12 ms·
Upgrading an M4 Pro Mac mini's storage for half the price
- zwilliamson 1y agoOr just go with a Beelink SER8 and toss Arch Linux + Wayland on it. you’ll save thousands of dollars and have a better user interface that’s way more customizable and efficient.
- Zenst 1y agoOnes you can replace the storage with a screwdriver are a safe risk, the soldering upgrades are a void warranty and something you are always best getting somebody who can do it in their sleep to do for you. Soldering is not as easy as it used to be, even the pros will not have 100% success and need to reflow or rework.
- nehal3m 1y agoI'm not usually one to respond with snark, but I'm sorry, your comment reads like what I imagine a stroke feels like. Can you please rephrase?
- jeffbee 1y agoComparing the speeds of a new flash device and an old, used one will typically not be valid unless steps are taken to condition the new device into a steady operating state.
- jtbayly 1y agoI’m surprised and happy that this is possible.
- porphyra 1y agoThere are also shops in China that will upgrade the SSD in a mac mini for cheaper and they will do all the work of the DFU restore etc.
- ttul 1y agoAnd when the machine arrives back in the States, it even has a fresh CPC ROM soldered onto the back of the SOC!
- mattl 1y agoCPC?
- msh 1y agoCommunist party of china aka ccp
- Doctor_Fegg 1y agoPossibly ParaDOS?
- mattl 1y agoHa! I’m sure I asked you about this before but I think you hinted at one point about being able to supply PD on a format other than disc and I think you said not on cassette. What was that?
- bigyabai 1y agoDon't be rude, your NSA ROM gets lonely sometimes.
- mmh0000 1y agoI feel that you're being downvoted by people who don't know history. I'll add some references: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa-upgrade-factory-show-cisco-router-getting-implant/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010s_global_surveillance_disclosures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010s_global_surveillance_disc...
- wpm 1y agoI was quite pleased with the iBoff 2TB SSD I got for my M4 Mini. It's sad how badly Apple has some of us conditioned with the pathetic amounts of storage they include. I haven't had a Mac with more than 512GB of storage, basically, ever? And recently I was on my Mini, digging through some old backups, and hesitated as I normally would downloading a 40GB zip from my NAS, because "oh geeze this is 40GB plus another 40 after decompression, do I have enough space?" because 80GB is normally 15% of my Mac's storage space. Then I remembered, oh yeah, heaps of storage, this'll only cost me 4% of the total. I bought this Mac with the 256GB base SSD knowing I could upgrade, and nearly 40% of the drive was taken up out of the box. It's pure robbery on Apple's part. Completely beyond the pale now. Their ridiculous RAM and storage prices were never that big of a deal back in the PowerBook/early Macbook Pro days, because you could always opt out if you were a tiny bit handy with a small screwdriver (my 2008 unibody lets me swap storage with *1* screw, swap a battery with zero!). Now? It's unforgivable. I don't care about soldered RAM, I get it, but it is despicable charging as much as the entire computer to upgrade the RAM a paltry 16GB. There's profit, and there's actively making your entire product experience worse in pursuit of profit. Having to constantly hem and haw over oh god oh geeze do I have enough local storage for this basic task, having to juggle external storage and copying files back and forth (since plenty of their own shit doesn't work if its installed on an external SSD), or constantly deleting and redownloading larger apps, makes the product experience worse. Full stop. At the very least every Mac they sell should have 512GB, if not a TB, stock. I'm tired of acting like SSDs are some insanely expensive luxury like it's 2008 again.
- yread 1y ago700$ for 4TB! Getting robbed in broad daylight and writing a happy blogpost about it
- teaearlgraycold 1y agoCustom low volume hardware is going to be more expensive.
- kevincox 1y agoGetting robbed less is better than getting robbed more.
- master_crab 1y agoTrue. But I don't know if I’d be gleeful if the robber left me the credit cards and took the cash. Looks like you also have to do the upgrade yourself (so it’s not all just cash money being forked over).
- tuananh 1y ago> I was provided the $699 M4 Pro 4TB SSD upgrade by M4-SSD. It's quite expensive (especially compared to normal 4TB NVMe SSDs, which range from $200-400)...
- dylan604 1y agoSSD speeds are nothing short of miraculous in my mind. I come from the old days of striping 16 HDDs together (at a minimum number) to get 1GB/s throughput. Depending on the chassis, that was 2 8-drive enclosures in the "desktop" version or the large 4RU enclosures with redundant PSUs and fans loud enough to overpower arena rock concerts. Now, we can get 5+GB/s throughput from a tiny stick that can be used externally via a single cable for data&power that is absolutely silent. I edit 4K+ video as well, and now can edit directly from the same device the camera recorded to during production. I'm skipping over the parts of still making backups, but there's no more multi-hour copy from source media to edit media during a DIT step. I've spent many a shoot as a DIT wishing the 1s&0s would travel across devices much faster while everyone else on the production has already left, so this is much appreciated by me. Oh, and those 16 device units only came close to 4TB around the time of me finally dropping spinning rust. The first enclosure I ever dealt with was a 7-bay RAID-0 that could just barely handle AVR75 encoding from Avid. Just barely to the point that only video was saved to the array. The audio throughput would put it over the top, so audio was saved to a separate external drive. Using SSD feels like a well deserved power up from those days.
- Spooky23 1y agoTotally. I spent a lot of time 15-20 years ago building out large email systems. I recently bought a $17 SSD for my son’s middle school project that was speced to deliver like 3x what I needed in those days. From a storage perspective, I was probably spending $50 GB/mo all-in to deploy a multi million dollar storage solution. TBH… you’d probably smoke that system with used laptops today.
- 392 1y agoIf only folks wrote software with this in mind.
- S04dKHzrKT 1y agoIn a similar vein, I had Western Digital Raptors striped in my gaming PC in the mid 2000s. I remember just how amazed I was after moving to SSDs.
- 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- contingencies 1y agoWhile you're at it add the USBC power hack https://github.com/vk2diy/hackbook-m4-mini https://github.com/vk2diy/hackbook-m4-mini I've been traveling for business with this as my sole machine for 3 months straight and it has proven to be an excellent system.
- beanjuice 1y agoWhat is the benefit over a macbook in this case?
- wpm 1y agoThe linked repo has a pretty good rundown of possible reasons: > If non-square screens on Macbook Pros make your blood boil with rage > If you can't afford or don't want to pay for a Macbook Pro (smart choice) > If you have ergonomics concerns with shrinking laptops and one size fits all keyboards > If you like your systems to be repairable and modular rather than comprised of proprietary parts shoehorned in to a closed source design available only from a single vendor for a limited time > If you are blind (and don't want to carry a screen around) > If you want to use AR instead of a screen and therefore prefer to be untethered > If you are on a sailing ship, submarine, mobile home, campervan, paraglider, recumbent touring bicycle, or otherwise off-grid > If you want a capable unix system to power a mobile mechatronic system I'd add in not having to deal with a Macbook in clamshell mode doing stupid crap like forcing you to double-tap the touchID button sometimes, refusing to connect to external keyboards and mice on wake, and some of the other annoyances I have dealt with. Also, a Mac Mini is small, and a MacBook is not, at least as a function of "desk area" vs "area consumed".
- notpushkin 1y ago> If non-square screens on Macbook Pros make your blood boil with rage > If you are blind (and don't want to carry a screen around) > If you want to use AR instead of a screen and therefore prefer to be untethered You can just remove the screen! My M1 Air works just fine at least. (I’ve broken the screen, but if you just don’t need screen at all, you can sell the top half assembly and save some money.)
- GeekyBear 1y agoThe article speculates on why Apple integrates the SSD controller onto the SOC for their A and M series chips, but misses one big reason, data integrity. About a decade and a half ago, Apple paid half a billion dollars to acquire the patents of a company making enterprise SSD controllers. > Anobit appears to be applying a lot of signal processing techniques in addition to ECC to address the issue of NAND reliability and data retention. In its patents there are mentions of periodically refreshing cells whose voltages may have drifted, exploiting some of the behaviors of adjacent cells and generally trying to deal with the things that happen to NAND once it's been worn considerably. Through all of these efforts, Anobit is promising significant improvements in NAND longevity and reliability. https://www.anandtech.com/show/5258/apple-acquires-anobit-bringing-nand-endurance-technology-inhouse https://www.anandtech.com/show/5258/apple-acquires-anobit-br...
- jeffbee 1y ago> Through all of these efforts, Anobit is promising significant improvements in NAND longevity and reliability. Every flash controller does this. Modern NAND is just math on a stick. Lots and lots of math.
- dontlaugh 1y agoPresumably Apple want to be able to guarantee the quality of such logic. Still sucks that you can’t use standard parts.
- jeffbee 1y agoSure, and I agree with that goal. In fact I would like NVMe controllers to simply not exist. The operating system should manage raw flash, using host algorithms that I can study in the the source code.
- mixmastamyk 1y agoInteresting… I see no reason to be downvoted.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- paxys 1y agoSo you pay $700 for an SSD that otherwise retails for $200 and then do an "unauthorized" modification of your own computer and void the warranty to install it, but that's still preferable because it otherwise costs $1200 directly from Apple. The Apple tax is really something else.
- hoistbypetard 1y ago> an "unauthorized" modification of your own computer and void the warranty to install it Citation needed. This modification doesn't look to me at all like it'd void the warranty unless you damage the machine while you do the installation. If you need to make a warranty claim, you should of course reinstall the factory one before you do so, since the vendor doesn't expect users to replace that and won't have any practices of looking/removing so they can return it to you if you take your machine in for service with a non-Apple card there. But voiding your warranty for this has been roundly rejected, in the US at least, as long as you don't damage your equipment by doing it.
- geerlingguy 1y agoApple even provides a support page with details on the process, for example: https://support.apple.com/en-us/121508 https://support.apple.com/en-us/121508
- xyst 1y agoThe people behind the "kingsener" YT channel have been doing these types of upgrades for a long time. He recently posted an upgrade of this same process as a short - https://m.youtube.com/shorts/b-Z5GhYhbjM https://m.youtube.com/shorts/b-Z5GhYhbjM It’s wild to see how much Apple invests in making these as hostile to the user to upgrade. But also cool to see people out there with the skills to desolder the chips, memory, and storage and replace with a much faster alternative. If Apple truly cared about their carbon footprint, devices would be easily serviceable and upgradeable by user
- vachina 1y agoApple solves carbon footprint by making devices that you will want to use for at least 10 years.
- celsoazevedo 1y agoShame that they don't support the device for 10 years too.
- isoprophlex 1y agoBeing relatively greener than a trash-tier dell laptop doesnt make you a green supplier in absolute terms...
- jeroenhd 1y agoYou mean the company that had several generations of those terrible laptop designs that made you rip out the whole chassis when your keyboard became unusable after dust got into the keys? New in box after having been stored in a warehouse for twenty years maybe. Apple isn't any greener than any of their competitors.
- fsckboy 1y agononsense, no developer wants to use a 9 year old computer, slower processor, slower lower graphics, paltry memory, and Apple also cuts you off from the latest OS long before that. and even if what you say had a shred of truth, the carbon footprint would still further reduce if they were not user hostile to upgrades.
- bee_rider 1y agoTangential, just based on a funny coincidence noticeable in the article: What do all these M’s stand for, anyway? I guess the M.2 might be inherited from the m in mSATA and mPCIe(?). For Apple… they had A for for their cellphone chips, which vaguely made sense because they were the only chips Apple made at the time. But then, M for their laptop chips? M as in… mobile, or mini? But they use it in their Macs Pro, including their workstation-y ones…
- gpm 1y agoHonestly the external option seems a lot better value for the money for almost all use cases. Something like half the cost. No tinkering with the internals of the very expensive thing. You can move it between computers, upgrade the stick in it, etc. I'm sure there are cases where you really do care about speeds >3GB/s (and USB-4, the port on the mac, should max out at ~5 which is still marginally lower than the internal one). But I doubt they are common. It's hard to process most data in a meaningful way that fast.
- jillesvangurp 1y agoYep, you can pick up a 4TB usb-c SSD for a few hundred dollars/euros. Unless you are moving around 10s/100s of GB routinely, it's not going to be horribly slow. I had a 2TB Samsung taped to my imac for a few years when its fusion drive failed. The 64GB SSD still worked. So I used that for the OS. And the Samsung for the rest. I had Steam installed and X-plane and a few other things. Worked great. This was the 2015 5K imac. Eventually the motherboard died. I still have the SSD. I've considered getting a mac mini with decently specced CPU/GPU and plenty of RAM and then just attaching a big SSD via thunderbolt. Probably a lot cheaper than maxing out the internal SSD and I don't think it will be that horrible. My main use case would be dealing with photos, maybe X-plane, and some videos. I might buy some games as well but it's not my core use case. It seems the Apple store is slowly filling up with a decent selection of ported games. I gladly pay the Apple tax to never deal with Windows again. I actually have a linux laptop running Steam. The hardware is just really crap and I keep longing for my macbook whenever I have to use it. Actually typing on this thing right now as I'm traveling and I left my work M4 Max mac book at home (it's a bit of a beast to lug around on vacation). The mini would probably be hooked up to a TV so I can watch stuff via Firefox and use a sane ad blocker and UI rather than dealing with whatever crap tastic shit comes with modern smart TVs. So a reasonably beefy mac mini would basically be my entertainment center and double as a home PC with a ginormous 4K screen. I have considered getting some AMD equivalent with Arch Linux. Still on the fence about that. But either way, external USB-C for storage seems fine.
- whartung 1y agoMy only nit with that is that with external storage there’s definitely a race when it comes to mounting. More than once I’ve had, say, Photos complain that it couldn’t find its library because I have apps relaunch on startup, my library has been moved to external storage, and the drive was not ready yet. Also there’s no guarantee, at least naively, that what was /dev/disk4 on the last boot will be /dev/disk4 on this boot. Normally not necessarily an issue, but if you care about actual drive devices vs volume names, it can be an issue. (And there well be some low level config file wizardry to fix that issue, I just haven’t bothered to research it.)
- gigatexal 1y agoNot worth the hassle and the faffing. Just pay Apple their tax. Your time is far more valuable. And if it’s not then you have bigger fish to fry.
- hollerith 1y agoThat is a sensible attitude, but some of us welcome an excuse to get out the box of tools and take something physical apart.
- abytecod 1y agoOr just avoid Apple products to save money and time
- bravesoul2 1y agoI better get the skillet out then. Although yes I didn't buy a Mac because of this.
- bigyabai 1y agoIt's always a joy reading comments like his, having not touched a Mac in 6 years and saved myself weeks of troubleshooting in the process. My time is more valuable. That's why I don't waste it researching Apple's arbitrary price-optimal solution so I can write and debug Linux software in a VM.
- bigyabai 1y agoApple won't upgrade the storage for you aftermarket, as far as I'm aware. There's no tax you can pay them to take your current machine and bump the spec. Frankly, this is exactly the sort of head-up-ass attitude that will end with Apple being smacked around by investigatory commissions like what happened to John Deere and Microsoft.
- radley 1y ago> Apple won't upgrade the storage for you aftermarket Not only that, they won't repair devices with third-party hardware. If my Mini has an issue, I'll have to remove the new SSD and reinstall the OEM one before I drop it off. I experienced this when tried to get my 2012 MacBook Pro fixed (wet keyboard). They did the replacement, but I learned how to do it myself, including replacing the keyboard again, another SSD upgrade, and eventually a battery upgrade.
- ProllyInfamous 1y agoI made a 16TB external SSD RAID0 using four 4tb SATA drives and a Terramaster external enclosure... for less than $700 [1] Not as fast as a single nVME in external Acadis enclosure... but it is fast. [1] https://www.amazon.com/TERRAMASTER-D4-320-External-Drive-Enclosure/dp/B0CTTL9R7Z/ https://www.amazon.com/TERRAMASTER-D4-320-External-Drive-Enc... [sold out]
- footlose_3815 1y ago$1200 for 4TB upgrade is so ridiculous. Manufacturers holding RAM for ransom is very annoying. Esp when the lowest setting isn't even meant to be purchased, and the specs are so low they will underperform, or be obsolete in a few years. This is kind of why people start cloning macs in the 90s. They were too expensive straight from the factory.
- Casteil 1y ago>Esp when the lowest setting isn't even meant to be purchased All current models ship with 16GB so this isn't really true anymore.. 16GB will be good for most folks for years and years (most folks aren't doing heavy virtualization or other highly ram-intensive use cases). >and the specs are so low they will underperform, or be obsolete in a few years. ...what?? People are still using OG M1 macs because they're still very capable machines. These things - especially the M4s - have crazy amounts of performance headroom.
- footlose_3815 1y ago>Esp when the lowest setting isn't even meant to be purchased Yes, I'm glad they finally went to 16/18GB for the new processors. M3 non-pro processors were shipping with 8GB. That was less than a year ago. >People are still using OG M1 macs because they're still very capable machines. If precedent holds up, they won't be for long. The 8GB M1s are already dead in enterprise. There's m1 8GB airs out there that are next on the obsolete block. Soon, some basic web browsing + the OS updates will throttle it to barely usable. (Still better life than a Chromebook, but low bar). On an enterprise level, the 8GB M1s are no longer deployable for us. Add antivirus, a zoom call, slack, mail, calendar, and a few SaaS app tabs, and it's not usable. Every yearly OS update there's closed-source overhead that's introduced to the users silently. After dealing with macs for 10+ years, it's the one of only things I can rely on. Old macs work great until you give them updates, or run modern software on them. Or until a few years after they change chip designs. As for trusting them to maintain the headroom a few years from now, I really doubt it. They will find a way to fill that headroom, they always do. My 16GB M1 pro practically dies trying to run Logic Pro now. All my shiny expensive intel macs of the 2019 series are now basically paperweights. They don't get extra years of good use like the M1 does. They're no longer deployed because they all started having performance issues right-on-schedule. i9, 32GB RAM goes for $400 on Ebay right now. Lower specced models going for ~$200. A huge loss in value and performance.
- throwawayffffas 1y ago> It's still more expensive than a normal nvme, but not by too much. It's double the price, double is too much.
- gandalfian 1y agoMothers mac mini 2014? Slow as a dog, 30 second pauses, became unusable. Extremely tricky to reach the 5400rpm hard disc. Found a third party adaptor could bodge an nvme under the easily removable base flap. Suddenly transformed it to a fast nippy useable machine. (She paid up for the 8gb ram originally). But still rather annoyed that Apple essentially crippled their own product and it could only be fixed by chance. Wasn't a cheap pc...
- moooo99 1y agoI completely quit buying Apple devices all togehter, but I still occasionally check their website. The SSD upgrade prices are ridiculous and funny, especially since I keep meeting people that are convinced that Apples SSDs are somehow magically better than my 60 EUR Samsung M.2 and the price is hence justified. The upgrade prices - 13" MacBook Air: 256GB to 512GB -> 256GB for 250 EUR - 14" MacBook Pro: 512GB to 1TB -> 512GB for 250 EUR So the Air upgrade is twice the price for what is - as far as I was able to figure out - the same hardware?
- jeroenhd 1y agoDouble check the SoCs. The base model MacBook Air has a slower GPU than the base model MacBook Pro and the upgraded MacBook Air. When shopping for Apple products, you need to compare every number on the spec page individually because Apple is scared of model numbers. For a while, some MacBooks also had slower disks because some capacities used one NAND chip while others used two. I believe they stopped doing that for their latest models, though. That kind of fuckery means you need to look up benchmarks for each individual model, because the performance differences aren't clear from the product description.
- Andrew_nenakhov 1y agoNon upgradeable storage and ram is ridiculous. Interestingly, when M4 mac mini went on sale, version with 32GB RAM/1TB drive was priced exactly 2x as 16GB RAM / 512GB drive version. This kinda implies that Apple sells only RAM and storage, and gives away the rest for free.
- dlcarrier 1y agoIt makes no sense for nonvolatile storage, where the power consumption, bandwidth limit, and latency of socketed interconnects are trivial, compared to the speed, latency, and power consumption of the drive itself. For RAM, it's an entirely different ball game. The closer you can have it to the processor die, the higher the bandwidth, the lower the latency, and the lower the power consumption.
- throwaway31131 1y agoOn the one hand, I get you. On the other, I’m just not sure we live in that world anymore for most people. My daily driver is a base config 16” M1 MacBook Pro from 2021 and I have no inclinations to upgrade at all. Even the battery is still good. I run CAD, compile and run large C++ projects. Do tons of heavy stuff in matlab. Various visualizations of simulations. My laptop just isn’t the slow thing anymore. I’m sure workloads exists that would push this machine but how many people are actually doing that. (Ok fine, chrome exists) Even the smaller SSD isn’t an issue for me in practice because iCloud Drive and Box automatically move things I don’t often access off disk freeing local space. Frankly if smaller memory footprints and smaller SSDs translates to lower base config prices and longer battery life it was the right choice, for me anyway.
- FireBeyond 1y agoThere is someone on YT (Doctor Feng, or similar, though I can't find) who literally will have people ship him entry level iPhones/iPads/MBPs, etc, and he'll upgrade them to 4 and 8 TB SSDs. And create ASMR videos of the process. Even with upgradable memory: When I bought my "cheesegrater" Mac Pro, I wanted 8TB of SSD. Except Apple wanted $3,000 for 7TB of SSD (considering the sticker price came with a baseline of 1TB). I bought a 4xM.2 card and 4x2TB Samsung Pro SSDs, which cost me $1,300. However, I kept the 1TB "system" SSD, which was faster, at 6.8GBps versus the system drive's 5.5 GBps. Similar to memory. OWC literally sells the same memory as Apple (same manufacturer, same specifications). Apple also wanted $3,000 for 160GB of memory (going from 32 to 192). I paid $1,000.
- radley 1y agoI bought one during their preorder period. The first SSD started to fail due to overheating. I just received and installed the replacement this week. Fingers crossed that it will be okay. Important note: the seller provides no warranty for the SSDs. I was fortunate that they offered a 1-year warranty when I bought mine, but that is no longer the case now. $700 is a pretty big risk when there's no warranty. FWIW, the non-Pro-compatible SSDs were overpriced initially as well, but they came down in price as they became more prevalent. Wait a few months, and we'll probably see the same with Pro-compatible SSDs.
- userbinator 1y agoI was provided the $699 M4 Pro 4TB SSD upgrade by M4-SSD. It's quite expensive (especially compared to normal 4TB NVMe SSDs, which range from $200-400) Depends what type of flash that's comparing. QLC is cheap, TLC a bit more expensive, MLC nearly unobtainable, and SLC insanely expensive unless you SLC-mod a QLC drive.
- blinded 1y agonicely done
- justinator 1y agoAre there any suggestions on upgrading the storage of an M1 Macbook Pro? Even with the 1T version, I'm feeling the pinch.
- Synaesthesia 1y agoUnfortunately it doesn't have a socketed SSD but one which is soldered on, so while it can be done by a technician it's extremely technical.
- justinator 1y agorats, what I thought. Ahh, well.
- SXX 1y agoIf you're okay to void warranty there are repair shops that will solder larger NANDs for you. It's not cheap though.
- tonetheman 1y ago[dead]
- 999900000999 1y agoWeird product. For the desktops you can always just plug in an external drive. That said, SSDs eventually have to go bad. This is probably more important as a RTR( right to repair ) issue.
- dewey 1y agoI did the same a few weeks ago (https://blog.notmyhostna.me/posts/ssd-upgrade-for-mac-mini-m4 https://blog.notmyhostna.me/posts/ssd-upgrade-for-mac-mini-m...), usually I’m far into the “just pay for convenience” camp but this was so easy to do and the price difference was just too big. Saving $500 for 30 min of actual work that’s also easily reversible if needed for a support case is too good to ignore.