14 ms·
Facebook's legal team bans developer of F.B. Purity from Facebook
- moepstar 14y agoI guess the EFF would offer help if they're asked for it? Other than that, i don't think Facebook has much legal ground if the facts presented in the blog post are everything to the story... IANAL, of course
- vermontdevil 14y agoThey don't care about the legal standing. They know that they can use the lawsuit threat as a weapon to force others into compliance. It's due to the cost of funding a lawsuit which is how corporations get their way whether they have strong legal case or not. Yes there are cases of the "small man" being able to fight back and win. I doubt its par for the course and it's one of the severe drawbacks of our legal system in the US
- wrboyce 14y agoI went to the EFF for help on a similar case once (I am the author of the old Chrome "Facebook Adblock" extension). I went to the EFF for advice mostly, did I need to comply with the takedown? Should I be concerned that I couldn't meet all of the ridiculous demands (they wanted personally identifying information about everyone who had downloaded the extension!). EFF's response? In summary "We're not sure on this one… But can we blog about it? This may or may not cause you more problems." I didn't hear from them again after I asked them to keep it quiet for the time being.
- saurik 14y agoI really wish this person, in the course of an otherwise sane argument (one that I feel for tremendously, as I have spent the last five years of my life organizing a community of people who do nothing but modify other peoples' software products, one that I always have felt has numerous analogies to what people do with GreaseMonkey scripts and browser extensions), didn't feel the need to play the "they don't own the letters FB" card... that is a ludicrous way of looking at trademark law (which involves a large dose of context sensitivity: if you are using FB for a coffee shop that is very different than an app that changes how people use a product that is often abbreviated FB). To then further claim that it stands for Fluff Busting and doesn't have anything to do with Facebook is just trying to play the audience for a fool: it doesn't matter what it "stands for", those letters would not have been chosen in this context had the name of the website been different.
- batgaijin 14y agoScrew that bs. What, no one can use any NASDAQ stock name as a prefix, suffix or in the name at all? I can't publish a book or record a scene with 'google that' because Google wants to protect their brand? Are nations going to publish a list of 'good' words that we can't get sued for using, and name it 'neotalk'?
- Confusion 14y agoDownvoted, because you're completely ignoring the point, which is that 'anyone' is allowed use the letters FB just fine, except for people that make an app that modifies Facebook or is similarly involved with Facebook. Just repeating your point of view doesn't engage the arguments levelled against you.
- catch23 14y agoShouldn't those other 20 developers using FB in their chrome extension on the chrome web store also get the same lawsuit? I feel like this developer might be singled out, since it directly reduces facebook's profits by removing sponsored stories, ads, etc.
- Confusion 14y agoAFAIK, Facebook is legally entitled to being as inconsistent as they want to be, allowing companies they like to use 'FB', while suing companies they don't like. They are entitled to single out developers that encroach on their territory. Now the morality of this behavior is an entirely different discussion...
- bwaskiew 14y agoAren't you at risk of losing some of the scope of your trademark if you do not consistently enforce it?
- 14y ago
- casca 14y agoI'm a little suspicious of this. It might be true but something doesn't sit quite right. Where's the full text? Or a scan of the letter. How do we know that this is done by Facebook's legal team? Why only this product and not others like SocialFixer? Surely the legal team would present a legal response, like a cease and desist?
- toyg 14y agoThis guy clearly was on FB's radar for a while, considering the previous dispute about the extension name. His post is so abrasive, I guess the relationship had never been particularly good.
- fbpdev 14y agoi dont think facebooks legal team like their missives being scrutinised as they put the "all rights reserved" disclaimer on each one. if i were to post a copy of their emails, im guessing they could use the DMCA law to get the posts taken down... is an "all rights reserved" signature legally binding?
- deong 14y agoRegular copyright law perhaps. Unless they protected those emails via some technological mechanism that you had to circumvent to publish, the DMCA isn't relevant. That said, if nothing else there is a strong argument fair use argument for posting excerpts from the communications along with your rebuttals. It's not my money of course, so I understand the reluctance to do so.
- KSerra 14y agoThe DMCA isn't relevant if you host your own website - they could sue you for copyright infringement, but that seems unlikely. Of course, IANAL. As a commenter below said, you would be the one taking the risk, but it would add a huge amount to the credibility of your claim if you posted the legal notices.
- danielweber 14y agoCourts have generally found you are completely in your rights to post any legal threats you get.
- mbusse 14y agoI develop a Greasemonkey/Tampermonkey script that adds features to the Facebook Comments Moderation Tool (http://mattbusse.com/fcm-enhance/ http://mattbusse.com/fcm-enhance/). I have not heard a peep from Facebook about it, although StatCounter tells me that at least someone there has seen it.
- davidjgraph 14y agoI like the comments on that page. Various users complaining how evil and vile they find Facebook. I take it they are annoyed because they use Facebook and want to do client-side parsing. Why not, y'know, just not use Facebook? Are we complicating this issue just to have a discussion? The solution is really simple, yet there seems to be tunnel vision when it comes to thinking of it.
- veemjeem 14y agoNot sure how helpful your comment is either. It would be like saying how evil and vile you find the US government, and your response would be to tell them to move to another country.
- davidjgraph 14y agoSure, that's a like for like. Moving country - deleting Facebook account.
- betterunix 14y agoFacebook interoperates very poorly with other systems, and there are a lot of people who are using Facebook as their primary communication tool. If you don't use Facebook -- I, for example, don't use Facebook -- you are forced to keep reminding certain people that you exist and that you can be contacted by email / IM / phone / etc.
- chii 14y ago> you are forced to keep reminding certain people that you exist and that you can be contacted perhaps those people need to pay more attention to you, instead of to your facebook status and/or wall. Real friends sms or call once in a while.
- nitrogen 14y agoUnfortunately, social convention evolves independently rather than being dictated. If convention evolves in the direction of Facebook events and newsfeeds instead of mass SMS invitations and e-mail, one is forced to choose either to use Facebook or to become a social outcast.
- imran 14y agoI think we should go for some other alternative besides facebook before its too late.
- bbrizzi 14y agoSomething like Diaspora?
- ceejayoz 14y agoIt's a stretch to call Diaspora an "alternative" at this point.
- Apocryphon 14y agoMySpace is on its way back. Should be worth a look, at least to check out its new UI and how well it serves bands and musicians.
- mosselman 14y agoPeople have to stop acting like they have 'the right' to use facebook. It is a product; they set out a couple of rules and act a certain way. Don't like it? Just don't use Facebook.
- marcf 14y agoDo you support Facebook blocking the developer pages of those who are creating the various AdBlock* browser extensions? Isn't that pretty much the same thing as FB Purity is doing but in a more general sense?
- mosselman 14y agoWho said anything about supporting? I am just stating that it is a product and you can choose whether you use it or not, for whatever reasons you deem worthy.
- sjmulder 14y agoI agree that people do not have “the right” to use Facebook, neither are people obliged to. That doesn’t meant that you can’t just not use Facebook. Social networks, in particular Facebook, have become a central part of social interaction. You can’t simply use another network, because they’re not interoperable. Your friends aren’t there, and you’ll be missing out.
- marcf 14y agoThey shouldn't be allowed to ban a company from having an account on Facebook for a web extension? Will the developers of all the AdBlock variants need to worry about their accounts being blocked as well (as they surely are against Facebook's terms of service as well)?
- haukilup 14y agoI'm not sure if your first sentence is questioning someone else's statement, or if you meant "Shouldn't they not be allowed to ...". If you meant to assert that they shouldn't be allowed to: why not? It's their website, and their TOS that's being ignored. They have every right to.
- kamjam 14y agoHis point is that AdBlock to a certain extend does the same thing as this plugin. You don't want to see ads, great we'll remove them. It just doesn't go as far as this plug in does in removing inline adverts and re-organizing content, but that's because it a generic ad blocker and not Facebook specific. So why is it one rule for this guy and another rule for AdBlock (or any other extension)? I run AdBlock, and was shocked to see the amount of adverts on "normal" computers, truly shocking. Does that mean you should ban my account? They have a Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/adblockplus https://www.facebook.com/adblockplus Maybe Google should stop offering AdBlock as a Chrome extension, given that advertising is a huge chunk of their business? You are able to achieve a similar Greasemonkey Firefox plugin. You just need to find the correct scripts... https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/greasemonkey/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/greasemonkey/ The guy should just open source it, let's see Facebook try and keep up with that one.
- oulipo 14y agoWait, I don't get something: how can there be any legal ground for forbidding someone to create a plugin that changes Facebook appearance? How is that different from creating your own browser that render sites however you want? Is Facebook going to try & sue Google when there is a rendering bug in Chrome? Will Facebook sue Userextensions.org? Would Facebook sue someone whose viewing condition alters the way it appears also?
- notimetorelax 14y agoI don't think that they were claiming that it was illegal to do that. They claim that extension breaks their ToS, which is a private contract.
- chii 14y ago> their ToS, which is a private contract. the ToS is between a facebook user and facebook, not the author of the extension and facebook. In fact, the author has no obligation whatsoever with facebook. If facebook does not like their site messsed with, they could detect and block this extension like how some sites block users with adblock running.
- eli 14y agoFacebook doesn't need to have a reason to ban you from their site. It's their site.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nathan_long 14y agoYes. They can ban anyone they want. My question is how they know that Facebook user X and browser extension Y have any connection. If the extension's maker was marketing on Facebook, he should have expected this. Meanwhile, yes, the TOS is between the user and the site. If Facebook wants to fight its users and say "if you don't send HTTP requests for our ad images, we'll stop answering your HTTP requests for our HTML pages," that's up to them. I do think we need to push back whenever companies assert a right to control how a user views their site. That is fundamentally not how the web works. Every resource my browser requests, it requests by my implicit command to do so. Nobody has the right to tell me what to request; they only have a right to decide how they'll respond to my requests.
- netcan 14y agoWhat exactly is the relevant law here. Trademarks are (as I understand it) a way to stop other from trading as you in some way. You can't pretend to be facebook, affiliated with facebook or use a name/symbol that makes it easy to get confused. OTOH, if your product relates to another (Companion to "Fundamentals Of Microbiology by James O'Leary" by Timothy Goldman), is that not allowed? Companies can be called "Help with Windows" can't they? What are the actual rules?
- praptak 14y ago"Trademarks are (as I understand it) a way to stop other from trading as you in some way." In the same way as patents are a way to encourage innovation. In the hands of corporate lawyers both turn into means to turn others' lives harder.
- rmc 14y agoBasically, if customers might think you are the original company. It's essentially a form of fraud protection.
- saurik 14y agoI am not certain there are, or even if there should be, steadfast rules: it largely comes down to whether there is a legitimate case for confusion. If you tried to prosecute this you would attempt to demonstrate cases where users were confused while potentially attempting to motivate that the name was chosen with at least some intention to confuse. To look at your examples, however: the usage of prepositions changes things drastically. Can you imagine Microsoft creating a new product, "Microsoft Essentials"? If you saw that book, would you at least momentarily, wonder if it was a first-party product (book, software, whatever) from Microsoft? I am not certain about you, but that sounds like it could be them. However, if I saw "Essentials of Microsoft", I am pretty certain I wouldn't jump there: I would think that this is something describing Microsoft, not something built by Microsoft. (edit: I thought I made that example up, but I then did a search for it after posting my comment, and it turns out that, in fact, that is so much the kind of thing that Microsoft would do that they pretty much have, with "Windows Live Essentials", "Windows Essentials", and "Microsoft Security Essentials", all being terms they've used. Yet, even with all of those usages, "Essentials of Microsoft" sounds more like a documentary or description than something they would have made themselves.) This gets exceptionally bad with little tags like Apple's "i"; the "i" is so overwhelmingly "Apple's thing" that if I saw an app on someone's phone called "iVideo" I can't imagine not thinking "wow, Apple made a video service?", and when people choose a name like that, it is because they know what the "i" means to people, and they want to look "more official" and "more like Apple", which even if the intention is not "I want them to think I am Apple" is still in the bad zone. Regardless, the core issue here isn't even this trademark problem, and that should probably have just been left at "we agreed this was fine, and now they are changing their minds". The more serious issue here is whether Facebook should be able to ban a user for building a product they don't like and whether building it, using it, or both are legally grounded.
- motters 14y agoProbably the way to go with this is to open source it, such that anyone can independently share and compile it. But just in case anyone becomes fatigued of fighting the ridiculous control freakery of Mr Zuckerberg’s lawyers there is always Friendica. Friendica is already open source. It’s themeable. There is no spam or bribed posts, and you don’t have to be trapped in some AOL-style walled garden.
- smeddinck 14y agoThe funny thing is: Facebook just blocked me from posting this link (even when processed by a link-shortener to be http://is.gd/facebook_megalomania http://is.gd/facebook_megalomania ), saying it has been "blocked for being spammy or unsafe"!
- bbrizzi 14y agoSo, should the Internet Explorer team also be banned from facebook? They too "interfere with the way Facebook is rendered to its users".
- hamai 14y agoHow long until DRM browsers where userscripts will be considered piracy?
- lazugod 14y agoThis is already the case with Chrome. See http://superuser.com/questions/450893/how-to-install-a-private-user-script-in-chrome-21 http://superuser.com/questions/450893/how-to-install-a-priva... which details how unauthorized userscripts are made difficult to install. Even better, try pasting javascript:alert('hi'); into the address bar.
- btrask 14y agoThose changes were made for security, to make social engineering attacks more difficult. You can still type JS into the address bar, you just can't copy and paste it.
- Kerrick 14y agoFurther, you can copy and paste it into the console.
- LesZedCB 14y agothis is probably a good thing more often then not, though.
- nathanhammond 14y agoI can confirm that this was to close actively exploited security vulnerabilities. I was one of the first to file a "bug" on this attack vector. :)
- 14y ago
- danso 14y agoInteresting...I started using the "Missing e" plugin for Tumblr...but after Tumblr kept giving me dire warnings about how I was compromising my security and being an otherwise bad person, I disabled it, thinking that at some point Tumblr might just hellban the plugin users. (Also, the plugin wasn't as useful for my usecases as I had hoped.)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Rudism 14y agoFacebook really couldn't have been more generous to this guy. He's really milking the free publicity, too, with all the talk of this being the end of the road (which clearly it won't be, since there's nothing to stop him from continuing work using an alternate account). I can't even imagine what Facebook was thinking, they must have known that attempting to shut this down would backfire. If I were Facebook and I really didn't want this extension or others like it to stay afloat, my approach would be simple... hire one guy whose only job is to monitor new releases of these extensions, and then make minor structural changes to the Facebook site that break them as soon as they're out. Become the mouse in a game of cat and mouse. When the extension keeps breaking within a day or two of each release, users would get fed up and stop using it, the devs would get overwhelmed with bug reports and complaints, and they'd all die slow, quiet deaths.
- sethbannon 14y ago"Facebook really couldn't have been more generous to this guy." Yes they could have. They could have not banned him for building a browser extension.
- hnriot 14y agoI think you missed the point entirely. Facebook have just become his marketing department.
- digitalengineer 14y agoPurity user here. Love your product but think perhaps it's time to let go. Attacking you personally with lawyers will end badly for you. Their goal is not to "win" but just to delay, frustrate and (if you keep it up) bankrupt you because of all the costs. It's the standard strategy followed by lot's of big companies with deep pockets. Purity rocked and so do you. I'd put those talents to good use on other ideas.
- itry 14y agoNot true. Big companies do not always win just because they are big. I wonder in what kind of world you live. When somebody has more money then you, you bow down no matter what he wants from you? Common. A bit more courage!
- digitalengineer 14y agoSomebody or FaceBook with it's infinite resources? What's the best he can hope for? Get his old account back and continue building a free product, all the while relying on the popularity of social network? If he becomes really big they'll turn it into a cat-and-mouse game like Apple did with other music players tapping in their iTunes. I was not thinking about courage, but rather about focus and choosing your battles.
- itry 14y ago> What's the best he can hope for? He can simply continue his project in any way he likes. He doesnt need a facebook account to do so. If he likes, he could also sue facebook for access. But as I said in another comment, I dont know US law enough to know if he would win. As I understand it, he has a large userbase. So his project has a purpose. Just because its free, it doesnt mean its no good.
- digitalengineer 14y agoAh but I didn't say it was "no good". Instead I said I was a user of Purity. Suing FB? Winning? We live in different world my friend ;-)
- twapi 14y agothis also means that blocking contents using Adblock extension violates T&C.
- ricardobeat 14y agoDo they have any legal ground for this? A browser extension doesn't interact with the service directly, and is explicitly enabled by the user, therefore it should not be subject to the service's terms. What about extensions that affect every website? God forbid we end up with a 'no-extend' tag that disallows them.
- greedo 14y agoSomewhere, Barbara Streisand is shaking her head.
- oliveoil 14y agoI think Facebook is not after FB Purity. They are after anyone who could come up with a plugin that scrapes the content and stores it to a db. People using the plugin would get access to the db in exchange: companies could look up prospective employees, ex-girlfriends spy on their defriended ex-boyfriends, etc. Hell, the idea is so tempting that someone is definitely doing this already. And you'd only need a percentile of the users to get the information for every other facebook user.
- patrickod 14y agoSurely this can be said of any application that you give such permissions to with OAauth? We've already seen cases of people selling the information they gathered.
- darrikmazey 14y agoUp-front disclaimer: I don't use facebook, but the precedent of this upsets me. It seems to me that a website can define the API by which you access their site (some subset of HTTP), but can they really make a definitive claim to how data is rendered on the client side once that data is fetched through legitimate targets?
- kfinley 14y ago"...Facebook is blocking direct links to my site and libeling me by claiming the site is “Spammy and Unsafe...”. Does anyone else see a problem with this, or is this justified? It feels like Facebook has crossed a line from guardian to censor.
- w1ntermute 14y ago> It feels like Facebook has crossed a line from guardian to censor. I'm pretty sure Facebook crossed that line a long time ago.
- sp332 14y agoThey've been playing censor for a while now. You can't post links to the pirate bay, for example. Not even in direct measages!
- tyang 14y agoSorry to hear this. I used F.B. Purity for several weeks/months. But good job in going public the way you did. You're now trending on HN.
- languagehacker 14y agoAt first I thought Facebook was the bad guy, and then I went to this guy's site. I'm legitimately surprised I didn't get a malware warning. This thing looks like it's from the '90s. Also, the begging for donations is slightly unbecoming when one of the primary purposes of your extension is to hide ads. Furthermore, take a look at this obnoxious Facebook page that I'm surprised hasn't been taken down yet: https://www.facebook.com/fluffbustingpurity https://www.facebook.com/fluffbustingpurity Isn't such heavy (and spammy, As-Seen-On-TV-Reminiscent) advertising about a product that flouts Facebook's functionalities on Facebook just playing with fire?
- Buzaga 14y agoI don't get it, why is it that the pages are ugly a reason to consider it "the bad guy"? I installed this extension before, I didn't keep it because it didn't had an option to silence events notification, what I was looking for, but it didn't seem bad
- throwaway125 14y agoI don't understand where your malware remark comes from. I've visited his website (albeit with noscript on) and it looks a lot more readable than your average news site. Seems like a low blow to attack him over how the website looks, especially when you mention you were surprised it didn't serve malware.
- eyeareque 14y agoI had never heard of f.b purity before today. Thanks to facebook for bringing this to my attention through hassling a developer.
- thisthisthis 14y agoFacebook has no control over a user's browser. The most they can do is randomly ban users, like this guy. The truth is this is something no website can control. If I want to view FB via a local proxy on my device that filters out commercial garbage, I can do so. And I can show any of my friends how to do the same. A little tcpserver, tcpclient and sed and we can clean things up quite nicely, with minimal fuss. These attempts to control how someone views a website (e.g. see Twitter's recent efforts) are futile. This is digital, not print. A social website is mainly just text (html) and various resource files (e.g. images), it is all malleable in digital form and there are myriad ways to process it and render it, of which the Facebook developers' choice or a popular web browser developers' choice are only a few. You have to wonder if FB's legal team even understands what is technically feasible and what isn't (like controlling how a page is viewed, on the client side).
- n9com 14y agoWow, anyone notice that you cannot post a link on Facebook to the fbpurity.com domain (even if you shorten the URL). Facebook is blocking the posting of the URL as it is in their words 'spammy or unsafe'.
- grecy 14y agoI find it interesting and scary that one of the most used information sources in the world can be arbitrarily censored so easily. I wonder if an article about some scandalous escapades of Facebook high-ups would be similarly censored.
- duncan_bayne 14y agoOf course it would. Obligatory XKCD: http://xkcd.com/743/ http://xkcd.com/743/
- perlpimp 14y agoyou can refer to as I did to: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/fb-purity-cleans-up-facebook/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/fb-purity-cle...
- simoncion 14y agoI wonder if Facebook still blocks links to youropenbook.org and/or openbook.org.
- mullingitover 14y agoSomebody on facebook has never heard of the Streisand Effect. This is actually a really great fix for facebook and it implements a lot of features I've really wanted. For example, the ability to hide sponsored stories.
- thisthisthis 14y agoIt would be interesting to know what FB (or Twitter, for that matter) tells its advertisers about how they can purportedly control the appearance of commercial content to the user. Are they upfront about the realities and the risks? Are they leading the advertisers on? Are advertisers well-informed? What would advertisers have to say about the existence client-side options that can easily manipulate content to the user's preferences? It would be interesting to know.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoSo if I build a scraper to give me my information from Facebook and archive it, am I violating the ToS? I'm so sick of this era of "Let's all build a service and lock users in" and it pains me every time YC picks another company whose future is "build a huge social base and then we'll figure out how to monetize it".
- readme 14y ago>What do you think I should do? Keep up the fight, or let the expletives deleted win? You lose either way. Either, you fight to keep your app, and you're helping a company that doesn't respect your contributions, or you give up, and you lose with less effort. Lose the easy way. Make an app for someone who cares.
- JeremyMorgan 14y agoI find it rather interesting that I tried to post a link to this article on Facebook and got this: http://i.imgur.com/REvQR.png http://i.imgur.com/REvQR.png The content you're trying to link to is spammy or unsafe. If so, FB Purity is the best malware I've ever downloaded.
- joering2 14y agoJust in case there is still someone left out there who believes in Zuck's lie about openess of the internet and giving users ability to connect and access their information freely. This is your wakeup call. Facebook can shine on the outside but it will take predatory steps against anyone fucking around with them and affecting their ad sale stock display.