6 ms·
>>You know my old saying, "Slavery was never abolished, it was only extended to include all the colors." Some people balk at the idea of "wage slavery," primar
by enraged_camel 13y ago
>>You know my old saying, "Slavery was never abolished, it was only extended to include all the colors."
Some people balk at the idea of "wage slavery," primarily because they think it is so different from the traditional slavery that it should not be called that.
But the question is, if you are doing something and the alternative is starvation and death, are you really a free human being? If you think about it for a while, the answer becomes clear: you are not free. Sure, you have the freedom to switch from one slave-owner to another, but at no point in the process do you have real freedom.
- philwelch 13y agoThere's no state of nature where people are free from starvation without having to work. Even hunters and gatherers have to hunt and gather.
- teeja 13y agoFrom what I've read, the hunter-gatherers still on Earth have to work about 2 hours each day. For everything. Of course they don't have all the fancy toys. Or the worries and medications. Running away from an existence you've never really been given time to understand. Bukowski's right about how it empties you out. But unless you're lucky as him, few options have been left you. The land's all owned, and the "hunting" is long-gone. In the end, only the market is free. Until the day you drop it and turn away.
- tomp 13y ago> the hunter-gatherers still on Earth have to work about 2 hours each day That's because they live in low numbers in tropical climates, where food is plentiful throughout the year and shelter is never needed.
- dsbmac 13y agoThis is true but the work that they do, they or their families will benefit 100%. "Free labor". It is honest equitable work. The system in place siphons that labor by people who control capital. Income inequality.
- ritchiea 13y agoI agree that wage slavery exists but let's be serious, slavery in many societies, including the US was a brutal existence that included beatings & intentional separations of families, often even if you as a slave were compliant in the system. If you weren't compliant you were subject to torture and/or a violent death. The cruelty of slavery stretches far beyond the lack of freedom you're describing here.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- cgag 13y agoCall it whatever you want, you're still not free.
- adestefan 13y agoThe difference is that you have a choice.
- Everlag 13y agoOkay, you have an excellent point that modern slavery is a kinder, more gentle version. Now, instead of being beaten physically, you are gutted mentally via long hours and unreasonable schedules. Now, you "choose" to live away from the rest of your family because a job could earn you so much more money. Even the punishment has become more moral and more evenly applied to all to of course avoid discrimination. You are subject to mental assault by all others and even by yourself when you do not follow the game of the wage slave. A violent death? A violent death would be a needle prick relative to the 60 years you are expected to slowly break yourself in half. Indeed, the lack of freedom is but one facet, but honestly, while we have become more free have we really gained anything in terms of long term ability to do what we actually desire or be our own masters?
- rfnslyr 13y agoI have to disagree. Strong people will pursue their passion and find their ways. Weak people will succumb and be scared. It depends entirely on the person. Most people simply prefer stability, that's all there is to it. Not everybody has this amazing idea they are absolutely passionate about and prioritize above everything else. I just started working in a corporate environment. I'm the best at what I do. I work beyond hours. I also have a life. I can choose to go home and have a four hour game of thrones session, or I can invest my time into personal interests and developing myself. It's up to the individual entirely. We live in a world where we are capable of forging our own path. There is no lack of freedom, there is simply too much of it. > while we have become more free have we really gained anything in terms of long term ability to do what we actually desire or be our own masters? YES. You have all the resources at your fingertips. Institutions, counselling, meetups for specific interests, the INTERNET where you can communicate with anybody in a millisecond. It's up to you what you do with these powers. Will you be complacent, or will you use them to your advantage? It's sad that most people use our new found technological superpowers to bore themselves instead of learn about our beautiful planet and all it has to offer.
- sown 13y ago>But the question is, if you are doing something and the alternative is starvation and death, are you really a free human being? If you think about it for a while, the answer becomes clear: you are not free. Thomas Jefferson would have agreed with you. His idea of America was the idea that there would be many small farms where people could be more or less self-sufficient and work would have instrinsic meaning. Of course, he had actual chattel slaves to help out. Hamilton had the idea that the US would become a trading nation. By their time, the industrial-capitalist revolution had not really gotten underway world-wide but the Hamiltonians won out in the end. The notion of 'work' as we know it now had also not really come into existence. Most people in the US worked on farms or otherwise for themselves.
- dsbmac 13y agoLincoln agreed as well. He did not endorse wage labor for similar reasons outlined by enraged_camel. That man was no dummy concerning slavery. Lincoln advocated 'free labor' as the moral and honest form of labor. Which took as a given that labor is greater than capital. Its proceeds should benefit completely its worker and his family not siphoned by the few who have capital. Industrialization has made the workplace of the farm or workshop obsolete but I believe the principle could be maintained if workplaces were employee owned and managed democratically rather than authoritatively.
- Houshalter 13y agoYes but that definition makes the word so useless to include the vast majority of people that have ever lived through all of history. It also an attempt to bring a lot of connotations which simply aren't true. People don't use the word because they want to explain something the reader doesn't already know, they want to make the connotations that come with the word.
- jgross206 13y agoThe difference, to me, is that the lack of freedom you describe is simply a part of the human condition (food and shelter require work, which has been true as long as life has existed) as opposed to what you call "traditional slavery" which is man-made.
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>"traditional slavery" which is man-made. So is capitalism. So is the corporate hierarchy. Heck, the society we live in right now is man-made. Why does that matter as an evaluation criteria? Yes, food and shelter have always required work. The difference is that they have required work by the person for the person. Or by the person for their family. Or by the person for their tribe. This meant that you worked only as much was actually needed - i.e. subsistence - and no more. That is a very different set up than what we have now. The cost of healthcare alone makes subsistence living impossible.
- sliverstorm 13y agoThis meant that you worked only as much was actually needed - i.e. subsistence - and no more. You do know that in agrarian societies this meant 12 hours a day 7 days a week with no holidays ever? And that children worked in the fields instead of going to school? People don't subsistence farm because they don't want anything more than the bare minimum for survival. They subsistence farm because the bare minimum for survival is the best they can manage.
- enraged_camel 13y agoI'm not sure if your second paragraph necessarily leads from your first one. I have two questions for you that you should think about. Question 1: Why is it that, as our productivity increases, we find more things to "fill up" our workday, instead of working fewer hours for the same output (which would satisfy our needs)? Question 2: Forget about need. Do people actually want the things they are working for today? Or is it that we are socially conditioning them, from the moment they are born, that a consumption-based lifestyle is one they need to strive for?
- dvanduzer 13y agoIt's a loaded term, though. Regardless of whether you believe African-Americans are still experiencing the negative effects of slavery 150 years after it was abolished. The thing that is so particularly sinister: A: "Slavery was never abolished, it was only extended to include all the others." B: "You're right, so we should do away with affirmative action." C: "Exactly, it's racist since these days there are plenty of white people that are just as disadvantaged." D: "I hereby enact this law that officially ends affirmative action." E: "Great, now let's solve the nuanced problems of inequality across the board!" crickets
- LekkoscPiwa 13y agothe thought political correctness police is coming, sure that helps!
- dcraw 13y agoLife cannot be sustained without effort. Does real freedom entail freedom from the demands of reality? The question I have is, whose obligation would you say it is to provide a job that you consider good enough?
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>Life cannot be sustained without effort. In this day and age, sustaining life should not require 40+ hours of work per week. As a society we are producing a ridiculous amount of surplus, and then conditioning ourselves to consume that surplus so that we can produce even more. Where does it end?
- dsbmac 13y agoIt ends in global financial collapse. Then rises again! The US will gradually fade from dominance as every other leader before it. I wouldn't be surprised if we're witnessing it's decline right now. I don't see how it gets out of the major systemic mess it is in. Detroit, Louisiana, etc. is how it begins. A first world country bit by bit reverting to third-world status. Until some place has a successful anarchic-type revolution (a la Spain & Paris) without an outside power coming in to overthrow them we're stuck with this legacy economic/political system and the best we can do is civilize it with prudent regulation (which we can barely do because it's been systemically corrupted).
- mason240 13y agoI'm curious to know just how you think humanity will be able to feed, shelter, and entertain itself if no does anything.
- wwweston 13y agoIf literally no one did any work, then yes, we'd have trouble with this. However, most industrial societies, things are long past the point where most people would need to work full time in order to feed and shelter their populations -- we now employ a decided minority of the labor force doing those essentials. Apparently instead of reaping a leisure dividend, though, we've decided other things are more important. Perhaps some of them even are.
- chii 13y agoand why would those "minority of people" doing all the work agree to share their fruits with you (who is not working!)?
- Dylan16807 13y agoTaxes. They might complain but they still have 10x as much money as non-workers.