8 ms·
EFF Politely Asks PTO to Stop Issuing So Many Crappy Software Patents
- richardjordan 14y agoSadly the way things appear to work nowadays unless you politely ask enough law makers with enough large checks attached to your polite requests, little happens.
- Ygg2 14y agoYou mean bribe?
- alive-or-not 14y agoYou mean lobbying? ;)
- DigitalSea 14y agoYou can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink. You can lead a corporate horse to water but you'll have to give it hundreds of thousands of dollars to make it drink. Everyone has been wanting the PTO to change the patent system, but it's most likely not going to happen (if it ever does) for a very long time.
- KNoureen 14y agoIsn't it good that the PTO resists pressure from either group? I mean, the only part which would have influence on how they work is the entity above PTO, whichever that one is (Supreme Court/DOJ/?).
- jacques_chester 14y agoCongress. Congress are the ones who count.
- DigitalSea 14y agoIt's both good and bad. It seems no matter how many people complain or companies like Google come forward and try and change things by kicking their feet around and causing a scene, nothing changes. The fact the system is such a mess and changing even the slightest part of the entire patent process would undoubtedly spawn more legal action than you could imagine from big and small companies alike who make their money off of obscure patents. When it comes to politics money talks, maybe someone should start a lobbyist website where people can crowd-source funds to lobby Government to get things changed? A Kickstarter for government lobbying to benefit the people.
- derefr 14y ago> A Kickstarter for government lobbying to benefit the people. That's actually a great idea--it's basically a petition with a donation required to sign (thus making it into something that actually has autonomous power, rather than some names on papper.)
- tfigment 14y agoI suspect that even if they allowed submitting code then it will probably not be mandated which language be used and we will likely get something like obfuscated javascript or Brainfuck or god forbid obfuscated Brainfuck (if that is not redundant) in the patent. Documented code would be a great step forward if we decide we have to keep patents around because at least your money is buying source code in some form.
- jacques_chester 14y agoIt'd be easy enough to mandate a list of languages. Or alternatively to require languages to be standards published by a recognised national or international body from a short list (ISO, ANSI and equivs, IEEE, ECMA etc).
- Guthur 14y agoWouldn't rule out Javascript then. I think common sense applied to the process would be enough, rather than mandating languages that may or may not be relevant in the future. Though Patent System and Common Sense might be bit of an oxymoron.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> Wouldn't rule out Javascript then. Or C# (ECMA), Common Lisp (ANSI), SQL (ISO), Fuzzy Control Language (IEC) ...
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoOr C (ISO/ANSI)
- jacques_chester 14y agoYes, but it's not as amusing :D
- Osiris 14y ago
- corporalagumbo 14y agoSeems pretty reasonable...
- benbataille 14y agoPTO is never going to stop issuing crappy patents. There is a huge conflict of interest there. It's easy. Every time someone files a patent, the PTO gains the filing fees. If they don't check too much, people file a lot and they win a lot. If they check, it means first more cost for them, then less patent filed hence less money. Now, what happens to them, when they accept bogus patents ? Answer : nothing. The PTO is simply not accountable for that. No surprise they have no incentive to do their work properly.
- ritchiea 14y agoGovernment agencies don't really work like that. The PTO doesn't get to give itself raises based on profits. The PTO's behavior is based on legislation, court interpretation and a small sliver of their own interpretation after the direction they receive from those more powerful government bodies. Last year there were about 577,000 patent applications [1] at $180 each for a little over $100M in revenue. That's fantastic if you're most companies, but just a tiny portion of the federal budget. The current patent situation is a failure of the federal government to understand and legislate contemporary technology, not a misalignment of incentives. 1. http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/ac/ido/oeip/taf/us_stat.htm http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/ac/ido/oeip/taf/us_stat.htm
- ScottBurson 14y agoWhile I agree that there is a failure to understand contemporary technology, I also think the incentives given patent examiners are misaligned. They're rewarded for applications processed; they're not graded on the number of bad patents they reject. A patent is a deal we, the people of the US, make with an inventor: add significantly to the sum total of our technical knowledge, and in exchange, we'll give you a time-limited monopoly on the technique you invented. The problem is that there isn't anyone unambiguously charged with making sure this is a good deal for us: that the knowledge we're getting is worth the price we're paying. It's technically the PTO's responsibility, and they do make some effort, but the incentives given patent examiners don't encourage them to be hard-nosed about it. Currently, I don't think patents about to be granted are reviewed by the examiners' supervisors or anything like that. Seems to me there should be an internal committee that reviews every patent about to be granted by junior examiners, and an occasional one of those about to be granted by senior examiners, to verify its quality. Repeatedly approving applications that then get rejected by this committee should slow an examiner's promotion progress.
- Gorbzel 14y agoI'm the biggest EFF fanboy there could possibly be. I'm a member, and I'm also repping IP and electronic freedom in the only completely crazy way I knew how, by attending the disaster that is law school. (Graduating in May. w00t!) If anything, following the EFF and their work while also studying what 35 USC 101 actually says really gets me tired of lazy "activism" like this. I fail to see what good this accomplishes other than inciting a circlejerk in the tech media / hive mind without directly promoting any meaningful reform. I'm a bit close to it, but the reform patent movement is definitely not in need of much more awareness. What is needs is nuanced understanding of the problem and fighting the good fight in meaningful ways. I've read too many EFF amici briefs to believe that they're doing anything but good, but campaigns like this just strike me the wrong way at this point.
- eepar6 14y agoIs there anything a layperson can do to help?
- ysapir 14y agoWhile the patent system seems broken as far as software patents go, some of EFF's corrections (in https://defendinnovation.org/ https://defendinnovation.org/) are problematic. This includes "Avoid liability if they arrive independently" (what happens if the general news about a company doing X profitably is enough to let you work out an algorithm independently, the company doing X still wants to protect the effort it spent to figure out X when it wasn't clear it would be profitable) or "can't collect millions if the patent represented a tiny fraction of the product" (what if it is a small piece of code in millions of lines, but without it there would be no product?). Also, the patent system should be modified to allow some way to handle customer discovery. Something like a single provisional filing fee allows you to file many iterative documents repetitively (with MVP source code perhaps) and those later provide a basis for priority date if proof is supplied they were customer-tested.
- vilya 14y agoIf just knowing that it's possible is all it takes to be able to independently reproduce an invention, then it shouldn't have been patentable in the first place. That's pretty close to being the exact definition of the "non-obviousness" criteria the USPTO is supposed to apply.
- ysapir 14y agoNo I don't think that's exact. If you need to know that it's possible in order to make it, then it is non-obvious. Maybe the algorithm is obvious, ie, to do X you need to do steps 1, 2, and 3, but X itself, the basic functional creation that employs the algorithm, is not obvious. Swipe-to-unlock, the basic algorithm, how to implement it is pretty clear. But matching and researching which gesture works with which functionality, to the degrees customers find it natural took effort and time, and it produced a creation that was not obvious before that research. Besides, if this is already part of the current rules, why do we need to amend the rules for it? Just enforce the rules better.
- icebraining 14y agoSwipe-to-unlock is an obvious transfer of a well-known physical concept (sliding the keyboard to unlock, as many Nokia phones had) to the touch screen. It's a great example of another big problem with software patents - the idea that adding "... on a computer" makes it somehow brand new.
- rlpb 14y agoI have filed a patent. It is a hardware invention, but generally would be implemented in software. Keep in mind that for a patent to be granted the invention must be: 1) Non-obvious to someone skilled in the art. 2) Novel (ie. not done before). Patent attorneys and patent offices seem to only use a test for novelty. They tell me that if an invention is obvious, then somebody would have done it before. They have no specific test for non-obviousness apart from demonstrating prior art. They seemingly have no ability to refuse a patent by just claiming that it is obvious. To them, lack of prior art is evidence of non-obviousness. It is as if they live in another world, where the only inventions and ideas possible are the ones previously patented. I can only assume that this has come about because a test for non-obviousness is subjective. It's easier for an examiner to let it through and lets the courts sort out the mess later, at our expense. It seems to me that this is the root cause of ridiculous patents. In technology, we're moving too quickly for this. We need a better solution.
- skore 14y ago> They tell me that if an invention is obvious, then somebody would have done it before. So it either already exists, or makes sense to be patented? This truly boggles the mind. Then again - does it really? If you are a patent lawyer, your job depends on there being lots of patents. The definition "anything that hasn't been patented should be" seems to be the logical extreme to serve that equation.
- dhimes 14y agoPatent attorneys and patent offices should be very different in these views. I'll give a pass to patent attorneys trying to get everything patented, but the patent offices (examiners) should be the gatekeepers. They're the ones that need to apply the test for obviousness.
- sageikosa 14y ago> They tell me that if an invention is obvious, then somebody would have done it before ...and for someone to have done it before, someone must have patented it... I think that's the real rub of the patent conundrum. The patent office assumes that if something hasn't been patented yet, it must be non-obvious. The whole "skilled in the art" things sort of goes out the window.
- Egregore 14y agoIs there a way to explain to other people (non software developers) how bad it can be to issue patents for obvious things? So that their voting power will be directed in the right direction.
- charlesjshort 14y agoTell Congress to eliminate the incentives for Examiners to issue quotas of patents.
- CodeCube 14y agoWhere is the PTO located? Can some local HNer just, apply for a job there? I think interested technical parties should try to "infiltrate" the organization to get more information and be able to answer some of the questions that just keep getting asked in every forum ad-nauseum and maybe do a reddit AMA or something.
- patentnerd 14y agoHi, I'm a patent examiner. I won't apologize for the agency, we have more than our share of problems, but I also think we get more than our share of criticism for bad patents. The PTO simply has no ability to change patent law. We apply it as it's written by Congress and interpreted by the courts. A few points on the law without getting into criticism of the agency (you can get easily find that elsewhere): 1. The burden on patent applicants is too low. There's a presumption that a patent will issue as soon as it's filed. The patent examiner has to prove that whatever is claimed was obvious, didn't work, wouldn't work, etc. If the patent examiner can't meet that burden, the patent issues. The patent applicant doesn't have to tell us about the state of the art prior to the "invention", what the improvement is, or why it deserves a patent. 2. As discussed upthread, the obviousness standards are too low. If you can't find evidence that each and every aspect of a claim was in the prior art, you have to allow the patent. Even then, a patent attorney can attack the rejection if the different prior art documents wouldn't fit well together. As an examiner, you can't simply say that something would have been obvious, with no supporting evidence. If you try to make such a rejection, the patent attorney will appeal your rejection, you'll get reversed on appeal and the patent will issue anyway. 3. The process naturally skews towards patent applicants. Most (nearly all) patent applicants have an attorney who is fighting 100% for as broad a patent as possible. The examiner is supposed to be a neutral arbiter who applies the law in an evenhanded fashion. There's no party fighting for the public, pushing back hard against the patent attorney. It's like a courtroom where only one side of the story is presented. You can find a lot commentary/criticsm of the patent examination process online BTW, but not generally on the tech sites - look more towards legal/academic literature. (Speaking on my own behalf, not the agency's)
- CodeCube 14y ago
- chris_gogreen 14y agoLet's publicize who the actual people reviewing the patents are, some personal accountability for the patents someone issues or approves could be powerful. I'd like to understand the KPI's of the PTO, are there patent agents issuing patents faster than possible? Robo signing? Are there incentives for an agent to issue more patents to keep organization wide throughput high? Where can I get Open Data related to the PTO?
- wissler 14y agoThe more and crappier the better, since it discredits and bogs down an intrinsically broken system, which we can only hope would lead to its demise.
- dlitz 14y agoWon't this just allow the incumbents to threaten others with their crappy software patents, while making it harder for new entrants to acquire enough of their own crappy software patents to defend themselves? A pretty good argument has been made that we should just legislate that developing, distributing, or running a program on generally used computing hardware does not constitute patent infringement.[1] Why not just do that? [1] http://www.wired.com/opinion/2012/11/richard-stallman-software-patents/ http://www.wired.com/opinion/2012/11/richard-stallman-softwa...
- geebee 14y agoOne reason that software patents are so crappy is that the patent bar actively filters out the people who would be most knowledgeable about mathematics and algorithms. The problem is that algorithms and math are not considered patentable. The guidelines for membership in the patent bar specifically exclude mathematics coursework as a valid educational background. The reasoning, I believe, is that abstract laws should not be patented. However, with the rise of software patents, we clearly are allowing algorithms and mathematics to be patented. However, the patent bar actually specifically excludes the background that would be most useful in evaluating these patents. It makes sense if you think of the patent system as a cartel. By allowing math to be patented, you expand your domain. By denying people with a mathematics background to sit for the patent bar, you restrict your competition. Sometimes, when you're confused by a bad policy, just ask yourself: what would a person with no morals, plenty of power, and a single minded desire to enrich himself do? Usually, that will explain the policy.