10 ms·
Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial area of Tolleson, AZ
https://www.theverge.com/news/790636/amazon-prime-mk30-drone-delivery-crash-arizona-pause https://www.theverge.com/news/790636/amazon-prime-mk30-drone...
- hn_throw_250926 1y ago[flagged]
- ge96 1y agodon't worry you'll get it back when it's restocked (returned items) my buddy bought these electric tooth brushes recently and the tips were missing inside ha, someone took them out and returned em
- waltbosz 1y agothey resold returned tooth brushes? eww.
- jacobgkau 1y agoRe-using the motor half of an electric toothbrush after a return doesn't seem egregious, but the fact that they didn't notice the tips were missing means they didn't even open them up to check their cosmetic condition, let alone clean them at all. I think that's the part that makes it bad, rather than reselling them itself.
- neom 1y agoLittle after 10am, pure speculation but wonder if the angle of the sun overwhelmed the dynamic range of the image sensor over a particularly inopportune area of the frame. Guessing no LiDAR on drones like this.
- oofbey 1y agoFine speculation. But they should be smart enough not to fly into their own blind spots e.g. the sun. They would tack back and forth I bet. They have a lot of tricks like this. I bet it has to be a confluence of factors. I hope Amazon reports openly what went wrong. FAA should demand it. Will be a very interesting report if we ever get to read it.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- testplzignore 1y agoThey should learn to shield their sensors with their hand and squint. Humans perfected this millions of years ago :)
- JCM9 1y agoGiven the severity of this it’s likely the NTSB will get involved, and Amazon’s ability to operate would likely be suspended pending a review of their operation.
- jampa 1y agoI wonder if they do a routine map of the delivery area (with a Lidar plane) so they have a high-resolution scan of the city for better pathing. But they didn't expect something like a crane that could be assembled so high and fast to be in the way.
- ooterness 1y agoWho could have predicted that drones flying outside during the day might have to deal with direct sunlight?
- LeifCarrotson 1y agoNo one could have known. And in Phoenix, no less, where it's famously overcast most of the time? Next you're going to tell me that a component overheated or clocked down for thermal throttling - preposterous, Phoenix is great for passive cooling! /s
- ge96 1y agoThe crash site is intriguing, want to see what tech they're using
- prein 1y agoI didn't even know they were using delivery drones yet. Why did they both crash, were they working in tandem carrying one payload or something?
- deadbabe 1y agoBeen using them for years, I got a package by drone the other day.
- Insanity 1y agoYeah but it’s in a pretty limited zone IIRC. Just some states and areas have it, and it’s definitely not yet a common practice.
- catlifeonmars 1y agoI was thinking maybe they used the same route planning system, so their routes were identical.
- dylan604 1y agoIf an amazon delivery drone uses the same route as a truck, what's the point of the drone? As a crow flies would be the point to be as direct as possible. Edit: Nevermind. I'm not awake yet. this logic does not compute. please ignore
- skygazer 1y agoWithout knowing anything about their routing, I think grandparent is saying they likely were on the same vector, perhaps same destination.
- dylan604 1y agowow, your interpretation is much better than whatever went through my head. i'm going with too early in the morning. not enough coffee.
- nuggetzs 1y agoOh man that Amazon paycheck gonna be huge.
- zenmac 1y agoWell thanks to tort reform likely not: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_Coffee_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_Coffee_(film)
- tamimio 1y agoThere were plenty of proposals back in 2021 about having highways in the sky for drone delivery operations, at least in Canada, so such incidents are avoided, as relying on technology alone isn't enough and the risk plans are only to mitigate rather than eliminate the risks. That being said, drone delivery will not really become a thing unless the endurance issue is resolved, like a new breakthrough battery technology that gives you at least 4 hours flight time (hybrid drones are noisy), as for any drone to have a proper impact, it should have three items checked: endurance, payload, and range. The last two are pretty much resolved by having modular payloads and flying over the internet, the first one is still pending.
- ge96 1y agoI thought this is a thing for autonomous vehicles carrying people at least I remembering seeing something with Honda
- tamimio 1y agoIt is for both, manned and unmanned, providing also a map of the network coverage in these “highways” and other active drones as well. I remember seeing a proof of concept platform that provided such functionality in Singapore, I am not sure if it became a reality later though.
- SketchySeaBeast 1y agoWhy is 4 hours a limit?
- tamimio 1y agoIt's not a limit, just from my personal exposure in the overall drone delivery, 3-4hrs would provide enough time with margin for any safe delivery, beyond that is definitely better but probably is too hard to achieve. Keep in mind the actual flight time will be less than that, accounting for payload weight and environment like wind and temperature. In cold weather like Canada, the batteries will consume some of their energy to heat themselves before taking off.
- xnx 1y ago[flagged]
- pixel_popping 1y agoAlternative working link: https://www.theverge.com/news/790636/amazon-prime-mk30-drone-delivery-crash-arizona-pause https://www.theverge.com/news/790636/amazon-prime-mk30-drone... 403 ERROR The request could not be satisfied. Request blocked. We can't connect to the server for this app or website at this time. There might be too much traffic or a configuration error. Try again later, or contact the app or website owner. If you provide content to customers through CloudFront, you can find steps to troubleshoot and help prevent this error by reviewing the CloudFront documentation. Generated by cloudfront (CloudFront) Request ID: 4nJBA53JFbgAlMjIy7AGSr8vdQd0NdIQCoCFvK67Mr-9yFUHlDpFJQ==
- dang 1y agoThanks, I've added that link to the toptext.
- mothballed 1y ago"Crane" is a highly optimistic word for what looks like a telescoping boom lift. Edit: per below was actually a crane
- mikeyouse 1y agoNah - at 0:35 into the video on the news page, you can see the crane they actually crashed into. There are boom lifts around, but they hit a proper crane. Pulled this link from the video but no clue how direct linking works with some of these weird sites; https://cf.cdn.uplynk.com/ause1/slices/14f/5c3d34b8b29a45469a86c02775b7a2cf/14fd60624b1548668bf1847fe8d5bc83/14fd60624b1548668bf1847fe8d5bc83_e.mp4 https://cf.cdn.uplynk.com/ause1/slices/14f/5c3d34b8b29a45469...
- mothballed 1y agoThanks! I took a quick look at the image in the article, and wrongly assumed they pictured the thing that it hit.
- stronglikedan 1y agoIt's a local news station who's targeting the lowest common denominator, so it's an acceptable usage in this case. EDIT: NM, it was a crane after all.
- jfengel 1y agoToday I learned: Boom lifts, available in various models such as mini scissor lifts for sale, spider lifts, and tracked scissor lifts, offer excellent mobility, flexibility, and cost-effectiveness for many tasks. Cranes, on the other hand, are essential for heavy lifting and large-scale projects. I also learned that "spider lifts" look like something a bad guy drives in a sci-fi movie.
- mrguyorama 1y agoBoom and bucket lifts all conveniently say "Do not use as a crane" It's so convenient to ignore too!
- bilekas 1y agoFrom their brief on the drones themselves: https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/transportation/amazon-drone-delivery-arizona https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/transportation/amazon-drone... > Our approval includes the ability to fly Beyond Visual Line of Sight, using our sophisticated on-board detect and avoid system. This is an historic, first-of-its-kind approval for a new drone system and a new operating location following a rigorous FAA evaluation of the safety of our systems and processes. It's true the FAA would have had to have signed off on these so that will be interesting.
- trollbridge 1y agoThe NTSB should be investigating, then.
- fakedang 1y agoMaybe the FAA let Amazon self-approve them. Business as usual.
- mattas 1y agoInteresting to me that _two_ managed to hit a boom lift.
- antonvs 1y agoBegun, the drone wars have
- jollyllama 1y agoTerrifying. Imagine being a roofer or other worker when a delivery drone knocks your ass off the n-th floor surface that you're working on. It wouldn't take much to get somebody killed in such a precarious situation.
- potato3732842 1y agoAny modern roofer or other worker that could fall far is wearing a safety harness (with some exceptions for flat roofs that have railing set up).
- jollyllama 1y agolaughs in independent subcontractor
- infecto 1y agoI am going to wager that 90% of resi roofers are not using harnesses unless the pitch of the roof is extreme. It’s all about the couch cushion.
- trollbridge 1y agoGenerally speaking you start doing that stuff once you get to 3 or more storeys, which is why residential mass builds are typically 2 or less. Workers’ compensation will specifically have job categories for work done on buildings 2 storeys or less, and it goes way up once you get to 3 (and even more for 4+). Even with all the gear, an unpredictable 80 lb object hurtling towards you is a major problem. Not to mention becoming a problem for any standing below.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 1y agoI had a chimney inspection and cap on my pretty steep pitched residential roof last year in MA on 2 story house. No harnesses that I saw. Wouldn’t be for me. Certainly harnesses and other safety gear are much more common in many situations.
- JCM9 1y agoFlying in uncontrolled airspace in VMC is a “see and avoid” environment, meaning this looks like a pretty bad screw up by Amazon. The fact that two different drones crashed into the same object raises even more serious questions on the quality of Amazon’s tech and their ability to safely monitor it.
- arbll 1y agowell at least it's consistent
- djtriptych 1y agoTwo drones doesn't really mean anything if they were following a similar flight plan to make a delivery at the same location right?
- BobaFloutist 1y agoIt means it wasn't a fluke or a bug specific to one drone, but something wrong in the overall software approach.
- promoterr 1y ago[dead]
- behringer 1y agowhen your account is blocked you've been flagged for fraud. Nobody's going to talk to you due to legal reasons. You just have to wait for them to either unblock you or until you die.
- jacobgkau 1y ago> when your account is blocked you've been flagged for fraud. Nobody's going to talk to you due to legal reasons. Devil's advocate, what are the "legal reasons" a human can't talk to someone whose account their company has blocked? Especially when the violation was apparently minor enough that it's only a 2-day temporary block?
- trollbridge 1y agoThere aren’t any “legal reasons”. There is a risk/reward calculation where a gigantic corp concludes the reward of 1 extra customer is less than the risk of 1 potentially problematic customer, so they perform the equivalent of exile.
- guerrilla 1y ago[flagged]
- potato3732842 1y agoYou're already gonna get screwed by your local government, your homeowners insurer, and all manner of other things on the basis of drone photography. That cat is already out of the bag. At least for the package delivery use case everyday people stand to benefit at least a bit.
- georgemcbay 1y agoI don't think people should shoot them down, but I do think drone-based delivery will be rejected by consumers if it ever reaches significant scale in non-rural areas which will create a self-limiter on growth of usage. Its cool if a drone delivers your sandwich. But when the sky is littered with them because they are also delivering random stuff to all of your neighbors it very quickly becomes a lot less cool. Never mind the fact that its concerning from a safety standpoint that one of the biggest players in the space has just proved (twice) that their drones can't even avoid a very large unmoving object.
- testdummy13 1y ago"but I do think drone-based delivery will be rejected by consumers if it ever reaches significant scale in non-rural areas" I'd wager it's the opposite: Rural areas would notice the one off noise of a drone flying overhead because humans notice novel sounds more. In an urban area you already have other significant sources of noise (traffic mainly) and if the drones are ubiquitous it might just be more of a background constant that people tune out.
- OJFord 1y ago> It's unclear if anyone was injured during the incident. 'It's unclear if' is a phrase that paints a brilliant picture of an organ's journalistic standing. It means there's no information either way, what follows is pure speculation, probably false, but the author can put whatever idea they want in our heads, since they've prefaced that it 'may or may not be the case'. It's unclear if the drones had malicious intent. It's unclear if the author was sober while writing and free of criminal record.
- sejje 1y agoI think they're just trying to get ahead of the question everyone wants answered, and they're saying they don't know yet.
- slashdave 1y agoHow about "there are no reports of injuries"?
- rtkwe 1y agoThat could be misread too though depending on when you're reading it and when you think the article was written in relation to the events. If it's a quick article right after it reads like the original verbiage but if you think it happened a while before the article was written it sounds more authoritative that there were no injuries. The "it is unclear" phrasing makes the ambiguity clear that the author doesn't know if there were any at the time of writing.
- anigbrowl 1y agoAnd if injuries are later reported people will sneer that 'media always gets it wrong/lies'. If they use plain language and say 'we don't know if anyone was injured yet' then people will sneer that 'I could have wirtten that, they're trying to sensationalize a nothingburger.'
- acka 1y ago
- amelius 1y agoBy the way, I see very little discussion on the drones used in the UA-RU war, which should be quite interesting from a hacker's perspective. Technology is going very fast there. Seriously, why is this downvoted?
- Etheryte 1y agoProbably because this thread is only remotely related to that? There's been countless discussions on the topic, doesn't mean every thread has to be about that.
- amelius 1y agoI mean on Hacker News in general.
- le-mark 1y agoI am personally working on intellectual property related to that. IMO this topic is impossible to discuss online, it’s a magnet for bots and troll farms.
- Etheryte 1y agoI don't really see what you mean, if you use the HN search Algolia provides, you can see people talking about it from different angles pretty much every day.
- amelius 1y agoStrange, because I never see it on the front page. Perhaps I should change the way I read HN. PS: I just searched, and indeed there is a lot of talk about incidents around drones. But what I mean is talk about the technology used in these drones. For example, how do you send a video feed through a kilometers long fiber optic cable that is cheap to produce and lightweight? These are the kind of questions I'm interested in.
- slashdave 1y agoAmazon engineer this morning to colleague: "Hey! Maybe we should include some cranes in our training data."
- blaufuchs 1y agoAs someone who has worked in AV perception this is unfortunately way too accurate lol, so much training set whack-a-mole
- andrewl-hn 1y agoLike, they may have trained on power lines, catenaries above rail tracks, network cables, etc. but all of them are horizontal. And the software couldn't recognize vertical cables or cables at an angle.
- reaperducer 1y agocables at an angle. With tens of thousands of guyed towers in the United States, that's a bad omission.
- barryrandall 1y agoI'm not looking forward to _that_ CAPTCHA.
- johntb86 1y agohttps://www.theverge.com/news/790636/amazon-prime-mk30-drone-delivery-crash-arizona-pause https://www.theverge.com/news/790636/amazon-prime-mk30-drone... gives more information, including that * No one was injured directly, but someone was treated for smoke inhalation * The drones "were flying back to back" * They hit the cable of a crane (including a link to a video showing the crane). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_ZpY6qHcTk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_ZpY6qHcTk
- cherioo 1y agoThe video also includes a video clip of package delivery, where drone would drop package to the ground, which worked. But then propeller blew the package right into the bush was lmao.
- perihelions 1y agoTimestamp for the ADHD's, https://youtu.be/E_ZpY6qHcTk?t=134 https://youtu.be/E_ZpY6qHcTk?t=134
- toast0 1y agoDrop and tumble helps reduce impact energy, might manage to keep the goods intact.
- mrguyorama 1y ago>someone was treated for smoke inhalation I'm mildly amused by this. It's an open air environment, did someone go stand over one of the crashed drones as it burst into flames and just, breathed deep? Glad they got treatment, plastic smoke is gross. Also wow, the drones are massive, and apparently flying so low they will hit cranes putting things on single story buildings? That's so stupid. Dear tech world: Please do not fly 80 pound projectiles just a few feet above my head at speed. Jeeze.
- Zigurd 1y agoGad. Zoox. I hope it's not the same team doing both.
- wavemode 1y agoSir, a second drone has hit the crane on 96th Avenue.
- hermannj314 1y agoHousehold ownership of cars hit 50% by 1930 but there was no federal seatbelt mandate unitl 1968 or regulation of intoxicated driving until the 1980s. Don't hold your breath waiting on the US government to give a shit about death and destruction of its people. Let the industry discover the tech and capitalist forces dictate safety, around 2060 we can start having serious conversations about drone safety. To any of the aspiring Ralph Nader's of the drone industry out there, thank you for your service in advance.
- oofbey 1y agoThe facts don’t line up with your concerns. Amazon announced prime air in what 2013 IIRC. Now 12 years later they have FAA approval for a small number of test flights. Exactly so they can slowly discover problems like this and fix them. Every safety critical system in the world is iteratively refined based on real world learnings about mistakes - mistakes made after careful design to avoid them. It’s just really really hard.
- Atheros 1y agoThe discover and fix phase is over. In August 2025, the FAA announced Part 108 which codifies the rules. Up until now, companies have been operating under waivers. The comment period for Part 108 ends on October 6th. After that the rules may be changed slightly and then will be finalized. https://www.regulations.gov/document/FAA-2025-1908-0023 https://www.regulations.gov/document/FAA-2025-1908-0023 You can select a few comments at random and quickly find a pattern: people are concerned that the drones everywhere except in the densest of areas do not have to see where they are going. If they hit a manned aircraft it's the manned aircraft's fault and the drone operator has no legal liability. Does that sound like something FAA employees wrote themselves? How much motivation will be there to "iteratively refine" when they have no legal liability and even admitting that a possible improvement exists would create legal liability?
- oofbey 1y agoWhat do you mean “the discover and fix phase is over”? That implies that safety critical systems stop trying to discover problems and fix them? In what world is that true? You are always learning from mistakes and fixing them. Forever.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 1y agoTo be clear, they crashed into the vertical cable hanging down from the end of the crane. Not into the structure of the crane itself. So it's not as bad as "they don't see cranes". But it absolutely raises the question of whether they can see cables, whether hanging from cranes or spanning telephone poles. And honestly, cables are really hard to see in the air. That's literally why high-voltage power lines hang those big red-orange marker balls on them for pilots to see. Genuinely curious what the solution here is. Hard-code some logic to identify cranes and always assume there's a cable dangling from the end? Never fly underneath anything? Implement some kind of specialized detection for thin cables if that's possible?
- delfinom 1y agoAmazon uses its lobbying powers to make it illegal to operate a crane without submitting an approval request to Amazon and paying a fee.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- JCM9 1y agoThat doesn’t make it better. The cable hangs down from the crane and thus the rest of the structure is still nearby. The drone should be well clear of any obstructions precisely to avoid this sort of thing from happening with hard-to-see ancillary obstructions. Something went really wrong here with the tech.
- jahsome 1y agoI'm genuinely curious what you'd define "nearby" and "well clear" as in concrete numbers. For the sake of clarity: I am not arguing against your point, nor am I defending Amazon or the tech in any way shape or form.
- lawlessone 1y agonot under it at a minimum lol
- tantalor 1y agoOnce is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. Three times is enemy action.
- hulitu 1y ago> Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial area of Tolleson, AZ What stupid crane flies into the path of delivery drones ? /s
- rkomorn 1y agoCommercial cranes, no less. They think they can compete with storks? Come on.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoTrying too hard to push a Jetson’s future on us that no one wants… I feel like soon kids will order the cheapest thing on Amazon for the free drone it comes with.
- AfterHIA 1y agoIf these things start hurting human workers I reserve the right to shoot them out of the sky.
- bronco21016 1y agoI spent some time searching the FAA NOTAM database... https://notams.aim.faa.gov/notamSearch/nsapp.html#/ https://notams.aim.faa.gov/notamSearch/nsapp.html#/ I can't seem to locate any NOTAMs indicating the presence of the crane. There are NOTAMs for a crane to the NNW of KGRY (Phoenix Goodyear Airport) but Tolleson is to the east of that airport. Is there a hole in how we're doing NOTAMs if we're expecting to have UAS operating at low altitude away from airports? Also, what other obstacle data is available? I know the US Gov't aviation maps depict significant man made structures that stick up like towers, windmills, and larger buildings. However, when you look at the NY Heli map, it's clear that not every building in Manhattan is depicted. These are generally low enough that a helo would be operating in see-and-avoid (VFR). Perhaps there is a new market available for this navigation data...
- jabroni_salad 1y agoI looked at the NOTAM guidance and they are simply not required if the crane's boom is lowered at night. Actually this pattern appears in a lot of NOTAM requirements. The FAA is permissive by default and they seem to think you don't need to report things that are 'visible'. Also, I dont think any of the equipment in this scene needs to be advertised to aircraft. None of this stuff is taller than a normal tree and we aren't filing NOTAMs for the presence of every public park, right? https://i.imgur.com/fmxVXQz.png https://i.imgur.com/fmxVXQz.png
- lamontcg 1y agoWe could have universal health care, but I guess we're going to get delivery drones instead...
- Animats 1y agoChina is way ahead here. There's now a Ministry of the Low Altitude Economy.[1] There's a Low Altitude Flight Service System, which is air traffic control for drones and flying cars. There are licenses for drone operators, categories of license, (advanced licenses require a flight exam), etc. China hasn't had much general aviation. There are very few private aircraft. So there was nothing like the US's FAA Flight Service Stations. Plans to change that started in 2018, as a new design, mostly automated. That system also handles drones above 120 meters, or is supposed to. [1] https://businessaviation.aero/evtol-news-and-electric-aircraft-news/low-altitude-economy/whos-who-in-chinas-low-altitude-economy-the-men-and-women-shaping-the-worlds-largest-low-altitude-economy https://businessaviation.aero/evtol-news-and-electric-aircra...
- rektomatic 1y agoChina is way ahead on what exactly? Regulation?
- Seattle3503 1y agoAn alternative way to look at this is they are (trying to) build the institutions that will pave the way for the success of the technology.
- Animats 1y agoFast food delivery in Shenzhen: Shipping end: [1] Receiving end: [2] Delivery is to a box like an Amazon delivery box. Here's the current list of delivery locations and how to use the app to order.[3] Weight limit 2.3kg. Delivery time 15 minutes. It's still rather limited. You can't have a delivery platform on your balcony yet. Mostly they deliver to parks and big open plazas. The Shenzhen city administration seems to be very drone-friendly. There are delivery drones. Advertising drones. Light show drones. Police drones. [1] https://wp.technologyreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Roof-workers1.mp4 https://wp.technologyreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/R... [2] https://wp.technologyreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/milk-tea1.mp4 https://wp.technologyreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/m... [3] https://shenzhentimes.com/how-to-order-takeout-by-drone-in-shenzhen/ https://shenzhentimes.com/how-to-order-takeout-by-drone-in-s...
- serf 1y agonice pictures. that fire proofing around all of the wires is neat, as is that bldc design with the integrated heat-sinks and the huge compute unit with the copper piping to external heat-sinks. very nice equipment before it was smashed to smithereens. it's rare to get a glimpse into this stuff internally. Similarly I wish Doordash would show what the Dot looks like under the bonnet so I don't need to wait for the inevitable collision pictures. The technical side of this emerging consumer-facing robotics thing just fascinates the hell out of me.
- bcrl 1y agoMove fast and break things doesn't work when safety is involved. Did a properly trained and licensed Professional Engineer review the design of Amazon's drones, their safety features and protocols before they got approval to fly outside of private testing facilities? If not, who would insure that hot mess?
- tt_dev 1y agoTwo Amazon deliver drones crash into a crane One drone says to the other: “They’ll do anything to stop us from unionizing” The other responds: “I just got put on PIP too…”
- cpgxiii 1y agoI think this is frankly the obvious consequence of the FAA inventing authority to allow commercial drone operations at low altitude (by "invented" I mean completely ignoring the precedent of United States v. Causby which establishes ownership of some airspace above one's property). Commercial drones are flying around at low altitude not because they should, but because they cannot safely share the airspace with other existing airspace users. The solution here is not more NOTAMs or specific hazard detection; the solution is having commercial drones get the hell out of other people's property (i.e. very low altitudes) and safely share the rest of the airspace with existing users.
- patrick451 1y ago> Genuinely curious what the solution here is. One obvious solution is to ditch drone delivery entirely. It's not a foregone conclusion that we must deliver trinkets by drone.
- johnnienaked 1y agoAmazon has assured us there is nothing wrong with the drones and they pose absolutely no safety hazard even though they crashed.