13 ms·
Elon Musk: Boeing 787 battery fundamentally unsafe
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- garretruh 14y agoWhile I have enormous respect for Elon Musk, I would hope that Boeing engineers have just as thorough an understanding of the workings and safety implications of Lithium-ion batteries. Though Tesla's engineering is admittedly much more focused around battery technology, Boeing has decades of experience with aircraft electrical systems.
- avelis 14y agoIt would appear that Boeing had a small oversight. Building a plane is not like building a car. There are different requirements. While some requirements overlap there are clear fundamental differences. Now, with that said, it could be that SpaceX and Tesla were allowed to focus more on batteries while Boeing had to improve jet engine efficiency as well as electrical battery usage.
- neurotech1 14y agoSpaceX and Tesla try to keep as much of this in-house as possible, so they can maintain full oversight and make changes without unnecessary cost overhead. Boeing had 10 layers of contractors involved in this SNAFU. WWED = What Would Elon Do.
- Joe_Knapp 14y agoI fear Boeing's problems are not limited to these batteries.
- gvb 14y agoPedantic: Boeing subcontracted the jet engine efficiency improvements to Rolls-Royce (Trent 1000) and GE (GEnx). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolls-Royce_Trent_1000 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolls-Royce_Trent_1000 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Electric_GEnx http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Electric_GEnx
- druiid 14y agoIn this case it is pretty pedantic I'm afraid. Engine subcontracting is pretty standard in aviation. Nearly all of the engine types I can think of are either GE or Rolls-Royce. It's kind of like Rotax for motorcycles and Snowmobiles... give the designs or specifications to a supplier and have them do all of the heavy lifting.
- MikeCapone 14y agoI'm sure Airbus engineers are also great with wing design, yet they recently had problems with the A380 wings because it was something new with which they didn't have as much experience. The same could be said about these advanced lithium-ion batteries, I believe.
- djt 14y agono doubt Boeing know that even if the batteries smoke and fail they wont be a threat to safety, but Musk has a better handle on marketing. If there is smoke on a plane or car people expect the worst, regardless of if it is actually a safety issue.
- jlgreco 14y agoI don't know, don't Li-ion batteries tend to fail fairly spectacularly? Those melted cars after Sandy come to mind.
- martinced 14y agoFrom my limited experience with smoke in cars, sadly they often turn to fire. Because, you know, like the first humans that did create fire, very often when a fire starts there's smoke... I've seen a Saab in which the ashtray started to smoke and then before we could pull out (on the highway) the dashboard had flames and started to melt. And I've seen a very nice and shiny Porsche 911 Carrera model 964 whose alternator belt did broke and then started "burning" on the engine. We smelled it and then we could see smoke. By the time we opened the engine trunk (with our fire extinguisher in hand) it was on fire. Funnily enough the repair were under warranty and there wasn't much to change (the trunk needed to be repaint and one or two pieces changed). When there is unexpected smoke on a plane it is a safety issue. Seen that a Boeing supplier's factory went up in flames due to a battery that took fire, I'm not exactly sure there's "no doubt Boeing know that even if the batteries smoke and fail they won't be a threat to safety". Same for the 16 hybrid sport cars that burst into flames on that parking lot due to batteries shorting. I think that: "There's no smoke without fire" may be the sentence you're after ; )
- Joe_Knapp 14y agoI don't think smoke is the issue. It's toxic fumes. It's not like you can open a window.
- djt 14y agoyes in a Petrol car there is a problem with smoke = fire. My whole point is that smoke in a petrol engine usually means something as either caught fire etc. Smoke in a Battery compartment may or may not. Is it a safety issue? Probably, but not definitely. Do the general public have a problem with smoke on a plane? Hell yes. Our experience with traditional cars and planes is that where there is smoke there is fire. That may or may not be true with the batteries, I dont know but I do know that Boeing do a LOT of testing, so would be suprised to see a plane go down due to these problems. I believe the cars you were talking about were completely submerged in sea water and then caught fire. Presumably any car or plane submerged in sea water will get written off which is probably why they dont worry too much about it.
- neurotech1 14y agoI have enormous respect for Elon Musk, and he's right, large cells without thermal barriers between cells are dangerous. Boeing doesn't have a "decade of experience" with Lithium-Ion batteries though. The particular type of batteries have an elevated risk profile, but are light weight. The 787 has a larger APU than previous aircraft, and requires a larger battery to start the APU. These particular batteries are Lithium Cobalt Oxide. One of the sub-contractors, Securaplane, who made the battery controller/charger, had their factory destroyed by fire, after a battery malfunction in 2006. Edit: Cessna had problems with their Lithium-Ion batteries in some Citations, and had to replace them with NiCADs in a emergency airworthiness directive.
- rst 14y agoIt's not necessarily Boeing's engineers. A lot of the 787 design (not just fabrication) was subcontracted out, so it's just as likely to have been whatever subcontractor had the combination of low bid and business connections to win the contract. Ref: http://www.newyorker.com/talk/financial/2013/02/04/130204ta_talk_surowiecki http://www.newyorker.com/talk/financial/2013/02/04/130204ta_...
- joezydeco 14y agoThe 787 electrical design was subcontracted to Thales, who then subcontracted the battery work to GS Yuasa: http://www.gsyuasa-lp.com/content/thales-selects-gs-yuasa-lithium-ion-battery-system-boeing%E2%80%99s-787-dreamliner http://www.gsyuasa-lp.com/content/thales-selects-gs-yuasa-li...
- chernevik 14y agoI shouldn't be surprised if there aren't several people within Boeing with exactly the right expertise. Whether they were identified and listened to by management is a separate question. If Musk is right (IANA Battery Guy), I would presume there are cost / design trade-offs involved. And some exec had to evaluate those against safety issues. Those are engineering decisions, they're also business decisions. If the execs deciding that didn't have the proper background to make an engineering evaluation himself, they are left trying to decide which engineers to trust. It isn't at all hard to see someone getting that wrong.
- starpilot 14y agoI'm an aeromechanical engineer, not an electrical one, but I suspect the fewer-cells design was chosen to save weight. Many unconventional design decisions in aerospace (everything with holes, novel materials which trickle down to cars and golf clubs) are driven by the need to reduce weight.
- chernevik 14y agoThese systems replaced hydraulics for surface control, right? On a weight advantage? Making good on a decision like that is exactly what confirmation bias is all about.
- cpleppert 14y agoThe hydraulics are controlled exactly the same as any other fly by wire aircraft like the 777 or a modern airbus. The computer takes the pilot inputs and combines them with a flight computer that controls electric motors which move the flight surfaces with hydraulics. The big increase in electrical supply (4x over the 777 i believe) is the result of the bleedless air architecture that boeing chose. There was a big push by boeing to make the system work as it was a selling point for the public and carriers. I think that decision didn't receive the scrutiny that it probably should have.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Camillo 14y agoThis is a very smart move by Musk from a PR point of view. By accusing Boeing's batteries of being fundamentally unsafe, he garners the maximum amount of trust from people who are concerned about battery safety, so that, when he immediately follows up with an explanation of why this couldn't happen on a Tesla, those very people are already leaning towards believing him. This goes over much better than attempting to defend the safety of high-density batteries in general.
- MikeCapone 14y agoI think he probably saw it as a defensive move: He doesn't want li-ion technology to get a bad name, and that doesn't mean only explaining why Tesla's approach is safe, but also trying to help others avoid mistakes that could hurt the whole industry including his company.
- dmix 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_best_defense_is_a_good_offense http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_best_defense_is_a_good_offe... > Generally the idea is that offensive action preoccupies the opposition and ultimately its ability to directly harm.
- nextparadigms 14y agoThat makes sense.
- Osmium 14y ago> This is a very smart move by Musk from a PR point of view. This is an awful PR move if he's wrong. I hope he's sure.
- sfall 14y agoan MIT professor already backs up what he is saying, he is not on his own with his opinion
- 14y ago
- eduardordm 14y agoElon seems to really want to get involved in this. Make no mistake, Boeing and SpaceX are fierce competitors for government contracts with very dubious selection processes. I'm saying this because he is a businessman, not an engineer. He seems to be getting a lot of information about the 787s batteries inner workings when the number of airplanes and suppliers are very limited. Edit: I'm not trying to be cynical, but I do think that if Elon really wanted to help he should contact Boeing and do it instead of playing politics.
- sfall 14y agowhile not a PE he is no slouch, he has a bachelor's in physics
- Evbn 14y agoWhich covers 0 information about Li battery vs other kinds, especially considering when he earned his Bachelor's.
- jonknee 14y agoThen there's that small matter of his founding an electric car company that uses Lithium Ion batteries. Oh and the rocket company. I can't imagine many people more qualified to talk about LiIon and aerospace.
- digikata 14y agoIs a Professional Engineer certification relevant here? All the PEs I've met work in the civil engineering field.
- itp 14y agoSounds like you only know people with Civil PEs, then. There are different examinations and qualifications for different disciplines. Source: my wife is a Naval Architecture PE.
- WestCoastJustin 14y agoForbes is running an article [1], suggesting it is in Boeing/SpaceX/Tesla's goint best interested to prove/make safe lithium ion batteries. Reason being, they all have products that use them, and they should have a great reputation, and there should be zero stigma attached to them. [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/davidewalt/2013/01/29/why-elon-musk-wants-to-help-boeing-fix-the-dreamliner/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/davidewalt/2013/01/29/why-elon-m...
- jpeg_hero 14y agoEverybody thought Musk was grandstanding when he first made the offer, but it sounds like he's got the answers!
- AndrewKemendo 14y agoThis a month and a half after Boeing/Lockheed was derisive about Musk publicly: http://go.bloomberg.com/political-capital/2012-12-18/musk-vs-lockheed/ http://go.bloomberg.com/political-capital/2012-12-18/musk-vs...
- lostlogin 14y agoGood link. One would hope that had nothing to do with it, but....
- josefresco 14y agoWow, a $70 billion market dominated by essentially only two major players. Sounds like a market ripe for disruption.
- notahacker 14y agoIf you have the ability to put together a team that can raise a few hundred million in venture capital to go after a few big government contracts, then maybe. There's a reason why some markets are dominated by essentially two major players. Not sure where the $70 billion valuation comes from either, but if you add together the market capitalization of Boeing, Lockheed Martin and SpaceX you're still under $100 billion. Boeing and Lockheed Martin also make other stuff.
- backprojection 14y agoSo what's the motivation for using these batteries in the 787 anyway? Can they just switch to whatever they've used before?
- sp332 14y agoThe new engine requires much higher-capacity batteries to start them. A battery with the old tech would be huge and heavy. The new battery technology is much lighter than the old ones.
- lostlogin 14y agoThat's interesting - why are the batteries onboard and not ground equipment? Obviously restarting a stalled engine would be handy, but is this something that actually happens? And if it is, couldn't the running jets provide the power somehow? I seem to remember that some old WW2 prop aircraft had ground equipment requirements to start them from cold (power or warmed air or something?) Obviously this isn't an area I know about but I am curious about it. Thanks.
- joezydeco 14y agoI found a Boeing technical publication that discusses the power architecture of the 787 and how the battery comes into play. Kind of interesting: http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/qtr_4_07/article_02_1.html http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/qtr_4... Page 4 says this: "The power source for APU starting may be the airplane battery, a ground power source, or an engine-driven generator. The power source for engine starting may be the APU generators, engine-driven generators on the opposite side engine, or two forward 115 VAC ground power sources. The aft external power receptacles may be used for a faster start, if desired." So the battery seems to be very important when you're somewhere with no ground generator. The battery starts the APU, then the power from the APU starts the engines.
- jessaustin 14y agoSo the battery seems to be very important when you're somewhere with no ground generator. Like in the sky? After your engines have stopped for some reason? That could be exciting!
- supercanuck 14y agoThe public doesn't see this as Larry Ellison criticizing Bill Gates, but that is essentially what is happening.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- wnoise 14y agoWhat do you mean by this analogy?
- snowwrestler 14y agoOne fierce competitor in an industry publicly criticizing another. (Their motives may not be completely pure.)
- apapli 14y agoI think this is a very smart move by Musk. Grow the Tesla brand at very little cost, and potentially win a new client to sell batteries to. Surely a Boeing contract would bring decent margins (they will now pay a premium for a quick fix) and much bigger scale economies for Tesla to further decrease their operating cost base.
- robomartin 14y agoWhile I can't dispute anything that is being said I think it is unfortunate that this is playing out the way it is. I can't dispute it because there's virtually no reliable publicly-available information on the design of this battery pack. I think it is unbecoming of an engineer or scientist, particularly of prominence, to voice such opinions without access to design data from the source. Before I could even begin to dare to voice opinion I would need to study CAD models, electrical and electronic diagrams and test data. I would also want to have access to representative samples of the packs for inspection. Even then, unless there was something so obviously wrong with the design that a conclusion was inescapable I'd refrain from rash public comments and redouble evaluation efforts to make sure every angle was evaluated exhaustively. Having designed high-performance, high-current chargers in the past I know a thing or two about battery technology, particularly when it comes to failure modes. When you are doing that kind of work you purposely test designs to induce and document failures and design around them when possible. Yes, I have blown-up lots of batteries and chargers. And, yes, this means that if you've worked with high-energy battery technologies (and electronics in general) you get a good general sense of the good, the bad and the ugly. I get it. And I would still want design and test data from the horses-mouth before uttering a word. The problem here is that the engineers at Boeing are not clowns. Unless you consider people with advanced degrees from the top engineering schools in the world to be clowns. This is an industry that takes what they do very, very seriously. A lot of work, simulation and testing goes into all of their projects. I could not imagine the engineers at Boeing slapping together a battery pack for something like the 787 project without years of work and testing. I just can't see it. Yet, they are human beings which means that mistakes and miscalculations do happen. That's true of any human endeavor. And so, making such comments is also disrespectful. I understand competitive forces very well. But there's a time and a place for that. If he is wrong he'll have a lot of explaining to do. If that is the case I hope he'll devote just as much energy to issuing the necessary apologies and clarifications as he does being critical. EDIT: If you ever get a chance to visit the Boeing factory in Seattle it is a must. I did many years ago. As an engineer it was fascinating. I remember one test they showed us where they clamped down (I think) a 747 wing in this huge structure and used incredibly large hydraulic jacks to bend the wing up and down repeatedly for failure-mode testing. I could be wrong, but I think I remember the peak to peak bending at the wing-tip was in the order of ten stories. I could not imagine designing and building an electro-mechanical structure that could do that and survive with enough functionality to get people safely back to ground level. I think this might be it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRf395ioJRY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRf395ioJRY Here's video on the 787 wing: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sA9Kato1CxA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sA9Kato1CxA Also: http://www.wired.com/autopia/2010/03/boeing-787-passes-incredible-wing-flex-test/ http://www.wired.com/autopia/2010/03/boeing-787-passes-incre... So, yes, please, I think it might be wise to remain quiet and let those who actually have real data go through a proper investigative process and get us real answers. If anything out of respect for the work, talent and dedication that goes into designing and building such amazing products.
- gtani 14y agoin addition to NYT story, Seattle Times, which has a reporter fulltime on aviation http://seattletimes.com/html/businesstechnology/2020241162_787battery29xml.html http://seattletimes.com/html/businesstechnology/2020241162_7...
- jessaustin 14y ago"I design a cell to not fail and then assume it will and the ask the next 'what-if' questions," Sinnett, [Boeing's 787 chief project engineer] said. "And then I design the batteries that if there is a failure of one cell it won't propagate to another. And then I assume that I am wrong and that it will propagate to another and then I design the enclosure and the redundancy of the equipment to assume that all the cells are involved and the airplane needs to be able to play through that." OK, maybe part of this is bravado, and it seems that the failure of one cell certainly has spread to another, but so far at least no plane has crashed as a result. I think Boeing's engineers should get some credit for that? One could imagine worse results than we've seen, especially in fields of engineering that don't have aviation's safety practices.
- cpleppert 14y ago>>but so far at least no plane has crashed as a result. I think Boeing's engineers should get some credit for that? There are a grand total of 49 planes total that have been produced and the plane has been in service for little over a year. The fact that no plane has crashed tells you nothing statistically about the safety record of the design. The fact that aviation has a great safety record is MORE reason to worry about any issue, not less. Modern commercial planes are expected to fly for decades over tens of thousands of flights. Even a small issue that is incredibly unlikely is too dangerous when compared to the great safety record of existing airplanes.
- ck2 14y agoThey should switch to LiFePo4 chemistry which will not burn. My bike battery is made of that.
- keeperofdakeys 14y agoLiFePO4 and LiMn2O4 chemistries aren't magic, although they are less prone to 'rapid disassembly', there is always a possibility. LiCO4 does have advantages though, mainly related to energy density. For something like a car, or a plane, higher energy density in cells means greater efficiency for weight vs. energy potential. Also, it isn't like lithium cobalt is going to explode if you look at it wrong. Nearly all the risk can be prevented by proper cell management, via electronics. LiFePO4 and LiMn2O4 have the advantage of larger output potential, which for your bike, allows a large amount of power to be put into the electric motor from a small battery. Electric cars/planes get around this by putting lots of cells in parallel, but requires quite a lot of regulation.
- gregcohn 14y agoThis article makes it sound like it could have been an issue more with the human factors surrounding battery user than with the battery itself. http://seattletimes.com/html/businesstechnology/2020241385_787deadbatteriesxml.html http://seattletimes.com/html/businesstechnology/2020241385_7...
- yardie 14y ago> Japanese inspectors have cleared the maker of the battery, GS Yuasa, of any defects before the unit leaves the factory. But both Japanese and US investigators continue to examine and test the batteries to understand why they failed after they were integrated into the 787 electrical system and operated on commercial flights. So it's not the batteries but how they are integrated into the plane? How is this any different than how Tesla has packed their cells? Their cells looked pretty densely packed from my POV.
- codex 14y agoI've found that humans are much better at doing than they are at thinking. Humans can generate countless hypotheses and evidence to support those hypotheses, and yet most human theories are flat out wrong. This is why we have the scientific method, which verifies hypothesis with good old fashioned elbow grease. The real "five whys" question here is: "Why did this battery get through Boeing's (most certainly exhaustive) certification process and win FAA approval?" Boeing is well aware of the risks of lithium ion batteries and must have "proven" to themselves and the FAA that this design was sound through rigorous testing. I suspect there is an "unknown unknown" here; something so unexpected a test couldn't be fathomed to exercise it. How does one find unknown unknowns? It's a fascinating question.
- jevinskie 14y agoQ
- EEGuy 14y agoThere is a published picture [1] of one of the failed assemblies next to a normal assembly of the same type, sitting on a forklift pallet. It's easy to gauge the assemblies' physical size and count a minimum of 16 visible cells. Not visible in the photograph are bus bars or power connector. I don't see a lot of paint discoloration, and a label of some kind is not charred or much discolored. [1] http://phys.org/news/2013-01-overcharging-batteries-eyed-boeing-mishaps.html http://phys.org/news/2013-01-overcharging-batteries-eyed-boe...
- alan_cx 14y agoFrom a complete position of ignorance, I have never felt comfortable with these batteries in aeroplanes. On of my wastes of time is RC modelling. These batteries have been used now for quite some time for power. What we RC people know is that while these batteries have great performance, it very easy to make one blow up if not handled correctly. Enough burned out sheds can testify to this. So, even if the engineers say they they can use them safely, I will always feel nervous of their use. Fine for things like RC models, laptops, phones, real cars even etc, but the plane use, to me, has a question mark against it. OK, Im 100% sure engineers can make a great defence of their use, but there will always be a nagging doubt for me.
- alanctgardner2 14y agoI think people have exaggerated feelings of insecurity about planes versus cars. Maybe it's because heavier-than-air flight just doesn't jive mentally, or maybe it's because you have very little personal control when flying. Either way, you carry these batteries on your person, in your coat pocket, in a bag, leave them in your study downstairs, hell, drive around in a big box made of them. Fisker Karmas were in the nasty habit of bursting into flames, but that was viewed as a one-off design flaw, not a crushing blow to 'batteries in cars' as a concept. I think the collective anxiety we feel towards planes, as a culture, shapes our views of these incidents too much. If your car was on fire on the highway you may not have handled it as well as the pilot in this scenario.
- LnxPrgr3 14y agoEven old-fashioned gasoline cars carry with them a tank of incredibly flammable fuel, a battery that can dump hundreds of amps into a short circuit (and that vents explosive gas in normal operation), and a much higher risk of colliding with other things on the ground. IIRC car crashes kill on the order of 30,000 people a year in the US. That said, I have had my engine catch fire while driving down the Interstate. It took me a few seconds to pull over and get out of the car. The best pilot ever isn't about to land a 787 from cruising altitude anywhere near as fast. I can only hope the design keeps the battery fire from endangering life or taking out anything else important in the meantime. But my understanding is the rate of spectacular li-ion battery failures is phenomenally low. Incidents happen, but the vast majority of batteries behave themselves. From the early reports I've heard, the Boeing situation sounds like one of abuse. But like I said with the Fisker situation, we won't really know anything about Boeing's situation until the investigations are complete. Either way, I'll drop my phone in my pocket today with confidence, right before doing something else far more likely to hurt me: driving to work.
- 3amOpsGuy 14y agoI'm just surprised there isn't more damage from the fire! I use similar chemistry batteries (although much smaller) in RC planes (they are very energy dense for their weight). When they are damaged (normally through charging incorrectly but in some cases through puncture / crash damage) they burn extremely rapidly and very violently for their size. The damage in the photographs of the 787 is not on the scale i was expecting.
- jlgreco 14y agoThis is a bit off-topic, but I have been considering retrofitting my roomba with Li-ion batteries but am a bit concerned about the fire risk (partly because I don't want to loose the roomba, but mostly since it is in my apartment.) Is there anything that comes to mind that I should particularly look out for or consider?
- 3amOpsGuy 14y agoMay be worth exploring the differences between "safer" cells such as LiFe / A123 vs the riskier Li-ion & LiPo types. I understand the charging strategy for A123 is much simpler to implement than for Li-Ion (may not even need a micro controller) but i'm not 100% confident in that statement!
- jlgreco 14y agoI'll look into that, thanks!
- nextparadigms 14y agoSo basically Boeing chose to use the cheaper kind of batteries, instead of the more secure kind. I imagine isolating thousands of tiny cells is quite a bit more expensive than isolating much larger ones.
- dade_ 14y agoI think Elon is justified for taking a public stance to protect his own interests. As his companies develop products with the same battery technology, it is likely that the hazards of the Boeing battery design could become associated to the entire battery technology. This would be disastrous for his organizations. I consider this a pre-emptive defensive move against technically ignorant public and media. Boeing has a strong reputation and will surely weather this mess just fine by identifying corrective action and doing the right thing.
- codex 14y agoElon might know a thing or two here, as just last year Tesla's battery testing facility caught on fire [1]. In the absence of more information, allow me to publicly speculate that perhaps that facility is fundamentally unsafe. <g> [1] http://abclocal.go.com/kgo/story?section=news/local/peninsula&id=8498972 http://abclocal.go.com/kgo/story?section=news/local/peninsul...
- teyc 14y agoBeing a bit snarky there? Fukushima reminded me that there are some designs that required active safety systems, while others like thorium reactors can be designed with passive safety system. Musk was not offering to help out with designing a new plane. He was offering help with battery systems. This, he has more expertise than Boeing or its direct subcontractor did. Musk did not strike me as a person who have actively sought out publicity for publicity's sake in the past. Personally, I'd rather more eyes went through the design of a plane that I might ride in one day. Teslas are too pricey for me.