9 ms·
Your website is not for you
- sitebirds 7mo ago[flagged]
- adampunk 7mo agoCounterpoint: yes it is.
- 0123456789ABCDE 7mo agoperhaps, before the thread derails into a bunch of comments like the parent, we should consider that the article is not a comment on what your side-projects look like, those obviously should look however you please. rather the comment is directed at folks who want both great UX, and for their taste to reflected on the website, and quite frankly: some of you have absolutely no sense of what usability affordances require, not to mention _taste_.
- adampunk 7mo agoCounterpoint: that's also wrong and those who give up the idea of their website being for "them" (a person or group) end up making websites that are bad. Jakob's law is often taken as support for the opposite position, but if Google looked like search engines circa 1998, no one would have switched.
- 0123456789ABCDE 7mo agohave you considered, in the specific example of google being different from the rest, that all the other services were _wrong,_ or their goals were different than google's?
- adampunk 7mo agoI’m not sure what you’re arguing with. GOOGLE did not look like the rest of the search engine engines on purpose. We agree completely. It looked very different and it operated in a very different way. If instead, we designed GOOGLE like we designed website websites now, with Jakob’s law front of mind, what would have been created would have just been another entry in a forgettable list. The argument is that user research will tell you when your customers want a faster horse. It will not tell you all that much else. If you want customers who want a faster horse or if what you need is to be told to make a faster horse—which is most websites— it works great.
- IAmBroom 7mo agoGoogle did, and we did. Google won the search engine war by having a far superior engine, not because they had cute art for the six letters of the company name (which came later).
- rustyhancock 7mo agoTime for my favourite old man yells at cloud opinion. The internet was a far better place when websites were created by individuals mainly for themselves. And probably hosted for free on Geocities.
- arlobish 7mo agoI get why a design studio would think this way, but in many cases it is for me.
- juddlyon 7mo agoBeware of the HIPPO! (Highest Paid Person’s Opinion)
- hyperhello 7mo agoThis writing was effective, clear, to the point, and revealed a human perspective. I can sense the frustrated professional going behind the curtain and tidying up his reservations about dealing with his clients. It was refreshing to read in exactly the way AI slop isn’t.
- deleted 7mo ago[deleted]
- newer_vienna 7mo agoThis was clearly written with AI help, the tells are all over the place
- big85 7mo agoPerhaps better stated: Your company's website isn't for you, it's to pursue the agenda of your company. Your personal homepage is for you, if you can free yourself from view count as a success metric.
- bcjdjsndon 7mo agoI think it's implicit...
- smeej 7mo agoIt is, but not until you actually get into the article. I also assumed the article would be about personal websites until I read it.
- satvikpendem 7mo agoPeople should be reading the article before posting knee-jerk responses like I see elsewhere on this thread.
- josefresco 7mo agoCame here to say basically this. Your company website is not for you, but your personal website should be. I spent years chasing Google traffic and useless business goals for my own blog until I realized I should publish for me, not the users. And if I do something that Google doesn't like... who cares? It's for me and Google will come crawling (literally) back anyways. Currently I use my blog as a bookmarking service. Instead of a browser bookmark, I built a Chrome extension that simply posts the link to my blog as a new post where it's public, and easily discoverable from any device BY ME!
- embedding-shape 7mo ago> The website isn't for the founder, the marketing manager, or the board. It should though, if people only got involved in stuff they're directly using themselves, all software would end up so much better. The best software out there seems to be when people who feel responsible over something, also uses that same thing themselves and they earn a comfortable living by doing so. If we could find a way of increasing the amount of software produced in this way, we could maybe avoid falling over spaghetti in some decades, otherwise we'll just live with 50% broken software which seems to be the current direction. Edit: I probably should have read the landing page first, which says: > Partner for designers - Websmith Studio builds future-ready websites in collaboration with world-class designers. They're clearly building client websites for others, then yeah, what they say is true, you're not building for yourself :)
- brynet 7mo agooh, okay then.. you can have it https://brynet.ca/ https://brynet.ca/
- doublerabbit 7mo agoHow dare you run a website without some sort of React framework.
- jdw64 7mo agoA website is a compromise between three parties. User: I want to get the information I came for. Business: I want to build brand trust and drive conversion. Internal organization: I want the owner’s taste and preferences to be reflected. The article strongly says that a website is for the user. I agree with the spirit of that argument, but in practice, most users’ “taste” is shaped by brand reputation. And where does brand reputation come from? Often, it comes from the owner’s taste, positioning, and accumulated decisions. A SaaS landing page is not only a place where users get information. From the company’s perspective, it is also a tool for imprinting the company’s positioning in the user’s mind. I think this phenomenon is essentially a principal-agent problem. In real client work, most clients are not thinking about UX. They are thinking about the owner’s experience — OX, so to speak. And in practice, most companies operate based on OX. In the ideal story, everyone says they care about UX. But most businesses do not actually run on UX. They run on OX. The key question is whether the owner’s taste happens to align with the public’s taste.
- jdw64 7mo agoWhy do people pay so much money for reports from dubious firms like Gartner? The game they are playing is almost like a coin toss. If you look at the Gartner reports that become publicly visible, they are often wrong. So why do reports from companies like Gartner still sell? Because they reduce the anxiety of the owner or decision-maker. Business is complex. Even a bad product can succeed because of advertising. Exaggerated marketing, fraud, timing, distribution, and luck all exist, and they can all produce success. UX is an ideal. But in practice, developers often have to satisfy OX: owner experience. Companies appear to pursue profit because most owners like money. But in reality, many companies are closer to the realization of the owner’s ideology, taste, and worldview. So what matters? For a developer, it becomes important to judge how closely the owner’s taste aligns with the public, and with the target audience. That is why developers often end up flattering the owner: not merely because of hierarchy, but because the owner’s taste is frequently the actual operating system of the business.
- adampunk 7mo agoHow does this generalize to firms with more than one stakeholder/owner? I don't see how it does without some magic where we assume that all members of e.g. the C-suite have similar, model-able reasoning.
- susam 7mo agoWhen I first read the title, my reaction was: how dare they say my website isn't for me? Of course it is. It's my space to share thoughts, jot down notes from things I come across, publish small tools, and so on. That made me click through and see how the article could possibly argue otherwise. Then I realised that the article talks about business websites, not personal websites. Quoting from the article: > The website isn't for the founder, the marketing manager, or the board. It's for the person you've never met - the customer weighing up a purchase, the lead chasing a phone number, the visitor sizing up your credibility or the member signing up to access gated content. Yes, I agree. While not really a business, I've always liked https://nhs.uk/ https://nhs.uk/ for its simplicity. I especially like the A-Z section where we can find details about a large number of medical conditions. Among actual businesses (small ones particularly) I like https://buttondown.com/ https://buttondown.com/ and https://kagi.com/ https://kagi.com/ quite a bit. That said (and this is off-topic for this article), the part of the web I enjoy most is where your website is indeed for you, the small web of personal websites. That part of the web was an important part of me growing up from my late teens into adulthood and it remains the part I enjoy most even now. I want this part of the web to remain healthy and vibrant for as long as possible.
- BoredPositron 7mo agoYour commercial website is not for you. Would be a better title.
- dwd 7mo agoOr non-personal. There are non-commercial websites such as Government that put a lot of effort into focussing on the user. Some of the Gov design systems are well worth looking at. https://design-system.service.gov.uk/ https://design-system.service.gov.uk/ https://designsystem.digital.gov/ https://designsystem.digital.gov/
- nephihaha 7mo agoI thought the object of government, legal and complaints websites was to reduce customer interaction? The British government is notorious for bad or barely functional websites.
- forgotusername6 7mo agoThis applies to pretty much every situation. It is not just about visual things, it is more about things that are easy to have an opinion on. Its similar concept to bike shedding, but with the added emphasis of the decision maker. Though the very fact we even call them that kind of implies that they should have a say right? I guess we object to the kind of say that they have. Should a decision maker just make binary decisions? Yes to this, no to that.
- aleda145 7mo agoI have felt this a lot when designing the landing page for my SQL canvas side project. _I_ really want to write about DuckDB WASM, pre-signed URLs and how cool Cloudflare's durable objects are. But my target audience are data analysts, and they just want to analyze some data! I have gone through a lot of design revisions because I have a hard time containing my technical excitement. I was surprised how hard communicating a product clearly is. As a backend/data person I was on the high horse thinking that designers jobs are so much easier than distributed systems. Now I feel the opposite!
- p2hari 7mo agoMaybe that's why I am not in your target audience, but love how the design looks. I have bookmarked it also. You show so many features and it is nice in the way it is being presented and is also mobile friendly. Also I too am a fan of neobrutalism. :)
- aleda145 7mo agoThank you! :-)
- paulhebert 7mo agoJust wanted to second that the design is lovely
- cyberge99 7mo agoHow do you know what his side project is? I couldn’t find a link.
- Stratoscope 7mo agoIt's listed in his HN profile: https://kavla.dev/ https://kavla.dev/ Along with his personal website: https://dahl.dev/ https://dahl.dev/
- aleda145 7mo ago
- coder97 7mo ago"Can I get the icon in cornflower blue."
- maxehmookau 7mo agoThis is a distillation of what we used to (still do?) teach junior SWEs. "You are not the customer for the thing we're making, nor have you ever been. You don't know what they want/need."
- adampunk 7mo agoThis is true but the common implication, "UX research knows your customer" is horseapples. I will point out we allow ourselves to believe that UX research knows the customer because we train like the above. We tell our engineers they don't know what the customer wants and when it comes time to put a foot down, they have nowhere firm to stand.
- maxehmookau 7mo agoI _think_ it's the best we have right now, right? Excellent UX research speaks for itself, there's just not much of it. As an industry, we've done a realllllly good job of devaluing high-quality UX research and those who do it for a living.
- FlamingMoe 7mo ago“A website isn't art. It's a tool with one job: get the user to do the thing they came for.” Eh, I don’t think this is accurate. A website does serve utility, but if you remove art from the discussion, then it becomes soulless, which is not the world we want to live in. Take HN for example. The first time I visited, I thought it was a terrible, dated design. But over time I grew to appreciate it. I think it is, in fact, quite artistic; it has a style, it makes a statement. If HN were “modern and user-first” maybe users would have an initial better impression, maybe they would even “convert” better initially. But long-term, it would start to lose its soul.
- adampunk 7mo agoYeah I think the whole "the website is to help the user do a job" mostly exists to give people who do UX a position of authority. The user needs to do a job; we can't pre-specify that job entirely; users who are frustrated in their job will leave with it incomplete. Those three things are totally true, but they are often used to justify a third thing: input on website design should be driven by user feedback, filtered through UX research. A refusal of the third thing is where you get design like HN. You can do UX research; everyone should. But if it is more than merely an input into design, you become rudderless.
- duskdozer 7mo agoI guess in a world filled with heavy, modern, nauseating design, being fast and simple can be a statement. But I don't think websites meant to be used should be art or statements.
- dmje 7mo agoThis is a job for people like me: product / project managers who work on a project to translate business (and audience!) needs into specifics around design and build. It's a skill all of its own, and it requires time and effort and expertise - it won't just emerge naturally, it won't happen without time thinking about strategy, audience, metrics, goals. We spend a whole bunch of time when we're running projects pushing back and telling clients to "think less like you and more like your audience". It's not surprising to me that clients come with pre-set notions: of course they do, it's their business, they're in it all day every day, and they're thinking about it all the time. This doesn't make them good at thinking about this stuff from alternative / audience angles!
- nxpnsv 7mo agoNo, my website is for me and not everything is a product
- pvillano 7mo agoIf you're in this comment section, consider play-testing your website. Find someone who has never used it and watch them explore it for the first time, while they think out loud, without giving them any help. My personal website had links to GitHub, LinkedIn, etc. on the home page, and the first thing my brother in law did was leave the site, without ever looking at any of my posts, which were indexed on another page. This example might be obvious to you, but I guarantee there's something you can learn through play-testing.
- xyzelement 7mo agoThe only problem with this analysis is that in practice a lot of the designers don't understand the customer and don't understand the business. Don't understand the market, at least compared to the founders or people who've been in the space for a long time. So there's a bit of a false confidence where the designers think they know what's really right because they did "scientific approach". But in reality the founders actually more correct.
- corry 7mo ago[dead]
- topham 7mo agoThis. Most designers are designing for their customer, their customer is the one paying their salary/commission/contract.
- almostarockstar 7mo ago100%. Ignoring the fact that sometimes founders feel the need to put their stamp on everything, for startups and scaleups that haven't progressed to corporate slog, I think it's near impossible for even the best staff designer in the world to arrive at the optimum website/deck/infographic/widget without founder or leader feedback. The key ingredient is their insight. That's what sets any startup apart. Otherwise the designer would be the founder.
- dnnddidiej 7mo agoSounds like the founder as well as the customers are who the designer should be gathering data points from. I think anything where a surprise is presented (in design or otherwise) means some missed communication.
- cybercatgurrl 7mo agoi would much rather work under a designer founder with someone who understands their domain than just about anyone else
- 7mo ago
- Nivge 7mo agoThe problem is that user research and competitive research are also not the truth. I prefer to ship something I know I like than what someone else thinks a third abstract person might like.
- DANmode 7mo agoUser research + your tasteful assumptions to fix pain points is the closest thing to truth we have.
- celltalk 7mo agoYes, it’s for agents traversing the web universe like photons.
- chrisweekly 7mo agoInteresting post. It pairs well with this other one^1 I bookmarked just yesterday about the way business websites' home pages so often suffer from lack of ownership (a la "tragedy of the commons"). In both cases, I'm reminded of Julie Zhuo's awesome "How to be Strategic" post^2 which emphasizes being crystal clear on WHOSE problem you're trying to solve. 1. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/website-you-havent-rebuilt-marketing-project-youre-avoiding-88rsc https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/website-you-havent-rebuilt-ma... 2. https://medium.com/@joulee/how-to-be-strategic-f6630a44f86b https://medium.com/@joulee/how-to-be-strategic-f6630a44f86b PS Disclaimer: It feels strange to share links to LIN and Medium, two problematic platforms I'd prefer not to support. But these specific posts are worthwhile, so I'm sharing anyway.
- erelong 7mo ago...and now it's for AI to "consoom"...
- huflungdung 7mo ago[dead]
- samagragune 7mo ago[flagged]
- jason_pomerleau 7mo agoI’ve found that the larger the company, the less this is a problem. At smaller orgs, it’s common for the owner or leader to have their personal identity tied up in the brand, sometimes a bit too much, which leads to hyper-involvement. As you move up the food chain, the distance between the people you answer to and the source of the money they are spending grows, personal attachment to the outcome diminishes, and you get a lot less meddling. It’s one of the main reasons our team turns away very small customers.
- ubermonkey 7mo agoI find that I am AMAZED at how few customer-facing sites have failed to even consider the basic idea of "why is someone on our site?" A great example is a restaurant site. If a user has to scroll and click around to find an address, a phone number, and hours of operation, the site has FAILED.
- IAmBroom 7mo agoLiteral pages of hyper-zoomed pictures of food, followed by pictures of groups laughing while eating, followed by mentions of catering and merch... and vital info at the very bottom, with dinner menus hidden in web menus, or only available from the "Order Online" link. What I see all the time. I hate it so much. "Oh, honey, this restaurant has a picture of pepperoni on cheese. Let's eat there... wherever it is!"
- Halloloid 7mo agovery Nice Blog its Really Correct That The Website is Not for You
- dgellow 7mo agoI fully reject the whole “the website isn’t art”, “the website isn’t about you”. That fees so myopic. A website is part of developing a brand identity. It is about expressing your values, while also providing information/a service (assuming we talk about companies). Art is about communicating feelings, emotions, a message, there is a clear overlap with a brand identity here
- xondono 7mo agoBut that isn’t the point at all. For most businesses, you’re not the target audience of your website, your potential customers are.
- dgellow 7mo agoYes. That’s the point. You’re in a conversation with your customers, their website interactions is your opportunity to develop your identity/brand. The way you yourself (assuming you’re the founder for example) feel about it does matter quite a lot
- satvikpendem 7mo agoThis is how your company goes broke. There was a company, Amie, that had this [0] as their landing page initially, without the /art path. Guess what, visitors didn't convert, and then the company redid their landing page [1] to actually explain and convert customers. They literally host their prior landing page as "art" because it was so terrible at acquiring customers. [0] https://amie.so/art https://amie.so/art [1] https://amie.so https://amie.so
- whstl 7mo agoThey had a "normal" page before the art one for the longest time according to my memory but confirmed by web archive. Also: the current website is for a different product altogether. They pivoted. Attributing low conversion rate to the style of the page isn't really fair when it was apparently a last attempt at attracting customers for an idea that was eventually abandoned.
- stephbook 7mo ago"Listen to the customer/research." Ah the customer isn't in the room? Well, too bad, now you have to listen to the author. How convenient!
- fduran 7mo agoYes, the website is for prospective (and current) clients. A small annoyance in startup circles is getting feedback about my website front page along the lines of "I didn't understand your hero, everybody should understand in one sentence what you do". Well, no, my clients will self-select as in not everybody needs to understand what "troubleshooting servers" or "devops" is :-)
- dist-epoch 7mo agoRelevant comic: https://theoatmeal.com/comics/design_hell https://theoatmeal.com/comics/design_hell
- shevy-java 7mo ago> The website isn't for the founder, the marketing manager, or the board. It's for the person you've never met - the customer Actually - the websites I create, design and maintain, are ... primarily for me. I am a very critical user though, so I am also a great feedback person. I tell myself "you need to improve this". Then I either do so, or put it in a todo file that is rarely looked at lateron again. So I don't agree that a website is not "for you". I think that a website CAN be for you. The article makes no such distinction; it only insinuates that everyone is incompetent and designs for things other people may not need or want. Besides, people are also different - designing a perfect webpage is not possible. You have to make compromises. Take reddit.com - I can only use old.reddit.com because the new interface is so useless. That's one example of so many more that could be given here.
- IAmBroom 7mo agoYou seem to be responding to the title, not the article content. Your website is your own, and that's not what the article is addressing. You don't have designers and governing boards; it's written about sites for bigger organizations.
- zkmon 7mo ago> It's for the person you've never met Well, you have made a big assumption there. Maybe you haven't met the decision makers. It's not just their own whims and fancies. It's true that one's own perception of what the customer likes, is influenced by their personal taste as well. But on the other hand, building something while disregarding your own taste completely, doesn't give the required motivation.
- hypron 7mo agoIronic that the site has a clock in the corner which is the site owner's current time.
- agmater 7mo agoWhat's the irony? The site telling your local time would be helpful how/why?
- amavashev 7mo agoTrue website is not for you and in the age for AI is not even for people. Its for AI agents reading your website and deciding what to do with it: recommend it, skip it, integrate with it, etc.
- SoftTalker 7mo agoYes more and more this will be the case. Websites will not be for people, because most people don't go to websites for the experience, they go there for information. And if a smart search engine can show them what they need to know without actaully showing the website, that's good enough in most cases. You can stop worrying about layout, styles, colors, fonts, responsive design... just put the information on a page so that AI can understand it.
- another-dave 7mo agoCase in point - My first webdev job was producing a site for the city library. My boss explained to them when going through their sitemap that they should to rename their planned section from "Lending" to "Borrowing".
- andrewingram 7mo agoI remember regularly scrambling to redesign our marketing site, because the CEO was going to start speaking to investors in less than a week. So we'd always end up with a homepage that represented a new narrative the CEO was trying out, often at the expense of current customers being able to find what they were looking for (our homepage was also our primary entry point into the onboarding funnel).
- dadie 7mo agoSorry to be frank and for the upcoming rant as your site is mostly fine, but looking at most websites I visite these days be it from a company, a service, a webshop, an open source project, a forum, a blog, a newspaper or almost any form of social media. I'd say I do not know for whom anyone is designing those sites, but I can clearly say it is not for me (as a human user and/or customer). The websites with the best UX I know are mostly those who haven't really changed for the past 20 years. I might be crazy but assume to not be alone in this one, as I have yet to find someone who likes their back button being hijacked. Likes being blasted by an autoplay video on max volume. Likes seeing the UI reorganized almost every other month. Likes seeing constantly moving and/or blinking elements on a mostly text based website. I've yet to hear from someone liking no longer being able to say "no" and being only allowed to say "yes" or "maybe later" (which is a code for "I'll annoy you till you finally break and say yes"). I've yet to hear someone liking to have less informationen visible and being forced to navigate a maze of menu items for things which used to be just their. Or who simply likes not being able to tell what is or isn't an element which can be interacted with. Who are those people who like to give almost every other site their phone number? And who are those who likes telling almost every other click how the "experience" with the website was so far? Who are those people who like being reminded about the mostly useless annoying AI assistance every other click? I've yet to find someone who sad "Oh boy, it was really nice that they asked me to give the online shop on some rando rating site 5 stars". Or "Oh boy, I sure love the popup about signing up to the awesome informative newsletter each time I visit the site". Or "I really like that my PC fan starts to spin audible whenever I go to this website". Or "Oh yes, I was so happy being asked to install the mobile app for an rando website I found via a search engine" Or "It's really nice that I always have to solve a captcha and noone is telling me why" In my experience people do not like modern website, they at most tolerate them. It's like paying taxes. Can't do nothing about it. Edit: Typos
- bee_rider 7mo ago> The websites with the best UX I know are mostly those who haven't really changed for the past 20 years. > I might be crazy but assume to not be alone in this one, as I have yet to finde someone who likes their back button being hijacked. Likes being blasted by an autoplay video on max volume. Likes seeing the UI reorganized almost every other month. Likes seeing constantly moving and/or blinking elements on a mostly text based website. Are these really common features for modern websites? I think most browsers block auto-play of videos. Back button hijacks: annoying but again I feel like I stumbled across that more often 5-10 years ago. Nowadays the annoying website thing seems to be screwing around with the scrollbar. Although, I definitely do agree that the 20-30 years ago style is best. Just give me some text. I’m going to block the JavaScript and set my own background colors and font anyway, so the less clutter the better.
- r00t- 7mo agoAnd why did you put a clock in your website? lol
- monokai_nl 7mo agoMy website is absolutely for me. Anyone who wants to visit is welcome though, I put it online for a reason. (You're also free to move along for that matter, that's up to you.) The article states "A website isn't art". This product mindset fundamentally makes the web a boring place. I would personally welcome all websites that are art.
- _fat_santa 7mo agoOne distinction the author didn't make was personal sites vs product / services sites. My personal site is for me, but the site for my SaaS app? That's for my customers.
- bisby 7mo ago_should be_ for your customers. Business minded folk can convince themselves that "ads are for the consumer because they benefit from knowing about our great deals!" but everyone else knows that ads are for the business to increase revenue. If they didn't increase revenue, the business wouldn't do it. If your website provides an actual utility, then that utility is for the customers. Everything else on the site (upsells, cross sells, branding), is for the business.
- satvikpendem 7mo agoThey increase revenue by...getting customers. Therefore everything on the site is for the customer, in terms of acquiring them.
- bisby 7mo agoI was merely trying to convey that when I go to a restaurant website, I want to: see the menu, make a reservation, see hours. There is a specific list of reasons I would go to your restaurant website. It is utility that serves me. If I go to your restaurant's website and have to dig to find the menu and the page is just plastered with "Fine dining with a wonderful view" and pictures of models eating... that's not helping me, that's advertising to me. And now your website is no longer a utility/service, it is a billboard. The only reason I tolerate the billboard is because of the utility, and if the utility doesnt exist, why would I ever come back.
- Jabrov 7mo agoI think part of the problem is that a lot of designers are simply not that good at what they do
- pimlottc 7mo agoGovernment websites are often particular bad this way. Nobody cares who the head of the agency is or wants to read their newest blog post. Most people don’t need to know that the new records department opened in Des Moines. They need to know what programs they qualify for and how to get benefits.
- d--b 7mo agoMany CEOs are pricks. Many UX experts are too. Shouldn't come as a big surprise really.
- frankdenbow 7mo agoVery true. I did over 300 product marketing website reviews and the most common thing I would see is a generic description of this big aspirational vision of the company and none of the specifics of what a company actually does. If you’re into see what great websites do the YouTube playlist with the top sites is at http://goatedguild.com http://goatedguild.com
- jp0001 7mo agoThat website was not for me.
- jppope 7mo agoI think the point is sound but the author is selling the fictional executives ("decision makers") short. Design research will inevitably always lead to a place thats reductive, nostalgic, and average (i.e. https://nothinghuman.substack.com/p/the-tyranny-of-the-marginal-user https://nothinghuman.substack.com/p/the-tyranny-of-the-margi...). Designers themselves are loaded with biases and often enough want to perform design work that doesn't serve the business (in software we would call this Resume Driven Development - building with shiny new things so you can put it on your resume). On the flip side, design is constantly victim to Dunning-Kruger or "bike shedding" - people with limited knowledge or competence in a domain greatly overestimate their own knowledge or competence. If the author was trying to write about the latter, they are failing to first acknowledge the former... for all we know the "decision makers" have decades of competent experience in brand, design, and user experience.
- superkuh 7mo agoExcept when your website is for you. That being the case where you aren't just making it because someone else is paying you or you think you might get hired because of it. Those websites aren't yours, obviously. I'm talking about the websites you make because it is actually your choice, not when you are coerced into it by external forces. That website is for you, it is your backyard garden of the mind and everything about it is only what you like. And it matters a whole lot more than anything you're being paid to do.
- drums8787 7mo agoI feel like I finally get to feel the designer’s pain when people arrive with their vibe-coded pile of garbage and I have to explain why it can’t just slide into the product. It does something and it’s what the business wants. So what’s my problem?
- aykutseker 7mo agohad this exact fight. founder wanted it more corporate, designer had the research, designer won. six months later pipeline was dead. buyers were enterprise procurement, the new look read as too small to trust with our budget. research was right. just not about these users.
- DANmode 7mo agoWhich role were you?
- shermantanktop 7mo agoThe ones who treat a website as their personal taste vehicle are the designers! Over and over I see tiny illegible fonts and gray-on-gray buttons being defended by the designer who made it. Maybe I have bad taste - I’ve built enough websites to know that good design is hard and doesn’t come naturally to me. But the professionals seem to have a hard time with being dispassionate about their own ideas.
- prerok 7mo agoI think there was another comment among these that said it best: "graphics designers". The main conflict seems to arise between usability (UX) and the "view". It may look pretty but if it's unusable it's a showstopper. Sorry for regurgitating what someone else posted but it really resonated with my experience.
- winddude 7mo agoNo one reads my tech blog, it absolutely is for me.
- alldayhaterdude 7mo agoYes, it is.
- khat_th 7mo agoBuilt a small SaaS recently and this hit hard. I kept asking myself "who is this paragraph for?" while writing the landing. Ended up cutting almost 60% of what I had planned. Most of it was reassuring myself, not the visitor. The stuff that survived were the things that confronted them — like a 4,000-dot grid showing every week of an average human life. The post is right that visitors aren't there to be impressed by you. But I'd add: they're not there to be reassured either. They're there to be confronted with something they already suspected was true.
- heliumtera 7mo ago[flagged]
- calebm 7mo ago"A website isn't art"? I disagree. https://gods.art/ https://gods.art/. https://fuzzygraph.com https://fuzzygraph.com.
- filleduchaos 7mo agoI'm fairly certain that neither of those websites has a board of directors.
- quaddoggy 7mo agoThis problem is inevitable in all but the most egalitarian workplaces. It's called HIPPO—The Highest Paid Person's Opinion. Organizations tend to favor the opinions of senior, high-earning leaders over data-driven evidence. And it manifests to the user in various ways, enshittification being one of them.
- jkonline 7mo ago"A website isn't art. It's a tool with one job: get the user to do the thing they came for." Great quote! This has already helped me frame a conversation with a client.
- groby_b 7mo ago> Here's what I find genuinely strange. A patient doesn't lean over the operating table and tell the surgeon where to cut. This is extremely funny given we're the industry full of folks that brought the world QS and longevity hacks, together with the peptide boom. "But that is only because doctors don't keep current/have preconceived notions" Which would never happen to designers?
- cweagans 7mo ago> A patient doesn't lean over the operating table and tell the surgeon where to cut. Web design _does_ sound much easier when clients can be anesthetized. :)
- bicepjai 7mo agoMy personal website is absolutely for me and not anyone else :) It’s like saying the art I made is not for me !!!?
- filleduchaos 7mo agoWhat part of the article gave you the impression that it was about your personal website?
- bicepjai 7mo agoSometimes sarcasm doesn’t always land in public forums, and this is a good example. You are right, the post is not about a personal website, and I was trying to make a funny argument.
- compiler-guy 7mo agoOne of the disadvantages of the Hacker News policy to only use article headlines verbatim is that a bunch of context can get lost. This article is on a blog that deals with professional web design for businesses, and starts with that assumption about the readers. Then hn comes and takes it out of that context.
- satvikpendem 7mo agoGood thing the article is not about personal websites then.
- tasuki 7mo agoConversely, I've seen a lot of designers hell-bent on making the thing pretty. It doesn't matter whether it's pretty! As the article said: > It's a tool with one job: get the user to do the thing they came for. In my experience, the people paying are often more sensitive to this than the designer. The designer wants it to look nice in their portfolio.
- satvikpendem 7mo agoPeople in this thread reading only the title and commenting knee-jerk responses (as is HN or any link submission forum tradition) like "actually, the website is for me," not understanding that the article is about business websites not personal ones, meant for converting customers to using your product or service. And in this case, the article is exactly right, the website is not an art piece, it must serve the function of making people buy from you to be successful, otherwise your company is a very expensive hobby.
- deleted 7mo ago[deleted]
- cnst 7mo agoThis doesn't even touch the entire resume-driven development issue. The vast majority of all websites today, are designed in such a way as to tout the resumes of all the people responsible for the site with all the latest buzzwords. Content hidden under drop-down menus noone cares about and which makes things very hard to find, pointless animation here and there, pointless custom zoom logic that doesn't work properly on the big screens, all the latest frameworks to display a few tables of text, progressive loading and pagination for the simplest of data (like the banking transactions of a consumer credit card) that in the old days could have simply been displayed on a single page etc.
- kazinator 7mo agoThis issue can affect even off-the-shelf software. Software designed to be used by company employess, but that has to be sold to upper management, prioritizes selling to upper management (e.g. features that face them) over usability by the employees. That can be baked right in; like it is assumed that the decision makers will be assuming that it's for them, and so it is designed accordingly.
- todotask2 7mo agoActually, I can see why this blogs and the agency was created after reading their FAQs (preferred Astro and Next.js). But note that, there are multiple WebSmith site which can caught new clients to be confused.
- samat 7mo agoWhy oh why do you use AI to write articles? ‘This is the bit that gets lost.’ as a start of the paragraph, and then the very next sentence parroting the chapters title. 3 sentences for 0 new information and this pattern is overused to death. Don’t you people read what you publish? So disrespectful
- squirrelon 7mo agoSolo founders typically spend so much time building an app completely invested in. They start neglecting the UX (marketing as well) and then they wonder why the app is not successful. I would definitely suggest sending the beta beta version to friends and family before investing 90% more time on it.
- zmaznevegor 7mo agoEgo of founders will tell you that they are actually the experts since they are understanding the company better than anyone. The problem is that it's not a reality but just an ego. You've actually described exactly the same problem that we've mentioned in our expectations as a design studio: https://klad.design/expectations https://klad.design/expectations
- jrowen 7mo agoCorporate bullcrap. Do your art, do what you believe in. Don't do it for "the company to make money." The company doesn't need to exist in and of itself. When you start making decisions that way, what is the point? So you can just say "I built a thing that conformed enough to the lowest common denominators of society to make a buck"?
- cybercatgurrl 7mo agobusiness incentives > user experience in my experience large corpos will always prioritise business incentives over a happy customer even when you make it blindingly obvious that a happy customer is actually better for their bottom line