9 ms·
Bitbucket had a pretty easy time of winning my business: free private repositories for small teams is a great way to draw people in.
by notatoad 14y ago
Bitbucket had a pretty easy time of winning my business: free private repositories for small teams is a great way to draw people in.
- hess 14y agoThe free private repos are a lifesaver. They also just released a refer a friend program like dropbox. You can get up to 8 users for free. - http://blog.bitbucket.org/2012/09/18/refer-a-friend-to-bitbucket-for-free-users/ http://blog.bitbucket.org/2012/09/18/refer-a-friend-to-bitbu...
- bitcartel 14y agoI like Bitbucket because they support both Mercurial and Git. They also acquired SourceTree (probably the best version control app on the Mac), employed the main developer and made the app free.
- Osiris 14y agoI've tried at least a dozen Git GUIs for both PC and Mac and SourceTree is by far my favorite.
- mitjak 14y agoCan you elaborate on why? I've found it to be far from intuitive and basically a direct mapping of CLI commands straight into UI elements. A user unfamiliar with command line git arguments would have a difficult time with SourceTree, I would imagine (most of my coworkers have).
- masklinn 14y agoOne more datapoint: can't say I like SourceTree. Still looking for a Mercurial GUI worth using. My biggest issue is that I'm a big user of annotate/blame (I have a very bad memory so finding out where/how/why a given piece of code was created or evolved is something I do at least weekly if not daily) and all the hg guis have absolute shit annotate. They also tend to look rather bad. GitX is pretty good (I think I still prefer the original one over the Laullon gitx, but the Laullon gitx has an acceptable annotate view and look nice), and surprisingly the best annotate view I've seen so far is in bazaar's qt-based UI. The tools are not necessarily great overall (and the OSX interactions are downright weird), but the annotate is excellent.
- Osiris 14y agobasically a direct mapping of CLI commands straight into UI elements That may be some of the reason that I like it. I am able to do a lot of the things that I could do from the command line, but with a visual interface to help me visualize what's going on. For example, when I'm doing a commit, I can click on each file that's been modified and see the diff for that file right on the side. I can then stage all or just parts of the changes. So if I have some debug lines, I can stage the file and then unstage the debug logging so it doesn't get committed. There's just a lot of little things like that that you CAN do with the git command line yourself, but it wraps up in a way that's easier to consume. I'd have to take more time than I have now to write up a full review of what I like about it compared to other GUIs.
- stickfigure 14y agoA user unfamiliar with command line git arguments would have a difficult time with SourceTree Let's be honest about git: A user unfamiliar with the CLI commands will have a difficult time, period. I hesitate to predict that it's impossible to create a good UX, but git is a very complicated system with an abstraction that leaks all the way down to database records. Breathe on it wrong and the repository will wedge into a state that sends longime veterans off to stackoverflow. Yes, git is worth it... but so far every clever GUI has basically been a convenience tool for power users, not a better abstraction that can sidestep the learning curve. It's hard to see how this is going to change without some sort of fundamental change in git.
- dfabulich 14y agoThe github GUI for Mac/Windows solves this problem completely, by hiding the vast majority of git's power-user features. (No stage, no no tracking branches, no manual rebasing.)
- stickfigure 14y agoOh, how I wish this were so! Even with fairly boring usage, the Github GUI periodically wedges my repository into a state which requires CLI interaction (and a trip to stackoverflow). It's even worse for newbies - I get desperate pleas for help from clients all the time. I have come to the conclusion that there is no way around teaching the command line first, then giving them the Github client after they achieve competence.
- dfabulich 14y agoCan you repro that?
- stickfigure 14y agoCan I repro giving the Github client to newbies and getting desperate pleas for help soon afterwards? Yes, it's consistent :-) No, I have not tried to reproduce the incidents which screwed up my repository. After a few harrowing experiences I pretty much gave up using the Github for Mac client for anything except basic commits. And even that screws up - I frequently have to commit files twice; it's like the client only stages some of the files, even though they're all checked. If my commits are large I usually go to the command line to avoid the double commit msgs. I'm about to give up entirely.
- ckeck 14y agoI haven't seen it mentioned here but Tower for Mac OS has been a great tool for those who are not too familiar with git or it's associated commands. I've recommended it to at least a few hundred clients many of which use it religiously today.
- josegonzalez 14y agoTower is slow. While a slightly nicer UI, and it running like shit on large repos - at least for work - makes it a non-starter
- tayl0r 14y agoI hate how slow it is. After I get to the commit screen it thrashes my CPU and takes ages before my typing shows up. It's still the best on OSX though.
- DenisM 14y agoEmail support, they developed has been super responsive.
- DomBlack 14y agoI personally prefer the simplicity that GitBox gives. (OSX only though)
- human_error 14y agoIMHO, Git-Tower is way better than SourceTree.
- Osiris 14y agoGit-Tower is $60. SourceTree is free. Compare accordingly.
- bruceboughton 14y agoIf you write software for a living, I would think you would see the value in a good piece of code.
- jksmith 14y agoHow long will it take for the private repos to be hacked? Would you put the company revenue generating jewels in there?
- kybernetikos 14y agoDo you think it's more or less likely to get hacked than private repositories on github (which are already trusted by many companies)? Before you answer, consider http://www.extremetech.com/computing/120981-github-hacked-millions-of-projects-at-risk-of-being-modified-or-deleted http://www.extremetech.com/computing/120981-github-hacked-mi...
- bitcartel 14y agoThe crown jewels should always be kept under lock and key! A couple of years ago I was at one of the Github drink meetups. I asked if they were working on encrypted private repos (this was just before or around the time Github Firewall was introduced). A Github employee told me no… before adding that in his opinion source code was not valuable. I asked him to clarify and he said imagine if Twitter had their source code leaked. It wouldn't be a big issue as Twitters success was built more on business execution rather than code. A valid point perhaps but small indie developers could easily be put out of business if the source code to their unique selling point or competitive advantage were to be made public. I'm sure Github (and others) take security seriously, but given the above, caveat emptor!
- trentmb 14y agoTwitter is a service.
- facorreia 14y agoDid you ask him for Github's source code?
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoHosted repos can only be so secure. If you need absolute trust, host them on your own machines (for which GitHub and Atlassian will happily sell you tools to make doing so easier).
- matwood 14y agofree private repositories for small teams is a great way to draw people in. Same thing here. I used to pay for github for a private repo for code to a couple of apps I sell. Once I found BB, it was a no brainer to switch over.
- kkowalczyk 14y agoIf free private repos is the only thing that BitBucket offers over GitHub, then they'll not be in business for long. You cost them money.
- nivloc 14y agoIt's a different way to price products - they charge per user. So, if your little startup starts growing, they bring in a bit of cash and have opportunities to up-sell with the other products in their line.
- nathan_f77 14y agoIf my startup grew past 5 team members, I would personally just move my private repos to GitHub and start paying them. Bitbucket provides a great free service, but I'd probably never pay for it.
- lalmalang 14y agoYou just might reconsider (and that is what bb is banking on), at the end of the day having to police the number of repos you can have is a pain(esp in a startup, where people are seemingly forever going off to hack away on random stuff). Sure bb isnt as pretty--current redraw notwithstanding--but unlimited repos is very handy indeed. just saying. Inline commenting was missed (we moved from gh to bb a few months ago), but i see that has been released too.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nathan_f77 14y ago
- ZoFreX 14y agoI was drawn in by Mercurial, went to GitHub when I switched to Git (the only thing that was holding me back, frankly) but left my private repositories on BitBucket, still in Mercurial. I shall be converting them to git and committing to sticking with BitBucket for all of my private repositories now!
- grandalf 14y agoWith the $100M investment I now think it's probably a bad business decision for github not to get a bit more aggressive on pricing for those edge cases where bitbucket clearly wins.
- sillysaurus 14y agoit's probably a bad business decision for github not to get a bit more aggressive on pricing for [free private repositories]... Yes. If Github offered just one free private repo, then I would move to them in a heartbeat. Github is still Github, after all. ("Second resume" etc.) Unfortunately current circumstances prevent me from open-sourcing a certain small segment of my codebase, and... well... Bitbucket is free, and I'm living on Ramen while trying not to worry about my dwindling savings account. So it's a pretty clear-cut choice for me.
- whichdan 14y agoPersonally I'm more bummed about a 1 collaborator limit on the $7/mo plan.
- shepbook 14y agoWhere is this "1 collaborator limit"? GitHub has unlimited collaborators on all repositories, private or public.
- gingerlime 14y agothere used to be a limit to the number of collaborators, but it was lifted a few months ago.
- whichdan 14y agoCool! I never noticed.
- pbz 14y ago
- yosoyzenitram 14y agoEven better: if you sign up with a .edu email address (hell, even my university email account works and it's a .es), they upgrade your account to unlimited everything, automatically. GitHub also does a Educational plan, but it requires manual requests and IIRC they give you a Micro account. So Bitbucket is the default choice for all my shared class projects.
- meemo 14y agoWhat if you signed up with your personal account? Is there a way to upgrade by changing your email address to an *.edu email address?
- pbnjay 14y agoyeah, just add the address and confirm it and it's automatic. I've shown this to a few friends, so I know it works (or at least, it has in the past).
- hayksaakian 14y agoThanks for the tip, I signed up for free private repos, but this makes me a real fan.
- arnarbi 14y agoThank you! My Swedish university address worked as well. Just created also an unlimited team account for my research group. This is exactly what I have been wishing Github would do for a couple of years now.
- wyck 14y agoIt also integrates with several atlassian products, namely Jira which in my opinion beats github's issue tracker into the dust.
- Ryan_Shmotkin 14y agoCan someone explain whats the catch ? Looks like I can host my $22 github account for free on bitbucket.
- Ygg2 14y agoIt's not as popular and the site isn't as responsive (UI wise) as Github. But other than that it's pretty awesome. It supports Git for some time too.
- zalew 14y agothere is no catch. their business model is not on repo count, but collaborators count. in other words, solo devs and very small teams can freeride, if you grow bigger you start paying. also, it's backed up by Atlassian.
- mylittlepony 14y agoNo catch, I've been using it for years, and always wondered why people preferred github.
- ElliotH 14y agoYou can. BitBucket is run by Atlassian, their goal is to later upsell you to their line of products, so they loss lead with free unlimited private repos in the hope that if you need a project management/bugtracker system you might choose JIRA.
- peterhost 14y agoSame here. Bitbucket for opensource things Stash for our firm's repos behind the firewall. And i have been using github for years, paid account, like others. Paid github vs Atlassian Stash ? Stash wins.