6 ms·
Scientists are rethinking the immune effects of SARS-CoV-2
- decremental 1y ago[dead]
- Animats 1y agoUh oh. We don't even understand "long COVID" yet. There's clearly a long-term aftermath, but it's not well understood. There are other diseases where that occurs, despite the initial infection seeming to be over. Chickenpox as a child can turn into shingles as an adult.[1] The virus is never completely cleared. [1] https://health.clevelandclinic.org/can-you-get-shingles-if-you-havent-had-chickenpox https://health.clevelandclinic.org/can-you-get-shingles-if-y...
- timr 1y agoPlease stop making this comparison. There's a clear reason why chickenpox can re-emerge as shingles later in life - herpesvirus maintains a circular chromosome within the nerve cells. It's a known feature of the virus family, and it's detectable [1]. There's absolutely no reason to believe that SARS-CoV2 has similar capability, and those who cling to this hypothesis are engaging in pseudoscience. Viruses are not so complex that we would trivially overlook a feature that would literally change the phylogenetic classification in a dramatic way. [1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5584196/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5584196/
- privatelypublic 1y ago> Viruses are not so complex that we would trivially overlook a feature that would literally change the phylogenetic classification in a dramatic way. You might think that, but in the past two decades theres been so many "how did we miss that?" in so many fields. I'll let field experts bring specifics up- I only know popularized examples like Roman Concrete. And the ever-easy Mars unit-conversion error.
- timr 1y agoYou can speculate if you like, but the claim you're advancing is fantastical to anyone who has studied virology, and requires an accordingly fantastic level of supporting evidence.
- privatelypublic 1y agoThe only claim I'm making is "never underestimate humanity's ability to hold to an initial assessment/viewpoint/assumption." Which has so many examples it's almost a truism.
- pessimizer 1y agoI assume, with this level of confidence, that we understand everything about Parkinson's now. It is a nerve disease so closely associated with influenza that there was speculation in the 60s that when the last child born during the Spanish Flu epidemic died, it would be completely eliminated as a common disease. Shouldn't we just look for the ring that we learned how to detect herpes in nerves? Because every virus has to be constructed exactly like herpes in order to infect nerve cells, apparently.
- privatelypublic 1y agoMight I suggest, instead of taking all the piss- to find an actual flaw in the given argument and highlight it with words?
- Animats 1y agoRight, chickenpox has a very different aftereffect mechanism. I'm just arguing against the popular "when it's over, it's over" position.
- PaulKeeble 1y agoHIV 10 years later turns into AIDs. Immune disruptions are especially scary because without an immune system the constant bombardment the human body is under from viruses, bacteria and fungi overwhelms us quickly. Finding Covid viral fragments in people long after the infection is very concerning, we don't know how its staying in the body or where but it seems likely its persisting.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoMeasles, too: https://arstechnica.com/health/2025/09/child-dies-of-horrifying-measles-complication-in-los-angeles/ https://arstechnica.com/health/2025/09/child-dies-of-horrify... Several variants of Malaria can be The Gift That Keeps On Giving: https://www.mmv.org/malaria/symptoms-and-treatments/relapsing-malaria https://www.mmv.org/malaria/symptoms-and-treatments/relapsin...
- timr 1y agoMalaria is not a virus. It's caused by a eukaryotic microorganism.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoI know. I guess that I should have mentioned that. However, from the article, it seems that they believe that COVID just whacks the immune system, in general, so everyone gets to belly up to the bar.
- timr 1y agoJust to be clear: "they", in this case, is a cherry-picked sample of scientists by a journalist.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoI think that's pretty much always the case, these days. Shouldn't be a problem, finding a cherry-picked sample to refute it.
- timr 1y agoRebutting this kind of stuff turns into a link-sharing competition. For any debated theory I can show you a thousand links saying the opposite of whatever claim is being advanced, but you'll just assume my links are self-selected. Look at the content of the article. Literally every quote in this piece is some scientist speculating. That's completely fine, and what scientists do, but the "journalist" is spinning it into a narrative of "scientists believe X", which is both true (some scientists can be found to support literally any claim), and misleadingly over-confident.
- btbuildem 1y agoIt's fascinating how unscientific ideas take root, because people want to believe. On the face of it, the idea of "immunity debt" is preposterous, yet it was amplified across the media -- perhaps because it was a convenient explanation that required no action from anyone.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoOne of my favorite cynical quotes, is: > "There's always an easy solution to every human problem; Neat, plausible and wrong." - H. L. Mencken
- bee_rider 1y agoWhy does it seem preposterous? If anything it seems dangerously not-preposterous, a sort of epidemiological “common sense” explanation. Lots of people experienced stuff like “getting chickenpox and then gaining immunity,” so the idea that not getting any illnesses for a couple years during lockdown would result in us being resistant to fewer illnesses seems not at all preposterous. Apparently general infection rates are still high, so it didn’t bear out. But preposterous? Not really…
- paulryanrogers 1y agoHaving had chicken pox twice, and read up on shingles, please get your kids vaccinated. Surviving an infection doesn't make us stronger, at least not at the individual level.
- bandiscordnow 1y ago[dead]
- nprateem 1y agoAs i heard recently. Severe acute respiratory syndrome. Something acute is severe by definition, but without the S we'd all be talking about ARS, so they added the Severe
- fluidcruft 1y agoI don't know what you are talking about definitions-wise here. Things can definitely be accute and not severe. This is easily resolved by looking at a dictionary.
- rzzzt 1y ago"acute" is paired with "chronic" and indicates onset, not severity.
- shawabawa3 1y agoPins and needles is usually acute, and harmless Chronic pins and needles should be checked urgently by a doctor as it's very serious
- PaulKeeble 1y agoIts important to note that Immunity debt is a concept that anti lockdown activists created in 2020. It was not in medical texts before that point, it never had any science behind it. It was a political term used to end mitigations against Covid not a scientific fact. There is no rethinking here from serious science (The BMJ is a really bad journal and one of the ones that supported this garbage), the science on infections has been clear for decades, every infection damages us. Covid especially so it damages the immune system directly suppressing CD4 and 8 T cells, B cells and other aspects. Its not a subtle change, in Long Covid research its become increasingly hard to find controls, many people without symptoms show the same blood based markers of immune dysruption and cognitive slowing.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- idontpost 1y ago[dead]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- timr 1y ago> Its important to note that Immunity debt is a concept that anti lockdown activists created in 2020. It was not in medical texts before that point, it never had any science behind it. It was a political term used to end mitigations against Covid not a scientific fact. No. It's a hypothesis, because nobody had any explanation for why flu "disappeared". You may not prefer that particular hypothesis, but that does not make it unscientific or political. In fact, doing what you're doing right now -- trying to present the hypothesis as activism in order to remove it from the realm of reasonable discussion -- is inherently political. > Covid especially so it damages the immune system directly suppressing CD4 and 8 T cells, B cells and other aspects. There is no good evidence for this claim. We have robust T- and B-cell mediated immunity to prior Covid infection, and there are now hundreds, if not thousands of papers showing it. Please stop. The general origin of this meme is the article linked in the piece, which, if you read the abstract you'll see is making a very limited claim about early infection, and cannot be used to support the notion that "Covid damages the immune system" in any long-term sense, particularly when we know the opposite is true from many, many other studies: https://academic.oup.com/jleukbio/article-abstract/116/6/1385/7762057 https://academic.oup.com/jleukbio/article-abstract/116/6/138... I don't like to resort to appeal to authority, but the article quotes Ashish Jha (hardly a Covid minimizer) as dismissing the "immune damage" narrative: > Ashish Jha, former White House covid-19 response coordinator under President Biden, has publicly rejected this hypothesis. “There’s a lot of bad information out there about how covid-19 damages the immune system. It really doesn’t,” he posted on X in early 2024. More than a year later, his view is unchanged. https://x.com/ashishkjha/status/1747412684889354266 https://x.com/ashishkjha/status/1747412684889354266
- alex1138 1y ago[flagged]
- privatelypublic 1y agoMaybe because "what the heck is rumble? Sure isn't a primary source."
- alex1138 1y ago[flagged]
- junto 1y agoIs it really a surprise? It’s full of half baked conspiracy theories. > The lizard-brain mentality trait is now easy to spot, plus those possessed cannot deviate from the exposed demonic global hive-mind narrative. Seriously?
- alex1138 1y ago[flagged]
- alex1138 1y agoI stand by what I said
- ahmedfromtunis 1y agoAs someone who is *not* interested in biology, I don't understand why this "immunity debt" is driving so much debate. If I understand Vox's definition of the term[0] correctly, this should be very easy to confirm or debunk. Why it isn't been the case yet? [0]: "A central premise of immunity debt is that for many infectious diseases, repeat infections are milder than the first infection."
- nomel 1y ago> A central premise of immunity debt is that for many infectious diseases, repeat infections are milder than the first infection. This is also the fundamental, well understood, mechanism of vaccines and herd immunity [1]: "Immunological memory" [2]. I think that sentence is very irresponsible. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity [2] Immunological memory: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immunological_memory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immunological_memory
- stefantalpalaru 1y ago[dead]