12 ms·
Inventing a Soccer Ball for Poor Countries
- sabret00the 14y agoObligatory "it's football not soccer" comment from the Brit. That aside, this is a fabulous thing. Anyone can play football in tight spaces with a group and on their own. Being the biggest sport on the planet, it's a marvellous thing that you can go literally anywhere and ask someone to play a game and you pretty much all know the simple rules. I'll always get behind things like this.
- EnderMB 14y agoAgreed. Some of my happiest times playing football were on a small side street using a dustbin as a goal net. There's a reason it's by far the most popular sport in the world and as such this news can only be a good thing.
- capdiz 14y agoIf any of you is ever in Uganda hit me up for a game of football. That aside i wish this had come when i was still younger. I remember inflating polythene that was used for packaging 1ltr milk sachets and using tyre tubes as strings for holding up these packagings and for football we lived. I should post a how to video for that come to think of it.
- LargeWu 14y agoIf you're going to be pedantic, then you might as well at least go all the way. The sport is called "association football". It is correct for Americans to call it soccer because, well, that's the most common name for it here.
- gokhan 14y agoIt seems that, as only Americans call it soccer, only Americans think it's real name is "association football".
- kinleyd 14y agoNot a Brit, but yeah, it is football to the world at large. Congratulations to Sting and Tim Jahnigen, this is heart warming. Regarding the cost of the balls, I think when you factor in a 30 year life and assume a cost of $30 per ball, we are looking at a $1/year cost. The up front cost might be higher, and that is an issue, but the actual cost per ball/year is a heckuva lot less. I'm not sure what kind of calculation Unicef is doing when they say “compared to the $2.50 we pay for a regular football, the current cost difference for the more durable solution is currently too high.”
- froseph 14y agoTheir funds are finite and the increased cost of a football would take away funds for other goods and services which they deliver. They need to prioritize their the current needs and demands, not just optimize for the long term cost of a football.
- GFischer 14y agoIt is a great idea, if it works like they say it does :) . I've seen foam footballs before... (after google search): http://www.decathlon.es/balon-futbol-de-espuma-kipsta-foam-id_6350059.html http://www.decathlon.es/balon-futbol-de-espuma-kipsta-foam-i... and they're much cheaper than the proposed one (you can get them for 1-2 dollars), but probably way less durable. "A lion at the Johannesburg Zoo, who would go through six regular balls a day, played with two balls. A German shepherd spent a year biting on a ball. In every case, the balls withstood the abuse." That does sound durable. As stated, U$ 40 is way too expensive for a ball, so the only way it will work is if they continue giving them away as part of relief efforts. Unicef: "“compared to the $2.50 we pay for a regular football, the current cost difference for the more durable solution is currently too high.”" And the shipping problems are also a hindrance. "because the balls cannot be deflated, they are more difficult to ship"
- narag 14y agoI've seen foam footballs before... I've played with it, my son has one. It has a weird way of bouncing, compared to inflated ones.
- DanBC 14y agoBuild a factory "over there" and provide employment opportunities. This helps develop infrastructure in a sustainable useful way. This also provides income replacement for the little children who are no longer stitching traditional footballs. (http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-09-27/rest-of-world/34126401_1_child-labour-australian-football-needle http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-09-27/rest-...) [1] Sorry for the "over there" which is a lazy perhaps offensive way to refer to the developing world.
- brudgers 14y agoIn Britain, the game is called "Association Football" to distinguish it from Gaelic, rugby, and other forms of football. The game is officially, "soccer" in the U.S. [United Sates Soccer Federation] and Canada [Canadian Soccer Association]. FIFA calls the game beach soccer, "Beach Soccer." It is played under the "Beach Soccer Laws of the Game." http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/tournament/competition/52/76/01/lotg_bswc_en_56329.pdf http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/tournament/competition/52/76...
- sabret00the 14y agoI ignored the other comment, but since people are trying to quote stuff, I feel it's important to put it right. Football is the official name in the United Kingdom and especially England. We don't have the Association Football Association but rather the Football Association. It doesn't not have a prefix when it's referred to in any form of media at all. 'Beach Soccer' has no relevance here.
- brudgers 14y ago"Association Football: the game controlled by FIFA and organised in accordance with the Laws of the Game." [FIFA Statutes, July 2012 edition, page 5 (definition 12)] http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/affederation/generic/01/66/54/21/fifastatutes2012e.pdf http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/affederation/generic/01/66/5... This definition applies to the FA per it's constitution and bylaws. "All Clubs and Aiffliated Associations shall play and/or administer football in conformity with these Rules and also: (a) The Laws of the Game (as defifned in the Articles); and (b) the statutes and regulations of FIFA and UEFA which are in force from time to time." [THE RULES OF THE FOOTBALL ASSOCIATION LIMITED, page 1] http://www.thefa.com/~/media/Files/TheFAPortal/governance-docs/rules-of-the-association/rules-of-the-association.ashx http://www.thefa.com/~/media/Files/TheFAPortal/governance-do... Here is a list of references to "association football" on the FA's Website: https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Athefa.com+%22association+football%22 https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Athefa.com+%22associat... "Beach Soccer" is of course relevant because that's the name of the game sanctioned by FIFA.
- 14y ago
- Dylan16807 14y agoThen I'll throw in the obligatory counter that the term 'soccer' was coined in Britain.
- mongol 14y agoIt is my belief that the common usage of this word will be an indicator when the English language stops being defined by its native speakers and starts being defined by its more numerable foreign speakers. In most languages, it is called something very similar to football. Since I don't have a native English language, I prefer to call it football for that reason. I don't give a damn about its history, soccer's origin as association football, etc etc. Football is Fussball is fotboll is futbol is fudbold is futebol is futball is fútbol is ..
- lmm 14y agoFootball is what the English, who have the best claim to being native speakers of English, call it.
- vacri 14y agoA native speaker is someone who grew up with the given language as a primary language, not someone who comes from the country the language is named after.
- jacalata 14y agoNo it won't, it'll indicate when the sporting options available to people have shrunk so that they no longer need words to differentiate between football (soccer), football (gaelic), football (Aussie Rules), football (rugby league), football (rugby union), football (gridiron) and any other kinds I'm not aware of.
- mmanfrin 14y agoUp until a few years ago, a lot of the english-speaking world called it soccer: Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, the US, Canada. It is called 'sokker' in Afrikaans. Additionally, in Japan is is most commonly called 'sakka'. Brits were truly the only ones calling it Football.
- mylittlepony 14y agoIn Argentina there is only one word for it: "fútbol"
- protomyth 14y agoI guess I'll make the obligatory American comment that we should ship them balls used for Stickball (American not Australian game) so when they grow up they would become fans of Baseball.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoThe article has a link to where you can buy one, but it's not called out as such. To make it easier for you to buy and/or donate to this awesome cause, here it is: http://www.oneworldfutbol.com/ http://www.oneworldfutbol.com/
- netcan 14y agoFairly pricey. Even at bulk and without the built in donation they are $15-$20 in bulk.
- JulianMayorga 14y agoI agree it's really pricey. I remember when I was a kid, a lot of times we didn't have a ball and we used whatever round thing we had and still had A LOT of fun. Let me tell you that scoring a goal with a can of coke it's priceless!
- bryanlarsen 14y agoAnd shipping outside of the States doubles the price. The high cost makes it even more important to donate.
- stevesearer 14y agoI think that the durability of the ball and its ability to outlast previously donated balls by many years makes the price acceptable. The article notes that standard inflatable balls will become useless in short order, whereas this ball might still be in use for years after it is donated.
- utopkara 14y agoAn inflated football in the middle of a game of 10 kids stopped because of a punctured ball is priceless. Bought 1, and will take 1 with me to my hometown next summer. This is not a cure for inequality, it will only make a temporary difference for the little people who are bound to suffer a lot further in their lives. I don't have any illusions of having done my part or anything, which is something that is being marketed at Starbucks with fairly traded coffee, donations etc. This is something I am doing, because I want the kids to be happier right now.
- Goronmon 14y agoThen he happened to be having breakfast with Sting, a friend from his days in the music business. Mr. Jahnigen told him how soccer helped the children in Darfur cope with their troubles and his efforts to find an indestructible ball. Sting urged Mr. Jahnigen to drop everything and make the ball. Mr. Jahnigen said that developing the ball might cost as much as $300,000. Sting said he would pay for it. Well...that's always helpful.
- josefresco 14y agoAlways helpful to know a super rich guy whom you can have lunch with and propose business ideas to. Funding aside, I'm sure it helped to have Sting's backing when this guy was approaching material producers and manufacturers and other corporations for sponsorship. I'm happy that it did get done, but how far would an average hacker get without those kind of connections? I suspect the startup cost would have been larger.
- debacle 14y agoSting: Like Bono, without the douche?
- jff 14y agoSomebody never watched Dune.
- kanamekun 14y agoTrue! However what's amazing is that with a vision like this, he could have pretty easily funded this through Kickstarter... and given out indestructible soccer balls as a reward. I would've funded something like this in a second... it's a powerful vision.
- NathanKP 14y agoEssentially they do the same thing as One Laptop Per Child. You buy one and a third world child gets one. They didn't go through Kickstarter but I think the model they use is more effective anyway.
- Evbn 14y agoYears ago I saw a video where kids made a ball by blowing up a condom and covering it with some srap fabric.
- hammock 14y agoThat's not too far from what an actual ball is. Much better than a trash & string ball.
- anothermachine 14y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57ndLGhffwE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57ndLGhffwE
- rickmb 14y agoThe great thing about soccer is that even having an actual soccer ball is not a necessity. Empty cans, ragged tennis balls, anything will do. This used to be perfectly fine in the first world country I grew up in, so although this is a great product, it doubt it will make as much of a difference as the author suggest. Kids will play soccer and enjoy it no matter what.
- Millennium 14y agoThe point is not so much to get kids playing soccer: they do that on their own. The point is safety: if the ball holds up, they won't resort to making their own from unsafe materials.
- ScottWhigham 14y ago"In May, Chevrolet, the General Motors division, agreed to buy 1.5 million One World Futbols over the next three years and donate them to needy children. " "At the end of September, the factory in Taiwan that produces the balls has been working two shifts a day to meet its target of 45,000 balls a month." Do we have a production problem? Maybe I missed it but it seems so. If Chevrolet is buying 1.5m balls in three years, that's 500,000 balls per year. If production is ideally reaching 45,000 balls per month, that's leaving very few for defects and other buyers. The other thing I thought of is that, if the ball is virtually indestructible, at some point there are enough balls deployed/in-place and we can stop production all together, right? At 500,000+ balls per year, how many years will it take before everyone who wants one has one? I know there are a lot of poor areas but surely there's a number at which point critical mass has been reached.
- Avshalom 14y agowell at 6 billion people on the planet and growing they might just run out of an market in a few thousand years.
- ScottWhigham 14y ago??? The market is poor countries/people who cannot afford soccer balls. That's hardly 6 billion.
- devin 14y agoMaybe this guy could pivot and invent a soccer ball that feeds starving people.
- nicpottier 14y agoI live in Rwanda and see kids playing with the trash/string balls all the time (among other toys they build out of random waste). I really don't see the point. The kids have plenty of fun with their homegrown balls. Just as the cardboard box the toy came in came be more fun than the toy alone, the fun of playing with a ball doesn't come from it being a 'proper' ball, but rather than it is a game to be played with others. This is a first world solution to a problem that it created to make itself feel warm and fuzzy inside.
- filip01 14y agoDo you play soccer? For someone with a real appreciation for the game, I'd say there's a huge difference between a trash/string ball and a proper soccer ball. Or maybe I'm just narrow minded.
- hammock 14y agoAnd this ball probably isn't for) those people. Sort of how you can tell when a basketball or a football is not regulation, or one of those self-inflating ones. It's just not the same and won't satisfy a player who wants a "proper" ball (get them a regulation ball)
- timeshifter 14y agoWould you rather have a ball made out of trash that falls apart when you kick it, a "proper" ball that gets torn to shreds, or this "not regulation" ball that can withstand any abuse you throw at it? This seems like a no-brainer to me. These kids don't need a regulation ball, and they deserve better than trash.
- stevesearer 14y agoObviously the ball isn't the same as a regulation ball, but the point is that the game is not being played on pristine World Cup pitches, but rather in dirt lots, streets, on cement, etc... So rather than sending over inflatable balls that are essentially unusable and thrown away after only a few uses, why not offer something more durable that is very similar.
- antidoh 14y agoMinimum viable help.
- isabre 14y agoAmazing story. Love the game and love the idea!
- phy6 14y agoDon't we have more pressing matters to devote brain power to?
- ygra 14y agoSure. And there are plenty of people working on that, too. But maybe the skills to invent a durable non-inflatable football aren't needed so badly when trying to solve energy problems or trying to bring peace to Syria. Or should people having an idea scrap it immediately just because it's not the most pressing concern to the world at the moment?
- jpxxx 14y agoExactly! What a risible waste of time and effort. Now: take your pet, snap its neck, and throw it in the trash. Then make a list of your family members and sort them by value. Get the least essential ones out of your life, by hook or by crook. Finally, start removing your least essential fingers. You can type with just two! Focus, focus, focus. This world is made for Big Thinkers, Important Ideas, and Stuff That Matters. Like you, your worthless values, and your blithering cynicism! It's all about YOU!
- jasonkostempski 14y agoLike commenting on HN?
- Axsuul 14y agoLike making another social app?
- robotmay 14y agoI laughed out loud on first reading this sentence (it could use an extra capital letter): "A German shepherd spent a year biting on a ball. In every case, the balls withstood the abuse." Man that must have been one bored shepherd.
- asnyder 14y agoNo idea why this wasn't mentioned, but http://soccket.org/ http://soccket.org/ (a soccer ball that's also a generator) seems like it would be significantly more useful, while also satisfying the same fun purposes.
- vacri 14y agoThe core reasoning behind the foam ball was that inflatable balls don't even last a day.
- tghw 14y agoI have one of these (and donated one). It's a pretty amazing ball. There's another charity called Alive & Kicking[1] that makes more traditional balls. The main advantages are that the balls are actually made in Africa, giving people jobs, and the outside of the balls have HIV/AIDS awareness messages on them. [1] http://www.aliveandkicking.org/ http://www.aliveandkicking.org/
- ebiester 14y agoHow does it feel as a ball? Can you give a short review?
- tghw 14y agoThe material feels like the Crocs foam, and I think it's a bit lighter than a regulation ball. It also squishes down more easily; you can flatten it by stepping on it, though it'll pop right back into shape. It also has different bounce characteristics than a regulation ball, I assume due to its weight and materials. The biggest downside is that the one I got is slightly out of round, though for anyone playing on a dirt "field", it wouldn't matter that much. Overall, it's kind of incredible what they've been able to do with it. That said, I wouldn't choose to use it over a regulation ball. But if it's all I had, I'd be glad to play with it.
- sp332 14y agoWhy is GM spending millions of dollars on soccer balls? Didn't they go bankrupt recently?
- Someone 14y agoMarketing? Also, it is not as if 'millions' is a lot of money for them. They will spend half a billion or so sponsoring a football club (http://uk.reuters.com/article/2012/07/30/uk-gm-manu-idUKBRE86T13220120730 http://uk.reuters.com/article/2012/07/30/uk-gm-manu-idUKBRE8...)
- SystemOut 14y agoYes, but they came out of bankruptcy and are profitable again. See https://www.google.com/finance?client=ob&q=NYSE:GM https://www.google.com/finance?client=ob&q=NYSE:GM. For the nine months ending in September they increased their cash position by 7.2 billion if I'm looking at their financials correctly. Their net income for the last quarter was 1.8 billion.
- ghoul2 14y agoI am sorry, but I have to ask. Why ship bulky non-de-flatable balls from their manufacturing in China (presumably) or North America all the way to Sudan or Rwanda? All this is being run with donations anyway, right? Why not setup a ball-manufacturing unit somewhere in Africa? Something that uses the bare minimum of automation that still results in a decent product? Employ a few dozen/hundred locals, aid the economy, more or less solve the shipping problem. Its probably not easy, given political situation, but I am sure some location can be found out there? Won't that help even more? I understand that something like the iPhone or a Tesla S cannot be manufactured out there. Supply chain issues, profitability concerns, reliability of production, etc etc. But these balls are anyway meant for Africa, they are meant to be given away, and they are supposed to be in a charitable cause. The complexity of production is (presumably) much much lower than manufacturing an iphone, there isn't much of a concern for profit, labour would be as cheap in Africa as it is in China, if not cheaper, and periodic disruptions in production won't affect the stock price of any large corporation. So why not?
- lmm 14y agoThe article says they're made in Taiwan. The manufacturing process for fancy plastics can be quite complex, and the whole point of these balls is to be consistently high quality, something that would be hard to achieve with African production. Not to mention that setting up your own factory is a massive amount of work compared to simply coming up with a design and outsourcing production to an existing supplier. Best to start with small steps for the first iteration.
- fcc 14y agohttp://www.aliveandkicking.org/what-we-do/ http://www.aliveandkicking.org/what-we-do/ What We Do Alive & Kicking manufactures quality sports balls in Kenya, Zambia and Ghana. Our footballs (soccer balls), volleyballs, netballs, handballs and rugby balls generate employment for over 120 people, provide a product tailored for the African market and are used as a tool for raising health awareness. Established in 2004 by the late Jim Cogan OBE, an inspirational teacher with a passion for African development, we are the only formal manufacturer of sports balls on the African continent. His vision was to see the large scale production of sports balls in Africa – to use the continent’s passion for football to boost local economies, provide children with the right equipment to play and to use sport to help combat the spread of deadly disease. This vision drives Alive & Kicking to this day. We are a social enterprise – an organisation that uses business practices to pursue our charitable objectives: Creating sustainable employment in the manufacture of sports balls Ensuring that disadvantaged children have access to balls that are suitable for the conditions Using sport to raise health awareness in sub-Saharan Africa The standard Alive & Kicking ball is made of African leather, which makes it twice as resistant to puncture as the most robust synthetic ball on the market. This helps our balls to be competitive in African retail outlets, where the majority are sold. We also supply NGOs, companies (for CSR and marketing) and government departments. Each of the 120 people that we employ typically supports an extended family of six people on their salary, so their jobs are extremely valuable to their communities. By focusing on sustainable solutions to real problems, Alive & Kicking is driving change in the communities in which we work.
- rgo 14y agoTL;DR: entrepreneur invents always-inflated, indestructible ball made of Crocs' foam, finds an investor (Sting) who sees a business opportunity selling to charities who cater to third world children. Now they're making ~$1M/month from customers such as GM and Unicef.
- jadc 14y agoIt is true that this not a non-profit organization. It is a B corporation. According to Wikipedia: "A benefit corporation is a class of corporation required by law to create general benefit for society as well as for shareholders. Benefit corporations must create a material positive impact on society, and consider how their decisions affect their employees, community, and the environment. Moreover, they must publicly report on their social and environmental performances using established third-party standards." How common are these B corps? Any other notable examples?
- masterponomo 14y agoAnyone else thinking such a ball would make an ideal "case" for a Raspberry Pi, especially once they add wi-fi to the R-Pi? Here's a ball, kids...BTW, it's a computer too. A kickable, waterproof, indestructible computer.
- enraged_camel 14y agoI was born and raised in Turkey. When I was little, I and the other kids in my neighborhood got together regularly and played soccer using crushed soda cans. While it was fun, there were several disadvantages: 1. They required one of us to purchase a soda (and chug it) 2. The cans only worked on asphalt and concrete. We couldn't play on grass. 3. Since the crushed cans had sharp edges, they ruined our shoes. 4. Occasionally they would take to the air and become dangerous flying projectiles. That said, they were far more reliable than actual soccer balls, which we could buy easily from sporting stores. They didn't go flat (they already were, ha!) and didn't need to be inflated regularly.
- GiraffeNecktie 14y agoI'm not knocking this idea, but it would be so much better if the balls could be manufactured in Africa using locally sourced materials rather than paying a factory in Taiwan to make them and ship them around the globe.
- kleiba 14y ago"Then he happened to be having breakfast with Sting, a friend from his days in the music business." Ahhh... that was easy.
- jdhzzz 14y agoHow long before folks complain that the indestructible ball is, well, indestructible?
- johnobrien1010 14y agoI wonder if I'm the only one who wished someone would start a company to sell soccers balls at a low price point to poor people instead of donating them, as it seems a better solution then making uber expensive balls that are then sold on a buy one/donate one basis (looks like it's about $40 http://www.oneworldfutbol.com/shop/one-world-futbol/ http://www.oneworldfutbol.com/shop/one-world-futbol/)? Is that crazy?
- mistercow 14y ago>But “compared to the $2.50 we pay for a regular football, the current cost difference for the more durable solution is currently too high.” My brain hurts. If a ball that costs $20 and lasts 30 years is too expensive, then a ball that costs $2.50 and lasts a day is also too expensive. This is not a difficult math problem.
- gus_massa 14y agoOne possible problem is that they say (estimate) that the new model last 30 years. (Let's wait until 2040 and see.) It's very difficult to estimate how many years it will last with the real use. * What happens when they get wet? Does it get a lot of mold? * What happens during a flood? * How fast the surface wears away? * What happens when a dog bites it? * Does the dirt accumulate inside and make the ball heavier? It's looks like an interesting idea, but the 30 years claim is a little optimistic.
- mistercow 14y agoEven so, it only has to last 8 days to break even.
- arturglier 14y agoHats off to you mr. Jahnigen and hats of to you mr. Sting for not just being good with music, but for being Good in general :) It's absolutely one of the most beautiful ideas I've ever heard. So simple, so powerful. Saw the Joy and harvest the Good.