13 ms·
VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously
- canttestthis 14y agoHow do these services monitor abusive customers if they don't even log user sessions?
- RKearney 14y agoDid you read the post? Here's just one example: Through packet level filtering at the firewall it’s possible to apply rules to an entire shared server, blocking the abuse immediately. For example, let’s say someone decides to use TorGuard to unlawfully promote their Ugg boots business (spam). In order for us to block this one individual, we simply implement new firewall rules, effectively blocking the abused protocol for everyone on that VPN server. Since there are no user logs to go by, we handle abuse per server, not per user. Seems like a silly way to handle it since eventually none of their servers will be able to access the internet.
- nwh 14y agoA VPN provides privacy not anonymity.
- Zirro 14y agoBehind an IP-address shared by many, I'd say you're pretty anonymous unless you give out your personal details. Would you like to explain why you think otherwise?
- nwh 14y agoYou are giving your real identity to a company that claims not to keep a log of your actions. As far as I'm aware, some of these providers give out unique IP addresses, or at least ones that aren't used by more than a handful of people. At any rate, determined law enforcement can pressure a provider into logging incoming connections. I wager that happens quite often. As another commenter suggested, they could all be honeypots. If I was going to trust my life to the anonymity of my data transfer, the last service I would want to be using is a VPN.
- Zirro 14y agoIf you assume the things you listed are going on at all VPN-services, I don't see how they supply "privacy" either. When it comes to law enforcement, I suppose there are differences in which approach they take depending on where the VPN-service is located. If law enforcement did what you suggest frequently in the country where I live, it would be presented as a scandal and would be the death of the VPN-service in question. Of course, you must choose a service you trust to not actually keep logs, and give out non-unique IP-adresses. However, if I lived in a country where I could not trust my government, I agree with you, I would avoid VPN-services located there.
- nwh 14y agoThey protect data in transit. If I use someone else's network my data is visible to them, no so much if I use a VPN.
- confluence 14y agoIf I were a governmental entity - I'd go ahead and set up my very own honeypot VPN provider. I'd then log everything - whilst providing exceptional service - and play the long game - collect as much data from people who self-select themselves as requiring large amounts of anonymity (the paranoid/people who can't access Hulu overseas/criminals/terrorists). I'd wait a few years and then use said data to slowly infiltrate various groups - looking to grab the big fish that are hopefully well separated from the VPN service and then take them down quietly. Hell - I might even turn a nice little profit on the side. Reality check: if your credit card details are visible to a third party - you're not anonymous. Note: I don't actually believe the above to actually be the case in reality - but one must remember that stuff like Room 641A weren't that long ago (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A). This is an example of where worst case thinking, despite its negative reputation, can help protect oneself from falling prey to the faulty assumptions that bring down complex systems (Will the generators kick in on time? What if the VPN provider is already compromised? Did we double check that after cleaning the safety valves - we didn't block any of them?).
- jacquesm 14y agoI'd set up a forum where I'd review these things to make sure that new entrants to the game would flock to my bugged services. I'd give articles there titles that suggest that the competition does not take your privacy seriously.
- benologist 14y agoWhy use a forum? It'd be much easier to just set up a blog and anonymously write heavily baited articles for other site's communities.
- antihero 14y agoI'd write an article on TorrentFreak and post it on Hacker News...
- Zirro 14y ago"If I were a governmental entity..." In that case, you would be a governmental entity which does not care much for the rights of your citizens. Instead, pick a service in a country with a transparent, low corruption-government. I suggest the Scandinavian countries.
- venomsnake 14y agoI hope that some of them will allow P2P inside their networks. That could solve a lot of problems. Anyway - does some of the services allow for independent audit of their systems to confirm that the policies they claim are real and enforced?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- donniezazen 14y agoWill your ISP or government get interested in you if you anonymize your connection through VPN or Tor?
- noarchy 14y agoThey might, but as many HNers can no doubt testify, many of us use VPNs for remote work, and I know a fair number of government workers who do this, too. It isn't optional; it is a requirement.
- donniezazen 14y agoCan one say more number of people use VPN/Tor for legal purposes than illegal?
- noarchy 14y agoVPNs, possibly. I don't know, for sure, how many use them for work, versus those who use them to evade governments. In the latter category it could encompass things as varied as pirating tv shows, to circumventing the Great Firewall of China. But Chinese workers use VPNs for remote work, too. As for Tor, I doubt that anyone is using that for work, but I also doubt that many are really using it for anything illegal. To be sure, there are the Silk Road-type sites, but Tor speeds are not conducive to piracy (and Bit Torrent is highly discouraged on the Tor network).
- unsignedint 14y agoThere's incentive to use VPN beyond the simple matter of anonymity. I, for example, often work/connect from Starbucks, and their wi-fi is not encrypted, and anything with Wi-fi monitor capability can pretty much scan all the traffic going through. (Theoretically, someone with a malicious motive can scan your traffic at VPN end, but what I'm talking about here is more of an unmanageable risk of someone with Wireshark at the range of WI-fi. Using the same with Tor is probably a bad idea, as potentially, anyone operating exit nodes can potentially log the traffic.) Especially in the case your work really doesn't offer real VPN to their corporate network, it is the next best thing to have. (Especially when they are affordable) You could have VPN looped through your home, but in this age of bandwidth capping, it is getting a less appealing option.
- johnpowell 14y agoI have a seedbox on OVH. I use sFTP to download from it. And I use a SSH tunnel to browse through that server. It is about 15 bucks a month. OVH could give me up but I am one of thousands. There is lower hanging fruit so I don't worry.
- vilgax 14y agoQuoting from the article it says "We are in compliance with DMCA as all companies, world-wide, must be." I didn't know that it's applicable worldwide. Wikipedia article states that it's an American law. Is there some kind of International treaty or that assumption is false?
- icebraining 14y agoWikipedia is right, they're idiots. Related: https://thepiratebay.se/legal https://thepiratebay.se/legal
- kintamanimatt 14y agoYou only have to be DMCA compliant if you're in some way based in the US. Complying with US laws when you're a non-US company is like complying with Australia's laws if you're a Canadian company.
- robinh 14y agoBut wasn't there something a while back about how people had to comply with US law if they owned a .com/.net/.org domain, since these were managed in the US?
- fiendsan 14y agothe only problem with this is trust, you have to trust that these companies will do what they say, there is no way to confirm it, maybe all of them are logging and they just say otherwise, and when we are talking about privacy and anonymity thats a bigggg deal breaker! also just because they do it now, doesn't mean that tomorrow they wont just turn on the logging... if you want anonymity and privacy you can only trust yourself and your own setup, leaving it at the hands of others is a huge exposure, as a sidenote since you are also using the services of a company that might attract the wrong sort of people that also migh expose you to potential problems (they give you up wrongfully, bad logs, payments to that company, the list goes on...)
- rdl 14y agoI'd be wary of any service specifically marketing to high-risk activities unless there are strong technical controls to make it trustworthy. There are no existing mainstream VPN providers who have strong technical controls to protect user privacy OR anonymity. There's Tor, and some other systems like that, which make a stronger technical case for anonymity. There's still a place for VPNs, but it's not as an anonymity service. On the other hand, I'd want all services to have high security built in -- your mainstream mail provider, mainstream note-taking service, etc. Some of that is technical (a "hostproof" architecture if possible, good internal audit on administrative interfaces, personnel security, etc.). But then, you're one of a mainstream company's customers, vs. a subscriber of the "illegal activity hiding service". There are "mainstream" uses of VPNs (business, local-privacy, desire to defeat geolocation, firewall-busting, etc.), for which they're great. There are some purposes (anonymity) for which they're horrible. There are things like file sharing in contravention of your ISP's policies or national law where they may work but might not be the best solution -- I'd really go with a seedbox instead of running peer to peer traffic over a VPN.
- davepeck 14y agoOne thousand times yes. VPNs have many uses, but true anonymity ain't one. I wrote a bit about it on our blog, here: https://www.getcloak.com/blog/2011/11/30/word-anonymity/ https://www.getcloak.com/blog/2011/11/30/word-anonymity/
- nachteilig 14y agoThis is what I'd be really interested in seeing--a list of good seedbox providers.
- rdl 14y agoWhat I'd really like is a file sharing network more in keeping with the original "mojo nation" concept vs. what we have with bittorrent. Tahoe-LAFS might be the best project right now.
- ksec 14y agoWhy would someone sign up for VPN when they could have set up the same thing with a much cheaper VPS? Anyway i am currently looking for something similar to Amazon silk and Opera Turbo, where the server downloads the page, compress it and send it back to you. Extremely useful for low bandwidth connection, as well as providing half of the VPN function. Does anyone know of software / scripts / services that are available?
- Hates_ 14y agoI would have thought that being the named owner of the VPS exposes you legally somehow, also that performing something like "illegal file-sharing" would be against your VPS's TOS.
- icelancer 14y agoYes, this will be an issue - encryption or not.
- mbq 14y agoBecause VPN works by diluting responsibility; i.e. in theory there is no problem to confirm that you have connect to a VPN/VPS X and that X made illegal action Y. However, while in case of VPN there are N other people who were also connected to X and thus might be blamed for Y, in case of VPS you are alone.
- acabal 14y agoI'm starting to feel like anonymity on the internet is going to be one of the most important challenges in the next decade. Especially with stuff like 6 strikes starting the ball rolling (today it's warning messags, in ten years it might be disconnection for breaking any of modern society's myriad and unfathomable laws). The internet wasn't built with anonymity in mind; eventually an IP address has to be tied to a paying customer. Is there any way we can build on today's technology to ensure anonymity on a grand scale? I.e., so that your grandma is surfing anonymously, even though she doesn't know it, using the iPad she just bought?
- robinh 14y agoThe answer might be something like Tor.
- nikster 14y agoNot something like, the answer is TOR. Thats exactly what it is for. Anonymity.
- robinh 14y agoEh, I was mostly responding to the 'grandma using an iPad' part. It's quite possible that Tor will eventually be what everyone uses for anonymity on the internet, but it might well turn out out to be something different. Hence the 'something like'. ;)
- thematt 14y agoUnless the government can see both what's entering Tor and what's exiting it. Then you're screwed.
- plg 14y agobut with Tor you are only anonymous at the exit node, right? Sure, your ISP (or anyone else listening in) doesn't know WHERE you are connecting to, when you use Tor, but if the connection isn't encrypted (for example using SSL or ssh) then they sure can listen in to WHAT you are sending and receiving. In other words if the traffic between your computer and the Tor entrance node is not encrypted (and it wouldn't be unless you are using SSL or ssh), your ISP (or any third party listening in on that traffic) can read everything you are doing. Or am I mistaken?
- cmpctyd 14y agoVPNs are constantly being mentioned as a solution to companies, governments, etc attacking privacy but it's extremely easy to make a bad choice and end up with more than you bargained for (a VPN ran by someone you were trying to escape, for example). It is still possible to do the following: 1) Wiretap the VPN. 2) Correlate with bandwidth/time. 3) Keep logs as a VPN provider. 4) Hack the VPN and do something evil (log, change content) 5) Block access to/from the VPN. 6) Correlate access logs with the VPN IP address (not always applicable, not all providers give unique IP addresses) The VPN provider doesn't have to want to betray you to do so. I could create "ProTurboVPN" and promise "anonymity", privacy and no logging, "nobody's touching your data!" but it won't stop the above problems. Even if I want to save the world as a VPN provider, I might not be able and it's safer to remember that than pretend I can and in the process, get someone into trouble.
- tomp 14y ago> We are in compliance with DMCA as all companies, world-wide, must be. Really? Why would a company that has no presence in the US have to comply with the DMCA? I see that one danger might be having it's domain seized, but AFAIK only if it's one of the domains controlled by US companies (.org, .com, .net, ...).
- rmc 14y agoI'm also not aware of what the "European equivalent" of a DMCA the article talks about it. Seems like a lot of "didn't do the homework" in this article
- mef 14y agoCouldn't a wiretap order compel a VPN company (even one with a reputation for anonymity) to transparently begin logging any data having to do with the target of the wiretap? The VPN company does have the capability to log, after all. Could they just refuse?
- pyre 14y agoDepends on what you're trying to do. If you're just trying to escape from the copyright groups, then it might be enough to just get a VPN in another country, especially one with weak copyright support. Then you just look like someone in that country, for the most part. The low-hanging fruit right now far out-numbers people hiding behind VPN / proxies / Tor.
- davepeck 14y agoI built GetCloak.com. I draw a hard distinction between privacy and anonymity and feel that it's disingenuous for VPN services to claim that they offer anonymity. Here's our take on it: https://www.getcloak.com/blog/2011/11/30/word-anonymity/ https://www.getcloak.com/blog/2011/11/30/word-anonymity/
- SomeCallMeTim 14y agoToo bad you aren't protecting anyone but Mac/iOS users, though. :(
- davepeck 14y agoSoon, my friend. Soon. :)
- VikingCoder 14y agoIf I counted right, there were 13 providers listed. If I had a ton of money, and wanted to be really, really anonymous, could I pay all of them, tunnel through all of them somehow, and then get 13 layers of privacy? (And very high latency!) How about two - are there two of them that I could somehow run one inside the other? Maybe I'd have to surf from a VM using one of them, running on a machine using another of them?
- glomph 14y agoIf you pay all of them with your details, then who ever was after you would only have to strong arm one / a few before it became obvious who they were after.
- seunosewa 14y agoThe first one you connect to will have all your data.
- HoochTHX 14y agoIts actually the last one that has ALL the data. I am currently using a chained VPN setup using 3 routers that with DD-WRT OpenVPN installed, PC->Router1(VPN3)->Router2(VPN2)->Router3(VPN1)->Modem All three encrypted. I am also using Tor on top of this because as someone else said this is a static version of the onion system. I've pretty much accepted the fact that if someone chooses to find out what I am doing they will find a way, but I am going to make it as difficult as possible.
- networked 14y agoThis would be a reinvention of onion routing [1], only more vulnerable to traffic analysis than Tor because, for one thing, you'd be the only person using it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onion_routing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onion_routing
- nadaviv 14y agoYou could setup tor nodes on your own servers, than configure your client to use them and mix in some regular public nodes. Its even better if you make your tor nodes public and let other people use them too, to make it more difficult to correlate traffic sent from/to the server with you.
- nonpme 14y agoI know that using VPN I "trust" the VPN owner, because he has all the data I send/receive. I was thinking about such setup: buy VPS (for example: linode; it would be good to buy one anonymously), setup my own VPN (openvpn) and then use some external (for example: mullvad) VPN provider. I'm not sure if it's right or more secure that regular VPN, without additional steps. Can someone comment? I have a couple more questions: 1. how can I use Tor with VPN the most efficient/anonymous way? should I connect VPN -> Tor or Tor -> VPN? 2. Can you point me to good resources about privacy/anonimyty online and linux configuration for privacy? Thanks for help.
- fuzzbang 14y agoWhile there are definitely benefits to using a VPN, they do not provide anonymity. They provide privacy, and it is not the same thing. "No one is going to go to jail for you". If a VPN provider is legally required to log your activity or face jail time, guess what? you're getting logged! To assume otherwise is just asking for trouble. All of this is better addressed in this slidedeck. http://www.slideshare.net/grugq/opsec-for-hackers http://www.slideshare.net/grugq/opsec-for-hackers
- lowglow 14y agohttp://valleyanon.com/ http://valleyanon.com/ - I'm building an anonymous blogging platform to help people tell their story without fear. I think anonymity online should be available to everyone and I'd love any feedback you might have.