5 ms·
Every well funded startup I’ve worked for went through a period where employees could get nearly anything they asked for: New computers, more monitors, special
by Aurornis 1y ago
Every well funded startup I’ve worked for went through a period where employees could get nearly anything they asked for: New computers, more monitors, special chairs, standing desks, SaaS software, DoorDash when working late. If engineers said they needed it, they got it.
Then some period of time later they start looking at spending in detail and can’t believe how much is being spent by the 25% or so who abuse the possibly. Then the controls come.
> There is abuse. But that abuse is really capped out at a few thousand in laptops, monitors and workstations, even with high-end specs,
You would think, but in the age of $6,000 fully specced MacBook Pros, $2,000 monitors, $3,000 standing desks, $1500 iPads with $100 Apple pencils and $300 keyboard cases, $1,000 chairs, SaaS licenses that add up, and (if allowed) food delivery services for “special circumstances” that turns into a regular occurrence it was common to see individuals incurring expenses in the tens of thousands range. It’s hard to believe if you’re a person who moderates their own expenditures.
Some people see a company policy as something meant to be exploited until a hidden limit is reached.
There also starts to be some soft fraud at scales higher than you’d imagine: When someone could get a new laptop without questions, old ones started “getting stolen” at a much higher rate. When we offered food delivery for staying late, a lot of people started staying just late enough for the food delivery to arrive while scrolling on their phones and then walking out the door with their meal.
- master_crab 1y agoThere also starts to be some soft fraud at scales higher than you’d imagine: When someone could get a new laptop without questions, old ones started “getting stolen” at a much higher rate. When we offered food delivery for staying late, a lot of people started staying just late enough for the food delivery to arrive while scrolling on their phones and then walking out the door with their meal. Ehh. Neither of these are soft fraud. The former is outright law-breaking, the latter…is fine. They stayed till they were supposed to.
- Aurornis 1y ago> the latter…is fine. They stayed till they were supposed to. This is the soft fraud mentality: If a company offers meal delivery for people who are working late who need to eat at the office and then people start staying late (without working) and then taking the food home to eat, that’s not consistent with the policies. It was supposed to be a consolation if someone had to (or wanted to, as occurred with a lot of our people who liked to sleep in) stay late to work. It was getting used instead for people to avoid paying out of pocket for their own dinners even though they weren’t doing any more work. Which is why we can’t have nice things: People see these policies as an opportunity to exploit them rather than use them as intended.
- master_crab 1y agosoft fraud mentality This isn’t about fraud anymore. It’s about how suspiciously managers want to view their employees. That’s a separate issue (but not one directed at employees).
- Aurornis 1y agoIf a company says you have permission to spend money on something for a purpose, but employees are abusing that to spend money on something that clearly violates that stated purpose, that’s into fraud territory. This is why I call it the soft fraud mentality: When people see some fraudulent spending and decide that it’s fine because they don’t think the policy is important. Managers didn’t care. It didn’t come out of their budget. It was the executives who couldn’t ignore all of the people hanging out in the common areas waiting for food to show up and then leaving with it all together, all at once. Then nothing changed after the emails reminding them of the purpose of the policy. When you look at the large line item cost of daily food delivery and then notice it’s not being used as intended, it gets cut.
- master_crab 1y agoThis might come as a bit of a surprise to you, but most (really all) employees are in it for money. So if you are astonished that people optimize for their financial gain, that’s concerning. That’s why you implement rules. If you start trying to tease apart the motivations people have even if they are following those rules, you are going to end up more paranoid than Stalin.
- Aurornis 1y ago> This might come as a bit of a surprise to you > So if you are astonished that people optimize for their financial gain, that’s concerning. I’m not “surprised” nor “astonished” nor do you need to be “concerned” for me. That’s unnecessarily condescending. I’m simply explaining how these generous policies come to and end through abuse. You are making a point in favor of these policies: Many will see an opportunity for abuse and take it, so employers become more strict.
- baq 1y ago> individuals incurring expenses in the tens of thousands range peanuts compared to their 500k TC
- Aurornis 1y agoVery few companies pay $500K. Even at FAANG a lot of people are compensated less than that. I do think a lot of this comment section is assuming $500K TC employees at employers with infinite cash to spend, though.
- hellisothers 1y agoBut at the FAANGy companies I’ve worked at this issue persists. Mobile engineers working on 3yo computers and seeing new hires compile 2x (or more) faster with their newer machines.
- alt227 1y agoIf they care that much about compile time, they would work on a desktop instead of a laptop.
- bigtechennui 1y agoThen the company would issue a desktop and a laptop, since they want engineers to be able to use computers in places other than their desk.
- alt227 1y agoYep, but then the laptop just becomes a screen and keyboard and can be the cheapest on the market. Remoting into your desktop to code is much more efficient than actually coding on a laptop, especially if you care about compile time. Then you can even set something compiling, shut your laptop and jump on your bike home, and have it done by the time you get there!
- LevGoldstein 1y ago
- incone123 1y ago$3,000 standing desks?? It's some wood, metal and motors. I got one from IKEA in about 2018 for 500 gbp and it's still my desk today. You can get Chinese ones now for about 150 gbp.
- Aurornis 1y agoThe people demanding new top spec MacBook Pros every year aren’t the same people requesting the cheapest Chinese standing desk they can find.
- incone123 1y agoI can understand paying more for fast processors and so on but a standing desk just goes up and down. What features do the high end desks have that I am missing out on?
- dcrazy 1y agoStability and reliability.
- ffsm8 1y agoStability is a big one, but the feel of the desk itself is also a price point. You're gonna be paying a lot depending on the type of tabletop you get. ($100-1k+ just for the top)
- incone123 1y agoMine is very stable. Top is just some kind of board. It took a bit of damage from my cat's claws but that's not a risk most corporate offices have.
- dcrazy 1y agoWhat price point did you buy at? I paid a premium for my home height-adjustable desk because the frame and top are made in America, the veneer is much thicker than competitors, the motors and worm gears are reliable, and the same company makes coordinating office furniture. The same company sells cheap imported desks too. Since my work area is next to the dining table in my open-plan apartment, I considered the better looks worth the extra money.
- Aeolun 1y agoDon’t you think the problem there is that you hired the wrong people?
- jayd16 1y agoMaybe so but it's not like that's something you can really control. You can control the policy so that is what's done.
- spyckie2 1y agoBasic statistics. You can find 10 people that will probably not abuse the system but definitely not 100. It’s like your friend group and time choosing a place to eat. It’s not your friends, it’s the law of averages.
- michaelt 1y agoWell partly, yes. But also, when I tell one of my reports to spec and order himself a PC, there should be several controls in place. Firstly, I should give clear enough instructions that they know whether they should be spending around $600, $1500, or $6000. Second, although my reports can freely spend ~$100 no questions asked, expenses in the $1000+ region should require my approval. Thirdly, there is monitoring of where money is going; spending where the paperwork isn't in order gets flagged and checked. If someone with access to the company amazon account gets an above-ground pool shipped to their home, you can bet there will be questions to be answered.
- SteveJS 1y agoWas trying to remember a counter example on good hires and wasted money. Alex St. John Microsoft Windows 95 era, created directX annnnd also built an alien spaceship. I dimly recalled it as a friend in the games division telling me about some someone getting 5 and a 1 review scores in close succession. Facts i could find (yes i asked an llm) 5.0 review: Moderately supported. St. John himself hosted a copy of his Jan 10, 1996 Microsoft performance review on his blog (the file listing still exists in archives). It reportedly shows a 5.0 rating, which in that era was the rare top-box mark. Fired a year later: Factual. In an open letter (published via GameSpot) he states he was escorted out of Microsoft on June 24, 1997, about 18 months after the 5.0 review. Judgment Day II alien spaceship party: Well documented as a plan. St. John’s own account (quoted in Neowin, Gizmodo, and others) describes an H.R. Giger–designed alien-ship interior in an Alameda air hangar, complete with X-Files cast involvement and a Gates “head reveal” gag. Sunk cost before cancellation: Supported. St. John says the shutdown came “a couple of weeks” before the 1996 event date, after ~$4.3M had already been spent/committed (≈$1.2M MS budget + ≈$1.1M sponsors + additional sunk costs). Independent summaries repeat this figure (“in excess of $4 million”). So: 5.0 review — moderate evidence Fired 1997 — factual Alien spaceship build planned — factual ≈$4M sunk costs — supported by St. John’s own retrospective and secondary reporting
- dcrazy 1y agoIs it “soft fraud” when a manager at an investment bank regularly demands unreasonable productivity from their junior analysts, causing them to work late and effectively reduce their compensation rate? Only if the word “abuse” isn’t ambiguous and loaded enough for you!
- WalterBright 1y agoYour employer being unreasonable is not an excuse to defraud him in return. Negotiate for better conditions. If agreement cannot be reached, find another job.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- AtlanticThird 1y agoLying about a laptop being stolen is black and white. I'm not sure how you are trying to say that is ambiguous. I don't know what the hell you mean by the term unreasonable. Are you under the impression that investment banking analysts do not think they will have to work late before they take the role?
- margalabargala 1y ago> Lying about a laptop being stolen is black and white. I'm not sure how you are trying to say that is ambiguous. I've been at startups where there's sometimes late night food served. I've never been at a startup where there was an epidemic about lying about stolen hardware. Staying just late enough to order dinner on the company, and theft by the employee of computer hardware plus lying about it, are not in the same category and do not happen with equal frequency. I cannot believe the parent comment presented these as the same, and is being taken seriously.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoNah the laptop and the dinner are exactly the same, they only differ in timing. You can steal $2000 by lying about a stolen laptop or lying about working late. The latter method just takes a few months.
- kev009 1y agoNetflix, at least the Open Connect org, was still open ended adjacent to whatever NTech provided (your issued laptop and remote working stuff). It was very easy to get "exotic" hardware. I really don't think anyone abused it. This is an existence proof to the comment parents, it's neither a startup and I don't see engineers screwing the wheels off the bus anywhere I've ever worked.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- lukan 1y ago"$1,000 chairs" Not an expert here, but from what I heard, that would be a bargain for a good office chair. And having a good chair or not - you literally feel the difference.
- locusofself 1y agoErgonomics is definitely something to skimp on!
- WalterBright 1y agoI've been using the same $25 chair I bought 45 years ago. I've always thought the "ergonomic chair" was a scam.
- kelnos 1y agoI think ergonomic chairs are good for people who have poor posture. If you have a strong core and sit up straight all the time, you can probably sit on just about anything and be fine. (I'm not saying you're wrong. I think the real solution is that people should take better care of their physical selves. Certainly there are also people with particular conditions and do need the more ergonomic setup, but I expect that's a small percentage of the total.)
- lukan 1y agoWell, I do lot's of sport and can sit comfortable on hard ground meditating for quite some time. I still enjoy a good chair way more than something "normal" for any longer computer sessions.
- WalterBright 1y agoIf a chair is too comfortable, I just fall asleep in it. It doesn't make me work better. A chair isn't any answer to poor posture. The answer is exercising your core muscles, being aware of your posture, and constantly correcting it.
- necovek 1y agoIf $20k is misspent by 1 in 100 employees, that's still $200 per employee per year: peanuts, really. Just like with "policing", I'd only focus on uncovering and dealing with abusers after the fact, not on everyone — giving most people "benefits" that instead makes them feel valued.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoSo then just set a limit of $200 per head instead of allowing a few bad apples to spend $20k all on themselves.
- necovek 1y agoThis was extra on top of whatever the average cost really is for employees who are not abusing the system. So, if other engineers get their equipment for $6k (beefed-up laptop, 32" or 30" 5k widescreen screen, ergonomic chair, standing desk — in theory amortized over 3-10 years, but really, on the retention period which is usually <3 years in software), we are talking about an increase of $200 on that. Maybe not peanuts, but the cost of administration to oversee spending and the cost to employees to provide proof and follow due process (in their hourly rate for time used) will quickly add up and usually negate any "savings" from stopping abuse altogether — since now everybody needs to shoulder the cost. Any type of cap based on average means that those who needed something more special-cased (more powerful machine, more RAM vs CPU/storage, more expensive ergonomic setup due to their anatomy [eg. significantly taller than average]...) can't really get it anymore. Obviously, having no cap and requiring manager approval is usually enough to get rid of almost all abuse, though it is sometimes important to be able to predict expenses throughout the year.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoYou could just have an average cap and require manager approval above that.
- engineer_22 1y agoThe effect on morale shouldn't be ignored tho either
- SCLeo 1y agoWhere do you even get the $3,000 standing desk? I am don't even compare prices and I got mine from Amazon for $200-$300. Sure the quality might not be the best but I just can't see there are people buying $3000 standing desks.
- criemen 1y agoThis desk (used to?) fit the budget, for example: https://www.architonic.com/en/p/holmris-b8-milk-classic-1070912/ https://www.architonic.com/en/p/holmris-b8-milk-classic-1070... Essentially, you pay a lot for fancy design.
- kelnos 1y agoEarly in the pandemic I bought a decent motorized standing desk for $520. It's nice, but I could very easily imagine a desk that costs 6x that. I would never buy that desk, but some people go for that sort of thing.
- skinkestek 1y ago2 things: 1. My brothers (I have a number of them) mostly work in construction somehow. It feels most of them drive a VW Transporter, a large pickup or something, each carrying at least $30 000 in equipment. Seeing people I work with get laptops that use multiple minutes to connect to a postgres database that I connect to in seconds feels really stupid. (I'm old enough that I get what I need, they usually rather pay for a decent laptop rather than start a hiring process.) 2. My previous employer did something really smart: They used to have a policy that you got a basic laptop and an inexpensive phone, but you could ask for more if you needed. Which of course meant some people got nothing and some people got custom keyboards and what not. That was replaced with a $1000 budget on your first day an $800 every year that was meant to cover phones and everything you needed. You could alsp borrow from next year. So if someone felt they needed the newest iPhone or Samsung? Fine, save up one year(or borrow from next year) and you have it. Others like me who don't care that much about phones could get a reasonably priced one + a gpod monitor for my upstairs office at home + some more gear. And now the rules are the same for everyone so even I get (I feel I'm hopeless when it comes to arguing my case with IT, but now it was a simple: do you have money for it? yes/no)
- mpyne 1y ago> It’s hard to believe if you’re a person who moderates their own expenditures. Yeah, it's hard to convey to people who've never been responsible for setting (or proposing) policy that it's not a game of optimizing the average result, but of minimizing the worst-case result. You and I and most people are not out to arbitrage the company's resources but you and I and most people are also not the reason policy exists. It was depressing to run into that reality myself as policy controls really do interfere sometimes in allowing people to access benefits the organization wants them to have, but the alternative is that the entire budget for perks ends up in the hands of a very few people until the benefit goes away completely.
- swat535 1y agoSeriously? You can't budget an extra 10-20k for hardware upgrades for the Software Engineer that you are paying 300k a year for ? Plus, not to mention the return on investment you get from retaining the talent and the value they add to your product and organization. If you walk into a mechanic shop, just the Snap On primary tool kit is like 50k. It always amazes me that companies go cheap on basic tools for their employees, yet waste millions in pointless endeavors.