12 ms·
Dijkstra: “You will be treated as grown-ups”
- tel 13y agoI've been reading the EWD archives the last few months. I'm coming to find Djikstra to be a role model. I think I would do almost anything to have two hours of his undivided attention today.
- cschmidt 13y agoIn case you miss the link in the upper right, his EWD manuscript archive is here: http://www.cs.utexas.edu/~EWD/welcome.html http://www.cs.utexas.edu/~EWD/welcome.html
- evanmoran 13y agoReading these EWD manuscripts are the reason I believe Dijkstra's lectures would be life changing. A truly wonderful read. For most professors this format would be terribly difficult. It is hard to teach. It is hard to listen and understand where students are and take them further. Also, if I may, I'm struck by how similar pg's writing is to Dijkstra. Something about the rhythm of it and its directness.
- techboots 13y agolol, wow. The arrogance of this guy is amazing!! "I will allow you 2 hours of my time. If I like you, you get a good grade. My decision is final." This was the exact reason I avoided English classes in the first place - I didn't want some arbitrary person assigning me grades arbitrarily. AND, I don't want to play "teacher's pet!"
- rumbler 13y agoRead Dijkstra, read Dijkstra. He is the master of us all.
- ColinWright 13y agoFor those who don't recognise this reference, it is a paraphrase of Laplace, who said, "Read Euler, read Euler. He is the master of us all."
- stiff 13y agoAnd the irony is that Euler was a really poor mathematician by Dijkstra's standards...
- ColinWright 13y agoInteresting you should say that - do you have some supporting evidence? Could you point us at the material from which you draw that conclusion?
- Someone 13y agoI think the evidence is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonhard_Euler#Contributions_to_mathematics_and_physics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonhard_Euler#Contributions_t...: "While some of Euler's proofs are not acceptable by modern standards of mathematical rigour..."
- ColinWright 13y agoPerhaps Dijkstra would've understood that Euler was obtaining correct results while working in an era when mathematical rigor was (by modern standards) almost entirely absent. To appreciate Euler's work in context would almost certainly prevent one from considering him a poor mathematician.
- epo 13y agoWikipedia is "evidence"? Considering we are discussing Dijkstra, this is beyond irony.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoI try to treat my students the same way. The fact that almost no one does so makes it tough. Average high school kids have a tough time adapting to it. But when they do, as Dijkstra says, they become much more effective. Sometimes there is a group that gets it right away, and runs with it, but it usually takes some time. There are usually a few who think they are smarter than average (they usually are), that their intelligence will compensate (it rarely does), and that they don't need to make any extra effort. They usually figure it out after a semester. I also had a class mutiny once. I had a couple of intelligent, but spoiled and opinionated students who were vocally critical of my/this instructional style. There was also a larger than usual number of dullards in the class, who were easily led (by the dissenters). The self-nominated leaders managed to turn most of the class' attitude sour. That was the worst semester I've had yet. Everything became difficult. I had trouble maintaining my own discipline. The real trick that I would like to learn, is how to turn more of the middle and bottom tier of students into better students.
- 1123581321 13y agoWhat frustrates me as a student and sometimes teacher is that the role of even the most engaged student cannot be expanded to do the opposite of mutiny: engage the less able students in the class. Why is it that the relationship between an engaged student and a teacher is an individual one? Can the student become engaged with the class of which the teacher is a part? I believe this is the key to solving the problem you pose in your last sentence.
- brandonbloom 13y ago> Can the student become engaged with the class of which the teacher is a part? It's certainly hard. I love to teach & help, but most students don't view other students' input as collaborative or helpful. I've frequently experienced cases where a student asked a question and it was obvious (to me anyway) what that student was missing or misunderstanding. Then, it becomes obvious that the teacher doesn't understand the miscommunication. But if I step in to synchronize, such that neither party is speaking past each other, then the student views me as a know-it-all trying to show off and the teacher views me as trying to undermine his authority. Ultimately, I gave up trying to help unless I know both the teacher and the student personally.
- HarryHirsch 13y agoDijkstra describes when instruction at a university ought to look like. However, this requires an experienced lecturer and properly enculturated students, and where do you get them from if you haven't got them already? If I go too fast, it is your duty to slow me down Haven't we all met inexperienced TAs who mention the salient points but not what makes them salient, and when you call them out they hide behind their great self-confidence? If I give homework, I give you tasks of which I believe that working on them is very instructive for you I think everyone has had their share of ill-set or plain pointless homework at uni. I will not use the overhead projector A colleague had a student mutiny because he refused to put up his lecture slides for download. The students were complaining that they had to copy lecture notes from a friend if they didn't show up.
- dman 13y agoI honestly never understood the TA thing. Why not just reach out to the professor in their open hours or before / after the lecture?
- munin 13y agothis presumes that: - professors have open hours - professors can be found before or after the lecture - professors respond to your email - professors ever go to their offices
- PhearTheCeal 13y agoWhich is ultimately a presumption that the professor still cares about teaching after they have earned tenure.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoTenure schmenure, if you want profs who do interesting research, they'll need some time to tend to that research.
- HarryHirsch 13y ago
- gcb0 13y agoKnowing academics in a few countries, i can see how those notes are needed in the us. Students here are really passives and have weird expectations about course work. And teachers usually don't even show up at their classes leaving all the teaching to TAs.
- stiff 13y agoYou can see how well that worked out in practice here (video lectures by Dijkstra, not from any course though): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNCAFcAbSTg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNCAFcAbSTg and here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nHv5MUw7Nc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nHv5MUw7Nc
- nugget 13y agoWhy do we celebrate this theme of Professor as omnipotent, benevolent dictator of the classroom? My last year in school the combined cost of tuition, books, and room and board hit $40,000. At what point do you become not just a student, but also a fee for service consumer, with an appropriate set of expectations for some level of responsiveness and customer service?
- GuiA 13y agoSee, that's one of the problems I have with outrageous tuition: it creates dumb expectations from students. In most European countries, your education is quasi free, and as a result students don't complain about professors not providing "customer service". You go to the university to learn from some of the most eminent figures of your field, people who have devoted their life to it, and you do as they say. If you're not happy, well you can just leave. And sure, some of them are quirky or do dumb stuff, but you're 19- you'll live. And TBH, even the professors I had in college who exposed me to the most BS are nothing compared to some of the BS I've experienced in the real world, with clients/bosses/etc. If you're going to University of Phoenix, sure, feel entitled to some degree of "customer service". But if you're studying under Dijkstra, just suck it up and soak in as much as you can, even if the "customer service" leaves to be desired. Again, you're 19- you'll live. Sorry, this is a bit abrasive, but I've been on multiple sides of the equation (student in EU university, student in US university, TA in EU university, TA in US university), and the students who say things like "I pay tuition, I'm a paying customer, professors have to do X/Y/Z for me" are rarely the ones at the top of the class (and rarely aspire to do so).
- hypersoar 13y agoI have a professor at a large state school who taught a couple of large (i.e. multiple hundreds of students) calculus classes a few years back. He assigned homework, but didn't make it part of their grade. It was just practice (the homework was through an online system). Lectures weren't required. Lots of students get stuck in these classes who shouldn't be, and he felt that they shouldn't be forced to sit through lectures that were a waste of their time. He left it up to them to decide whether they needed the lectures or not. The result? Most of the students decided that they didn't need to do anything for the class aside from take the final exam. Most of them failed, including almost half of the engineering students (who, as a result, couldn't finish an engineering degree in 4 years), and there was a university-wide outcry.
- Shish2k 13y agoAnd lo, the students learned a lesson which will be more important to them in the real world than any amount of math would have been.
- MaxScheiber 13y agoI really wish I could agree with you. My gut tells me that a good number of the students that failed probably decided that it must have been because they're not good at math or engineering.
- chacham15 13y agoIm sorry, but if you think that you can NOT attend a class and do well, you deserve whatever grade you get. It is not the teachers fault for not forcing you to go to class.
- thrownaway2424 13y agoWell, I don't know. I had an upper division thermodynamic class where the professor was an admitted bad lecturer. He had two policies. One was if you had an A grade already based on the mid-term exam and weekly assignments, you need not take the final exam. The other was if your final exam grade was higher than your mid-term + homework, you get the grade from the final. I personally rarely attended the lectures and walked out with an A prior to the final. Friends of mine also did not attended, but passed the final exam. A number of people who regularly attended the lectures failed the class. From this experience I formed the belief that a university lecturer can actually be counter-productive to the students learning the subject.
- 10098 13y agoThis is the way we were taught pretty much every subject in our university. It doesn't work. What happens is, nobody studies anything during the semester (because nobody checks their progress), then there's a one or two week cram session before the oral exam, and after that you forget everything forever. P.S.: I'm not from US, in our country you could get education for free
- kenster07 13y agoJust because someone is brilliant does not mean they are a good educator.
- bryceneal 13y ago* If I am unable to find you in the classroom. I will proceed to search every adjacent desk recursively until I find you.
- clubhi 13y agoIt seems more cost efficient to just read one of this books and pay him $500/hour for private tutoring.
- soheil 13y agoI'd imagine almost any other 70 old year teaching a math class would pass around a very similar syllabus.
- vlasev 13y agoGreat person != great teacher. To be honest, if you watch [1] his lecture, he doesn't grab me as a good teacher. In fact I would probably fall asleep in his lectures. I've seen a lot of professors and how they teach during my undergrad and graduate mathematics education. It's not uncommon to witness a professor who has numerous awards for their research but who is awful as a teacher. It could be lack of motivation on their part for all I know. Dijkstra could be the very best out there in some matters but it doesn't mean we should take after his style of teaching. To be more specific, Dijkstra's organizational matters make him seem to me as somewhat cold and detached. Watching his lectures on youtube confirms this feeling. He also TEACHES in that way and frankly this is not the best way to get knowledge into students' heads. Nor will students ever feel like he really cares. Perhaps such a person will be more engaged if he teaches a graduate course with topics from his research but from what I've seen, this is not always the case. In fact, the worst course I ever had was by a professor with numerous awards, who's also great at giving presentations and talks, but who taught his research topics like absolute crap. [1]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNCAFcAbSTg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNCAFcAbSTg
- ColinWright 13y ago> In fact I would probably fall > asleep in his lectures. It's not his job to entertain you. It's his job to make the material available for you to study and assimilate, and to provide insight you would find difficult to gain simply by reading from a text. You falling asleep is your problem, not his. Everything you say sounds plausible, but a recent paper[0] shows that two teachers delivering identical material, one in an organized and engaging manner, the other disorganized and unengaging, received exactly the evaluations you'd expect, but their styles resulted in exactly the opposite. In particular, lecturer A was engaging and organized, and got excellent evaluations. Lecturer B was disorganized and unengaging. And yet in subsequent courses it was the students of lecturer B who went on to get the higher grades. Thinking someone is an excellent lecturer is not the same as being taught effectively. [0] HN submission[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6041803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6041803 [1] Direct link: http://www.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/scarrell/profqual2.pdf http://www.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/scarrell/profqual2.pdf
- kqr2 13y agoAre there any books or lecture notes for the class? It sounds pretty interesting.
- peterwwillis 13y agoIt's funny that he has to explicitly state that. It pretty much implies he knows they are not grown-ups. I imagine the average college student being scared shitless of interrupting the highly-esteemed professor to ask him wtf he's talking about.
- tokenadult 13y agoThe comments here are very illuminating about attitudes that some learners have to learning. Thanks to Colin for sharing the link. Some instructors here ask how to set expectations so that students will be ready to take responsibility for their learning and work hard before giving up. This is a problem that consumes my attention as I offer advanced mathematics lessons (a prealgebra course using the Art of Problem Solving textbook http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Store/viewitem.php?item=prealgebra http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Store/viewitem.php?item=p... for third, fourth, and fifth graders). Many American elementary school pupils are not used to challenging mathematics lessons. I have to establish expectations appropriately to have any hope of success in class. (And I have enjoyed some gratifying successes with many of my alumni over the years.) To inform parents (and their children) in advance about what my classes are like, I have prepared some FAQ documents about mathematics learning "Problems versus Exercises" http://www.epsiloncamp.org/ProblemsversusExercises.php http://www.epsiloncamp.org/ProblemsversusExercises.php "Repetition and Practice" http://www.epsiloncamp.org/RepetitionPractice.php http://www.epsiloncamp.org/RepetitionPractice.php "Links About Learning Mathematics" http://www.epsiloncamp.org/LearningMathematics.php http://www.epsiloncamp.org/LearningMathematics.php and "The Explorer is the Person who is Lost, or Courage in the Face of Stupidity" http://www.epsiloncamp.org/CourageandStupidity.php http://www.epsiloncamp.org/CourageandStupidity.php to help the learners get ready for the delight of taking on tough learning challenges. The last of the four FAQs is based on an inspirational speech given in various forms in various places by mathematician Paul Zeitz, a coach of the 1996 United States "dream team" to the International Mathematical Olympiad (IMO), still the only IMO team ever to achieve perfect scores among all six team members. His key word from his speech is featured prominently in the FAQ and in first-day-of-class messages I give live to all my new students. It is now the "inspirational word" for many of my students as they grow up into adult life.
- impendia 13y ago> 1996 United States "dream team" 1994 :)
- tokenadult 13y agoPast my edit window. Thanks for the correction. P.S. I do still have my edit window for THIS comment, so I'll add a (user-edited, alas) link to a description of the 1994 United States IMO team, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Mathematics_Competitions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Mathematics_Competitio... and a link with IMO results from 1994: http://www.imo-official.org/year_country_r.aspx?year=1994 http://www.imo-official.org/year_country_r.aspx?year=1994
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mathattack 13y agoHas anyone here had Dijkstra as a teacher? This note could be the intro to a phenomenal learning experience, or a pompous self-important jerk. Given his impact to the field, it could actually go either way. Can anyone here speak to personal experience with the professor?