5 ms·
An open letter to Steve Jobs about approving the amber alert application
- pantsd 18y agoThe letter points out a number of competing methods of delivering mobile applications, but the way it is worded leaves me wondering if the AMBER alter application is available on any these platforms?
- jgrahamc 18y agoI did a search for this and it does not appear to be.
- jgrahamc 18y agoWhat's really missing here, if you want to do this right, is a way to have the application run in the background with GPS active. Then I could get alerted to missing children who have been abducted close to where I am.
- ars 18y agoCan the iPhone do something like cron, or alarms? This program doesn't need to run all the time, every 15 minutes is enough.
- dharris 18y agoNo. The iPhone cannot currently do anything like that. There was an early preview talk about a background push framework at Apple's WWDC in June 2008, but still hasn't been made real yet. I appreciate the app author's desire to create something that can enhance the AMBER alert system, I think that this app will be useless until the iPhone supports background processing.
- redrobot5050 18y agoYeah, and more importantly, can't you just sign up your phone (you know, with a phone number) for TXT or SMS alerts from the AMBER ALERT folks? I'm certain some of my family members have gotten AMBER ALERT TXTs before. And then, you know, since your phone has internet access you could just pull up their webpage or local news through safari.
- hboon 18y agoNo. A notification API/service was supposed to be available to work around this. But no further (public) news about it has been released.
- ars 18y ago<incredulous>You can't even make an alarm clock app for the iPhone??</incredulous>
- hboon 18y agoYou can. But the user must keep the app running, i.e. cannot switch to another app or go to the homescreen. Switching off the screen (the power button), or answer (not initiating) phone calls is OK. Which is kind of a big limitation. But really has been OK for millions of users so far...
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- jzdziarski 18y agoUnfortunately the SDK doesn't allow backgrounding, but for the 1.7 million users running Cydia, they can install Backgrounder to keep AMBER Alert running in the background. It has a built-in background checking utility so that it will vibrate and set a badge if you're, say, looking at one of the other pages in the application. If you background the app with Backgrounder, this mechanism continues to run as well, providing notifications every 30 minutes.
- qubikle 18y agoYikes, the answer to this problem is so simple. I had a similar problem, and really, all you have to do is call the folks at apple. There's a number hidden somewhere for the app store team, you call them and they will escalate the matter for you. It worked with 2 other companies we consulted for and it worked for my app. I don't want to self promote here, but those who are interested in the book I co-wrote about this should check out the link in my profile.
- nailer 18y agoIf he's writing an open letter, I suggest he makes it possible to read without having to highlight, copy, open a text editor that supports wordwrap, paste, enable wordwrap. Otherwise few people will read it.
- palish 18y agoChrome wordwraps it.
- redrobot5050 18y agoWhich means WebKit wordwraps it. So Steve Jobs will have no problem, assuming he's been using the Safari Beta/Developer Preview for months now.
- nailer 18y agoSure, but the reason it's an open letter is so that others will read it too.
- omouse 18y agoFirefox will wordwrap it if you say "view source".
- boredguy8 18y agoSome of us read on screens that have thousands of pixels horizontally. More than 80 characters on a line is just bad form.
- dustmop 18y agoIn Firefox, View Source -> View -> Wrap Long Lines. Still 3 annoying steps, but its better than 5.
- falien 18y agoIt seems to me that this is exactly the type of application that needs to be reviewed the closest. The author is right that we live in a depraved world. One where plenty of people would not think twice about taking advantage of others who want to do a good thing by installing this application. While I'm not defending apple's review policy because I'm sure its as terrible as everyone believes, I would prefer if all such applications got a lengthy review to ensure they're not doing anything they shouldn't be. Personally I'm just waiting for a better variety of Android phones though, so if iphone users want to be bombarded by poorly reviewed applications I have no problem with it.
- CWuestefeld 18y agoThe letter makes the assumption that the Amber Alert program is one that deserves fast-tracking. It sounds like the hackneyed "but if it saves even one child" line. In reality, the effectiveness of Amber Alerts is quite debatable, and so the resources might be deployed to greater effect elsewhere. Take, for example, this article: http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/articles/2008/07/20/abducted/ http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/articles/2008/07/20/... "These are encouraging statistics - but also deeply misleading, according to some of the only outside scholars to examine the system in depth. In the first independent study of whether Amber Alerts work, a team led by University of Nevada criminologist Timothy Griffin looked at hundreds of abduction cases between 2003 and 2006 and found that Amber Alerts - for all their urgency and drama - actually accomplish little. In most cases where they were issued, Griffin found, Amber Alerts played no role in the eventual return of abducted children. Their successes were generally in child custody fights that didn't pose a risk to the child. And in those rare instances where kidnappers did intend to rape or kill the child, Amber Alerts usually failed to save lives." For more concrete criticism, see the actual study: "Abstract The AMBER alert system is likely affected by a number of psychological processes, yet remains understudied. The system assumes people will remember Alert information accurately and notify police, but psychological research on related phenomena (e.g., memory, willingness to help) indicates that people may not be able or willing to act in ways the promote the success of the system. In addition, the system is intended to deter child abductions, however, the system could prompt copycat crimes from perpetrators seeking publicity. The system could also cause a precipitation effect in which a perpetrator who sees the Alert could decide to murder the child immediately to avoid capture. Policy recommendations are made based on psychological research and theory, although more research is needed to develop the most effective system possible." http://preview.tinyurl.com/bsg5mw http://preview.tinyurl.com/bsg5mw (sorry, the link was ridiculously long)
- ajo 18y agoHis letter is below. The person made a poor choice on formatting, but sounds like it's worth people knowing about: "Open Letter to Apple, Inc., and Steve Jobs To the Executive Team at Apple, and Steve Jobs, The need to send an email such as this represents the magnitude of the problems the App Store faces, and everything that is wrong with its lengthy and ambiguous review process. The mere fact that a free utility that can quite possibly save lives cannot make it into people's hands within a reasonable amount of time is just a highlight of the ongoing problems independent developers like myself have been experiencing with Apple for the past year. This letter is to make you aware of an application I've volunteered my time to engineer with the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children - AMBER Alert. This App Store application has the potential to revolutionize how missing children are reported to law enforcement. By using the iPhone's GPS and some geo-analytics, we're able to build a number of automated logistics tools and quickly relay sightings to law enforcement agencies. With an audience of millions of iPhone users, the missing kids that are out there stand to gain a LOT more exposure. Yet nearly a month has passed since my February 14th submission, and the application continues to sit "In Review". NCMEC has adapted their infrastructure to handle these submissions and has a call center trained to respond to them, as well as their CIO, regional directors, and many others ready to devote time to making this application successful - yet this entire team continues to wait on Apple to approve this application. The App Store review process is non-responsive to a cruel degree, and unfortunately, a month is sadly only a small amount of time compared to some of my other applications that Apple has chosen to flat out ignore for three months or more. While spending time developing commercial applications only to face Apple's silence is frustrating, to have an application (like AMBER Alert) developed solely on a volunteer basis, and for such a good cause as finding kidnapped children - to have this non-profit application ignored is entirely insulting. Is it the belief of many that these discriminating and opaque review processes are hurting Apple's relationship with independent developers - a demographic that once carried Apple for many years. With the advent of the Android store, the Blackberry store, and competing iPhone application stores such as the Cydia Store, continuing to operate in this mode of cold silence will only drive away more developers. While these matters are better left for lengthier conversations, I'm asking that you pick up the phone today and help push the AMBER Alert application through. If you had to sit and look at these kidnapped children, as I have while working on this application, you'd realize just what a depraved world we live in, and how urgent it is to have an application like this be able to get information out (and sightings back in). As a developer and a human being, I'm anxious to see this application released. If I were the parent of one of these missing children, I would be beside myself with anger over Apple's apparent lack of interest in this application. The reprobate and fearful world these children are surviving in - if they are still surviving - may very well be prolonged because of Apple's lack of interest in independent developers like me. Please feel free to contact me if you'd like to discuss this. Otherwise, I hope you'll do the right thing and light a fire under someone's seat in the App Store. If there is any application that should be getting reviewed today, this is it. I would be glad to put all of my other application submissions on hold to see this processed as soon as possible. Jonathan Zdziarski"
- DLWormwood 18y agoThere seems to be a deliberate ignorance of recent history regarding the iPhone as a development platform, to the point that a lot of people are developing a sense of entitlement regarding access to the device. Apple didn't originally announce application support at all for the iPhone in the first place. (Remember Steve Jobs pushing Safari as a web app host for the iPhone, with no mention of a possible SDK just 2 years ago?) The iPhone/iPod touch is probably the most quickly successful product that Apple has ever produced, much more so than the original iPod or the iMac. Yet, people expect Apple to have the resources to bend over backwards for every individual developer for the platform, regardless of good intentions. I was once a shareware/freeware developer for the Mac platform back in the 68k era. The simple fact of the matter is that despite Apple's "big" size, in comparison with most of the computer industry, they are small potatoes. For over a decade, the primary development tools for Apple hardware were provided by third-parties even. (First Symantec, then Metrowerks.) This, combined with Apple's reluctance to take on debt (partly out of self-defense), means that Apple will never have the responsiveness towards developers that the open source community or even Microsoft has. Compared to back then, Apple is much more developer friendly, but the company has always been more focused on user experience, even if this leads them to try to shackle developers with overly limited or complicated APIs or UI conventions. If the letter writer really thinks Apple is being that incompetent, he should give up on the iPhone as a platform and focus on the rest more accessible platforms. Yes, I know the goal is the maximize visibility for your cause, but the problem with any and all outreach efforts is that people naturally avoid information channels like this. Just as web readers migrated from SlashDot to Digg to Reddit to Hacker News, and social networking drifted from MySpace to FaceBook, the "popularity for its own sake" principle and the people it attracts alienate the very people you try to reach. Nobody goes there anymore. It's too crowded. - Yogi Berra
- StrawberryFrog 18y ago"a lot of people are developing a sense of entitlement regarding access to the device" Yeah, it's funny how people get these notions of fairness and equal treatment from somewhere.
- unalone 18y ago
- spoiledtechie 18y agoThis one needs to be voted and submitted as much as possible to any and every news reading site.
- unalone 18y agoWhy? Apple's being lax about publishing apps isn't particularly newsworthy. Even if it's a fairly good cause, this isn't ultraurgent news. We've still got genocide in Africa. How about we make a deal where if we're going to be melodramatic, we be melodramatic about something that matters?
- krschultz 18y agoThat's a bit callous. There really are thousands of kids kidnapped every year in America. And as someone who has been to Africa to help out with Engineers without Borders, I still feel like fighting kidnapping here is a worthwhile cause.
- unalone 18y agoOh, absolutely! I think that that's worth fighting for. But write an article about that, not about an application being rejected from the app store.
- sho 18y ago"There really are thousands of kids kidnapped every year in America." [Citation Needed]
- jgrahamc 18y agoThe National Center for Missing and Exploited Children has data on this here: http://www.missingkids.com/missingkids/servlet/PageServlet?LanguageCountry=en_US&PageId=2810 http://www.missingkids.com/missingkids/servlet/PageServlet?L... "115 children were the victims of “stereotypical” kidnapping. (These crimes involve someone the child does not know or someone of slight acquaintance, who holds the child overnight, transports the child 50 miles or more, kills the child, demands ransom, or intends to keep the child permanently.)"
- TweedHeads 18y agoAmber Alert: Good Public Pressure: Ridiculous It is none of your competence why the AppStore has the guidelines they have in place. It is not a good idea to try to cause a bad PR storm in order to get their attention. If you need help, ask for it gently. They'll respond in accordance.
- sho 18y agoI have very negative feelings about the whole AMBER alert idea. Maybe I'm a callous bastard, but what is so special about child abductions that they require an entire separate national infrastructure to "alert" the citizens in the (incredibly unlikely) event they occur? According to wikipedia the AMBER alert system has helped in the the recovery of 27 children; even this is disputed. Sounds impressive until you remember that thousands of children drown in backyard swimming pools every year. It's absolutely nothing, not even a blip. Sorry, I know it sounds heartless, but facts are facts. There's a sinister aspect too - by making such a big deal about this essentially dead crime, which isn't even a rounding error on child death statistics, I get a nasty feeling that "the powers that be" are trying to unite the public - united with the govt, of course - against this "pedophile child kidnapper" bogeyman. Again, the numbers suggest this creature is almost, if not completely, non-existent. "But they must be everywhere, right? That's why we had to have AMBER alerts!" Encouraging paranoia, manipulating groups to unite against faceless and unlikely enemies .. I don't like it one bit. Saved 27 children since inception. All this righteous fuss. Meanwhile, in Africa, 8 children die every minute from preventable diseases. Where's their alert? Where's their iPhone application? Selective caring. Couldn't give a shit about the thousands of swimming pool deaths. Couldn't care less about childhood obesity or dropping educational standards or manufactured food or childhood deaths in Africa from trivially preventable diseases or child labour in Vietnam which you buy off the shelf at wal-mart but OMG PEDOPHILES APPROVE MY IPHONE APP NOW OR YOU ARE KILLING CHILDREN! I don't really know how to express my loathing for such people but basically I think they're hypocritical, self-righteous douchebags. I hope and expect Apple to ignore this nonsense. (updated to reflect the fact that I couldn't cite a good reference for the 55,000 annual swimming pool deaths I originally wrote - replaced with "thousands", which should definitely be safe.)
- anamax 18y ago> Sounds impressive until you remember that 55,000 children drown in backyard swimming pools every year. Where? Not in the US - the total number of drownings (including adults and other bodies of water) is under 4k/year. http://www.cdc.gov/HomeandRecreationalSafety/Water-Safety/waterinjuries-factsheet.htm http://www.cdc.gov/HomeandRecreationalSafety/Water-Safety/wa... I agree with the sentiment expressed - I'm just quibbling with the numbers used to support it.
- briansmith 18y agoThey haven't approved my fire alarm iPhone app either. Who knows how many lives could have been saved in the weeks since I submitted it? The application is so simple: When you see a fire, you go to your iPhone, click on the "Fire Alarm" icon, go over by a window to get a good 3G data connection, then wait for a GPS fix, then swipe the screen to activate the alarm, then wait as the alert is uploaded. If your iPhone and your window are nearby, it could save a marginal amount of time and effort compared to finding and pulling a real fire alarm. If you already downloaded the fire alarm app, that is; otherwise, it might take a couple of minutes to dig around the app store to find it. Getting notified by the fire alarm application is even easier. First, you just need to go to the App Store and download it onto your phone. Then, you just leave it constantly running on your phone instead of using your phone for anything it was designed for. Then you wait for somebody to "pull the alarm." And wait. And wait. (I recommend sitting by a window.) Edit: Somebody emailed me this question: Q: What about the vast majority of people that don't have iPhones? How will they be alerted? What about building it as a SMS service that would work on every phone? You know, like this existing government-created Amber Alert system for phones: http://www.amberalert.gov/wireless.htm http://www.amberalert.gov/wireless.htm. A: I like playing with my iPhone and complaining about it publicly. I also enjoy self-promotion. The fire alarm app is just a means of pursuing these hobbies. I have no interest in distributing any kind of alerts to anybody besides iPhone users. The actual alerting is secondary to my interests anyway.
- misuba 18y agoIf the author wants to put public pressure on Apple he'll develop an Android version of the app, and a Symbian version, and a Palm Pre version, and whatever else. Until then, he's all mouth and trousers.
- snorkel 18y agoThe app is on hold because Apple's review team can't find the FART button. It would do Apple a world of good to democratize the app review process. Let the reviewers and customers decide what is App Store-worthy.
- xenophanes 18y agoThey should call Apple and offer $20,000 to review the app immediately. They say they have a call center of trained people waiting. That's expensive, so this would save them money. And it's a (small) win for Apple too. When you want special service from a for-profit company, just do the obvious: pay them for it.
- timbowen 18y agoExtremely interesting discussion in this thread. When I first started reading sho's comment I was instinctively leaning the other way, but ensuing discussion has convinced me that these millions would be much better spent on... universal healthcare for example. That would absolutely save more lives.
- GrandMasterBirt 18y agoYou people might be forgetting the most important point of abductions. If you see an AMBER alert on the news, you will see it, and probably forget about it. You might see one on a site like www.woot.com but that is in a different state. Chances are you WONT REMEMBER IT. Yet an application that can show you amber alerts for you current location would actually improve the chance that people would actually memorize the important faces and can always refer back to them immediately when seeing the child and boom press a button to submit a sighting or call immediately. The fact that the information is readily available might be the missing key. Until now unless the picture is posted all over your neighborhood, you will have no idea that you just passed the abducted child. The point is, this application has nothing but good intentions to the public good in mind, is free, is developed by volunteers, and can potentially do a lot of good in America... yet it is delayed for quite some time just because of apple's monopolizing process. The letter mostly points out that the apple store's only reason for being used is because there is no alternative, if one comes out or other platforms, it will be discarded because of apple's poor policies. The application is not perfect and the AMBER system in general has many theoretical flaws which are quite real even if given informational access through this app, but its not like this guy is making a profit from it.