6 ms·
A monopoly achieved thanks to everyone that forgot about IE lesson, and instead of learning Web standards, rather ships Chrome alongside their application.
by pjmlp 1y ago
A monopoly achieved thanks to everyone that forgot about IE lesson, and instead of learning Web standards, rather ships Chrome alongside their application.
- bayindirh 1y agoChrome was made to fracture, and everything started with the aptly named “Atom” editor (they “invented” Electron). Everybody choose convenience over efficiency and standards, because apparently nobody understood what “being lazy” actually is.
- pjmlp 1y agoMicrosoft invented Electron, when Windows Active Desktop came to be. Mozzilla also invented Electron, when XUL applications were a thing. Both failed, as shipping regular processes with the default browser kept being used.
- necovek 1y agoKDE invented Electron, when they built KHTML as independently embeddable HTML + CSS + JS engine. Mozilla did it with Gecko even earlier, really — but they gave up on it to focus on browser itself. (There were a number of Gecko-based browsers like GNOME default browser Epiphany using it) Apple built WebKit on top of KHTML just as Gecko stopped being updated: I guess they invented it too. Tools like Windmill (web rendering automation for testing) took programmable concept further. And Sun did very similar things with Java applets and Java applet runtime for desktop.
- account42 1y agoI don't think KDE ever used KHTML as an app development platform rather than as a plugin for rich text.
- necovek 1y agoI only offered that in jest: an embeddable rendering engine is really what WebKit + v8 was, and Electron was just a packaging system for it. There were previous attempts at making cross platform apps for the web and for the desktop.
- brookst 1y agoConsumers never really pick products for ideological reasons, no matter how galling that is to ideologues
- pjmlp 1y agoExcept, many developers contributed to the actual situation. The same excuse was given regarding IE.
- rightbyte 1y agoYou should block adds for practical reasons too though, not just for moral reasons. I can't fathom how there are so many devs that don't use adblockers. It is so strange and when I look over their shoulders I get a shocking reminder how the web looks for them.
- johnnyanmac 1y agoI think ads go well past "ideaology". very few like ads, and they have only gotten more persistent over recent years.
- GoblinSlayer 1y agoAnd they slow down already dog slow web2.0 shit.
- imhoguy 1y agoBut consumers pick products for convenience reasons and Chrome updates crossed PITA line. Even my "boomers" family switches to FF.
- necovek 1y agoIf that was really the case, it would start showing up in the stats too. Firefox is still declining last I checked (I am still using it, but more and more sites have problems in FF.
- pyrale 1y agoOh no, instead consumers pick products because of advertising. What an improvement.
- echelon 1y agoThe answer is antitrust. The FTC / DOJ should strip Google of Chrome. Honestly, they should split Google into four or five "baby Bell"-type companies. They're ensnaring the public and web commerce in so many ways: - Chrome URL bar is a "search bar" - You have to pay to maintain your trademark even if you own the .com, because other parties can place ads in front of you with Google Search. (Same on Google Play Store.) - Google search is the default search - Paid third parties for Google search to be the default search - Paid third parties for Google Chrome to be the default browser - Required handset / Android manufacturers to bundle Google Play services - Own Adsense and a large percentage of web advertising - Made Google Payments the default for pay with Android - Made Google accounts the default - Via Google Accounts, removes or dampens the ability for companies to know their customer - Steers web standards in a way advantageous to Google - Pulls information from websites into Google's search interface, removing the need to use the websites providing the data (same as most AI tools now) - Use Chrome to remove adblock and other extensions that harm their advertising revenues - Use Adsense, Chrome performance, and other signals to rank Search results - Owns YouTube, the world's leading media company - one company controls too much surface area of how you publish and advertise - Pushes YouTube results via Google and Android ... and that's just scratching the surface. Many big tech companies should face this same judgment, but none of the rest are as brazen or as vampiric as Google.
- worik 1y agoYes to everything except the first statement: > The answer is antitrust. Anti-trust is crucial to make the capitalist economy work prperly, I agree But another answer is "Firefox"
- gg82 1y agoI would love to say another answer is "Firefox" (which is my default browser), but Mozilla have gotten fat of Googles money over the years and got distracted by other things.
- al_borland 1y agoI would love if some of these projects that fall backward into loads of money would stay lean, and invest that money in a way that allowed them to become truly independent. So when the money dries up, or the funding becomes dirty, they have the freedom to cut ties and continue their lean operations, self-funded by the interest from their investments.
- userbinator 1y agoIE was far less user-hostile than Chrome.
- leptons 1y agoOnly because Microsoft got slapped on the wrist way back when. Google should get slapped too, and they might be headed that way... https://www.npr.org/2025/04/20/nx-s1-5367750/google-breakup-antirust-trial-remedy-phase https://www.npr.org/2025/04/20/nx-s1-5367750/google-breakup-... Safari is also pretty user-hostile, which is why Apple is getting sued by the DOJ for purposely hobbling Safari while forbidding any other browser engine on IOS. They did this so that developers are forced to write native apps, which allows Apple to skim 30% off any purchase made through an app.
- userbinator 1y agoThere's a huge difference between antitrust concerns, and mass surveillance and anti-user hostility. MS' business back then was to sell software, not monetise users.
- leptons 1y agoYou don't think Microsoft is doing mass surveillance? They own Outlook and Teams, and Windows 11 is quickly turning into a platform for training AI on your data. I doubt Edge is going to be much different. It's the reason I'm switching to Linux.
- userbinator 1y agoThey started going down that route many years ago now (Windows 10 "telemetry" being a critical inflection point), but the Microsoft of the 80s and 90s and even early 2000s was not about mass surveillance but selling software.
- aspenmayer 1y agoPerhaps you’re right, but by the time Microsoft acquired Hotmail in 1997, MSN was already two years old and had its own dialup service. Microsoft knew what they were doing.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 1y agoExcuse me. If it's on MDN, I'm going to use it if it's useful for my app. Not my fault if not all browsers can keep up! Half JK. If I get user complaints I'll patch them for other browsers but I'm only one person so it's hard and I rely on user feedback. (Submit bug reports y'all)
- jmb99 1y agoWhy not only use features that are compatible with all browsers? You don’t need to use every bleeding edge feature to make a website.
- hdjrudni 1y agoI mostly do stick to baseline widely available, but once in awhile something can only be done with a niche API unless perhaps I include a 10 MiB, slow, clunky polyfill. And for a hobby site without paying users, I basically just don't care.
- account42 1y agoCan you name some examples? Are those APIs required for core functionality of your websites or are they limited to features that could be made optional?
- pjmlp 1y agoWelcome to Microsoft world of IE.
- carlosjobim 1y agoThe issue is completely different if the users of an app or a website are customers. Then you have to make it work for them or you'll lose sales. If it's non-commercial project then it doesn't matter if it works with all browsers or not.
- azangru 1y ago> instead of learning Web standards, rather ships Chrome alongside their application I am confused. - The "shipping Chrome alongside their application" part seems to refer to Electron; but Electron is hardly guilty of what is described in the article. - The "learning web standards" bit seems to impune web developers; but how are they guilty of the Chrome monopoly? If anything, they are guilty of shipping react apps instead of learning web standards; but react apps work equally well (or poorly) in all major browsers. - Finally, how is Chrome incompatible with web standards? It is one of the best implementer of them.
- paulryanrogers 1y ago> how is Chrome incompatible with web standards? It is one of the best implementer of them. They have so much market share that they control the standards bodies. The tail wags the dog.
- JimDabell 1y agoThis is not true yet, but it’s getting close. The pattern is this: - Google publishes a specification. - They raise request for feedback from the Mozilla and WebKit teams. - Mozilla and WebKit find security and privacy problems. - Google deploys their implementation anyway. - This functionality gets listed on sites like whatpwacando.today - Web developers complain about Safari being behind and accuse Apple of holding back the web. - Nobody gives a shit about Firefox. So we have two key problems, but neither of them are “Google controls the standards bodies”. The problem is that they don’t need to. Firstly, a lot of web developers have stopped caring about the standards process. Whatever functionality Google adds is their definition of “the web”. This happened at the height of Internet Explorer dominance too. A huge number of web developers would happily write Internet Explorer-only sites and this monoculture damaged the web immensely. Chrome is the new Internet Explorer. The second problem is that nobody cares about Firefox any more. The standards process doesn’t really work when there are only two main players. At the moment, you can honestly say “Look, the standards process is that any standard needs two interoperable implementations. If Google can’t convince anybody outside of Google to implement something, it can’t be a standard.” This makes the unsuitability of those proposals a lot plainer to see. But now that Firefox market share has vanished, that argument is turning into “Google and Apple disagree about whether to add functionality to the web”. This hides the unsuitability of those proposals. This too has happened before – this is how the web worked when Internet Explorer was battling Netscape Navigator for dominance in the 90s, where browsers were adding all kinds of stupid things unilaterally. Again, Chrome is the new Internet Explorer. The web standards process desperately needs either Firefox to regain standing or for a new independent rendering engine (maybe Ladybird?) to arise. And web developers need to stop treating everything that Google craps out as if it’s a done deal. Google don’t and shouldn’t control the definition of the web. We’ve seen that before, and a monoculture like that paralyses the industry.
- isaacremuant 1y agoNot everyone. Some of us used Firefox all along and didn't just go with the "default" invasive thing.
- account42 1y agoOkay, but the two of us are not statistically significant.
- genman 1y agoThe main wrong lesson learned was to promote Chrome instead of Firefox (also in what many HN readers have been guilty of).
- Ygg2 1y agoThat's fundamentally a mischaracterization. Everyone focused on short term gains. Optimizing for browser with 30% market share, backed by Google makes more sense than a browser with 20%. Repeat with 40% and 20% respectively. And so on, and so on. There isn't a lesson to learn. It's just short term thinking. Now Google has enough power and lacks scruples that would prevent it from exploiting.