26 ms·
Excess Automobile Deaths as a Result of 9/11
- devx 13y agoI bet a lot of people chose driving over flying not just because they're afraid of having their planes hijacked, but also because of the TSA and not wanting to deal with them.
- chiph 13y agoI'm one. I'd rather spend a day and a half in the car than deal with them.
- ds9 13y agoExactly. The Xray scanners (now pulled), the offensive groping, the authoritarian attitudes, the long delays - I'm sure I saw some numbers showing big declines in the airline industry from late 2001, and undoubtedly few Americans today think terrorism is a big threat, but no one likes the TSA.
- ChrisClark 13y agoYes, that's exactly what the article says. In fact, it says the TSA inconveniences are the main reason people chose to drive instead.
- marssaxman 13y agoI am not at all afraid of having a plane hijacked, but if I choose to fly it is a dead certainty that the TSA will invade my privacy, violate my rights, and waste my time. I would rather deny them the opportunity by driving.
- chatman 13y agoI don't understand why this post is featured on HN. It is just commentary on a previous essay, and doesn't even sound like a comprehensive commentary; just a few observations.
- eru 13y agoIt has a catchy title, however.
- timdiggerm 13y agoBruce Schneier.
- coldcode 13y agoThis just shows you that security is always a trade-off, whether in your application or in life in general. People rarely consider the true cost of a change in security policy.
- ds9 13y ago"since airline travel is far safer than car travel" -- source quoted by Schneier This old line has been exaggerated because people make a fallacious comparison. Ask whether people feel safer driving or flying, and many will say driving - this may still be statistically wrong, but it is intuitively based on the correct comparison. The comparison people intuitively make is "events I can't control in each alternative", while the fallacious-debunkers compare total casualties. But almost all of the plane casualties are beyond the traveler's control, while on the other hand he/she can make sure the car is in good condition, drive while alert, obey speed limits and so on. The plane casualty number may still be lower than the corrected car casualty number, but not nearly by as much as is sometimes claimed.
- blackhole 13y agoYou can't control other drunk drivers, either.
- GrinningFool 13y agoIt does always take two people to get in a [two vehicle] collision. You can't control the other driver, but you can control how you react - and usually whether you've seen them coming in time to do so. Sometimes it's unavoidable - you're stopped at a light and someone crosses the median to plow into you. In that situation, you are screwed. But often, there is something you as the not "at fault" party could have done to avoid the collision (even with the drunk driver), had you been paying attention enough to see the situation. Change lanes. Slow down. Speed up. Leave more room. Leave less room. Always, no matter what, be looking. Once I prevented myself from getting rear-ended at a traffic light: I was stopped and saw someone coming up behind me way too fast. I leaned on my horn, they clued in, and braked in time to stop just touching my fender. (I was in a motorcyle at a time, so REALLY happy with the outcome.) Again, sometimes it really is unavoidable - but in a surprising number of situations there are actions a driver can take to avoid or reduce the severity of the incident. Insurance companies understand this - that's why your rates raise when you get in an accident, regardless of whether you're legally "at fault". Driving well and alertly doesn't end at the bounds of legal fault. Sure if you were rear-ended someone else will pay damages - but if you're in a wheelchair or dead, that money isn't going to make things better. So to GP's point: there are a LOT of things that are far more under your control when you're driving. Falling out of the sky... not so much.
- chimeracoder 13y ago> The inconvenience of extra passenger screening and added costs at airports after 9/11 cause many short-haul passengers to drive to their destination instead "Inconvenience" is putting it mildly. Even before my recent experiences with airport security[0], I preferred to drive or take the train for short distances (NYC to Boston, Philly, DC, etc.). As one can imagine, that aversion has only increased. Nate Silver puts this well: > According to the Cornell study, roughly 130 inconvenienced travelers died every three months as a result of additional traffic fatalities brought on by substituting ground transit for air transit. That’s the equivalent of four fully-loaded Boeing 737s crashing each year.[1] Emphasis mine. [0] Previously submitted to HN, but for the lazy: http://varnull.adityamukerjee.net/post/59021412512/dont-fly-during-ramadan http://varnull.adityamukerjee.net/post/59021412512/dont-fly-... [1]http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/11/18/the-hidden-costs-of-extra-airport-security/?_r=0 http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/11/18/the-hidd...)
- drpgq 13y agoI guess 9/11 has been a benefit for Amtrak.
- chimeracoder 13y agoCue the "Joe Biden caused 9/11" conspiracy theories!
- betterunix 13y agoOnly in the Northeast. For most of America it is easier to get around by plane than by train.
- stephengillie 13y agoTravelling from Seattle to LA is fastest by plane, then car, then bus. Amtrack is slower than those 3, and more expensive than the last 2.
- GrinningFool 13y agoSince the new "security measures" have gone into place. I've instituted a 12- to 14-hour rule: if I can get somewhere by driving there in less than 12 (to 14) hours, I'll drive. As a tall person, a plane has always been uncomfortable for me. Add to that experience the long security lines and being treated like cattle... nah. It costs me more, but I'll drive.
- pre 13y agoAfter the tube-bombings in London a friend's mom offered to buy him a car so he didn't have to get the tube and risk being blown up. Ha. He refused (mostly to spare her the cost I think) while pointing out that would have been a good way to increase the chances of him dying while traveling.
- bloat 13y agoI am (irrationally) afraid of flying, but I try and counteract it by telling myself, when I get out of the car at the airport, "Phew, that's the dangerous part of the journey over with."
- mhb 13y agoThat depends on how far you drive to the airport versus how far your plane trip is.
- netrus 13y agoI'd guess the distance of the flight is not that important, because risk is mostly constant (one take off, one landing). If you can choose to drive instead of to fly, however...
- cjrp 13y agoIn fact, shorter flights may carry more risk with the regional pilots that operate them typically having less flying experience and a higher likelihood of suffering from fatigue.
- peferron 13y agoAnother mind trick is to tell yourself a few minutes after takeoff that you're now very safe for the entire journey until the landing.
- tedunangst 13y agoNot sure. Of the four recent crashes that come to mind, two involved landing or takeoff (sfo crash, ny plane that landed in Hudson). Casualties were minimal. The other two (French flight from brazil, upstate ny crash) basically fell out of the sky mid flight. Everybody died.
- sklivvz1971 13y agoI'm one of the "people that commented" and the thread is here: http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/q/17578/96 http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/q/17578/96
- api 13y agoOur irrationality in the face of minor but "scary" risks (vs. chronic ones) is brilliant for Schneier to point out -- it's really one of the pivots on which the whole surveillance issue rests. Throwing away our freedom to prevent rare, statistically insignificant events is equally stupid. By doing so we are risking a much greater danger -- the chronic danger of a corrupt and possibly deadly police state.
- brudgers 13y agoWe tend to accept that death has a color [1]. Unfortunately, we tend to let our governments decide which deaths have what color. No doubt the 500 or so US residents who died each year as a result of actions following 9/11 constitutes many individual tragedies. But there have been many many more colorless deaths around the world as a result of other government actions with 9/11 as their rationalization. [1] http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23
- lostlogin 13y agoThere might have been many due to other government actions, but the vast majority are surely attributable to the US government. What's a few hundred thousand deaths when they are Muslim though?
- JackFr 13y agoI read the original Cornell paper which attempted show the effect of security measures on demand for air travel (http://dyson.cornell.edu/faculty_sites/gb78/wp/airport_security_022305.pdf http://dyson.cornell.edu/faculty_sites/gb78/wp/airport_secur...), and frankly I didn't find it very compelling. But even were one to accept its conclusion that security measures (and not an economic downturn or a change in preference due to a percieved risk) caused the change in demand, no one presents any evidence that the air travel was replced with car travel. It seems quite likely that many trips would have been simply forgone, or along the BOS-NY-WAS corridor replaced with the train.
- toblender 13y agoI first heard about this from the book, the "Science of Fear". It's unfortunate that fear of something like flight, can lead to death by other means.
- mathattack 13y agoFrom the comments: Another good illustration: In the past 20 years total, deer have killed more on American soil (~150-200/yr) than terrorists. So where is the trillion dollar War on Bambi?
- refurb 13y agoThat's a ridiculous comment. The commentor is comparing the numbers of deaths that occurred over 20 years to the number of deaths that occurred during a single morning on 9/11?
- Amadou 13y agoWhat do you think would be an appropriate comparison? The number of deer-related deaths that occurred on 9/11?
- samatman 13y agoI rode my electric scooter to work this morning. If I had accelerated all at once, the jerk would have broken my neck. Quantity/time has a quality all of its own.
- lostlogin 13y agoAnd the politics of race/religion. If those deer and your scooter start acting all foreign, there is going to be trouble.
- betterunix 13y agoMajor terrorist attacks are extremely rare in America. They were rare before 9/11 and they have been rare since. Deer hits, on the other hand, are common and cause extensive damage to vehicles and injuries to drivers. Also, there is a war on deer, but we prefer to call it "hunting." Hunting regulations are designed to cull the deer population, particularly in areas where natural predators were killed off by humans long ago. Hunting regulations balance the need to keep the deer population down with the need to not drive deer into extinction. It might make sense to bump up the number of kills allowed per hunter per season or to make the seasons longer if automobile hits are a serious enough problem (there are still more deer now in many eastern states than there were when the colonies were first established).
- jweir 13y agoWhy does the Wikipedia article show a steady decline of fatalities? And this is occurring in a growing population. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_in_U.S._by_year http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_in...
- lingben 13y agoyou answered yourself, the decline is in fatalities per capita
- Someone 13y agoIt also is in absolute number of fatalities, since 2002, except for 2005.
- sp332 13y agoFatalities from automobile accidents have plummeted, to the point that suicide is now a more-frequent cause of death for men age 25-34. Note that suicides are down too, but car deaths are down even more sharply.
- Zigurd 13y agoCars used to be death traps. Now even the lowest cost cars have decent survivability.
- revelation 13y agoNo idea, what does it have to do with the question at hand here? Maybe car turnover (switching to safer cars) acts stronger than flawed government policy.
- jacquesm 13y agoTo really properly balance this you'd have to compare with a world where the TSA does not exist. But we don't actually have the possibility to compare the two. Chances are (not saying this is the case) that the combined haul of what the TSA found during the last decade would have led to more deaths. Controlled experiments on this scale are unfortunately not possible so in the end it all boils down to what you wish to believe most or what seems to be most reasonable.
- HarryHirsch 13y agoIn Europe we had a rash of airplane hijackings in the 1970s and 1980s, onsequently there is plenty of institutional experience in how to deal with terrorism and aircraft. We chose not to plump for the TSA groping squad. Neither should the US.
- anigbrowl 13y agoThere were also quite a lot of hijackings in the US during that period. But none of them ended as badly as 9-11, so it's not a terribly meaningful comparison.
- HarryHirsch 13y agoI wouldn't say the comparison was meaningless. The blood toll of Entebbe and Landshut was less, but the public impact was enormous. One must keep the public mood in the back of one's head - this was in 1977, there was a series of attacks by the Red Army Faction, which everyone had thought was dead, and then, just as now, there was the discussion about dragnet surveillance and civil liberties, there was even discussion about the aims of the RAF, perhaps they even had a point. The keyword is "Deutscher Herbst".
- mikeash 13y ago"Chances are" implies that this is the most likely possibility. I think you may have meant to say, "it is possible".
- 13y ago
- downandout 13y agoAn interesting tidbit in the post is that DHS values each life at $6.5 million. Since most people do not have a net worth that high, and will never earn anywhere near that much in their lifetimes, it really makes me wonder where they get these numbers. While any loss of life is tragic, that loss rarely represents a financial loss of $6.5 million to the economy - even if you take earning potential into account.
- cynicalkane 13y agoAre you actually expressing confusion that the value of a life is higher than its discounted cash flow?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tlrobinson 13y ago"[Economists] often consider the value of a statistical life (VSL). The VSL is the value that an individual places on a marginal change in their likelihood of death. Note that the VSL is very different from the value of an actual life. It is the value placed on changes in the likelihood of death, not the price someone would pay to avoid certain death." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life
- frobozz 13y agoSimply adding up all the dollars that might find their way into and out of your bank account is rather a naive way to value a life. You may not ever earn or own that much money, but perhaps one of your descendants might be the next Gates/Buffet/Rausing/Musk (pick your favourite rich person). If you are yet to breed, or having bred, yet to finish your job of raising that child, then you might want to include the potential financial loss that your descendants incur by not living up to their full potential, or taking an extra generation to climb above your current social level. You mention a financial loss to "the economy", rather than explicitly to the household of the deceased. You may not earn $6.5M for yourself, but you might implement some feature that saves 1000 people who earn $65K each a year of effort. Your employer may need to replace you, we often see posts about how important it is to hire the right people, because of how much the hiring process itself costs. If a well-liked individual dies, then the productivity of some of those close to them drops for a period. Your next of kin may have to take time out of work to arrange the disposal of your remains, attend an inquest, deal with probate, authorise the withdrawal of life support from your brain-dead body (and deal with the psychological trauma that that might cause). Your friends and relatives may take a day off work to attend a funeral. If blame is to be apportioned for someone's death, expensive legal professionals will be involved in working out how much blame should fall on whom. Insurers will argue about how quickly their liability should be discharged, and how much they should actually pay.
- hobb0001 13y agoSecurity theater. sigh If the government was actually serious about protecting women and children from people with malicious intent, terrorists would be toward the bottom of the list, just above school shooters. Domestic abuse far outstrips any news-worthy outrages, but you don't get many votes talking about that.
- lukifer 13y agoSecurity theater to treat criminal violence theater. It makes a perverse sort of sense. Terrorism is not really about deaths; there are many greater causes of preventable death, as you note. It's about attacking a nation's perception of safety. You can ignore another random car accident or drug-related murder, but it's much harder to ignore 9/11. I'd much prefer the vaccine to the "cure": to educate ourselves on this tactic and refuse to play along, treating terrorism the way we would treat a natural disaster. But alas, there's too much money and power to be gained in the security theater racket, and power abhors a vacuum.
- 3am 13y agoThis is a morbid point, but I dislike the figure of ~3K people killed in the 9/11 attacks. If either of the towers had fallen sooner or had fallen sideways instead of collapsing almost completely vertically, then it could have been much worse. I'm trying to make the narrowest possible point when saying this: just that ~3K casualties was far from the worst case outcome that was possible that day. EDIT: per my reply below, I'm only trying to make the discussion as honest as possible. At the core is the question, "Given X casualties to air travel based terror attacks, is a particular security policy worth implementing if it leads to Y casualties indirectly?". I'm addressing a shortcoming in what I see as the figure being used for X, since it's a small data set. It would be interesting to address the effectiveness (% of attacks thwarted or discouraged) of the security policy, too.
- bmm6o 13y agoWhy does it make sense to introduce into this discussion some number of hypothetical counter-factual fatalities?
- 3am 13y agoBecause at the core of the point is a comparison between a very large data set (auto fatalities) and a very small data set (large scale terrorist attacks). Since - thank god - there is a very limited data set available in the second case it's worth asking if the expected value is higher than the observed value up til now.
- recursive 13y agoAnd the actual number of car-related casualties are far from a worst case scenario also. Why do you dislike an apples to apples, actual to actual comparison?
- scoot 13y agoIt was also far from the best. The second tower could have been evacuated before the second plane struck. One or both towers could have remained standing. Speculating as to what could have happened makes no sense. The number who died is what it is, for better or worse.