8 ms·
'Block Everything' protests sweep across France, scores arrested
- ktallett 1y agoFrance do protests and civil disobedience like no one else and I'm here for it.
- bell-cot 1y agoPretty much. I've seen it attributed to the legacy of the WWII French Resistance ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Resistance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Resistance ) or the Paris Commune ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Commune https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Commune ) or the Flour War ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flour_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flour_War ). But there's a lot more, and it goes much further back - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_incidents_of_civil_unrest_in_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_incidents_of_civil_unr... Perhaps France's ruling classes are especially inclined to ignore the concerns of the poor and working classes, and the latter often feel that forceful resistance is their only option?
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoFrance aggressively centralised its bureaucracy in the '89 Revolution. That may help disconnect Paris from its constituents more than in other systems.
- vdupras 1y agoAs Tocqueville writes in "De l'ancien régime et la révolution", centralization was already underway since Louis XIV, and heavily. Napoleon just picked up on it and continued the process.
- googlryas 1y agoDoes it lead to obviously better results in quality of life compared to people who don't riot quite so frequently? Is the average londoner worse off than the average Parisian? What about the average British person vs the average French person? I just pick the UK because it is nearby, approximately the same population and same GDP
- ktallett 1y agoI feel they can make a change through protest and it feels like an inherent part of their life that they get to protest when the government or officials have made a change that isn't what the people want. Whether it makes a significant difference is hard to judge without living there. Likewise who knows what life would be like if they hadn't protested. They have great working rights though, and a less stressful life in that respect so that is a positive.
- astrolx 1y agoAfter a long day out that started early, I can tell you that our riot police has no budget issues!
- oldpersonintx2 1y ago[dead]
- ThrowawayTestr 1y agoIf everyone protested like the French the world would be a much better place.
- baal80spam 1y agoIt would be a much poorer place, that's for sure.
- vdupras 1y agoYou'll see a lot more of the "dirt poor" class in american cities than in french ones. On that aspect, America is closer to third world countries than France.
- jonp888 1y agoWould it really? France has the lowest retirement age of any EU country, the second highest expenditure on social benefits, and a large debt burden. Raising the retirement age by a couple of years is obviously unpopular, yet arguably sensible - but trying to do that was what caused the last set of violent protests.
- BriggyDwiggs42 1y ago> France has the lowest retirement age of any EU country, the second highest expenditure on social benefits Right, exactly
- ricksunny 1y agoLove it. the previous two parent comments place the cognitive dissonance of Anglo-Saxon economic narratives in stark relief.
- tristor 1y ago> Love it. the previous two parent comments place the cognitive dissonance of Anglo-Saxon economic narratives in stark relief. For sure, the cognitive dissonance between those who understand basic economics and those who don't. Those who do understand that some of these facts are indicators of a coming crash, and the ones who don't think they're good because they like "free" stuff and don't understand how anything works or gets paid for. We can see where this goes, whether we want to or not, by watching France over the next two decades as it drives the leading edge of the upcoming long-term recession across all large Western economies.
- jonp888 1y agoI do wonder what the French population actually want as a solution to the unsustainable debt and huge proportion of tax revenue(second highest in the EU) spent on social benefits. Clearly they recognise a need for reform because they vote for politicians who run on a reform platform. Yet as soon as said reformer tries to change anything at all, it's back to the barricades. Reduce benefits? Riot! Increase tax rates? Riot! Extend the retirement age? Riot! Increase immigration? Riot!
- warkdarrior 1y ago> Increase tax rates? Riot! Somehow the tax rates for top 1% never go up.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> tax rates for top 1% never go up Genuine question: what is the effective tax rate on France's top 1%?
- bwb 1y agoincome tax is 45% on all income above 177,106 Euros
- Ruphin 1y agoThe effective tax rates on high income individuals is likely much less. There is a large correlation between income and wealth, and wealth increase through asset appreciation is largely not taxed, or at best taxed at much more favorable rates than general income tax. Tax on income is not the problem, it's tax on wealth gained through asset value increase.
- bwb 1y agoThat is why you have capital gains, which is ~30% in France. Investment income is flat taxed. And inheritance taxes, which are very high in France. If you want to increase taxes, consider taxing income more and capital gains at a progressive rate. Although I haven't seen good data on effects of say a 70% capital gain tax, might hurt th,e economy. I did some reading on this subject last month and the sweetspot was around 20% to 35% on that classification of income. Do you want to take people's wealth and cap it? IE, nobody is allowed more than $5 million? What are you advocating for instead?
- aurareturn 1y agoWealth inequality is causing many protests recently. Indonesia's protest was about wealth inequality where nepo babies flaunt wealth on social media while the poor are suffering. Exact same situation in Nepal. Seems to be the same generally in France even if the trigger for protests is not the same. The main theme is that these protests are led by Gen Z people. It's the younger generation that is hurting because they do not own real estate and stocks so they have not benefited from wealth creation via money printing and ZIRP era. My guess is that this will happen in the US soon as well. Entry level jobs are threatened by low investments due to tariffs, high interest rates, and the perceived notion that AI is taking their jobs. Young couples can't afford to buy a home to start a family because interest rates are 3x higher than a few years ago while home prices went way up since covid - not to mention ever increasing real estate tax, home insurance, etc. Now the tariffs will make everything much more expensive for the working class. Tariffs go into paying down national debt while the rich get a tax break via BBB. Tariffs disproportionally affects the poor. It's hard to be a 22 year old college grad right now. Not as bad as 2008 but definitely harder than in the last 15 years. PS. Everyone living in the west missed it but the 2019 Hong Kong protests were more about wealth inequality even if the trigger was the China extradition law. This was never mentioned in western media. I was living there during the protest. Young Hong Kongers felt hopeless because real estate prices to income ratio was the highest in the world at the time. By far. They didn't want to live in an apartment the size of an American bedroom with a family of 4 and spend a lifetime trying to pay it off - if they could even muster up the downpayment for it. Unlike Americans who can move to a more affordable city or state, young Hong Kongers had no where else to go. This pent up frustration for young Hong Kongers boiled over into months long riots.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoI suspect the big crash is coming within the next few years — and I think we've seen nothing yet. I've wrestled a bit with how to prepare financially for what could lie ahead but decided that there was really no harbor that is sure to be safe. I'm prepared to basically be poor and die from a thing that could have been prevented with some measure of health care. I'm usually an optimist by nature, but I've never been so with regard to the economy and the growing wealth inequality. There is no soft landing for either in my mind.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 1y agoNote that both the deficit and debt levels that are seen as so problematic in France are lower than American levels.
- xxpor 1y agoFrance doesn't control the Euro/ECB, so the situation is structurally different.
- saubeidl 1y agoThe French know how to do a proper protest. The US would do well to learn from them.
- alephnerd 1y agoWhen France eventually defaults because of the untenable fiscal situation, no amount of protests will move the IMF or ECB. Ask Greece.
- saubeidl 1y agoThen they better tax the rich and corpos.
- alephnerd 1y agoThey already have a 45% income tax above €177k, a 30% capital gains tax, a 36.2% real estate gains tax, and a corporate tax rate of 25% - much higher than their peers in the rest of the EU. The reality is France can't afford the status quo (in reality, only the expansion from 2005-25 was prolifigate) much longer. Under IMF or ECB receivership, taxes would rise AND social services would be cut. By cutting stuff today, they can at least minimize the pain from cuts.
- disgruntledphd2 1y ago> When France eventually defaults because of the untenable fiscal situation, no amount of protests will move the IMF or ECB. Protests won't work, but if they elect a government that wants to resist, then that government would have political power to force changes at the EU level, as they have a much larger vote bloc than Greece.
- alephnerd 1y ago> then that government would have political power to force changes at the EU level The ECB - like most central banks - is given completely autonomy from decisionmakers in the EU and EC. France's politician weight in the EU has little bearing on what the ECB or the IMF decides if France defaults. In 2006-07, Italy and Spain were similarly sized economies to France, but when they defaulted due to the Eurozone crisis, their entire autonomy on budgetary decisions was stripped despite also being large and (then) politically powerful nations within the EU. France needs to rightsize it's social benefits to be comparable to it's EU peers like Germany or Netherlands ASAP or they will be forced to with no say during a default.
- aynyc 1y agoAll I know is this. People keep on saying the economic model of what the French people want isn't sustainable. Is the US model sustainable? From all accounts, nope. So what do we do? Go back to communism? The funny part is, regardless of which social, cultural or economic model you want, the one that everyone hate is the inequality.
- icepush 1y agoAs long as the US retains the ability to control the supply of USD (Which France does not have over its own currency) the US model is sustainable.
- aynyc 1y agoIs the current situation in US sustainable? I don't see it. But again, we said the same for Japan for the last 3 decades and they still seem fine.
- icepush 1y agoAre you talking about the financial situation or something else? As mentioned above the financial situation is sustainable indefinitely because the US controls the printing of the dollar. Other situations might be sustainable or not, depending on what you mean.
- SantalBlush 1y agoIt could be stable in the US. The basic idea behind Keynesian economics is: during contractions, decrease taxes and increase spending; during expansions, increase taxes and decrease spending. Doing this helps smooth out business cycles, promotes steady growth, and collects revenue for the government. The problem is, as we've seen, our government is cutting taxes and raising spending no matter where we are in the business cycle. That's a very easy problem to solve, if there is the political will, but right now, there isn't.
- aynyc 1y ago
- honeybadger1 1y agoavoir le beurre et l'argent du beurre
- markstos 1y agoLooks like numbers for France's deficit and debt are similar to the US.
- mitchbob 1y agohttps://archive.ph/ms6aS https://archive.ph/ms6aS
- phoenixhaber 1y ago[dead]
- port11 1y agoI'd never advocate for the French level of rioting violence, but I hope we follow some of their footsteps here in Belgium. We're under the same pressure and have allowed an abomination of a neo-liberal government to take hold. I have some acquaintances complaining they will now have to pay a modest tax of stock purchases and capital gains. My, oh my… sorry about that, let's keep destroying the lower and middle classes instead. Belgium really could borrow a spine from its neighbour. We don't have one Macron, we have a small cabinet of 'em.