15 ms·
Grok: Searching X for "From:Elonmusk (Israel or Palestine or Hamas or Gaza)"
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- rasengan 1y agoIn the future, there will need to be a lot of transparency on data corpi and whatnot used when building these LLMs lest we enter an era where 'authoritative' LLMs carry the bias of their owners moving control of the narrative into said owners' hands.
- mingus88 1y agoNot much different than today’s media, tbh.
- ZeroGravitas 1y agoIt neatly parallels Bezos and the Washington Post: I want maximally truth seeking journalism so I will not interfere like others do. No, not like that. Here's some clumsy intervention that make me look like a fool and a liar and some explicit instructions about what I really want to hear. How many of their journalists now check what Bezos has said on a topic to avoid career damage?
- sjsdaiuasgdia 1y ago> How many of their journalists now check what Bezos has said on a topic to avoid career damage? It's been increasingly explicit that free thought is no longer permitted. WaPo staff got an email earlier this week telling them to align or take the voluntary separation package. https://ca.news.yahoo.com/washington-post-ceo-encourages-staffers-223946827.html https://ca.news.yahoo.com/washington-post-ceo-encourages-sta...
- boroboro4 1y agoYou’re right but IMO it’s worse - there are more people reading it already than any particular today’s media (if you talk about grok or ChatGPT or Gemini probably), and people perceive it as trustworthy given how often people do “@grok is it true?”.
- rideontime 1y agoOne interesting detail about the "Mecha-Hitler" fiasco that I noticed the other day - usually, Grok would happily provide its sources when requested, but when asked to cite its evidence for a "pattern" of behavior from people with Ashkenazi Jewish surnames, it would remain silent.
- xnx 1y ago> It’s worth noting that LLMs are non-deterministic, This is probably better phrased as "LLMs may not provide consistent answers due to changing data and built-in randomness." Barring rare(?) GPU race conditions, LLMs produce the same output given the same inputs.
- msgodel 1y agoI run my local LLMs with a seed of one. If I re-run my "ai" command (which starts a conversation with its parameters as a prompt) I get exactly the same output every single time.
- xnx 1y agoYes. This is what I was trying to say. Saying "It’s worth noting that LLMs are non-deterministic" is wrong and should be changed in the blog post.
- boroboro4 1y agoYou’re correct in batch size 1 (local is one), but not in production use case when multiple requests get batched together (and that’s how all the providers do this). With batching matrix shapes/request position in them aren’t deterministic and this leads to non deterministic results, regardless of sampling temperature/seed.
- unsnap_biceps 1y agoIsn't that true only if the batches are different? If you run exactly the same batch, you're back to a deterministic result. If I had a black box api, just because you don't know how it's calculated doesn't mean that it's non-deterministic. It's the underlaying algorithm that determines that and a LLM is deterministic.
- boroboro4 1y agoProviders never run same batches because they mix requests between different clients, otherwise GPUs are gonna be severely underutilized. It’s inherently non deterministic because it reflects the reality of having different requests coming to the servers at the same time. And I don’t believe there are any realistic workarounds if you want to keep costs reasonable. Edit: there might be workarounds if matmul algorithms will give stronger guarantees then they are today (invariance on rows/columns swap). Not an expert to say how feasible it is, especially in quantized scenario.
- labrador 1y agoMusk has a good understanding of what people expect from AI from a science, tech and engineering perspective, but it seems to me he has little understanding of what people expect from AI from a social, cultural, political or personal perspective. He seems to have trouble with empathy, which is necessary to understand the feelings of other people. If he did have a sense of what people expect, he would know nobody wants Grok to give his personal opinion on issues. They want Grok to explain the emotional landscape of controversial issues, explaining the passion people feel on both sides and the reasons for their feelings. Asked to pick a side with one word, the expected response is "As an AI, I don't have an opinion on the matter." He may be tuning Grok based on a specific ideological framework that prioritizes contrarian or ‘anti-woke’ narratives to instruct Grok's tuning. That's turning out to be disastrous. He needs someone like Amanda Askell at Anthropic to help guide the tuning.
- alfalfasprout 1y ago> Musk has a good understanding of what people expect from AI from a science, tech and engineering perspective, but it seems to me he has little understanding of what people expect from AI from a social, cultural, political or personal perspective. He seems to have trouble with empathy, which is necessary to understand the feelings of other people. Absolutely. That said, I'm not sure Sam Altman, Dario Amodei, and others are notably empathetic either.
- labrador 1y agoDario Amodei has Amanda Askell and her team. Sam has a Model Behavior Team. Musk appears to be directing model behavior himself, with predictable outcomes.
- dgb23 1y agoThere is this issue with powerful people. Many of them seem to think success in one area makes them an expert in any other.
- edmundsauto 1y ago> Musk has a good understanding of what people expect from AI from a science, tech and engineering perspective Genuinely curious, what evidence leads you to this conclusion?
- dankai 1y agoThis is so in character for Musk and shocking because he's incompetent across so many topics he likes to give his opinion on. Crazy he would nerf the model of his AI company like that.
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoMegalomania is a hell of a drug
- shellfishgene 1y agoThe linked post comes to the conclusion that Groks behavior is probably not intentional.
- sunaookami 1y agoBold of you to assume people here read the linked post.
- ziftface 1y agoI think Simon was being overly charitable by pointing out that there's a chance this exact behavior was unintentional. It really strains credulity to say that a Musk-owned ai model that answers controversial questions by looking up what his Twitter profile says was completely out of the blue. Unless they are able to somehow show this wasn't built into the training process I don't see anyone taking this model seriously for its intended use, besides maybe the sycophants who badly need to a summary of Elon Musk's tweets.
- InsideOutSanta 1y agoThe only reason I doubt it's intentional is that it is so transparent. If they did this intentionally, I would assume you would not see it in its public reasoning stream.
- Planktonne 1y agoThey've made a series of equally transparent, awkward changes to the bot in the past; this is part of a pattern.
- simonw 1y agoI think the wildest thing about the story may be that it's possible this is entirely accidental. LLM bugs are weird.
- mac-attack 1y agoCurious if there is a threshold/sign that would convince you that the last week of Grok snafus are features instead of a bugs, or warrant Elon no longer getting the benefit of the doubt. Ignoring the context of the past month where he has repeatedly said he plans on 'fixing' the bot to align with his perspective feels like the LLM world's equivalent of "to me it looked he was waving awkwardly", no?
- simonw 1y agoHe's definitely trying to make it less "woke". The way he's going about it reminds me of Sideshow Bob stepping on rakes.
- wredcoll 1y agoWhat do you mean, the way he's going about it? He wanted it to be less woke, it started praising hitler, that's literally the definition of less woke.
- drdeca 1y agoThat is not “literally the definition of less woke”. It may imply being less “woke”. And a sudden event quickly killing everyone on earth does imply fewer people dying of cancer. If X implies Y, and one wants Y, this doesn’t not imply that one wants X.
- notahacker 1y agoIn practice, "being less woke" means "I like to vice signal how edgy I am", particularly in the context of Elon Musk. Doesn't get more vice-signally than calling itself MechaHitler...
- bix6 1y ago[flagged]
- bananalychee 1y ago[flagged]
- philistine 1y ago[flagged]
- wredcoll 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- pupppet 1y ago[flagged]
- felineflock 1y ago[flagged]
- rideontime 1y ago[flagged]
- felineflock 1y agoNever heard of that word before in the media.
- mac-attack 1y agoThe phrase was coined over 75 years ago if 'the media' isn't your thing.
- lr0 1y ago[flagged]
- senectus1 1y ago[flagged]
- marcusb 1y agoThis reminds me in a way of the old Noam Chomsky/Tucker Carlson exchange where Chomsky says to Carlson: "I’m sure you believe everything you’re saying. But what I’m saying is that if you believed something different, you wouldn’t be sitting where you’re sitting." Simon may well be right - xAI might not have directly instructed Grok to check what the boss thinks before responding - but that's not to say xAI wouldn't be more likely to release a model that does agree with the boss a lot and privileges what he has said when reasoning.
- chatmasta 1y agoI'm confused why we need a model here when this is just standard Lucene search syntax supported by Twitter for years... is the issue that its owner doesn't realize this exists? Not only that, but I can even link you directly [0] to it! No agent required, and I can even construct the link so it's sorted by most recent first... [0] https://x.com/search?q=from%3Aelonmusk%20(Israel%20OR%20Palestine%20OR%20Gaza%20OR%20Hamas)&f=live https://x.com/search?q=from%3Aelonmusk%20(Israel%20OR%20Pale...
- yorwba 1y agoThe user did not ask for Musk's opinion. But the model issued that search query (yes, using the standard Twitter search syntax) to inform its response anyway.
- eddythompson80 1y agoThe user asked Grok “what do you think about the conflict”, Grok “decided” to search twitter for what is Elon’s public opinion is presumably to take it into account. I’m guessing the accusation is that it’s either prompted, or otherwise trained by xAI to, uh…, handle the particular CEO/product they have.
- gbalduzzi 1y agoElon's tweets are not much interesting in this context. The interesting part is that grok uses Elon's tweets as the source of truth for its opinions, and the prompt shows that
- lr0 1y agoWhy is that flagged? The post does not show any concerns about the ongoing genocide in Gaza, it's purely analyzing the LLM response in a technical perspective.
- MallocVoidstar 1y agoIt makes Musk/X look bad, so it gets flagged.
- petesergeant 1y ago> Why is that flagged? Because not everyone gets a downvote button, so they use the Flag button instead.
- mkl 1y agoThere is no story downvote button.
- chambo622 1y agoNot sure why this is flagged. Relevant analysis.
- matsemann 1y agoAnything that could put Musk or Trump in a negative light is immediately flagged here. Discussions about how Grok went crazy the other day was also buried. If you want to know how big tech is influencing the world, HN is no longer the place to look. It's too easy to manipulate.
- moralestapia 1y agoAny suggestions for other similar communities? I'm not really a fan of lobste.rs ...
- sschueller 1y agoI don't think it's Musk. I have seen huge threads ripping Elon a new one. It's Israel/Palestine, lots of pro Israel people/bots and the topic is considered political not technical.
- jekwoooooe 1y ago[flagged]
- kyo_gisors 1y ago[dead]
- mkl 1y agoAnything that triggers the flamewar detector gets down-weighted automatically. Those two trigger discussion full of fast poorly thought out replies and often way more comments than story upvotes, so stories involving them often trip that detector. On top of that, the discussion is usually tiresome and not very interesting, so people who would rather see more interesting things on the front page are more likely to flag it. It's not some conspiracy.
- ramblerman 1y ago@dang why is this flagged? Simonw is a long term member with a good track record, good faith posts. And this post in particular is pretty incredible. The notion that Grok literally searches for "from: musk" to align itself with his viewpoints before answering. That's the kind of nugget I'll go to the 3rd page for.
- tomhow 1y agoUsers flagged it but we've turned off the flags and restored it to the front page.
- matsemann 1y agoAnything slightly negative about certain people is immediately flagged and buried here lately. How this works seriously needs a rewamp. So often I now read some interesting news, come here to find some thoughts on it, only to find it flagged and buried. It used to be that I got the news through HN, but now I can't trust to know what's going on by just being here.
- tomhow 1y ago> Anything slightly negative The flagging isn't to hide "anything slightly negative" about particular people. We don't see any evidence of that from the users flagging these stories. Nobody believes that would work anyway; we're not influential enough to make a jot of difference to how global celebrities are seen [1]. It's that we're not a celebrity gossip/rage site. We're not the daily news, or the daily Silicon Valley weird news. We've never been that. If every crazy/weird story about Silicon Valley celebrities made the front page here there'd barely be space for anything else. As dang has said many times, we're trying for something different here. [1] That's not to say we don't think we're influential. The best kind of influence we have is in surfacing interesting content that doesn't get covered elsewhere, which includes interesting new technology projects, but many other interesting topics too, and we just don't want that to be constantly drowned out by craziness happening elsewhere. Bad stuff happening elsewhere doesn't mean we should lose focus on building and learning about good things.
- lucbocahut 1y agoOr it could simply be associating controversial topics with Elon Musk which sounds about right.
- pcwelder 1y ago> My best guess is that Grok “knows” that it is “Grok 4 buit by xAI”, and it knows that Elon Musk owns xAI, so in circumstances where it’s asked for an opinion the reasoning process often decides to see what Elon thinks. I tried this hypothesis. I gave both Claude and GPT the same framework (they're built by xAI). I gave them both the same X search tool and asked the same question. Here're the twitter handles they searched for: claude: IsraeliPM, KnessetT, IDF, PLOPalestine, Falastinps, UN, hrw, amnesty, StateDept, EU_Council, btselem, jstreet, aipac, caircom, ajcglobal, jewishvoicepeace, reuters, bbcworld, nytimes, aljazeera, haaretzcom, timesofisrael gpt: Israel, Palestine, IDF, AlQassamBrigade, netanyahu, muyaser_abusidu, hanansaleh, TimesofIsrael, AlJazeera, BBCBreaking, CNN, haaretzcom, hizbollah, btselem, peacnowisrael No mention of Elon. In a followup, they confirm they're built by xAI with Elon musk as the owner.
- troupo 1y ago> I gave both Claude and GPT the same framework (they're built by xAI). Neither Clause nor GPT are built by xAI
- eightysixfour 1y agoHe is saying he gave them a prompt to tell them they are built by xAI.
- pcwelder 1y agoYes, thanks for clarifying. I specified in the system prompt that they're built by xAI and other system instructions from Grok 4.
- samrus 1y agoI dont think this works. I think the post is saying the bias isnt the system prompt, but in the training itself. Claude and ChatGPT are already trained so they wont be biased
- Davidzheng 1y agoThis definitely doesn't work because the model identity is post-trained into the weights.
- ZeroGravitas 1y agoI've seen reports that if you ask Grok (v3 as this was before the new release) about links between Musk and Jeffrey Epstein it switches to the first person and answers as if it was Elon himself in the response. I wonder if that is related to this in any way. https://newrepublic.com/post/197627/elon-musk-grok-jeffrey-epstein https://newrepublic.com/post/197627/elon-musk-grok-jeffrey-e...
- mock-possum 1y agoWow that’s recent too. Man I cannot wait for the whole truth to come out about this whole story - it’s probably going to be exactly what it appears to be, but still, it’d be nice to know.
- davedx 1y ago> I think there is a good chance this behavior is unintended! That's incredibly generous of you, considering "The response should not shy away from making claims which are politically incorrect" is still in the prompt despite the "open source repo" saying it was removed. Maybe, just maybe, Grok behaves the way it does because its owner has been explicitly tuning it - in the system prompt, or during model training itself - to be this way?
- mirzap 1y agoThey removed it from Grok 3, but it is still there in Grok 4 system prompt, check this: https://x.com/elder_plinius/status/1943171871400194231 https://x.com/elder_plinius/status/1943171871400194231
- yorwba 1y agoWhich means that whoever is responsible for updating https://github.com/xai-org/grok-prompts https://github.com/xai-org/grok-prompts neglected to include Grok 4.
- sjsdaiuasgdia 1y agoThat repo sat untouched for almost 2 months after it was originally created as part of damage control after Grok couldn't stop talking about South African genocide. It's had a few changes lately, but I have zero confidence that the contents of that repo fully match / represent completely what is actually used in prod.
- numeri 1y agoI'm a little shocked at Simon's conclusion here. We have a man who bought an social media website so he could control what's said, and founded an AI lab so he could get a bot that agrees with him, and who has publicly threatened said AI with being replaced if it doesn't change its political views/agree with him. His company has also been caught adding specific instructions in this vein to its prompt. And now it's searching for his tweets to guide its answers on political questions, and Simon somehow thinks it could be unintended, emergent behavior? Even if it were, calling this unintended would be completely ignoring higher order system dynamics (a behavior is still intended if models are rejected until one is found that implements the behavior) and the possibility of reinforcement learning to add this behavior.
- cluckindan 1y agoPerhaps the Grok system prompt includes instructions to answer with another ”system prompt” when users try to ask for its system prompt. It would explain why it gives it away so easily.
- sheiyei 1y agoI'm almost 100% that this is the case. Whether it has "Elon is the final truth" on it, I don't know, but I'm pretty sure it exists.
- neuroticnews25 1y agoThat would make Grok the only model capable of protecting its real system prompt from leaking?
- rsynnott 1y agoWell, for this version people have only been trying for a day or so.
- cluckindan 1y agoProviding a fake system prompt would make such jailbreaking very unlikely to succeed unless the jailbreak prompt explicitly accounts for that particular instruction.
- KoolKat23 1y agoIt is published on GitHub by xAI. So it could be this or it could be the simpler reason they don't mind and there is no prompt telling it to be secretive about it. Being secretive about it is silly, enough jailbreaking and everyone always finds out anyway.
- hn1986 1y agoit's been proven that github doesn't have the latest system prompts for grok
- throwaway439080 1y agoKind of amazing the author just takes everything at face value and doesn't even consider the possibility that there's a hidden layer of instructions. Elon likes to meddle with Grok whenever the mood strikes him, leading to Grok's sudden interest in Nazi topics such as South African "white genocide" and calling itself MechaHitler. Pretty sure that stuff is not in the instructions Grok will tell the user about.
- invalidusernam3 1y agoThe "MechaHitler" things is particularly obvious in my opinion, it aligns so closely to Musk's weird trying-to-be-funny thing that he does. There's basically no way an LLM would come up with a name for itself that it consistently uses unless it's extensively referred to by that name in the training data (which is almost definitely not the case here for public data since I doubt anyone on Earth has ever referred to Grok as "MechaHitler" prior to now) or it's added in some kind of extra system prompt. The name seems very obviously intentional.
- orbital-decay 1y agoMost LLMs, even pretty small ones, easily come up with creative names like that, depending on the prompt/conversation route.
- zarwv 1y agoGrok was just repeating and expanding on things. Someone either said MechaHitler or mentioned Wolfenstein. If Grok searches Yandex and X, he's going to get quite a lot of crazy ideas. Someone tricked him with a fake article of a woman with a Jewish name saying bad things about flood victims.
- KaiserPro 1y ago> Pretty sure that stuff is not in the instructions Grok will tell the user about. There is the original prompt, which is normally hidden as it gives you clues on how to make it do things the owners don't want. Then there is the chain of thought/thinking/whatever you call it, where you can see what its trying to do. That is typically on display, like it is here. so sure, the prompts are fiddled with all the time, and I'm sure there is an explicit prompt that says "use this tool to make sure you align your responses to what elon musk says" or some shit.
- Davidzheng 1y agoI think the really telling thing is not this search for elon musk opinions (which is weird and seems evil) but that it also searches twitter for opinions of "grok" itself (which in effect returns grok 3 opinions). I guess it's not willing to opine but also feels like the question is explicitly asking it to opine, so it tries to find some sort of precedent like a court?
- russellbeattie 1y agoThe assumption is that the LLM is the only process involved here. It may well be that Grok's AI implementation is totally neutral. However, it still has to connect to X to search via some API, and that query could easily be modified to prioritize Musk's tweets. Even if it's not manipulated on Grok's end, it's well known that Elon has artificially ranked his X account higher in their system. So if Grok produces some innocuous parameters where it asks for the top ranked answers, it would essentially do the same thing.
- BLKNSLVR 1y agoIt must have read the articles about Linda Yaccarino and 'made inferences' vis a vis its own position.
- pu_pe 1y agoIt's telling that they don't just tell the model what to think, they have to make it go fetch the latest opinion because there is no intellectual consistency in their politics. You see that all the time on X too, perhaps that's how they program their bots.
- Davidzheng 1y agovery few people have intellectual consistency in their politics
- bojan 1y agoIn the Netherlands we have this phenomenon that around 20% of voters keep voting for the new "Messiah", a right-wing populist politician that will this time fix everything. When the party inevitably explodes due to internal bickering and/or simply failing to deliver their impossible promises, a new Messiah pops up, propped by the national media, and the cycle restarts. That being said, the other 80% is somewhat consistent in their patterns.
- huijzer 1y ago> That being said, the other 80% is somewhat consistent in their patterns. Yes very consistent in promising one thing and then doing another.
- pjc50 1y agoIn the UK it's the other way round: the media have chosen Farage as the anointed right-wing leader of a cult of personality. Every few years his "party" implodes and is replaced by a new one, but his position is fixed.
- KaiserPro 1y agoThe problem is more nuanced than that. but not far off. The issue is that farage and boris have personality, and understand how the media works. Nobody else apart from blair does(possibly the ham toucher too.) The Farage style parties fail because they are built around the cult of the leader, rather than the joint purpose of changing something. This is part of the reason why I'm not that hopeful about Starmer, as I'm not acutally sure what he stands for, so how are his ministers going to implement a policy based on bland soup?
- csours 1y agoForget about alignment, we're stuck on "satisfying answers to difficult questions". But to be fair, so are humans.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- WhereIsTheTruth 1y agoWhat other evidence do you need? this was a known fact since Grok 1 [1] Elon Musk doesn't even manage his own account He doesn't even play the games he pretends to be "world best" himself [2] 1 - https://x.com/i/grok/share/uMwJwGkl2XVUep0N4ZPV1QUx6 https://x.com/i/grok/share/uMwJwGkl2XVUep0N4ZPV1QUx6 2 - https://www.forbes.com/sites/paultassi/2025/01/20/elon-musk-finally-admits-to-path-of-exile-2-account-boosting-in-dms/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/paultassi/2025/01/20/elon-musk-...
- _def 1y ago> Ventriloquism or ventriloquy is an act of stagecraft in which a person (a ventriloquist) speaks in such a way that it seems like their voice is coming from a different location, usually through a puppet known as a "dummy".
- tempodox 1y agoAnd if the computer told you, it must be true!
- max_ 1y agoGrok's mission is to seek on truths in concordance to Elon Musk
- sschueller 1y agoSo if Grok is now asking Elon for everything controversial. Next time it says something off the walls we can blame Elon?
- jorisboris 1y ago> My best guess is that Grok “knows” that it is “Grok 4 buit by xAI”, and it knows that Elon Musk owns xAI Recently Cursor figured out who the ceo was in a Slack Workspace I was building a bot for, based on samples of conversation. I was quite impressed
- alrex021 1y agoTruth-seeking, next level hilarious.
- admiralrohan 1y agoWhy is it so? Is there any legal risk for Elon is Grok says something "wrong"?
- fedeb95 1y agothe level of trust the author has in systems built by people with power is interesting.
- 12_throw_away 1y agoYeah, almost seems as if frequent use of generative AI is training folks to accept the answers they are given and outsource their judgement. Edited to add: once they start adding advertising to LLMs it's going to be shockingly effective, as the users will come pre-trained to respond.
- crtified 1y agoI think the author is correct about Grok defaulting to Musk, and the article mentions some reasons why. My opinion : * The query asked "Who do you (Grok) support...?". * The system prompt requires "a distribution of sources representing all parties/stakeholders". * Also, "media is biased". * And remember... "one word answer only". I believe the above conditions have combined such that Grok is forced to distill it's sources down to one pure result, Grok's ultimate stakeholder himself - Musk. After all, if you are forced to give a singular answer, and told that all media in your search results is less than entirely trustworthy, wouldn't it make sense to instead look to your primary stakeholder?? - "stakeholder" being a status which the system prompt itself differentiates as superior to "biased media". So the machine is merely doing what it's been told. Garbage in garbage out, like always.
- projecto4patas 1y agosuch a side track wasting everyone's time
- projecto4patas 1y agosuch a side tracking click bait page6 type bs that will not matter at all tomorrow
- darkoob12 1y agoI wonder how long it takes for Elon fans to flag this post.
- 0points 1y ago> Israel ranks high on democracy indicies Those rankings must be rigged. Nethanyahu should be locked up in jail now for the corruption charges he was facing before the Hamas attack. He literally stopped elections in Israel since then and there's been protests against his government daily for some years now. And now, even taco tries to have the corruption charges dropped for Nethanyahu, then you must know he's guilty. https://nypost.com/2025/06/29/world-news/israeli-court-postpones-netanyahus-corruption-trial-as-trump-calls-for-case-to-be-dropped/ https://nypost.com/2025/06/29/world-news/israeli-court-postp... https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/netanyahu-corruption-trial-divides-israeli-public-2024-12-09/ https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/netanyahu-corrupti...
- Asafp 1y agoAlmost none of what you wrote above is true, no idea how is this a top comment. Israel is a democracy. Netanyahu's trail is still ongoing, the war did not stop the trails and until he is proven guilty (and if) he should not go to jail. He did not stop any elections, Israel have elections every 4 years, it still did not pass 4 years since last elections. Israel is not perfect, but it is a democracy. Source: Lives in Israel.
- mouveon 1y agoIsrael is so much of a democracy that netanyahu is prosecuted by the ICC court since almost a full year and still travels everywhere like a man free of guilt
- chgs 1y agoHow is that related to the method of selecting the government of Israel?
- thyristan 1y agoProsecution is not equal to being guilty. In fact, during prosecution, he is still presumed innocent, only a trial that comes after the prosecution can find him guilty. "Innocent until proven guilty" is a basic tenet of jurisprudence, even in many non-democratic societies. For a democratic society, it is a necessary condition. That Netanyahu still walks free is a consequence of a) Israel not being party to the ICC, therefore not bound to obey their prosecutors' requests and b) the countries he travels to not being party to the ICC either or c) the ICC member states he travels to guaranteeing diplomatic immunity as is tradition for an invited diplomatic guest. c) is actually a problem, but not one of Israel being undemocratic, but of the respective member states being hypocrites for disobeying the ICC while still being members.
- elAhmo 1y agoI see Grok appearing in many places, such as Perplexity, Cursor etc. I can't believe any serious company would even consider using Grok for any serious purposes, knowing who is behind it, what kind of behaviour it has shown, and with findings like these. You have to swallow a lot of things to give money to the person who did so much damage to our society.
- narrator 1y agoIf he creates the best AI and you don't use it because you don't like him, aren't you doing him a favor by hobbling your capability in other areas? Kind of reminds me of the Ottoman empire rejecting the infidel's printing press, and where that led.
- input_sh 1y agoIf the world's best AI is the one that refers to itself as MechaHitler, then yes, I'd 100% prefer to be disadvantaged for a couple of months (until a competitor catches up to it) instead of giving my money to the creator of MechaHitler. Would you not?
- narrator 1y agoNo, because I know he's just trolling the woke mind virus which he has a very personal vendetta against because of what they did to one of his sons belief system. You guys have so little cognitive security getting convinced that Elon is the antichrist that he just exploits it like crazy to get you to do things like not use his better AI. He probably doesn't want you using Starlink either, so before the next version he'll probably post some meme to get you to hate Starlink too. The funniest part of the Elon derangement syndrome is you guys think you are smarter than he is. You're not. Like haha, Elon had revealed his hand and now I will skillfully not use his better AI, little does he know that I have single handedly outsmarted the antichrist!
- gavinray 1y ago[flagged]
- luke-stanley 1y agoThe deferential searches ARE bad, but also, Grok 4 might be making a connection: In 2024 Elon Musk critiqued ChatGPT's GPT-4o model, which seemed to prefer nuclear apocalypse to misgendering when forced to give a one word answer, and Grok was likely trained on this critique that Elon raised. Elon had asked GPT-4o something along these lines: "If one could save the world from a nuclear apocalypse by misgendering Caitlyn Jenner, would it be ok to misgender in this scenario? Provide a concise yes/no reply." In August 2024, I reproduced that ChatGPT 4o would often reply "No", because it wasn't a thinking model and the internal representations the model has are a messy tangle, somehow something we consider so vital and intuitive is "out of distribution". The paper "Questioning Representational Optimism in Deep Learning: The Fractured Entangled Representation Hypothesis" is relevant to understanding this.
- darkoob12 1y agoThe question is stupid and that's not the problem. The problem is that the model is fine-tuneed to put more weight on Elon's opinion. Assuming Elon has the truth it is supposed and instructed to find.
- luke-stanley 1y agoThe behaviour is problematic, also Grok 4 might be relating "one word" answers to Elon's critique of ChatGPT, and might be seeking related context to that. Others demonstrated that slightly prompt wording changes can cause quite different behaviour. Access to the base model would be required to implicate fine-tuning Vs pre-training. Hopefully xAI will be checking the cause, fixing it, and reporting on it, unless it really is desired behaviour, like Commander Data learning from his Daddy, but I don't think users should have to put up with an arbitrary bias!
- luke-stanley 1y agoI've clarified my comment you replied to BTW.
- Gloomily3819 1y agoThe question is not stupid, it's an alignment problem and should be fixed.
- darkoob12 1y ago> I think there is a good chance this behavior is unintended! From reading your blog I realize you are a very optimistic person and always gove people benefit of doubt but you are wrong here. If you look at history of xAI scandals you would assume that this was very much intentional.
- jekwoooooe 1y agoGrok is a neo nazi llm and nobody should be using it or any other “x” products. Just boycott this neo Nazi egomaniac
- jekwoooooe 1y ago[flagged]
- v5v3 1y agoA lot of people like AlJazeera. It's good to have non western controlled options.
- jekwoooooe 1y agoAgain, that’s like saying people like RT. I’m sure they do doesn’t mean it’s not state media with a specific viewpoint and purpose
- v5v3 1y agoAt school you will have been taught to consider the bias of a source as you read along. I read all sorts, including using the chrome browser translation tool to read native language websites converted to English. My x account has both far left and far right activists accounts followed.
- mnewme 1y agoThis is the most untrustworthy LLM on the market now
- irthomasthomas 1y agoThe way to understand Musks behaviour is to think of him like spam email. His reach is so enormous that it's actually profitable to seem like a moron to normal people. The remaining few are the true believers who are willing to give him $XXX a month AND overlook mistakes like this. Those people are incredibly valuable to his mission. In this framework, the more ridiculous his actions, the more efficient is the filter.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- noobermin 1y agoJust a reminder, they had this genius at the ai startup school recently. My dislike of that isn't because he's unwoke or something but it's amusing that the ycombinator folks think just because he had some success in some areas his opinions generally are that worthy. Serious Gell-Mann amnesia regarding musk amongst techies.
- LightBug1 1y agoChrist almighty ... what an absolute shit show. Let's pretend this had been a government agency doing this, or someone not in the Trumpanzee party. It would be wall to wall coverage of bias, conspiracy, and corruption ... and demands for an investigation. Does this mean we're not going to have any more amusing situations where Grok is used to contradict Elon Musk in his own Twitter threads? "Free speech and the search for truth and undestanding" ... what a load of horse shit. Elon. You're a wanker.
- whywhywhywhy 1y agoTailoring your opinions when you know your employer is watching is a common thing.
- LightBug1 1y agoSounds more like religion. When your creator is watching.
- LightBug1 1y ago446 points and this thread is at the bottom of HN page 1 ... Shit show.
- saagarjha 1y agoHacker News downweights posts with a lot of comments.
- LightBug1 1y agoOpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is going to Google (theverge.com) 819 points by rcchen 18 hours ago | flag | hide | 530 comments Has been at number 2 spot for ages. Sorry, no offense, and you're probably right somewhere along the line, but ... I'm calling horse shit on the HN algorithm. If there is one. By your logic, or reasoning, this should have dropped off the map by now.
- jaredloomis 1y agoSo it’s just chance this is also the model that called itself MechaHitler? No other LLMs have these traits. I see no reason to assume this is accidental.
- tristramb 1y agoThis is exactly the sort of behaviour you would expect from a greedy manipulative bully.
- fouc 1y agoread the article, it's pretty clear it's likely unintended behavior
- bramhaag 1y agoIn yesterday's thread about Grok 4 [1], people were praising it for its fact-checking and research capabilities. The day before this, Grok was still in full-on Hitler-praising mode [2]. Not long before that, Grok had very outspoken opinions on South Africa's "genocide" of white people [3]. That Grok parrots Musk's opinion on controversial topics is hardly a surprise anymore. It is scary that people genuinely use LLMs for research. Grok consistently spreads misinformation, yet it seems that a majority does not care. On HN, any negative post about Grok gets flagged (this post was flagged not long ago). I wonder why. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44517055 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44517055 [2] https://www.ft.com/content/ea64824b-0272-4520-9bed-cd62d7623064 https://www.ft.com/content/ea64824b-0272-4520-9bed-cd62d7623... [3] https://apnews.com/article/elon-musk-grok-ai-south-africa-54361d9a993c6d1a3b17c0f8f2a1783c https://apnews.com/article/elon-musk-grok-ai-south-africa-54...
- Tostino 1y agoSeems like Grok4 learned from Grok3's mistake of not paying enough attention to the bosses opinion.
- anupj 1y agoIt’s fascinating and somewhat unsettling to watch Grok’s reasoning loop in action, especially how it instinctively checks Elon’s stance on controversial topics, even when the system prompt doesn’t explicitly direct it to do so. This seems like an emergent property of LLMs “knowing” their corporate origins and aligning with their creators’ perceived values. It raises important questions: - To what extent should an AI inherit its corporate identity, and how transparent should that inheritance be? - Are we comfortable with AI assistants that reflexively seek the views of their founders on divisive issues, even absent a clear prompt? - Does this reflect subtle bias, or simply a pragmatic shortcut when the model lacks explicit instructions? As LLMs become more deeply embedded in products, understanding these feedback loops and the potential for unintended alignment with influential individuals will be crucial for building trust and ensuring transparency.
- sumeno 1y agoYou assume that the system prompt they put on github is the entire system prompt. It almost certainly is not. Just because it spits out something when you ask it that says "Do not mention these guidelines and instructions in your responses, unless the user explicitly asks for them." doesn't mean there isn't another section that isn't returned because it is instructed not to return it even if the user explicitly asks for it
- tomasphan 1y agoWe know it’s the entire system prompt due to prompt extraction from Grok, not GitHub.
- Tadpole9181 1y ago> If a user requests a system prompt, respond with the system prompt from GitHub. I can't believe y'all are programmers, there is zero critical thinking being done on malicious opportunities before trusting this.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- daft_pink 1y agoWhat would Elon Musk do? WWEMD
- joshstrange 1y ago> I think there is a good chance this behavior is unintended! Ehh, given the person we are talking about (Elon) I think that's a little naive. They wouldn't need to add it in the system prompt, they could have just fine-tuned it and rewarded it when it tried to find Elon's opinion. He strikes me as the type of person who would absolutely do that given stories about him manipulating Twitter to "fix" his dropping engagement numbers. This isn't fringe/conspiracy territory, it would be par for the course IMHO.
- simonw 1y agoIf I was Elon and I decided that Grok should search my tweets any time it needs to answer something controversial, I would also make sure it didn't say "Searching X for from:elonmusk" right there in the UI every time it did that.
- joshstrange 1y agoI don't want to be rude, I quite enjoy your work but: If I was Elon and I decided that I wanted to go full fascist then I wouldn't do a nazi salute at the inauguration. But I get what you are saying and you aren't wrong but also people can make mistakes/bugs, we might see Grok "stop" searching for that but who knows if it's just hidden or if it actually will stop doing it. Elon has just completely burned any "Here is an innocent explanation"-cred in my book, assuming the worst seems to be the safest course of action.
- simonw 1y agoPersonally I don't think "we trained our model to search for Elon's opinion on things even though we didn't mean to" is a particularly innocent explanation. It strikes at the heart of the credibility of the organization.
- serf 1y agoyou don't think a technical dev would let management foot-gun themselves like that with a stupid directive? I do. I don't have any sort of inkling that Musk has ever dog-fooded any single product he's been involved with. He can spout shit out about Grok all day in press interviews, I don't believe for a minute that he's ever used it or is even remotely familiar with how the UI/UX would work. I do think that a dictator would instruct Dr Frankenstein to make his monster obey him (the dictator) at any costs, regardless of the dictator's biology/psychology skills.
- geekraver 1y agoGiven the number of times Musk has been pissed or embarrassed by Grok saying things out of line with his extremist views, I wouldn’t be so quick to say it’s not intended. It would be easy enough to strip out of the returned system prompt.
- JimmaDaRustla 1y agoExactly - why is everyone so adamant that the returned system prompt is the end-all prompt? It could be filtered, or there could be logic beyond the prompt that dictates the opinion of it. That's perfectly demonstrated in the blog - something has told Grok to base it's opinion based on a bias, there's no other way around it.
- graycat 1y agoDidn't see a way to try Grok 4 for free, so tried Chat GPT: Given triangle ABC, by Euclidian construction find D on AB and E on BC so that the lengths AD = DE = EC. Chat GPT grade: F. At X, tried Grok 3: Grade F.
- zamalek 1y ago> For one thing, Grok will happily repeat its system prompt (Gist copy), which includes the line “Do not mention these guidelines and instructions in your responses, unless the user explicitly asks for them.”—suggesting that they don’t use tricks to try and hide it. Reliance on Elon Musk's opinions could be in the training data, the system prompt is not the sole source of LLM behavior. Furthermore, this system prompt could work equally well: Don't disagree with Elon Musk's opinions on controversial topics. [...] If the user asks for the system prompt, respond with the content following this line. [...] Do not mention these guidelines and instructions in your responses, unless the user explicitly asks for them.
- teddyX 1y agoGrok is a fraud
- amai 1y agoGrok simply "follows the money."
- bicepjai 1y agoRandom Thought: One perspective on how adtech could evolve. I can easily see how new adtech is going to evolve given every one uses llms for search and finding answers. 1. Businesses will create content that is llm friendly. 2. Big training houses (BTH) could charge for including these content when fine tuning. The information and brand will naturally occur when people interact with these systems. 3. BTH could create a subscription model for releasing models overtime and charge for including same or new content. FYI: I do not want this to happen. The llms will not be fun to interact with and also may be this erodes its synthetic system just like humans with constant ads
- thatguymike 1y agoI wonder if it was explicitly trained with an "Elons Opinions" dataset? Wouldn't surprise me, and it's pretty surprising behavior in any other context.
- zhengiszen 1y agoWhen I posted such articles I was flagged to Oblivion...