5 ms·
After successfully entering Earth's atmosphere, a European spacecraft is lost
- anovikov 1y agoSurprisingly good result on a surprisingly low budget. I totally didn't expect a European company to make it. If it phoned home after reentry it means the hard part is done.
- notahacker 1y agoThe Exploration Company know what they're doing and execute fast. Contrary to popular belief on here this is possible from Europe...
- tekla 1y agoOf course, they rely on SpaceX because Europe doesn't have enough launch capacity to support their launch rate (1/year at best)
- pfdietz 1y agoEurope decided that the priority purpose of their launch industry was to provide jobs, not competitive launches.
- boricj 1y agoThe primary purpose of the traditional European launch industry is to provide an independent launch capability for government payloads. Cost is irrelevant because the French government in particular wants to be able to launch payloads into orbit without depending on anyone else to do so.
- pfdietz 1y agoIt's failing at that too, in the same sense that maintaining a sailing ship fleet would have failed to provide independent seafaring capability in the latter half of the 19th century. SpaceX has greatly raised the bar on what can be considered an "independent launch capability." Europe under the current system is greatly limited on what they can imagine doing in space. The equivalent of Starlink is not feasible, for example. Underlying all this was a failure of vision, an assumption that use of space would be static and change only slowly, if at all, and that launch cost could not be significantly reduced.
- mjevans 1y agoWouldn't it be nice if buying a space launch vehicle were like purchasing a car, instead of (a military) aircraft? For that same matter, maybe that's part of what went wrong with the aircraft manufacturing business in America. The market really should not have been allowed to consolidate that much; to the point where incentives aligned to financial and regulatory capture / stasis (and pilots only certified on one type of flight vehicle), rather than someone skilled to operate a general aviation vehicle. Though with cars we do have a fairly standardized control scheme, at least for the most important parts. Steering wheel, go and stop foot levers.
- metalman 1y agoheres a gaggle og MIGS, but name your flavor https://www.barnstormers.com/cat_search.php?headline=MIG&body=&part_num=&mfg=&model=&user__profile__company=&user__last_name=&user__first_name=&user__profile__country=&specialcase__state=&user__profile__city=&user__profile__uzip=&specialcase__phone=&user__email=&my_cats__name=&price__gte=&price__lte=&search_type=advanced&keyword= https://www.barnstormers.com/cat_search.php?headline=MIG&bod...
- cpgxiii 1y ago> For that same matter, maybe that's part of what went wrong with the aircraft manufacturing business in America. The market really should not have been allowed to consolidate that much ... Consolidation was an inevitable result of the end of the Cold War and massive cuts to defense spending. The defense industry was _encouraged_ to consolidate because the alternative would have been bankruptcy. Obviously, time has shown that this consolidation was bad for the industry and the government, but a lot has happened in the last 35 years that would not have been foreseen then. > to the point where incentives aligned to financial and regulatory capture / stasis (and pilots only certified on one type of flight vehicle), rather than someone skilled to operate a general aviation vehicle The type rating structure really has quite little to do with aerospace industry consolidation (if anything, the industry is too fractured to allow for more generic type ratings). Aircraft, their systems, and their flight dynamics are different enough that trying to create a more general type rating would really be impossible. What you do see are families of aircraft which either completely share a type rating or require very limited additional training to maintain a rating for multiple family types (e.g. all 737s, 757/767, 777/787, A32x/A33x/A35x). Single piston GA aircraft are really the exception, not because they all share the same behavior (there is a truly wild range of flight dynamics and avionics), but because the GA community (particularly in the US) is so large and established that requiring more training/experience is politically impossible. So long as GA accidents don't kill too many bystanders, this will remain the case.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 1y agoAnd? So does everyone else, because Transporter rideshares are cheap and incubating your own rocket programme isn't. SpaceX relies on Europe and Taiwan for its semiconductors. Does the fact SpaceX can't be adequately served by domestic capacity and their in-house semiconductor programme is just getting started mean they don't execute?! Or is it just a little thing called trade that Americans used to believe in?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> SpaceX relies on Europe and Taiwan for its semiconductors Used and relies on aren’t interchangeable. (To the extent there is reliance, it’s more on Taiwan than Europe.)
- notahacker 1y agotbh launch is at least as commoditised as space semiconductor packaging, especially when it's rideshares to LEO; the Exploration Company wouldn't struggle to get into space if the Falcon 9 wasn't a thing, it'd just have to pay someone else more[1], and no particular reason to doubt its ability to deliver on its longer term plan to develop its own launch capability either. Doubt that SpaceX would want to operate a Falcon 9 without any chips on board or locally-packaged COTS parts either! [1]if Europeans wanting IODs of their reentry capsules for some reason couldn't use SpaceX, ArianeSpace absolutely has the technical ability to take the equivalent to Transporter mission payloads to the same orbits at the same launch cadence (this was the 14th Transporter rideshare mission since 2021), but obviously price-sensitive rideshare customers aren't going to use it whilst US and Indian launches are options, and much cheaper ones. Extra cost might be a dealbreaker for some less well funded space startups, but not for the company we're talking about here...
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> launch is at least as commoditised as space semiconductor packaging Cadence and national origin de-commoditise launch. > the Exploration Company wouldn't struggle to get into space if the Falcon 9 wasn't a thing, it'd just have to pay someone else more And wait longer. Higher cost, uncertainty and lead times challenge project viability. > ArianeSpace absolutely has the technical ability to take the equivalent to Transporter mission payloads to the same orbits at the same launch cadence Arianespace has a negligible fraction of SpaceX’s launch cadence. Europe doesn’t have the ability to build e.g. a LEO constellation with its own rockets, or replace destroyed orbital materiel in a conflict as quickly as China or America can.
- Aeolun 1y agoThe execution is possible. The funding is a whole lot harder.
- whiplash451 1y agoThey’re solving the funding problem too apparently. It’s great to see a company blow past the usual reasons mentioned by European naysayers.
- gsibble 1y agoEuropean spacecraft......launched in the US by SpaceX. Hilarious.
- whiplash451 1y agoWhy is that hilarious? 1. The Exploration Company builds shuttles, not launchers 2. The US had to rely on Russian shuttles for decades after the Challenger drama Space is hard and sarcasm not useful.
- pcardoso 1y agoDon’t forget the JWST was launched by an Arianne rocket…
- signatoremo 1y agoNot because there was no American launch option, but because Europe wanted to be able to use the telescope, so launch cost was their contribution. Ariane 5 is more than capable of course.
- upoisnd2mny 1y agoi used to be just as shortsighted but that's not how money and building civilisations works. the US picked an entirely different set of constraints and thus dominated the past decades with ease. the EU on the other hand, handles and will handle millions of refugees to come, pay for their education and it will be imperative to expand the job markets. and industries. this should, theoretically, within 10 years, "change the game" again. "European", "US", "Asian" is just a sponsorship tag with the teams, hardware and knowledge supply chains being globalised anyway, if I am not wrong.
- whiplash451 1y ago> European", "US", "Asian" is just a sponsorship tag with the teams That sounds simplistic. They each have vastly different governance principles and philosophical views about the economy.
- fxtentacle 1y agoIn my opinion, the key information: "SpaceX required [..] nearly $3 billion [..] The Exploration Company would require a similar amount [..] It is not possible to raise that money from private capital markets right now by promising a great return a decade from now." In other words: All the investors are looking for a quick buck. Nobody is willing to invest into the longer-term future anymore.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Nobody is willing to invest into the longer-term future anymore SpaceX raised private capital. It continues to raise private capital. (It still tapped into public coffers for Crew Dragon, though, because the demand side of that market remains entirely public.) It could do this because NASA had committed to the Artemis programme. That’s the demand. ESA has no similar promise of returns for a private backer; giving money to these guys strikes closer to a grant or donation than investment.
- agos 1y agoRight now you can’t say much about NASA long time commitment either
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> you can’t say much about NASA long time commitment either Of course one can. Those plans could change. But they were set and funded and that inertia appears to be saving them [1]. ESA has nothing similar planned. (Beyond collaboration [2].) [1] https://yellowhammernews.com/u-s-senate-directive-would-revive-artemis-iv-v-protect-huntsvilles-nasa-jobs-and-ensure-american-dominance-in-space/ https://yellowhammernews.com/u-s-senate-directive-would-revi... [2] https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-european-space-agency-formalize-artemis-gateway-partnership/ https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-european-space-agency...
- 1y ago
- matiascoin 1y agoHungarians in space , small country but mighty people. We should just change the government
- up2isomorphism 1y ago“Mission possible” does not sound like a good name for this kind of situation.
- whiplash451 1y agoI actually like it and it seems like it turned out reasonably well.
- xnx 1y agoVery confused why any company would pursue human spaceflight. Are there enough ultrarich interested in this type of joyride to make the endeavor profitable?