5 ms·
Let's stop pretending that managers and executives care about productivity
- fatbird 1y agoAs I keep mentioning, I worked as a contractor inside Honeywell for 5+ years. My experience of my immediate team was mixed: some very good people, some total morons. My experience of the organization was uniformly terrible. Absurd company-wide requirements for security checks, code quality verification, financial controls. Insane restrictions on product development to use X technology or integrate with Y unit's product. Billions wasted on their IIoT play that got rebooted after several years (and the billions I saw wasted wasn't its development, it was moving everyone in the company onto and off it again ["offboarding"]). In that time, the stock price went up, and Honeywell went back on the Fortune 100. Just zero relationship between productivity or effectiveness within the company and the stock price.
- whatshisface 1y ago>Just zero relationship between productivity or effectiveness within the company and the stock price. Losing billions of dollars doesn't keep you off the Fortune 100, only losing billions of dollars more than the other companies people could invest in.
- lotsofpulp 1y agoNominal stock price going up does not mean anything (nor does Fortune 100), it could just be a function of the decreasing purchasing power of the currency. 5/10/15/20 year annual Honeywell returns are 9.74/10.29/14.03/11.78%. SP500 is 14.69/13.80/14.42/10.57%. I would characterize Honeywell as treading water until 2011, and since then they have been losing. https://dqydj.com/stock-return-calculator/?ticker=HON https://dqydj.com/stock-return-calculator/?ticker=HON https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/ https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/
- kenjackson 1y agoThey do care about those things. But it turns out that stock price and profits often turn on “bigger” things than productivity. Google didn’t win search because they were productive. Nor did Tesla win EVs due to it (and they won’t lose EVs due to the lack of it). There are some spaces where productivity does matter. My uncle runs a painting company. It’s all about productivity, costs, and customer acquisition. HeAl’s not waiting on new markets or innovation to fundamentally change how he makes money (although tech has improved productivity). He’s made it for the same way for the past 30 years.
- whatshisface 1y agoIf there's an action that would lower the price per share by 10% but raise an individual's stock based compensation by 12%, every executive in the world would take it.
- SoftTalker 1y agoGoogle and Tesla both won by being vastly better than the competition. After they won, perhaps their motiviations changed.
- snapcaster 1y agoBut they didn't win by being marginally more productive than competitors
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoTesla was iterating and innovating way faster on the SW and HW front with less R&D resources, than the stablished German or Japanese players. By that metric, they were significantly more productive. Stock market is a gambling game that has little to do with actual productivity, it's about convincing other fools to pay more for the stock than you did so that you can make a profit and leave them holding the bag.
- marcosdumay 1y agoLet's not pretend that the productivity gains from the stuff on the article are marginal.
- lapcat 1y ago> They do care about those things. The article author argues that companies enforce policies that are manifestly unproductive. Do you have a counterargument, or evidence that they do care?
- zdragnar 1y agoThe article incorrectly conflates "cares about productivity" with "cares exclusively about productivity". SWE salaries are a massive cost. Improving productivity is one way of offsetting that cost. The examples provided for "don't care about productivity" are things like open office plans- where a certain amount of productivity is sacrificed while offsetting a different cost (building space). Yes, it is fair to say that managers and executives do not care about productivity to the exclusion of all else. It's something of a pointless statement, though, as I don't think anyone actually thinks that.
- burnte 1y agoGood ones really do and they work hard to enhance the productivity of their workers. I always say to my people that my job is to make their jobs easier, and to a large degree that's true. There are other types who prefer the power trip, or that if you're a bad manager then your job is pretty easy, etc. But GOOD execs actually do care quite a lot. I tend to tangle with HR over salaries because I'd rather hire a handful of really good people for 15% above market and get double the productivity than a lot of people at or below market. This article is confusing the corporate raider mindset rampant in big public companies with the genuine growth mindset most companies actually have. Everyone focuses on productivity and costs, enshittification only happens when you're near enough of a monopoly you can afford to squeeze your customers. Most companies can't do that and most companies try to just keep improving. Don't look at MS or Exxon and think that's who most companies actually work. That's just the beginning of the end stage of a megacorporation's life.
- jdefr89 1y agoUnfortunately It seems most companies only purport to have "growth mindset" In my experience, at least now, the author nails the issue right on the head. You have executives with a dogma that ultimately means controlling others... I see little proof the opposite is true.
- burnte 1y agoI don't see that generally. It's mostly only in huge corps, not mid and small size companies, the types that make up the majority of world employers.
- jackero 1y agoMaximizing productivity comes from maximizing efficiency. Efficiency is about sitting down and analyzing your tasks holistically and doing min-maxing to ensure every process achieves its greatest result. Now ask yourself this: how often do people do this at all? Pretty much never. Most of us only do it when you have to, because you aren’t making enough money, because your application is slow, because you can barely meet budget, or because you are trying to land on the moon and failing costs too much.
- boothby 1y ago> Efficiency is about sitting down and analyzing your tasks holistically and doing min-maxing... Accurate analysis depends on accurate data. Which is why some people I know are required to account for their work activities in 7-minute increments, have frequent and detailed meetings to account for progress, project planning, etc. Actually, doing that analysis has a cost that must be discounted from any perceived gains of efficiency, to be truly efficient. One learns to tolerate some waste to avoid the ultimate time-suck. To say nothing of maintence and sustainability -- if you're always sprinting, you're doomed to fall.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Sevii 1y agoFor factory optimization they didn't ask people to track their hours at 7 minute intervals. They put a camera on them and analyzed what they did over an entire shift. Then they redesign the factory line to optimize things. Having people manually track time has far more overhead and is less accurate in general. In practice I've never seen a software org take estimates or time tracking seriously beyond "Track your hours in 15 min increments against tickets".
- 7952 1y ago7.5 would be nicer as it fits into sixty minutes!
- 1y ago
- paulcole 1y ago> There’s obviously a financial bubble in full force. If it’s so obvious, figure out how to bet against it, get rich, and never have to worry about productivity again. > The environmental impact is real. If every LLM disappeared tomorrow, the environment is still equally fucked as it is today. “Think of the environment” is the second most mindless appeal to emotion argument against anything other than “Think of the children.”
- jgeada 1y ago"The market can remain irrational longer than you can stay solvent" -- John Maynard Keynes
- TheAmazingRace 1y agoIt's why I just invest in indexes and not sweat it. Yeah, I won't make big bucks like some day traders do if they get lucky (like one guy I saw make $50k on an option contract for RDDT with just a few grand of starting capital), but that's just too nerve-wracking for me.
- paulcole 1y ago[flagged]
- Buttons840 1y agoSomeone who is extremely skilled at trading stocks, and consistently out-performs the market, while having access to a median amount of money, is going to earn like $10 an hour. Most people don't have access to enough money to begin profitable trading. Most people don't have a realistic option to even try trading.
- paulcole 1y agoI would think that someone who is absolutely sure we are in the middle of a massive bubble would do everything in their power to bet as much as possible against it. Because they are absolutely sure that we are in the middle of a massive bubble, they surely can’t lose, right?
- moc_was_wronged 1y agoLarge language models have their place, but they’re quite limited and no real substitute for human intelligence or judgement at its best. That said, abusive corporate environments (and they’re pretty much all abusive) turn people into automatons. Execs can thus wave LLMs around and say, “Look, you’re so useless a machine can do your job.” And even then it does a shitty job. It misses special cases and causes messes. But it’s cheap in the short term, which is all that matters to the boss’s career. Things will go to shit in a few years, but if you’re good at executive social climbing, you are three promotions away from your bad decisions by the time anyone figures out that’s what they were.
- jdefr89 1y agoIt's ironic because the executive aspects of the job are easily the ones almost anyone can do. I say that as someone who has created and sold startup with a couple friends. We had to take on the role of both engineers and executives. Guess which one was far far easier and which one actually mattered?
- nine_k 1y ago> which one was far far easier and which one actually mattered? Let me guess: the engineering was easier and more pleasant, and what mattered was sales?
- tptacek 1y agoThe author has twisted themselves into a weird pretzel trying to tie a broad societal critique about short-termism to day-to-day line management. Your manager almost certainly does care about your productivity; in fact, the more biting critique is probably that they care too much about it, working to juice output in the short term while paying short shrift to downstream consequences.
- add-sub-mul-div 1y agoSounds like the same argument. They don't care about true productivity, they want the appearance of it, the illusory short term gains of AI.
- knallfrosch 1y agoA genie offers you either: You're 50% more productive, or you appear 50% more productive. What would _you_ choose?
- beng-nl 1y agoI don’t see the dilemma - if you want to appear 50% more productive, why not actually be 50% more productive too? Or do you mean being more productive doesn’t automatically translate to it being visible.. yeah that is a tricky one..
- fcatalan 1y agoThat guy that doesn't even show up might be just playing videogames... Or maybe taking credit for your work over a coffee with the boss of your boss
- eptcyka 1y agoUnless further elaborated, why would one assume that being 50% more productive will not appear as being 50% more productive?
- 1y ago
- taeric 1y agoThe pretense here is that we actually know what leads to long term progress? As much as it pains people to admit it, short term results are often far more predictive of long term results than any other single data point. Is it perfect? No. Of course not. But having a team that is just willing to show up and work towards a goal is such a leg up over any other thing that we know that it is painful to see it argued against. Will there be some people that make progress in leaps? Absolutely. Most of that progress will be taken up and incorporated rather quickly in the places that also employ the teams that just show up.
- NickM 1y agoThe trouble is that making progress in leaps is often mutually exclusive with being productive in the short term. It’s hard to think big and plan long-term when you’re constantly overwhelmed with what’s in front of you. Slow Productivity by Cal Newport talks about this trade-off extensively and provides interesting points of reference where real famous historical figures achieved incredible things in ways that would seem slow and lazy by modern standards.
- taeric 1y agoBut that is part of my point. This is not actually the conflict. Progress by leaps is often only possible in places that are also making repeated incremental progress. It is tempting to think of this in terms of sports. As an easy example, home runs make larger impacts for teams that are good at getting people on bases. Of course, you can argue that baseball has a ceiling on how much you can make from a single home run which is not true for most businesses. But even sports somewhat miss one of the main things that is hard to communicate. What feels like small progress is often needed just to stay afloat. I suppose the sports nature of it would be that you have an offense and a defense, usually. In business, that daily short term progress would be the defense. It is frustrating, because we do want to focus on the big ideas. But so many of the big ideas needed a TON of little ideas around them to be viable. And by nature, when we discuss one as a thing that we want, we almost necessarily ignore the other. We can really only focus on one thing at a time.
- Buttons840 1y agoThis, again, makes me question what meaning individual workers should find in work. Ideally (level 3, the best), I could work with good people on something that I personally care about, like curing childhood cancer or something. This is the type of work I would do even if I wasn't paid, although I couldn't do as much without pay. The meaning is obvious. This type of job is rare though, so I can't reliably expect to find this level of meaning in work. But maybe (level 2), I can work with good people towards making a company profitable. Helping an honest company be profitable for the mutual benefit of all the good people I work with is meaning enough for me. But companies often ask individual workers to do stupid things, or a company is not open to hearing ideas about how to be more successful from individual workers. So I can't reliably take personal meaning from making the company profitable, because the company isn't interested in hearing my ideas about the business, and/or is acting is self-destructive ways, and/or the companies profits are completely disconnect from anything I personally do. But maybe (level 1), I can find meaning in making my boss happy. This is hell, this is a pathetic meaning for work, but making the boss happy is at least something. But often my bosses are not good people (about 50%). I've seen what makes them happy and I don't want to be that. So, (level 0) I guess the only meaning I have left is to make money. If this is really the meaning behind my work, then I see no reason to not cheat and lie at every opportunity, while being careful to avoid consequences. If earning money really is the deepest meaning I should seek in work, then lying and cheating will help me with this--let's go full psychopath mode! On HN people often say that level 2 is the right attitude, but companies do things that are self-destructive, so I cannot maintain level 2. Level 1 and level 0 are stages of hell. What meaning do you find in work? What level are you?
- HPsquared 1y agoThen there are levels of meaning in "making money". Are you feeding the family, or paying student loans for a course you didn't use? Etc etc
- serial_dev 1y ago> a company is not open to hearing ideas about how to be more successful from individual workers I got happier when I realized this and accepted I’m just a cog. Before realizing this, I’d want to make sure people understand my viewpoint, argued and reasoned, then got frustrated when I got ignored. The realization came when I worked for a very small startup where, while being 33% of the company (first employee to the two founders), my ideas and warnings were continuously ignored. So more I’m close to your level 0. Focus on making enough money to support my family and humble financial goals, try to work on interesting projects, build my resume, and make sure I can leave when things inevitably turn to sht. Sure, if I strongly disagree with something and I believe there is a chance my feedback will make a difference, I’ll give it once, if I get ignored I just move on.
- didibus 1y agoA bit tangential, but I've wondered with AI where is the growth? If you want to move up the stock, cost cutting is good, to some extent, but it has limits, competition can become more fierce, and the whole thing can become a race to the bottom, you cut cost, than you're forced to cut margins, and now you are no less profitable. Growth requires new products, new markets, for people to spend additional money, to acquire more customers, etc. A few companies are growing because their product is AI, so that's going to be new money coming in from people who want AI in itself. But for those using AI?
- marcosdumay 1y agoThe one coherent theory I've heard is that the growth will come from all the new tasks done by the new software that we will have due to the severely increased programmer productivity. Except that software has a very iffy history of contributing to overall productivity, the impact isn't severe by any measure (and negative by a few), and on the level of investment happening now we would need to increase the (already huge) size of "software" on our economy several times.
- c-linkage 1y agoProcess efficiency is about doing less to achieve an objective than you used to. This is the idea behind LEAN. If companies keep adding tasks then this is the exact opposite of LEAN. The only way doing more tasks makes sense is if said company is expanding into different markets, but that can be challenging and distracting from the core business (a reason why many non-core tasks are now outsourced.) Software automates processes. Processes are currently designed with human decision makers in the loop. If you want software-enabled process to achieve maximum productivity then humans must be removed from the loop. This is the true objective of AI as it is being deployed and hyped today.
- marcosdumay 1y agoSoftware can do a lot of things. It can automate processes, it can help you optimize, it can make enough data accessible for you to not need a process, it can partition and generalize processes, it can control stuff... The relationship between software and productivity is really not as simple as you put. But also, the AI being hyped today is completely incapable of removing humans from a process. Several other forms of AI do this, the one on the hype doesn't.
- ratelimitsteve 1y agothe stock price thing at least seems like Goodhart's law. Stock price is supposed to be a measure of investors' confidence in whether a company will make money, because (common, non-voting) stock is nothing more than entitlement to a share of the profits. How much will you pay me today for a tiny slice of the pie periodically over the lifetime of the company? The problem w this is twofold: 1) You can sell stock after you buy it, which isn't itself a problem but introduces a confounding variable. Now stock price is a reflection partly of investors' confidence that the company will make money, and partly of investors' confidence that the stock price will go up. These two obviously feed back into one another: if a company announces things that make it seem profitable the stock price will go up, which can drive another round of investing beyond what the announcement warrants just hoping that they can ride the wave upward and get off at the peak. I personally did this with dogecoin when it went on its bull run a few years back. Despite my wholehearted belief that DOGE was basically worthless, I saw the price going up so I threw some money at it with the intention of bailing as soon as I saw any substantial growth. I tripled my money in three days and greater fool'd my way out of that position. 2) The tail starts to wag the dog. The perceived health of the company should make stock prices go up, but the stock price going up ends up influencing the perceived health of the company. What other measure do we have? The answer of course is "several, but none as easily summarized and delivered as a single number that has either increased or decreased since yesterday".
- lotsofpulp 1y ago3) company publishes their 10-Q and 10-K with terrible results and the gamblers try to rush out as they watch themselves be the greater fools. Trustworthy, transparent financials mitigate the above 2 “problems”. Trustworthy and transparent being key requirements, which can only be satisfied if with a trustworthy and transparent auditor (i.e. government). Edit: Also, the author's quote here >This is what Deming meant when he said “nobody gives a hoot about profits”. does not make sense to me, considering the large gains (to the tune of trillions of dollars) are to the shareholders that own shares in businesses with enormous profits. Obviously, someone (everyone?) gives a hoot about profits. Those obviously translate directly to money in one's pocket, especially those of managers and executives getting paid in equity.
- wheelerwj 1y agoI have a better idea, let’s stop pretending that someone is an expert just because they bought a domain name. This post is full of non-sequitur assumptions, conjecture, and almost every logical fallacy.
- mleonhard 1y agoPlease explain.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- BrenBarn 1y ago> For those of us who care about improving how we work and, specifically, about making better software, is there even an audience out there that both cares about doing things well and has the ability to change their practices? Most of that sentence is overkill. :-) It's becoming hard enough to find organizations (or even individuals) that care about doing things well, period.
- librasteve 1y agoTurns out that if you’re core philosophy is authoritarianism, that surveillance and control matters more than anything else, including profits and business outcomes.