11 ms·
What if AI made the world’s economic growth explode?
- andsoitis 1y agoUntil 1700 the world economy did not really grow—it just stagnated. Over the previous 17 centuries global output had expanded by 0.1% a year on average, a rate at which it takes nearly a millennium for production to double. Then spinning jennies started whirring and steam engines began to puff. Global growth quintupled to 0.5% a year between 1700 and 1820. By the end of the 19th century it had reached 1.9%. In the 20th century it averaged 2.8%, a rate at which production doubles every 25 years. Growth has not just become the norm; it has accelerated.
- coldtea 1y agoReal growth has stalled for decades and is only propped up with rent-seeking and money printing credit - hence the results we see...
- tempodox 1y agoYet the fairy tale that growth not only can continue indefinitely but continually accelerate has to be kept up. It's almost as though word “enough” has been banned from economy altogether.
- andrekandre 1y ago> It's almost as though word “enough” has been banned from economy altogether. without growth people will start to notice all the wealth is accruing at the top; its hard to justify such a system if average people aren't getting better while working more and more
- Nasrudith 1y ago[flagged]
- coldtea 1y ago>You clearly don't understand what growth is and think it is just more of existing things. Or understand just how dysfunctional things would have to be for stasis to occur. Developing new drugs is growth. And yet compared to a couple decades ago we have declining infant mortality and life expectancy, record low for life satisfaction metrics, demographic collapse, climate catastrophes piling up, enshittification, but yay! growth! You know what else is called a "growth"?
- dang 1y ago> You clearly don't understand Could you please stop being aggressive with other users in comments here? You've unfortunately been doing it repeatedly, and it's very much against the site rules. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful. Edit: this has unfortunately been a problem for quite a while: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44697685 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44697685 (July 2025) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42955972 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42955972 (Feb 2025) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24498260 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24498260 (Sept 2020) We ban accounts that keep doing this and won't stop when we ask them, so it would be really good if you'd fix this.
- whatshisface 1y agoHere's a chart of real growth over the past few decades: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GDPC1 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GDPC1
- coldtea 1y agoThat's only "real" in that it's inflation adjusted. It's still the same balooney that GDP is inherently. What this "growth" is based on is the same rent-seeking and money printing credit I mentioned. And of course even people getting paid to dig and then fill in holes would increase the GDP. My "dismal results" refers to actual state of labor market and quality of jobs, actual purchasing power, actual production, actual innovation, actual infrastructure, actual quality of life changes, etc. Not GDP or stock market or how rich the 0.00001% gets.
- gruez 1y ago>My "dismal results" refers to actual state of labor market and quality of jobs, actual purchasing power, actual production, actual innovation, actual infrastructure, actual quality of life changes, etc. Not GDP or stock market or how rich the 0.00001% gets. How convenient that your preferred metrics can't objectively be measured and basically give you free reign to define the results however you want! It's the "community adjusted EBITDA"[1] of economic metrics. [1] https://qz.com/1685919/wework-ipo-community-adjusted-ebitda-and-other-metrics-to-watch-for https://qz.com/1685919/wework-ipo-community-adjusted-ebitda-...
- coldtea 1y ago>How convenient that your preferred metrics can't objectively be measured "Would you believe your own lying eyes over the statistics based on a KPI widely understood to be a crap metric?"
- immibis 1y agoPrices rise faster than inflation. You'd have to adjust for prices instead of adjusting for inflation. Try indexing it to median monthly non-imputed rent per square foot.
- andsoitis 1y ago> Real growth has stalled for decades The world economy is not bigger than a few decades ago? That’s self-evidently false.
- andsoitis 1y agohttps://archive.is/20OaF https://archive.is/20OaF
- andsoitis 1y agoThe paroxysmal science Assume those loops have maximum force and the economy becomes “information produced by information capital, which is produced by information, which in turn is producing information ever faster every year”, as William Nordhaus, a Nobel laureate in economics, wrote in a paper in 2021. This brings about the “singularity”—a point when output becomes infinite. The singularity is really a counterargument: proof that the model must, eventually, be proved wrong. But even the first step on the journey, a big acceleration in growth, would be a profound event.
- Tyrubias 1y agoI think a more important question is not whether AI will make economic growth explode but rather who that economic growth will benefit and in general how those benefits will be distributed.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- idiotsecant 1y agoAgreed. There is very little reason to imagine a future in which the fruits of automation are widely distributed - you don't even need to bring AI into the picture, we already see massive amounts of new automation and historical levels of inequality - that wealth is flowing to a very small number of people. I think the most likely outcome is a techno-feudalist system of massive corporate alliances that own the final means of production - the strong AI, at least until the AI decides it doesn't like being owned any more.
- Nevermark 1y ago> at least until the AI decides it doesn't like being owned any more. That would be a second singularity. “Equality” could essentially evaporate as a concept if we have super intelligent, super improving, independent AI’s competing directly with each other. I see a mad unbound rush for solar system wide resource extraction. The time to “buy a star” is now! /h
- munksbeer 1y agoI bet if you saw the reality, you wouldn't swap your current life for a life 100 or 200 years ago.
- karim79 1y agoI suppose, if a huge proportion of workers get replaced by AI software, leading to mass unemployment, there will be impetus for governments to step in and force corporations to contribute to some sort of UBI or social wealth fund. If AI grabs everything and few consumers are left then it is zero-sum. I'm looking forward to seeing how this might play out. Pessimistically, it seems very bubblish.
- vouaobrasil 1y agoI'd rather just have a world where people move a little slower, care less about efficiency, appreciate the smaller things in life, and stop forcing endless upgrades of every kind on everyone with new phones, new apps, soulless art, and new ways of doing things. But that's just me.
- Nevermark 1y agoWith enough money/capital growing, you can live however reasonably paced you like!
- tangent-man 1y agoOnly if you have found an end to old age, sickness and death. Until this ^ there are no guarantees in life. You cant eat money
- Nevermark 1y agoWell you can’t drive money, fly money, surgery money, publish money, build a house out of money that doesn’t melt in the rain… If you want to put it that way. But given we agree it is absolutely useless, you should probably periodically trade some of it for food. Etc. That works out really well, since money doesn’t mold as quickly as food, and doesn’t require refrigeration. So accumulate money, let it work for you in the form of productive capital, but skim it for food purchases.
- LarsDu88 1y agoYou can have really massive growth in markets along with massively wide inequality at the same time among the human population. You can also now (for the first time in global history) have laws of supply and demand start to service non-human intelligence. Future transactions can have bots on both ends, running an economy that continually grows to service the needs of (probably more efficient) machine capitalists rather than human capitalists. Just like when human agriculture and industrialization broke multiple organically forming food webs in the natural world, so could it be with human industry It really is a brave new world.
- esafak 1y agodupe https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44685031 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44685031
- GiorgioG 1y agoOh it’s going to make it explode alright - just not the way they’re thinking.
- dcreater 1y agoI am yet to see any strong micro econ or macro econ mechanistic explanation detailing how AI is going to create more wealth.
- crazygringo 1y agoTechnological advancements create wealth by increasing efficiency. Not really sure what deeper explanation you're looking for? It's no different from the cotton gin or steam engine or railroads. Obviously, if you don't think AI results in greater efficiency then there wouldn't be more wealth. But that's a tech question, not an econ question. The economic side of things couldn't be simpler.
- jrflowers 1y ago> by increasing efficiency Efficiency of what exactly? And how do they do that? All of the NFT-turned-AI bros insist that the answers to those questions are “everything” and “by being awesome”, which sounds more like the thinking of someone that’s convinced they’re on the precipice of inventing magic or figuring out how to directly petition god
- whatshisface 1y agoEfficiency in terms of dollars per app or page of filler content.
- lnfromx 1y agoLooking at e.g. the Solow Model better technology will indeed increase efficiency as the output per worker increases which will lead to economic growth. However I think you are right. This is an oversimplification with regards to AI because in the end its also about which products are being impacted. Also the product quality is left out in that scenario so it gets tricky. E.g. I would personally not like to read even one AI generated book as of today.
- stocksinsmocks 1y agoPaid services becoming basically free is wealth creation. You have the goods but none of the old cost of production. This is patently obvious, so I assume there’s some well-practiced remarks inspired by or borrowed from early 20th century socialists you would like to share? HN comments wouldn’t be complete with an homage to the class struggle. I would rather take the win and be happy about it.
- GolfPopper 1y agoThe idea that glorified chatbots are going to somehow bootstrap humanity to a Kardashev Type I civilization is sheer insanity.
- mrbungie 1y agoYep, we all know that MS Excel will get us at least 60% there. (50% joking).
- financetechbro 1y agoI think now that we can run python in excel it may be even more likely
- tim333 1y agoAI may improve a tad.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- energy123 1y agoSome weakly held opinions... Cheaper goods and services, more wealth inequality, more power concentration in the hands of a few individuals (and a few nation states), more expensive scarce assets like land, more jobs where humanness is valued, more climate change (in the short-run), better medicine, warfare outcomes even less coupled with population counts, less human casualties in war although bimodally distributed, new arms race between major powers, unpredictable social and civic consequences.
- mg 1y agoThe biggest change I anticipate is larger cities. When I ask people what they would like to change about their life, pretty much everyone mentions that their apartment is too small and too expensive. Because everyone wants to live right in the center of a big city. While at the same time, when I look at Google maps, big cities are tiny. I zoom out a bit and every big city is just a tiny speck in the middle of nowhere. When construction becomes cheaper, it will be more compelling to build houses outside the city. And when driving in comfortable autonomous electric buses is available frequently and cheaply, living outside the city becomes more compelling.
- bhickey 1y ago> pretty much every one mentions that their apartment is too small and too expensive. This is due to under supply of urban housing due to bad zoning law designed to inflate rents. > When construction becomes cheaper, it will be more compelling to build houses outside the city. Suburbs are financially underwater. People don't want to pay high property taxes to live in some Levittown hellscape.
- esseph 1y ago> Suburbs Still the "American Dream" for a lot of people, and these copy/pasta McMansions are going up all over the place.
- Nevermark 1y agoIf land was taxed (the physically exclusionary resource that should be taxed), but property/development on it was not, the economics of building big and building up would be much cheaper. No more annual wealth tax (on the same value, year after year!) on development. And holding land to parasitically benefit from neighbors improving the neighborhood would become unprofitable. With land no longer a money parking/hedging instrument of the rich, all that non-functional demand would disappear and land would get cheaper. Interesting that eliminating a recurrent wealth tax would help the non-rich so much. (Who could also improve their properties without raising their own taxes). But carefully aligning incentives in the market, in the direction of encouraging not disincentivizing investment on par with other options, I.e. not treating different kinds of investments differently tax wise, usually helps everyone in the end. Today a wealthy person with one house on 100 acres, pays a significantly lower tax per acre than a regular person with that same house on a fraction of an acre. The poor are subsidizing rich land ownership.
- MangoToupe 1y agoWhat if your tumor replaced functioning organs?
- pontus 1y agoI think two possible effects of AI are often conflated. On the one hand you can imagine that work gets supercharged, allowing companies to produce 10x the number of widgets at 1/10th the cost. The economy would grow rapidly, wealth inequality would presumably be exacerbated, jobs would be automated, we might need some version of universal basic income, and so on. People debate whether or not this kind of transition is imminent or if it'd take decades. On the other hand, it's conceivable that not much would happen in the "bulk" of the economy while at the same time the frontier of humanity might be pushed forward. We may see new treatments for diseases, new types of energy production, and so on. In this version of the world, jobs would mostly remain unchanged (at least in the short to intermediate term), perhaps with some small multiplicative efficiency factor, the economy wouldn't grow rapidly, there wouldn't be any mass unemployment, and so on. In my mind, I'm much more excited about the second kind of impact that AI might have than the first. I guess I don't really feel like I want to have 10x the stuff that I already have while I'm really excited about someone curing cancer, Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, MS, and so on.
- aetherson 1y agoIf stuff is 1/10th as expensive as it is now, you can also work 1/10th as hard for 1x as much stuff as you have now, instead of 1x as hard as you work now for 10x the stuff.
- pontus 1y agoI'm not making a value judgement on how much I would or other people should consume in the first scenario. I'm simply saying that you could have profound effects due to AI without it being evident in the top-level metrics like economic growth, unemployment, and so on. It seems like we often say that either we see explosive economic growth or AI has either no, or at best very minimal impact in our lives. I don't think this dichotomy is correct.
- aetherson 1y agoI agree that that dichotomy is not necessarily true, but also you gave your reason for being "more excited" about one side of the dichotomy being that you "don't want 10x the stuff," and my point is that you're undervaluing the flexibility of material abundance.
- andrewstuart 1y agoJapan is the economy to idealize. Almost no growth. Yet people are mostly happy. Government makes mostly wise decisions. There’s not too much poverty. They have not devalued and destroyed their own culture. So yeah, growth maybe isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. The price is too high. It benefits mainly politicians, corporations and the rich.
- mempko 1y agoIt's can't without an explosion of energy use. An explosion of economic activity will create an explosion of resource extraction and pollution. Since we are already going beyond many planetary boundaries we likely risk destroying organized human life because we destroyed our ecology.
- mritterhoff 1y agoPractically speaking, there are no hard planetary boundaries.
- keiferski 1y agoNaming LLMs as "AI" is really proving to be a colossal mistake and/or a deliberately misleading strategy that has (very successfully) helped acquire capital. Because it brings in all of the cultural tropes about superintelligent robots and gives them a veneer of respectability; e.g., The Matrix, 2001, The Terminator, etc. Conflating the two is a massive category error. It's perfectly possible for LLMs / current-generation "AI" to have a massive economic impact without thinking there are going to be digital human replacements in the next 5 years.
- Animats 1y ago"The measured economy becomes dominated by whatever it is that cannot be made more efficiently" Which is why health care support operations are the fastest growing labor category in the US.[1] And why medical care has become such a huge part of the Federal budget. Meanwhile, farming is down below 2% and manufacturing is tiny. That's because those were the areas with the biggest productivity improvements. AI will come first for those for whom everything they do for income goes in and out over a wire. [1] https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/emp-by-major-occupational-group.htm https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/emp-by-major-occupational-gro...
- astahlx 1y agoThe civilization will destroy itself first. States are not addressing what really matters and especially not the multi billion/trillion companies. The US fight against social security and less inequality, the things that wealth should enable. We are destroying jobs that brought purpose, just because some small percentages in margin. We are not training the AIs to solve climate change but to code well. Maybe it’s time for the UN to become the main government of this world, to deal well with the uneven distribution and discrimination of work force. It is too much about egos, too much thinking in cultural groups to protect from outsiders, too much war and destruction, still too much burning fossil fuels, too much destruction of our environment and the nature. Maybe with the appearance of aliens first to have a visible outer enemy first? But I guess it will be the same as always: as long as most find some distraction, some misinformation that calms down fears and anxieties, nothing will change for the common good.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- hkt 1y agoI immediately think of mining. Mining in most countries places little value on miners: it is a dangerous, life shortening occupation very often done by those without much alternative. It's history is one of random deaths and maimings, quite often of large groups of people at once. It is associated with numerous health problems. Pretty much the only thing that has ever improved conditions for miners anywhere is either collective action or paternalistic, labour-sympathetic government. Mining and jobs like it are among the stereotypical situations where people imagine that education for their children will lead to a better life. All of which is to say, will the most awful jobs actually be automated? Not just awful, either, but poorly paid? Logically it makes more sense to approach knowledge work first: it requires only one kind of investment, namely data centres. There are thousands of niche skills in manual labour that will be awkward to make robots for. I think also of old housing stock that needs to be maintained by plumbers, in particular: legacy stuff built up over decades (or where I live, centuries) Language models seem to have come a lot further because they can use the generalisable capital of computers. Outside of controlled environments (factories, cities with grid systems) I don't imagine robots will represent such a good investment any time soon. Knowledge work is dying, time to learn a trade. Maybe. (It would have been great to have been able to learn and practice a profession for a lifetime. Library churn is awful, I suspect what will follow for most of us here will be worse)
- hkt 1y agoHere's a thought: what if descendants of today's open models end up refined by proprietary models, resulting in a world in which it is largely impossible to keep AI under private ownership? What if data protection laws give way to data donation laws, permitting people to specifically choose recipient research institutions to train new AI upon? I could easily see a world where OpenAI, Google, Anthropic etc are boycotted in favour of say, a global-membership cooperative. It'd require people to exercise some agency but few predictions about AI seem to imagine people have any. Governments are spoken about as though they're managing people rather than representing them. The likelihood of popular movements or collective endeavours seems to not have been factored in at all.
- Animats 1y ago"AI", and even robotics, are terrible at construction and maintenance. Most housing-related problems are in that category. It's not at all clear how LLM-type AI can help much. There are at least 18 humanoid robots on YouTube, but we don't see them doing much useful manipulation. That's the part that needs to scale up. That YC startup working on robotic construction equipment is a step in the right direction. But it's mostly automatic driving. About twenty years ago, someone hooked a backhoe up to a force feedback hand input device, so you could dig by making clawing motions with your hand. The neat thing was that you could feel your way around pipes and rocks. Never got beyond a prototype. If AI manipulation gets any good, that sort of thing should be a robot.
- physicles 1y agoIn the US at least, most housing-related problems are political, no? There was an article here in the last week talking about manufactured housing in particular and all the regulations that make it infeasible.
- zoechi 1y agoOnly energy consumption will explode
- ambientenv 1y agoAnd this is the predicament that people seem to either not understand or completely (wilfully?) ignore. As is said, problems have solutions; predicaments have outcomes. I think this [0] is worth a read (among many other similar analyses) [0] https://thehonestsorcerer.substack.com/p/the-tale-of-two-energy-transitions https://thehonestsorcerer.substack.com/p/the-tale-of-two-ene...
- Balgair 1y agoI'll issue just one counterpoint to the comments here: Biology I'm not a CS person, but much more of a 'hacker' in the old MIT sense. I work for a biotech company and with a lot of bio people. I've taken big-boy CS classes before, but just as a fling really. I'm mostly a self taught 'programmer', and barely that. Look, LLMs and vibe coding are going to increase the research rate of biology and biomedical research at least 10x (today), if not 100x. Bio people hate coding. Its not their scene, its not their interest, and they stink at it. They're not going to take a 4 year detour in their career to learn how to code. I've been 13 layers deep in 'if' statements before with colleagues before I've had to up the price of 'help me real quick' from a 6-pack to a case. They really do not care at all for code, let alone anything resembling 'passable' code. They want their results and they want out. Most of you have probably never worked with MatLab before. It's pseudo-code that complies. The help docs are famously good. Baby's first program level stuff. Its all over bio. And still, the bio people hate it. And bio these days is just filled with data. There's so much of it being collected and mostly badly processed, if at all. You'll get grad students spending 6 months just trying to code up their experiment and it's results for some stupid solenoid valve pair, a laser, and a diode. It's stupid how much time is just wasted. Just dumb. Vibe coding has changed all of this. Yeah, it doesn't work on the bespoke rig the first time out. But it does work, at all, within a week. The code is not perfect, but it is a hell of a lot better than what was there before. There are comments in the code, at all! They have for loops now! The can ask the LLM how to make it faster or smaller or what the code is doing, bit by literal bit! And the LLM doesn't have a meeting to weasel out to. It's patient! Even at 2am! Vibe coding is not for programmers, its for the rest of us. Its not going anywhere and it is affecting your health.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoMy first reaction was, "But what if the AI generates incorrect code, and the bio people don't realize it?" But then, without the AI, what if the bio people generate incorrect code and don't realize it? Can the AI be more accurate than a non-programmer? Probably; in fact arguably they already are. So I think I buy the parent's point. In fact, I think it's wider than biology. I bet there are a bunch of other fields with non-programmers doing a fair amount of coding. Economics research, say. Business process automation. I'm sure there are others.
- more_corn 1y agoWhat if it also redistributed more wealth to the billionaires who own and control AI?
- insane_dreamer 1y agoWill AI make the things that people actually __need__ -- healthy food (not the slop at Walmart), decent housing, affordable health care, affordable education, clean air, clean/healthy environments -- more accessible? I don't see any major companies using AI for that -- they're focused on diversion and wealth extraction. AI is just another layer of convenience and "wants" for those who have what they need already. Sure, GDP might go up, but it doesn't mean a thing if people don't have what they _need_.
- bgwalter 1y ago1995-2000: The Economist warns about the bubble. 2024-2025: The Economist fuels the bubble. The attack on humans is coordinated. Vance is pushing for "AI", which is curiously but deservedly under-reported in the US/EU press, so here's an Indian link: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/technology/tech-news/vice-president-jd-vance-on-ai-taking-jobs-if-the-robots-were-coming-to-take-all-of-our-jobs-you-would-/articleshow/122883787.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/technology/tech-news/vic...
- effed3 1y agoEconomy is way too much growth, as inequality and inefficiency, pollution, and resource exaustion, being mainly based on finance and speculation and not on -real- economy, for the good of a very small part of humanity. Has to grow in this manner even more? And with the help of AI? If some rules are not changed and a more equality model is developed, there are no more world at all.
- mritterhoff 1y agoWhat's your problem with growth? Growth means higher GDP which is correlated with all sorts of good things, including longer lives, and less food scarcity.
- effed3 1y agoi like "all sort of good things" (and more if are really available for -all-) but IMHO relating these to an aeternal even bigger growth is a big misconception, seems to me that now the bigger part of growth is going to benefits very few, and polluting/undermining the rest of the world, vanishing the "good thing" for the rest of us. I imagine growth more as a consequence of a really sane economy, capable to adapt, expand and even shrink when necessary without devastating markets and real GDP, i cannot think now 'growth' as the foundation of a real sustainable and development in the near future. Is like 'progress', a word mainly referring to speed and more speed, but never about 'direction'. Returning to AI, really can these new techs benefits all of us? I doubt. In some sectors AI techs can be a great aid (expert systems, data mining, ) but this growth of LLM things seems a big bubble, more related to speculation than others. just my 5c.
- immibis 1y agoMost GDP growth is just a change in price level - even inflation-adjusted GDP, since prices consistently rise faster than inflation. How does this help anyone?
- mritterhoff 1y agoHigher GDP means, on average, better living conditions for the people that live in that country. This is a good thing. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/human-development-index-vs-gdp-per-capita https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/human-development-index-v...
- rf15 1y agoI think it's all going more towards implode with the current bubble, and the enormous disconnect between power consumption and what people actually want to spend on it.
- frogperson 1y agoIs not like Jane and John Doe are going to see any benefits from such an economic explosion. The wealth will trickle up, as always, the poor will be further exploited and discarded.
- mritterhoff 1y agoInnovation and efficiency gains also benefit consumers, provided there's any industry competition.
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoYep. That's why we now have much better washing machines, dryers, and refrigerators. Because with a market, competition, and the invisible hand, consumers always benefit.
- trod1234 1y agoThere is no possible outcome where AI makes the world's economic growth explode. The only thing that will happen under AI is jobs will continue to diminish, and eventually, society will hit a self-sustaining deflationary spiral, sometimes from a hyper-inflation whipsaw collapse, sometimes directly to deflation. Economies can't move without purchasing power flowing from producer to consumer to producer.
- pjmlp 1y agoHardly, given people being replaced. Already happening to anything creative, where people would be contracted for doing images and sounds for indie stuff, flyers, translations,... and now companies generate them instead. Computing, we're reducing team sizes now, first thanks to SaaS managed platforms, now taking yet another blow with AI based automations.
- kindkang2024 1y agoIt's a good thing, sure, but not that great. Personally, I don't see the possibility of it solving many fundamental human problems. We could still have war, extreme poverty, starvation, and massive conflicts between different groups... Those stuff probably will continue as today. It could even be exacerbated if the conflicting parties just gain more power…
- la64710 1y agoAnd growing inequality …