39 ms·
Doctors are finally learning to manage antidepressant withdrawal
https://web.archive.org/web/20260826205502/https://www.newscientist.com/article/2584861-antidepressant-withdrawal-symptoms-are-prompting-a-radical-rethink-of-how-we-treat-depression/ https://web.archive.org/web/20260826205502/https://www.newsc...
https://archive.ph/zahjc https://archive.ph/zahjc
https://x.com/mikesmariani/status/2092966720252133523 https://x.com/mikesmariani/status/2092966720252133523
- classichasclass 3mo agoThough this article concentrates on the SSRIs, other meds like the SNRIs can have a similar or even worse withdrawal effect. We didn't call it "Side Effexor" for nothing. People legitimately need these drugs, including in the short term. The problem for acute stressors once they resolve is how to get them back off.
- Paracompact 3mo ago> Though this article concentrates on the SSRIs, other meds like the SNRIs can have a similar or even worse withdrawal effect. And don't even get me started on tricyclics or MAOIs... no, seriously, don't get me started on them! The current generation of first-line antidepressants (SSRIs/SNRIs) might as well be free compared to the old school crazy pills.
- SV_BubbleTime 3mo ago> school crazy Yep, that’s how I associate SSRIs.
- sheepscreek 3mo agoMuch of medicine (especially mental health related) is rather primitive. We are literally reverse engineering discoveries that seem to work on some other animals, and then figuring out how (to the best of our limited ability). I liken SSRIs to carpet bombing - also their mechanism to increase seratonin in the brain is by making something else not use it (reuptake inhibition). We’re guessing that other thing isn’t a big deal. But who knows. Serotonin is produced in the gut and it controls melatonin, which controls our sleep. It’s all connected in a bizarre way.
- matheusmoreira 3mo ago> I liken SSRIs to carpet bombing It's like inserting objects into the body's event loop and hoping it produces the desired effects as it circulates, only to find that everything reacts to the event, not just the parts we want. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37029912 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37029912
- KurSix 3mo agoIt's probably less "modern antidepressants are uniquely bad" and more "we got much better at starting people on safer drugs than we did at figuring out how to stop them"
- deleted 3mo ago[deleted]
- KurSix 3mo agoFor something prescribed to get someone through a temporary crisis, "how and when do we get you back off this safely?" should probably be discussed at the beginning, not years later when the patient decides to stop.
- bcjdjsndon 3mo ago[flagged]
- probably_wrong 3mo agoIf a fireman is trying to stop a house fire and suddenly they catch fire themselves, no one would argue that they need to focus on the house fire first. Antidepressants are the same: they won't stop the bigger fire by themselves, but by preventing you from catching fire right now they give you the tools to deal with the larger problem more effectively that if you tried to do it while flailing around and screaming.
- john_strinlai 3mo agoman, you're all over this submission shitting on antidepressants and questioning people's experiences. it's irresponsible and really not cool.
- sixeyes 3mo agofor my snri i lessened the dose by 25% and that alone cost me a week of work, i was so fucked over. when i quit this i will for sure do the thing where you open the capsules and remove a little of the contents, gradually removing more each day. i read online about people doing this and thought they were nutjobs. well, now i know.
- ImHereToVote 3mo ago"People legitimately need these drugs" First. Do no harm.
- isolli 3mo agoNot to mention benzodiazepines... https://www.benzoinfo.com/ https://www.benzoinfo.com/ https://asprescribedfilm.com/ https://asprescribedfilm.com/
- D-Machine 3mo agoBest way to manage the withdrawal would be to dramatically reduce them being prescribed in the first place. The linked article says they have "small to moderate effectiveness", but this is being far too generous. The correct way to measure drug effectiveness is if the treatment meets the standard of a minimal important difference. I.e. you measure depression on various rating scales, like the 17-point HAM-D, and research suggests a minimal important difference (i.e. one patients and clinicians can actually notice) needs to be about 3-5 points. But the average effects of almost all antidepressants do not meet these thresholds, i.e. the effect actually appears practically invisible. [1] Then you'll get waffling like "oh, but it really has a big effect for some people", but, well, no, we've looked at that too, and the placebo groups get just as miraculous "big effects", i.e. evidence supporting the idea "they really help some people" is also largely lacking [2-3]. All the other attempted saves ("oh, but eventually you find one that works for you") are also not really well supported either [4]. Like, maybe they really help some people, but it is far, far less clear than most assume, and should be balanced with concerns like withdrawal and serious side effects like emotional blunting and sexual dysfunction. EDIT: And just to be clear to anyone doing a drive-by downvote thinking this is about recent asinine US politics, it emphatically isn't. There are serious methodological concerns here that desperately need to be communicated to the public. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33593736/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33593736/ [2] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7451660/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7451660/ [3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33175895/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33175895/ [4] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11844611/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11844611/
- Paracompact 3mo agoOn an academic level, we have reined in much of the excess enthusiasm in antidepressants that was courtesy of 90s-era pharmaceutical reps and ad men, but I don't think this revision ever occurred in the cultural consciousness at large.
- D-Machine 3mo agoYup, I would agree. The meta-research / methodological research and awareness here is really quite impressive, even though its conclusions are a bit grim and not well-known.
- sandcat_ 3mo agoTo provide one additional anecdote: I came off escitalopram with no taper after taking it for about five years (10mg). I got brain zaps for a while, got very irritated at times, but largely was fine after a few weeks. Not downplaying the withdrawal effects for some people, but they’re not as catastrophic as this article suggests for many (perhaps most). And overall I’m very glad I took it! It got me through a rough patch, and seems (in combination with therapy, and some life changes) to have rewired me a little. Symptoms I had for a decade prior have not returned. And I’m not sure I could have made those life changes without it. Sadly my arachnophobia came back though. Oh well.
- delichon 3mo agoGood news, exposure therapy is quite effective for arachnophobia and is the first-line treatment. SSRIs do not have the same level of supporting evidence, and the effects are not as durable.
- sandcat_ 3mo agoThanks, yeah, but if I’m honest I don’t really care enough to go through with it. I almost did once, years ago, the London Zoo have a programme. I mentioned it though as one of the most stark changes I noticed after getting on an SSRI was pretty much immediately losing my fear of spiders. It was the first sign I had that showed it was doing something. I used to literally, on occasion, launch my phone across the room if I was scrolling and came across a spider (sometimes drenching myself with coffee or whatever in the process!) and then one day, shortly after getting on it, I stumbled across some awful tarantula video or something and I just stared at it like “huh, why am I not freaking out”.
- deleted 3mo ago[deleted]
- simiones 3mo ago> SSRIs do not have the same level of supporting evidence, and the effects are not as durable. To the extent that we can measure depression, SSRIs have been widely proven in gold standard phase III clinical trials to help with the treatment of major depression. What exactly is supposed to be lacking in the supported evidence?
- SV_BubbleTime 3mo ago[flagged]
- wredcoll 3mo agoWait til you hear about microplastics!
- majormajor 3mo agoMost of us have no idea how many non-commenting readers w/o first-hand experience are just reading, and so no ability to draw any conclusions about the number of ones who comment with first-hand experience. 100 people out of a 1000, and 100 people out of a million, are very different things.
- pibaker 3mo agoAn HN post like this will gather like what, at most two dozens of anecdotes from a highly self selected user pool of maybe a million top? Is this how you base your "sheer number" on? Is this how you judge what is good or bad for your definition of social good? I got some other news for you, buddy. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49444514 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49444514
- SV_BubbleTime 3mo agolol, don’t worry about asking someone if they’re addicted to some bug pharma product… they’ll be right along to defend it!
- jerbearito 3mo ago> far too high for a social good Not sure what you're basing this on -- hopefully not just your impression after reading things online.
- SV_BubbleTime 3mo agolol, I know plenty of people offline that are addicted to this shit too. It’s just that this forum and Redditors cheerlead about their addictions willingly. Most people are shyer about it.
- laughing_man 3mo agoSSRIs and SNRIs just didn't work very well for me. If they had an positive effect at all, it wasn't enough to rise above the proverbial noise. Coming off of them wasn't too bad though. I got the brain zaps, but those were easy to cope with. More than anything the whole experience was a waste of money, and what finally fixed my problems was retirement and a greater attention to my health.
- litigator 3mo agoHave you looked into mirtazapine (tetra cyclic), vortioxetine (serotonin modulator) or atomoxetine (SNDRI). Atomoxetine has been a god send for me.
- burnt-resistor 3mo agoI've tried 20-some-odd antidepressants titrating off and on and usually back off again. Mirtazapene (ATeCA) is the only one that could manage my depression. Unfortunately, it leads to severe weight gain that my health plan's formulary refuses to cover GLP-1 for because obesity is considered "a choice". It's the only one where the depression mostly goes away and the side-effects aren't life-threatening/-debilitating for me. If I forget a single dose at night or anytime I go to sleep without taking it first, I end up with almost exactly the feeling of an alcohol hangover. It's also a pretty powerful antihistamine. I also usually can't get to sleep if I don't take it. :/ Vortioxetine gave me horrific myoclonus and vestibular symptoms. Atomoxetine is mostly for ADHD and gave me tachycardia, profuse sweating, uncomfortable nervousness, and anxiety. It didn't do shit for my ADHD or depression. YMMV.
- piperswe 3mo agoAtomoxetine can cause some wild mood-related side effects, just as an FYI for anyone considering it. For me, it made me perpetually pissed off, and made me feel like I had a cold. I’m jealous of people it works well for though - seems like a great drug when it works!
- laughing_man 3mo agoI stopped looking into drugs when I stopped having problems.
- snailmailman 3mo agoI forget exactly which antidepressant I was on, but when i finally stopped taking it, i was instructed to reduce dosage by half a pill every two weeks. Anecdotally, that was not anywhere close to slow enough. I had panic attacks almost every day while I was reducing the dosage. Those weeks were hell. I couldn’t think straight. I honestly don’t remember much of what occurred during that time, because the withdrawal took over my life. The pills were too tiny to split into fourths easily, but I wish I had done something to reduce dosage in smaller increments or over a longer time period. It makes me strongly reconsider ever taking any antidepressants ever again. They didn’t tell me when I started taking them that the withdrawal would be so terrible. Those months were easily some the worst of my life.
- Aboutplants 3mo agoI’ve also been told the 2 week reduction (reduce by half every two weeks) schedule and agree it is also not nearly long enough. I really wish you could get incremental decreasing doses over the course of months to properly ween. If I ever have to do it again I will be taking a much more concerted longer period, really being specific on the tailing dosages. The body and brain needs way more time than we think
- almost_usual 3mo agoSSRIs not Benzodiazepines. Withdrawals from the later can be life-threatening if you abruptly stop after prolonged use.
- shoopadoop 3mo ago"Prolonged" is not a long time either. You can be ensnared after just a couple weeks. And even a safe taper is still pretty hellish. I had to wean off Klonopin, prescribed for a bout of COVID induced insomnia. Only on it for a month and it took a microgram taper and nine months to get off of completely. Had to go slow because the original recommended rate was wayyyyy too spicy for my central nervous system. Even at the slow rate I was going it was difficult to make it through life. Most doctors are unaware of how to deprescribe this shit safely.
- petesergeant 3mo agoI don’t think “most doctors” is accurate any more, but a doctor prescribing a month of klonopin for insomnia needs some urgent continuing professional development.
- shoopadoop 3mo agoIn France it is still "most doctors". They hand out benzos like candy there.
- exogenousdata 3mo agoWhile you are entirely correct that immediate withdrawal of benzos is life-threatening, the same is true for short-acting SSRIs/SNRIs. For eg, when admitted to a psych ward, there are a handful of things that the hospital will continue giving to a patient and gradually taper. Benzos, SSRIs/SNRIs, anti-psychotics, anti-convulsants & alcohol. I mention this just to urge folks not to go cold-turkey on SSRIs/SNRIs as it can be life-threatening.
- throwaway250501 3mo agoWhen I was diagnosed with depression - amongst other things - my doctor prescribed SSRIs with a caveat that they might or might not work. After a few weeks I was tapered off them. I felt no different before, during or after them. What helped was 3 daily walks around the park, around 9km per day after each meal. Anecdotal but it is what it is. Right now I have bigger problems than just depression.
- garciasn 3mo agoLexapro, noted in the article, was literally life changing for me. I felt better within 3d and I notice severe issues if I miss ~3d of doses in a row, even though the half-life should support ~7d without according to my physician. That said, yes; walking is the best medicine for me.
- zdragnar 3mo agoI start getting effects the same day if I miss my morning dose, but like you, it was life changing (in a good way) for me. I've got two friends who didn't benefit from it, so it isn't a miracle cure for everyone, sadly.
- 121789 3mo agoI think exercise, sunlight, good sleep and diet, and good social relationships are all more effective than SSRIs. But anyone who's had bad depression knows how hard those things are to maintain if you're depressed. SSRIs make some portion of people functional enough where they can at least build a healthy life. But definitely not everyone, and they are definitely not "the cure"
- deleted 3mo ago[deleted]
- Aurornis 3mo ago> After a few weeks I was tapered off them. > I felt no different before, during or after them. SSRI onset is slow, which is one of the common problems with treatment. In studies where they survey both the patient and their family members, the family members actually start noticing improvements before the patient. Onset is slow and it takes a long time for patients to realize the positive effects. Ideally they’re prescribed along with other lifestyle changes like your walks. It doesn’t have to be an either-or. A lot of patients get offended when doctors suggest things like walking because they think it indicates the doctor is telling them to “just walk it off” which doesn’t go well. It’s not surprising you didn’t feel anything noticeable after a few weeks. It’s also unfortunate, but not too surprising, that your doctor wasn’t informed enough to communicate these things. Some doctors are great about setting expectations and following up. Others write a prescription and send patients off to fill it without the necessary context.
- matheusmoreira 3mo agoTLDR: Rate is individualized and determined by the patient's tolerance. If symptoms appear, maintain or increase dose to stabilize, then try reducing again later. Use liquid medication for more granular dosing. Doctors aren't "finally learning" how to manage withdrawals. This is essentially the common sense algorithm, and I'm pretty annoyed that they wrote this whole ass article just for that.
- fsckboy 3mo agoI've taken antidepressants for years (20 mg prozac) and have sometimes tapered off them, restarting later. I can barely tell that I'm taking them, I feel 100% like myself on--and off of--them. I know they do something because when talking about difficult traumas with my therapist, if I'm not taking flouoxetine I will get choked up to the point I can't speak. That's the only difference I can perceive. My dose is not a "happy pill", it simply smooths out some extreme lows. Tapering off (a few weeks of 50% exponential declines) I've done because it's recommended, but again, I've never noticed any affect on mood before, during, or after. after a number of years, a small dose of lithium (300mg) was recommended by a psychiatrist who stood apart (at least in that respect), and it was magic at mood stabilization, I never before even realized that I experienced hypomania (and I took it for anxiety), I just thought I was "bold". (Lithium is not a drug, it's an element, taken as a metallic salt. It occurs naturally in the water in various parts of the world, and those populations have been studied and suffer lower rates of mental illness. My shrink said his recommendation was based in conjunction with the prozac I was taking, i.e. a known correlation. Bipolar II is a different mental condition than bipolar I, and somewhat slippery/loosely defined) The extreme anecdotal stories people report online as in this forum strike me, an experienced but likewise only an anecdotal user, as more an artifact of underlying emotional distress rather than a result of the drugs. I just wanted to contribute a different voice to this topic. I should add, I do have "extra money" and am able to pay extremely qualified and expensive doctors, an option that is not available to everyone, including those with full public health services.
- exmadscientist 3mo ago> bipolar I think this is more relevant than people give it credit for. While bipolar depression and unipolar (major) depression might generally be functionally indistinguishable from the outside, they seem to have genuinely different origins within the body and brain. And the drugs seem to be far more powerful for people with bipolar. That's both good and bad. Good, because between mood stabilizers and very careful use of antidepressants, many people with bipolar can genuinely achieve complete treatment, or close enough to pass as complete. Which is wonderful! Bad because antidepressants and (hypo)mania are a dangerous combination, and the antidepressants can have more kick than one would normally expect. They'll often cause a patient's first manic episode, which can be very bad on its own but might get things on the right treatment course. (Of course, they often still do nothing much at all. I think the tapering may be related as well. I was eventually diagnosed with bipolar II and I've never really had to taper off anything that didn't have a black-box warning about tapers (either intrinsically or due to blood-pressure effects, which are worth taking seriously). I've stopped some things cold which one really shouldn't stop cold. I didn't really notice much other than the bad side effects causing the stop going away. > I do have "extra money" and am able to pay extremely qualified and expensive doctors I don't really have "extra money" but I still do this anyway. My psychiatrist is $500 an hour, out of pocket, no insurance accepted period. He actually listens. It's worth it.
- KurSix 3mo ago[dead]
- deleted 3mo ago[deleted]
- elil17 3mo agoOnly slightly related, but can anyone ELI5 why Bupropion XL is not the universal first line treatment for depression and is hardly used at all in Europe? It has fewer side effects vs. SSRIs, can be safely used as a long term medication (which many people do with SSRIs even though it can have negative effects), and doesn't have the same horrible withdrawal symptoms (although you still need to taper).
- LoganDark 3mo agoMy doctor tried me on Bupropion for ADHD and I think it caused my BorderlinePD to get much worse, so definitely YMMV.
- hapless 3mo agoAnxiety is a common comorbidity in depression patients and buprioprion can dramatically raise anxiety levels It is a second-line treatment for a reason. Great when it works. Harmful when it does not.
- petesergeant 3mo agoJust want to underscore that this is the right answer.
- haswell 3mo agoYeah, this is exactly why I couldn’t stay on it. I already deal with GAD and OCD, and whatever benefits it had for the depression were directly counteracted by the return of acute anxiety. It was truly hellish. Feeling like I had this energy that I needed to use, while also feeling so anxious that I didn’t want to leave the apartment. I know it works really well for some people but I was definitely not one of them.
- bcjdjsndon 3mo ago[flagged]
- elil17 3mo ago
- lloydatkinson 3mo agoWell this would be an improvement over my former NHS GP practice deciding the best way for me to come off antidepressants was immediately stopping them without renewing the prescription or even discussing it with me! I think they just forgot to renew the prescription.
- abbadadda 3mo agoOof, this tracks with my experience on the NHS… it seems like extreme busyness comes off as a lack of due care. One time I met a psychiatrist after moving to a new area. In our very first meeting he takes me off a medicine I’ve been on for nearly 7 years, cold turkey. Then? _Zero_ follow-up, no check-ins, and I can’t get an appointment on my own for months. The decision may have been wise, leaving out specifics here, but the lack of follow-up really was negligent.
- ButlerianJihad 3mo agoMy parents tried seeking out help for me when I was about 10 years old, but they got cold feet, and I believe that they were unwilling to accept any responsibility or blame for what was going on at home. So when I reached the age of majority, they fully funded therapist and psychiatrist sessions for me, and they foisted Prozac upon me, starting around 1991. I began taking Prozac and suddenly exhibited a remarkable improvement in my mood and affect. These improvements were largely because I was getting attention, I was getting "weekly pep talks" from a professional, and at long last, there were names I could affix to those extremely troublesome spirits that tormented me night and day. But the doctors, having a practice in the Children's Hospital, didn't see fit to warn me not to drink alcohol, especially not to excess, and I was simply reaching that age where this was happening frequently. So, the mixture of SSRI plus ethanol was really disastrous for me and my loved ones. I cycled through all kinds of meds, and clinicians tried finding some other stuff to medicate, like maybe hypothyroidism, and I really hated the medication, and I got hospitalized and discharged with a cocktail of at least 5 prescriptions all at once. I suffered really awful adverse side effects. But it wasn't realistic to stop. I kept cycling through new and different drugs. Every time it was new and different, and I had more complaints, and I stopped again and again. I had all the "brain zaps" especially Zappy Zoloft, and more hospitals and more upheavals in life. I've finally reached a point where I can steadfastly refuse any medication, up to the point where inpatient treatment is done. I am 100% off drugs, and I feel great about that. I tend to inform my providers that I have "a Lithium deficiency" because bipolar isn't real: it's merely a cluster of highly-subjective "symptoms" and behaviors, under an ever-widening umbrella, and the bottom line is that they just want to put Lithium Carbonate on the checklist of "subject is treating this thing" and then once I'm taking enough of it, they can heap on more and more drugs on top. And Lithium is one of those where they grab you for a monthly blood test, to "trust, but verify" as the Soviets would say. So I am pleased that SSRIs and their ilk are far, far behind me. I inwardly chuckle or sigh wistfully when I hear another patient extolling the virtues of ECT or Ketamine or something. How wonderful for you to be dependent on quacks and pseudoscience. Read any Wikipedia page for these drugs. They are fairy tales. I am a practicing Roman Catholic: I don't need to believe in fairy tales from foreigners and infidels who distribute condoms and wear white coats. Thank you for your attention to this matter! Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.
- ernsheong 3mo agoLookup "occupancy chart antidepressant", study the chart. There is an exponential drop-off at lower doses. Hence to taper off without feeling it, one needs to cut smaller and smaller doses, (or liquify) which may be impractical.
- mrec 3mo agoInteresting; I wasn't aware that 20mg was considered the minimum effective dose for fluoxetine. I tried tapering from 20mg to 15mg (alternating 10/20) after ~4 years and was absolutely fine; I then tried the next step down to 10mg and crashed hard. Probably going to stay on it for life now, which is fine; I never really experienced any negative side effects.
- ernsheong 3mo agoWith this chart we now know why stepping down from 15mg to 10mg is a HUGE step.
- mrec 3mo agoCould you link to the specific chart you're looking at? I think our searches are finding different things.
- ernsheong 3mo agohttps://www.madinamerica.com/2021/09/antidepressant-effects-serotonin-plateau-minimum-recommended-dose/ https://www.madinamerica.com/2021/09/antidepressant-effects-... and its variants
- bb123 3mo agoThere is a real lack of transparency in communicating some of the long term impacts of SSRIs to new patients. When I was prescribed sertraline not one doctor mentioned the massive (and sometimes permanent!!) sexual side effects, the likelihood of weight gain or how brutal it would be to taper off. Also, I ended up ignoring my doctor's (way too aggressive) tapering schedule and managing my own down-dosing with a pill crusher and a milligram scale. I went about 5x slower than the standard advice and avoided all of the worst side effects. I don't think it would have changed my decision to start taking it but I would rather have known about all this up front so I could make a more informed choice.
- asa123 3mo agosomewhat off topic but i’ve thought about tapering like this, but i’ve got wondered where can one get a calibrated milligram scale? or perhaps it doesn’t matter too much.
- lazycatjumping 3mo agoRelative precision is enough if you just want to get rid of pills
- jychang 3mo agoAWS Gemini-20 below $100 Or a precision one for $$$ All the other sub-$100 ones are mostly junk, with a few decent ones. But just get the Gemini-20
- mapt 3mo agoLike buying a five gallon boiling flask, one assumes this will get one put on a list in the US.
- deleted 3mo ago[deleted]
- IncreasePosts 3mo ago
- pcblues 3mo agoZoloft for me (Sertraline) years ago. Was on for a few years and came off cold-turkey when it didn't seem to help any more. My life outside my head was crazy enough. My mind then matched it. I don't regret taking it, but it is a real trap of taking sanity from your own future and paying it back later. Advice I received was if my body could handle it, I should stay on it forever. I didn't like that idea, though. Among the negative side effects, the chemical sexual drive suppression caused its own problems. YMMV of course.
- drayfield 3mo agoI've been on 40mg citalopram for about 20 years now. I've tried a few times to come off either tapering or cold turkey and in all cases it's been horrendous. My biggest worry is that I'll never be able to come off them as I'm on such a high dosage, even if it was tapered off over a very long period of time.
- bcjdjsndon 3mo ago[flagged]
- clsec 3mo agoI said it elsewhere, but it took me a month of micro dosing down to get off my 40mg/day citalopram habit, which I had been on for 15 years. And even on my own super slowed down schedule I still experienced massive side effects. Good luck to you if you ever decide to wean yourself off of it & always remember to keep backup citalopram in case you can't get your script refilled right away.
- drayfield 3mo agoThanks, I appreciate it.
- move68k 3mo agoHey, don't lose hope. I got prescribed and took 30 mg of Citalopram for about 10 years to treat general anxiety. At some point, I wanted to stop taking it because of the emotional numbness (and also because of a tendency toward mildly aggressive episodes). I gradually reduced the dosage from 30 to 20 mg (over the time of 3 to 4 months), then down to 10 mg (for another 2–3 months), and then I finally reduced it to 5 mg (half a 10-mg tablet) over a period of 4–6 weeks. I told my doctor beforehand, they only told me that I should fade it out slowly. But please excuse me for not knowing the exact time frames of the tapering process any more. I took my time at the beginning of the tapering and moved more quickly toward the end. During and afterwards I didn’t notice any severe side effects, aside from the fact that the recurring emotions really overwhelmed me at times. Not only that, but I would cry at the slightest hint of emotional and romantic scenes in movies and series, which lasted for about three months. Nowadays, I feel quite normal. I miss the slight comfort Citalopram gave me, but I have my feelings back, I feel more myself again. If a bit more anxiety is the price for that, then so be it.
- ZeroDayDreamer 3mo ago[flagged]
- bookofjoe 3mo ago>The baffling science of SSRIs: how do they really work? https://archive.ph/yaEZJ https://archive.ph/yaEZJ
- florkbork 3mo agoThis is an absolute failure on the part of medical science. SSRIs went mainstream in 1988. By 1992! We knew about withdrawal issues: https://www.wikidoc.org/index.php/SSRI_discontinuation_syndrome https://www.wikidoc.org/index.php/SSRI_discontinuation_syndr... Let's be generous and give it until the 2000s for the knowledge to spread and science to validate; and we're still left with 26 years of blundering around without IMO sufficient warning to patients about withdrawal risks. I would wager some of the doctors who prescribe today were well past a glint in their father's eye when we started to know about this.
- whatsThisBtn4 3mo agoSeemingly around the world, physicians are often nepo babies. In the United States, our physicians are paid by taxes for grad school. The physicians decide the supply with an unelected private org ACGMe. It really shows that despite the corruption, people will go to great lengths for health.
- forestrywat 3mo agoMy physician told me withdrawal was hard, and laid out all the negative side effects. Searching for them online was pretty trivial too. The pharmacist also spoke to me when I picked up the first bottle, and the pamphlet I received with the medicine also had information about it. At some point, we have to trust that even if one or two of those fail, the information is readily available and issued four times before you start.
- deleted 3mo ago[deleted]
- Scubabear68 3mo agoThis is a serious issue, but for a humorous sci fi take on this issue, go read The Lust Lizard of Melancholy Cove by Christopher Moore. It deals with a small town psychiatrist who takes a whole town off of anti-depressants, and an ancient monster is summoned from the depths attracted by all the heightened emotions and terrorizes the town.
- chewbacha 3mo agoI’ve been on a SSRI for 5 years and not once have I thought about getting off of it. It literally saved my life. I remember a while life of depression and constant churn of recursive emotions destroying me. I’m worried that too many people are downplaying the benefits that this drug for those of us that it has helped immensely. And it’s extra risky to be downplaying it while RFK jr is actively working to remove the drugs from the market.
- bcjdjsndon 3mo ago[flagged]
- pyth0 3mo agoChronic depression doesn't usually have a "cause" that you can fix without some form of treatment. It happens that these meds often do remove the extreme effects of depression and allow you to focus on other problems.
- gilrain 3mo ago> Chronic depression doesn't usually have a "cause" Is that true or your guess?
- pyth0 3mo agoI have first hand experience. Also "depression" is different from "chronic depression". You can experience the former as the direct result of some cause.
- gilrain 3mo ago> I have first hand experience. You can't have first-hand experience of "usually" where that applies to multiple people.
- 3mo ago
- dib258 3mo agoGoing cold turkey is always the worse way to wean off a SSRI, but the half-life of the drug is also a good indicator of the intensity of the withdrawal. Also, some people might eliminate a drug faster than others, so the result is surely harder on some that others. Doctors that tells you how to reduce the SSRI/SNRI are following what's available on the market, and generally the gap between doses is always huge and gives a big gap and so bigger withdrawal. Once I asked to a pharmacist if he could make smaller doses and he answered me to be like a good junky and open the capsules and cut them myself. I was a bit shocked at the moment, but at least it costs me less that him having to do it a that helped me greatly to reduce a SNRI without feeling too much symptoms. So a good advice, is look at the half-life of the drug you are taking, and be a good junky and split the capsules or have liquid form to reduce by small amount. Half-Life of Specific SSRIs - Fluoxetine (Prozac): 4 to 6 days, with its active metabolite norfluoxetine lasting 7 to 16 days. - Sertraline (Zoloft): Roughly 22 to 36 hours. - Citalopram (Celexa): About 36 hours. - Escitalopram (Lexapro): About 27 to 32 hours. - Fluvoxamine (Luvox): 17 to 22 hours. - Paroxetine (Paxil): About 21 to 24 hours. Half-Lives of Common SNRIs - Venlafaxine (Effexor): About 5 hours for immediate-release (extended-release has an effective transit/clearance profile, though parent half-life remains short); its active metabolite (desvenlafaxine) has a half-life of about 11 hours. - Desvenlafaxine (Pristiq): About 11 hours. - Duloxetine (Cymbalta): About 12 hours (range of 8 to 17 hours). - Levomilnacipran (Fetzima): About 12 hours.
- bcjdjsndon 3mo ago[flagged]
- pas 3mo agopeople whose life is amazing don't go through the process of getting stimulants (or even SSRIs) prescribed to them. psychiatrists know about this. the plan is usually to cycle the meds. is this great and works every time? no. is this better than the alternative? yes. ADHD is not great. and in many cases it's so bad people die from "not paying attention", and Ritalin (methylphenidate) is visibly helping people avoid those early deaths. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10901868/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10901868/
- richardlblair 3mo agoOne should not question the seriousness of ADHD or the benefits of an appropriate treatment plan. One should question the rate of which it is diagnosed, and who is getting diagnosed.
- chownie 3mo ago> One should question the rate of which it is diagnosed, and who is getting diagnosed. The medical consensus after multiple enquiries in the UK has come to: 1. The rate of diagnosis is far too low (the evidence of this being we're catching people as adults who should've been caught as children). 2. Our diagnostic criteria aren't inclusive enough (we have historically missed inattentive presenting ADHD, we have historically missed ADHD presenting in women) These results are politically unpalatable so the enquiry is I think currently being run for the third time, but signs point to ADHD overdiagnosis being a hoax/fake news/whatever you call it.
- hirvi74 3mo agoI say this as someone with ADHD: The issue is that ADHD is not real in the organic sense. Well, at least the evidence is scant. It's more of a description than a disorder. It's not something one "has." I like to compare ADHD to racial categorization of people. Race is not real in a biological sense, but it's definitely real in a social sense. I am probably butchering what I am trying to say so, just read this if you want to understand someone(s) that can communicate eloquently. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9189308/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9189308/
- jkxyz 3mo agoI went cold turkey off of citalopram when I was a teenager and it was a pretty unpleasant two weeks of heart palpitations, but the immediate benefit of no longer experiencing emotional blunting made me avoid taking any more antidepressants for 10 years. I was prescribed it by a GP and never given any real support in my mental health or in coming off of it. It was a real black pill for me on the UK's treatment of mental health issues. Last year I started taking buproprion (Wellbutrin) after seeing a private psychiatrist in Romania, and I found it beneficial, but ended up losing more than 10kg, and becoming malnourished to the point of my hair falling out. Again I stopped of my own accord, and buproprion has basically no cessation symptoms. This spring I saw a psychiatrist through Romania's public health service who prescribed me vortioxetine (Brintellix/Trintellix) after I shared my history and it's been a game changer. I experience basically no side effects besides a slight reduction in libido, with no other effects on sexual function. It's really helped me to find my balance again. And I see a psychiatrist once a month paid for by my public health insurance with the medication fully comped. Vortioxetine has a half-life of 66 hours so the one time I did have to skip a day and a half, the withdrawal was not noticeable. Just sharing this to say that there are good doctors and good meds out there, and that having low tolerance for one medication doesn't mean that you shouldn't talk to a doctor about it and try others.
- Scubabear68 3mo agoIt can't be emphasized enough for me just how unpleasant side effects like heart palpitations, tachycardia and related conditions really are. For me at least, those kinds of conditions trigger something close to a panic attack which feels like a very deep seat primitive protective measure in our brains. Laying in your bed trying to be restful and feeling your heart slamming away at 140 beats per minute with little you can do about it goes behind miserable into outright alarming, even if you are "used" to it.
- krupan 3mo agoI've heard similar stories. Different people react to the same med differently
- tedmiston 3mo agoFWIW quitting any SSRI cold turkey is highly disrecommended vs gradual tapering over ~2–6 weeks but even that current guidance is probably too aggressive. Something like one step down every 2–4 weeks or ideally hyperbolic tapering is better for neurobiology but that's also a PITA. https://www.outro.com/blog/stopping-antidepressants-what-is-hyperbolic-tapering https://www.outro.com/blog/stopping-antidepressants-what-is-...
- tsoukase 3mo agoAll cases are possible with S{S|N}RIs (I am a doctor but I know a little regexp). Patients that took them for two months and never needed again and others that cannot stop them after 20y. The start, the stop and every restart of the drug needs an indication so it should be approached with the same care as any medical decision. It's not right to call it withdrawal. These drugs are not addictive like benzos or alcohol are. If any symptom reappears it's just that the mental disease most usually changed form after so long time. As for the sexual dysfunction, a common known side effect is that they kill (delay or eliminate) the orgasm. Libido and male erection are affected by so many psycho-social, somatic and genetic factors that it's usually difficult to spot the exact relation with these drugs.
- movespebp 3mo agoThe sexual side effects can be much much worse, and far more permanent than delayed orgasm or low libido - https://www.pssdnetwork.org https://www.pssdnetwork.org It's also not difficult to spot - the complete removal of libido, sometimes permanently for life, with these drugs has been seen in animal models, and also is not present in other classes of ADs. A lifetime of chemical castration effectively. Clinicians really have been misinformed about these drugs, the awareness campaigns of the 90s still cast a long shadow, with many not really truly understanding the actual potentially permanent and serious effects of these drugs, or assuming that they're rarer than they are (they aren't rare) - because that's what the pharmaceutical company campaigns have told them.
- gib444 3mo agoRight! No thread on antidepressants is complete without a downplaying of PSSD
- Shortness8 3mo agoI don't think this is true. As a doctor, anything told to me by a pharmaceutical company (who never directly engage with us as medical staff) is taken with the world's largest pinch of salt. Generally my default is to disregard what they saw until I see the published evidence. I have seen and treated a large number of people with SSRIs, and the majority are incredibly thankful. I spoke to a patient yesterday who told me his Sertraline saved his life following a suicide attempt a few months ago. I saw a patient last year who fantasized constantly about murdering his colleagues at work. Fluoxetine cured him completely and he was incredibly grateful to not be tortured by those thoughts anymore. Some have had sexual side effects, but in my experience switching SSRIs often cures these. They aren't perfect drugs, but on balance they help a lot of people. I do not think engaging with the above sort of network is a good idea, I suspect a large amount of these people suffer from psycho-social causes of libido/orgasm loss and being part of an echo chamber telling you that change is permanent will only reinforce that idea if indeed it is a psychosocial change. I practice in the UK so things may be different here. I've never heard of a patient with persisting sexual symptoms following an SSRI switch. Certainly hear about a lot more psychosomatic conditions in the US than we seem to see here. I think a lot of this is downstream from the US fee-paying healthcare model where the implication is that doctors want to make money. As a side note, and I find myself saying this a lot on HN, but most of you are not doctors. There are a huge amount of unknown unknowns in medical practice that the layperson is unaware of. I wouldn't even think about commenting on any technical subject with the amount of confidence most commenters here give with single-digit sample sizes, or using self-reinforcing internet forums as evidence. Frankly what we say in the consultation room and what patients walk away with is often different. All doctors know SSRI's have side effects and in my experience all counsel on these. There's probably something for us to improve there with communication, but after you explain side effects and give a leaflet explaining those again, and the patient still claims you didn't tell them about a side effect, I feel like there's not much more we can do. Also, NewScientist is a poorly written pop-sci publication. It has constant inaccuracies and misinterpretations of the evidence. I cancelled my sub years ago when they were bought by the Daily Mail. There is some utter pseudoscience in this thread and some completely misunderstandings of how medical practice works. The body is infinitely complex on a biochemical level and we have a very limited understanding of the interplay between all systems. Just because the serotonin theory has been disproven by one systematic review does not mean SSRIs are a bad treatment or do not work, it just means we do not fully understand their mechanism of action. These are not the same thing. I suspect some SWE's or similar in this thread are used to having the complete understanding of a system and the levers involved, this is simply not the case for the human body.
- movespebp 3mo ago[dead]
- richwater 3mo agoSince when do we allow people to push conspiracy nonsense on this website?
- dennis_jeeves2 3mo ago>In a generation these drugs are likely going to be seen as a big mistake and a medical scandal. Of course the next generation will deal with a bunch of other drugs where the side effects are underplayed. The playbook of the mainstream medical industry is a common one.
- PaulHoule 3mo agoMyself I tapered Paroxetine without any pill cutters or special techniques and had no physical problems... But I did have something like a manic episode that lasted for about six months, had a psychogenic fever, lost more than 30 pounds in a few months (I was working out like a "maniac" and eating a mostly liquid diet at times to take stress off my TMJ) and was very high functioning in most respects despite being under the influence of a system of delusions.
- ivansavz 3mo agoThe relevant book is The Maudsley Deprescribing Guidelines Antidepressants, Benzodiazepines, Gabapentinoids and Z-drugs by Mark Horowitz and David Taylor (2024). This book is for medical professionals, but if you find your doctor doesn't have the relevant training then worth to educate yourself. The TL;DR is that you need to go really slowly in the final steps. Horowitz also has many talks and podcast appearances on youtube. Example old video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRr09mvMEAU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRr09mvMEAU but he has many more recent ones. I don't have any direct experience with this, but I've been watching my best friend struggle with widthdraw symtoms for many year, and I also know from doctor friends that they are not trained on de-prescribing protocols.
- mancerayder 3mo agoBy the way - turning off scripts allows the original to load without paywall. (Probably not using Chrome.)
- krupan 3mo agoSSRI's saved my life with no side effects that I can discern, yet I still have the urge to try and get off of them from time and so do friends and family of mine that also benefit from them. Maybe that urge needs more study because it is not taking us in a good direction. I'm not saying that because of the difficulty of weaning off, but because of the benefits of staying on. For those of us that need them, trying to wean off of them is like trying to wean off of I don't know, vitamin C or something else essential. Don't do it! Be glad you found something that helps! Keep taking it!
- gwbas1c 3mo ago> Likewise, a 2025 study found that people with dementia who were taking antidepressants experienced more rapid cognitive decline. “Sometimes we think a lot about medications when we start them, but we don’t think enough about stopping them at some point,” says Sara Garcia Ptacek, a neurologist at the Karolinska Institute in Sweden, who worked on the study. My aunt had Alzheimer's and had to be put on anti-anxiety medication just so that her caretaker could manage her. (This was at the point where she no longer recognized her children, but recognized her siblings.) Even if it accelerated her eventual end, it certainly improved the situation. She would have been impossible to take care of otherwise. That being said, before Alzheimer's, she was a very anxious person and often difficult. If she was medicated earlier in life, would it have accelerated the onset of Alzheimer's?
- cnees 3mo agoI’ve known two people who experienced psychosis after quitting their meds. One was retired and rode it out, but the other quit his job and ended up being committed, totally upending his life.
- 15feetOfclay 3mo agoThis comment section is absolutely full of people ready and willing to insist that people with depression simply need to cheer up and get over it. And all I can say is: I hope someone shows them a similar level of compassion when they are at their lowest.
- fsuts 3mo agoMost of the problems I would say are related to the modern isolated Nuclear family. See that programmer sat next to you that is not a nice person? Well some kid had no choice but to have him as a parent. Throw in a society that doesn’t value teachers and pays them below many other jobs and the kid spends all his day and evenings with no one to guide and nurture him or her.
- stronglikedan 3mo agoThere is no modern isolated Nuclear family. There's mostly broken homes now, and that is the root cause of most of the problems.
- fsuts 3mo agoAre you one of those religious Bible loons who believes couples need to stay together even if it’s a disaster relationship. As you are wrong if you are. Children suffer more in bad parent relationships
- 15feetOfclay 3mo agoCertainly we are all an alchemical output of our nurturing environments and our intrinsic characteristics, and I don't dispute that we could likely dramatically lower the incidence of severe mental illness by improving our culture's capacity for care and solidarity. It's tough out there, for children and adults.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3mo agoTruly, the cause of all this suffering is not enough antinatalism. You've cracked the code.
- reindeer2 3mo ago[dead]
- Noaidi 3mo agoI think about 10 years ago maybe even more than that maybe 15 years ago I had a conversation under a different name on hacker news and I was telling them about my antidepressant withdrawal. I was downvoted and ridiculed. Told it was just my mental illness and it was all in my head. I even attempted to show the mechanism but people thought that was not enough. Now I see this. It makes me angry. No one listens to the mentally ill and our experiences. By the way, this is also true for and drugs that act on receptors. Like most antipsychotics. It’s is even true for GLP1 drugs. This is a form of addiction that is not see only because the “craving” is absent. It is an addiction which fits not tell you what you are addicted to. Psychiatry is the worst practice right now. There has been zero progress and even less compassion.
- chakintosh 3mo agoNone of my doctors spoke of the withdrawal side effects. But they'd happily prescribe stuff. I was on SSRI (Sertraline) for around a year, and it absolutely demolished my libido, to a point where I became repulsed by it and actively avoided anything sexual with my wife. Luckily, I didn't gain any weight but the sexual side effects were brutal. I eventually visited a couple other doctors, same story, keep sertraline, increase the dose and here are some multivitamins, good luck bro. Eventually had enough of the bull** and stopped it all cold turkey, both Sertraline and Lamotrigine, no tapering off or anything. The headaches that followed were brutal but for me it was way better than the risk of ruining my marriage. A year later, I went back for another try, got prescribed Bupropion and Lamotrigine (again) but neither made any difference, they basically had the same effect as the water I drank with them. So again, stopped them cold turkey and vowed to never get any drugs for my depression and anxiety, and came out with the conclusion that therapy is broken. They'd happily prescribe meds than actually get to the bottom of the issue, it's a symptomatic treatment.
- foco_tubi 3mo agoWithdrawing from citalopram after dropping out of college was one of the worst summers of my life. Brain zaps are real.
- cnlwsu 3mo agoThere’s a lot of focus on negatives in comments. I will say ssris probably saved my life and I have had zero side effects to date. It’s easy to say “just suck it up and power through it”. That advice can kill people
- orangedog 3mo agoThis topic always draws out the contrarians. It's like vaccine discussion.
- elevation 3mo agoPerhaps because various SSRI users have contrary outcomes?
- orangedog 3mo agoSure. I always find the more extremist responses (you can find some towards the bottom) confusing because the only side effect I've ever been aware of is not wanting to die. I just think there's a lot of fud around this and I have friends who have never taken them that were very ready to jump in on the discussion about how they destroy lives.
- 15feetOfclay 3mo agoI'm observing ~3 categories of SSRI negativity in this comment section: 1. Those who have directly experienced negative outcomes from SSRIs or observed negative outcomes in people they care about 2. Those who feel that the medical establishment should more loudly caution about the side effects of SSRIs 3. Those making something tantamount to claims that depression is a natural phenomenon which has been collectively constructed as a mental illness For (1) and (2) I have only compassion and modest disagreement. For (3), I have nothing but disdain.
- JohnMakin 3mo agoI am by no means advocating against taking anti-depressants, I am just sharing my own experience. I have to say this because I have seen people with severe depression make night and day transformations off of these medications and know they can work. For me, it wasn't an SSRI, but a norepinephrine-dopamine reuptake inhibitor - often prescribed for treatment-resistant depression. In my early 20's, I had tried everything, nothing seemed to work, then these treated the physical symptoms pretty well - I got my energy and motivation back, sleep normalized. After several years though they stopped working. We upped the dose until there was nowhere left to go. At the dose I was taking, it was very important to take it at the precise right time or you could spiral into some very bad symptoms. Drink at all, or just a little too much, could spiral you into an episode. I finally decided that it was worth being depressed than what I was dealing with physically and emotionally on the drug, so I stopped it. It was a rough month or two but I entered a new treatment program, the doctor found I was severely D3 deficient. We worked on my sleep habits, nutrition, diet - finally discovering what I had was seasonal affective disorder. So we have a plan for those months, and honestly, it's been 2 years off of them and I have never felt better. Depression is a complicated condition, there's no one treatment in my mind, it's a lot of contributing factors. I won't take them again, especially since there's a moderate chance these drugs actually worsen depression and highly increase risk of suicide. Doctors will just prescribe them without much warning, and that is what I hate, not the drugs themselves.
- ButlerianJihad 3mo agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_the_Clancy_children#Mental_health_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_the_Clancy_children... While her husband was gone, Lindsay strangled their three children one by one with exercise bands in the basement. She then attempted suicide by cutting her wrists and neck and jumping from a second-story window.[6][27] Lindsay sustained spinal cord injuries from the fall and was hospitalized; she remains paralyzed from the waist down as of 2026.[31][32] A forensic toxicologist later testified that Lindsay's blood showed evidence of Remeron, Lamictal, Trazodone, and Seroquel.[33]
- spicyusername 3mo agoI just... are we sure everyone needs to be on anti-depressants? I get that life can be unpleasant, but it just feels like it's so many people. I really have a hard time believing it needs to be so many. It's normal to feel bad.
- snikeris 3mo agoWhether a medication leads to dependence and withdrawal should be given greater weight than it gets in the regulatory process. There needs to be a greater counterweight to the obvious conflict of interest in selling a medication that makes you ill when you stop taking it. Doctors should hold themselves to a higher standard than the chronic disease paradigm.
- nerdyadventurer 3mo agoThis reminded me of this Ted talk: https://www.ted.com/talks/david_anderson_your_brain_is_more_than_a_bag_of_chemicals https://www.ted.com/talks/david_anderson_your_brain_is_more_...
- Snacklive 3mo agoCool, being non reactive to these kinds of medication save my ass in some way