14 ms·
Lord British launches “Shroud of the Avatar” on Kickstarter
- lnanek2 14y agoReally preferred the original title on this Hacker News story. More people know what Ultima is, and the creator launching a new project means something to far more people than his specific nick or the new projects name. The submitter's title was much better.
- adventureloop 14y agoKickstarter page is not up yet, but there is a live streamed announcement via http://www.lordbritishpresents.com/ http://www.lordbritishpresents.com/.
- mmastrac 14y agoOdd. I'm seeing the kickstarter page myself. Already 200+ backers.
- adventureloop 14y agoThe links on lordbritishpresents.com didn't have the -0 at the end. I only got on once someone tweeted a different link. It might be because I was watching as the timer stopped.
- danso 14y ago> Multiplayer Online Game - which can also be played solo player / offline I remember when UO came out...I never played it but I wondered if it would be the end of good single-player RPGs. Luckily, it wasn't, but it was basically the end of Ultima as a series, though arguably it wasn't a causation. In any case, it's hard to imagine an RPG world that could be designed successfully to be a MMO and a good single player experience. Good single player experiences are bespoke storytelling affairs...and to abstract it out to accomodate MMO interaction would seem to necessarily dilute it. Maybe I'm in the minority here, but I'm not at all against games that just end, rather than try to shoot to be a world in which you can fully "live a life" and in which the world is infinitely evolving. It's not that such a prospect isn't interesting, it's just that it inevitably leads to the kind of feature creep that leads to bugs and outright brokenness (insert reference to SimCity). I'm OK with games ending after 50-100 hours (or even 10, in the case of the Portal series), if those hours were fantastic. I'd contribute if Lord British were going to make a modernized version of Ultima VII. Even though the limits of its world are obvious in retrospect, it really was way ahead of its time in creating a believable digital world for the single-player, and the constructs it used to maintain that facade (and have a story arc) would not have worked if it were a MMO.
- FD3SA 14y agoYes, my experience compels me to agree. The best compromise I've found are Diablo-style co-operative stories, where multiple people can go through a very engrossing story as a group of adventurers, and progress to the game's final end. I argued that the great failure of SW: The Old Republic was that it removed the one element that made Knights of the Old Republic such a success: the engrossing single player story. Massive online environments, by definition, prohibit a single character from being important. The natural solution is the instanced single player game, allowing large party sizes which scale difficulty based on the encounter. A corollary of this is that any true, persistent MMO must be sandbox type, allowing individual players extreme freedom to write the stories. The best example of this is EVE, and a lesser known korean RPG Lineage: The Blood Pledge, which allowed players to control castles of each kingdom, creating incredible game histories due to player competition alone. It is clear that the single player co-op and the MMO are now distinct genres, catering to different play styles. Attempts to bridge this gap have generally failed from a storytelling perspective, even in great games such as Guild Wars 2 and The Old Republic.
- Lockyy 14y agoI agree with you that trying to merge multiplayer with singleplayer would be a very difficult affair. I think swtor attempted this, but I cannot say because I never played it. I am excited to see if anyone takes up the idea of making something akin to the elder scrolls franchise and adding small scale multiplayer into it. Not specifically co-op but just where multiple people are dropped into the world together and then left to their own devices. In a game where up to say 10 people were allowed to wander free it would be fun to have rivalries and alliances arise as people try to further their own goals. What saddens me is that this sort of idea seems to be forgotten completely in lieu of the industry direction that seems to suggest the only multiplayer fantasy rpg games we'll ever get are shameless wow clones. I would love to be wrong by the way, if anyone does know of any of these sorts of games feel free to correct me.
- adventureloop 14y agoIt sounds like the multiplayer is implemented in similar way to Fabel 2. A single player game, but if your friends were online you would see a floating orb where ever they were in the world. You could interact through game play as well, though I am a little rusty on how that worked. An implementation like that would be really cool. It would definitely me a nice argument against the EA / Activision(Blizzard) always online approach.
- Kurtz79 14y agoI remember fondly Ultima 7 and Ultima Underworld 2. Incredible titles, way ahead of their time. Ultima 7 has probably more sophisticated interaction mechanics than 99% of the games today.
- jiggy2011 14y agoName? Job?
- Kurtz79 14y agoBye.
- bornhuetter 14y agoThey remain two of the best games I have ever played. Looking at the games the team have made brings back a lot of good memories. Wing Commander Privateer was also phenomenal at the time.
- gavanwoolery 14y agoI grew up on the Ultima series - in fact it is exclusively the reason I became a programmer and game developer. I do not know how good this recent iteration will be, but at least it looks like Richard is keeping a close ear to his community. In all honesty though I would have settled for a 2D/isometric non-MMO (in the spirit of Ultima 7) -- I think that's where his original fans lie.
- danielweber 14y agoIt was Ultima III that first made me realize that all data lived on the disk and that I could alter all of it. And I did. Maybe I'm weird but it's fun to read the assembly for Ultima 3. I was stuck in the Apple world so I stopped playing after U5. I bought the Ultima-giftpack on GOG.com before Christmas, but still have only had the time to work through the first 3. I'm savoring them, still.
- T-hawk 14y agoMe too... Ultima III was part of my introduction to hacking, but on an entirely different platform. I had it as the NES cartridge, mostly oblivious to the franchise's history on the computer platforms. I also had the Game Genie cheating device, whose codebook had a fairly rich set of codes for the game, changing your characters' health and stats and such. There were enough closely related codes (30 strength, 60 strength, 90 strength) that I started seeing the patterns, working out how the Game Genie code letters mapped to bits and represented the data values. So then I started synthesizing more codes that weren't in the book: hey, adding one to this letter changes the next stat instead, that must be a memory location. What happens if I add 16 to it, nice it changes the next character. Ultimately I never really played the game with hacked characters, since the challenge of the game wasn't the stats but in exploring and mapping the dungeons and hidden areas. (I had nightmares for years about getting lost in Ambrosia.) Other NES games were much more interesting with hacked stats, notably Final Fantasy I. Ultima III on the NES also contained the first major loophole exploit I discovered in a game. When in a dungeon, your magic power would slowly recharge with every step, but also risk running into a monster encounter. But I happened to realize that _rotating in place_ did the former and not the latter. So just by pressing the right arrow 300 times between encounters to recover 75 MP, you could cast the top-end magic nuke spell on every single monster group, virtually achieving god mode.
- potatoman2 14y agoI'd pitch in if they promised to base the engine off Ultima 8.
- ralphleon 14y agoWhy not ultima 7? Ultima8 wasn't as interactive as ultima7 imho.
- Kurtz79 14y agoI agree, graphics were prettier, but controls were sluggish and unresponsive. Jumping mechanics were a nightmare. The series really started its downward slope from there.
- potatoman2 14y agoI think it was the kind of game that was so bad that looking back I have fond memories.
- Kurtz79 14y agoI wasn't all bad, I liked the new world and the darker "edge" of the plot (I still remember the beheading scene), the complex magic systems, the duels with the sorcerers... Ultima 9 was the really stinking blob of pus.
- estebank 14y agoVery, very recommended: Ultima Retrospective[1] by "Spoony". Goes into detail on the rise and fall of Ultima. [1]: http://spoonyexperiment.com/category/game-reviews/ultima-retrospective/ http://spoonyexperiment.com/category/game-reviews/ultima-ret...
- CamperBob2 14y agoHoly unskippable obnoxious video ads, Batman!
- bobsy 14y agoI am going to rant about graphics here. The graphics on this game look 8 years old. A game doesn't need to look fantastic to be good but surely a new game should have good graphics. I am not talking about realistic graphics. Simply esthetically pleasing graphics. The graphics in the video look like something from runescape... Looking elsewhere. Is this game not called 'Ultima Online' because Garriot doesn't own the rights? A sequel in all but name? While the vision sounds promising I worry about broader appeal. Who is this game for? Tabula Rasa failed pretty badly. I don't quite see the appeal of this game. Most MMO's have a clear goal. Even if that is the same. "Level up, do quests, reach new areas, get gear." Perhaps I misunderstand but the goal of this game seems to be 'explore for yourself.' I don't think that is enough to pull people in. I have played the Ultima series. I still give Ultima Online a spin every couple of months and this new game doesn't pull me in.. The video left me feeling like the game is a time sink without getting the reward of getting little achievements like gaining levels and discovering new gear. The very things that make such games addictive. When I saw the title my first thought was "TAKE ALL MY MONEY NOW." After seeing the video I think perhaps there is a reason why EA didn't take the franchise further.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- moron4hire 14y agoThe quality of graphics that we see in modern games has more to do with art assets then with programming of the game engine. Take a close look at the surroundings in your next game session. Every single thing in the game at some point had to be modeled by a person. When you're just starting with a project, you don't have those various and detailed models available. What you saw here was the "programmer art" version, which is actually pretty good for programmer art. And apparently "explore for yourself" worked for Minecraft. Any style of game can be successful, it just takes a good gameplay element on top of it to make it.
- bobsy 14y agoReally? Everything is modeled by a person? I thought it was done with magic. I haven't heard of programmer art. Why would a programmer work on models? Perhaps the game demo is using stock models or something but it seems strange that you would have prototypes and a demo like this with no artistic direction implemented. I am not sure what exactly you think this has in common with Minecraft.
- estebank 14y ago> From Lord British's Treatise on "What is an Ultimate RPG?": > * Fully interactive virtual world - If it looks usable, it should do something > * Deep original fiction - Ethical parables, cultural histories, fully developed alternate language text This reminds me of the first Deus Ex. Wonder if they'll be able to pull it off.
- ordinathorreur 14y agoGame designer Warren Spector worked on both the Ultima series and Deus Ex which might explain the similar philosophy.
- chaostheory 14y ago> Since then, most every other RPG has focused more on level grinding then “role playing”, which has been reduced to a few initial character choices... Less open. Less immersive. I don't think this team has played any RPGs over the past decade. Non of them are like this other than JRPGs. It lessens his project's credibility.
- jbattle 14y agoI agree. I'm not a big RPG player, but aren't basically all of the Elder Scrolls games going back to Daggerfall built around this very concept?
- Kurtz79 14y agoI agree. The Ultima games were ahead of their time but the industry eventually catched up. The first Fallout had terrific role playing already, and then all the Black Isle, Bioware, Bethesda titles, the Gothic, Witcher series...
- bentcorner 14y agoHmm.. Kickstarter Estimated delivery date: Oct 2014 Amazon authorized payment window: July 2013 This should be interesting...
- sirn 14y agoKickstarter will charge your credit card as soon as the funding ends (April 7) so the payment window date should not matter.
- simonsarris 14y agoI'm glad that "Meaningful PvP" was singled out. PvP is important to me and its one of the things that Ultima Online got right that vast swaths of MMOs since have floundered with (in my opinion). In parts of the world (Felucca[1]), UO was a rare RPG where anyone could kill anyone, for any reason, but with the repercussion that they would be branded a "Bad person" (visible with a gray or red name instead of blue). Stealing from good people corpses also did this. Anyone can attack and kill bad persons, and if you killed even more people you were a murderer and it took a very long time to return to normal. You want to use super awesome powerful gear? None of this sissy MMO stuff. Die and you lose it, and your enemy (or his enemy!) gets the spoils.[1] Those are the two criteria by which I think "meaningful PvP" should be judged: 1. Can I kill anyone? (ie, in WoW you can't kill 90% of the people you see, they have to be in an arena/faction/alliance). 2. When you kill someone do you actually win something? (preferably something of theirs), and when you die do you actually lose something (preferably the equipment you risked to try and have a more favorable fight). Ultima and UO were very big into morality and moral dilemmas, which is a thing I love in both single and multi-player games. Some of the Ultima games featured very interesting choices, like whether or not you should kill "evil" (possessed) children or leave them alone. In UO, if you did have a "bad person" title and wanted to know how much time you had left before you would be considered blue again, you had to type: "I must consider my sins" ~~~ The other problem I have with a lot of MMOs is that the power of your character is simply how much time you sink into the game. Essentially, MMOs are games that reward wasting time. UO had so much more than that. The class-less system definitely helped, and UO was a game where treachery and sneakiness really paid off, if you wanted them to. Lots of ways to nearly instantly kill or entrap people lead to a lot of very exciting plots where guilds might be laden with spies. Absolutely nothing like the limited PvP found in many modern MMOs. In a lot of ways UO was the Diplomacy (diplomatic back-stabbing board game) of MMOs. And it was great. See also outworlder's wonderful comment explaining UO 90 days ago[2]. Also considerably interesting was the economy of UO[3], which was wrought with a good deal of experimentation. ~~~ Also, if you played UO, you'd know that property taxes are a wonderful idea. So many people land-rushing to get the largest properties possible, who then sat on them and never built anything! (Or never played, while newcoming regulars had zero chance of ever finding a home at a reasonable price) ~~~ [1] In the beginning there was only Felucca. And an insurance system was added later (2005ish?) where you could pay a certain amount per item to not lose it on death. Both were attempts to make the game less harsh. Like a lot of later patches, this was unpopular with older players and popular with newer players. Over its lifetime, UO did a lot of things to make the game world less cut-throat, which will always be controversial. Some realms rules stayed more "hardcore" than others as a compromise. [2] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4890513 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4890513 [3] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4890481 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4890481
- gebe 14y agoMight as well chime in with another Kickstarter in progress for a spiritual successor of another famous RPG: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/torment-tides-of-numenera http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/torment-tides-of-... Kickstarter has been really great so far for people, like myself, who were and are very fond of the "old school" type of RPGs.
- pearle 14y agoYeah, I'm surprised the Torment KS didn't appear on HN after it ended up being the fastest KS to hit 1 million (8 hours).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- victorantos 14y agowow, $2+ mln and still 28 days to go... http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/torment-tides-of-numenera http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/torment-tides-of-...
- sp332 14y agoAccording to HN Search, several people posted it but none of them got more that 5 points.
- Semaphor 14y agoKinda happy this seems as bad as it does, prevents me from backing yet another project so shortly after Torment.
- pearle 14y agoI backed Torment and Project Eternity but I'm also backing this. I spent a good chunk of the 90s immersed in games by Origin and I'm now interested in seeing what Garriott can do without the shackles of a publisher (EA, back in the day).
- chjj 14y agoThis is so great. I'm such a damn UO fan I can't even put it into words. I'm not a "gamer", but UO was the __best__ game I've ever played. No game, as far as I can tell, has even come close to replicating the brilliance of UO around 1998-1999. It probably gave me some of my best childhood memories, and it was also the first time I was ever called a "fuking n00b" on the internet.
- Erwin 14y agoI'm not sure what to feel when someone who spent (reportedly) $30MM for a space trip: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Garriott#Spaceflight http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Garriott#Spaceflight asks me for $1MM But I guess the more power to semi-independent studios we can give through Kickstarter the better. I like the $10 "guilt pledge": "If you ever pirated an Ultima game or used an exploit to grief other players in Ultima Online, here’s your chance to repent! For your $10 donation you will receive a clear conscience and Lord British's undying gratitude.".
- adventured 14y agoIt's real simple. Don't spend a penny of your money toward it if you don't want to / if you disagree with it. And $1 million? It's going to cost radically more than that to launch the product. You do realize how much even a mid size title costs to make these days, right? All $1 million does is get the ball rolling (barely). Try $15 to $30 million dollars just to build it out.
- jsnell 14y agoYou're probably thinking of Kickstarter in its original "support a cool project to make it happen" mindset. Like most high profile projects, this isn't like that. It's one part marketing, one part a pre-order system, and one part a market research tool. In that light the personal wealth of the project owner is irrelevant.
- spqr 14y agoI pirated Ultima IV, but in fairness it was on a Commodore 64 in 1985 and I was 13 years old. I assume the statute of limitations has run out, but if not will I still be tried as a minor? I guess I can flip the guy at least $10 for the best RPG I ever played in my life.
- thisone 14y agoI don't think personal wealth of an owner has anything to do with a business. I'm probably a greedy SOB, but that's his money, not the company's money. If the company can't exist without him paying his own money into it, then the company probably shouldn't exist. I find it laudable if an owner would help float a company through a short bad period using their own money, but I wouldn't expect them to beggar themselves (or not get paid back) just to keep a failing company running.
- erickhill 14y agoPer the title of this post, it's not exactly "Ultima" or a sequel. As found on the official site's FAQ: "But is this the Ultima sequel I’ve been waiting for? This is NOT an “Ultima”, as that is a trademark owned by Electronic Arts. Ultima fans know though, that great RPG’s can be been played anywhere; on earth, in space, in Britannia and in many other lands. I am creating a new land for Shroud of the Avatar, which will adhere to the design principles that all of my FRPG games adhered to." https://www.shroudoftheavatar.com/?page_id=19 https://www.shroudoftheavatar.com/?page_id=19
- papsosouid 14y agoIt is pretty sad that kickstarter gets abused like this so much. Garriott is filthy rich, and has been in the game industry for decades. There is absolutely no need for him to be seeking financing from us, he could pay for it a dozen times over out of his own pocket. His reputation means he could easily get actual funding if he doesn't want to risk his own money. But instead, he abuses the willingness of ordinary people to take all the risk for him, and get nothing back in return.
- lnanek2 14y agoEven rich people here in SV often take investment for their new startups after the first. It's silly to go it alone, risk everything, and not recruit people with skin in the game. Even if he didn't need the money, it's worth it for the PR alone, which will benefit everyone into the game since it will take longer to die a lonely death.
- papsosouid 14y ago>Even rich people here in SV often take investment for their new startups after the first. Yes, in exchange for something. They don't ask for funding from people and offer them nothing in return, forcing them to take all the risk while he stands to make all the profit.
- autarch 14y agoOr ... this is a good way for him to see if there's actual interest in the product. And given his track record of actually finishing stuff, it seems like this is relatively low risk as far as Kickstarter projects go.
- papsosouid 14y agoNeither of your points address the concern I raised. This is a guy who paid $30M to go in to space for fun. A guy who lives in a castle. If he wants to make a game, he can. He doesn't need kickstarter at all. He is simply using it to make a game for free, rather than investing in it personally. The idea behind kickstarter was to allow people who couldn't get funding through traditional channels an opportunity to appeal directly to their potential customer base for funding. Not a way to make rich people richer with no risk to themselves.
- viseztrance 14y agoKotaku has a rather lengthy interview which you may want to checkout as well as some extra game play. http://kotaku.com/5989447/richard-garriott-revolutionized-video-game-rpgs-now-the-creator-of-ultima-wants-to-do-it-again http://kotaku.com/5989447/richard-garriott-revolutionized-vi...
- Apocryphon 14y agoKickstarter should spin out their video games category into its own brand. After all of the long-dead series/genres they've been reviving, they're the most beloved "publisher" in ages, the direct opposite of EA/Activision.
- rschmitty 14y agoFor something different, here is a soon to be launched kickstarter. From someone not as successful as Mr Garriot but if you played Dark Age of Camelot you might be in love already http://citystateentertainment.com/camelotunchained/ http://citystateentertainment.com/camelotunchained/ Here is a long interview describing the goals: https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=yBfRU8BTsNk https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&... View on what is wrong with MMOs @ 4:16 No more hand holding @ 7:00 Class System - Rock Paper Scissors @ 11:46 Race/Sex Considerations - Choices Matter @ 13:40 Crafting - First class crafting @ 18:18 Random Critical Hits - You will laugh and cry @ 25:17 Randomness for Crafting - Sometimes stuff will go horribly wrong/perfectly right @ 31:11 Leveling - No PvE, unclear on soft vs hard caps at this stage @ 34:07 Kickstarter - Pick your rewards! @ 40:19
- trotsky 14y agoI wasn't familiar with this, but Mark Jacobs is a founder and they are based out of DC like Mythic was.
- kdazzle 14y agoMan, Ultima Online was so good. I would love to see this. And corpse-looting gave PvP adrenaline rushes and was something that UO did really well. Without that huge sense of having something to lose, the fights become meaningless and stale. Like in gambling.
- justjimmy 14y agoWow…just when I thought there was no more hope in MMO, this definitely revived my interest. I've always been a fan of: 1. Skill based system vs. Level/Class based system. 2. Looting Corpses/Houses 3. Player Housing 4. True/Open PvP Having said that, I'm not going to come near this game if it's going to offer: 1. Trammel 2. Insurance 3. Closed PvP 4. Class/Level System I don't mind the dated graphic looks. Look forward to more info. Hopefully they'll bring some old school principles and mechanics back.
- spqr 14y agoRichard, you have an aging fan base. The people who played your original Ultima games are adults with careers, wives and families. For that reason, you're focusing on the wrong type of game. Stop working on an MMO. We don't have time for it - we have lives. Do the best single player campaign game you can come up with and it will probably be far more successful than the MMOs you've worked on lately.
- Yuioup 14y agoI was going to back then until I realised it's an MMO. Not since 1995 did I ever want anything to do with MMO's and I have no intention of playing them. Please give me a meaningful single player experience.
- ssdsa 14y agoHoly cow! Everyone who pledged $10.000 or more receives a copy of "Akalabeth"! [ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akalabeth:_World_of_Doom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akalabeth:_World_of_Doom ]
- com2kid 14y agoIt is somewhat interesting that an online multiplayer game is having more difficulties raising funding than Torment, a single player RPG. Both seemingly have similar old school appeal, though the Planescape Torment audience is maybe slightly younger (5-8 years?) compared to fans of Ultima. I'll admit, while I threw a good chunk of money at Torment, this Kickstarter is less appealing to me just because it is Online. I also feel that there is some ambiguity over the vision of this game. The FAQ says this isn't an MMO , but you have online property you can buy and it has PvP? I am seriously confused as to the genre of this game. Confused people don't pledge.
- lordofmoria 14y agoThe timing on this and the Torment kickstarter is truly impeccable, with all the hate at DRM, EA. What better way to vent frustrations than help support the revival of the old-school? Personally, I really hope this succeeds. If KS represents the next generation of game studios/production, then I'm all for it.
- adamrights 14y agoI played Quantum on Atlantic and Heroku and later helped run parts of the Dr.Twister network :). Short of WoTMUD early UO is the best pk system I've ever experienced. I still talk of game memories with my brother and my friend Jason that played Sir Alf. I don't think the felucca 'carebear' world helped the game. Yes, there were some issues with griefing -- but the playerbase was in control (I admit I'd polymorph into a slime around coveous, flag myself gray, and have people attack me to freely pk them). When Sir Alf and I used to raid this RP heavy village, and we became a nuisance -- they hired guards...real players -- to keep us at bay. Eventually they befriended us and paid us in regents and offered protection. We once betrayed a friend in-game and the father called us -- I learned peer mediation from UO :) I got my first case of the shakes. I wish LB the best in this venture
- brisance 14y agoInevitably, there will always be tension between the creative aspects of one's vision and the need for viable product to keep the lights on. SotA is NOT UO or Ultima I-IX. It's a clean slate. Yes, it's good to have discussions about PvP and whatnot, because we are passionate about these things that have been with us through the years. On the other hand, consider why RG chose to go through Kickstarter. It's to free himself, his idea, from meddling managers who only care about the bottom line, the lowest common denominator, and not the creative aspects. And that's what kills art. I would prefer that we discuss what new and interesting behavior could arise if a certain gameplay mechanic were implemented, instead of "SotA needs PvP/perma-death/what-have-you because every other MMO has it".
- boksiora 14y agoI like it