8 ms·
Expulsion? Seriously? I am grasping at straws here but since it's Florida is it possible she is "the wrong color" ? Would another kid just get a suspension at b
by ck2 14y ago
Expulsion? Seriously? I am grasping at straws here but since it's Florida is it possible she is "the wrong color" ? Would another kid just get a suspension at best? Horrible to be thinking that way.
Did she have prior issues? If there were prior issues with warnings/suspensions, yeah I could see expulsion. If first time ever in trouble, there is something else going on here. perfect behavior record seems to suggest no priors.
added: apparently this is an institutionalized system she was just shoved into, please read the link in this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5636788 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5636788
- dangrossman 14y agoZero tolerance rules: most schools have had them for a long time now. Anything that explodes is a weapon, and weapons on school grounds are an automatic expulsion.
- ck2 14y agoSo if a kid put a mentos in his soda at lunch, that's an expulsion?
- dangrossman 14y agoPossibly, if any kind of administrator dares call it an explosion. I'm not in favor of zero-tolerance policies either, just acknowledging how common they've become. Packing a metal butter knife in a lunch box can lead to expulsion these days (it's happened several times, and made the news each time).
- dmxt 14y agoPlastic knife also count, my friend got suspensed from school for bringing that.
- pekk 14y agoOuch. Maybe now all our dishes and utensils can be small discs. Made of pleather.
- sdsfds 14y agoBetter yet, go Indian, eat with your hands.
- snogglethorpe 14y agoHey hands are among the deadliest of instruments! oO;
- illuminate 14y agoMight be used to choke someone! Stick to trenchers.
- Vivtek 14y agoA trencher could be a pretty effective blunt instrument. Intubation is appropriately American these days.
- chris_wot 14y agoWhat about farting in the playground? That's a small gaseous explosion, expulsion? Lets have preschoolers who throw Lego thrown in jail while we're about it. Honestly, this "zero tolerance" just ruins lives. You've just taken an A grade student who could be contributing to society and possibly put them into a life of poverty and disadvantage. That's great for society.
- snambi 14y agoI agree. The law cannot be applied word by word. If we start doing that each one of us is committing some crime every minute.
- powertower 14y agoSoda cans and farts are not the same thing as ammonia and bleach and drain cleaner being mixed together in a container. Those are serious acids and bases. And these analogies are crap.
- chris_wot 14y agoYou miss the point. Sure, the girl should have been punished. The issue is the degree. Her intent seems pure, it should have been taken into account!
- intractable 14y agoNo, the analogies are spot on. Anything in the preceding comments which seems ridiculous has been introduced by the concept of "zero tolerance", which precludes common sense. Zero means zero. If the rules are enforced as written - arguably as intended - this is what you get. The preceding comments just take the concept to its logical conclusion.
- csense 14y ago> each one of us is committing some crime every minute This statement is actually not absurd. Well, actually, it is an absurdity, but it's also an accurate description of reality. I was reading a comment by someone (I believe a law professor and criminal defense lawyer) who rode along with a highway patrolman in the US. They played a game, where the officer would follow a car, and the officer would win if he could name a legitimate traffic offense committed by the car, for which he could pull the driver over if he was so inclined. The officer won every time, usually within well under a mile. There are so many laws, and they are so complex, that just about anyone is probably guilty of something if you just look hard enough. Only the thin paper shield of the Constitution (in particular 4th and 5th amendments) is about the only thing that stands between just about anybody in the US and prison. For more, see this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
- randallsquared 14y ago> made the news each time Really? Citation needed, I think.
- webjprgm 14y agoImpossible. You could only cite cases where it did, not where it didn't. Or you could give personal witness of seeing a case that did not make it on the news. But no citation.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- uptown 14y ago@randallsquared: http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/Story?id=3758286&page=1#.UYETJSt4ZMg http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/Story?id=3758286&page=1#.UY... http://attleboro.patch.com/articles/student-suspended-for-butter-knife-in-school http://attleboro.patch.com/articles/student-suspended-for-bu...
- muzzamike 14y agoHaving done the mentos "experiment" after lunch in middle school, I can confidently say it was not classified as an explosion. We did have to miss out on recess the next day thou...
- cbsmith 14y agoThat was then... Most of the stuff we did as kids would get my son locked up or doped up (often both) today.
- seanp2k2 14y agoOoooohohohohoho you would SO get expelled for that, since it's a much more violent reaction than what happened here. K-12 schools are largely totally unreasonable organizations run by completely unreasonable individuals who wouldn't make it in the real world.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoThere's more to it than that. Let's assume just for the sake of argument that every actor from their own perspective is reasonable. The problem is that a small group of parents are at the top of the "food chain." These parents are self-selected and therefore have a more overbearing personality (i.e. helicopter parents) than average. So these parents sit in PTA meetings or similar and pass more and more rules based on the latest moral panic (e.g. guns, knives, hairstyles, video games, healthy food, etc). They aren't trying to strike a "balance" to find what is reasonable they're trying to keep the kids safe even at the cost of everything and everyone else. Now you might say "but isn't the principal in charge?!" well, no, not really. I mean the principal is in charge of certain things but if they fail to keep the PTA happy they will be replaced by someone who will. Child safety (as the PTA will spin it) is one of those areas where principals have very little freedom. With this specific incident in mind, even if the principal AND the teachers thought it was crazy to both exclude and arrest her, they might have effectively zero say in the matter.
- nnnnni 14y agoExactly. A lot of people have no idea how it really works -- the "noisy" members of the community have a lot of control over how things are run since they can have someone fired/impeached for not kowtowing to every crazy knee-jerk demand.
- jgoewert 14y agoThey had best get rid of the microwaves in the teachers' lounge. Cooking your soup on high too long can result in an explosion of steam sending flying fragments of meat and potatoes all over!
- dkrich 14y agoTypically expulsion requires a review and vote by the county school board (at least that's how it works where I grew up). My dad was on the school board and had to review a few ridiculous cases like a kid who brought a pocket knife, or another who brought a flask of alcohol to prom. Stupid, draconian laws enforced by ridiculous school administrators. Zero-tolerance laws are illogical because they make an attempt to pass-off guilt, logic, and responsibility by simply saying "perform any act bordering on this description and we have no choice but to come down on you with this one-size-fits all penalty." They are willing to screw up a kid's life because they are unwilling to use logic. Bringing a gun into a classroom != having a pocket knife in the center console of your car, but they are treated as if they are the same act.
- mesozoic 14y agoAnd he better not dare eat pop rocks to go along with it!
- raverbashing 14y agoZero tolerance for common sense as well. Why think when it's easier to hide behind the rules?
- illuminate 14y agoFear of lawsuit when the truly unpredictable occurs, I imagine. Again, not justifying the mandatory application of this policy.
- bmmayer1 14y agoIf you set out to create an explosion. If this is a complete accident how is this an expulsion-worthy offense?
- conradev 14y agoAnd this is why zero tolerance rules are despicable. Not because they were enforced in this case, but because of the countless times they were probably threatened and not enforced. These rules don't enforce justice, they leave justice up to the arbitrary will of an administrator. My school has a rule that states "If a phone is seen out, you will get 20 lunch detentions." And yet most of the teachers do not enforce the rule. In fact, here I am typing a response on Hacker News. Yet if a teacher were to not like me, he/she could single out me and only me and give me lunch detentions. This may only be a simple example, but it scales all the way up to serious offenses and the higher level administrators as well. "You seem like a nice kid, I'll let you off this time" It becomes even worse when bias and prejudice are involved.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoEqually despicable are rules so vague that a mishap can be treated as a criminal act. Carmen Ortiz would approve.
- tg3 14y agoThis is the way police states operate - ridiculously strict laws that are only laxly enforced. In such a system, the enforcers (not lawmakers) have inordinate power to punish or reward people as they see fit.
- specialist 14y agoWorking for a tyrant, I learned the cliche "ambiguous rules, ruthlessly enforced". I believe laws are best wielded against people you don't like. There are so many laws, so broad, so contradictory, every one of us is doing something wrong at any point in time. So enforcement is just a matter of choosing how to punishing your enemies.
- fibbery 14y agoExpulsion is nothing compared to a felony charge.
- ck2 14y agoWell it will be pled down to misdemeanor and juvenile record will be sealed, but yeah that pretty much ruins job applications.
- tiredofcareer 14y agoHow exactly would a sealed juvenile record affect job applications? They don't show up on any criminal background inquiry that companies have access to. Police and government (i.e., clearance or priors), yes. Juvenile charges are practically thrown out by everybody, minus things that require clearance or sensitivity. Regardless, the article says she's going to be tried as an adult, which means it's an adult charge. It'll stick, but... Even an American adult, in most states, can make a felony disappear with some effort and the cooperation of the convicting judge. In other states, it becomes a charge but no conviction is recorded from the company's perspective, so you can say "no, I've never been convicted of a felony." (I'm a felon with extensive experience in this area.)
- ck2 14y agoAs far as I know, employers aren't prevented from using Google?
- tiredofcareer 14y agoNobody does. I promise. My conviction made lots of news as well; has never come up since I got it expunged. Typical BigCos get a standard background on you (these are measured in dozens of dollars), and any further investigation that involves a human being is reserved for a very, very rare candidate. HR and operations are expensive at scale. Since everybody rational considers this news item ridiculous, I think we can safely say this girl will be alright. The expulsion is the thing she'll have to work around, but even a felony conviction is not a life-ender. Many companies specifically hire felons because they're a tax break if filed properly.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jstrate 14y agoImmediately citing racism as the reason for her punishment isn't grasping at straws, it's ignorant. Did you read the part where she was creating _explosives_ on school property? Especially within two weeks of a major bombing involving household materials!?
- sterlingross 14y agoShe could have very well mixed vinegar and baking soda and sealed the result in a weak bottle. Given the right amount of each ingredient, this mixture would "explode".
- MikeAmelung 14y agoIgnorant? You're going to say someone else is ignorant while comparing some mild gas expansion in a closed bottle to devices designed to maim and kill. It's almost like, why am I even writing this comment...
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoTechnically the "device designed to maim and kill" also had a gas expansion inside of a closed vessel. I am just making this post to point out that what she was doing COULD have been dangerous or fatal, it just wasn't. Fortunately plastic containers will fail long before the buildup of pressure becomes too powerful. But in general, that kind of explosion does and can kill.
- primelens 14y agoIt's to do with intention. Even if she were to set off an explosion she'd not be guilty unless it were intentional and meant to hurt people. The most she deserves in this case is a rap on the knuckle. I'd say not even that - maybe a gentle talking to - "be inquisitive, explore ... but be a little more careful."
- pessimizer 14y agoSo does a shaken up bottle of champagne. COULD that be dangerous or fatal? Story at 11.
- uvdiv 14y agoExpulsion? Seriously? I am grasping at straws here but since it's Florida is it possible she is the wrong color? Would another kid just get a suspension at best? Here's one reference point: http://tech.mit.edu/V130/N30/sodiumcasedismissed.html http://tech.mit.edu/V130/N30/sodiumcasedismissed.html MIT students' pyrotechnics fun caused five people to suffer chemical burns (including three paramedics treating the first two). They were punished with community service and fines.
- qiqing 14y agoAnother reference point, though in a different state: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kids_for_Cash_scandal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kids_for_Cash_scandal "The "Kids for cash" scandal unfolded in 2008 over judicial kickbacks at the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania. Two judges, President Judge Mark Ciavarella and Senior Judge Michael Conahan, were accused of accepting money from Robert Mericle, builder of two private, for-profit juvenile facilities, in return for contracting with the facilities and imposing harsh sentences on juveniles brought before their courts to increase the number of inmates in the detention centers. For example, Ciavarella sentenced children to extended stays in juvenile detention for offenses as minimal as mocking a principal on Myspace, trespassing in a vacant building, and shoplifting DVDs from Wal-mart." Not saying this is what happened here, but a plausible hypothesis.
- OGinparadise 14y agoDespicable, and I suspect not that rare. If I were the sentencing judge I'd add every sentence given by those judges to the kids, double it and make all involved serve them. With no parole. In general population.
- chris_wot 14y agoCiavalla lost his pension and is serving 28 years in jail. He'll be out when he's 85, with no pension. I feel very little sympathy for him.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bconway 14y agoMixing ammonia and bleach is actually quite dangerous, and regularly warned against in most chemistry classes. Calling this an "experiment" is generous at best.
- deelowe 14y agoWhere did you get that she mixed ammonia and bleach? The article just states "household chemicals"
- bluedino 14y agoCould have been baking soda and vinegar.
- ja27 14y agoI'm waiting to hear what she really mixed. If it was baking soda and vinegar this is ridiculous. If it was a strong acid and aluminum or bleach and ammonia, I could maybe understand this level of reaction.
- cantankerous 14y agoEven then, there's no reported evidence of criminal intent...and she's being charged with a felony, yes?
- ja27 14y agoThey won't need to show mens rea (criminal intent) because it will never go to trial. They'll beat her over the head with the potential of a felony conviction until she agrees to plead guilty to a misdemeanor charge. It would be great to see a decent defense lawyer pick this case up and take it to trial.
- WettowelReactor 14y agoLast line in the article since it has been updated: "We've also obtained the police report from the incident. It shows that Wilmot was mixing toilet bowl cleaner and aluminum foil." Link to police report: http://www.scribd.com/doc/138927259/Wilmot-Arrest http://www.scribd.com/doc/138927259/Wilmot-Arrest
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- zipppy 14y agoExpulsion isn't really the worst of it, either. Because this is Florida, if she was convicted of a felony she would lose her right to vote. http://felonvoting.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=286 http://felonvoting.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=2... Imagine losing your right to vote, forever, because of this incident.
- powertower 14y ago> I am grasping at straws here but since it's Florida is it possible she is "the wrong color" ? You are right. This was not an over-reaction of a reported explosive device (made with caustic acids and bases - maybe a mix of bleach, ammonia, drain cleaner, etc) going off on school grounds in this climate of fear after the Boston bombings. This can be more easily explained away by the hate and bigotry brewing in this white school and this white police force. I mean, they are white, she is not. Nothing more to say here. P.S., nothing is likely to come of this once the facts are brought up in court... http://www.wtsp.com/news/topstories/article/312750/250/Student-accused-of-setting-off-explosion-on-campus http://www.wtsp.com/news/topstories/article/312750/250/Stude... There are 300MM people in this country, things like this will happen regardless of your race and color.
- nwzpaperman 14y agoI'm guessing you don't have a material Anglo-Saxon genetic pedigree, right? Way to whip-out the race card with no details deeper than: 1) explosion 2) arrest 3) school photo. Your conjecture is an embarrassment to this community.
- tankbot 14y agoThe comment you are replying to was obvious irony. Everything before the P.S. was pure sarcasm, and everything after the P.S. is a further indication of this fact. Maybe you meant to reply to the GP?
- malandrew 14y agoTBH, The only way expulsion is going to be justified is if they also punish the teachers and the principal for not providing the oversight to make sure these chemicals were not available to the kid to do this experiment in the first place. And even then I'd say the adults in charge are the ones that should be punished for this. If the kid brought these chemicals to school to conduct the experiment, then I would definitely venture that there is fault with the kid here, but hardly felony territory and questionable expulsion territory. It really depends on the severity of the incident and the amount of prior knowledge the kid had about the safety. The severity should take into account both the size of the explosion and whether or not students and teachers were at risk when this experiment was conducted. Most kids who know something might be a bit dangerous or uncertain at least have the common sense to conduct these experiments in places where people are unlikely to experience bodily harm. Everyone I knew as a kid that did something like this (including myself) knew enough to guess the maximum magnitude of potential damage and made sure to conduct such experiments far enough from others. When you hear about kids playing with hardcore stuff like a homemade pipe bomb, it's usually a rural or suburban kid that goes way out into the woods to conduct their experiments. When it is something minor like strapping a bunch of Estes model rocket engines together and lighting them, they know enough to have everyone stand far enough back and behind cover before starting the fuse for the experiment. Expulsion really is only merited if humans were actually legitimately at risk. They don't need to have knowledge of the experiment to be culpable, just knowledge that these chemicals were made available without adult supervision. Lab/chemical safety is no joke and I would bet that it was lax or non-existent oversight of these chemicals that prompted this. Kids will be kids. They have limited knowledge of the consequences of their actions, especially when chemistry is involved. The best situation is one where chemistry can be taught safely in schools by teachers with enough knowledge and good sense to provide a safe environment. The next best alternative is to provide a limited subset of chemistry equipment and chemicals that cannot cause an explosion or serious harm, but still provide educational value. Only when neither of those two conditions can be met, should you remove lab chemistry from an educational environment. This is certainly not desirable, but still better than providing an unsafe environment for chemistry.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>adults in charge are the ones that should be punished for this. // She's 16, she's not a child.
- caffeinewriter 14y ago> "Kiera Wilmot got good grades and had a perfect behavior record." What is wrong with this world? It's understandable that this was dangerous, but they just destroyed this girl's future. First of all, they released her name to the public, second of all, this was a first offence, third, this wasn't an intentional bombing. It literally says, it was a science experiment gone wrong.