4 ms·
The Google URL shortener stopped accepting new links around 2018. It has been deprecated for a long time. I doubt it was a cost-driven decision on the basis of
by Aurornis 1y ago
The Google URL shortener stopped accepting new links around 2018. It has been deprecated for a long time.
I doubt it was a cost-driven decision on the basis of running the servers. My guess would be that it was a security and maintenance burden that nobody wanted.
They also might have wanted to use the domain for something else.
- resize2996 1y ago"security and maintenance burden" == "cost" == "cost-driven decision"
- aspenmayer 1y agoCapital inputs are one part of the equation. The human cost of mental and contextual overhead cannot be reduced to dollars and cents.
- mixdup 1y agoSure it can. It takes X people Y hours a day/month/week to perform tasks, including planning and digging up the context behind, related to this service. Those X people make Z dollars per year. It's an extremely simple math equation
- aspenmayer 1y agoEmotional labor doesn’t show up on a balance sheet.
- cogman10 1y agoHow much of a burden could this really be? The nature of something like this is that the cost to run it naturally goes down over time. Old links get clicked less so the hardware costs would be basically nothing. As for the actual software security, it's a URL shortener. They could rewrite the entire thing in almost no time with just a single dev. Especially since it's strictly hosting static links at this point. It probably took them more time and money to find inactive links than it'd take to keep the entire thing running for a couple of years.
- londons_explore 1y agoI think the concern is someone might scan all the inactive links and find that some of them link to secret URL's, leak design details about how things are built, link to documents shared 'anyone with the link' permission, etc.
- cogman10 1y ago> I think the concern is someone might scan all the inactive links How? Barring a database leak I don't see a way for someone to simply scan all the links. Putting something like Cloudflare in front of the shortener with a rate limit would prevent brute force scanning. I assume google semi-competently made the shortener (using a random number generator) which would make it pretty hard to find links in the first place. Removing inactive links also doesn't solve this problem. You can still have active links to secret docs.
- bapak 1y ago> You can still have active links to secret docs. If they're have a (passwordless) URL they're not secret.
- londons_explore 1y agoTo make the URLs actually short, you need to use most/all of the keyspace. Back when it was made, shorteners were competing to see who could make the shortest URL, so I bet a brute force scan would find everything.
- simonw 1y ago"How much of a burden could this really be?" My understanding from conversations I've seen about Google Reader is that the problem with Google is that every few years they have a new wave of infrastructure, which necessitates upgrading a bunch of things about all of their products. I guess that might be things like some new version of BigTable or whatever coming along, so you need to migrate everything from the previous versions. If a product has an active team maintaining it they can handle the upgrade. If a product has no team assigned there's nobody to do that work.
- EGreg 1y agoHow much does it really cost google to answer some quick HTTP requests and redirect, vs all their youtube videos etc
- rany_ 1y agoI really doubt it was about security/maintenance burdens. Under the hood, goo.gl just uses Firebase Dynamic Links which is still supported by Google. Edit: nevermind, I had no idea Dynamic Links is deprecated and will be shutting down.
- mort96 1y agoDocuments from 2018 haven't decayed or somehow become irrelevant.
- rdtsc 1y ago> I doubt it was a cost-driven decision on the basis of running the servers. My guess would be that it was a security and maintenance burden that nobody wanted. Yeah I can't imagine it being a huge cost saver? But guessing that the people who developed it long moved on, and it stopped being a cool project. And depending on the culture inside Google it just doesn't pay career-wise to maintain someone else's project.
- JimDabell 1y ago> My guess would be that it was a security and maintenance burden that nobody wanted. Cloudflare offered to run it and Google turned them down: https://x.com/elithrar/status/1948451254780526609 https://x.com/elithrar/status/1948451254780526609
- dangus 1y agoI think the problem with URL shorteners like Google’s that includes the company name is that to the layperson there is possibly an implied level of safety. Here is a service that basically makes Google $0 and confuses a non-zero amount of non-technical users when it sends them to a scam website. Also, in the age of OCR on every device they make basically no sense. You can take a picture of a long URL on a piece of paper then just copy and paste the text instantly. The URL shortener no longer serves a discernible purpose.
- cbarrick 1y agoShorter URLs mean fewer characters to encode in a QR code.
- 1over137 1y ago>The Google URL shortener stopped accepting new links around 2018. It has been deprecated for a long time. It's a strange thing to consider 'since 2018' "a long time". Only in tech circles is this so, not in normal life.