8 ms·
If you only hire in the Valley, you don’t have the best talent
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- michaelochurch 13y agoDevil's Advocate here. Most Silicon Valley startups don't need top talent. They're marketing experiments with a small bit of technology and a lot of painful support work (due to massive, accumulating technical debt) that can only be done out of VC-istan dues-paying as young people take on pager duty for the job they think will get them investor connections in 6 months so they can do their own gigs (ha!) They need some flashy talent (young, clueless Ivy/Stanford grads) so they can tell investors that they bought a bunch of Ivy stock on the cheap. They don't need top talent. On the other hand, hungry talent (in a world where most people will never buy a house) and prestige-seeking talent and clueless/young talent are useful to them, especially if it congeals in one metropolitan area (such as Silicon Valley). The Valley's more than good enough for most of these firms. They complain about the "talent shortage". There isn't one. They're just complaining about paying more for talent than they think it should cost, and "what they think it should cost" is Dickensian. Of course, there are companies out there (if few) that demand extremely high levels of talent, but at that rarefied level, you're either (a) going to be small enough that you can do it within one location, or (b) going to ignore location outright, as OP suggests.
- coolsunglasses 13y ago"Dickensian" is right, I once knew a poor soul that were making 1/3 what I was in a startup. I've known several that were ~1/2. I'm not sure being full-stack really accounted for the full difference. Probably more to do with being viciously acquisitive and enjoying sales and negotiation. Also, I'm not working on the fashion thing anymore, thought of a better marketing experiment to try.
- michaelochurch 13y agoStartups will pay well if you know how to negotiate and have leverage, but if not, you'll get screwed. Usually the equity is pretty pathetic too. They're much more likely to exploit transient weakness than larger corporations, which have lower bounds on salary range as well.
- coolsunglasses 13y agoThe corporations benefit from stability more.
- LowKarmaAccount 13y ago> Most Silicon Valley startups don't need top talent. They're marketing experiments with a small bit of technology and a lot of painful support work (due to massive, accumulating technical debt) that can only be done out of VC-istan dues-paying as young people take on pager duty for the job they think will get them investor connections in 6 months so they can do their own gigs (ha!) The same thing is true about lots of Google (your favorite company) jobs. For many positions, they don't need brilliant people hacking Lisp, but rather they need competent Java or C++ programmers to make sure that their code base is "good enough". The result is that you get things like Google Calendar. What's wrong with Google Calendar? John McCarthy put it best: "Now of course Emacs is merely and editor but nevertheless is does permit significant user modifications and the modern operating systems do not. Let me give an example: one thing that I have done is to add a feature where you can put in a file, the name of another file and even also a location in that file. And then with a single key press it will search forward till it finds its file name and go to that filename in place. And I use it for putting references to email messages in my calendar file. That's just one of the uses of it and I asked about the new Google calendar file. Can you put a reference to email messages in there? And the answer is not only can't the user do it, but even the implementers can't do it, but to me anyway it's very useful. When I receive email about a meeting or a seminar, or something like that, to be able to put a link to the email itself into the calendar file and Emacs permitted me to do that myself, without my even having to become a real expert in the inners of it, and I think this will be important. " http://www.infoq.com/interviews/mccarthy-elephant-2000 http://www.infoq.com/interviews/mccarthy-elephant-2000 The quote is from clickbox 9. That page has a horrible layout.
- michaelochurch 13y agoThe same thing is true about lots of Google (your favorite company) jobs. For many positions, they don't need brilliant people hacking Lisp, but rather they need competent Java or C++ programmers to make sure that their code base is "good enough". Yeah. It seems that most of the large technology employers want to hire the best people to do middling work, ignoring the unhappiness that ensues when people are over-leveled for what they're asked to do. Closed-allocation needs to die in a fire, in other words.
- johnrob 13y agoYou often refer to something called "VC-istan". That name implies that the VCs have some sort of scam going on where founders/employees are the victims. Am I correct?
- colkassad 13y agoI've always understood that term as a play on Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, etc...i.e. implying a distasteful regime.
- michaelochurch 13y agoVC-istan is the hypothesis that the VCs and the companies they support function more like a postmodern corporate entity than a fleet of competing investors and companies. The name itself doesn't imply anything negative. "-stan" just means country. I could just as easily have called it "VC-land" but that sounds light. Of course, my view of the existing VC-istan is negative-- and the culture of co-funding and note-sharing is both unethical and illegal-- but there could be a good VC-istan.
- enduser 13y agoI am the sort of experienced full-stack hacker many Valley companies would love to have on their team. However, I like smaller cities, commuting exclusively by bicycle, having an enormous garden, eating locally grown food, easy access to amazing outdoor adventures, and mild winters. You'll probably never find me in the Valley or in the Boston or New York area. The bay area is too populous and northeast winters are terrible. No amount of money can change those things. Quality of life is worth more to me than high salaries. I do, however, like interesting work and brilliant coworkers. I mostly work with local businesses that are doing interesting non-high-tech stuff, like mass-custom lean manufacturing, but it would be great to have more options for working with people who know programming at least as well as I do. Working locally with people does seem to beat the isolation of remote work, however. It probably makes sense for a company focused on collaboration tools to have a team that relies on collaboration tools to function.
- spudlyo 13y agoCome to Seattle if you're not already here, sounds like it would be right up your alley.
- wavefunction 13y agoSounds like they're right where they want to be.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoSounds like they are already in Seattle or Portland, or somewhere international.
- chris11 13y agoColorado, specifically the Boulder area or even Denver, would also probably be a good fit.
- rdl 13y agoIf Seattle had a better investor population, it would be a no-brainer. That seems to be the key thing holding it back.
- nostrademons 13y agoI think most companies in the Valley would acknowledge this. The thing is - most companies are not looking for the best talent, they're looking to build the best teams. And one of the things that helps a team to gel is having all the members co-located together. It would be wonderful if the physical presence barrier was broken and you could setup virtual presences that were as efficient as physical ones, but something intangible seems to be lost when you only interact over e-mail. It works for GitHub because it makes the company a very incentivized user of their own product - they're developing for precisely the sort of organization that is their market, and so they understand their market better than if they acted like a normal start-up. But if they were playing in a fast-moving consumer market or trying to capitalize on a recent platform or innovation, they'd get eaten alive.
- ryanSrich 13y agoI know you pointed out github but I'd have to disagree about the physical part for consumer facing markets. I'll point to Fictive Kin[1] and 37signals[2] as just two very successful examples. 1.) http://fictivekin.com/ http://fictivekin.com/ 2.) https://37signals.com/ https://37signals.com/
- nostrademons 13y ago37signals is B2B2C: their primary market is small businesses. I'd never heard of Fictive Kin before, and a quick Google doesn't turn up anything other than their website, where it looks like they're more of a consultancy than a product.
- ryanSrich 13y agoFictive Kin invented Gimmebar[1] among other products. 1.) https://gimmebar.com/ https://gimmebar.com/
- rdl 13y agoAutomattic (Wordpress) is probably the canonical b2c distributed team example (although I think they make more from b2b sales of WP:Enterprise)
- kasey_junk 13y agoNot that I disagree with the sentiment or to rag on GitHub or their management (I think they have a nice product). But this article is simply quoting the CEO of a small company that has been around for very little time. Is the Valley so insular that they think this is truly a management success or is this just a terrible article?
- jusben1369 13y agoI'm not a huge fan of the Valley having lived there for a long time and moved away however.......what the Valley does really well is understand very quickly when something new and revolutionary is afoot. That's the difference between picking the next 100 bagger or being a sheep. Github is a rapidly growing company hiring some of the best talent globally in a game changing way - and so far it's going against all the "common perceptions" about how you build and scale out a startup. I'd say watch this space closely.
- Aloha 13y agoThe experiences I have had in the Valley have led me to call it "The Valley of my Discontent"
- jacques_chester 13y agoThe Valley does this by assuming that everything is new and revolutionary and forgetting that almost nothing is. The hits are remembered, the far more numerous misses are forgotten. That's why it works at all. If the Valley was stocked with grumpy curmudgeons like me, there wouldn't be a Valley.
- ilaksh 13y agoYou aren't giving Github nearly enough credit for their importance today. Sure, they haven't been around long, and they might not be so critical in 5 or 10 years, but at the moment Github is arguably the most important internet company in terms of the number of other startups and established businesses that are completely dependent upon them. Yes, of course we can all move our repos to Bitbucket or wherever, but currently there are tens or probably hundreds of thousands of the most innovative companies relying on their product. It won't be a minor inconvenience if Github goes away. Tom Preston-Werner is a very influential leader. Aside from Github and other projects, he is also the author of Semantic Versioning, which has played a significant role in the success of Node.js and its standing as the most advanced system for modular server-side development.
- oxtopus 13y agoI think the title of this is a bit misleading. The message is much less about "the valley" and more about building a culture around geographically distributed collaboration.
- zura 13y agoThe goal is to get shit done, not necessary with the best talent.
- dotBen 13y agoPost ends with "While talent may be distributed everywhere, that kind of serendipity is the most concentrated in Silicon Valley." Um...
- cliftonmckinney 13y agoWrote a relevant blog post about this issue not too long ago. The article states the obvious of course. Talent isn't evenly distributed, but it is distributed. What's most compelling for perhaps Valley and New York companies only, is the wide disparity with regard to compensation: Two Silicon Valley startups raise $1M and they each have need for a great team. Team One is on site. They spend a lot of otherwise productive time attempting to hire great engineering talent away from other equally impressive startups in the area. They pay $150k per person (let's call it $200k fully loaded) for talented, but not phenomenal people. Team Two is fully distributed. They decide to hire the best, no matter where they are, and at $150k per person everyone outside of Silicon Valley gives them a look with much less effort on their part. They save time, they save on office space in SV, and, best of all, they build a team of truly phenomenal folks who are happy to be making $150k, because it's likely $50k higher than they were making at whatever job they had before they got recruited. Assuming you can build a better team in the Valley is only relevant if you have a reasonable expectation that you'll find similarly talented folks at the same price no matter where you are. That is simply not the case. More on the blog: http://blog.workforpie.com/2013/06/04/the-case-for-remote-work/ http://blog.workforpie.com/2013/06/04/the-case-for-remote-wo...
- hawkharris 13y agoI've heard that the costs of living are very high in California. Is actual compensation much lower when you take this into account?
- krichman 13y agoBut that's part of the point, isn't it? If SV companies need to adjust for cost of living in SV, the same salary could attract a better employee in an area where adjustment is not so necessary.
- cliftonmckinney 13y agoSan Francisco is 1.85x what it costs to live in, say, Nashville, TN. http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=salary+comparison+Nashville+vs.+San+Francisco http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=salary+comparison+Nashv...
- ilaksh 13y agoI think that the chat room seems obvious but it is not to a lot of older managers and it is very important. I have worked with some (generally older) developers who just didn't have online communications skills and even refused to use a shared chat room. They might be seemingly able to exchange a few emails or IMs, but then the next week they would be busy, stop using emails/IMs, but the day you go into the office or call them suddenly the communication increases 10-fold. Or they did it but didn't know how to use it. I.E. they would spread the chat out into many many rooms and fill them with irrelevant design speculation and idle chat.
- apinstein 13y agoGitHub is a pretty amazing company and story. Their culture, the tools, etc are all very inspiring, and the whole community definitely benefits from their experiments. This meme always gets me thinking about how to attract the best talent for our company. That said, holding them up as a model of how to build a tech team never quite feels like a good idea. GitHub is a developer product, built for developers by developers. That essentially makes all of their employees domain experts in the product as well. They can also robustly dog-food their product. Both of those factors in my opinion make it much easier to have a successful distributed team. They can trust everyone to make good decisions absent a strong product team. I've worked at 5-6 different startups with varying levels of distributed teams and never felt that distributed communication of product, architecture, etc was ever as productive as with the co-located teams. Trying to involve the remote people always felt like "extra work" and it wasn't a smooth process. I would be very curious to hear from non-developer product companies about their successes (or failures) with remote teams. Are new tools like Google hangouts, shared whiteboards, and github really enough to allow you to have a productive product/engineering team?
- ilaksh 13y agoDid you have a shared chat room and use it?
- apinstein 13y agoWe have tried that for the local team but it didn't get used despite trying 3-4 different chat tools (IRC, HipChat, I forget the others). People end up talking in person b/c it's easier.
- ilaksh 13y agoLOL why didn't you try it for the remote team??
- apinstein 13y agoAt the time I had lots of remote teams, those tools didn't exist. This is why I'm asking for counter-examples. The few times I have done remote teams it has always devolved into the expected problems. I want a non-GitHub example of someone that makes it work.
- bdcravens 13y agoIrony is that this is coming from a San Francisco based, VC-backed media site, of which most of their writers (kinda assuming this based on their staff list) are located in SV.
- drawkbox 13y agoLove this. Talent is all over the world. This is also why companies of the old style, non virtual offices, have multiple offices in some aspects. New, distributed companies, such as github, 37 signals, small game companies etc, they will always have the best employees and even if an employee moves they are still actively on the team. For some industries like games, it might be the only way to gather all the people and skills needed as especially with games it is hard to find people in the same area with required skills. Virtual teams lead to much less disruptive change to a team which leads to stronger teams. But like it is stated, all important communications need to be virtual and through that channel first, it will fail otherwise and some can't do it. The world is big, cities are big, why destroy competitive success because it is to hard to coordinate? Traffic, moving, costs (living/goods/travel) are all better suited for easy access and ultimately company survival with virtual teams. The absolute best thing about virtual teams is it is all about delivery and getting things done. Minimizing BS, time wasted and shipping product. Virtual teams can come together for integrations, planning, celebrations and be as strong or stronger as physical logistical teams. It doesn't work for all industries but in technology/creative it can truly free up people to focus on work. How many offices have you worked at that after a while actual productive work hours go down to 3-4 due to all the excess stuff, then you have to work at night or after hours just to keep up with all the wasted time at the office and travel and general life that pops up. Virtual team are delivery first and that is the right way to be productive.
- chaz 13y agoI feel like developer-heavy organizations would be more successful at this. A major factor is the tools facilitate a lot of the communication (commit messages, bug tracking, build notifications, documentation, etc.). They're also comfortable using tools and generally adapt quickly to new platforms. And in my own personal experience, it worked with their personalities. I'd like to hear more examples of this working successfully at scale in highly-cross functional teams, with distributed marketing, sales, design, support, and product groups. Communication always seems to be a complaint at companies, and I'd like to hear more about how this was addressed.
- SeoxyS 13y agoThis is somewhat off topic; but I have to say I am quite disappointed by the way in which PandoDaily puts out its events. I was quite looking forward to seeing Tom talk; so I got my first PandoMonthly tickets. The event started at 6, with the talk scheduled to start at 7. I only really cared about Tom, not so much networking, so I showed up at 7. Made it there by 7:01, only to be greeted by a bouncer that told us that they had just closed the doors. They were instructed by PandoDaily not to let anybody in after 7. When we mentioned that we had paid for tickets; we were told "too bad." PandoMonthly, from this experience alone, is already the worst event I have ever seen put on. Way to tell your customers "fuck you."
- megablast 13y agoIf the talk started at 7, it would be rude to arrive anything later than 6:50. I think this is great, blocking people at 7. There is no other way to get things running on time and without disruption.
- moremonkeys 13y agoI've done both and I have to say distributed is guaranteed to win in the long run. In my last venture we had the Palo Alto office on University Ave, and I've walked a few miles up and down SandHill Rd, so when I say distributed works I'm contrasting it against past experience of trying to hire developers, architects and (worse) project managers in SV. The challenges raised above in many of the comments about "being within shouting distance" and "eye contact" - together with the fear of distributed workers being passed over for promotions because of their lack of water cooler time - goes away when the ENTIRE team is distributed. In a situation where the "core team" is within a fun, social campus and George is working from Seattle in his bunny slippers then it is very difficult to convince the in-office workers not to have chats over their cubicle walls and innovate during lunch on the bean bag chairs. Using the collaboration platforms like GitHub and Basecamp becomes a pain in the ass to them. But, when EVERYONE is distributed, then a lot of that goes away, and we've found adoption and proficiency with Google Hangouts (wired or WiFi, sorry) and all the other tools go way up. In our current team for Infinite Monkeys[1] we've built the entire venture with funding from founders and SV sources, but a team that is purely distributed using over 200 contractors through oDesk[2], literally on six continents. It has allowed us to move beyond "hiring the best people who coincidentally live within 30 miles of San Mateo" to just hiring the best people. And so we have designers in Bulgaria, developers in Spain and India, marketers in Singapore, a bookeeper in Mauritius and a PR Lead in Michigan. It has allowed us faster release cycles and massive savings in our GoToMarket burn. There are still challenges no doubt, and the fact is building this kind of startup even 36 months ago would have been almost impossible, but tools like Google Drive, oDesk, GitHub and Hangouts, I think are making it possible. We have replaced the water cooler with 15five[3] (ironically a SFO startup) - asking each team member to write a 15 minute shared report of what went well this week, what challenges there are, and what ideas they have for improving the business. I'm getting better feedback now through my distributed team than I ever did with our hub and spoke teams before. Lastly, and only because it hasn't been mentioned above, but I think another example of a long-term distributed company that has done it well is Mozilla. Say what you may about their products and direction, but the fact is their developer base is massively distributed and has been for years. [1] Infinite Monkeys - www.monk.ee [2] oDesk - www.oDesk.com [3] 15five - www.15five.com