6 ms·
Modern Cars Wreak Havoc on Radar Detectors
- steve_gh 1y ago...or you could drive sensibly within the speed limit.
- gwbas1c 1y agoWhat fun is that? That being said, "speed culture" varies a lot from state to state. Where I live it's assumed and expected that you will speed, and in other areas you can get a ticket for going 1 over. The legal and cultural ambiguity means that someone who is unsure of the real, enforced, culturally-accepted speed limit may want to use a radar detector.
- rogerrogerr 1y agoYup, in Idaho you’re pretty much expected to do +5. I swear they figure out the proper speed and subtract five from it. Going the speed limit will get you run over.
- devilbunny 1y agoMake the speed limit sensible, and I will. I don't speed in Europe because 130 km/h is a perfectly fine limit; I've driven faster on uncontrolled Autobahn segments, but I'm not bothered when there is a limit. 65 mph on the NJ Turnpike (and only on the southern part) is not.
- yugioh3 1y ago65mph is plenty fast. going beyond 70/75 is diminishing returns in the safety of other drivers, not to mention worse greenhouse emissions. a crash at 80+ is so much worse than one at 65. and American highways are not the Autobahn. different design and engineering.
- rafram 1y agoIf anything, American highways are wider and straighter than the Autobahn.
- dangus 1y agoBut they are less well maintained and with fewer safety features, built to a lower cost per mile. Being straighter is actually bad for safety (highway hypnosis). You’ll find long stretches of interstates with no guard rails as well as state highways with direct intersections with rural roads.
- dkiebd 1y ago[flagged]
- dotancohen 1y agoThe energy (damage) of a crash is proportional to the square of the speed. Therefore a crash at 80 units per hour has over 1 and a half times the amount of energy, and thus one and a half times the damage, as one at 65 units per hour.
- dangus 1y agoThat limit is completely reasonable on the NJ turnpike especially considering that the cultural norm is to go 5-10 mph over. American speed limits are determined with the expectation of drivers going over. In other countries the limit is more literal. No cop is going to ticket you for going 70-75 on the turnpike.
- devilbunny 1y ago> No cop is going to ticket you for going 70-75 on the turnpike Unless it's the end of the month and they have to meet quota and blah blah blah... Australia seems to get away with ruthlessly enforcing ridiculously low speed limits. The correct speed limit, by your own comment, seems to be 75 (120 km/h) at least.
- amanaplanacanal 1y agoIn my town you don't get a ticket unless you are going 10mph over, and this is on surface streets. They might be stricter in the 20mph school zones though.
- seanmcdirmid 1y agoSometimes the speed limit is set to lower the accident rate on a particular piece of road. Like those 30 MPH curve warnings on a mountain road. Even in straight shots the amount of traffic could make 80 MPH significantly more dangerous than 70 MPH.
- HeyLaughingBoy 1y ago...on the long (9 miles to the next town), straight county road just by my house with a 50 mph speed limit that sees maybe 1 car per minute on average. There's a reason that the average speed there is 65mph+
- bsder 1y agoThen set the limits properly at the 85% mark. And ban speed limit fines from going into local coffers.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoDare I ask what the 85% mark is?
- amanaplanacanal 1y agoThere was a rule at some point that the way to set a speed limit was to measure the speed of cars using that road, and set the limit so that 85% were under and 15% were over. I don't know how much this is actually used any more. From a safety point of view the proper way to do it is to decide up front what speed limit you want on that road, and then design it so that drivers feel unsafe going over that speed. If you have to have a sign telling drivers to slow down, you designed the road wrong.
- toast0 1y agoThat's the basic standard for a traffic survey, which is sometimes required for enforcement. California has a speed trap law that prevents accepting radar evidence of vehicle speed unless the speed limit was set by a recent traffic survey, on a local road or school zone, or the limit is 65 for cars and 55 for trucks. Maybe some other exceptions. I 100% agree on build the road to result in the behavior you want. Speed limit signs have some effect, but narrow lanes are much more effective.
- m463 1y agohttp://m8y.org/bloomcounty.jpg http://m8y.org/bloomcounty.jpg
- The_President 1y agoThere are back roads out there that drop 15 mph at the state line with no population around for miles. Detectors offer peace of mind for travel at a leisurely self-determined rate.
- marssaxman 1y agoWhich one is it, driving sensibly or driving within the speed limit?
- Spivak 1y agoYeah the internet it weird about speed limits for some reason meanwhile the moment you drive on real roads in the US you lean very quickly, even explicitly if you did in-cars in driver's ed, that the posted speed limit is the minimum.
- dangus 1y agoIn the places where it’s like that, enforcement is lax and you’ll never need a radar detector. In the other places, it’s very simple to sit in the right lane and you won’t be going wildly slower than the rest of traffic. There are always trucks and governed vehicles on the road that are going the speed limit that you can swim through the stream with. I used to be in the camp of defending the legality of radar detectors, and really I don’t think they need to be legal, but at the same time the only people buying them are dangerous assholes who treat public roads like their personal race track. It takes at least one ticket to pay off the investment which means radar detector owners intend to be repeat offenders.
- dmd 1y agoThere are roads here that “feel” like a 35 or even 45mph road. The speed limit is 7. Yes, 7. It’s purely for local revenue.
- vasco 1y agoCan of spray and a night off and they all become 70
- gwbas1c 1y agoIf anyone's still reading this: As I read this, I think it makes more sense for the police to replace radar with a high-resolution camera and a computer that can determine speed of vehicles. Any thoughts on that?
- EA-3167 1y agoIt's hard to find exact stats because of how procurement and statistics works across jurisdictions, states, etc... but from what I CAN find it seems that LIDAR is more common than Radar these days. Over the whole country it looks like a slight majority lead for LIDAR, but in some (quite populous) states they almost only use LIDAR (PA for example had 93% of their tickets come from LIDAR, and I believe most of the rest used speed cameras or 'clocking' rather than RADAR). Sources: https://www.legis.state.pa.us/WU01/LI/TR/Transcripts/2018_0045_0002_TSTMNY.pdf https://www.legis.state.pa.us/WU01/LI/TR/Transcripts/2018_00... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lidar_traffic_enforcement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lidar_traffic_enforcement https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/lidar-speed-enforcement-weapon-choice https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/lidar-sp...
- toomuchtodo 1y agoLIDAR can't be used in motion, the LEO has to be stopped to be pointing it. Your laser detector will warn you, but it's already too late at that point; my two cents is using Waze/Google LEO alerts is state of the art at this point (until someone starts multilateration of patrol cars using their radio RF emissions and SDR networks).
- bob1029 1y ago> LIDAR can't be used in motion To be clear, the reason for this is because the width of the beam requires aiming it like a sniper rifle, not because we can't compensate for operator motion.
- misswaterfairy 1y ago
- The_President 1y agoLotta miles using radar detectors -- they detect 3 different bands of radar and some "detect laser." Radar detectors are great insurance, and more useful on the open highway than they are in town, but I've not seen a vehicle give off Ka band emissions that wasn't law enforcement. I have noticed that newer Honda cars set off the K band, which is also used by a lot of the cheap lightpole "your speed" I've seen. Very rarely still I will see X band speed radar being used in the middle of nowhere where the cop cars are older. Radar detector users just learn to ignore the X and K band alerts while simultanously learning a subconscious quarter second brake reaction time based on the Ka band noise.
- dreamcompiler 1y agoExactly. I haven't encountered a cop using X band since the 1990s. All X band signals I see now are door openers at grocery stores. And yeah, a K band zap in the middle of nowhere usually means there's a Honda nearby.
- burnt-resistor 1y agoLast time I had a detector (a remote Bel Pro RX75 Plus with laser jammer that works), I turned off X band because of incessant false positives. With just K and Ka (and laser), almost all detection were legit. Radar detectors on the windshield look dumb, clutter the windshield, and encourage ticket-writing by offending some cops with fragile egos. Remote detectors or go home.
- yugioh3 1y agogood. speed kills. off highways, speeding is particularly dangerous for pedestrians, cyclists, and other drivers.
- unshavedyak 1y agoI just wish cops would actually do that more frequently. My local interstate is basically only trapped during a small window a day, easy to memorize. I don’t blame people for speeding when we care so little as to actually monitor and enforce. Especially when it’s easy to automate.
- LtWorf 1y agoIf you've ever driven in italy you know that velocity is normally measured in a 100km/h road, right after a 20km/h sign that was there for no other reason than to fine people. For bonus points the sign can be hidden behind a bush or can be so old and faded nobody knows what it says.
- Dylan16807 1y agoI'm pretty sure the context here was not off highways.
- nathanaldensr 1y agoNo, speed differential kills.
- margalabargala 1y agoWhen someone is talking about speed in a car, they are always talking about speed differential, vs the earth.
- rafram 1y agoIf the person in front of you has to brake hard or swerve to avoid an obstacle, your speed differential with them can very quickly become equal to your speed. If there’s a stationary object on the road, your speed differential is always equal to your speed. In many circumstances that cause deadly accidents, speed differential vs speed is just pedantry.
- aussieguy1234 1y agoThese detectors have been illegal in Australia for as long as I can remember. But with apps like Waze and TomTom Amigo, I probably don't need them. I can see where all the speed cameras are and police get reported on the map fairly quickly (I also contribute to these reports, let's subvert government power together)
- dreamcompiler 1y agoThere are quite a number of areas in the rural US where there's no cell coverage. In these places Waze won't help you, but radar detectors still work.
- kjkjadksj 1y agoWhat are the odds a cop is taking up a radar position in a place without cell service today? These guys famously play Pokemon Go and other games on call.
- elric 1y agoInstead of radar, more and more places are installing ANPR (aka ALPR) cameras here. They measure how long it taked you to drive between two locations, if it's faster than the speed limit, the fine will find you. Tiny Belgium already has more than 5k ANPR cameras. Predictably, the system is being (ab)used for all kinds of monitoring and tracking on top of speed enforcement. And in a certain sense, all those irresponsibly fast drivers with radar detectors are partially responsible for the further erosion of privacy on the road.
- Dylan16807 1y agoIt sure doesn't sound like those systems were built to go after irresponsibly fast drivers.
- elric 1y agoThat was their original intent, but of course, once you have a dense network of cameras that can sort of reliably track individuals, people find all sorts of other uses for them.
- Dylan16807 1y agoYou're sure it wasn't largely to milk fines from people going slightly over? What was the initial threshold for fines? What is it now?
- prmoustache 1y agoNobody is milked. The rules are simple and trivial to follow. Those that are fined are really asking for it. An upper limit is not the desired and accepted speed everybody needs to aim for.
- Dylan16807 1y ago> An upper limit is not the desired and accepted speed everybody needs to aim for. I agree entirely. But while you seem to be thinking about the situation where the speed limit is higher than the natural safe speed range people would intuit without a sign, often it's significantly lower. That's a bad way to design roads and speed limits. In pedestrian areas restrict the roads more, and in non-pedestrian areas let people go a good pace on straight dry roads. > Nobody is milked. The rules are simple and trivial to follow. Those that are fined are really asking for it. How much over is your threshold for "really" asking for it? If it includes people going 2-3 over then I very much disagree.
- wolfi1 1y agoin most of Europe these detectors are forbidden, I tend to drive within the speed limit, much safer
- technick 1y agoAll of that noise is K band and soon to be spread out across 77 ghz, outside of the bands being used by law enforcement (for now). If you take high velocity seriously, I recommend getting a Uniden R9 and a ALPriority Laser Jammer system. Then add in a dedicated android tablet running Highway Radar, you'll be a hard target to target. Also get a pair of binoculars (bonus points if they're thermal). I haven't had a speeding ticket since 2018, before I had my tools. Just this week I was averaging 120 mph across Utah, turned my 11 hour trip into 8 hours.
- cowthulhu 1y agoMy understanding is that in most jurisdictions a laser jammer is a magic device that transmutes a speeding ticket into a complementary trip to jail
- nathanaldensr 1y agohttps://www.automoblog.com/are-radar-detectors-legal/ https://www.automoblog.com/are-radar-detectors-legal/
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- kjkjadksj 1y agoSpeed tickets are very unequally enforced. Last time I saw speeding enforcement plotted on a map, most states were broadly the same of hardly any enforcement. However, Ohio was the striking standout by iirc a full order of magnitude to the nearest peer.
- secabeen 1y agoThat has been the pattern for years; before people demolished the Cannonball run record during COVID, getting through Ohio clean was one of the biggest challenges.