7 ms·
What Is Seen and What Is Unseen: The Hidden Price of Immoral Acts
- Xcelerate 14y agoVery good article! I think it really comes down to the fact that people can rationalize anything nowadays. Get 10 people in a room and they'll all disagree on what's right and wrong. You know, I always feel like deep down, everybody knows what is really right. Whenever you make a bad decision, you've just got to know that you're rationalizing why it's okay. How could you not? But maybe I'm wrong; I doubt that sociopaths and psychopaths have a true sense of right and wrong. There's stories of these people being in interrogation rooms and revealing all of the atrocities they've committed with no trace of emotion. It's only once they read the faces of their interrogators that they realize other people are horrified. And then they pretend to have remorse because it improves their own chances of a good outcome.
- yason 14y ago> the fact that people can rationalize anything nowadays. That's the whole point of rationalization. Rational process of thinking can be applied to anything, to choices deemed good or bad, much similarly to science which can be (ab)used for purposes deemed good or bad. Nobody can't make a decision based on pure rationalism because anyone half-skilled in rationalizing is able to counter-argue his own argument down. Rational thinking is a valuable tool to gain insight into things but only a fool thinks he can solve dilemmas of good vs. bad with it. Ethics itself is a product of a mind and what mind does is always rational.
- mooism2 14y agoYou seem to be confusing rationalisation with rational thinking. Rational thinking involves making logical deductions from a set of objectives and constraints to determine what actions to take. Ideally some of the constraints will be ethical, and perhaps some of the objectives will be emotional. Rationalisation involves coming up with reasons to justify a decision that has already been made for other reasons. Perhaps the real reasons do not satisfy the person's conscience. Perhaps the real reasons will not persuade other people. Perhaps the real reasons are emotional and not rational. But the process of inventing these reasons is not allowed to challenge the original decision.
- stephengillie 14y agoVery good article! I think it really comes down to the fact that people can rationalize anything nowadays. Get 10 people in a room and they'll all disagree on what's right and wrong. We know what happens when we put 12 angry men in a room.
- MartinCron 14y agoLegendary acting performances?
- tristanj 14y agoA few years back, coach Angel Heredia did an interview with Spiegel on the same topic in which he alleges many of today's world-records would be impossible without PEDs. There's a translated version below, but note that at the time of interview, he under investigation for supplying illicit drugs to athletes, and his responses are mildly tainted by personal agenda. Translated Spiegel.de article: http://www.sherdog.net/forums/f13/angel-heredia-interview-sports-doping-1927491/ http://www.sherdog.net/forums/f13/angel-heredia-interview-sp... NY times discussing the investigation: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/13/sports/13doping.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/13/sports/13doping.html?_r=1&...
- scotty79 14y ago> This is the problem with cheating across the moral landscape: it’s robs others of their possibilities. If 1000 guys compete, only 1 wins the possibilities, 999 of them will be robbed of their possibilities regardless of whether the winner cheats or not. Don't plan (let alone invest significant portion of you life and health) on 1/1000 ratio. You have more or less that chance of dying next year. Do you plan on that?
- mooism2 14y agoNo, if the winners didn't cheat to get there, then the others have not been robbed of their possibilities.
- yason 14y agoFrom doping to trading, the tragedy is that people take it so seriously and thus turn it into a life-and-death game of all-or-nothing. Taking things seriously robs any chance to just be good enough and be happy about that. Anyone who can complete Tour de France at all or moderately but steadily grow an investment portfolio over the years should be extremely satisfied with just that already. If you're not, you'll seek greater but less likely and more momentary satisfaction from winning to win, and you'll likely end up more miserable in the average.
- ddfisher 14y ago> Anyone who can complete Tour de France at all or moderately but steadily grow an investment portfolio over the years should be extremely satisfied with just that already. (I'm not certain what "should" means in that sentence - a moral judgement? - but I'll interpret it as advice.) I think that this is excellent advice for some people, but poor advice for others. I don't think there is anything wrong, per se, with wanting to be the very best at something. There's just a trade-off: you can be happily excellent, or you can take a chance and be perhaps the best but most likely just unhappy. But this decision is, in my opinion, a personal one: happiness does not have to be the ultimate goal of life.
- yason 14y agoYour interpretation is correct: I wrote it as an advice, not a judgement. Whenever in doubt, prefix the original sentence with "In my opinion, " and internet comments start making a whole lot of sense.
- chii 14y ago> I don't think there is anything wrong, per se, with wanting to be the very best at something. Its probably obvious, but everyone wants to be the very best at something (or even everything?), even though of course its unrealistic, so most people disregard that desire almost immediately after thinking of it. However, there are a minority that feel they can be, and when they realize they mightn't be, they cheat to do so, at the cost of others. And that's what i think is the real crux of the problem.
- cerebrum 14y agoWhat is not seen is that for this homo sapiens to be writing this book his ancestors had to cheat themselves for him to be here. Killing off the Neanderthals and whoever/whatever stood in the way is how humankind got here. I think his observations are correct but the conclusion wrong. Cheating is the way to go but unfortunately this cannot be said out loud. Homo Hypocritus(hat tip to Robin Hanson) at work here.
- chii 14y agoI m not sure that cheating "is the way to go" - you are right in the sense that there is no such a thing as cheating in nature. But this very reason is why humans had to have civilization - otherwise, the lives of each individual would be brutal and paranoid. To me, cheating is like achieving a local maxima, whilst full cooperation, when cheating would give an individual a slightly better pay off at the cost of the whole, is achieving a global maxima.
- sneak 14y ago"Thou shalt remember the Eleventh Commandment and keep it Wholly." --Heinlein
- ubernostrum 14y agoIt's not possible to "cheat" at natural selection, because it's not a thing and doesn't have rules; it's just a mathematical fact that's true. And, like the other reply pointed out, human societies have systems of rules because the results are worse when they don't (to stretch your example, a species which consumes or destroys too much of a limited resource dooms all its members, whether they "cheated" or not).
- cerebrum 14y ago> It's not possible to "cheat" at natural selection You are right but the same can be said for winning in contests. The only real rule is "to win" all the rest are social contracts that you can break if you can get away with it. In that sense the smarter, more capable more hypocritical individuals will win, so yes, you are selecting for those same traits. I take objection with the author for his moral preaching.
- hasker 14y agoI take issue with how this article represents Lance Armstrong's doping as a fact. He never tested positive. From what I understand, someone just testified that they saw him shooting up with something. Who knows what Lance and his team really did or did not do. The US Anti-Doping Agency was out to get him, and from what I understand, the burden of proof is so low that they can get anyone they want. I also do not understand how the affordability of top doping experts is any different than affordability of top coaches and nutritionists. The author claims that only the top 25% can actually compete legitimately since top doping specialists cost a lot. Top coaches likely do also. I think these two points weaken the authors points tremendously, when I somewhat agree with is point. He just needs better examples.
- davidjohnstone 14y agoActually, he has tested positive. On multiple occasions. There was a urine test he failed in 1999 that he got out of with a backdated prescription. More controversially, it has been alleged that he failed an EPO test in 2001 that Hein Verbrugghen (then head of the UCI) made disappear. Coincidentally, Armstrong donated $125,000 to the UCI at this time. Also, 1999 TdF samples of his have recently tested positive to EPO (they didn't have an EPO test back then), but those positives didn't count because the testing was done for research purposes. It's rather cynical, but http://cavalierfc.tumblr.com/post/30172302298/its-not-about-the-bike http://cavalierfc.tumblr.com/post/30172302298/its-not-about-... is worth a look.
- yread 14y agoIf anyone has any doubts about doping in cycling I recommend reading about Christoper Bassons http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bassons http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bassons a professional cyclists who was bullied out of cycling for speaking against doping (also by Armstrong).
- james1071 14y agoPerhaps you mean well, but you have not got a clue what you are talking about. Armstrong has not tested positive for EPO, HGH or anything similar. The allegation about the prescription drug incident is completely irrelevant. Whether he has in fact taken PEDs is another question.
- ma2rten 14y agoAre the rich and famous happier than the rest? I think the average professional cyclist might be less happy then the average plumber, even without doping. Think of all the pressure, knowing that you career will have to end soon, still not being the best, dealing with the press, etc. In my mind, Cyclist Joe might be lucky to have become Joe the Plumber instead.
- spindritf 14y ago> Are the rich and famous happier than the rest? Generally, yes, though not as much as expected. See http://www.bakadesuyo.com/who-is-happier-billionaires-amish-the-homeles http://www.bakadesuyo.com/who-is-happier-billionaires-amish-... or https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:www.bakadesuyo.com/would-you-be-happier-if-you-were-rich https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:www.ba... for example.
- bdunbar 14y agoAt least one rich guys says 'yes'. I forget the exact quote by Dave Ramsey - who has been rich, then poor, then rich again, said something like 'People tell you being rich sucks. Nu-uh.' One can be rich and unhappy, and poor and happy. This is not news. But .. having been poor myself (and then middle-class) having money to pave over the small bumps in life makes it a whole lot easier to be content.
- brudgers 14y agoI am so disappointed by American cyclists doping that I will no longer watch cycling on TV. The benefit is that I now have more time to watch (American) football.
- james1071 14y agoYes, watch the boys on roids.
- fghh45sdfhr3 14y agoCan't tell if joking....
- api 14y agoThere's an alternative interpretation here: that the heights of human achievement are not available "cleanly." Truth be told, there's a lot of doping in other fields. I've hung around startuppers, scientists, and med students who heavily use racetams, modafinil, amphetamine, B12 megadosing, "stack" diets, and massive amounts of caffeine. Musicians and artists use psychedelic drugs to artificially enter hyper-creative states. Isn't that a form of doping? Would we have most of the music we have if there were no THC, psilocybin, or LSD? And doping is just augmentation. A bicycle itself is an augmentation. Shoes and special clothing are augmentations. The list goes on. A race where runners run almost naked and are strictly limited to a straight diet would be interesting in itself, but it would not achieve anywhere near Olympic performance numbers. I'm not necessarily saying that doping in sports is good, per se. If the rules don't allow it in your event, you are cheating in your particular sport. (There are no such rules for startups, science, or music.) What I'm really getting at here is that there is another issue, and that the overall issue is more morally complex than "honest and clean" vs "doped." I also know that doping can destroy your health. Those modafinil/amphetamine stackers in the startup world might be shortening their life spans. LSD and psilocybin can make you go nuts. Steroids can cause cancer, heart disease, and mood disorders. But what if that's the price for exceeding the records?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mh_ 14y agoIt almost makes me sad that this comment wasn't explored deeply enough. It raises an awesome point that is often ignored. You could do this simply: a pure tour de France and a doping-ok tour de France. (would ppl tune in for the purity of the sport when times start to lag the open division?) Recent sporting questions raised during the Olympics (when is a runner a female?)(or how do you differentiate between awesome Nikes, prosthetic legs or hyper prosthetic legs?) all fundamentally challenge our concepts of "fair"
- jonathanjaeger 14y agoI don't think the musician/startup analogy works. Regardless of the legality of using certain drugs and prescriptions, sports players are competing against each other for a certain output. Musicians and entrepeneurs are creating a product, whether it be music or a company, that stands alone irrespective of the lengths they went to achieve that creation. The people consuming that product aren't suffering because someone else did the drugs, unlike the cyclist who is competing against a doped up competitor or the investor who doesn't do insider trading like others do.
- james1071 14y agoSo Tyler Hamilton has got a book out. What a joke.
- rnernento 14y agoReally well written and really depressing.
- mikecane 14y agoFor Want of a Nail (proverb) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_Want_of_a_Nail_%28proverb%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_Want_of_a_Nail_%28proverb%2...
- mikecane 14y agoFor Want of a Nail (proverb) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_Want_of_a_Nail_%28proverb%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_Want_of_a_Nail_%28proverb%2...
- notaddicted 14y agoReminds me of a piece that I read on Marc Andreessen's blog back in 2007. Now I see that it was written by Ben Horowitz. I'm almost embarrassed to admit it how long it took me to find this, like 10 minutes. Anyway, quoting: "Once WorldCom started committing accounting fraud to prop up their numbers, all of the other telecoms had to either (a) commit accounting fraud to keep pace with WorldCom's blistering growth rate, or (b) be viewed as losers with severe consequences. How severe were the consequences for not breaking the law? Well, like a baseball player who refuses to take steroids, CEO Mike Armstrong of AT&T did not keep pace with the cheaters. As a reward for his honesty and integrity, he was widely ridiculed in the press prior to being fired and AT&T, perhaps America's most valuable brand, was acquired for cheap. Now you see why Barry Bonds needed something to help him keep pace with Mark McGwire." http://web.archive.org/web/20090621225533/http://blog.pmarca.com/2007/06/ceo-crime-punis.html http://web.archive.org/web/20090621225533/http://blog.pmarca...
- api 14y agoThere is a difference between financial fraud and doping. The latter can actually increase performance, while the former only appears to on the surface. Lance Armstrong actually is faster. WorldCom was not, in fact, doing any better than AT&T and may have actually been doing worse.
- aaron695 14y agoI think we need context here, these are just people going around in circles on a track. Their object is to entertain, and that they have in more ways than one. This concept sport people are anything more is a sad reflection on society. The technology and methods they spend billions on developing are mostly useless to the normal world. Even movie technology builds on itself and makes better movies, sport technology just shaves 100ths of a second off records, what is the point. It's forgotten by all but diehards 10-20 years later. At least a good movie or book lasts hundreds of years. To say sport is more than that is quite sad I feel, people need to get over pretending it that important.