd want to carefully analyze how much more you'll make with that education, how long it'll take you to pay off the debt, etc. It can certainly make sense when attempting to bootstrap yourself if your alternative is no higher education at all, but if you're in a financial position where you have to borrow for tuition, you may well qualify for better options such as scholarships. If you're reasonably well off and borrowing to go to a higher-end school, that makes much less sense. And yes, the savings -> years to retirement table came from a Mr. Money Mustache article: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-simple-math-behind-early-retirement/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-sim... .
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tunesmith 13y agoThe chart is also unrealistic since it relies on overly optimistic long term percentage averages.
- pmorici 13y agoMr. Money Mustache's advice wasn't to never borrow money. He said the only reason to borrow money was to buy a house.
- coldtea 13y ago>would include never having a mortgage, which would be a huge lost opportunity for many A lost opportunity? If you can afford a house easily buy one, if you cannot afford it a mortage is anything but a huge opportunity. http://www.jamesaltucher.com/2011/03/why-i-am-never-going-to-own-a-home-again/ http://www.jamesaltucher.com/2011/03/why-i-am-never-going-to... http://www.jamesaltucher.com/2011/05/why-i-would-rather-shoot-myself-in-the-head-than-own-a-home/ http://www.jamesaltucher.com/2011/05/why-i-would-rather-shoo...
- sliverstorm 13y agoThis advice seems to completely gloss over one key fact: You have to live somewhere. Seriously- if you didn't, buying a house would be a terrible investment! But you do, so the cost of owning a house needs to be compared to the cost of renting, instead of being discussed as a normal investment.
- untog 13y agoNot sure why this is being downvoted. If you don't get mortgage, the presumption is that you aren't going to buy a house outright, either. You're going to rent, which isn't exactly an ideal situation in the long term.
- sliverstorm 13y agoHaha yes, if you can buy a house outright, definitely do that. Unless, of course, you can land an incredibly low interest rate on your mortgage and have something interesting to do with your capitol, like fund your business.
- coldtea 13y ago>the cost of owning a house needs to be compared to the cost of renting Emm, the linked articles get into exactly this.
- superuser2 13y agoOpportunity cost. $250,000 invested now could be substantially more by retirement than the cost of the mortgage over its lifetime.
- jmharvey 13y agoPeople frequently get themselves into serious financial trouble by borrowing money to "invest in themselves" or "start a business." On a case-by-case basis, these may actually be sound financial moves, but there are whole industries built on suckering people into making "investments" that aren't financially prudent.
- throwaway1979 13y ago"Save 20%" ... gross or net?
- JoshTriplett 13y agoNet. Gross is uninteresting for almost all purposes other than pre-tax investments you can make; just write off taxes as a drag force and pay attention to what fraction of your net income you're saving. The important detail about increasing your savings rate: it also means decreasing your spending rate, and you can retire as soon as your savings generates income greater than your spending rate, not greater than your overall income.
- sliverstorm 13y agoIt would have to be net. Your tax situation determines the conversion from gross to net, and can vary wildly from person to person making percentage rates based on gross too variable. While you should of course do what you can to reduce taxes, that's so complicated it warrants completely independent dialogue.
- BrandonMarc 13y agoFair question, but OTOH it kinda doesn't matter since nobody does either. Seriously, everybody talks about saving money, and everybody intellectually agrees it's a good thing, but next to nobody actually does it. Which means, even if you're aiming for 20% of the little number, you're behaving smarter than the vast majority of your peers.
- ultimoo 13y agoThis is really interesting and inspiring for someone like me who is in his mid twenties. Burning question: what to do when you have (education) debt? Do you put every spare dollar in repaying it or still inculcate a habit of saving 20%?
- JoshTriplett 13y agoWhat's the interest rate on the debt, and how much are you making on your investments? To a first approximation, you can treat the debt as an investment with a guaranteed rate of return. If you have debt that's not at such a ludicrously low interest rate that it makes sense to hang onto the money and invest it (rare), then your savings should be going straight into paying off that debt. The savings rate still applies; it determines how fast you can pay off the debt. If you can reduce your spending and increase your savings rate, you'll pay off the debt that much faster, and the same principle applies once you've paid it off and started investing.
- scott_karana 13y agoSpot on analysis. I'd caution that you should still keep a small cash reserve for emergencies, of course. Savings are liquid: student loans are not.
- gerickson 13y agoRecent college grad and young working professional here. I graduated with ~$25k in student loan debt 2 years ago and am due to pay it all off by April 2014. I struggled with burning question, as well. The general advice I got was that if the loan interest rate is less than 6%, you're better off investing the majority of your excess cash into something like an index fund since it theoretically will give you >6% gains. However, I hate the stress, mental overhead, and risk involved in owing somebody money, so I decided to automatically save 10% of each paycheck (set up direct deposit to funnel 10% to a separate savings/investment account) and essentially contribute as much as possible after that to student loans. I'm happy where I currently am - almost out of debt and with a non-trivial amount saved up. The key for me was automatically moving the first 10% to savings then setting an ambitious goal each month to put toward debt. Good luck!
- coldtea 13y ago>Bump it to two-thirds and retire in 10 years. Expand it by 100 and you would be already retired before you would were even born! I guess the point of the advice is to be realistic. >The only more important factor is "never borrow money", and in particular "never carry a balance on a credit card". Well, lots of people have started companies or saved themselves from starvation by maxing a credit card.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoThe idea that >20% savings rates are not "realistic" is a serious mindset problem. Almost anyone on Hacker News with a paying job (i.e. not an early-stage no-funding startup) should easily be able to save much more than that. Sure, saving two-thirds of your income might be out of reach, and even the 20% advice is better than most sites that often say 5-10%, but consider carefully whether you can increase it and retire years earlier (or become effectively retired, in the sense that you no longer depend on having an income). EDIT: "Almost anyone on Hacker News". Yes, 20% would be significantly harder on minimum wage.
- drivebyacct2 13y ago:eyeroll: about the level of response this post deserves
- throwaway812 13y agoYes, >20% is viable for Software Devs. Ask someone making minimum wage with no benefits to save more than 20% of their income and they will laugh at you.
- timr 13y agoEven if you're a "rich" software engineer, the advice is overstated. You need to make a lot of money (or be really lucky in the stock market) to have a 66% savings rate lead to any sort of real retirement in 10 years. Say I make $100k gross per year. That's a very nice salary for a new grad engineer -- the kind of person who might take this ten-year-retirement advice to heart. Roughly 1/3 of that income goes to taxes, so I'm actually taking home $66k per year. If I save 66% of that, I'm saving ~$44k per year. These numbers can shift a little depending on where you live, how you save, etc., but they're not going to change by a huge amount. Multiply that $44k by 10 years, and you're not even at half a million dollars. That's not retirement money (unless perhaps your "retirement" is to continue to live off of $20k/year indefinitely and die young from eating too much ramen). The other half of the equation is finding investments that return a reasonable yield without betting the farm on timeframes <= 10 years. In this market, that's nearly impossible. Your choices are stocks and bonds (which are fine, but are risky on anything less than a ten-year window), or investments that don't yield anything.
- enraged_camel 13y agoOne of the recommendations is actually wrong, and in fact outright harmful. "Buy inexpensive, well-diversified mutual funds such as Vanguard Target 20xx funds." Yeah, no. Mutual funds, even those by Vanguard, have high expense ratios, and there is absolutely no evidence that they outperform their equivalent index funds. Jack Bogle, founder and retired CEO of Vanguard, himself recommends index funds over mutual funds for this reason.
- Shengster 13y agoGood point, although I think he implicitly implies "index funds" in this case because later there's a bullet that says: * Pay attention to fees. Avoid actively managed funds.
- ankzap 13y agoVanguard Target funds are nothing but a collection of passively managed index funds. The ER is slightly higher than doing it a la carte, but it re-balances without having to worry about it.
- enraged_camel 13y agoYes, Vanguard is a lot better than others in this regard, that is true. But the fees are still higher. Automatic re-balancing is nice, but it's not like balancing a portfolio is anything to "worry about" once you figure out the basics (which you should). There's also the fact that not everyone's 401k is offered through Vanguard. For example, if you're stuck with Fidelity like I am, then you will definitely need to avoid their mutual funds and choose their index funds instead. (With 401k, you cannot pick a fund outside of the broker that manages it.)
- cowsandmilk 13y agoit is only higher if you qualify for admiral shares in all the funds contained in the target fund. With the current case of most target funds having a 2% holding in International Bonds, you would need to have $500,000 invested to make it cheaper to buy the individual funds.
- 13y ago
- sologoub 13y agoIt's not quite that simple. What you need is a savings rate that is far above society's average in order to be ahead by that much. For US, that's relatively easy, but for many cash-heavy economies it is not. If your country propensity to save is 90%, getting to 99% isn't all that groundbreaking. The other thing missing is to take calculated risks for higher returns. For example, if you see housing starting to recover, picking up a distressed rental is smart. Provided you know what you are doing. I recall a while back someone posted here about picking up semi-abandoned apps that were generating some cash flow, sprucing them up and letting the revenue drip in. Again, this works if you know what you are doing, but won't work for average Joe.
- raintrees 13y ago"Never borrow money" excludes Smart Debt: Debt someone else pays for you, such as Investment Property, or Big Business (not small business. This definition of Big Business is where you have a controlling interest and you can leave for 6 months and business is even better). It depends on how quickly you wish to generate wealth. Leverage (OPM, OPT) must be used wisely, but significantly speeds up the process.
- DustinCalim 13y agoIronic "Never borrow money" shows up here considering the start-up orientation of this site... Small business owners are a cornerstone of capitalism and our economy so we should incentivize people to take risks when they can.
- WildUtah 13y agoBorrowing money for current consumption and for investment are very different things. Furthermore, borrowing money for investment and selling equity in a business to investors are two very different things.
- superuser2 13y agoNever borrow money? You've just completely eliminated car ownership for a good chunk of the middle class, and homeownership for pretty much everyone but the very rich. That's probably a defensible position, but it's definitely not normal financial advice. If putting $7,000 away for retirement right now nets you more by retirement age than the lifetime cost of a car loan, you should take the loan.
- derekp7 13y agoI've owned cars since I was 17 year old, and never had to borrow money for a car till I decided to buy a brand new car years later Since then, I've decided to do the following: So you make "car payments" into your savings account every month, and after 1 - 3 years you can get a usable or very nice used car. Then continue to make car payments into your savings, and 5 years afterwards you can get a brand new car -- one that will last you for 15 years (at least). Then, in the last 5 years, do the same thing if you want to continue to drive new vehicles.
- superuser2 13y agoBuying brand new cars is not good financial advice either. Instant depreciation, no time for problems to blow up in someone else's face first, tiny longevity gain over buying a 2-3 year old car for drastically less.
- derekp7 13y agoOh, I agree with that in general. I've just never been able to get a 2-3 year old car to be worth keeping for more than another 3-5 years (either previous owner got rid of it early because it was a lemon, or didn't take care of it [oil changes, garage kept, easy driving, etc]). Whereas a car I've owned from day one (since year 2000) has only needed minor repairs (most of which I do myself, except when the fuel pump went out far from home). Once it starts costing me more than a couple thousand a year for repairs, or becomes unreliable, it will be time to trade up. If I keep it for a couple more years, it comes out to about $1500 a year. Heck, I may keep it for 20 years. I just can't see me wanting to keep a car I bought used for 20 years though (or till the car is 20 years old even).
- alok-g 13y ago>> ... Bump it to 35% and you'll retire after 25 years. Bump it to 50% and retire in 17. Bump it to two-thirds and retire in 10 years. Can you/someone please point to the maths behind this? It sounds to me there are some assumptions about returns on investments and inflation rates.
- stephenbez 13y agoThe math is covered here: http://earlyretirementextreme.com/ http://earlyretirementextreme.com/ Basically the thought is that 20-25 years of living expenses will generate enough income for you to early retire on. If you make 100k (post tax) with a 20% savings rate, you save 20k, and have living expenses of 80k. Ignoring future compound growth, for each year you work, you save 1/4 a year of living expenses. If you go the other extreme, and have 66% savings rate, you save 66k, and have living expenses of 33k. With 33k living expenses you need 660k to retire. Each year of working you end up with 2 years of living expenses. Even ignoring the effect of investment growth before you retire, that is only 10 years of working. Of course 20 years of savings maybe be too optimistic. The book is good and has more details.
- alok-g 13y agoI'll have to read the book for more but the math you explain seems incomplete. The earlier I retire, the more would be my expected number of years in retirement (assuming a given life expectancy). If in one scenario my retirement is 40 years away and I need to save for 20 more years, then in he other scenario where I retire in ten years, I need to save for fifty! That's a factor of 2.5 in this example! Ignoring growth rates and inflation is also a huge simplification. E.g. 3% yearly growth doubles your money in about 24 years. So it may again be a factor bigger than two between the two scenarios above.
- stephenbez 13y agoI think the idea is that if you have a large pile of money and take out a small portion of it each year to live on, due to growth the money will last indefinitely. So if you have 25 years of living expenses and each year take out 1 year of living expenses, that is 4% of your money. If you earn ~4% a year then your account balance stays the same. The 4% number matches the 4% rule: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/four-percent-rule.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/four-percent-rule.asp Of course after the great recession now the common wisdom is that the 4% rule can't be trusted: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324162304578304491492559684.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142412788732416230457830... Personally I think it would be foolish to plan on retiring with only 20 years of living expenses. However some people also plan on holding a part time job at least in early retirement.
- pwthornton 13y agoWhy would you want to retire in 10 years? Isn't that like saying you hate your work? I enjoy my work, and am working to make it more enjoyable. The idea that I would try to live like a pauper so I could retire in 10 years and not do anything seems kind of strange. If I retired, I would just find another job or career to make stuff.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoJust because you have enough savings to retire doesn't mean you have to retire; it just means you have the option to. And "retire" doesn't mean you have to stop doing interesting work, either. You could keep working an existing job that you enjoy knowing that it's completely optional for you, or you could spend 100% of your time doing work that doesn't necessarily pay (e.g. a startup, or working on random Open Source projects that tickle your fancy).