6 ms·
VOC injection into a house reveals large surface reservoir sizes
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- gwking 1y agoI have never seen the word “partition” used in this way before. Hard to search for examples because unrelated computer graphics articles about surface partitioning dominate. I did find this: Partitioning is the distribution of a solute, S, between two immiscible solvents (such as aqueous and organic phases). It is an equilibrium condition that is described by the following equation: S(aq) ⇄ S(org) Interesting to think that a surface can play a role comparable to a solvent. I wonder what a chemist would have to say about it. https://www.chemicool.com/definition/partitioning.html https://www.chemicool.com/definition/partitioning.html
- PaulHoule 1y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octanol-water_partition_coefficient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octanol-water_partition_coeffi... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adsorption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adsorption
- pbhjpbhj 1y agoIn the UK a non-structural wall is called a partition wall -- they're usually plasterboard (I think that is called sheetrock in USA) over wooden studs whilst ordinarily walls are plaster on brick/stone. I wonder which partitions more VOCs/SOCs, partition or structural walls.
- PaulHoule 1y agoMore generally partition (as a verb) means "to divide into parts" which is used for numerous purposes such as -- to divide a country into parts (e.g. separate Pakistan and Bangladesh from India) -- to divide a physical space with walls -- to divide a population of molecules between molecules floating in the air and molecules stuck on walls
- lazide 1y agoAlso to divide digital storage into individually addressable segments (disk partitions).
- whatevertrevor 1y ago-- "Divide" an integer into two or more integers that sum to it too. :D
- JadeNB 1y agoThe trivial partition n = n also usually counts as a partition. This is useful if you want to be able to dualize partitions, and want n = 1 + 1 + ... + 1 to have a dual partition.
- tsimionescu 1y agoAlso to separate a computer network into two or more disconnected networks, the P in the CAP theorem stands for "partition tolerance" (i.e. that a system can keep working in case its components end up in a partitioned network).
- Polizeiposaune 1y agoA more generic term is drywall or gypsum board. It generally is covered by a skim coat of plaster and is then painted. "Sheetrock" is a particular brand of drywall. For instance, see https://www.lowes.com/pl/drywall/sheetrock-brand/4294864808-4294851233 https://www.lowes.com/pl/drywall/sheetrock-brand/4294864808-...
- ninalanyon 1y agoGypsum board is a considerably more specific, less generic, term than partition. My wooden house has some internal non-structural walls but none of them use gypsum boards (called plasterboard in British English). Neither are they skimmed with plaster. They are instead faced with a very dense and flat hardboard.
- quickthrowman 1y agoGypsum board is the term for a type of wall covering, which itself is part of a partition. A partition is an interior wall assembly typically consisting of framing, (optional) insulation, and a wall covering (like gypsum board, but this could be anything: wood, shiplap, masonry, lath and plaster, etc.)
- ChoGGi 1y agoYou only tape the joints, not the whole wall.
- quickthrowman 1y agoThere are multiple levels of drywall finishing. A level 5 (highest grade) finish involves skim coating the entire gypsum wallboard with joint compound. It’s not very common, but it is used in some commercial settings.
- hxorr 1y agoI think it would depend on what paint is used. Although I would strongly suspect exposed porous surfaces like plaster, masonry, drywall to have a large reservoir capacity due to their surface area at the microscopic level
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- s0rce 1y agoI'm a materials scientist/chemist and the word partition made sense in this context. The VOC/solute is preferentially on surfaces vs floating in the air. This finding doesn't seem super surprising to me given the large surface area of all the stuff in a home.
- fuzzfactor 1y agoIn separation science a partitioning coefficient can be described for an undesirable contaminant, inbetween a solid adsorbent having a certain degree of retention, versus a solvent where it is soluble to its own certain degree, under static equilibrium conditions. IOW the smoke will have different affinity for different types of furniture, carpets, and window coverings, and when it comes in contact with these they soak it up like a sponge. Because the adsorbent materials are physically like a sponge more often than not, whether on a macro, micro, or molecular level. The solvent is plain air, but the "solubility" of the raw smoke in air is not a factor because the smoke is not actually dissolved in the solvent (air) at this point, or ever really. The smoke consists of a lot of solid particles that have been forcefully dispersed into the air at uneven concentrations. The smoke itself is not a chemical contaminant that dissolves in the air, it's just dispersed in the air not much differently than an unwanted chemical, for a least a good period of time. But the solids will eventually settle if they are not purged beforehand. What you're left with after that is then chemical equilibrium. In a confined enclosure, static equilibrium will eventually be reached between the amount of chemical contaminants dissolved in the air at that temperature, versus the amount adsorbed onto available surfaces. After which no more odor can be released from the furniture once the air is saturated. To really get rid of the smell you're going to have to replace the saturated air with fresh air and one compete air exchange is not usually enough. Also the more efficient air exchange the better, and the fresher the better. If one person smoked one time, or you burned some popcorn and did not let out the smoke right away, that's not much contamination and it's not constant, but it's also not unusual to still smell it a week later when you first walk in from a fresh outdoor air environment. But just don't open the windows when something like a diesel truck is idling outside, new odor could then be coming in in greater quantities than the old odor can escape, one roomful at a time. You may have grams of "odor" soaked into the carpet along with 100 grams of dirt & dust. But what if the chemical causing the odor only "evaporates" into the air a few milligrams at a time? Because the heavier the liquid, the slower the evaporation and the resulting partitioning coefficient using air as a solvent is such a low number. And it's not too unintuitive to figure that things which are semi-solid like tars or true solids like some pesticides hardly evaporate at all, but can really stink when there's only a few milligrams in the air. Stuff like that is not going away without a solvent much stronger than air, and also a more concentrated solvent than a gaseous fluid can make contact by the gram much faster than a gram of fresh air can eventually flow by the unwanted material to be removed. Plain water may not be any better as a solvent at dissolving cooking oils and tars than air is a solvent, but you sure can get a lot more grams into contact with a surface or macro adsorbent quicker compared to air as a gas. Plain steam dissolves things so much better just from the added heat of the liquid turning it into a stronger solvent, plus so much of the water evaporates so fast at that temperature there is also a purging effect. Then there's the carpet-cleaning liquids that can improve the partitioning coefficient of water so it will dissolve otherwise insoluble materials without nearly as much heat as steam. Like grams of detergent added to volumes of water to clean a certain area of carpet, or hundreds of grams of water-soluble organic solvent over the same area instead. Or both, simultaneously, or sequentially. Then when you do the math you see how much more effective sequentially is. Now without doing any carpet cleaning, when you enhance the air exchange rate to do as good a job removing odors as that can accomplish, you are then trying to establish a dynamic equilibrium so odors are being purged outward at an enhanced rate due to increased fresh solvent (air) flow. Kind of like sequential carpet cleaning. One window fan blowing in and one blowing out at opposite ends of the structure can sometimes be more effective than all windows open whether or not using the same fans. >I wonder what a chemist would have to say about it. I wouldn't be surprised if people are still wondering :) Edit: Hopefully they're wondering even more about a lot of things where they didn't know there were equations, actually ;)
- jagraff 1y agoInteresting, it seems that the actual surface material of walls and/or furniture makes a large difference in how long VOCs stick around, due to differences in surface area at the microscopic scale. I have a couple HEPA filters in my house that hopefully keep particulate exposure down. Does this mean that I have to run them longer? That I need more of them continuously running to keep exposure to VOCs low?
- lm28469 1y ago> HEPA filters They won't do anything against VOCs, you need activated charcoal filters
- throwway120385 1y agoThis kinda makes sense. Water vapor diffuses out through the building materials so why wouldn't VOCs diffuse into those materials? What you're looking for are not HEPA filters but organic vapor filtering. If you were shopping for a respirator it would be easy but organic vapor extractors I think are a lot more expensive than HEPA filters. I looked in to it when I was doing a couple of oil based coatings for a home renovation project.
- wongarsu 1y agoA lot of air purifiers are advertised as HEPA but really contain a filter stack consisting of a pre-filter, a HEPA filter and an activated carbon filter. Those would presumably help against VOCs, assuming you change the filter frequently enough
- s0rce 1y agoFrequent replacement is critical, my understanding is the activated carbon filters typically provided have very limited capacity. More so when compared to the lifetime of the hepa.
- bonesss 1y agoCompare those air ‘purifiers’ with the activated charcoal setups they use on cannabis grow operations, and you’ll get a sense of what volume of charcoal and air circulation is necessary to combat those small particulates. Purifiers help in theory but are nowhere near effective or active enough to combat off gassing or VOC dispersals in practice.
- lxgr 1y agoReminds me about this recent Reddit thread where somebody ran an Ozone generator in a house for hours to get rid of smells, and in exchange ended up with a much worse situation: https://www.reddit.com/r/chemistry/comments/q949go/holy_shit_why_are_ozone_generators_legal_to_buy/ https://www.reddit.com/r/chemistry/comments/q949go/holy_shit... VOCs getting absorbed by surfaces was the most plausible theory in the comments there as well. Interesting to see more evidence for it.
- bob1029 1y agoI've ran an ozone generator in a house for multiple days, but I went into it with the expectation that it would be uninhabitable for a period of time afterward. Ozone won't stick around for very long. It is extremely reactive. With windows / doors open and vent fans running it will be cleared out in maybe a few hours max. The first few minutes is definitely overpowering though. You need to have a plan to turn the machine off and ventilate the building that doesn't involve walking through it for longer than you can hold your breath.
- mindslight 1y agoI just wore a half face respirator with an activated carbon filter (3M 7503 + 6001 + something over that for particulates, probably 2297). Quality respirators seem like simple table stakes for doing a lot of things these days. It was an off label use of the organic vapor cartridge but it worked fine (it also worked fine for cleaning with ammonia in deep cabinets). I also probably plugged the O3 generator into an extension cord which I could unplug without going in the room, the mask was just to go in and open the windows some time afterwards. It seems like, as with anything, the important part is to know the technicals of what something does and create an overall plan.
- ok_computer 1y agoI’ve used respirators through prior lab work and be warned the ammonia grade and organic solvent grades are distinct filter packing.
- DoneWithAllThat 1y agoAs with so many headlines like this, it should read (title), claims a single unreplicated study.
- colechristensen 1y agoNo it does not need that. Replication and peer review are required to be very careful about believing small effect sizes that are inconsistent across populations which are so common with papers in biology and medicine measuring the effect of X on Y when it's entirely believable that the study might just be statistical error or cherry picking. This study is measuring something pretty obvious and it's more akin to you demanding replication and peer review to your bathroom scale. There might be room for some additional studies but the conclusions here "surface areas for VOCs to stick to are much bigger than this simplified model" don't really need to be doubted all that much.
- syawaworht 1y agoThere's actually a decent amount of work recently in this space, some of it motivated by the wildfires. Here's another recent paper with similar findings. The persistence of smoke VOCs indoors: Partitioning, surface cleaning, and air cleaning in a smoke-contaminated house https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10575580/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10575580/
- anarticle 1y agoDoes this mean the Germans are right with Lüften!? I habitually have done this as an American in the morning for my office, something about morning fresh air after the night seems right?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- tecleandor 1y agoThey usually do it for avoiding condensation, hence mold. New german buildings are very well insulated (sometimes too much) so you gotta move that condensation humidity.
- ted_dunning 1y agoIt helps a lot with CO2 accumulation as well which is a problem in a tight house.
- fnordian_slip 1y agoI always thought the American meme about Lüften / Stoßlüften was just about the fact that people like exotic names for normal behaviours. Are you telling me that there is a significant percentage of people in the US who don't fully open two or more windows to get the air completely exchanged about three times a day in the winter? I know you have AC for the summer, where we use Lüften during the night and then close our exterior blinds. And that makes sense, as your summers are hotter in many areas and it doesn't get cool enough at night for our strategy to work consistently. But I have always assumed that everyone does Lüften in the winter, and that you guys just like the funny sounding word we use for it.
- crowbahr 1y agoI run a CO2 monitor to let me know when to open the windows in the winter cause it's damn cold here but yeah: many Americans never open any windows. Usually the houses are too poorly sealed to keep the air in anyways, so you get slow air replacement from the leaks.
- Groxx 1y ago>Our estimates of the total surface partitioning capacity are much larger than if the reservoirs are taken to be thin organic films on smooth, impermeable surfaces. ... so is "smooth, impermeable surfaces" the current begrudgingly-accepted model or something? because there's no way any person who has ever been in a house would think that's a reasonable model. permeable surfaces are all over the place, literally most of the place because it includes essentially all walls and therefore wall interiors. managing that for e.g. humidity is a significant part of building design because it's completely inescapable... and that's before even touching stuff like fabric where your average couch probably has more surface area than all structural surfaces combined.
- frickinLasers 1y agoYes, it probably is. Have you ever heard of the spherical cow?* Simplifying the surface makes it possible to model the system with equations that can be solved analytically--which gives theorists something to work on. Modeling more complex systems (which often happens, eventually) typically requires lots of computing power and results in a model that doesn't generalize well. * https://www.sphericalcowblog.com/spherical-cows https://www.sphericalcowblog.com/spherical-cows
- strongpigeon 1y agoThat reminds me of when I was living right by the BLM protests/CHOP [0] in Seattle and got tear gas in my condo. I had just bought some new coffee beans to try out and when I did the next morning, thought they tasted super "chemical-y" and immediately threw them aways. Turns out tear gas is known to seep into food items, especially porous food like coffee and bread [1]. Not surprised at all that VOCs linger in reservoirs as mentioned in the article. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitol_Hill_Occupied_Protest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitol_Hill_Occupied_Protest [1]: https://www.propublica.org/article/tear-gas-is-way-more-dangerous-than-police-let-on-especially-during-the-coronavirus-pandemic https://www.propublica.org/article/tear-gas-is-way-more-dang...
- arcanemachiner 1y ago> That reminds me of when I was living right by the BLM protests/CHOP [0] in Seattle and got tear gas in my condo. I had just bought some new coffee beans to try out and when I did the next morning, thought they tasted super "chemical-y" and immediately threw them aways. This is by far the most Seattle thing I have ever read.