5 ms·
$83B Wasted: Showing up at the airport 3 hours before your flight
- ktallett 1y agoUgh, this cost to the economy calculation because you aren't at your desk is not accurate. There is no way the loss is simply equivalent to your rough hourly rate for your time. There is no way to quantify whether for this or for bank holidays how much money was lost from the economy. Especially when salaried employees can still do their tasks for the week or month with or without that extra day.
- nv-vn 1y agoThen what are they doing at work all day??? If they spend 20% of their week slacking off then they would get paid more if they just worked the whole time and got more done
- ktallett 1y agoBecause a salary is about doing the task you are employed to do, it's not about filling up every available moment or that you are slacking if you have free time one week. If an employee is able to find a quicker way to do the tasks they need to do that week than the norm, good for them as long as it means the work is done to the same standard and on time.
- newAccount2025 1y agoI don’t buy it. This assumes the tasks to be done are fixed, pre-determined, binary pass/fail kinds of things. Many (most? all?) salaried jobs aren’t like that: you can spend more time and do more, or so it more thoughtfully, insightfully, carefully, etc.
- ktallett 1y agoI would agree many aren't like that, but you can set your own deadlines and tasks and break down a big project into smaller goals. One day's difference in a big research project or when developing a piece of software is not going to change the cost or lose significant value in society or to the business. So why would that be attributed as loss in these calculations?
- esseph 1y agoYou still have certain work that has to be delivered by certain deadlines.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoHe calls himself a "thought leader" not a "statistics leader".
- jdietrich 1y agoThe price at which someone sells their time seems like a pretty good indicator of how much they value their time. An hour of lost leisure is still a loss, even if it doesn't affect GDP.
- ktallett 1y agoBut salaried jobs are not time based. They are often focused on doing a task across many months, one less productive day won't mean a significant loss financially for the company. We all have less productive days, is that a direct loss financially to the gdp? What about more productive days is that me helping the gdp? Or does it balance out? Fixing time wasted at an airport could be useful but it's not the biggest issue ever and I certainly wouldn't frame it as a GDP issue if we could fix it. More efficient for humans to do things they want to do with their time, not to do work instead. Even trading time for money jobs, are not as clear as that, as often you produce far more money for the business than you get in return. So a simple addition of what your pay per hour is to the overall cost sum is still not accurate.
- jltsiren 1y agoYou can get a much lower value for time by measuring how much extra time people are willing to spend to save some money on groceries and other purchases. But this is not a new problem. There are established models for the value of time in most countries, and they are used extensively when planning traffic and infrastructure. Typically the value of working time is based on the cost to the employer, while free time is valued between 1/3 and 1/2 of the nominal wage. As most trips (including commute) are done in free time, the average value of time is ~1/2 of the wage.
- hhh 1y agoI don't value my commute time as free time.
- brewdad 1y agoMakes sense since it is part of your employment commitment. How do you value your Saturday grocery run? The multiple hours spent at kids sports practices? Time spent doing home improvements? Those are the hours that are more difficult to accurately model.
- impossiblefork 1y agoI actually think it is. You actually become quite tired from this airport stuff, and even if you get back to the office the next day you'll be less productive.
- ktallett 1y agoI would agree it is tiring, but how much of an issue is one slow day at work. How do you factor in that each day is such a small part of what I assume is a bigger project or goal?
- epolanski 1y agoI think what the author really wants in reality is high speed trains.
- q3k 1y agoWait, people actually show up 3 hours before their flight? I try to make it 1 hour before, and that's only because of bag drop off deadlines. I know plenty of light travellers that show up 15-30 minutes before departure, basically at gate close time. (disclaimer: in the EU)
- haswell 1y agoVery much depends on the airport. Before I was an experienced traveler, I used to show up at O’Hare in Chicago 3 hours early because who knows how long the security lines will be. It was overkill, but gave me piece of mind. At some point I took a job that required significant travel, and I learned to cut things much closer. Usually not less than 45 mins. But if I’m flying internationally I’ll still show up at least 2 hours early.
- RajT88 1y agoI too mostly fly out of O'Hare. Once I got global entry, I was a reliable 45-60 minutes before wheels up guy. I have never had Precheck take longer than 15 minutes.
- codelikeawolf 1y agoI'm also an O'Hare flyer and the biggest time vampire you face there isn't long security lines, it's the four-mile walk to your gate lol
- RajT88 1y agoSeems like a United issue. I have been flying American and others lately, and it feels like very manageable hoofing. Nothing compares of course to traffic on 90/355/190.
- codelikeawolf 1y agoIt's usually Alaska. I fly back and forth to PDX pretty frequently, so I get plenty of cardio at the airport. And you're right about the traffic, but I would argue that 290 is the absolute worst :)
- mattmaroon 1y agoPeople are told to eat less processed food and more vegetables and yet we’re all fat. Nobody listens. Anybody who listens to this either doesn’t travel much or is the sort of person who’d get there that early anyway. Unless I’m checking a bag (which means I’m going somewhere that I’m anticipating bringing a lot of stuff back) I lazily aim for an hour early and am closer to 45 minutes. I’d be even later but there’s substantial chance of random traffic between me and the airport I most frequently fly out of.
- codelikeawolf 1y agoI take at least 6 - 8 flights a year and I have never needed to show up to the airport 2 hours early, but for some reason, I still do. Maybe it's superstition? I almost always end up at my gate within 15 minutes of walking into the airport (thanks TSA PreCheck!) That being said, even if I could confidently start showing up 45 minutes before my plane is about to take off, I'm essentially just sitting around at home, waiting to get a ride to the airport. So I'm either sitting in a chair on my laptop at home or doing the same at the airport. At least the airport has a Starbucks.
- kstrauser 1y agoI cannot relax before I’ve physically visited the gate, starting from the night before. I sleep poorly before a flight, waking up a hundred times to glance at the clock to make sure I haven’t overslept. I’ve never overslept. It doesn’t matter. So, my mental options are 1) give in, get up, take a leisurely trip to the airport without worries of an unplanned traffic slowdown, get through security, stroll to my gate to make sure I know where it is, then find a lounge and chill in relaxation knowing that everything’s fine, or 2) stress out that something might go wrong and make me miss my flight up and wish I’d left earlier. I know me. I’ve done this plenty of times. This is my choice. So I go with the first every time: get there too early, then chill more than I possibly could if I were anywhere else. Either way I’m going to be up and moving. Why not use that time to radically de-stress my morning?
- mattmaroon 1y ago
- csomar 1y agoThe 3-hours is a recommendation so that the airline can "cover its ass". Air Travel got worse after Covid, especially for International travel. Domestic is less complicated but if you are travelling internationally, the security checks are a plenty and I have learnt my lesson to be at least 3 hours early. Most of the time, the time was wasted between passport/visa checks, slow check-in, buggy self-checkin so back to queue, slow security, slow passport checks, big airport -> takes lots of time to move around, etc. I had a Turkey-China flights 3 months ago. I arrived at Istanbul international more than 3 hours early. Between all of what I described above, I arrived at my gate just 10-15 minutes before departure. I am actually wondering about the lost opportunity cost to have these large expensive airports with all these shops and then leave passengers with no time to shop around.
- brewdad 1y agoMy last two international arrivals back into the US were at ATL and JFK. Both times I had more than a three hour layover. Both times they were boarding my middling group when I got to my gate. Train broke down at ATL. Lines were super long and slow at JFK (both Global Entry and TSA). There’s no way I would book less than two hours these days unless I know there are many options for my connecting flight when things go south.
- amelius 1y agoThey need a way to justify those Platinum VIP priority access programs, whatever it's called, with shorter show-up time.
- ccppurcell 1y agoI have had some of my best ideas and productive hours at airports though.
- SpaceNoodled 1y agoI once made insane time to the airport, caught the parking shuttle right as it was leaving, hit zero-line security, and found my flight delayed, leaving me with a massive block of time I then spent on the phone coaching a colleague to help him prep for an interview, which he subsequently aced.
- PaulKeeble 1y agoWe buy our ticket from the airline but they don't get service guarantees from the airport so all the risk is passed onto their customers who can miss their flight and be held responsible for it, despite it being the airports fault. The incentives for the airport are to be as cheap as possible, which they do by not having enough staff manning bagging/security et el for the peaks. Airports are a natural monopoly within an area so there isn't competition to loose out to, there is no where else for the planes and travellers to go and cities wont be putting down space for multiple airports to compete. Because of the monopoly aspect it requires legal requirements for service guarantees to be laid out on the airports to fix this, without which the situation wont change and the risk will continue to lay with the customer for airport failures and they have little choice but to turn up early to mitigate the risk of the airport not having enough capacity. Its a system where all the companies are acting in their own best interest.
- mannykannot 1y agoThe airport, being, to no small extent, a shopping mall, has incentives to get you there early. One thing that would tend to discourage frequent travelers from determining their optimal pre-flight margin would be to have somewhat arbitrary and frequently-changing security procedures and requirements. A second way to encourage long loitering times would be to under-staff vital functions such as Air Traffic Control. EWR appears to have nailed these strategies.
- SJC_Hacker 1y ago> The incentives for the airport are to be as cheap as possible, which they do by not having enough staff manning bagging/security et el for the peaks Anyone who doesn't work for the airlines at large commercial airports in the US, is very likely to be a government employee. TSA being a very large portion of that. They do not have any direct incentives to be cheap. In large urban areas you will generally have more than one airport, so its not the monopoly you're making it out to be. Any delays caused by the airline (long lines at bag check) would also be subject to competition with the airport itself from competing airlines.
- djoldman 1y agoI detest flying. If it seemed to be the only possible reality, I wouldn't care. But for flights that don't span water, my understanding is that it's almost certain that a train system is far superior. (Emissions, weight&volume vs energy expenditure, and speed when accounting for loading/unloading and security).
- SJC_Hacker 1y ago> But for flights that don't span water, my understanding is that it's almost certain that a train system is far superior. I'll assume you are speaking theoretically, as the inter-city train system in the US is mostly a joke except for some very specific routes (such as NYC-Philly-Baltimore-DC) Even in an ideal world, a coast-to-coast train express train in the US is going to be way slower than flying. If time isn't a major consideration or is "downtime" anyway, such as a overnight sleeper train than it might be somewhat better, but chances of that ever getting built are essentially zero in a world where we can't even connect two major cities on one coast.
- djoldman 1y agoAgreed, a good passenger train system in the US won't happen in our lifetimes. It's frustrating to contemplate what could have been.
- listenallyall 1y agoWhat could have been? How could you build a train system from say, Denver to Los Angeles, Miami to New Orleans, Chicago to Dallas, that could be less than 3-4x the flight time and have enough passengers to be remotely economical (not necessarily profitable, just not a massive drain)?
- vinni2 1y ago> But for flights that don't span water, my understanding is that it's almost certain that a train system is far superior. That’s an ideal world that should have been a given. But unfortunately for most of the world this is a fantasy.
- komali2 1y agoEvery improvement to heavier-than-air air travel is a waste of resources. Mass rapid transit over land became a solved problem in 12th century Germany when mine workers put wagons on wooden rails, and same for air travel when the Montgolfier brothers floated a sheep, duck, and rooster in a hot air balloon for the pleasure of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette. Planes spend a tremendous amount of fuel, cramp people into a tiny space, require substantial engineering efforts and time to upkeep, are incredibly difficult to automate, incredibly difficult to route efficiently, require gobsmacking infrastructure to safely take-off, land, and route, and thousands of manhours of training and hundreds of humans per plane, per day, to handle every aspect of operation. And yet still sometimes they crash, sometimes even on purpose. Meanwhile the modern train is nigh-uncrashable with modern safety technologies, even if someone wanted to. They're so simple to automate you can create an entire scale model automated system in your basement with safety features and routing, and reprogram it, with the knowledge within just a couple books. They take up far less space and their routing is simpler, their infrastructure may on the surface seem larger but in reality are basically one and done two slabs of iron that are dead simple to maintain. They're already electrified, already automated, already safe, already more comfortable, already faster point-to-point when you consider that they can take you from one city center to another and require far less security since they can't be crashed into buildings by hijackers (so you can show up 10 minutes before departure and stroll on). For getting over oceans we should use blimps, which are awesome, or humongous sailing ships, which would also be awesome. Hell if you want you can even "fly" the most modern of sailing ships. There's your plane, you degenerates that chose planes as your special interest. Pick a real one, pick hydrofoil sailing ships instead.
- josephcsible 1y ago> And yet still sometimes they crash, sometimes even on purpose. > Meanwhile the modern train is nigh-uncrashable with modern safety technologies, even if someone wanted to. Your comment is super misleading because it makes it sound like trains are safer than planes, but in fact, trains have several times more fatalities per passenger-mile than planes do.
- komali2 1y ago
- TrackerFF 1y agoI sometimes wonder, what is the collective money and manhours spent on airport security check around the world, since 9/11? Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that there should be no security checks - but it has to be astronomical.
- marssaxman 1y agoIt could never possibly be justified. The only security measure which mattered after the 9/11 attacks was the introduction of locking cockpit doors.
- pseudo0 1y agoThe TSA has a workforce of 65,000 people, it's an insane waste of collective time and energy. Meanwhile private planes don't even have to go through the TSA, presumably because big donors have actual political pull and the risk is laughably low. Too bad Elon didn't pick the TSA as a DOGE target, it would have been actually useful and wildly popular.
- lurking_swe 1y agoit’s basically a jobs program…and a waste of most peoples time.
- heavensteeth 1y ago> Taking an extra two hours per passenger on average, that’s 1.725 billion hours, or $83 billion cost to the economy just for extra time wasted for domestic passengers. That seems really wrong to me? 1. Business flyers are getting paid for the day, wherever they are. Whether they spend an extra hour in the office or at an airport is orthogonal to them getting paid. They may be producing less output which in turn decreases GDP, but that's its own can of worms and also not what this is trying to calculate anyway. 2. Leisure flyers, naturally, fly when either their business is closed or they've taken time off. So again, whether they leave at 2AM or 4AM, they're not getting paid for that day. I don't think the layman would end up with any more money in their pocket were they to leave 2 hours later for their flights.
- vinni2 1y agoThis is a very pessimistic view. Everyone adjusts their lives including business and leisure flyers to account for the unpredictable time needed at the airport. This not only affects the travelers but also people around them or connected to them. This has cascading effect on time used for other tasks which indirectly affects the productivity of a person overall.
- cmurf 1y agoAirports are shopping malls. The article underestimates the sales being generated from a captive audience. The show up lead time recommendation isn't followed by everyone, of course. But it produces a distribution of arrivals. The farther out, the more it moderates the peak arrival of passengers at the counter. The idea is to reduce that peak so that airlines save money not having to overstaff. But also, if an airline is willing to set a policy that favors additional time for their passengers to spend more money, maybe they get a fraction of a percentage reduction in rent or some other kind of rebate? We don't know all the incentives that go into the way things are the way they are. I'm not sure how the credit card lounges make up their costs. Given Chase is raising their premium card from $600 to $800, it seems it's increased aggregate demand for such perks.
- johngossman 1y agoI've always assumed they tell you to arrive early in order to account for the chance it will take you longer than you guess to get there, just like doctors do. I've never had it take 2 hours from arrival to gate, but I have been 90 minutes late because of traffic and would have missed my flight (not a big deal) if I hadn't aimed for being there two hours early. In any case, the assumption that this time is wasted is spurious whether you're a road warrior catching up with e-mail or a tourist researching your trip, you're not sitting in a lounge chair like a zombie.
- ortusdux 1y agoHank Green - "This Gate is the Reason You Have to Get to the Airport 2 Hours Early" https://youtu.be/ps2IZyV3Ih4 https://youtu.be/ps2IZyV3Ih4
- exiguus 1y agoI think there are two kinds of people: Those who fly often and those who fly a few times a year. Regular flyers know their airports, the days and vacation times. Then you can reduce to 30 minutes airport time. If you only fly a few times a year or don't know the airport well and are traveling during the vacation season, you have to play it safe. Then 1 hour of flight time can quickly add up to 4-6 hours. However, as long as airplane fuel is subsidized, few people will pay twice as much for trains, even if they are just as fast or faster and much more comfortable.
- xnx 1y ago> airplane fuel is subsidized, Airplane fuel is subsidized? I thought it was taxed in the US.
- orwin 1y agoNo, you even have an international treaty enforced by the US that prevent taxes on jet fuel.
- xnx 1y agoIs this page wrong? "U.S. Government-Imposed Taxes on Air Transportation" https://www.airlines.org/dataset/government-imposed-taxes-on-air-transportation/ https://www.airlines.org/dataset/government-imposed-taxes-on...
- orwin 1y agoNo, i was. Jet fuel is exempt from taxes for trips between US and Europe+UK because of a bilateral agreement. Those agreements are signed country per country, and could be changed of one partner insisted on it. I was lied to, did not do my research, then lied to everyone here instead, sorry.
- OneMorePerson 1y agoNowadays with so many people having lounge access via credit cards it's not like you have to sit at the gate in a noisy environment anymore. For me I get there 2 hours early, quickly verify my gate wasn't changed (sometimes that info only shows up on the internal monitors at the airport), and then go to the lounge and read a book, code, do whatever. Free drinks and snacks.
- roxolotl 1y agoThe reason you have to show up so early is because the downside of missing a flight is huge. Absolute best case you’re at a large city flying to another large and an airline, likely different from the one you planned on traveling on, can get you on their next flight within the hour. This is going to be pricy. The next best case is you’re able to get a flight out the same day but hour later maybe for free or a small up charge if it’s the same airline. Then you also have problems on the other end. You can easily lose a whole day at your destination. That might mean the car you’re planning to rent is no longer available, the person picking you up is no longer free, you miss an connection etc. Of course if we have one hour electric commuter flights which just turn around and go again that makes things very different. Worst case, assuming there’s seats, you’re out two hours and on the next flight. So what the article is describing is a totally different game.
- readthenotes1 1y ago$83B is not enough to build a short High-Speed rail, so it's really not enough to move the system.
- nunez 1y agoThis is not wasted money. The article fails to take leisure travelers and airport economics into account. Us seasoned travelers are very comfortable being in airports and airplanes. We have no problem with getting to our gate as boarding is happening because we (a) usually travel alone, (b) have acquired a really good gut feel for the amount of time it takes to get to the gate and (c) have CLEAR and TSA Precheck or similar security programs to move through security rapidly. Most Americans only travel by plane once or twice yearly. It doesn't look that way in an airport, but that's the magic of large numbers at work. Those travelers don't have any of these advantages. Many of those people travel with families, and everyone with kids knows how big of a job traveling with kids is. Many people also don't know how to transit through security, given how little they travel. They need the three hours. Modern airports are built around this, like the article describes, but this is also what people _want_. Many people praise how luxurious some international airports are, especially when compared to ones in the US. Them serving as lush shopping malls is a big part of that. Airport spending is also a huge economic driver for cities. So many taxes get shoved into purchases at airports and rental cars. Cities aren't going to just give that revenue up.
- 1659447091 1y ago> Many people also don't know how to transit through security, given how little they travel. They need the three hours. More and more are getting pre-check status since their credit cards pay for it. More than once I have been stuck behind a group (LAX Int'l terminal) where the middle aged male would hand a stack of 4-6 passports to the unlucky TSA person who will either be annoyed and purposely take their sweet time looking through the passports and handing them to each person and telling them they have to be the one to hand it over or hand them all back to the guy and tell him to give the passports to their owner to be checked, at which point there is a 50/50 chance (in my experience) that he will start arguing with the TSA person, throughly embarrassing the adolescent humans in the group. The MyTSA app is great for getting average wait times, which check points are open/closed and instructions for how to do security. As someone else posted, Planning ahead pays off. > Many people praise how luxurious some international airports are, especially when compared to ones in the US. Them serving as lush shopping malls is a big part of that. One of my early international travel experiences was clearing customs at Amsterdam Schiphol and being dropped into a literal mall while looking for the train; it was one of my more bewildering and awestruck airport experiences
- drewbitt 1y ago> Why do we simply accept showing up 3 hours before a flight Because what's the alternative - airports pinky promise that they really, really won't have any passenger intake delays, then it magically becomes true?