9 ms·
Few Americans pay for news when they encounter paywalls
- whycome 1y agoDoes the rise of paywalls also correlate to an increasingly politically divided public? Echo chambers can be reinforced if wider and balanced voices are behind paywalls
- teeray 1y agoNobody wants a subscription to the Podunk Nowhere Times—they just want to read the one damn article they published this decade that is actually interesting.
- yorwba 1y agoPeople in Podunk Nowhere might want to read it more often. And everything about Podunk Nowhere Times' monetization structure will be designed around those repeat customers, not people who visit their website once a decade. If you hit a paywall and don't want to pay, most likely you're not the target audience anyway.
- chaostheory 1y agoApple News gives me access to most of the popular paywalled news sites at a reasonable price. I think Bloomberg is the only one that’s not covered.
- janandonly 1y agoToo bad I still don’t have that service in my European country.
- PaulHoule 1y agoLies are free but the truth costs money.
- crabmusket 1y agoYep, because the truth is hard to vary but lies have few constraints.
- PaulHoule 1y agoLies have their own pataphysics. In my mind "fake news" is characterized not so much by its falseness but by the way it plays on people's emotions. News gathering, on the other hand, means riding a regional jet coach to a flyover state, talking to people you don't know, working for six months on a data project and sometimes putting your life on the line. [1] The sad thing is that most clicks to The New York Times are for the editorial page where the likes of Ezra Klein, Paul Krugman, David Brooks and Charlie Blow blow it out their ass every day. [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Bolles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Bolles [2] It's not whether I agree with them or not but rather that it is all low effort and it sells because it plays to people's emotions. I can see things to agree with or disagree with with Klein's "Abundance Agenda" essay but it's the kind of thing a high-schooler could write as an essay.
- jasonfrost 1y ago>nyt is truth
- ludicrousdispla 1y ago"all news is views"
- h4ck_th3_pl4n3t 1y agoBy this logic, Twitter is truth?
- Ferret7446 1y agoNot really, there's more than an abundance of truth to be had for free, you can even pick what truth you want, from the boring "aligns with my beliefs" to the more exciting "makes me slightly uncomfortable" and even spicier than that when you're looking for a complete makeover.
- MathMonkeyMan 1y agoI don't want to read the news often enough that I'd pay for a subscription. Not anymore, anyway. Maybe I should go back to paying [7 bucks](https://store.nytimes.com/products/print-newspapers https://store.nytimes.com/products/print-newspapers) every time I want to sit down and read the news.
- warkdarrior 1y agoI subscribe to a print newspaper every day, it's about $2.35 per day, delivered to my house.
- joshka 1y agohttps://archive.is/MaMdu https://archive.is/MaMdu
- ProllyInfamous 1y agoHilariously enough, this Pew article would not have been worth having paid any subscription term to have read. I would, however, have donated a nickel.
- donatj 1y agoI was pondering this earlier today while manually prepending archive.is to a pay walled link on my Android phone for the umpteenth time today. The micro-transaction proposals everyone cried about in the early 2000's would have been so much better than this. The odds of me paying for a subscription for some tiny local newspaper on the other side of the country are literally nil, but I'd be far more willing toss you a penny or two to read the content of a single article.
- nlawalker 1y agoI’d even pay a respectable amount more than that, but it needs to take like 3 seconds tops with no typing. Heck, the faster it is, the more likely I’d be to impulse buy more content from the same place. I’d be fine with some up front work to create an account and associate a payment method or something, but not on each individual site. PayPal pretty much fits the bill for me for most transactions, where is PayPal for microtransactions?
- SpaceNoodled 1y agoBRB gonna make Superman 3 money
- greyface- 1y agoIn addition to being frictionless, it needs to be anonymous - if the publisher ends up receiving my full name, email address, phone number, and/or postal address, then I'll continue to choose piracy.
- salawat 1y agoCongratulations. You've proposed something dead on arrival in our current regulatory regime. You can't have financial transfers like that. Only criminals want/need that. What are you, some sort of money launderer? No electronic funds transfer without that transparency of origin, says the man in Washington.
- 1y ago
- cypherpunks01 1y agoDid all the pay-per-article services fail (like Blendle) or are there any decent ones remaining?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- kevin_thibedeau 1y agoI would pay for news if I knew I could cancel easily without jumping through ridiculous hoops. I'd really like to get a NYT subscription but that'll never happen so long as they have their Kafka inspired cancellation process in place.
- Cerium 1y agoSame! I have contemplated it many times since the content is consistently good and I canceled my local paper after they doubled the price twice in the last couple of years.
- grogenaut 1y agovery agreed, they have tons of good articles which is about as many times as I've been warned never to sign up with them because you cancel.
- apical_dendrite 1y agoYou can subscribe to The NY Times through the App Store and then cancel painlessly just like any other app subscription.
- mertd 1y agoCalifornia has this and it's great. https://calmatters.digitaldemocracy.org/bills/ca_202320240ab2863 https://calmatters.digitaldemocracy.org/bills/ca_202320240ab...
- MrDrMcCoy 1y agoI use privacy.com proxy cards for this. Don't even bother unsubscribing most of the time, I just cancel the card and let nature run it's course :)
- hiq 1y agoLegally, can't they let the subscription run and say you owe them the money?
- 1y ago
- usrusr 1y agoIn the ad-fundeed years, we got used to not feeling tied to the opinion bias of one or two publishers. Even if effectively we are tied, not really routine-checking more than one of two news sources, it would feel like a huge loss loving ourselves down by a subscription or two, as we did in the paper age (those of us old enough to remember). Publishers need to find some way to recreate that universal access feeling of the ad years with a subscription. Everything else feels like a downgrade from freeloading and nobody wants to pay for a downgrade. One model that could work, I think, is if there was some "inverse syndication" mechanism: you subscribe on your "home news source", but it also gets you some form of "paying visitor" access on other sites that are completely unrelated except for being on the same "inverse syndication" network. That network would then do some crude redistribution based on views, like how (I think?) the Spotify subscription gets distributed: a view by a user with few cross-publisher views would give more redistribution than a view by a user that spends the entire day consuming "inversely syndicated" content. Distribution rules would be something end users would not have to be concerned with, same for defining what exactly publishers are expected to include in "paying visitor" access (I think it should be allowed to be a little worse than "home news source" access?). The key requirement would be that participating sources would have to be all shades of claiming neutral (instead of just one side of the aisle), and ideally also regional, from all regions (just like adtech gave us the possibility to "pay" with local ads on a regional news site half a planet away). So why not "Spotify for news"? Because no trade wants to give away the keys to their entire effective market. I'm looking not only at Spotify's (+Apple, Google, Amazon) grip on the music industry, also at booking.com's (+AirBnN) grip on lodging. Journalism absolutely cannot want that. They need to get their stuff together and federate a coop.
- lazyasciiart 1y agoI would pay double my local newspaper subscription if it would get me access to a couple dozen articles from other newspapers each month, especially regional papers where I’m never going to subscribe for that one-off piece about a friend but I want them to survive.
- timewizard 1y ago> I think, is if there was some "inverse syndication" Or just a clearinghouse model. I buy a "news pass" loaded with some amount of credits. When I go to a site I can choose to use these credits to read full articles. Perhaps just having the pass gives me a longer preview than non pass holders. > grip on the music industry It's the other way around unfortunately.
- k310 1y agoMicropayments never went anywhere, so how about this? Part of the exorbitant highwayman fees collected by ISP's could buy credits for content creators. A bazillion risky online payments is the problem, not the solution. Breaches are a matter of when, not if. Paywalls incresse the digital divide. Lies and hate will always be free. Democracy Dies Behind Paywalls. Graphic (imgbb) https://i.ibb.co/d663L0X/waoi.jpg https://i.ibb.co/d663L0X/waoi.jpg
- theamk 1y agoso, how does one get to be a "content creator" and how much money to the pay? If it's going to be per-view, who is going to be fighting ad^H^H view fraud, and what would be their incentive to do so? If this this going to be fixed amount per content creator, why won't every random person sign up to be one?
- k310 1y agoI was thinking that you get credits to spend as you choose. Smacks of "free market" :-) Monopolists and gatekeepers will hate the idea. So, I decide that 5 credits are too much to pay NYT for news that everyone knows, or some outlet that smacks of having LLM's write everything, so I spend them rewarding some freelance writer or artist. If NYT does some outstanding research, I'll pay some credits for it. Freedom of choice. A radical idea for media. Indies need equal footing.
- theamk 1y agoSo, how does this work concretely? Is there a HTML snippet/button that each site must embed? If so, it'll be gamed/frauded like crazy, kinda like with ads today. Except unlike ads, there is no incentive to keep fraud away, so all the credits will likely go to people who know how to game the system. Or is there a page hosted by your ISP where you allocate where the credits go? If so, which fraction of ISP subscribers will be visiting it? And if they do visit it, what are the chances they'll still remember the name of that freelance writer or artist, and not just pick a well-know/popular brand instead? Or some sort of (again, ISP-provided) browser/browser plugin? If so, how many people would install it? I certainly would not trust _anything_ my ISP provides.
- grogenaut 1y agohaving been screwed by multiple peridocials when I wanted to cancel I'm very suspect on signing up again. and when I did It was such a pain to stay logged in. Archive.is is easier. If they fixed that and allowed simple cancellation I'd actually consider it. and as others have said I don't need to be contacted by you. The amount of unasked for marketing emails I get is insane these days. yes I can opt out but every baseball game I go to I get enrolled without asking. Every purchase I make, that's 5 emails a weeek.
- charbelnicolasg 1y agoImagine having to pay mostly for propaganda and fake news... No, thank you.
- tonyedgecombe 1y agoRead the news and you are misinformed, don't read the news and you are uninformed.
- asimpletune 1y agoI sincerely believe many of our societal issues could be resolved if, somehow, people started paying for stuff again.
- yuretz 1y agoAnd vice versa, many of our societal issues would go away, if companies won't only be concerned about profits. Let's not blame the players for the game rules being flawed.
- Workaccount2 1y agoEveryone is only concerned about profits. The reason corporations are greedy isn't because they just love money, it's because you love money too and those corporations are taking your money. And just like them you care a lot about money too. I'm continually upset that it took me 15 years to realize this.
- spencerflem 1y agoCorporations are way more shameless then people, because they are not people. My needs are met right now, I genuinely don't need any more money. I would take less even if it meant working at a place whose mission I vibe with more. No amount of money would get me to build surveillance devices or slot machines or lie about how much I'm polluting. I pay taxes and vote for candidates that would increase them to better provide for everyone.
- selfhoster11 1y agoWe can, and should, fight a game that is unfair. We should blame players who play the game unironically without acknowledging the harm in some way.
- _Algernon_ 1y agoIt's a bit of a chicken and egg problem though, isn't it? Everything is so enshittified that very little (including news) is worth paying for.
- _wire_ 1y agoWho wants to pay to be told what to think?
- ggm 1y agoThe value proposition shifted. I subscribed to print paper and they had a model: hook you in on a dollar a week, move you up to a dollar a day. Now. .. the model is "subscribe to our mega package for $29.95" and I'm nup. And when I did hit up wapo on $1 the nag was endless. So much spam. Guys, the field is huge, do $1 a month and then work me to $1 a week. And cut the spam.
- CSSer 1y agoI knew someone who worked for Gannett. He told me that the churn rate for their subscription numbers were insane. I asked him why he thought this was the case and he just laughed. You see, they do this promotion where it starts at a reasonable figure and then much later jumps to one that is not reasonable. The reason he found this funny, he said, is that they spent incredible amounts of money doing data analysis, surveying, and remarketing to try to identify the cause for that rate and reduce it. All of this despite the obvious answer staring them right in the face.
- ggm 1y agoThis I believe. From print media days, I was told by an industry insider the "make your model with free parts every month" magazine churn was enormous, they were in profit from part 2, which is why they even hit "part 2 free with part 1" because they didn't want to admit parts 3 onward weren't coming. The sell was to ad-land, to all intents and purposes the customer didn't exist beyond the first sell. Could be rockets, cakestands, wedding dress or cookoo clocks. Same model same outcome.
- spacemule 1y agoThis sounds interesting, but I cannot understand what you're saying. Could you dumb this down a bit for someone with no experience in marketing/sales?
- ggm 1y agoThere is a class of magazine aimed at fanatics for some things. Let's say its steam trains. Or dolls. You gin up a mock-up magazine, and sell advertising space in this proposed magazine, predicated on the target audience. When you've sold enough to be in profit, you go into print. Typically there is a free gift in part 1, or a model to be constructed from parts included in the magazine with an implication parts 3,4,5.. will be published in due course. A common sell was to include part 2 with part 1 free. It somehow built belief. If a significant proportion of magazines sold resulted in a subscription you might go ahead but in practice you didn't bother printing volume 3 onward. My contact from the biz said they'd repeated this model many many times.
- bigbacaloa 1y ago[dead]
- Animats 1y agoMost major news sources now have paywalls. NYT, Washington Post, CNN, Reuters... The legacy broadcast networks just dislike ad blockers, though. Fox News, One America News Network, and Breitbart News remain freely available. This is a problem.
- ruined 1y agogood news doesnt pay for itself and neither does bad news
- janandonly 1y agoWhich Europeans remember Blendle? You put a few € into your account and then you browsed all popular magazines and news papers. If you saw an articled of interest you bought it for 10-70 cents. Nowadays they don’t work with that model anymore, unfortunately. The next best thing we have now is zapping on Nostr. Install the Primal.net app and find out for yourself ;-) The concept of “zapping” small amounts of money to others for their texts or memes is one of the things that makes the Nostr social network so much more fun that Twitter. I only wish more websites supported the ability to “zap” an article that I enjoyed.
- guerrilla 1y agoThese kind of things still exist. Libraries often have them. I think it might just be a case of weak marketing. We don't hear about them.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- selfhoster11 1y agoA $0.70 article is not a micro-transaction, just a regular transaction.
- 486sx33 1y ago[dead]
- Ferret7446 1y agoDevil's advocate, the best solution to this would be a cryptocurrency protocol that could actually scale to micro transactions along with sufficiently good UX. It needs to be trivial for anyone to tip anyone a few cents here and there.
- martin_a 1y ago> best solution to this would be a cryptocurrency No. Cryptocurrencies are never a solution to anything. Don't lie to yourself (or others).
- ChaoPrayaWave 1y agoMost people don’t pay because the flow is broken. You’re curious, you click, and then you hit a wall. The moment is gone. It's not about money, it's about momentum.
- enraged_camel 1y agoNot really. Even sites that make payments optional and present the dialog after you've been on the page for some time aren't successful.
- amelius 1y agoWe need more paywalls in social media feeds.
- gethly 1y agoThis is interesting because about next month, I'll start working on paywall as a service to add to Gethly.com platform. There are few challenges with this and I am not surprised we have not seen much traction with this.
- littlecranky67 1y agoNews is technically stuck in the 2000s. I would pay a Netflix-like subscription of 10$, but would not want to install custom Apps for each and every news product that tracks me. Send me the newspaper in an open format (pdf, epub, mobi) everyday via Email - that is a news subscription worth paying for.
- Daisywh 1y agoMaybe the problem isn't why people won't pay, but why the news industry still thinks the old model works. People are willing to pay for music, games, coffee, but news isn't engaging or pleasurable anymore. It's more like spinach: good for you, but you don't crave it.
- keiferski 1y agoBut does it actually matter in terms of what happens in the world? My impression is that people deeply involved in business, politics, etc. do pay for the news, and often pay for multiple subscriptions to things like the NYT, The Economist, Financial Times, etc. and they all seem to be doing just fine financially. News simply might not be a mass market product, at the end of the day.
- spencerflem 1y agoThe Guardian is the only good US news site, and it doesn't have a paywall. I donate and reccomend others do as well.
- techright75 1y ago[dead]
- presbyterian 1y agoI just wish they had good RSS support
- jimnotgym 1y agoI wouldn't be suprised if few Americans (proportionately few) read quality news at all. People seem more interested in forming into tribes
- bell-cot 1y agoPre-web, when high-quality news seemed to actually exist, and I could just pay for dead-tree editions of that, I did. Probably over $2k/year, in today's money. Now - most newsrooms have been gutted, once-great magazines like Scientific American are sick parodies of their former selves, supposedly top-tier news sites are full of click-bait drivel, they monetize your personal information every way they can, and cancelling your subscription may require lawyer. I pay $0/year.
- postexitus 1y agoIt would be interesting to compare this with The Guardian's model - it's not paywalled, but you are encouraged to donate / subscribe (similar to Wikipedia). I have not only subscribed to digital edition, but also included physical delivery later. I think people would be more willing to pay after receiving a knowledge service, seeing the quality and being satisfied with it.
- techright75 1y ago[dead]
- wkat4242 1y agoYes I subscribed too in the past. Few good news sources that are as aligned with me. I dropped them during Brexit though, i got sick of the topic. And never subscribed physically, too difficult and annoying when not living in the UK. But Brexit moved me from a slight "like" of the UK to a definite "dislike" and I've cut most of my ties with it. The guardian suffered. I might have stayed if they'd made a Brexit-news-free front-page but that must have been a sensitive topic inside the UK. Sometimes their front page was half Brexit news and I was so sick of it.
- stared 1y agoI pay for a subscription -> a year later I see that I paid $ for something I barely read. At the same time, I would love to pay $2 (a half of a cup of coffee) or so for a quality article. Most people, as I understand, would rather waste their time and attention than pay anything.
- UmGuys 1y agoI would certainly have negative money if I subscribed to every prompt. How would a person even manage that? The emails. You would have to hire someone to unsubscribe. The model clearly isn't functional. It seems like only the entertainment outlets can afford to be free. So we have MAGA and really wild people.
- lynx97 1y agoMost news aren't worth a penny. Whining about people not wanting to pay for your "tomorrow out of-date"-lies is pretty pretentious.
- timbit42 1y agoBut some are. The problem is people don't know how to figure out which ones are.
- _Algernon_ 1y agoIs that a problem with people or with the news itself? And are people incapable or just unwilling to sift through the haystack? And if it is a problem with the news or people are simply unwilling to sift through the haystack, why should we expect people to pay for that privilege?
- kelnos 1y agoOf course I don't pay for news. I had a WaPo subscription for a couple years, but I cancelled at some point once I felt Bezos was exercising too much editorial control. Most of my news comes from aggregators, where every day I click through to many sites that I may have never visited before, and may never visit again. Even sites I will come back to, I might read 3 or 4 articles a month. That's not worth $15/month to me. Even if it was something more reasonable like $2/month (for that quantity of articles), I'm not going to subscribe to a news source (or lots of sources) when I don't actually visit their sites directly; it's like roulette through the aggregators. If I hit a paywall, I'll mostly just close the tab. Occasionally I'll see if it's on archive.is, if it's a topic I'm really interested in, but if I'm clicking through from something like Google News, odds are there's another site without a paywall that is discussing the same thing.
- robertlagrant 1y agoI think this would need to be integrated into web browsers as a standard or as an extension. You have a chunk of money you've prepaid to a service, and that service lets you pay (makes you pay?) $0.05 for viewing an article, and remembers that you did it, and the paywall gives you the option to instantly pay with PayService. Of course then PayService will have surge pricing turned on. And that will be fun. But still - viable?
- skeezyboy 1y ago[dead]
- diogolsq 1y agoThat shows the danger of the clickbait economy. A weird, provocative headline creates misinformation. Of the people who try to access the article, only 12% actually read it (1% who pay, and 11% who bypass the paywall). Another 53% look for the information elsewhere, which may or may not clarify the misinformation. And those are only the ppl that tries to read the news, the majority of ppl doesn't even bother trying to open the news link.
- Ylpertnodi 1y ago> Another 53% look for the information elsewhere, which may or may not clarify the misinformation. How is the number '53%', calclated? Whilst I'm here... If the 53% got the information [they looked for], and it thereafter WASN'T 'misinformation', would that be considered a good, or a bad, thing?
- diogolsq 1y agoLate reply. There are two groups: 1. The ones who go after the news (a minority). 2. The ones who don’t even bother reading the article (the vast majority). From group 1, we have those numbers. Yes, potentially those 53% could read the news in full in another place and avoid falling for the misinformation. So, out of the people who read, I know for a fact that 12% — plus some chunk of the 53% — might be able to clarify the misinformation. The numbers still stack up for the people who fall for misinformation in headlines.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- uzername 1y agoI've been paying for NYT for five years. I remember the NYT paywall before that. I've been interested in local news so after my 5th hit in recent memory hitting my local newspaper's paywall, I finally bought a year subscription. On the other hand, my mom used to read the physical newspaper. She would buy it at the gas station. She refuses to buy any type of news online. So it's unfortunately all Facebook and YouTube news shorts slop for her now.
- dzonga 1y agopaying for the physical paper made sense specially for local papers - since relevant local ads/ opportunities were in those papers. now the major papers just run propaganda under the veneer of news - looking at you NYT. now why would you pay for biased coverage for a piece of news & not even see the relevant business opportunities / ads ? internet ads are personalized but don't make you 'money' ie show you opportunities such as RFQs/tenders/jobs requested by local businesses as it was back in the paper days.
- Hilift 1y agoI'm not paying for something that is more annoying on mobile than on a notebook or desktop. You want money you should learn how to interact with humans.
- tim333 1y agoI'm surprised "other" is only 2%. I bypass most paywalls with a couple of chrome extensions. (bypasspaywalls and the archive.is one).
- JohnFen 1y agoI pay for sites that I frequent. For the ones where I'm just interested in a single article, I would be willing to pay to read it if the price for it were reasonable and I didn't have to subscribe or have an account.
- _Algernon_ 1y agoThe only way I would consider paying for news[^1] is if they removed all the negative first and second order effects of advertisements and clickbait for paying subscribers. In other words: - Neutral front page with informative titles and headings that are designed to inform, not make me click. Articles written from the ground up with the inverted pyramid[^2] in mind. - Remove most "psuedo-events"[^3] based "reporting", and if not analyse them critically. - Pretend that the 24h news cycle doesn't exist. Update at most once a day. - Do proper investigative journalism. - Be conscious of the 5 filters outlined by Chomsky in Manufacturing Consent and actively resist them. In short, the news should live up to the narrative of being the fourth estate it claims legitimacy from, instead of being an entertainment product serving the lowest common denominator in terms of audience. (This will of course never happen.) [^1]: With the possible exception of being forced to pay for my nation's public broadcaster through taxes. [^2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_pyramid_(journalism) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_pyramid_(journalism) [^3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_event
- mystified5016 1y agoMore people might be willing to pay for news and journalism than we are to pay for ads, clickbait, ragebait, and ""entertainment"".
- sotix 1y agoReminds me of the YouRube extension DeArrow[0], that renames videos and replaces the thumbnail with an accurate still from the video to make the content less clickbaity. It’s a seriously valuable change in my experience. [0]: https://dearrow.ajay.app/ https://dearrow.ajay.app/
- 113 1y agoDo you know if it uses AI to generate any of the titles?
- _Algernon_ 1y agoIt's crowdsourced (at least that's what it says on the site). Same creator as sponsorblock, so it's built on the same principle.
- rascul 1y agoI pay for LWN. I will not pay anything for the garbage called mainstream news.
- mensetmanusman 1y agoNews agencies should have immediately merged after google was formed to create a counterbalance to google earning all the profits of news and destroying journalism by accident.
- hedora 1y agoThey did. Something like 99% of local news outlets are gone or were acquired. Now, the remaining ones are centralized enough to be effective propaganda outlets.
- mmh0000 1y agoFor anyone using Kagi, you can set up a custom bang to get you to achieve.is: https://kagi.com/settings?p=custom_bangs https://kagi.com/settings?p=custom_bangs Redirect: "https://archive.is/newest/%s" Bang: a [X] URL Encode Then, when I hit a paywall, just prepend "!a " into the URL Bar and boom content! // Yes, I'm aware I could do a bookmarklet or whatever, but the Kagi solution works across all my digital addictions and only has to be configured once.
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoSuppose this report is more about behaviour and the UX of paywalls rather than subscriptions. But meanwhile was under impression that digital subscriptions at key players were rising rapidly in the last 3-4 years. Data points like NYT digital subscriptions having banner years up like 1M subscribers over last year, and sub sports site The Athletic turning a profit for the first time since acquisition in 2022. And what about sources closer to home here like The Verge introducing paid options recently? How's that working out?
- AlwaysRock 1y agoI would if they were more affordable or consistently offered a pay $1 to view this one post option. My local news paper is $17 a month for digital or $45 a month for print and digital for a paper that prints three day a week. I know news isnt cheap but... I just cant justify that for what is a pretty OKAY newspaper. They mostly repost national news and cover local elections or town issues. Oh and lots of ads or "Partner articles" I'm glad they exist but if they went away, which I'm sure they will eventually, I wouldnt really miss it. $10 a month could be reasonable. I know they must have done the numbers but I imagine there are a lot of people like me who want to support x news org but just cant justify the only very limited payment options that are offered.
- anonfordays 1y ago[flagged]
- ectospheno 1y agoWhen I was a child in the 1980’s I was blissfully unaware that many adults around me were convinced the world was about to end. I went to school, came home to read and ride my bicycle, then went to bed. I didn’t really care the news existed or bother trying to consume it. After reaching adulthood I wondered why the situation was now different. Why did I read so much of it? Why did I care? Was the news I was reading important or was this just a thing adults did and bandwagons are fun? It took me a bit to realize the economics at play. The valuable part of the news transaction isn’t the news. Properly reported news is the relaying of factual data. The portion of our transaction that has value is my time. I as a consumer have a fixed amount of time in the day to be presented with things I’m supposed to pay dollars to consume. “Cheap” news outfits dispense with the pretense and load me up with ads. “Reputable” news outfits can’t do that so they are forced to make the news itself be the thing I pay for. But the news sites that want the most money have the longest time to publication and are selling editorials rather than facts. What sane person pays for that with money, much less their time?
- tmaly 1y agoWith search transitioning to AI previews and traffic to news sites dropping substantially as a result, how long will the news business model last?
- SllX 1y agoFor as long as there is financial gain to be had from it, business and investment news will continue to be a profitable niche. Sports also seems to do just fine, I don’t personally understand Sports very well, but even from an outsider perspective, there continues to be a lot of money and emotional investment in Sports, and that includes coverage of Sports. Not sure anything else is safe, but they weren’t exactly in a safe position prior to AI either.
- metalman 1y agohere is the crux of it, new term, "adverstalking" say you are just a tiny bit dopy and off you game, something interesting, harmless, relaxing, evoctive of some dream, pops up, you click, for one fleeting sub second moment there is a nice layout, plenty of text, pic's ,and the blam, the midway carnival jams back in and picks up where it lost you earlier, and well.at a certain number of repitions, it is a take up arms or walk away decision, and 99.99999999999% walk away, some few go all in on adbusting and firewall penetration as a proxy for squishing heads, but there is no one who does not find themselves shaking a clenched fist, which personaly I channel into my biggest smileyest bright eyed cheshire,I am overjoyed face, double down and find some new way to decouple from the asymetric market and do what I can for myself and the people I have made promises to.
- rdm_blackhole 1y agoI am not from the US but I can relate. I don't watch the news, I don't want to waste time on it and avoid it as much as possible. Journalists an news organizations were supposed to be the ones keeping governments in check by digging up the skeletons of those who call themselves leaders today. Instead a lot of the news is now clickbait and attention seeking and many news organizations are actually financed by governments (BBC, Al Jazeera, France 24 and so on...) thereby removing any hope of having an unbiased news source because you simply don't bit the hand that feeds you. If I want to know facts, I'll buy a book about some specific topic/event 10 years after it happens, so that the whole picture can be understood instead of reading editorials and opinions about ongoing events that most likely will be invalidated by the end of the week. So it is what it is. Not my circus, not my monkeys.
- wkat4242 1y agoNo shit. Who's going to sign up for every site hacker news links to? It's just impossible. I pay for sites I read daily, that really mean something to me. Not the ones i get i linked to twice a month.
- p3rls 1y agoMy website has a dedicated news portal and we don't have a paywall but a guiltwall where we beg for $3 a month like wikipedia does but less obtrusively (it'll even pop through most adblockers until you manually div block it) It has been pretty effective.
- ETH_start 1y agoThe problem isn’t that people won’t pay for news, it’s that the payment mechanisms suck. Subscriptions are high-friction, lock-in models for content people rarely read. What’s missing is an open, low-friction way to pay per article without creating an account, entering card details, or giving up personal data. This is where crypto actually makes sense, as payment infrastructure. A browser wallet on modular extensions of Ethereum, like Base or Arbitrum, could handle sub-cent payments instantly. You could read three articles and be down 3 cents, no login required and no data trail. And if it's all built on open standards, you avoid the usual siloing problems you'd get with Apple or PayPal running the system, like a private company gaining control over a monopoly and abusing that position to extract economic rent. Smart contracts could automate revenue splits between writers and outlets, basically a decentralized Spotify for news, but programmable. And crucially, if payments are peer-to-peer, the biggest regulatory burdens — the terribly thought out KYC/AML anti-privacy laws — don’t apply. Those laws target intermediaries, not end users. That’s critical for making anonymous micropayments viable at scale. Most past micropayment models failed because the rails weren’t there. Now, thanks to upgrades to public blockchain technology, they are, or at least we're getting close.
- scriu 1y agoAsking for a donation, instead of a paywall, could have a better chance to get some cash?
- lincon127 1y agoHonestly if there were a solid, unbiased news source that just covered geopolitics and science, I'd be all over that. But now I just sub to Ground, and that works decently well.
- CHUCKEESH 1y ago[flagged]
- MrDrMcCoy 1y agoTracking subscriptions isn't the problem. The problem is how much work it is to go and unsubscribe from many services. They all have a different process, that they don't make easy to find, and add as much friction as possible to discourage you. If you are trying to clean up your finances and unsubscribe from lots of things at once, it's exhausting. Having a single list of per-service cards that you can run down and click a button to pause or cancel is as much a convenience as it is a relief. As a bonus, it's much easier to see where I've been spending so much money than running through my bank transactions and doing my own tally against their unhelpful categories and mismatched business names. And of course, the spending limits do as much to protect me from myself as it does surprise charges and price increases. It's been an invaluable tool for me, and I heartily recommend it.
- jweatherby 1y agoHey, this is relevant to what I'm working on - I'm building an alternative to subscriptions for online publications. Instead of subscribing to entire publications / blogs, publishers would register their site on this network and configure thresholds and pricing. Add a bit of code to the publication and a paywall will show up, allowing configuration per article and allowing readers to pay for individual articles. The prices would be minimal, amounting to less than a dollar in most cases. i.e. reading articles using micro-transactions. I know it's been tried before, as has been mentioned in this thread, but I thought I'd attack it with a few different angles - web based, no chrome extension, and thresholds to help verify the article is worth it. Check it out here - https://paperwall.io https://paperwall.io Especially considering the nature of this thread, I'd love feedback and what you'd like to see out of a solution like this.