14 ms·
It's a Dumbphone, But It's the Nicest Dumbphone You Can Buy
- apendleton 13y agoAfter the recent price drop, it ends up being only 25% cheaper than a Nexus 4, which is way more phone than this. It's not clear to me that there's anyone interested in the particular price/features intersection where this phone sits.
- benologist 13y agoThe enormous number of people who don't want or care about smartphones, and the enormous number of people whose sticker price is closer to $1000 for the Nexus 4 because of import duties and stuff.
- apendleton 13y agoFor the former group, I'm well aware that there are people who don't care about smartphones, but do you think there are many of those who want to be able to adjust the white-balance on their phone cameras? I think most people who don't care about smartphone features would probably do just as well with a $50 phone as this one, with less of the "fancy" stuff.
- benologist 13y agoI agree that most people would do just as well with a $50 phone. The difference between this and every other option is superficial. But the RAZR wasn't that much better than everything else either and it sold over 100 million units.
- alextingle 13y agoI can't find a Nexus 4 for under $300, which is double the RRP of this phone. The Nexus has a RRP of $799, so I'm sure the Nokia will also be a lot cheaper than $150 in practice.
- lstamour 13y agoThe Nexus 4 8GB is on the Google Play (U.S.) store right now for $199, and 16GB for $249. Where did you get $800 from? It was never 800.
- alextingle 13y agoLinky: http://www.amazon.com/LG-Unlocked-International-Version-Warranty/dp/B00ABPKHH0/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1377894180&sr=8-1&keywords=nexus+4 http://www.amazon.com/LG-Unlocked-International-Version-Warr...
- lstamour 13y agoAfaik that doesn't say much. Amazon listings list prices are often as inflated as cell phone prices are in the first place. Amazon uses list prices as a maximum, then puts the item on sale based on how it sells. Though it's equally true that Google is selling the phones basically at cost, making money instead off the people using them.
- tene 13y agoYou can buy it for $199 straight from Google: http://www.google.com/nexus/4/ http://www.google.com/nexus/4/
- hyperpape 13y agoNo, it ends up being far cheaper than a Nexus 4. For many people, the point of a dumbphone like this is that you can save hundreds of dollars on data plans, or even more with prepaid. Right now, I pay roughly $10 a month for my phone, and I'm reasonably happy with that (the reception is a bit weak, perhaps because the phone is so cheap, or perhaps because Tracfone is bad in my area).The problem is that my phone itself is terrible. The UI and the physical design are both atrocious. I'd gladly drop $100 on a device that was pleasant to use. I've even contemplated shelling out a few hundred for a no-contract smartphone (I have wifi at work, wifi at home, etc...)
- mcpherrinm 13y agoYou're comparing the price of presumably unlocked phones. Nobody is forcing you to get a data plan with your Nexus 4.
- scott_karana 13y agoYup. Get the same plan as the Nokia user, and then use free Wi-Fi, applications, etc...
- libria 13y agoCan't speak for other carriers, but Verizon prohibited me from using a smart phone on a non-data plan. I assume some technological breakthroughs are required to permit that pairing.
- mcpherrinm 13y agoThat sucks. While I was a student, I just got the cheapest prepaid SIM card for my old Nexus One and paid the $10/mo for unlimited texting. Wifi blanketing campus, my house, and my favourite bar meant I rarely missed data. I certainly wouldn't go with Verizon if that was the case.
- hyperpape 13y agoFair enough. I guess I was under the mistaken impression that carrier subsidies were a bigger deal with all smartphones than they really are.
- tyw 13y agoI still haven't joined the smartphone revolution and this appeals to me in some respects, but I wish they'd have opted for a full physical keyboard. I avoid sending texts whenever possible because T9 is such a pain in the ass compared to QWERTY.
- ImprovedSilence 13y agoTo each their own, I love the minimalistic "candy bar" approach to phones.
- cbhl 13y agoHave you considered a BlackBerry Q10?
- pearjuice 13y agoRead: Have a you considered a dead corpse?
- Fuzzwah 13y agoI held off on a smart phone for so long it became a running joke in my circle of friends, I loved T9 on that nokia 6100.
- netghost 13y agoI have a co-worker who saw my dumb phone and thought it was some new cutting edge device since it was so tiny. Good laugh for all the devs in the office.
- zokier 13y agoI think Asha 210 is the phone you are looking for; featurephone with qwerty keypad: http://www.gsmarena.com/nokia_asha_210-5417.php http://www.gsmarena.com/nokia_asha_210-5417.php
- GigabyteCoin 13y agoReally? With the properly configured dictionary, T9 can be a treat. I regularly type 2 or 3 page texts in under a minute using T9.
- chmike 13y agoExcellent: 38 days autonomy. Some people favor that. Make it ip67, and this could be a hit. There is plenty of room there in the market.
- devx 13y agoI've seen phones claim "4 weeks of standby" in the early 2000's too. They don't actually last that long. The test is most likely done on some "absolute minimum usage". But it can probably last you about a week with moderate usage. That's how a lot of dumbphones (and even Blackberries) used to last before the iPhone, and all the touchscreen phones that arrived after it, but I think most people have forgotten that. It's because they used very limited operating systems and small screens with small resolutions, so they don't use nearly the same amount of power as today's touchscreen smartphones, with 4"+ screens and ~720p resolutions.
- pyre 13y agoI only remember my dumbphone lasting 2 ~ 3 days with little to moderate usage. Maybe it matters that it was a CDMA (Verizon) phone?
- bradfa 13y agoMy Nokia C1 (GSM on T-Mobile in USA) goes for about a week between charges and it's about 2 years old on the original battery. It's my only telephone which I on average text or talk on at least once a day. As long as coverage is decent and I have reasonable signal levels that's usual. With weak signal levels or no service when it's hunting for service the battery will go flat in a day or two.
- jol 13y agoI have nokia x1-01 for family & friends only number and as a phone that I use when I want to be reachable but not to worry about loosing the smartphone, with 20-40 min talk time a day it lasts for more than a week on single charge, thus 4weeks standby seems credible to me
- 13y ago
- xutopia 13y agoHow much is it?
- freehunter 13y agoIt says at the bottom that it's 150USD. No word on prices in other markets.
- mikkom 13y agoIn Finland Nokia has announced that the "official" price will be about 115 eur.
- jlgreco 13y agoWith a camera on it, wouldn't it be more of a "feature phone"? Looks very slick, whatever you call it.
- fleitz 13y agoFeature phone is a euphemism for dumb phone.
- mortenjorck 13y agoOr dumb phone is a glib neologism for feature phone.
- pavlov 13y agoAnd both can be replaced with plain old "mobile phone".
- cbhl 13y agoNo, a dumb phone has calling and SMS only. It is distinct from feature phones, which have features like a camera or Java ME.
- mkr-hn 13y agoDumb phone and feature phone have always been synonymous to me. That's a common theme in this thread. I don't think you can reasonably speak in absolutes on this.
- hrktb 13y agoThis is a feature phone: http://k-tai.casio.jp/products/ca007/index.html http://k-tai.casio.jp/products/ca007/index.html Waterproof, 8M camera, snapdragon chipset, full email, GPS and BREW apps, NFC, running 240 hours. There's quite a gap with a "dumb" phone.
- dave1010uk 13y ago
- ImprovedSilence 13y agoHA! that looks awesome. Somewhat similar in looks to the LG Glance[1] that I had as my last "dumb-phone". Of which, I will say I loved the ergonomics, battery life, and durability of that phone. Honestly, the only real data function I require on my phone these days is maps... I would be very tempted to drop the data plan on go this direction. A bit pricey though, I would still probs go with a $25 phone over $150 anyway.... [1] image: http://i-cdn.phonearena.com/images/phones/16040-large/LG-Glance.jpg http://i-cdn.phonearena.com/images/phones/16040-large/LG-Gla...
- ImprovedSilence 13y agoFor those interested, full Specs of Nokia 515: http://www.nokia.com/global/products/phone/515/specifications/ http://www.nokia.com/global/products/phone/515/specification...
- sliverstorm 13y agoHonestly, the only real data function I require on my phone these days is maps... Car GPS? The inexpensive ones cost about as much as a few months of data plan, and require no service contract.
- ImprovedSilence 13y agoNo. I despise turn by turn navigation. With the passion of 1000 suns. and sometimes I'm not driving, sometimes I'm just walking around a city looking for the nearest subway station. Granted, paper maps will get me 70% of the way there, and I do look at googles turn by turn readout, and view the entire route on a map. But I refuse to succumb to those shitty navigation systems. I want to look at a map, a suggested route, and make my own decisions on what course to take. Also without fumbling around for 20 min just trying to plug in a specific address when all I have is a general idea of the area I'm trying to get to. I don't even need gps on a phone, I usually know the general area I'm in, or I just use cell tower triangulation.
- sliverstorm 13y ago
- lechevalierd3on 13y agoDoes not it look fat to you ? I would expect such a phone to be much slimmer than today's smartphone. I do get that the battery takes space, but still. Wasn't the RaZor much slimmer ?
- Pxtl 13y agoHonestly, if I were getting a modern dumb-phone my top priority would be compactness and low-weight rather than battery life or build-quality. I'd want something absolutely invisible in my pocket, and any clever usage would go through a smart tablet tethered to it.
- lucaspiller 13y agoAny recommendations for a good dumb phone that can tether?
- pepsi 13y agoI had a Nokia 6790 "Surge" running Symbian that could do Bluetooth tethering.
- foxpc 13y agoFor such a "dumbphone", it seems to be kind of pricey, in my opinion. The camera sensor is probably the most expensive there :) For a seriously dumb phone, I'd go for a Nokia 100 or 101 (2 sim slots). It's got absolutely nothing - not any kind of web/wap accessibility, no front/back camera or a memory card slot. A resolution of a handsome 128 x 160 and a battery life of ~35 days. All for a price of ~20-40 bucks.
- cbhl 13y agoWhat I'm curious is whether it's $150 after subsidies or before subsidies. If it's the latter, then this phone could easily be offered as a $0 phone on a two or three year contract.
- wmf 13y agoYou know what else could be offered free on contract? An iPhone.
- cbhl 13y agoI thought they only did that with the two-generation-old-phones-that-they-want-to-get-rid-of-stock-of that they were selling for $99 off-contract.
- jonknee 13y agoThe oldest iPhone is still quite a bit more modern than a Series 40 Nokia. You can buy plenty of phones for cheaper.
- cbhl 13y agoAgreed, but I can access Facebook and Twitter over SMS. What does a "Modern" enable me to do? Type long emails with my thumbs, play Angry Birds, and eat up the battery by having a huge screen and GPS powered on all day. I bought a smartphone because it lets me check email when I'm sitting in lectures at university and I'm bored. I haven't really used my smartphone as a phone as much as its price would have you expect.
- heterogenic 13y agoI'm sticking with my MOTOFONE F3 (The "Zombie Apocalypse" phone: e-ink display and a 2-week battery life.) It feels like Nokia's missing the mark here though. Once you get below a certain threshold, you hit customers who are prioritizing price, simplicity, size or battery life. The Nokia 515 is pretty good on all of those, but not the leader on any. It's sort of the least dumb dumbphone, but not necessarily a great dumbphone. I don't quite know who this is for... but I sure wish they'd applied the same energy to optimizing for size or battery life in a beautiful container. Something that can fit in my smaller pockets and has a great antenna would be amazing as a "going out" phone, even if it only did voice & SMS.
- anigbrowl 13y agoAccording to the article, it has a 38 day battery life, which is more than double yours and as high as any phone that I'm aware of. I'm not sure what point you're making here.
- heterogenic 13y agoYes, I see that. However it is a few mm thicker, 50% heavier, 400% more expensive and 7 years(!!!!) newer. Imagine what they could do if they were actually optimizing on dumbphone strengths!
- stingraycharles 13y ago"They could've done even better" doesn't invalidate his argument, though.
- heterogenic 13y agoNo: they could've done different. As it is, it's sufficient in battery life but slightly larger and much more expensive. Close, but not worth upgrading for.
- rsync 13y agoExactly. Now, this same phone at 100mm x 44mm x 7mm ? I'll buy that today.
- jdcarter 13y agoHere's a GSM dumbphone that's $80 and runs on a AA battery: http://spareone.com/ http://spareone.com/
- RBerenguel 13y agoI carry around an Emporia Elegance, a phone designed for old people. Great battery life, no hassles. When this dies, I'll be getting this Nokia or some descendant
- AsymetricCom 13y agoIf it supports corporate Exchange and Tethering, I'm sold.
- pavlov 13y agoAccording to the product page [1], the Nokia 515 includes Mail for Exchange and does support tethering (Internet sharing) at up to 3.5G speed. [1] http://www.nokia.com/global/products/phone/515/ http://www.nokia.com/global/products/phone/515/
- AsymetricCom 13y agoNow I just have to wait for my contract to expire or have them buy it out..
- shitlord 13y agoI really wish more smartphones had some of the dumbphones' features: better battery life, better casing, etc. As much as I love my Nexus 4, the battery life isn't great and I'm always worried that I will drop it and the whole thing will shatter.
- sp332 13y agoI found the Lumia 900 to be the cure for both of these. Indestructible polycarbonate and pushing 2 weeks battery life. And the screen is great, I can even read my emails in direct sunlight. Edit: I realize it's no replacement for a Nexus 4, just pointing out that it's definitely possible to make a decent smartphone with different design parameters than Android or iPhone have been chasing.
- brazzy 13y agoWell, that big screen, fast multicore SOC and huge memory aren't powered by wishful thinking...
- radicalbyte 13y agoIf this can be used as a Bluetooth 3G modem for a phablet then it would be pretty useful. Big phablet for internet + emails combined with a small phone for voice. Plus the battery last more than 5 mins so it's useful for a festival :)
- deepuj 13y agoWas hoping for one without a camera. The camera ruined it. :(
- deepuj 13y agoWas hoping for one without a camera. The camera ruined it. :(
- bradleysmith 13y agoNice! I love high end dumbphones. Bad title though; this[1] is a much 'nicer' dumbphone I can buy. radicalbyte said what I was thinking exactly: this plus a Bluetooth modem (way to share data plan between devices) plus a big phablet/small tablet would be a badass professional setup. Battery life sells it for me, but not carrying my GPS-enabled google box everywhere with me would be pretty appealing too. [1] - http://www.aesir-copenhagen.com/ae-plus-y/ http://www.aesir-copenhagen.com/ae-plus-y/
- almondsays 13y agoI was interested until I saw that it starts at €7,250.00!
- hit8run 13y agoHow should one read HN on it? :D I often thought that it would be cool to have a feature phone that has extremely long battery life and a very minimalistic and thin design. I like their approach but I think it might be too expensive considering the fact that you can get a nexus4 for 199€ without contract here in germany.
- joeblau 13y agoIt looks nice, but I think it' a bit thick. I feel like they could have made something half as thick as the Razr.
- skrebbel 13y agoThat's roughly the same price point as Nokia's dumbest smartphone, the Lumia 520, which is significantly more fully featured. The point really must be simplicity, not price.
- lallysingh 13y agoIf you don't want a data plan, a 38-day battery life is damn appealing.
- nilkn 13y agoBattery life is actually my #1 complaint with smartphones by far.
- pearjuice 13y agoThe OS is not 14-year-old but actually the newest reiteration of S40 which has no problems running Whatsapp, native Facebook apps, Exchange support et cetera. It is not a dumb phone but a feature phone. The OS still has its raw edges here and there[0], but it is anything but old or dated. [0] I tried it for a week or so on a Nokia 301 and an example of a raw edge is that when using the music player and you accidentally remove the head phones, the music continues over the phone its speaker immediately. It should pause instead.
- meowface 13y ago>when using the music player and you accidentally remove the head phones, the music continues over the phone its speaker immediately. It should pause instead. Isn't this the case for a lot of devices? Every desktop and laptop I've used, on Windows and Linux, follows this behavior.
- stelonix 13y agoYeah, pretty much. I'd be pissed and amazed if the default was to pause the song. I don't want the device to try to figure out what I'm trying to do, I want the device to do exactly what I tell it to do, which, in this case, would be to simply do nothing. I just removed a physical cable, I don't need it to do anything on the software side other than make sure it updates the current audio output.
- sliverstorm 13y agoThe purist thing doesn't tell us much. You could equally as easy interpret things as, I didn't tell it to output music on another speaker, I only told it to stop outputting music on the headphones. Different people have different ideas of what the correct behavior should be.
- thisishugo 13y agoAlso, Android, iOS, and (if my memory serves) Windows Phone all exhibit the behaviour of pausing music on disconnecting headphones. Whether right or wrong, it is common and expected behaviour - doing differently (without good cause) is bad design.
- lygaret 13y agoAre there any dumbphones that have 4G hotspot tethering as a feature? I'm not that interested in all the extra stuff that comes in the smart phone package, but being able to tether my laptop or tablet is really useful to me.
- mfringel 13y ago+1 A "dumbphone that can make calls, send texts, and tether" would be pretty much perfect.
- pessimizer 13y agoWouldn't that kill the battery and nullify the major benefit of a dumbphone?
- lygaret 13y agoIt couldn't kill the battery any faster than a phone with a giant screen...
- davidu 13y agoSince it has a BL-4U removable battery, this will be the phone to get for those of you who are privacy conscious. It's unfortunate it has Bluetooth, but at least no Wi-Fi. I would have normally written "privacy paranoid" but it's clear that the spectrum has been lowered from paranoid to just conscious due to current realities.
- pearjuice 13y agoPrivacy conscious? When you first start any S40 phone, it will connect to Nokia servers and push certain data like your location. You wouldn't know because the OS is proprietary. They say this is for statistics but it could be anything. You can't start the phone before you aggree to this happening or before it actually happened. I have tried, really.
- davidu 13y agoThis is surprising. And unfortunate if true and unable to disable. Agree that the proprietary nature of the OS is a concern. An android or OSS OS would be preferred here.
- venomsnake 13y agoBut you can turn it really off. The moment you turn a phone on the whole world knows anyway. Or just the NSA if the fishnet order is still valid - the one with the metadata of all calls in the US.
- cmars 13y agoThere was some controversy [1] [2] about Nokia decrypting SSL connections for their accelerated browser. Not familiar with their platform, or whether you could remove them, but Nokia proxy certificates are certainly being trusted by default. If you're this paranoid, build one of those laser cut Arduino GSM phones instead[3]. You could add your own discreet baseband kill switch. [1] https://gaurangkp.wordpress.com/2013/01/09/nokia-https-mitm/ https://gaurangkp.wordpress.com/2013/01/09/nokia-https-mitm/ [2] https://freedom-to-tinker.com/blog/sjs/how-the-nokia-browser-decrypts-ssl-traffic-a-man-in-the-client/ https://freedom-to-tinker.com/blog/sjs/how-the-nokia-browser... [3] http://web.media.mit.edu/~mellis/cellphone/ http://web.media.mit.edu/~mellis/cellphone/
- Corrado 13y agoThe AARP should be sponsoring this, seriously. My parents would love to own this phone, or rather I would love for my parents to own this phone. They don't want or need a data plan. They don't want to play games or get stock reports. They just want an easy to use phone with big numbers and screen that they can see. Currently, they are using cheap, plastic phones with tiny little screens and complex OSes. They aren't durable, have poor battery life and have an appalling UI. I wanted them to upgrade to an iPhone just because its easier to use than the no-name phone they are using now. However, the iPhone has way too much capability and would more than likely confuse them. If this Nokia "dumbphone" can deliver a sturdy phone with a simple, streamlined UI I would get my parents one in a heartbeat. Pair it with a cheap phone only plan from T-Mobile or AT&T and my Christmas shopping is done this year. :)
- almondsays 13y agoHave you seen the Just5? http://www.just5.com/ http://www.just5.com/
- slantyyz 13y agoThey're not that very well built. My retired anti-tech, luddite, menu-fearing dad had plenty of trouble using the older, more squarish model.
- nilliams 13y agoWoah, the brick [1] is seriously cool (no irony), I would love to try one of those out. [1] http://www.just5.eu/brickred.php http://www.just5.eu/brickred.php
- vinhboy 13y agoI used to think like that too. But then one day I saw an older person who was really happy with the Note II. I think sometimes we over generalize, with good intentions, and make wrong assumptions about what the older folks want. I now think that they actually do like being connected, but they just need a bigger screen to work with. Which is why the Note II is a good option.
- at-fates-hands 13y agoIt's interesting to hear so many people still use these kinds of phones. Reminds of people who used to carry their palm pilots and their phones around with them. Hell, I used to be one. the Handspring Treo 270? Oh man I loved that phone!!
- acuozzo 13y ago> It's interesting to hear so many people still use these kinds of phones. Why? I do exactly two things with my mobile phone: SMS and calls. I primarily have it around for emergencies and, due to the nature of my work, I only have access to it for a few hours per day (that is, when I'm not at work). When I'm home I use my desktop computer and I often use my iPad for "portable computing". How would a smartphone serve me better than my LG VX9900?
- at-fates-hands 13y ago>>> Why? http://www.businessinsider.com/chart-of-the-day-smartphone-penetration-2013-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/chart-of-the-day-smartphone-p... "The U.S. added 31 million smartphone subscribers in the past four quarters. That represents a reacceleration of growth in U.S. smartphone penetration." "Overall, U.S. smartphone penetration stands at 58% of mobile subscribers aged 13 and above. That's up from 54% at the end of 2012." >>>How would a smartphone serve me better than my LG VX9900? Ever get lost? Do you travel a lot to other states/cities? Maybe its your first time in a city and you have no idea where a decent place to eat is. Ever want to check HN on the fly? Maybe get caught up on current news events or breaking stories? Ever wonder how your favorite sports teams are doing? Maybe you want to know how hot its going to be so you know what clothes to wear or if it's going to rain at 2pm or 3pm today. I can do all of these and more with my smartphone. Not sure you have that capability with your 9900. Although you do have a camera and can shoot video.
- acuozzo 13y ago> Ever get lost? Rarely. I use a GPS most of the time. > Do you travel a lot to other states/cities? Absolutely not. I try to spend as much time in my home as possible. > Ever want to check HN on the fly? No. > Maybe get caught up on current news events or breaking stories? Rarely. > Ever wonder how your favorite sports teams are doing? I hate organized sports. > Maybe you want to know how hot its going to be so you know what clothes to wear or if it's going to rain at 2pm or 3pm today. I wear blue jeans and a dark-colored button-down short-sleeved shirt year-round, regardless of the weather. I also keep an umbrella in my car.
- zokier 13y agoNokia has been claiming month+ standby times for a long time. There has been plenty of disappointed people when in reality the battery life is <1 week. http://developer.nokia.com/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=1255 http://developer.nokia.com/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=1255
- mingabunga 13y agoMy wife would love this, a stylish feature phone. She just wants text and calling, but all the phones out there like this are crappers. 38 days battery life is pretty awesome too.
- msoad 13y agoFor $50 more you can get a Nexus 4. Wow!
- YuriNiyazov 13y agoI recently experienced a really good reason to have a dumbphone. I was in the process of getting mugged. Someone was pointing a gun at me and telling me to give up my things. My hand was in my pocket, and I wanted to dial 911, but I couldn't, because all the smartphones nowadays have touch screen buttons.
- andyakb 13y agoIn almost all cases like this, your absolute best choice is to simply give them what they want and gtfo of there. If they see you playing with something in your pocket, it could escalate things very quickly
- hfsktr 13y agoI've often thought about "what if..." that smartphones would suck at that older phones were better at. Mostly if you couldn't see the phone (by being blinded or it's not in view). I do notice my phone has a small 'emergency call' button on the lock screen so that's a plus. I probably wouldn't notice it in a real emergency though (I can only imagine I'd panic and forget it).
- GigabyteCoin 13y agoYou're probably lucky you didn't get the chance to dial 911. Because after you did there was probably a 50/50 chance of the perpetrator injuring you further or running away.
- zokier 13y agoCould someone explain what's the idea behind Nokias longstanding strategy of flooding the market constantly with new models with very minor differences? Nokia 301 is almost identical with this new 515, and was released only 6 months ago. They seem to be releasing ten dumb/feature phones per year. I honestly don't feel like that approach results good quality end products. edit: Also what's with the aggressive market segmentation? Why aren't the models globally available?
- cbhl 13y ago> Why aren't the models globally available? Cellular standards are completely different in different countries, let alone on different continents. Your flagship smartphone might have a quintuple-band chip in it so that you can sell the same model everywhere, but most of these smaller devices only do two or three bands, where the antenna can be smaller / they can get away with using fewer of them.
- r00fus 13y agoThat's fine - but not all iPhone5's have the same bands either - still they're still called the "iPhone5" (with small ways of finding out exactly what model you have if you really care). They should call the model one thing and just have small variances in model that are descriptive (e.g.: MOTOFONE F3 vs. F3c - the latter is CDMA). Having random numbers with substantive differences in features that aren't "cumulative" just seems egregious and anti-consumer.
- cbhl 13y agoI've never paid much attention to model numbers when trying to buy a phone; for feature phones I usually just walk into the carrier-of-choice's shop, filter by form factor, and then look at which one has the right price point. Most of the time, a lexicographically larger model number means "bigger, better, and more expensive", which is enough of a heuristic if there are only ten models on display. Having lots of models at different price points seems crazy for Apple, but it makes sense for just about anyone else making cell phones. Flooding the market with tons of choices at different price points happens in everything else we buy, from CPUs to cereal boxes to jeans. Plus, if they change a part inside (say, update the CPU, or cut the RAM), the home-tech-support person in me would rather that they change the model number, than sneak in a nontrivial "Rev. 2" update. (This was a big deal with the WRT54G, when people were buying them and flashing custom ROMs that only fit in older models with more memory.)
- primelens 13y agoLooks like this can't do email. Is there such a thing as an otherwise dumb phone that can just do email (specifically Gmail)? I can live without all the other smartphone features, but email would be nice to have.
- wwweston 13y agoGmail works pretty well with all kinds of older devices. Up until last year I was using Gmail with a Nokia 6820 (an S40 phone from 2004). Arguably almost as good an experience as on the iPhone. :/
- mkr-hn 13y agoSo it's like my current phone, but with a touch screen and a decent camera? Sounds good. I could leave my 16MP pocket camera in the car and only have one device in my pockets. Smartphones never appealed to me. They're just bad enough at all the things I want to do with a mobile device to make it a poor value proposition. I'd rather have a nice tablet. Something like the Surface (non-RT) with a few more iterations.
- begriffs 13y agoThe best and dumbest phone http://www.johnsphones.com/store/johns-phone-business/item45 http://www.johnsphones.com/store/johns-phone-business/item45 Just a dial pad with a paper(!) phonebook that fits inside. Yum, it tickles my inner hipster.
- karma_fountain 13y agoMake it run spotify, have good sound quality, and wifi, and I'm sold.
- philip1209 13y agoA 38 day battery life and 2 sim ports? Sounds like a good company-provided phone for PagerDuty.
- Shivetya 13y agoSimple enough, even my parents wouldn't mind
- Eliezer 13y agoDear telecoms: Please give me a credit-card-sized e-ink-based phone which does nothing but send and receive texts and has a standby battery life of a week. Thank you.
- wffurr 13y agoDo you mean like this? http://www.amazon.com/Motorola-Motofone-F3-Dual-Band-1900-International/dp/B0013A7KMW/ref=cm_cr_pr_product_top http://www.amazon.com/Motorola-Motofone-F3-Dual-Band-1900-In...
- mellamoyo 13y agoI've actually owned that phone. It really, really does not work well, even for just calls. My battery life when using it was atrocious. Also, send/receiving texts was a very difficult task.
- magic_haze 13y agoAgreed. The battery life was surprisingly short, given the epaper screen and the lack of any features. The UI was a product of a completely deranged mind. The only way to get to some really common settings is to press dozens of random buttons, like game cheat codes. It doesn't even have the ability to sync the clock from the phone network, so I constantly had to reset the clock (!). The idea is good, but the implementation sucks badly in every single dimension.
- BCM43 13y agoHow would it alert you of texts?
- __--__ 13y agoWhat would that look like? The peek[1], but with an e-ink screen? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peek_(mobile_Internet_device) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peek_(mobile_Internet_device)
- drivingmenuts 13y ago