14 ms·
Addiction Markets
- toomuchtodo 1y agoRelated: Coffeezilla: Exposing the Gambling Epidemic - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45773049 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45773049 - October 2025
- Hasz 1y agoGreat video. The convergence between traditional stock market finance and casino gambling is going to seriously scar a generation.
- skippyboxedhero 1y agoWho do you think was buying options 30 years ago? Institutional demand, particularly for non-OTC options, was zero. Countries which have legalized gambling tend not to have large options markets. There is no convergence. They have always been the same thing. The difference is that you can provide a venue where harm is reduced or one where harm is maximised.
- hollerith 1y agoOptions markets help farmers and miners decide how much to invest in future production. Ditto the consumer of a commodity faced with an investment decision where the success of the investment depends on continued access to the commodity.
- malfist 1y agoAre you thinking of the futures market? That's different than options
- hollerith 1y agoYes. My bad.
- steveBK123 1y agoOptions can be thought of as a form of insurance, so they have a useful purpose. In the simplest case you might hold a stock and a put to limit your downside for a set period of time.
- nimos 1y agoThe opposite is also true - you can use options to increase risk. I don't think insurance is a particularly good analogy in general.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- steveBK123 1y agoI mean generally speaking derivatives can be used as insurance or for speculation, and a wide gradient of gray in between. By contrast, sports gambling is well, gambling. And importantly as we've seen in a lot of reports - the big online sports books essentially freeze out anyone who is good so that they are collecting revenue primarily from the.. innumerate. Of course you also have some markets like India without legal gambling and oversized derivatives markets that are unfortunately serving as a replacement. I'd also point out that you don't see the sort of degenerate nonstop advertising for options punting that you see for sports gambling. "Thanks for tuning into the ESPN FanDuel pregame show at the Caesars Superdome / and don't forget to stop by the DraftKings Sportsbook lounge." Followed by a barrage of other gambling ads in between plays.
- csomar 1y agoThey are roughly the same thing packaged differently. Both can be used to lock-in the price at a certain premium.
- 1y ago
- Hasz 1y agoWasn't around to personally witness it, but I do not believe the first part is true: https://www.princeton.edu/~ota/disk2/1990/9015/901507.PDF https://www.princeton.edu/~ota/disk2/1990/9015/901507.PDF, specifically page 94. Also, IMO there is a big difference between an open market that allows for price discovery and free trading versus placing bets against the same casino at predetermined prices.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mlrtime 1y ago100% agree, ban it all and it goes underground or shifts somewhere else. See prostitution.
- fud101 1y agoI still can't take him seriously, he's a long time crypto grifter exposing grifting, why should we enable him? I don't follow him very closely but he always positioned himself as a pick me saavy crypto investor not like the others (who were into shitcoins).
- ngruhn 1y agoAny example video?
- thrill 1y ago“Take athletics. Americans love sports, and that cultural centerpiece is being corrupted in an orgy of greed and speculative ferver.” Professional (and collegiate) athletics has always been corrupt - now it’s just more visible. The only thing needing abolishing is the advertising of gambling.
- InfiniteRand 1y agoSay it ain’t so Joe
- ToucanLoucan 1y ago> A quarter of bettors can’t pay a bill because of their wagers, a third have gambling debts, more than half carry credit card debts, and a quarter of them are afraid they can’t control their gambling. No way. It's almost like these are addictive products being engineered to be as addictive as possible and deliberately punch people's brains in such a way to make them stay. That's so weird.
- supportengineer 1y ago>> addictive products being engineered to be as addictive as possible and deliberately punch people's brains in such a way to make them stay The exact same argument could be used to make social media illegal.
- cyberax 1y agoYou're saying it as if it's a bad thing. Limiting social media to be only used for communication, and not algorithms is a good thing.
- ToucanLoucan 1y agoFuck yeah let's do it.
- skippyboxedhero 1y agoHopefully, the responses to this have highlighted the kind of people you are dealing with. No-one can use social media because some people in our society can't control themselves. Socialise the losses.
- gassi 1y agoYou can allow freedom of communication while restricting the algorithms that have poisoned an entire generation of children. https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2025/05/430011/yes-social-media-might-be-making-kids-depressed https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2025/05/430011/yes-social-media-mi...
- ToucanLoucan 1y ago
- daft_pink 1y agoShould be abolished, but please leave the prediction markets and just limit participation to a small number.
- mattmcknight 1y agoI am really tired of the lazy argument style of using "corporate" as a synonym for "bad". I too think it's bad to encourage addictive gamblers. I don't care if it is corporate, individual, or state run.
- loeg 1y agoMatt Stoller is a leftist and views everything through that lens. I agree the framing is unfortunate. On the other hand, if you ignore the unnecessary "corporate" part, he's basically right.
- brettgriffin 1y agoThe problem isn't the 70M people who placed bets, its the ~25M with broken risk aversion. These are mostly men, and a very specific type of men. You can try to curtail their access to gambling but we're missing the underlying problem.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- palmotea 1y ago> These are mostly men, and a very specific type of men. You can try to curtail their access to gambling but we're missing the underlying problem. You should address that too, but gambling is frankly a parasitic business meant to exploit such people, and we should not let the perfect be the enemy of the good by avoiding the re-abolishment of such a pernicious industry.
- hollerith 1y agoWell, sure, but it is unlikely that we can fix the underlying problem: the science of psychology is not advanced enough.
- michaelt 1y agoHas society ever addressed an underlying psychological problem successfully? Because when it comes to the underlying psychological causes of homelessness and drug addiction and school shootings and violent extremism my impression is we don’t really do much.
- brettgriffin 1y agoI'm an optimist at heart, but this subject is dear to me, and my opinion may seem pessimistic: the short answer is, no, it cannot be fixed at any large scale, at least not in a lifetime.
- squigz 1y agoLarge-scale societal change requires generations of work, indeed. That may be disheartening, but it is the way it is, and we should continue to work toward those changes.
- rybosworld 1y agoI don't think you can kill corporate run gambling - people will just use some offshore website instead. It might be something we should treat more like smoking. - Require a disclosure of the EV of each bet as the user is placing it. E.g.: Expected loss $5. - Ad targeting restrictions.
- pstuart 1y agoAs someone who believes in legalizing all drugs and in general "personal freedoms", I'd add recreational drugs to this list. The demand will always be there but there should be strong incentives to not incentivize use (e.g., the Purdue Pharma debacle). We're better served by having these markets addressed by legit players rather then criminal cartels. I'm not sure what the best solution is, but unfettered promotion to consume is not the way.
- toasterlovin 1y agoOn the other hand, legit players can lobby for their interests, whereas criminal cartels generally can’t.
- kelseyfrog 1y agoYou can't kill murder; murder will always exist. Surely, like murder, and other negative outcome behaviors, we can reduce the occurrences, right?
- rafale 1y agoGamblers know the odds are stacked against them yet they end up stuck in a psychological prison within their own brain that they can't escape from even if they realize what they do is harmful. Maybe a better law: check id, you are not allowed to take from any gambler more than 10 bets a year and no bet can be over 1k. For big gamblers, we can have "qualified gamblers" rules like we do for qualified investors. Funny how we don't let average people invest in some stuff but we let them gamble. For offshore gambling pursue them aggressively if they serve US clients.
- gcanyon 1y agoThis line from the ads always strikes me as darkly ironic: > if you need help making responsible choices, call… Like, the only “responsible” choice is not to gamble online. What do they even think we’re supposed to take away from that line of the commercial?
- savanaly 1y ago> the only “responsible” choice is not to gamble online I don't gamble at all in any form, but I still firmly disagree. Some people enjoy gambling in a way that never hurts them-- I've known countless friends and coworkers who talk about doing a bit of it in Vegas or what have you. You're saying every last one is a degenerate gambler somehow concealing it totally from me? They know they're not going net positive on the experience, usually lose some money, and get some entertainment. There's a saying about this: abusers give vice a bad name. People should be free to gamble if they want to, and certain checks should be put in place for people who choose to gamble so much it is ruinous to themselves.
- random9749832 1y ago[flagged]
- BoorishBears 1y agoYou can't let society keep inventing new vices for profit in an uninhibited way. It feels like a bell curve topic, where the most naive people think you should just ban all vices and have a strictly better world, the middle of the road thinks it's all down to personal fortitude, and then people who know how the sausage is made realize the level of asymmetry that exists. Weed isn't just weed anymore, it's fruity pebbles flavored. Porn isn't just porn anymore, it tries to talk like a person and build a parasocial relationship. Video games aren't just video games anymore, they start embedding gambling mechanics and spending 2 years designing the "End of Match" screen in a way that funnels you into the next game or lootbox pull. You need to stop somewhere. Tech + profit motives create an asymmetric war for people's attention and money that results in new forms of old vices that are superficially the same, but realistically much much worse. Gambling specifically online might just be giving tech companies too many knobs that are too easy to tune under the umbrella of engagement and retention.
- mberning 1y agoI don’t have an overly paternalistic view of the government. I’m rather libertarian in that regard. But is it too much to ask that we place some guardrails on things that are know to have trouble with? Smoking, drinking, gambling, etc. I certainly feel that people should be able to do it if they really want to, but making it super accessible and highly advertised seems like a bad idea.
- dinkleberg 1y agoAgreed. Aside from actions that harm others (like theft, murder, etc.) the government shouldn’t be policing what individuals do. But it should absolutely protect the citizenry from malicious businesses whether it be praying on addictions like gambling and smoking, data privacy, polluting communities, and any other antisocial behaviors that harm the people.
- Ylpertnodi 1y agoVery contradictory statement.
- dinkleberg 1y agoHow so?
- skippyboxedhero 1y agoThere are guardrails. Gambling is legalised to introduce guardrails so that regulated providers can exist and provide a product that stops people using offshore. Neither accessibility or advertising impacts rates of addiction. It is a real addiction. Does a lack of advertising stop heroin use? Behave.
- mberning 1y agoIf advertising didn’t work to drive consumption no business would ever spend a dime on it. When your product has addictive qualities advertising absolutely increases the number of people that get hooked. This is something that was well understood in the past, for example the huge curtailment in cigarette advertising.
- cal_dent 1y agoThere has recently been many looks at the epidemic in gambling. Wonder how all of the focus seem to happen at the same time Off the top of my head: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-10-31/great-british-bake-off-fans-are-now-betting-on-who-ll-win-the-show https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-10-31/great-bri... https://kyla.substack.com/p/gamblemerica-how-sports-betting-apps https://kyla.substack.com/p/gamblemerica-how-sports-betting-... https://www.ft.com/content/e80df917-2af7-4a37-b9af-55d23f941ec6 https://www.ft.com/content/e80df917-2af7-4a37-b9af-55d23f941... https://www.dopaminemarkets.com/p/the-lottery-fication-of-everything https://www.dopaminemarkets.com/p/the-lottery-fication-of-ev... https://www.investors.com/news/investing-gambling-robinhood-polymarket-kalshi-betting/ https://www.investors.com/news/investing-gambling-robinhood-... https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2025-premier-league-football-kit-sponsors/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2025-premier-league-footb... https://www.ft.com/content/a39d0a2e-950c-4a54-b339-4784f7892720 https://www.ft.com/content/a39d0a2e-950c-4a54-b339-4784f7892...
- neonnoodle 1y ago> Wonder how all of the focus seem to happen at the same time Because this practice was made legal very recently in most places in the US and a concomitant advertising boom has saturated the media. Before the last few years, your average American couldn't bet on sports without visiting a casino sports book in person, or having a bookie (i.e., entering into a risky relationship with organized crime). TV sports coverage now openly refers to how you can use their analysis to make bets.
- neaden 1y agoAlso because the NBA is going through a gambling scandal with players being involved with the mafia.
- robotnikman 1y agoThis is the first time I heard of this, I decided to look up some of the news stories behind it. Maybe I'm nieve, but I thought the Sicilian Mafia died out decades a
- nekusar 1y agoPeople are also leaving out stuff like Pokemon, Yu Gi Oh, and Magic The Gathering. All of them also introduce rarities (arbitrary exclusiveness), hidden cards in a pack, and extreme gambling gamification. The only non-gambling MtG packs are the preconstructed commander decks. All 100 cards are published. But the packs and boxes? Pure gambling, especially for the chase rare cards. And before anyone asks, yes, my username is based after this $2 card. https://edhrec.com/commanders/nekusar-the-mindrazer https://edhrec.com/commanders/nekusar-the-mindrazer
- belkinpower 1y agoThe Pokémon card mania in particular is deeply weird to me. I play Magic at a local card shop a few times a month and it’s always full of people playing Magic, D&D, or various board games. I don’t think I’ve seen a single person playing the Pokémon card game. So who’s buying the valuable singles? What’s keeping the market afloat? It’s bizarre.
- squigz 1y agoMy guess is literally just the people who trade them - and maybe like, 10 13 year olds.
- asdff 1y agoPeople in their 30s and 40s. It is the same thing with boomers and comic books. What was once in mass circulation in your childhood is now out of print and commanding real value among your nostalgic peers.
- belkinpower 1y agoSure, that explains vintage cards. I’m more confused about the demand for new ones.
- musicale 1y agoPokémon TCG seems to have turned into a contest among opportunistic resellers to see who can buy up all of the cards and sell them to ... collectors? Other resellers? Who knows? Which is a shame, since the game itself is actually fun. Or it would be if you could buy the cards easily and cheaply.
- skippyboxedhero 1y agoPredictably gets several things wrong. 1. Gambling is a real addiction. It is quite strange that someone using the term "Addiction Markets" fails to understand this. People who are gambling addicts were gambling before it was legal, they were just getting their legs broken in a way that was non-visible to you. 2. If you ban gambling, the ability of people to gamble online is not reduced in any way. None. The US offshore market was the biggest sports gambling market in the world before it was legalised. Not even close. 3. I would take a close look at how offshore gambling operators work before casting aspersions about onshore. Onshore, providers are working with regulators to an extremely significant degree. Offshore, sites will advertise that you can gamble on their site if you are on an onshore ban list. If onshore providers are so terrible, why is this the case? 4. The attempt to say that lotteries are addictive is just nonsense. Generally, there is a very poor understanding of what gambling addiction is (again, point 1). Certain games are designed to appeal to gambling addicts (again, the most prevalent ground for these was...the US...before online gambling was legal, biggest market by far, almost all the large companies making these games come from the US), those games are harmful. Lottery, sports gambling, raffles, DFS, etc. lack all of these properties. In particular, providers will often use virtual events (virtual horse-racing) to try to mimic the properties of more addictive products (with relatively little success)...because the original thing is not as appealing to addicts. 5. It is correct that the UK has "stake limits" (not quite sure what the author thinks this...all regulated US providers also have these, some states also have deposit acks...which would be beyond the UK standard, I would say many US states are ahead of the UK) but this is only on certain kinds of machines. The author spills a huge amount of words, talks about Trump, talks about the 1980s...but doesn't seem to talk about these machines, which are more prevalent in the US, at all. The author doesn't say anything about the issues in the UK being the same. VIP programs in the UK aren't regulated in any way different to the US (providers have no market lists). There is one important difference: in the UK, the government has given gambling providers that powers to perform extensive background checks, they take your income, an audit of your assets and then decide whether you can use their product...people opposed to gambling never mention this. How does that fit with neoliberal? A company being given the same powers as regulators? 6. There is an issue with corruption in the US. There is no coincidence that the law on online gambling changed within a few months of one of the largest donors blocking this. Both sides benefitted from this as the largest Democrat donor in those years was the Las Vegas casino workers union. Again, because this corruption meant that some kinds of gambling didn't happen...no mention. This was, we now know, hundreds of billions in value generated by paying politicians hundreds of millions a year...no mention. 7. The author appears to be unaware that DFS existed after UIGEA, not "laughable"...just a basic understanding of the sequence of events. 8. Gambling is not inherently addictive. Many things that are legal in the US are not only inherently addictive, but are inherently harmful. Liberals care about you losing your money when you buy a $5 scratch-off, they don't care about you losing your mind with mind-bending psychoactive substances.
- Karrot_Kream 1y agoOn a somewhat related note, there seems to be a huge interest in vice policing on social media. Gambling, sex, drugs, these are some of humanity's oldest vices. Why has it become so popular on social media to highlight these, along with a narrative of social or cultural decline?
- fritzo 1y agoAnd the fourth oldest vice is gossip, the original social media, talking trash while you pick bugs out of your friend's hair
- asdff 1y agoStandard bible thumping. You will notice that there is also an emphasis on traditional family values as well both in the media and in the positions of politicians.
- Karrot_Kream 1y agoI guess it's been interesting watching this become popular in secular, lefty circles rather than the historically religious right circles I see this from.
- asdff 1y agoThe mainstream left (really a centrist party) might be nominally secular but not really removed from conservative religious values. E.g. consider treatment of gay people in the media vs actual gay culture. In the media it is always a happy monogamous couple where one of the gays is clearly masculine and the other is clearly more effeminate. In reality gay culture is far more complicated than that, with many engaging in polyamorous relationships and/or routine clubbing for example that you won't ever see celebrated in this way in the mainstream media, which sees that sort of behavior as immoral just as a religious person might. I'd hate to get all true scotsman but a true leftist would never preach for prohibition as a solution for vice.
- 1y ago
- sakopov 1y ago> Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong rattled off crypto buzzwords at the end of the Q3 call, resolving $84K in prediction market bets to "yes." https://x.com/Cointelegraph/status/1984161085780263322 https://x.com/Cointelegraph/status/1984161085780263322
- alphazard 1y agoPolymarket is not even close to the same thing. Sports betting allows a blessed few corporations to run rigged markets and intentionally prevent price discovery by keeping the smart money out. Polymarket uses open orderbooks where you match against someone else who wants the other side of the trade just like the stock market. Prices are set by the market, as they should be.
- array_key_first 1y agoPolymarket is like the stock market, that is to say, it's gambling. Nobody should be day trading unless it's their job. Yes, I have seen many guys get sucked into it.
- Karrot_Kream 1y agoAnd people shouldn't be constantly buying mechanical keyboards and keycaps for farming social media karma and affirming their identity when they probably only have a few devices that need keyboards anyway. There's a whole rabbit hole of vice out there if you're interested in looking. While we're at it, I propose a Board of Ethically Allowed Activities that make sure we can only do the good and moral things.
- array_key_first 1y agoI'm not saying that we should restrict it. I'm just saying it's not productive or healthy. The difference is that hobbies are fun. Gambling is fun in the same way smoking is fun. It's not, but you have to do it. I know, because I was a smoker. Also, on the topic of morality: morality is stupid. Gambling isn't immoral. Or maybe it is, I don't care. Gambling is self destructive. It can pretty much exclusively only make your life worse.
- aeternum 1y agoNice try MGM Grand.
- tucnak 1y agoThat's good thinking
- loeg 1y agoMatt Stoller is an idiot, but it's hard to disagree with the thesis.
- Humorist2290 1y agoBut if you want to outlaw this harmful activity [licensed gambling], you have to find a way to replace 6.4% of Maryland’s budget, which is slightly less than the entire amount the state brings in from corporate taxes. A fraction of the proceeds of losing bets from a fraction of Maryland's citizens contributes almost the same to state services -- EMS, education, road maintenance, etc -- than the total corporate taxes levied on all businesses. Do I misunderstand, or is this just actually incredible?
- only-one1701 1y agoIncredibly damning, yes
- edot 1y agoDamning which way, though? Are gambling taxes too high, or are corporate taxes too low? And since corporate income is surely higher than gambling income, I’m inclined to think that gambling taxes are too high AND corporate taxes are too low, creating this odd fact. Edit: and I know it sounds weird to say that gambling taxes are too high, when one could argue that high taxes are meant to disincentivize a thing - but if that thing is highly addictive, and if no other state action is taken to disincentivize that thing, then it’s actually a really sticky income source for the government who now doesn’t want to get rid of their cash cow. Tobacco ads are outlawed, which did more than taxing tobacco. Gambling ads are absurdly common.
- musicale 1y agoWhen you lose (most people, most of the time), you don't have to pay tax on winnings because there aren't any. But gambling itself seems like sort of a regressive tax that preys upon those susceptible to gambling. Edit: at least with state lotteries the state gets most of the money so it is more like a tax; in the case of corporate sports betting the corporation takes the money and then pays a small corporate tax on it.
- superfrank 1y ago
- shipman05 1y agoIt feels like banning advertising for gambling would be a sweet spot between harm reduction and maintaining individual liberty. Sports gambling ads have ruined sports media. State lottery ads are even worse. The government should not spend money to encourage its own citizens to partake in harmful activities.
- rufus_foreman 1y ago>> It feels like banning advertising for gambling would be a sweet spot between harm reduction and maintaining individual liberty No. If you want restrictions on gambling, on advertising it, on participating in it, on making money from it, you want to restrict individual liberty. I want to restrict individual liberty, I have voted against gambling when it has come up for a vote in my state over and over. You want to appear to be the type of person who wants to maintain individual liberty, but you in fact are not. You want to restrict individual liberty in the area of gambling. I would also like to appear to be the type of person who wants to maintain individual liberty, and I will vote against gambling every single time it comes up. No gambling.
- rockskon 1y agoGambling vs advertising gambling are two different things. Equating them as exactly the same doesn't serve your argument justice even if you do have a point with respect to the OP's "have their cake and eat it too" rhetorical flourish.
- rufus_foreman 1y agoIf you want to restrict advertising on gambling you want to restrict individual liberty. I want to restrict individual liberty. Do you want to restrict advertising on gambling?
- virtue3 1y agoAdvertising isn’t “individual liberty” — it’s paid psychological manipulation. Banning gambling ads isn’t banning gambling. It’s just stopping corporations from pushing addictive behavior on people who didn’t consent to see it. We banned cigarette ads for the same reason — harm and addiction. Limiting corporate ad power protects individual liberty. I can choose to gamble if I want, but I shouldn’t have to fight off brainwashing every time I watch a game.
- jerednel 1y agoJust ban advertising and let me gamble.
- nextworddev 1y agoListen kids, your dopamine circuits are beyond screwed up already. All this is designed to aggregate capital… into crypto ecosystem
- econ 1y agoWe should do licenses for gambling that cap betting at some percentage of your income or wealth. For example: you earn 50k annually, you get to gamble 250 or 0.5%.
- renewiltord 1y ago[flagged]
- jjbigs 1y agoIt's quite reactionary to label betting as addiction markets. I see little reason to draw that corollary to other, often detested, vices. To label such activity as a tax on the poor is nothing more than a euphemism. I understand what is being said by the verbiage "tax" in this context. Although no real tax is voluntary. Labeling this as an issue that disproportionately affects poor is misleading. This is an issue for a few select individuals who make poor decisions. The correlation for poor decisions and lower disposable income is higher than the contrary. Wealthy by all means have the ability to wager more than they can afford. Often times, they wager significantly higher than average income individuals; however, they stay within their means
- gloryjulio 1y agoThere is a Chinese term called 'porn gambling drugs business'. And these businesses will always be lucrative
- widikidiw 1y ago[dead]
- agigao 1y agoPersonal choice is when it just exists, like Las Vegas in Nevada. If you really really want to gamble then go, travel to Nevada and do it. The problem is sticking their filthy ads and purchased propagandists into the faces of vulnerable people and society at large. Preying on victims over the phone, soc. media ads, bought manipulators so called influencers with no morale.
- globular-toast 1y agoIf you think this is bad, have you noticed fast food? It's engineered to be addictive, the cause of obesity and diabetes epidemics, and they're allowed to advertise everywhere. What is it about gambling that people find bad while other advertising for harmful stuff gets a free pass?
- daseiner1 1y agothe outsize harms of gambling, financial ruin that is highly individualized, highly destructive, and particularly devastating. there are obviously significant public health costs from fast food, but its destruction does not present the same way.
- mock-possum 1y agoI sure did have to scroll down to find the best comment - appreciate that you were willing to make it.
- DecentShoes 1y agoIt's weird how we're so strict on consenting adults gambling, but when underage children gamble on Counter Strike, we as a society deem it totally fine, acceptable, and normal. I don't get it. Somehow, them being underage makes it better and not worse??
- brap 1y agoHow about we treat people like adults?
- haritha-j 1y agoI used to live in Sri Lanka and one of the most pervasive things I noticed when I moved to the west were all these gambling ads. There, it was widely accepted that gambling was harmful. Yes, you could do it, but you could never advertise it. I'm shocked that my 3rd world country has way better control over this than the west.
- vanderZwan 1y agoI think that's an unfair conclusion towards Sri Lanka, it's not like Western countries are inherently superior. Some things are further developed, some things were lost, and some things just reflect different values.
- haritha-j 1y agoThis is true. Growing up, there was always this ideal that the West was superior ingrained in us (colonial hangover as some put it), and it takes a lot of unlearning to see past it.
- PaulRobinson 1y agoI am a semi-professional gambler, based in the UK. To parse that statement: I have a day job; I make about as much income from software that trades on betting exchanges as I do from the day job, except that income is tax free (because UK law does not recognise it as a taxable trade - another debate); and I spend a lot of time watching, reading and understanding changes in the gambling industry because a significant chunk of my savings income comes from it. The UK went through almost everything the US is going through right now some years ago, where problem gambling led to suicides and people struggling to pay bills. Multiple measures have been taken that seem to have directly helped that situation: VIP programs have been scrapped; advertising is being limited; and, you may have to prove you can afford to bet the levels you're betting at to an operator, which is an incredibly unpopular move (who wants to send their pay slips to their bookie?), but does seem to have quelled things a little. However there is more to do, and there is something you can do right now if you are losing money and want to reduce the impact these products have on you. Stop playing casino and video slot games. Focus on sports only. The myth is that the problem gamblers are losing their money on 2nd Division Nigerian netball games in the middle of the night. Yes, there are some people who are looking for sports action all the time, but that's not the biggest source of problems. With sports, you have a little time to think. I recommend not playing in-play unless you have automated that solution to find EV and its executing for you (I know people who make money doing this on Betfair in the UK). Bet before game only, and you will have a built-in "cool off" period. You don't get that with casino games or video slots. Its relentless, and you can lose thousands an hour before you even realise what is happening. And then, there's EV. Expected Value. Sometimes (actually, kinda often), the odds a bookmaker puts up are a bit wrong. Not every price, it might be a prop bet on a particular player, and they're putting a price up on a Monday for a Saturday game, and you have a spreadsheet that dings something and tells you what the kelly stake should be and you put 1% of your bankroll on it, and then you might sell it back on Saturday morning when the market has got right or you let it ride (and there's maths to tell you when to do that and when not), and you ride some variance but make money. That's not possible on casino or video slot games. They just bleed you. There is no EV. If you win, you got lucky (the scientific name for this is "experienced positive variance"), and you should run away quickly before you lose it back. But the sure way to win on those games is the same as in Wargames: don't play at all. I'm biased, I realise that, but I would love to see the outlawing of casino and slot games on mobile. I would also like to see more education in schools around probability and statistics (the founder of SIG, a storied institution who is now a market maker on Kalshi, the prediction market platform), argues that the fascination with calculus in schools might have helped during the space race, but today we need people to really understand Bayes theorem more than anything else. I agree. If you want to start your own education in how to bet a little smarter and lose a little less, I can recommend The Logic of Sports Betting [0] and its sequel Interception [1]. I also like Dan Abrams' book [2], that talks about expected growth, not just exepcted value. These are not get rich quick schemes, but it will give you an idea of what goes on in the minds of people who try and take this all very seriously. You'll still need to think about modelling and how to get your own prices to compare with those you're being offered, but if you're not prepared to do that work, what is it you're actually doing? [0] https://www.amazon.com/Logic-Sports-Betting-Ed-Miller/dp/1096805723 https://www.amazon.com/Logic-Sports-Betting-Ed-Miller/dp/109... [1] https://www.amazon.com/Interception-Secrets-Modern-Sports-Betting/dp/B0CKTC45KY https://www.amazon.com/Interception-Secrets-Modern-Sports-Be... [2] https://www.amazon.com/But-How-Much-Did-Lose-ebook/dp/B0DRZ2192J https://www.amazon.com/But-How-Much-Did-Lose-ebook/dp/B0DRZ2...
- ripped_britches 1y agoThis is a horribly written article littered with logical fallacies. Nearly every point is just a random fact about gambling that doesn’t add to the argument. - fanduel owns networks. So what? - gambling taxes = corporate taxes in MD. This is misleading as state level corporate are effectively $0 - 20% of Americans have placed a bet. So? I have never done sports gambling myself but this article fails to convince that it’s a problem
- peer2pay 1y agoMeanwhile Mr POTUS himself wants to introduce prop betting in his social media platform. Don’t expect anything to change anytime soon
- pavlov 1y agoThe president wants to let people gamble on election results on a platform he owns. Which is a fun novel conflict of interest because he’s also ultimately the executive in charge of making sure national elections are properly conducted. Since this is the direction America is going, why not have judges take bets on the outcome of trials? Would be a nice income stream for them, and it would save taxpayer money when judges don’t need to be paid anymore.
- TimByte 1y agoWhat really struck me is how gambling has quietly become infrastructure. That's a deeply unsettling shift.
- zkmon 1y agoWhat happened to America. Maybe 70's or 40's were it's peak. Every activity has become a betting. Investments, sports, relationships, home-buying. Addictions are a symptom of having an excessive amount of free time, floating money and lack of fear of reprisal from family and society and lack of basic wisdom. Excessive prosperity breaks social rythm. It removes dependencies and relations across individuals. It's like a tree turned into chips, with freedom for every chip. As individuals, you won (materialistic luxury etc), but as a family, community or country, you fail.
- carefulfungi 1y agoThe 70's were an economic horror show, Richard Nixon, and a legitimate fear of nuclear war; the 40's were a global war. Weird take.
- zkmon 1y agoWell, that kept you folks together atleast, and kept you focused on things that were not betting.
- Dumblydorr 1y agoExcessive prosperity is one phrase for it. Another is kleptocracy, politics have been co-opted by money and those who have it now control 99% of US society. Those who have no prosperity are often the ones gambling, not the rich. When SS checks come in, our local casino fills with chain smoking seniors pulling levers on the slot with all their retirement security. It’s a sad addiction.
- clejack 1y agoSo to avoid the suffering of gambling we need to simply suffer and toil so much in day to day existence that we don't have the capacity to engage with anything else?
- intended 1y agoEh? Theres too many moving parts in your very short paragraph, to actual engage with without any substantial engagement being minced into woodchips, I fear. Theres many things that have happened since the 40s, just to name ONE thing that has resulted in this - we have much better psychological technology than we did ever before. Skinnerian conditioning, reward schedules, their results - we never had that. MS Excel alone would mean we better ways for the statistically inclined to zero in on more attractive addictions, just through better data analysis. Just consider how common place and obvious A/B testing is. How do you think humanity will fare on average, against industrial strength siren songs?
- tsoukase 1y agoGambling, especially low cost continuous play, can be a symptom of latent mental disease, especially depression or simply low intelligence to conceive the fraud (the company always wins). These people need protection by banning ads for any gambling and provide support and guidance to uncover the scam.
- m0rissette 1y agoIsn’t everything deceptive? Isn’t every thing that produces a dopaminergic burst addictive? Should we dismantle and ban fast food? Social media? Fried food? Everything is coercive. You want a cure; force feed people mindfulness and psychology. All commercials are potentially coercive and deceptive. I’m watching a Walgreens commercial; there is no line in the commercial, the person behind the pharmacy is smiling and happy, no one else is in the store, the “paid for” actor leaves the pharmacy happy. This just seem like the reality of any Walgreens I’ve visited. But I digress; my argument for addiction markets as a recovering alcoholic… I grew more as a human from the experience of addiction and recovery than any other day to day mundane dopamine driven activity. Sometimes we need to fall to get back up. It makes us stronger, we learn to ask for help.
- intended 1y agoIf everything is coercive - Yes. Your definition of coercive is too permissive, so it ends up being more of an ideological stance, but its a saturday, so its a fun argument to work through. If something is coercive, its inherently aiming to generate an unfair transaction. That means we need to spend a ton of effort on forums where such unfair transacations can be reversed, and punitive measures applied. Otherwise we are always going to fail as a society, simply because coercive technqiues will be the default. Any new business, discovery, or product which provides a net benefit without defending itself from predatory practices will be torpedoed. resulting in a moribund economy and culture. Having gone through what you have, I suspect you quietly prefer people learning from your example, over discovering the same lessons by following in your foot steps.
- freen 1y agoFun fact: Biff Tannen was modeled after Donald Trump. Turns out the darkest timeline is also the dumbest. https://www.nme.com/news/back-to-the-future-writer-reveals-biff-tannen-was-inspired-by-donald-trump-2560286 https://www.nme.com/news/back-to-the-future-writer-reveals-b...
- Balgair 1y agoI'll make a bet here: By the 2040 US presidential election, anti-gambling legislation will be a bigger party platform issue than abortion is for one of the two major US political parties. We are ruining a generation of men with this, just as we did with alcohol in the era before prohibition. A wiser and more sensible approach is desperately needed today, but will not come for another 15 years until the damage is inescapable to see.
- uvaursi 1y agoThere’s something entertaining about an article on addiction-driven gambling and then a comment that uses a provocative, attention grabbing hook, on a website that has trained its audience to respond like Pavlovian dogs to bait.
- Den_VR 1y agoA generation of men?
- Balgair 1y agoI mean, in my little part of the world if you go up to any sub 24 year old male and say: " What's the line?" you'll get the betting numbers for the 'largest' local team playing that day. It's a bit different today in particular though as we're in equinox season (when many major sports leagues play on the same day). So your local college football team is playing today, the world series game 7 is today, and there are NBA and NHL on today, and NFL is tomorrow.
- JumpinJack_Cash 1y agoWhat a bunch of fearful people in the comments. Gambling , especially in person gambling such as poker is basically a toned down version of combat sports where you are socially allowed to take something from somebody else because the other person accepted the conditions by sitting at the table or entering the casino. Much like a boxer accepts the risk when they enter the ring. The same thing happens on your beloved stock market, you just don't see it.
- trashface 1y agoI hope if there is a regulatory backlash it results in loot crates in games getting regulated, ideally outlawed. Apologists for that practice claimed there was no harm in it, but now we see the harm - a generation of young men trained on those that is now older and ruining their financial future on sports betting.
- indolering 1y ago> “21% of sports bettors say they’ve verbally abused an athlete, either in person or online, after losing money on a bet.” This is exactly what it felt like to work in crypto.