8 ms·
The Thinking Game Film – Google DeepMind documentary
- DrierCycle 1y agoAlphaFold is optimization, not thinking. Propaganda 'r us.
- aschla 1y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- DrierCycle 1y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44203562 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44203562
- dwa3592 1y agowhat is thinking?
- DrierCycle 1y agoSharp wave ripples, nested oscillations, cohering at action-syntax. The brain is "about actions" and lacks representations.
- __patchbit__ 1y agoCreatively peeling the hyper dimensional space in the scope of simplectic geometry, markhov blanket and helmholtz invariance????
- fredoliveira 1y agoDid you watch the documentary? Would probably fare better if you did, because it'd give you the context for the film title.
- DrierCycle 1y agoI'm an hour into it, unconvinced. The illusion that agency 'emerges' from rules like games, is fundamentally absurd. This is the foundational illusion of mechanics. It's UFOlogy not science.
- fredoliveira 1y agoWell, two things: it's the last sentence of the film; being on hour into something you're calling propaganda is brave. Anyways. I thought the documentary was inspiring. Deepmind are the only lab that has historically prioritized science over consumer-facing product (that's changing now, however). I think their work with AlphaFold is commendable.
- DrierCycle 1y agoIt's science under the creative boundary of binary/symbols. And as analog thinkers, we should be developing far greater tools than these glass ceilings. And yes, having finished the film, it's far more propagandic than it began as. Science is exceeding the envelop of paradox, and what I see here is obeying the envelope in order to justify the binary as a path to AGI. It's not a path. The symbol is a bottleneck.
- Zigurd 1y agoEverything between your ears is an electrochemical process. It's all math and there is no "creative boundary." There's plenty to criticize in AI hype that we're going to get to machine intelligence very soon. I suspect a lot of the hype is oriented towards getting favorable treatment from the government if not outright subsidies. But claiming that there are fundamental barriers is a losing bet.
- DrierCycle 1y agoIt doesn't happen "btwn ears" and math is an illusion of imprecision. The fundamental barrier is frameworks and computers will not be involved. There will be software obviously. But it will never be computed.
- Rochus 1y agoNot sure why this is downvoted. The comment cuts to the core of the "Intelligence vs. Curve-Fitting" debate. From my humble perspective as a PhD in the molecular biology /biophysics field you are fundamentally correct: AlphaFold is optimization (curve-fitting), not thinking. But calling it "propaganda" might be a slight oversimplification of why that optimization is useful. If you ask AlphaFold to predict a protein that violates the laws of physics (e.g. a designed sequence with impossible steric clashes), it will sometimes still confidently predict a folded structure because it is optimizing for "looking like a protein", not for "obeying physics". The "Propaganda" label likely comes from DeepMind's marketing, which uses words like "Solved"; instead, DeepMind found a way to bypass the protein folding problem.
- DrierCycle 1y agoI'm concerned that coders and the general public will confuse optimization with intelligence. That's the nature of propaganda, substituting sleight of hand to create a false narrative. btw an excellent explanation, thank you.
- autonomousErwin 1y agoWhat's the difference between optimisation and intelligence?
- HarHarVeryFunny 1y agoFor a start optimization is a process, and intelligence is a capability.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- dekhn 1y agoIf there's one thing I wish DeepMind did less of, it's conflating the protein folding problem with static structure prediction. The former is a grand challenge problem that remains 'unsolved' while the latter is an impressive achievment that really is optimization using a huge collection of prior knowledge. I've told John Moult, the organizer of CASP this (I used to "compete" in these things), and I think most people know he's overstating the significance of static structure prediction. Also, solving the protein folding problem (or getting to 100% accuracy on structure prediction) would not really move the needle in terms of curing diseases. These sorts of simplifications are great if you're trying to inspire students into a field of science, but get in the way when you are actually trying to rationally allocate a research budget for drug discovery.
- HarHarVeryFunny 1y agoSure, but AlphaFold is still probably the most impactful and positive thing to have come out of "Deep Learning" so far.
- theturtletalks 1y agoDidn’t the transformer model come from AlphaFold? I feel like we wouldn’t have had the LLMs we use today if it wasn’t for AlphaFold.
- HarHarVeryFunny 1y agoThe Transformer was invented at Google, but by a different team. AFAIK the original AlphaFold didn't use a transformer, but AlphaFold 2.0 and 3.0 do.
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoStreaming on YouTube now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d95J8yzvjbQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d95J8yzvjbQ
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoHard to discount the impact of AlphaFold in science work but submitting this to a number of film festivals like Tribeca seems a bit AI-washing.
- incognito124 1y agoWatched it a while ago. Made me seriously think about AI and what we should use it for. I feel like all the entertainment use cases (image and video gen) are a complete waste.
- jeffbee 1y agoDeepMind's new [edit: apparently now old] weather forecast model is similar in architecture to the toys that generate videos of horses addressing Congress or cats wearing sombreros. The technology moves forward and while some of the new applications are not important, other applications of the same technology may be important.
- incognito124 1y agoIs it really similar? I was under the impression it's a GNN of a (really dense) polyhedron, not a diffusion model
- jeffbee 1y agoGenCast is a diffusion model, but it is not the "new" one like I said. Apparently there is another one. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2506.10772 https://arxiv.org/pdf/2506.10772
- mattlondon 1y agoThe chatbots and image editors are just a side-show. The real value is coming in e.g. chemistry (Alpha fold etc all), fusion research, weather prediction etc.
- dwarfpagent 1y agoI find it funny that the YouTube link takes you to the film, but like an hour into it.
- vmilner 1y agoYes, it made me think I'd already watched it and had forgotten about it...
- redbell 1y agoJust watched it yesterday and enjoyed every second of it, the director put more focus on Demis Hassabis which turns out to be a true superhero and I have to confess that I am probably admiring him more that any other human in the tech industry.
- nightski 1y agoIn my experience all DeepMind content ends up being a puff piece for Dennis Hassabis. It's like his personal marketing engine lol.
- stevenjgarner 1y agoIs that a good thing or a bad thing? Demis is after all a co-founder and CEO.
- Hacker_Yogi 1y agoMakes it seem that AI is a one-man show while also feeding the hype cycle
- ainch 1y agoPerhaps they need more advertising around the correct spelling of his name.
- nightski 1y agoGood catch but it was just an honest typo.
- ipnon 1y agoHe's the leading AI researcher at the 3rd largest company in the world in the middle of an AI boom. He's naturally going to have quite the marketing budget behind him!
- tim333 1y agoAll content about organisations tends to go that way. I guess it's just easier to talk about the leader than the thousands of others involved.
- Glemkloksdjf 1y agoOur society is leader based. Otherwise the garbage Trump wouldn't matter but he does. The same thing with garbage Musk. Musk gets what he wants from Tesla because the shareholders believe that Musk is critical to Tesla. Both are fundamental to their followers. So its quite clear that you can't just say 'its DeepMind' but have a figure in the middle of it like Dennis. They trust him to lead DeepMind.
- stevenjgarner 1y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d95J8yzvjbQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d95J8yzvjbQ
- lysace 1y agoIt's official too. It's on: https://www.youtube.com/@googledeepmind https://www.youtube.com/@googledeepmind Moderators: Please change the link; feels kind of unethical to bait someone into paying for this now.
- dwroberts 1y agoI want to watch it, but at the same time, it’s basically going to be an advert for Google. I’m not sure if I can put up with the uncritical fluff. I would love to see a real (ie outsider) filmmaker do this - eg an updated ‘Lo and behold’ by Werner Herzog
- actionfromafar 1y agoWhere he speaks french
- dist-epoch 1y agoIt's an advert for Demis Hassabis, not Google.
- ilaksh 1y agoIt was directed by Greg Kohs, who is a real filmmaker and does not work for Google.
- lysace 1y agoAre you saying this movie production wasn't paid for by Google? If it was, surely he did?
- ilaksh 1y agooh it might have been paid for by Google for sure.
- lysace 1y agoLike 99.99% probability, sure. Greg's previous big feature was on Deepmind's AlphaGo, three years after its Google acquisition. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6700846/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6700846/
- gardnr 1y agoFull length: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WXuK6gekU1Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WXuK6gekU1Y They do a great job capturing the "Move 37" moment: https://youtu.be/WXuK6gekU1Y?t=2993 https://youtu.be/WXuK6gekU1Y?t=2993
- dwa3592 1y agoLoved this documentary. People complaining - WTFV first.
- jnwatson 1y agoI caught it on the airplane a few days ago. I would have loved a little more technical depth, but I guess that's pretty much standard for a puff piece. It is interesting that Hassabis has had the same goal for almost 20 years now. He has a decent chance of hitting it too.
- someguy101010 1y agoreposting this from youtube comment From 1:14:55-1:15:20, within the span of 25 seconds, the way Demis spoke about releasing all known sequences without a shred of doubt was so amazing to see. There wasn't a single second where he worried about the business side of it (profits, earnings, shareholders, investors) —he just knew it had to be open source for the betterment of the world. Gave me goosebumps. I watched that on repeat for more than 10 times.
- dekhn 1y agoAnother way to interpret this (and I don't mean it pejoratively at all): Demis has been optimizing his chances for winning a nobel prize for quite some time now. Releasing the data increased that chance. He also would have been fairly certain that the commercial value of the predictions was fairly low (simply predicting structures accurately was never the rate-limiting step for downstream things like drug discovery). And that he and his team would have a commercial advantage by developing better proprietary models using them to make discoveries.
- tim333 1y agoAlso since selling Deepmind to Google, it's Google's shareholder's money really.
- sgt101 1y agoI think that's a rather conspiratorial way of framing it. I think it's more about someone trying to do the most good that was possible at that time. I doubt he cares much about prizes or money at this point.
- dekhn 1y agoIt's hardly a conspiracy to use strategy and intelligence to maximize the probability of achieving the outcome you desire. He doesn't have to care much about prizes or money at this point: he won his prize and he gets all the hardware and talent he needs.
- 1y ago
- beginnings 1y agoi tried to watch it but like AI in general, it was extraordinarily boring. neural nets are really cool technically, but the whole AI thing is just getting old and I couldnt care less where its going we can guarantee that whether its the birth of superintelligence or just a very powerful but fundamentally limited algorithm, it will not be used for the betterment of mankind, it will be exploited by the few at the top at the expense of the masses because thats apparently who we are as a species
- hbarka 1y agoHi, I’m genuinely curious about your writing style. I’m seeing this trend of no proper casing and no punctuation becoming vogue-ish. Is there a particular reason you prefer to write this way or is this writing style typical for a generation? Sincere question, not snark, coming from an older generation guy.
- aswegs8 1y agoIf you grew up in the internet of early 2000s, that's how we wrote online.
- querez 1y agoI grew up in the Internet at that time, and it's certainly not how I type. So you might want to be more specific about which sites or subcultures you think this style is representative of?
- luma 1y agoI’m certainly no authority but i tend to write the same way for casual communication, came from the 90s era BBS days. It was (and still is) common on irc nets too. Autocorrect fixes up some of it, but sometimes i just have ideas i’m trying to dump out of my head and the shift key isn’t helping that go faster. Emails at work get more attention, but bullshittin with friends on the PC? No need. I’ll code switch depending on the venue, on HN i mostly Serious Post so my post history might demonstrate more care for the language than somewhere i consider more causal.
- quirino 1y agoWatched it this week. Pretty good. There are a couple parts at the start and the end where a lady points her phone camera at stuff and asks an AI about what it sees. Must have been mind-blowing stuff when this section was recorded (2023), but now it's just the bare minimum people expect of their phones. Crazy times we're living in.
- HarHarVeryFunny 1y agoI was ok with that as "fledgling AI" at the start of the movie/documentary, but thought that going back to it and having the chatbot suggest a chess book opening to Hassabis at the end was cheesy and misleading. They should have ended the movie on the success of AlphaFold.
- ilaksh 1y agoGreg Kohs and his team are brilliant. For example, the way it captured the emotional triumph of the AlphaFold achievement. And a lot of other things. One of the smart choices was that it omitted a whole potential discussion about LLMs (VLMs) etc. and the fact that that part of the AI revolution was not invented in that group, and just showed them using/testing it. One takeaway could be that you could be one of the world's most renowned AI geniuses and not invent the biggest breakthrough (like transformers). But also somewhat interesting is that even though he had been thinking about this for most of his life, the key technology (transformer-type architecture) was not invented until 2017. And they picked it up and adapted it within 3 years of it being invented. Also I am wondering if John Jumper and/or other members of the should get a little bit more credit for adapting transformers into Evoformer.
- circadian 1y agoThere's some funny comments going on in this thread. Understandably so. What could be more divisive an issue than AI on a silicon valley forum!? As a brit, I found it to be a really great documentary about the fact that you can be idealistic and still make it. There are, for sure, numerous reasons to give Deepmind shit: Alphabet, potential arms usage, "we're doing research, we're not responsible". The Oppenheimer aspect is not to be lost, we all have to take responsibility for wielding technology. I was more anti-Deepmind than pro before this, but the truth is as I get older it's nicer to see someone embodying the aspiration of wanton benevolence (for whatever reason) based on scientific reasoning, than to not. To keep it away from the US and acknowledge the benefits of spreading the proverbial "love" to the benefit of all (US included) shows a level of consideration that should not be under-acknowledged. I like this documentary. Does AGI and the search for it scare me? Hell yes. So do killer mutant spiders descending on earth post nuclear holocaust. It's all about probabilities. To be honest: disease X freaks me out more than a superintelligence built by an organisation willing to donate the research to solve the problems of disease X. Google are assbiscuits, but Deepmind point in the right direction (I know more about their weather and climate forecasting efforts). This at least gave me reason to think some heart is involved...
- vismit2000 1y agoEarlier on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46086561 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46086561
- sakesun 1y agoIs the multimodal agent really as good as shown in the documentary? If so, why did Google need to stage parts of the demo at Google I/O? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38559582#38566618 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38559582#38566618
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mskogly 1y agoTwo thoughts: 1 the field of ai research moves so fast that any attempt to make a full documentary would we obsolete long before it was released. 2 all I want ai do to right now is to remove generic «dramatic» music from YouTube clips.
- mattlondon 1y agoWhat confused me about this documentary was the "at home" scenes for Hassabis. He is famously a North London lad, but the at home shots are clearly shot from South London looking North (you can tell by the orientation of The Shard and Bishops Gate out of the window). I thought that this might have been a "stage home" but it appears to be the same place in the background of various video conferences he is on too, so unless those were staged for the documentary (which seems like a lot of effort), then he lives near Crystal Palace and not Highgate?
- kk58 1y agohttps://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5409063 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5409063 AI for science is much bigger than RL or Generative AI in science. There are several classes of models Like operator learning, physics informed neural networks, Fourier operators That perform magnificently well and have killer applications in various industrial settings Do read the attached paper if you're curious about AI in science