16 ms·
How about another detail -- the fact that the message said the user had photos to share, when he didn't? There's annoying spam, and then there's straight-out-l
by crazygringo 14y ago
How about another detail -- the fact that the message said the user had photos to share, when he didn't?
There's annoying spam, and then there's straight-out-lying spam -- the "x has sent you a message, you need to create an account to view it" type.
Just curious, is there a way to sue/fine a company like this for false advertising, essentially?
- creativityland 14y agoMaybe that's why we've been seeing Path more in App Store top charts recently? Another app doing similar spamming is Circle: http://discovercircle.com http://discovercircle.com - surprised no one talked about that...
- angersock 14y agoGrowth hacking through grey-hat tricks? This is an outrage! (your winnings, sir.)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- micampe 14y agoApps can't send text messages without the user knowing it on iOS, you have to tap Send for each one of them, so this couldn't have affected App Store rankings.
- ahknight 14y agoYou presume the app sent it and not their servers or a partner service provider. They already grab your address book, including phone numbers. They don't need you after that.
- micampe 14y agoIn that case don't you think we would have seen many more reports of this shady practice? This seems to me a combination of purposefully bad UI and the user not paying attention. Still the same practice spammers use, but very different from "covertly uploading my contacts data and texting everyone without telling me".
- glesica 14y agoActually the article notes that quite a few other people do seem to have experienced this in the past...
- Avenger42 14y agoThere was a court case against a high school alumni site that sent out "a classmate is searching for you" emails to get people to sign up: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/11/how-lawsuit-against-classmates-com-ended-in-paltry-3-93-payouts/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/11/how-lawsuit-again... > The case originated with two lawsuits claiming that Classmates.com had sent out millions of deceptive e-mails telling users that an old friend was trying to contact them, and had viewed their profile or signed their "guestbook." For the great majority, that wasn't true; no one at all had shown an interest in their profile. About 60 million users were contacted, and about 3 million actually took the bait, paying between $10 and $40 to Classmates.
- rhizome 14y agoYou don't know how happy it makes me to see former annoyance-kings classmates.com referred to as a "high school alumni site." Ah, the pre-FB days.
- JGM564 14y agoClassmates.com was sued in 2008 for sending emails claiming former classmates were searching for you. Similar, but Classmates.com was actually requiring a paid subscription before telling you there wasn't actually anyone on the other end. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2010/03/classmatescom-settles-suit-over-misleading-e-mails/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2010/03/classmatescom-set...
- jliptzin 14y agoSimple math is all it takes to understand why this is pervasive. In the classmates.com example, they collected upwards of $75 million in revenue from this scheme, and only had to dish out $2.75 million for the settlement several years later. So for any newcomers, this type of bait is an attractive business proposition; the potential lawsuit years down the line can simply be attributed to cost of revenue. And you'll obviously only get sued if there's money to be won, which means the scheme was a success, so in other words, you want to get sued. The real problem is the judgments/settlements are an order of magnitude lower than they should be.
- ericd 14y agoThere's the hidden cost of permanently alienating potential customers, though, which will show up silently in reduced conversion on all subsequent advertising efforts.
- radiusq 14y agoSure. But it gets some douche product manager his bonus for revenue/user acquisition which was the only goal in the scheme.
- matthewmcg 14y agoAnother hook might be a violation of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) which has been interpreted to prohibit automatically sending text messages without the recipient's consent. The statutory damages are $500 per incident.
- bitcartel 14y agoWe need to nip this in the bud. Maybe it's time to create a Hippocratic Oath for developers to publicly commit to? A future Path developer could then refuse to implement an unethical "feature" by pointing out that the company had hired them with the full knowledge that the oath had been undertaken. I don't think the company would pink slip the developer, as they would probably want to avoid any attention being drawn to the unethical "feature" in a tribunal or other legal setting.
- mikeash 14y agoWhat difference would that make? Path could still fire him, oath or no oath, and I can't see their decision being much influenced there.
- criley 14y agoPublicity. He writes a blog "Path fired me for not breaking the oath" and then communities like this one will rally around that whistle-blower.
- mjolk 14y agoYeah, that negative publicity around Foxconn's workplace conditions really tanked Apple.
- eksith 14y agoI get your point, but these guys don't have anywhere near the same clout that Apple has. Path is young (and building a service, not a device/OS) and it can be abandoned for something similar since all they're keeping is data. Once you buy a gadget, that's an investment on your part which will make a lot of people hesitant to give it up and the culture it that surrounds it. And I wouldn't bet that Apple will be able to survive scandal after scandal and still survive unscathed. Cook is no Jobs.
- mcherm 14y agoMaybe not, but Apple changed their practices pretty darn quick. They now review suppliers much more closely than they did before, and Foxconn's practices have changed a bit as well. You can argue it didn't have ENOUGH effect, but you can't claim it made no difference.
- tlogan 14y agoThis is proven (and risky) way to grow. I really cannot blame them: they have to pay their rent and VCs are nervous. This approach might burn them completely but also can get them to some significant number of users (after which they will issue an apology and pay all fines if needed).
- eropple 14y ago> I really cannot blame them Shitty behavior does not stop being shitty behavior because you have bills to pay. And it's not even in the "understandable under duress" area of shitty; Path isn't a person with a starving child and that dude's contact list isn't a loaf of bread. If your company can't exist without being shitty, your company shouldn't exist.
- tlogan 14y agoI completely agree with you on "If your company can't exist without being shitty, your company shouldn't exist.". However, here in VC-stanm the behavior like this is considered "hacking the growth" and something which is not considered a bad thing. So unfortunately, you cannot play the game here (ok, you can play but no big money will bet on you) if you not ready to do things like this.
- randrews 14y agoShitty behavior also does not stop being shitty behavior when you're pressured into doing it.
- obviouslygreen 14y agoI'm all for the moral high ground, but it becomes a lot less simple when "pressured" means something like a combination of "sole breadwinner" and "ethical choice." Reality doesn't bend to our idealism, and businesses are grounded solely in reality (often to our detriment).
- 14y ago
- jrs235 14y agoFine you say? Here's an earlier HN submission pertaining to just that: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5630449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5630449 UPDATE: That appears to be related to collecting info on minors. Looks like they need to be fined again for this.
- joelhaasnoot 14y agoFacebook does that exact thing by the way - my boss came back from a week of vacation and wondered how I found him on Facebook. Facebook had sent each one of us in the office a link, that he didn't know about. Anytime you send email as a user - it needs to be very explicit.
- andrewhillman 14y agoThere's no way to sue, but I suppose the FTC could take action and fine. They will claim it's a "bug"... albeit one of those "viral bugs" that seems to lead to topping the App Store download charts. These tactics make me think there's no such thing as organic growth within the app stores.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>There's no way to sue // You can sue for anything; just not always successfully. That said ... This appears to be trespass which I think is a tort (entering a part of property, the phone, that was off limits and without consent). You can sue for that. It's also in the same respect contrary to the UK Computer Misuse Act (crime) AFAICT [story appears to be in the UK, or is it just UK entries in the addressbook]. That would probably hinge on the consent to access the particular files duplicated. Then there's database rights (tort?), a sort of copyright for databases. [Copyright wouldn't apply as it's not a creative work]. Harassment (tort I think) and infringement of the right to a private life as enshrined in the ECHR (crime) seem to be causes to object as well. As the calls were business motivated then failure to check against a telephone cold-call blacklist could also generate extra fines. Seems there's much that could be sued for.
- micampe 14y agoHow about another detail — the fact that – according do another comment here, the only one that seems to actually have looked at how the app behaves before jumping the gun – the app tells you it's going to invite everyone on first launch and you need to tell it not to? Still bad, but quite a different perspective.
- jpatel3 14y agoProbably that why they hiring director of legal and privacy - https://hire.jobvite.com/CompanyJobs/Careers.aspx?c=qd29Vfw3&cs=9et9Vfwv https://hire.jobvite.com/CompanyJobs/Careers.aspx?c=qd29Vfw3...
- Alex3917 14y ago"Just curious, is there a way to sue/fine a company like this for false advertising, essentially?" Yes. It's illegal to use someone else's likeness for advertising without their permission.
- Tsagadai 14y agoIn Australia it is possible to get companies that send unwanted texts banned from sending texts on Australian networks.
- Cub3 14y ago"The Privacy Act gives you the right to make a complaint if you believe an Australian or ACT government agency, or a private sector organisation covered by the Act, has mishandled your personal information contained in a record." http://www.privacy.gov.au/complaints/what http://www.privacy.gov.au/complaints/what
- reidrac 14y agoWell, I don't think we should look for malice when is just incompetence. LinkedIn keeps asking me to share my mail user/password so I can connect with more people, and says that X and many others already did it. I can't tell about others, but X is my wife and I'm certain she didn't do it. So well, as I said I think that this is just a matter of incompetence (ie. automated message gone wrong). EDIT: typo
- SagelyGuru 14y agoSee, I am not convinced that it was an innocent "automated mistake". This is equivalent to the anecdotal old excuse one always hears from the government officials: "the computer did it". When some spamming process like this is automated, all it means is that it is being inflicted on lots of people and most likely deliberately, so automation is not something that can be accepted as an excuse, on the contrary, it is an aggravating circumstance. I incline towards the opinion that these sharks do it quite deliberately. They just don't care how many people they embarrass and annoy, as long as some of those tech-innocent grannies and plumbers join up and thus put figures on their business projection sheets that get these sharks closer to cashing in big on an FB style IPO.
- mike-cardwell 14y agoReminds me of the emails Facebook sends me telling me that I've missed important notifications when I don't log in for a while. I log in, and there are no notifications waiting. And the messages Facebook sends me telling me about an event and letting me know that one of my friends is a guest, when they've been invited but haven't actually confirmed.