9 ms·
California needs to learn from Houston and Dallas about homelessness
- poppobit 1y agoI think this piece makes a strong point — when there’s already a working model, just copy it instead of endlessly debating. The homelessness crisis is real, and doing nothing while watching it grow worse is the worst option. Of course there’s a chance it fails, but the bigger issue is that no one wants to take responsibility if it does. That lack of strong leadership is, in itself, part of the problem.
- nis0s 1y agoI am not saying it’s okay that anyone should be homeless, but it’s baseless to call homelessness a crises for the U.S. The homeless population accounts for 0.23% of the total U.S. population, or about ~771K people. https://endhomelessness.org/state-of-homelessness/ https://endhomelessness.org/state-of-homelessness/ For comparison, more people are getting DUI citations per year, https://www.safehome.org/resources/dui-statistics/ https://www.safehome.org/resources/dui-statistics/
- watwut 1y agoWhy are you comparing amount of homeless people to DUI?
- superxpro12 1y agoScale of the issue relative to the risk, I think.
- harpiaharpyja 1y agoIt's another public health issue that could also be receiving attention which causes harm to people.
- pessimizer 1y agoWhat is supposed to be the relationship between those two things? Will you be comparing it to the number of ham sandwiches next?
- nis0s 1y agoYou would think that since DUI operators present a greater social problem, both in numbers and potential to cause harm, there would be all sorts of active campaigns against such an issue. But the present reality is that some issues have great political forces behind them, and the media takes care to paint such issues as “crises”. Maybe it is a crisis, for a certain locality, and that reflects on the governance of that place. But I don’t think it’s fair or accurate to say your local problem is a problem at large, even if that means you get less federal monies to deal with it. Maybe what that means is that people need to reflect on how their localities are spending their budget, or sorting their priorities.
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y agoThere's 8300+ homeless people in San Francisco. That's 1% of the population. Maybe not a big deal to you. There's only 13,000 city blocks in SF. That's a homeless person every 2 blocks. Kind of dangerous to be walking past people in all different states of desperation multiple times every trip everywhere you go, is another way to look at it.
- Broken_Hippo 1y agoEven if you end homelessness, you'll still be walking past people in all different states of desperation multiple times everywhere you go. People looking like they have homes or acting like it won't stop this. It doesn't make people inherently dangerous. Don't get me wrong, I think any percent of the population being homeless because of lack of options is a tragedy. (I don't really care if someone wishes to be so, and I think we should have appropriate living options for this). I understand that you can't really stop temporary homelessness - fires and urgent things happen - but that's something we can deal with as needed.
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y agoIs your argument that, because x% of the population is desperate, we shouldn't care or do anything about x%+y% being like that? y% LIVES on the blocks - so the multiple on y is higher (higher probability you encounter them), and the desperation factor is also likely much higher.
- nis0s 1y agoPlease note that someone giving you a quantitative context isn’t necessarily saying don’t care. But it’s important to be mindful of how people use words in the media to describe certain issues because it benefits them politically or financially. The problem which sticks out to me is that homelessness can be addressed by providing housing, but that’s not an easy solution to provide in a country that gets 10s of millions of illegal immigrants. So why is someone talking so much about homelessness relative to other issues? Do they want the U.S. to provide a house for every illegal immigrant who crosses a border? If political officials in states struggling with homelessness really care about solving the problem, they would do what other states are doing, as mentioned in OP’s article.
- 0_____0 1y ago771K people isn't a small number. 0.23% isn't a small number when it comes to homelessness. This also doesn't consider people who are housed but are overcrowded or living in otherwise very poor environments. You also ignore that it's a rapidly growing problem. Comparing it to DUI numbers doesn't make any sense whatsoever.
- nis0s 1y agoDisagree that it’s a growing problem, there are lots of states dealing with it correctly. Look at the article, for example.
- sethammons 1y ago> it’s baseless to call homelessness a crises for the U.S Sure, a quarter of a percent is not a big percent, but that sure is a lot of people. It is _more_ than the entire population of Alaska, Wyoming, or Vermont. It is near the population size of several other states. An entire US state's worth of people are unable to find adequate housing and not just because they are off their meds. According to the 2024 Point-in-Time count, the US Department of Housing and Urban Development estimated 22% of homeless are facing a severe mental illness. So nearly 4 out of 5 homeless are regular people who simply cannot secure permanent housing. That sure as hell sounds like a crisis to me.
- pandaman 1y ago> So nearly 4 out of 5 homeless are regular people who simply cannot secure permanent housing. How does it follow? Not having a severe mental illness makes one normal? It's as same as saying that not suffering from severe obesity makes you fit and healthy.
- sethammons 1y agoObesity is an excess of something. If we flip it, you can say that "too skinny is a problem" and there is a difference between someone someone with an eating disorder that makes them avoid food vs those who simply don't eat enough. The unhoused has those people with a housing disorder, aka mental illness, and those who, simply, don't "house" enough. Why don't they house enough? Many reasons. But nearly 4 out of 5 are not ticking the severe mental illness part. So there is less water in the argument that homelessness is caused by mental illnesses which is the leading reason I hear when people talk about homelessness. So, they aren't "mental," they are "normal."
- pandaman 1y agoPerhaps having a severe mental illness is somehow important for you but I still don't see how is it relevant in this context other than it shows that the fraction of homeless with it is ~4x bigger than in regular population so it's likely the rest of them are suffering with less than severe mental illness (not even taking drug addiction into account).
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bdcravens 1y agoWhether it's homelessness, DUIs, or fentanyl deaths (only 75k per year!), measuring the impact of something by ignoring the blast radius is disingenuous. All who are touched are part of it. In the case of homelessness, it's a burden on emergency services, creates unsafe environments, impacts businesses, etc.
- nis0s 1y agoI think the article points out some useful ways to deal with the problem at hand.
- HankStallone 1y agoA quarter of a percent still seems like a lot to me, even if it's not a "crisis." But we can't do anything about it until we face up to the problem. Spending more money won't help. I'm somewhat familiar with the activity at our local jail, and a good part of it is homeless people rotating in and out. They get brought in because they were trespassing or shoplifting or something, the jail cleans them up and dries them out (they're usually on drugs, which they somehow manage to buy) and tries to get them back on their medications, they get released, and the cycle begins again. Most of them are mentally unstable, and perhaps they'd be somewhat functional if they could stay on their medication, but they don't, so they can't function in society for long. We don't want to put them back in asylums, because some asylums really were hellholes, and I guess we don't trust ourselves not to let them be hellholes again. That seems awfully pessimistic; factories used to be pretty awful too, but we require them to be safe and clean now. Seems like we could do the same with asylums, but we won't even consider it. So we're left with letting them wander the streets, maybe bedding down at homeless shelters when they feel like it, using the jails as temporary asylums when they get in trouble, and throwing more money at the problem once in a while to soothe our guilt. It's sad.
- nis0s 1y agoDifferent US states have implemented useful measures for helping homeless people, but states which are struggling with their implementation have other issues as well. Border states in particular have illegal immigrants to contend with as well, so a housing-first policy for homelessness gets taken off the table right away. California has the means and resources for dealing with its homelessness problem, but the political will is murky.
- captainclam 1y agoI've always been surprised by the official homeless population count, but it turns out there's a lot more to it. The department of HUD generates this ~771K figure from a "point-in-time" estimate, a single count from a single night performed in January. They literally have volunteers go out, count the number of homeless people they observe, and report their findings. It's not hard to imagine why this is probably a significant undercount. There is likely a long tail of people that happened to be in a situation that night where they were not able to be counted (i.e. somewhere secluded, sleeping in a friend's private residence that night, etc). Even if these numbers are correct, to my mind a "crisis" is still more characterized by the trend than the numbers in absolute. From the first link you provided, we saw a 39% increase in "people in families" experiencing homelessness, and 9% in individuals. A resource from the HUD itself suggests a 33% increase in homelessness from 2020-2024, 18% increase from 2023-2024. That is far apace of the population increase in general. https://www.huduser.gov/portal/sites/default/files/pdf/2024-AHAR-Part-1.pdf https://www.huduser.gov/portal/sites/default/files/pdf/2024-... And even then, I would say many people would suggest that the change in visible homelessness they've experienced in the last 10 years would amount to "crisis" levels, at least relative to the past. It's completely fair to argue that it is not in fact a crisis, but claiming that it is certainly not "baseless."
- saghm 1y agoIt's kind of wild that they pick maybe the coldest month of the year to do this. You'd think that would be when people are most likely to try to find some sort way of avoiding direct exposure to the open air even if it's extremely short term.
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y ago> The homelessness crisis is real, and doing nothing while watching it grow worse is the worst option. California isn't doing nothing. They keep spending even more money and wondering why it's not working. If it was a problem that could be solved by giving people money, they'd have solved it already.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoEverything except ending the ban on homeowners & landowners building market housing. (ofc they are taking bites out of this apple, especially very recently, but every step is fought tooth & nail by homeowners who prefer the status quo just fine)
- Spivak 1y agoI'm fully in the camp of just give people dollars and let them decide how to spend it rather than navigate a bureaucratic nanny state system like SNAP. But if you're only doing that well no shit it doesn't help. You have to actually put them in a stable house/apartment and get them set up with work. Or if they're homeless due to mental illness get them admitted.
- MontyCarloHall 1y ago>Or if they're homeless due to mental illness get them admitted. Therein lies the problem. A large proportion of homeless fall into this category [*], and it's very hard to institutionalize people against their will. We like to think that most homeless are functional people who are simply down on their luck, and thus putting them in stable housing and getting them set up to work would solve their problems. But this is sadly not the case. [*] This study [0] found that 80% of homeless people have some kind of mental illness, with 30% having severe mental illness. This is compounded by the fact that >50% have substance abuse problems. [0] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8423293/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8423293/
- HankStallone 1y agoRight. As I touched on elsewhere in the thread, our local jailers know all the homeless people in town because they show up regularly when their mental illnesses and/or substance abuse get them into trouble. The ordinary guy who wound up homeless due to a string of bad luck and just needs a place to sleep and a new job to get back on his feet is more a movie trope than reality. These are people with real problems who in many cases need regular supervision in something like a group home, if not outright institutionalization. And as you said, the latter is very hard to do now.
- Yizahi 1y agoThe problem is not that lack of examples. Technically, all two hundred something countries could take example of the best one in every metric and just copy most of the stuff to make life better. The problem is that politicians are afraid to do anything (outside of direct and indirect enrichment). No one can blame some John Doe, chief Busybody of the Busyarea, if he won't do something. Because that didn't happen, nothing to point finger at directly, except for "you don't do enough", which is generic enough to be used at anyone and so ineffective at everyone. But if he will do something and it is immediately painful to at at least some group, then he will be blamed and his opponent will do that with pleasure too.
- jsbisviewtiful 1y agoHow does Houston deal with those that can't be housed? Sure, 90% retention sounds nice for these people but California has limited housing/higher housing costs, in general, last I had read. The write-up even mentions rising housing costs or the Trump admin taking away their funding can crash the system, so unclear how easily this system could transfer to other cities. Sure, better communicating systems and a better hierarchy will lead to better outcomes for most orgs, but that's a pretty general statement about basically every org out there. I also feel like this write-up sugar coats some of the actions Houston/Texas has been taking against non-compliance. Ticketing homeless people $200 for existing on the streets seems a bit counter intuitive - and Texas has been systematically shipping homeless and immigrants around the country (human trafficking) for political theater, so are they excluding that data? Probably. I'm not an expert, but this write-up really comes off as one-sided since it's only talking about what's not working in California and ignoring some of the background stuff Texas is up to. Overall, do agree that better management and accountability would do other cities favors, but again, that's such an easy statement to make about any plan or org. https://www.houstonpublicmedia.org/articles/news/city-of-houston/2025/10/01/532418/exclusive-houston-ramps-up-citations-of-homeless-after-july-civility-ordinance-expansion/ https://www.houstonpublicmedia.org/articles/news/city-of-hou...
- nradov 1y agoHigher housing costs in California are in some sense an artificial manufactured problem. California should mimic Texas by making it easier and cheaper to build more housing. Take approval power away from local governments, and give property owners and developers the right to build pretty much whatever they want wherever they want.
- stonogo 1y agoThat point would be strong, but this article doesn't make that point, or any other points I can tell. It does really weird things like comparing the annual cost of housing one Texan person to building an entire Californian housing unit, changes which definition of "homelessness" it uses (sometimes mid-sentence), ignores Houston's extremely police-oriented approach to the topic (police can cite you for trespassing if you're at a bus stop and don't produce ID), pretends the Texas cities aren't sweeping encampments (they are, right now, on Nance Street), and just generally plays fast-and-loose with the facts in Texas.
- softwaredoug 1y agoI think there's a crisis of ineffectiveness in Center-Left institutions They are too deliberative, and take excessive time including voices of every stakeholder. So you don't just go do the "obvious thing". You cater to trying to listen to every voice in an effort to be as inclusive as possible. Committee after committee and an obsession with process. You can spend years placating NIMBYs and people living with their own alternate reality. Meanwhile real people are suffering from lack of action. This level of ineffectiveness just enables authoritarianism ("at least they get something done") and gets people to seek the private industry for their solutions.
- sailingparrot 1y agoThis is basically the entire theme of "Abundance" by Klein and Thompson, for those looking for a longer read on this. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_(Klein_and_Thompson_book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_(Klein_and_Thompson_...
- spiritplumber 1y agothank you, i'll grab this!
- rufus_foreman 1y agoAnother recent book along the same lines would be "Why Nothing Works: Who Killed Progress and How to Get It Back" by Marc Dunkelman: "When he looked into the history, Dunkelman realized that progressives have long swung back and forth between two opposing impulses. One is what he calls Hamiltonianism: the desire to achieve progress by empowering government and institutions to tackle big problems at the direction of strong leaders (like Robert Moses) and informed experts. The other is what he calls Jeffersonianism: the desire to prevent unaccountable centralized authorities (also like Robert Moses) from abusing ordinary citizens by empowering them to fight back." -- https://www.niskanencenter.org/why-nothing-works-with-marc-dunkelman/ https://www.niskanencenter.org/why-nothing-works-with-marc-d...
- lkey 1y agoAbundance is just https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Way https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Way neoliberalism with a new coat of paint. The answer to all questions is 'bust unions and environmental groups'. We've been here before: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancer_Alley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancer_Alley All the Reaganite conservative institutions (https://www.abundancedc.org/speakers https://www.abundancedc.org/speakers) that are leery of fascism, but love business back this 'program'. We need a new 'New Deal', that rebuilds what was broken during these last 90 years. We need the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frances_Perkins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frances_Perkins of this era. "Frances Perkins was not just the architect of SSA: she also proposed and implemented many of the foundational labor and safety laws1 still relied upon by the American working class. We can also thank her for the 40-hour work week, minimum wage, unemployment compensation, worker’s compensation, workplace safety, abolition of child labor, direct federal aid to the states for unemployment relief, a revitalized federal employment service, and universal health insurance. Well, except the last. We are still working on the last. " She got everything she wanted done as Labor Sec. Except for universal healthcare. And it was a great loss for everything living American every year since.
- josefresco 1y ago> Houston has no zoning code Too many and too restrictive building codes are bad, but no codes? Yikes.
- Forgeties79 1y agoI lived in Houston for six months and I don’t understand anybody who would ever use it as a model for any city in any capacity unless they love endless interstate construction and taking 60-90 minutes to get anywhere. “Sprawling mess” doesn’t even begin to cover it.
- akgoel 1y agoYes, it takes me 60 minutes to go 45 miles when I cross the extremes of the city. Oh noes! How far does the red line go in Boston and how long does that take?
- codyb 1y agoI think the better question is general walkability. The extremes is a pretty weird trip to do comparisons of since most people go from the outskirts into the centers to work and play and then go back to the outskirts. The question becomes... once you get to your destination, can you get anywhere else without having to hop back into the car? In cities like NY or Boston you can ride into town, hit a restaurant, go to the show, grab a few drinks then hit the clubs all without getting back into your car or just by taking short stints on readily available public transportation or taxis. Can you have that same experience in Houston? I don't really know. Maybe. Where I'm from it's not concentrated like that so you go to your friends house... then you get in a car and go down to the bars... then you get in the car again to go to the arena for the show. Everything's very dispersed. I personally like that much less.
- vel0city 1y agoYou can have that experience in Houston, but most of "Houston" isn't like that. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fMTaNYYvwE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fMTaNYYvwE
- dylan604 1y agoLike Dallas that rounds up the homeless and puts them on busses to drop off in Houston? "The success in Houston and Dallas came from building operational infrastructure to make encampments disappear permanently instead of temporarily." This is 100% BS. I drive past tent encampments every day. All that happens is the city comes in and disrupts the encampments so they are clear for a couple of days, and then everyone just returns. They have even started placing signs at the intersections where the people from the closest encampment under the bridge pan handle that discourages "street charity". If this is what is considered success, then it must be really bad elsewhere. At least on the west coast the homeless do not have to worry about the weather as much
- aprilthird2021 1y ago> If this is what is considered success, then it must be really bad elsewhere Yes, it is, lol...
- alberth 1y agoTexas still has its own struggles. "Tent cities" do still exist, regardless of what the article stated. And under bridges is still a common gathering point. But yes, to a way lesser degree than anything you'd find in CA.
- beardedwizard 1y agoThis is such a bad faith article, downtown Dallas is full of homeless and the cvs has everything locked up. If homelessness went down it's because they moved to CA. We do need more accountability for non profits though.
- rhubarbtree 1y agoI’ve been to more US states and cities than most Americans and every city I’ve been to has a severe homeless problem. Whilst it’s true that europe does have homelessness too, and it has gotten worse in recent years, it is incomparable to America. It doesn’t seem like a problem that can be fixed by some local policy or other. It’s a societal problem. America also has stratospheric levels of inequality, a terrible healthcare system, and lacks a functional welfare state. I do not think this is a coincidence. I’d much rather live somewhere more civilised, at the cost of higher taxation. It always irks me to see Americans taunt Europeans on social media about their lack of very large tech companies, whilst the Europeans are perhaps too dignified to point out the consequences of America’s hypercapitalism (such as homelessness, crime, and trump) in return.
- bz_bz_bz 1y agoWhat social media platforms do you use where Europeans are too dignified to point out the consequences of America’s hypercapitalism?
- Ylpertnodi 1y ago"Too dignified to point out...." That would be all social media platforms., then. Or [n]one.
- yardie 1y agoI remember a report about either SF or LA converting a parking lot to safe place for homeless and the mayor going on TV to show how proud they were this was a solution. I was flabbergasted. Because in no way would my SE coastal sensibilities regard this as any fucking solution to homelessness. It was literally a parking lot full of tents for the homeless.
- aprilthird2021 1y agoGood article. Very convincing. Even if the housing bit cannot be solved (NIMBY-ism in California is very strong) the other solutions should help. And there's no reason homeless people in SF or LA should stay in the most expensive housing areas of a completely Democratically controlled state
- temptemptemp111 1y ago[dead]
- bravetraveler 1y agoNot sure the whole of California can take the advice from subsets of Texas, considering the state of the intersections in Austin. The brushing-along still happens
- okkdrjfhfn 1y ago[flagged]
- okkdrjfhfn 1y ago[flagged]
- Psillisp 1y agoAgree with you. Too bad this argument is using the wrong terminology. To be acceptable to society, you either need to be willing to subjugate yourself for rent or be rich enough to own actual land. humans are no longer allowed a natural state.
- otikik 1y agoDidn't some cities "solve" the problem by buying homeless people bus tickets so that they go to SF? That is a system that "works".
- Psillisp 1y agohttps://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/is-relocating-homeless-people-a-life-line-or-broken-system https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/is-relocating-homeless-peo... Don’t forget to donate for the excellent journalism.
- gradientsrneat 1y agoThere was also that one time Texas claimed to have sent 100,000 migrants to San Francisco and other cities.
- j3th9n 1y agoFollow the money. Create a homelessness crisis, buy the cheap houses surrounding the tent cities and sell/rent them again for a bit/way more money when you fixed the crisis.
- estearum 1y agoThis helps too: https://gov.texas.gov/news/post/texas-transports-over-100000-migrants-to-sanctuary-cities https://gov.texas.gov/news/post/texas-transports-over-100000...
- Psillisp 1y ago100 degree plus days in summer Torrential rain Hail storms Hurricanes flash floods Houston is not a place to live outdoors.
- selimthegrim 1y agoNever stopped anyone in New Orleans or Miami.
- brewdad 1y agoDoesn't justify herding people up like cattle. Most of the US would be a miserable place to live at least 3-4 months out of the year.
- premiumLootBox 1y ago[dead]
- chaoticmass 1y agoNot really fair to compare the two geographic regions. Nobody wants to live on the streets in Dallas or Houston. It’s way too hot in the summer and too cold in the winter. That said, living in Dallas I have seen the odd tent city pop up under some freeway overpasses but they don’t stick around very long so I guess the city does do something about it.
- 6stringmerc 1y agoWhat the actual fuck? The homeless problem here in Dallas is at an all time high. I've been in and out of the Downtown proper for 20 years now. Completely unbelievable premise and not worth reading. Citation: I was recently homeless following a stint in jail on a bogus Felony charge, and still frequent some of the resources / areas where I got help. 24 Hour Club. Dallas Public Libraries. Tarrant County has a very good homeless program. They throw them in jail. Then let them out to do meth, then put them back in. They were my company in Lon Evans.
- codr7 1y agoDoes it look like they are even trying to solve the problem? Perhaps they're more waiting for the public to beg for permanent military presence. Create a problem for the solution you're looking to implement. I have no idea about California, but I do know that's how it works in Sweden.
- ckemere 1y agoI’m a bit confused about this. I live and work in Houston, and it seems like the number of apparently homeless panhandlers I see (specifically in the med center / NRG) area seems approximately constant over the last decade. Disclaimers- I don’t actually gather data. I don’t explore at night to see who is actually sleeping rough. I do get report from panhandlers that they need $20 to stay at the shelter…
- refulgentis 1y agoArticle comes across as complete slop, if written by a human hand. Articles thesis is "build working systems" and "who knows if we're getting rid of the homeless people and drug users or just moving them around"[1] and top comment here is "committees are annoying." [1] true! what's the next thought from there? :)
- Tiktaalik 1y agoInteresting article though it curiously deemphasizes what is likely the most significant reason for the differences in outcomes, which is that housing is more cheap and abundant in Houston/Dallas stemming from being easier and cheaper to build. (Yes this is mentioned, but it doesn't end up in the 5 point conclusion list). This passage for example. Houston can only achieve permanent placement if it actually has homes to place people in. SF is just rearranging deck chairs on the titanic because it has no where to put people and they're in and out of shelters. (Vancouver has the same issue) > Houston houses people first, then closes encampment sites permanently. San Francisco deploys enforcement first, achieves temporary displacement, and watches areas refill. Houston tracks every person from intake through permanent placement. San Francisco can’t determine if anyone is being permanently housed at all. Beyond better outcomes around creating new affordable housing if Houston and Dallas are also doing a also better job at keeping rents low and maintaining existing affordable housing that will also prevent people from becoming homeless in the first place. A recent study in Vancouver found that one of the most significant single causes of homelessness (20%) was people simply running out of money and being evicted. The direct cause of this is high rents. So any city that is building more housing in general, and not demolishing existing affordable rental is going to be doing a better job in this category at reducing homelessness.
- potato3732842 1y agoExactly. There's a lot less homeless when you aren't constantly lubricating the "miss one paycheck -> living in car -> seriously homelss" slope.
- infamouscow 1y agoTexas cities don't just stumble into better homelessness outcomes because they build more houses—though, yes, their zoning laws are less suffocating than California's bureaucratic strangulations, letting developers churn out homes while keeping rents from spiraling into the stratosphere. The real engine here isn't just policy, it's the stubborn, unapologetic religious underpinnings of Texas. Those churches you see in Austin, from non-denominational barns to Catholic sanctuaries, are the sinew of a community that doesn't bend to the fickle winds of election cycles. The faithful don't wait for a ballot to act—they feed, clothe, and stabilize the downtrodden with a doggedness that shames the state's tepid, vote-chasing programs. Why? Because they answer to a higher power than city hall, and their time horizon isn't the next electoral race. Contrast this with the secular cathedrals of the blue coasts, where government is God and every solution is a press release, not a commitment. SF's "enforcement-first" shuffle—clear an encampment, watch it refill—betrays a system that worships process over results. Texas' edge lies in cheap homes plus a culture that scorns the state's monopoly on virtue. The religious don't just build safety nets, they weave them into the social fabric, outlasting the transient schemes of politicians.
- nerdsniper 1y agoHouston has an absolutely massive amount of homelessness. It just also has tons of “null space” for them to exist invisibly. No one here walks or bikes so no one sees it only because they aren’t looking. Homelessness becomes a much bigger problem for society when homeless people cant find any space to be away from the public.
- gamblor956 1y agoTexas' official policy on homelessness and drug users for at least a decade was to buy them a bus ticket to California. Gov Rick Perry bragged about it in a presidential debate. His successor bragged about it in a gubernatorial debate. When the LA Times tried to survey the homeless population two years ago, fewer than 25% of the homeless in Hollywood were from California and none of them were locals. Want to guess the #1 state of residence for LA's homeless (Hint: it's Texas.) But this article is right: once LA started buying the non-local homeless bus tickets back to their real home cities, things started getting better in LA. It's now part of our current mayor's homeless strategy to convince people to go back home. Also: California defines homelessness differently (more broadly) than most states. Using the California definition, Texas, North Dakota, Florida, New York, and Oklahoma all have almost as many homeless. But when those states redefine homelessness to mean something narrower, of course they're going to look better. If California were to limit the "homeless" population to just Californians who became homeless (meaning that they owned, rented, or otherwise had housing before losing it), it would have fewer homeless than Texas.
- tiahura 1y agoMany of the country's druggies have migrated to druggie havens like California, Denver and Portland.
- insane_dreamer 1y agoGood points and centralized infrastructure does seem key , but I think the biggest factor is the cost of housing. If Houston is half the cost of LA you’re going to have a lot less homeless to begin with and it’ll be a lot more affordable to over then housing. This overlooks the weather factor. if you’re homeless and have the chance to get a bus to LA, would you rather try to survive in the streets of LA or Dallas (or Houston)? Easy decision.
- asacrowflies 1y agoDon't these places knowingly round up their homeless populations and bus them to "left wing" cities???