9 ms·
NASA’s X-59 quiet supersonic aircraft begins taxi tests
- boguscoder 1y agoThe distance from front wheel to the end of the beak is impressive, its sooo engine-side heavy I guess. Curious if it requires a lot more tender landing procedure
- echoangle 1y agoThe cockpit slightly in front of the nose wheel isn’t that unusual and the rest is just a very long nose cone added for the flow effect (that’s probably pretty empty and light).
- colechristensen 1y agoIn planes with tails, the center of gravity is always a little bit forward of the areodynamic center of the wing which is at approximately 25% from the front to the back of the wing. This arrangement is what allows the tail and the wing to balance each other.
- lifestyleguru 1y agoThe design is awkward, not impressive.
- adastra22 1y agoIf it works, the design is perfect. This engineering, not fashion week.
- KyleBerezin 1y ago"The missile is too round, it needs to be pointy!"
- erikerikson 1y agoIs any super sonic flight truly commercially viable/sustainable or is this just a skunkworks front?
- epicureanideal 1y agoEven if supersonic flight were 2.4x less fuel efficient than regular flights, based on Concorde vs other aircraft, if that translated into 2.4x ticket prices, a lot of people would still pay it. $1000 vs $2400 to get to Europe in 6 hours instead of 12? A lot of people who just hate those long flights would pay for it, especially given that flights are only a portion of total vacation cost, together with hotels, etc. Or for a flight inside the US, $1000 rather than $400, but to get from coast to coast in 3 hours rather than 6, may be very worth it for some people. https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/107206/how-close-can-supersonic-airplanes-get-to-subsonic-fuel-efficiencies https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/107206/how-clos...
- erikerikson 1y agoThe Concorde and what I understand to be it's lack of viability was exactly what I was thinking about - it motivated my question. What's different now?
- pests 1y agoI remember seeing something from Boom (now renamed?) which was an YN company years ago. I recall them developing some technology to solve the noise problem - somehow bouncing the sound off the atmosphere or similar IIRC? I do think its viability has increased over the years, just everyone has this default "it wont work" mindset because of the failure that was Concorde.
- adgjlsfhk1 1y agothe biggest difference is that composites and better computers probably make designing and manufacturing a good design a lot more feasible
- kaptainscarlet 1y agoThey should use a Starship rather. Much quicker. The only hurdle would be the price.
- wat10000 1y agoAnd the dying in a fireball. Starship’s design seems fundamentally impossible to make safe.
- somenameforme 1y agoThat's akin to saying that it seems fundamentally impossible to make landing rockets safe which, in fact, is exactly what Boeing/Lockheed were saying when SpaceX was first revolutionizing that space as well.
- wat10000 1y agoI’m not aware of any rocket landing safe enough for human use. NASA nixed the idea of propulsive landing for Dragon 2 for this reason. It’s extremely difficult to make safe, since just about any reasonable engine configuration means guaranteed death if a single engine fails at a critical moment. Compare with modern airliners where an engine can fail at any point in flight and the plane can land safely. So yes, I agree, it is akin to saying that.
- panick21_ 1y ago> NASA nixed the idea of propulsive landing for Dragon 2 for this reason. That is completely false. First of all, NASA didn't nix it, they just didn't make it a priority as it had little value from their perspective. The reason it was not done is that para-shouts have to be in the design anyway for abort situations, so that was fixed. So for SpaceX, the question was to likely delay the program, and take on a whole lot of extra engineering work that they were not actually getting paid for, remember fixed price contract. They were only going to work on it if they really thought they needed it for something like Red Dragon. And then they could still add it later. And one of the primary reason SpaceX thought that its to hard, is that they landing feet would have to have gone threw the heat shield. That would have made the whole heat-shield design massively more complex.
- NooneAtAll3 1y agoReminder that NASA's X-59 (which tests redirecting shockwave mostly upwards) is different from Boom Airspace's XB-1 (which tests flying slower than speed of sound down on the surface)
- Robotbeat 1y agoNeither of those parentheticals are acute.
- NooneAtAll3 1y agowdym acute?
- Robotbeat 1y agoAccurate
- widforss 1y agoIt looks like the pilot barely sees out the window? Does it rely on cameras or does it föy by itself?
- Tankenstein 1y agoIt relies on cameras. Wikipedia: The flush cockpit means that the long and pointed nose-cone will obstruct all forward vision. The X-59 will use an enhanced flight vision system (EVS), consisting of a forward 4K camera with a 33° by 19° angle of view, which will compensate for the lack of forward visibility.
- ivape 1y agoWhat happens if the camera stops working?
- burnt-resistor 1y agoRUD.
- phs318u 1y agoSame thing that happens when flying through storms or clouds - fly by instrument.
- nradov 1y agoRegular aircraft equipped for IFR can't safely land with zero forward visibility. The pilot has to be able to see the runway for the final touchdown and roll out. Only a few aircraft and airports are able to do Category IIIC precision landings. https://skybrary.aero/articles/instrument-landing-system-ils https://skybrary.aero/articles/instrument-landing-system-ils
- psunavy03 1y agoIn an emergency you do whatever you have to in order to preserve safety and lives. No idea if the procedure here would be use a backup camera, try to land on ILS, or eject/bail out (if equipped). Presumably they've thought of that and it's in the "emergency procedures" section of the flight manual.
- HPsquared 1y agoI wonder how they manage the stability with that much aerodynamic surface out front.
- voidUpdate 1y agoBig Fins and fly by wire probably
- wkat4242 1y agoQuiet supersonic taxiing is indeed impressive
- amendegree 1y agoSomeone at NASA is trying to get some good PR going, this is barely a story.
- marcosdumay 1y agoHaving only seen images of that plane on its side, I really didn't expect the beak to look like a duck.
- mlsu 1y agoWhat's the strategic reason for having a supersonic aircraft, when we have ICBMs? I thought the reason the SR-71 was cancelled/mothballed was because the missiles got good enough for it to be totally ineffective.
- KyleBerezin 1y agoThis isn't really meant to be a military demonstrator. It is more like a proof of concept for Concord 2.0. A lot of what NASA does is help progress the field of aerospace and provide consultation to the industry.