11 ms·
How YouTube won the battle for TV viewers
- consumer451 1y agoYouTube is apparently #1 in music streaming as well, which I found surprising.
- pie_flavor 1y agoYT Music is a dollar cheaper than Spotify, and generally better; it's also included in YT Premium, so if you already have that, 'may as well'.
- al_borland 1y agoIn terms of subscribers or actual use? I have YT Premium, so I automatically get YT Music. I would much rather pay less and drop the Music app. I almost never use it and don’t like it. I can’t justify buying for another service on top of this, so I went back to managing a local library and manually syncing all my music to my phone like it’s 2007. A side effect of YouTube treating music special is that I can’t read comments on the TV for videos that it thinks are music. I find this very annoying. The same video will have comment on mobile or the computer.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- consumer451 1y agoIIRC, it was in terms of use.
- anon7000 1y agoMy gripe is that when you try to sync over a library from, say, Spotify, you’ll end up subscribed to hundreds of artist’s YouTube channels in your main TV app, and playlists are basically shared too. Which I do not want at all
- al_borland 1y agoYep. This is one of the reasons I don’t really use YT Music. The shared playlists are a nightmare. If someone tells me to check out a song, I might go there to listen to it as a one-off, but that’s about it. It’s so poorly done for anyone who also uses YouTube, which I assume is everyone.
- oersted 1y agoQuick tip: You can see the comments on such videos (at least on my TV), the comments button not shown but clicking on the video title to open the description also shows the comments.
- dartharva 1y agoYT Music arguably has a much larger library than any of its mainstream competitors (since it can also draw from music videos uploaded to Youtube). Also, better audio quality in my subjective opinion.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoWent to a wedding, 10 years ago even, and the "kids" DJ-ing the wedding party were pulling up music on YouTube. (To be sure, this was very much a low-key affair, teens there with their parents were "DJ-ing" — but I was still surprised that is was YT. Just vanilla YT, pulling up "videos" and hitting "play".)
- radley 1y agoYouTube is pretty common for in-person, social music sharing because it's the least friction. It's hard to share between Spotify, Apple Music, Soundcloud, and personal collections from the same device. YT search will usually find pretty much everything.
- t-3 1y agoIt's because most music in on youtube, and the audio quality is good enough for the average joe running bluetooth speakers or whatever, and it's free+usable without an acount unlike all the other music services. Free is the most important part.
- ksec 1y agoI dont believe that is the case, and I cant any reference to it. Nearly all are pointing to Spotify as number one both in terms of revenue and market shares. The thing I dislike about Youtube Music is how it is basically not a product the team have put any thoughts into it. It is constantly rated one of the worst in Apple Music and Spotify comparison. It has so much potential but it is just very poor done.
- apricot13 1y agoso did I until I found myself using YouTube music over Spotify more and more. it has all the standard music but also includes more remixes and smaller artists. the most important thing is that it doesn't mix podcasts in with music and you can easily view your own playlists! haven't used Spotify in any meaningful way in a few years now.
- mrj 1y agoSame. Also, my Spotify auto generated playlists hadn't changed for several years. I finally got fed up and googled around only to find it was a known issue. Clearly somebody realized they could just turn off those expensive GPUs...
- rambambram 1y agoI always wondered if this would be the case. All non-tech-nerd people I know share Spotify links that I can't open (yes, I can download another app, no I'm not going to do that). I use Youtube extensively for discovering new music and new artists. Sometimes (1 out of 100 times) I find myself on Soundcloud for a song that's not on Youtube, but for the rest Youtube is just perfect. I always wondered how many people use Youtube for music streaming... apparently a lot.
- qingcharles 1y agoThe reason I've always used YouTube Music over the competition is that it includes whatever-the-hell anyone uploads on YouTube. So, while Spotify can't get the rights (or the data) for that band that played down the pub one time in 1987, someone happened to record them and put them on YouTube and now they have royalties sat accruing somewhere and I get to listen to them on a nostalgia binge.
- rchaud 1y agoNot surprising, Youtube has tracks that Spotify does not. Live stuff, unofficial bootlegs, out of print B-sides, the lot. Some are "official" but many are user-uploaded. Youtube has enough legal power to keep those online I suppose, where smaller operations like Grooveshark did not.
- al_borland 1y agoI’d say 98% of my YouTube views are on the AppleTV.
- GauntletWizard 1y agoI ditched Chromecast recently. They made YouTube too heavyweight for the Chromecast Ultra, to the point it regularly crashed. The new "Chromecast With Android TV" is barely more specs and has broken the interface by being... Android TV. Rather than take a well deserved second place, they chased Apple's design and ruined their niche. Worse still, the best replacement I could find... Was Apple TV. So now I'm on that ecosystem.
- kimixa 1y agoDoes it use a different app on the Ultra? I'm still using my second generation and (aside from some nonsense earlier this year about expired certificates) still going strong - can't ever remember it "Crashing". Perhaps it's not "app weight" but more specific to the 4k video or SoC implementation?
- JKCalhoun 1y agoThat alternatives to YouTube have come to naught feels unfortunately like a de facto monopoly. Certainly it's because the content creators stay on YouTube because that's "where the eyeballs are". (Or rather, the money is to be made there on ad revenue ... because that's where the eyeballs are.) I don't know how you break that. eBay is probably in the same enviable position.
- veggieroll 1y agoUltimately, we need to convince DC to start enforcing monopoly laws again.
- nine_zeros 1y agoAin't happening with the current party at the helm.
- veggieroll 1y ago[flagged]
- spwa4 1y agoThat won't work, Youtube is fundamentally dependent on massive storage, massive compute and massive internet connectivity PLUS a revenue mechanism for creators. A whole lot of infrastructure. Monopoly laws and taxes are punitive. In other words: they can only ever create a situation where there is fundamentally less available. They cannot create a second Youtube, they can only destroy Youtube. Unless the government builds the infrastructure, which is a nonstarter. If you cannot use state power and/or resources to create a second and third Youtube, then letting Youtube be a monopoly is probably the best option. The big difference between competitors and a monopoly is that a monopolist can only improve outcomes by growing the market ... which is exactly what we want. Unfortunately it is very much not what the government wants. Well, it is not what governments (plural) want. Governments think they're god, and of course like two people in a madhouse that both think they're god, there is a rather fundamental disagreement here. They will realize, eventually, just how stupid it would be for god to let other gods (anyone but themselves, other governments, but also private people) control mass media. This means we will get closer and closer to the situation that Youtube cannot satisfy multiple governments. This could even apply to multiple parties within one state structure. You would hope this means they'll build infrastructure, but we all know what will really happen: they'll destroy it. Youtube will end because governments will see it as a threat to them, and they just won't care how much damage they're doing. Just look at the current government. There are a LOT of economy texts, some quite old that warn about the dangers of letting private interests control the only market for anything. They suggest the government should make sure they own or at least control the market itself, but that includes paying for infrastructure. This has it's own problems (like censorship), but there is really no alternative. Either you do that or eventually the monopolists will BE the government.
- heavensteeth 1y agopersonally i havent watched tv or listened to the radio on my own accord in many years because there are too many ads. i like the idea of not being able to choose the content im engaging in but it feels like 70% ads and 30% content
- ksec 1y agoNon Youtube contents such as TV broadcast needs to get streaming done right. And they haven't done it. Apple or Google could have helped here. Where All Broadcast TV are in one place / App just like a normal TV. And the content will be streamed in decent quality. But neither are they interested as Youtube belongs to Google and Apple is going with Apple TV+ direction and wants to own TV itself. It is such a sad state of things since Steve Jobs passed away both Apple and Google have a complete lack of taste and product sensibility to deliver something truly helps the customers. Instead every product and features are marketing or sales driven.
- halJordan 1y agoThis could easily have happened. Apple especially lets anyone fit their catalog into the TV app. It's the non-Apple and non-Google part of the equation that chose the current system.
- ksec 1y agoThere are additional requirements involved with getting the catalog in TV App. And Apple obviously are not willing to share accurate user count numbers as well as a lot of other data. Once they said they are Apple's customer and not those TV / Broadcasting customers that was the end of the conversation.
- jppj 1y agoI wonder what it's like in various countries. I was surprised that Japan came up with that, TVer which basically all broadcast shows end up on for at least one week, shown with ads. AFAIK it's driven by a coalition of broadcasters with nothing to do with the big platforms - where there's a will there's a way I guess.
- izacus 1y agoApple and Google tried that for years on their TV platforms and the content providers aggressively blocked them. E.g. Netflix outright refuses any kind of integration where their content would be surfaced next to other services - their product managers DEMAND that people go to their app into their owned experience to access content. And designers/product managers at other content providers are the same.
- brycewray 1y agohttps://archive.is/Ii9n3 https://archive.is/Ii9n3
- radley 1y agoI feel like this is the result of the major streaming services cutting back on original content due to production costs, the 2023 strikes, and winning the broadcast fight. Initially, streaming had to compete with broadcasting's long seasons by producing the equivalent amount of content, spread between more shows, with higher-quality production but much shorter seasons. Now streamers are providing fewer shows and only semi-annual seasons. It ends up leaving a lot of open viewing time with nothing fresh to watch. YouTube also has the advantage of people making highlight reels of the most popular movies and series. We get out-takes, behind the scenes, bloopers, best quotes etc. Streaming services haven't figured this out (yet). I've never watched The Late Show with Stephen Colbert on TV, but I watched almost every monologue on YouTube.
- Night_Thastus 1y agoStreaming services in general have become terrible. What once was on ~3 platforms is now on ~10+ platforms. They constantly shuffle around who has what, new promising series are constantly killed because if they don't instantly become a worldwide sensation and the prices are rising non-stop. At some point I just said screw it and left all of them.
- DevX101 1y agoI'm not sure the economics of big budget TV series work anymore unless you catch lightning in a bottle so I understand them cutting prod costs. YouTube's economics are just so much better. YT provides no up front payment for content. The channels are almost infinite, microtargeted to everyone's interest. And the payout is proportional to the success of the content, and paid AFTER the audience has viewed. TV on the other hand has to make big bets before they know whether a show will be a hit. I've had a TV for years but don't have cable and never watch broadcast. My TV is just a large ipad.
- elzbardico 1y agoI never get this argument. To see themselves without fresh content, I reckon people would have to expend at least some 4 hours every single day watching tv. Anyone watching this much TV should instead cut it down, it is fucking too much time wasted.
- h4kunamata 1y agoTV is hot garbage now. YT has solid channels, from DIY to black hole talks and most importantly, uncensored news. TV is just ADs and more ADs, garbage content after garbage content. Not everything is pretty tho, YT has a complete monopoly and there is nothing anybody can do about it, the alternatives suck with some silly subscription when there is no even content. I do pay for Youtube Premium since Youtube Music is hands down better than Spotify. I would pay for alternative services to help them out IF they were worth it. YT Premium is the only subscription I pay and happy to do so, I see value.
- lowdownbutter 1y ago> uncensored news. Get a load of this guy
- tietjens 1y agovery curious what is meant by uncensored news.
- philipallstar 1y agoI think it's the sort of news that doesn't sound as though all the news channels had a meeting and decided to say the same thing at the same time.
- amelius 1y agoIs YT Premium 100% ad-free? I get the feeling that if many users start using Premium, at some point they'll see ads again.
- RaSoJo 1y agoYT-Premium is still ad-free, though they did bump up the prices recently. Being a monopoly gives them that kind of power, but they haven’t gone overboard—probably because they know regulators would start poking around if they did.
- nickthegreek 1y ago
- apricot13 1y agoTV channels have been forced to produce TV shows that will draw the biggest audiences. they've not innovated online either. Streaming services make great shows then stop them after one season or force one episode a week. they also drop then pick back up shows constantly. YouTube let's people watch the kinds of shows they want to watch and let's people create the kind of shows they want to create. everyone wins, including YouTube! plus they do music, smaller artists, bigger artists and mashups in between. it's all just there fairly reliably and it works on every platform.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ddtaylor 1y agoJellyfin is really popular in our house. Everyone associates YouTube with quick and dirty dumb content. Garbage "looping" style content is allowed in private, but long form content on a screen or playing aloud has to be something that is an actual 30+ minute thing with a point to it.
- zarzavat 1y agoYou need to subscribe to better YouTube channels. I stopped watching regular TV (including Netflix, etc), because YouTube is much more erudite and I actually learn things rather than passively consuming dramas.
- ddtaylor 1y agoThere are a lot of really amazing TV and movies from the last 60 years. It seems we never have time to get around to finishing what we want, but I am genuinely curious what my wife and kids think about various scenarios presented in shows like Black Mirror. Likewise, despite their inaccuracy, movies like The Imitation Game or A Beautiful Mind led me to look at the life of Alan Turing beyond just what I learned in college. Consuming content is very much a time-blocked thing for me. I have some YouTube content I consume to stay up with various AI/ML groups, etc. but that is closer to work-related and not something I will put on during a break from work as that will defeat the purpose of recharging my brain. It's also interesting to see how movies or shows capture small details that change over time.
- rambambram 1y ago> actual 30+ minute thing with a point to it Good point. I hardly see any movies anymore and lately I found that what I miss is a good story. Some Youtube channels come close, but these are all 'garden variety' stories, so to speak.
- southernplaces7 1y agoSince this isn't a defense of Google but of the many clever creators on YouTube, I can comfortably applaud so much of their work. YouTube isn't at all about just garbage content. It has no shortage of that, but it also has absolutely no shortage of truly fantastic, educative, production-worthy videos and channels of all kinds. I mean some truly excellent ones here, that are easily as good as or very often much better than anything I used to see for documentaries on network or cable TV. That so many of them are made at a fraction of those old documentary budgets and by completely independent creators (often just some guy working from his home studio) is an incredible achievement of modern media technology and innovation. The YT algorithm will often promote to you more that's similar to whatever you've already watched, so if you actually start seeking out a certain type of quality content, you'll find more of it being recommended. I carefully pick the things I take the time to view or play in the background while im working on household chores and so far haven't had any shortage of genuinely great things to enjoy. YT has its many flaws, but one of them certainly isn't a shortage of quality vidoes about nearly anything you could want to know about.
- linsomniac 1y agoToo bad the YouTube TV viewing experience sucks. Don't get me wrong, I've been a subscriber for a very long time, and I get a lot of great content there. But going there to watch something specific, or watching a TV series, really sucks. I recently realized a few studios (IIRC Warner Bros and Paramount) had put a lot of content there including movies and TV shows. I decided to watch Dick Van Dyke, because I'm a Carl Reiner fan. You can't really "Watch Next" a TV show and then go in to watch the next episode. And in fact sometimes it just wants to show you the shows in a non-linear order. "I want to watch the next Dick Van Dyke" is not something that YouTube makes easy. Another example, a friend recent sent me The Chit Show, I opened the playlist of the shows, and it played them in the reverse order (which I didn't really understand until the end when I realized I was on the first episode). Also, the YouTube algorithm for suggesting things for you to watch is really bad. It gets stuck in ruts and it's hard to get out of them. YouTube is amazing for learning DIY things, which is a large part of why I have subscribed for so long. But for watching entertainment the whole UI really just doesn't work.
- eliasbagley 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- wpm 1y agoDo you work for the YouTube UX team? What’s the deal with this incredibly out of pocket snarky reply to a list of genuine and reasonable gripes?
- umeshunni 1y ago> You can't really "Watch Next" a TV show and then go in to watch the next episode. From the article: A coming YouTube feature, called “shows,” can automatically queue the next episode on a channel, rather than serving whatever the recommendation algorithm thinks you’ll like best from billions of options.
- 1y ago
- legitster 1y agoI'll come out and say that I am a full blown Youtube addict. A lot of what I may watch on Youtube might be categorized as "background noise" - lots of talking head content that I can play on the background. Much of it is low quality and self-serious - but it's arguably much better quality than any equivalent "background noise" show on TV. Ironically, I feel like longform Youtube content is actually better for my attention span and more rewarding - because creators aren't trying to appeal to broad audiences, they don't have to jump from topic to topic and keep things under a time limit. I recently watched the Animagraffs video on the Hoover Dam and I was blown away. I have probably watched dozens of TV documentaries on the Hoover Dam over the year, but none of them actually just stop and methodically explained everything from top-to-down so thoroughly. Even beloved shows like Mythbusters, there are now dozens of channels on Youtube that do all the same things we enjoyed Mythbusters for but better and with less filler and shmaltz.
- miduil 1y agoI've watched this video the other day https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWsL8ME3ruk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWsL8ME3ruk and it somehow helped me breaking my YouTube addiction for the last several weeks. Quite random but it really helped. I still muscle memory enter youtube.com and I'm blown away how incredible addictive everything is setup there to be, the "algorithm" has trained the content creators to maximize their reach with incredible captivating thumbnails (and of course great content).
- vouaobrasil 1y agoBest thing is to turn off recommendations and history, which can be done with YouTube. You can also use uBlock Origin to block even more controls (on YouTube on other websites too), which make websites more unintuitive to use.
- Lammy 1y ago> I'll come out and say that I am a full blown Youtube addict. A lot of what I may watch on Youtube might be categorized as "background noise" I'm like this too, but I prefer stuff like railfan videos that are short on words and long on landscape shots and monotony-quenching machine sounds. They never leave me with that feeling where my attention snaps back to the video in a way that makes me feel like I missed something and need to skip back a few seconds. This channel is an especially-good example of what makes great background YT viewing to me: https://www.youtube.com/@7ideaproductions/videos https://www.youtube.com/@7ideaproductions/videos
- ErrorNoBrain 1y agoFor me... TV costs money Youtube is free... and i can block the ads
- nodejs_in_2025 1y agoGood fucking ridance. Youtube is also shit, but I cant help but cheer the demise of deep state controlled traditional media..
- kingstnap 1y agoYouTube could be so much better. But because the alternatives are so bad, they full on monopoly it. They could fix the bot problems, they could bring back dislikes, they should show downvotes on comments, comment history in profiles and an inbox for replies, search is broken, shorts is terrible, etc etc....
- wanderingmind 1y agoOne thing I wished YouTube had like Twitter was to see what other channels the channels you like to subscribe. This way you are not held hostage by YouTube recommendation, which is definitely not in favor of the viewers
- unixhero 1y agoThey just don't produce very good tv shows anymore. There is nothing to watch. In the 90s we had Seinfeld, X-Files, King Of Queens, Frasier, Star Trek TNG, Macguyver and so on. Then onto 1990s movies, which by the time they reached TV syndication were still good! Will I watch Lethal Weapon or Die Hard even though I've seen it before? Heck yes!
- leephillips 1y agoWhen I visit the link I get: Access blocked. We detected unusual activity from your device or network. Reasons may include: Rapid taps or clicks JavaScript disabled or not working Automated (bot) activity on your network [...] Use of developer or inspection tools
- toisanji 1y agoI have recently been using technology to create long form videos on youtube and it has been a lot of fun to do edutainment https://www.youtube.com/@studyturtlehq https://www.youtube.com/@studyturtlehq I wish there were better ways to monetize it.
- gandalfian 1y agoWorse for television I have a PVR so I fast forward through the TV adverts... YouTube is about the only place left I sit through video adverts.
- cardiffspaceman 1y agoThe algorithm has done well by me. It brought me Davie504, Georgian pianist Khatia Buniatishvili playing Rhapsody in Blue, ICEPEAK, Ningen Isu, Rock Fujiyama, a Hungarian choir singing Metallica, and Donner Pass railroad/snowplow porn. Just a subset.