10 ms·
Flickr's redesign makes it a photo service actually worth sharing
- chuhnk 14y agoThis is the second coming of Flickr, a rebirth, and I couldn't be more excited. I'm not a power user of Flickr but a fan of what it once was back in the day. It was a real shame to see it be neglected after the acquisition but Marissa Mayer has arisen as it's saviour and beyond that the saviour of Yahoo. For anyone of us it was blatantly obvious how powerful Flickr was and how it could have continued to dominate the photo sharing social scene. For some reason Marissa's many predecessors failed to see this. Honestly, if utilised in the right way, Flickr is a Facebook killer. At the core of Facebook is it's photo sharing service, take that away from them and it's nothing but useless news items from people you wish you could block.
- danso 14y agoI'm as quick to dismiss re-skinning as any self-righteous dev, but this really hit the spot for Flickr. Flickr has always had a trove of useful photo archiving and categorizing features...sometimes I upload photos just because their geocoding editor is so convenient to use. Many of the other major photo services lack even simple group creation of photos (I.e. having a single photo endpoint both be in your "Family memories" and "Summer Vcation" albums)...and Flickr is by far the best in terms of making it easy to discover old, but significant photos. This is not to say that this means Flickr will survive against Facebook, anymore than quality point and shoot pocket cameras have a chance of revival in our camera phone era. But Flickr, for now, definitely has the edge in quality and variety of photos. Even if you think Instagram filters are the best thing ever, the laws of physics (I.e. optics) limits the vast majority of their photos to a narrow range limit. It's worth pointing out that Google Plus has had a better photo album design than Flickr for awhile now...I just tried them out (again) and saw that they, for the most part, have most of what makes Flickr useful. However, Gplus is decidedly focused on social sharing...it's hard to describe how this drastically impacts its use as a photo service...but using GPlus's photo feature was, for the first time in a long while, that I've just given up in frustration in the first five minutes. But this may be just a sign that I've finally hit old age.
- chuhnk 14y agoYou make some valid points. I was not aware of the Google+ photo album design but then again I was only a user when it was mandatory within Google. I don't personally know anyone outside of Google who uses it. Quite a few public figures have accounts but none of my friends are on there. Google+ feels like a very closed community. I've never seen anyone share links to albums on there whereas someone is always passing around a Flickr, Twitter, Facebook, Imgur or Dropbox url. Flickr is almost 10 years old. They've been around longer than anyone right? It only makes sense that they would have one of the most mature products relevant to people who want to maintain thousands of photos and share them. I think we'll see a lot more interesting features for Flickr over the next year as social and mobile becomes a bigger priority for Yahoo.
- bdowney 14y agoNot sure if you're trolling. Google+ has never been mandatory within Google. There's plenty of people at Google who despise Vic Gundotra and don't want to have anything to do with G+. On the other hand, there are very active and vibrant communities in Google+, perhaps you should try looking them some time.
- saraid216 14y agoYou seem desperate to find reasons to dislike G+, so I'll help you out: https://plus.google.com/communities/101451257802046158545 https://plus.google.com/communities/101451257802046158545
- chuhnk 14y agoOh I have nothing against G+ personally. I just don't use it and none of my friends do either. If there was a significant level of activity on there or better content discovery then perhaps I would use it.
- saraid216 14y agoDid you actually click on the link and look at the timestamps, or are you just blowing smoke?
- adriand 14y agoAnother awesome thing about Flickr is how good its API is. If you look around for web apps and mobile apps that do something interesting with photos, they're almost always built using Flickr's API, for good reason: it's likely the most open, easy-to-use, well-designed API for photos out there.
- beat 14y agoTo be fair, I think of Facebook more as a good microblogging platform than photo sharing. Unless more has changed than I expected, Flickr will still suck for that.
- chuhnk 14y agoIs it really though? I wouldn't necessarily classify it as a microblogging or photo sharing platform. It's a good old fashioned social networking service which revolve around the world of profile pages. Early on they introduced photo albums and it became huge for photo sharing with your friends. At the end of the day Flickr is about one thing, photos, and it needs to stay that way. Yahoo bought Tumblr, an actual microblogging platform, that's their way into the big social game.
- analog 14y agoIt is pretty nice but navigation between photos still feels a little clunky. I'd have expected the 'next' and 'previous' arrows to slide/load in the pre-loaded image rather than generating a full page refresh. Still very nice all in all though and a terabyte of free space makes it an easy choice for the default place to store all your photos. Goodbye iCloud for me.
- danso 14y agoFWIW, yesterday I saw a "fail whale" page on Flickr for the first time ever (though it was of a baby panda). I don't know if that's a consequence of infrastructure changes or increased traffic...I don't think it's the latter but perhaps the increase number of fetches on each normal page load is causing a burden. Also, the simple prev/nav between single photos has always been unacceptably slow...hopefully that gets fixed, as that's also kind of key to the viewing experience
- noloqy 14y agoWith this new move, it seems that Flickr has made a turn towards the domain of 500px.com, also known as providing a stylish way of showcasing your photos. 500px actually used to have a design that was almost an exact match to what Flickr has now, and still looks remarkably similar.
- robotmay 14y agoI launched the beta of my own photo sharing site a few weeks back and the new Flickr design is somewhat similar in parts (flexible width/tiling photos). It seemed logical to me to adopt a Pinterest style grid for varying size images, rather than cropping them all to squares, though I notice that Flickr's design works more in terms of rows (https://www.flickr.com/search/?q=nature https://www.flickr.com/search/?q=nature) than columns (https://photographer.io/categories/nature/photographs https://photographer.io/categories/nature/photographs). I'm very curious as to which style people find the easiest to browse.
- nicholassmith 14y agoI think one of the interesting bits of info to bubble up since the redesign was launched was they said mid-March was when they geared up and went for it. Even if they had bits of it done they did a great deal in a small time frame and made massive improvements, and it's a great sign for Flickr because they've got room to get better. I was a paid up Flickr Pro user for a while, and I actually let it expire this year as I'd decided it wasn't going anywhere but this has really got me interested again. Seems like Yahoo understands the potential value of Flickr, it might not compete against Facebook in terms of raw numbers and standard phone camera photos but there's potential to get the serious enthusiasts back.
- tonylemesmer 14y agoI like the new Flickr. Its made me want to use it again. Both for the large amount of storage, the new Android app and the website. I've not had time to fully try everything out yet. Facebook's dominance may mean its too little too late except for the crowd who detest using Facebook (myself included).
- varjag 14y agoOK, coming from a regular user: - Your updates and activity entries are now mixed with other people's photos. That the photos are humongous and your updates are tiny one-liners doesn't help. You have to eye-grep and scroll the infinite image feed all the way to the bottom. - At the same time, the right bar is occupied with such immensely useful things as "Flickr Blog", "People you may know" and a patch of empty space. - Portrait orientation photos are disadvantaged in the feed layout. - The documentation is not updated! It took me some time to find how to share BBCode in the new layout. - Flickr is no longer Safe for Work! If any of your contacts posts a nude image, instead of tiny thumbnail it gets blown into all its high res goodness.
- e40 14y agoI think all of this is to compete with G+.
- cowpewter 14y agoI don't like the intermixing of photos and activity either, but you can get to a feed of activity only by mousing over the You menu in the top left and choosing Recent Activity, or go directly to http://www.flickr.com/activity http://www.flickr.com/activity Regarding the SFW issue, I know Flickr has safety levels on photos...if you go to http://www.flickr.com/account/privacy/ http://www.flickr.com/account/privacy/ there's a Content Filters section, but it's not clear if it would apply to your Contacts photostream or only searches/viewing another member directly. The setting says: Choose a "safety level" that will apply to any site-wide searches you perform or member pages you visit on Flickr. You can also set the sort of content you'd like to see.
- tathagata 14y agoThe design might be modern but it is very distracting. The photos are surrounded closely by so many other photos that it is difficult to enjoy the beauty of a particular photo - it like a painting framed by a gold gilded frame which is more beautiful than the painting itself. Photography is an art form but in this new layout the art is overwhelmed by its 'evil' cousin, design.
- corresation 14y agoThe photos are surrounded closely by so many other photos that it is difficult to enjoy the beauty of a particular photo On the "feed" screen, sure, because that's the point of a feed screen -- information density is key. You navigate to a specific photo for immersion.
- TelmoMenezes 14y agoYes, but is it really necessary to have a feed screen in everything? There's already Facebook and Google+ for that. Flickr was nice because it was geard towards the less ephemeral. I guess "less ephemeral" goes against the zeitgeist.
- corresation 14y agoBut it is a feed of contact photos. The presentation makes sense. With the flickr redesign (and, more importantly, the massive speed up of their backend servers), I've looked at dramatically more of my contact and group photos in the past two days than I did in years prior combined. It makes it so pleasant and effortless.
- philwebster 14y agoAgreed. I also miss being able to see photo titles for all of the displayed pictures. Now, in order to view the title, you must mouse over the photo which is a tedious task when there are hundreds of images.
- antr 14y agoAs a former active Flickr user all I can say is that I have gone back to the product, big time. I have ditched iPhoto as my archiving software and moved my +150GB of photos and videos to Flickr. I couldn't be happier. I'd also like to note that I share zero photos with the public, all my photos are 100% private or shared with family members/close friends. Having said that there is plenty of improvement to go: - iOS app (maybe it is also the case for the Android app) needs to improve (auto upload, better integration with iOS, etc). Recently I went on holiday and only used my iPhone to take pictures (over 5GB), it would be nice for an easier way to tag + create/add to set + upload photos and videos. By the way, where is the tablet app? - Video is really really bad. Apparently Flickr doesn't support long video playback (and by long I mean 10 seconds or more - i think). Now a days (specially with smartphones) video is a big part of albums/experiences. Video needs to be permitted and nicely integrated within photo albums. - Upload via web is nice, but a better Mac/Windows/Linux native app would go a long way for power users. Better upload resume, tagging, etc. - Map view. Something is wrong with the new Flickr, it has a world map view, but it doesn't read/process any geo location from my pictures - unlike iPhoto which does this flawlessly. I need to drop one by one the photos into the map for these to be processed. I also have to say that the Nokia map could be better, I'd love to see Flickr using Google Maps. Has someone experienced this same thing? - Better album sharing, a la Dropbox, would be great (e.g. allow friends and family to download an album as *.zip) These are just a few things I would like to see in the coming updates.
- chuhnk 14y agoJust to address the Video issue. I think Yahoo knows this is a general problem for them and it's probably the next on the list of things to address. I have a feeling it's going to come in the form of a Video service acquisition that will then tie into Flickr and other services rather than trying to improve on Flickr's inadequacy. Although I hear you when you say that videos need to be permitted in albums.
- antr 14y agoI thought the same thing as you did: Yahoo needs a video acquisition. Maybe that's where the failed DailyMotion acquisition came in. I think Vimeo is the perfect fit for the new Flickr, but good luck buying that from IAC.
- josephlord 14y agoWhat are the privacy/access controls/sharing facilities like? Are the terms of service and privacy policy OK? A convenient way to store online and share selected photos and videos would be good. I don't trust FB/Google with images of myself and my family or my geo-tags. I would automatically be similarly sceptical of Yahoo bet a quick glance at the main TOS didn't show anything obviously objectionable.
- Terretta 14y agoFlickr even offers geofencing that will prevent people from seeing any geotags within zones you mark out.
- theshrike79 14y agoWhat drove me to flickr as opposed to other places years ago was the detailed access control it offers. I can have public photos, photos of family events and pictures from drunken escapades on the same account and I can reliably and easily have just certain people have access to them via guest passes.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pessimism 14y agoI wrote a thing about how your favourites are public and searchable with not opt-out on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5756487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5756487. Other than that, Flickr is one of the most privacy-conscientious services I know—which is why it took me by surprise that there weren’t controls for my favourites. Flickr’s (general) emphasis on privacy and ownership rights are their main features to me. Maybe those are just hold-overs from the early days when monetizing your users’ data weren’t in vogue, though.
- josephlord 14y agoThanks, your link is to this topic though. I think you meant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5751591 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5751591 I've also asked a question on that topic.
- dabeeeenster 14y agoAnyone know of a decent way to sync a set of photos in folders with Flickr? Mac or Linux...
- sagarun 14y agoOn Linux, there is a photo app named shotwell. shotwell has a flickr plugin that works like a charm
- liotier 14y agoNarcissism aside, why did they drop the view counts ? I used to find them useful to see what people actually look at and therefore which of my pictures work and which don't. Comments and 'likes' are good, but only view counts are honest.
- antr 14y agoI still see view count, under user avatar > "Taken" > Location > Device/Camera
- djloche 14y agoFor reference: http://www.flickr.com/photos/yourusernamehere/stats/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/yourusernamehere/stats/ should provide you with what you're looking for (although it may be a paid feature, I am not sure as I have been paying for flickr for years now...)
- habi 14y agoStats are only available for (new and old) paying members
- insteadof 14y agoThat's a Pro feature. You couldn't get stats on the free plan. And it seems, you can't get stats on their new replacement plans either. So far it looks like if you want stats, hope you're grandfathered in as a Pro user and keep on renewing.
- pydanny 14y agoWhat I don't like about the new Flickr is that if you look at single photo, it's presented on a black background. While this is stylish, it's also feels distracting. I miss the white background.
- ekr 14y agoEven with its new design, I find it surprisingly primitive. I don't have an account, but if i try to watch a set from some user as a slideshow, I have no option to scale the picture to my screen size (or at least no obvious way of doing it). Furthermore, when I rightclick, I get a list of sizes, but those links only embed a full-size picture into a new page. How useful is that. Anyway, needs lots of improvements. On an unrelated note, I am planning to make a backup of all my ebooks there, by storing them as pictures (something like https://github.com/meltingice/flickr-store https://github.com/meltingice/flickr-store, but better).
- tonywebster 14y agoI must be the only one who doesn't like Flickr's redesign. Sure, there's some good benefits from it, but... - The lines and colors are harsh - The grids on the single image view separate the page in non-equal thirds which feels awkward - A lot of the data elements just run together without labels or any indication that they're links: http://i.imgur.com/Szy3Y7Z.png http://i.imgur.com/Szy3Y7Z.png - In 2013, I'm a bit shocked that the site isn't responsive, even if they do have a good mobile app: http://i.imgur.com/OMiqoZs.png http://i.imgur.com/OMiqoZs.png Everything else is okay, but only because they didn't actually redesign the majority of the site. Go to your groups, stats, etc. and you still see the nicely organized old Flickr. I'm a fairly active user and usually a big fan of redesigns and changes, but I don't see myself using it much now.
- aeturnum 14y agoThe reactions on the Flickr forums are heavily weighted against the redesign as well. There are lots of little problems I noticed (the links to fullscreen images on my feed would fullscreen a different image - fixed now), and hopefully they can run the problems down over the next few weeks. I'm equally aghast that their mobile website hasn't changed - come on guys. Overall, though, I really like it. I think it's a much more attractive public face.
- maximem 14y ago/almost off topic/ I love the history Flick'r! Back in 04, made for gamers... A brillant turn over induced by users misusing the website uploading their holidays photos... A lesson to keep in mind, always listen to your customers!
- thomaslutz 14y agoWhat is the best tool to move all my photos from my local harddrives (unorganized currently) to Flickr in an easy way?
- spiek 14y agoProbably a photo editing app. Adobe Lightroom has a Flickr plugin and I think a 30 day free trial. Import everything into Lightroom, and then set up the Flickr plugin, and then push everything to your account.
- junto 14y agoFlickr Uploadr works for me: http://www.flickr.com/tools/ http://www.flickr.com/tools/
- pavs 14y agolast update in 2009... And I have tried uploading, its not convenient at all. I have switched to google+ auto backup cause, I don't care about super high resolution since I am not a photographer and my upload speed sucks, I don't have to worry about manually uploading (though its also possible and very convenient). I just set it and forget it, it works in the background. The UI is very very nice, probably the best out there at the moment. If flickr continues to make minor tweaks and comes in par with google+ photo looks and if my upload speed ever improves then I might consider moving to flickr. I am still a paid flickr member since 2007.
- Groxx 14y agoAs I mentioned elsewhere[0], I've had lots of problems with their Mac uploader. I'd heartily recommend sticking with the web upload until it's updated, or using some third party tool (if you have tons, this might be the best option - web is limited to 200 at a time, not resumable if something goes wrong). [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5758033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5758033
- rkuykendall-com 14y agoI was a huge Flickr user from 2006-2009, but the service stayed in 2006, and so I moved on. The new changes are very exciting, but I still have one huge gripe. For a service about to turn 10 years old, being unable to change my URL is a deal breaker: I registered my URL in high school, and now I'm starting my masters. My photos have improved, and so has my online identity. I'm considering just switching to a new account, but the situation gave me no faith that Flickr was worth the effort. I look forward to a similar post when Flickr overhauls the backend.
- whafro 14y agoI have this same gripe (about HN too, I suppose). Flickr claims that it's a philosophical thing - that URLs shouldn't change, so the username I chose when I first registered years ago should invariably be what I'm associated with for the rest of my life. They likely do have the technical ability - when you initially register, your URL is represented by internal IDs (like 1234567@Z01), and you then choose your 'friendly' url. So it doesn't seem like a stretch that they could extend this to allow changes.
- rkuykendall-com 14y agoI understand the philosophy of keeping URLs active, but this is taking it to a new extreme. How about changing URLs every... 5 years or something ridiculous. I mean, they allow me to delete my account and that would kill URLs, so if it's between deletion or changing, what is the difference?
- mrto2013 14y agoBut i still prefer the old design
- fakeer 14y agoAll said and done, somehow I feel it looks a little Instagrammy. - More clutter - Less clean - Congested, as in a little border would have done no harm. - Looks loud but maybe that's just Instagrammatical. - For me, at least, the home page takes longer to load. - Maybe earlier they had the site built for photographers and now they have made it for everyone - just like lady Mayer said.
- astine 14y agoWhere are you getting that? It looks more like Pinterest than Instagram. There's less whitespace, but the old design was more complicated. It's more colorful now and there is more focus on the photos.
- sergiotapia 14y agoI find the website really slow when scrolling, as if the Javascript engine were choking. And I'm using a 8GB RAM, i7 laptop.
- luiperd 14y agoOverall I really like the new Flickr layout, especially the main photo stream. It's more of a Portfolio that one can use rather than a collection of your photos one after the other. What I don't like is the single photo page. The photo itself is nice and big, which I like. But once you scroll past it it's pretty much a cluster fuck of information that looks very much out of place. It looks like they didn't even bother to make it blend well with the page.
- TorKlingberg 14y agoFlickr has long had good features for sharing photos with Creative Commons licenses, and for searching based on license. Example: http://www.flickr.com/search/?q=duck&l=commderiv&ct=0&mt=photos&adv=1 http://www.flickr.com/search/?q=duck&l=commderiv&ct=... I am happy this still works. If Flickr gets more popular with photographers, there will be even more photos available to Wikipedia and other free content projects.
- meowzero 14y agoThey're late to the game. I use Facebook, Google+, and Dropbox to share and view photos. Right now, Flickr doesn't give me any reason why I should switch. Facebook is already good because everyone uses Facebook. It's a convenient way to tag, share, and comment on your photos of your friends. Google+ has a great Communities section where people share and post photos to other people. Also, a lot of photographers hang out there. Dropbox is great if you want people to download your photos. They automatically zip the photos up. Or if they have a dropbox account, you can share your folder with them. I do like they give us a TB of space. I think if they make a way for Flickr to sync my Lightroom catalogue and all my RAWs, I think that would be a good use of that TB of space.
- hcarvalhoalves 14y ago> They're late to the game. I use Facebook, Google+, and Dropbox to share and view photos. Right now, Flickr doesn't give me any reason why I should switch. Let me give you one: full quality image. Aside from Dropbox, the other services will compress your images. If you're an enthusiast and expect people to see your photos in all it's glory, that's important. And while Dropbox does that, it doesn't really supports the concept of galleries and such.
- brandonsowers 14y agoThis is a really good model of product resurrection. Now lets what yahoo do more of the same thing.
- xmmx 14y agoCan someone comment on the new flickr vs PIcasa?
- Groxx 14y agoSo far I'm liking Flickr better, though I've only dipped my toe in. Uploads (on the site, see [0]) are fast, organizing is fast (though the batch organize is weird IMO), everything can be made private by default easily, and ONE TERABYTE OF STORAGE. It's also much better for browsing than Picasa Web Albums, which are functional but don't really do it well. Flickr makes browsing quite pretty (in a good way, mostly) and generally better for showing your photos to someone. Picasa the website is fine, and does just about everything right, though generally not in the most ideal way. Privacy controls are rich and you can still link directly to a photo to bypass (and revoke existing links). Albums are functional, face tags are functional (though now they use G+ accounts if you link to contacts... not happy, but I guess it works), comments are a bit hidden but work. I have several gigabytes in it (and bought more), no problems, no complaints. Main downside is it has definitely not been updated along with the rest of Google's properties, and it integrates very poorly for the most part (notifications, accounts, weird partial G+ linkage...). Picasa the application is... different, but decent. It's surprisingly good in a number of ways, and I'd recommend it over iPhoto if only because iPhoto has routinely lost my data during updates, and slows to a crawl after several thousand photos. Picasa stays fast, searches quickly, organizes oddly but effectively. It leaves your photos in folders that (basically) match the UI, which may or may not be a good thing for you. Picasa the application when synced to your Google account is slick 95% of the time (it all works as you'd expect), and a total hell-hole of duplication, sync failing, and filename mangling the remaining 5% (though most of that only rears its head when you hook it up for the first time). The 'Sync to web' on/off switch for each album is handy when it works, but hasn't generally handled turning on dozens at once. I would honestly recommend against the syncing aspect of it, though sadly it's a major selling point. If you can hook it up once and leave it that way you probably won't have much trouble, but I did a lot of reconnecting, and it definitely got confused sometimes. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5758033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5758033
- caycep 14y agoWhat I'm wondering is: are the android and iOS apps being developed separately now?
- tlogan 14y agoI wonder if Flickr API ToS is going to be updated. Last time I tried to integrate Flickr API, the rules were that you need special permission to use Flickr API for commercial use. I sent multiple emails and nothing happend. Is this going to change?
- neovive 14y agoIt's great to see Yahoo! in the news so often. Growing up in the first Internet boom, Yahoo! still holds a place in my heart as my first search engine and homepage. Flickr has been a great asset for Yahoo! but has lost much of its momentum, especially with the rising popularity of Pinterest.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- snogglethorpe 14y agoARgh, and they still haven't released the Android app (and apparently the iOS app) in Japan. It's available in Peru, it's available in Ukraine—but not Japan (which is much larger, richer, and almost certainly has more photographers than those two countries), and this has been the situation for ages. WTF, Flickr... [And unfortunately Flickr has always had a very annoying habit of completely stonewalling on such issues.]
- orangethirty 14y agoFlickr seems to be down at the moment.
- xwowsersx 14y agoI'm really picky about the way my photos are presented and right now flickr looks cleaner to me than G+ photos. Flickr puts the photos at the forefront and I also like the photostream idea in general. For me though it feels really hard to switch everything over to Flickr bc there are other issues. For example, with Google I get auto backup of photos taken on my phone which, as we all know, is accounting for a greater and greater percentage of total pics taken. So that's kind of a big deal to me. Anyhow, assuming I wanted to transfer ALL of my photos from G+ to Flickr, how the hell would I go about doing that?!