7 ms·
Make sure you press the "c" button in the bottom right. Light is incredibly slow, and everything seems out of reach. I think we'll have a holodeck before we r
by amelius 1y ago
Make sure you press the "c" button in the bottom right.
Light is incredibly slow, and everything seems out of reach.
I think we'll have a holodeck before we reach another star. And maybe that'll be enough.
- beklein 1y agoMaybe light’s insanely fast and space is just huge. It’s all relative ;)
- isolli 1y agoI would say they're two sides of the same coin. The time it takes for light to travel the universe (which makes communication even with nearby stars essentially impossible) is what makes the universe huge.
- neuroelectron 1y agoLuckily FTL communication isn't actually impossible and special relativity only applies to energy and mass.
- krapp 1y agoFTL communication is actually impossible, what are you talking about?
- jordigh 1y agoI can't tell if you're joking or if you know something nobody else does. As far as I know, anything going faster than the speed of causality violates causality. So what are you talking about?
- ClumsyPilot 1y ago> violates causality But we don’t know that casualty is a law of physics, do we?
- IAmBroom 1y agoOnly inasmuch as we don't know that gravity and the Strong Nuclear Force aren't.
- neuroelectron 1y agoDon't conflate causality and special relativity. SR breaks down at both ends of the spectrum, at the event horizon of black holes and in Bose Einstein condensates. That proves that it is an emergent property of observations, statistical behavior of decoherent systems, and not a universal law.
- munksbeer 1y ago> Light is incredibly slow, and everything seems out of reach. Yes, agreed. I find it a little depressing. An unimaginably huge universe, tantalisingly there, but completely out of reach.
- once_inc 1y agoAssuming our models of the universe are correct, and faster than light travel is impossible. There are very strong reasons to believe this, but perhaps we can cheat by stretching and compressing space around us.
- nurettin 1y agoMeh, most of it is just more of the same thing. I'd rather play with a paper plane than float in space.
- sheepscreek 1y agoIt’s not the destination, it’s the journey :)
- ant6n 1y ago10,000 years of empty space to get to the next solar system. Exciting.
- dylan604 1y agoPlenty of time for reflection on one’s choices in life that put them in that situation.
- ant6n 1y agoEspecially generation 143 of 330, they can definitely spend their whole life on that reflection.
- literalAardvark 1y ago
- barrenko 1y agoI really thought hitting "light speed" would just zoom it all in a minute, but nope... So much for my physics preconceptions.
- pdpi 1y ago> would just zoom it all in a minute, The Earth is about 8 light-minutes away from the Sun :)
- barrenko 1y agoI am not liking this fact.
- justusthane 1y agoThe sun could have exploded seven and a half minutes ago and we’d have no idea! Enjoy the next 30 seconds of your life.
- scraft 1y agoWell, if you were traveling at light speed you could move anywhere in the universe instantly. If you are an observer on earth, watching an object move away from you at the speed of light, then it will take a very long time to traverse the tiniest regions of the universe.
- Reubachi 1y agoEr, "instant" here is "relativistic instant." even in a vaccum, light speed travel from the travelers POV still takes time, and said traveler would perceive time passing exactly as occurring in that local space. But yes you're totally correct, the observer on earth would in this time see only the briefest part of my journey's trail due to light from my journey taking "exponentially" longer to travel back to the observer.
- scraft 1y ago
- uncircle 1y agoTrue but doesn’t matter how slow light is. The closest to c your speed is, the shortest the time you experience on board of the space ship. At light speed, space and time cease to exist. You reach destination instantly. So the goal is to create engines that can take us close to light speed. Then the issue is braking (spacetime expands as you slow down…)
- thrance 1y agoIf you travel at relativistic speeds, your trip will appear far shorter to you than to those that stayed on Earth. With a ship able to accelerate at 1G continuously, you can be at the edge of the observable universe in <50 subjective years [1]. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/s4tbry/oc_space_travel_with_constant_acceleration/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/s4tbry/oc_...
- sestep 1y agoNaive question: is accelerating at 1G continuously within the range of what we consider possible?
- Vvector 1y agoIt's a simple question of weight ratios.
- thrance 1y agoNot naive at all. With chemical rockets we can only sustain 1G for a few minutes, so it won't do at all for interstellar flights. There is a known way to achieve 100% fuel efficiency: antimatter. By storing equal parts matter and antimatter, you can fuse them to propel your spacecraft. It's unknown wether or not this kind of engine can actually be made. Alternatively, and even more far-fetched, you could onboard a small singularity. Dumping anything into it will result in it being turned to pure energy at 100% efficiency, through Hawking's radiations. The smallest the singularity, the fastest it radiates, meaning you can sort of control the output. You can create singularities with very large particle colliders. With 100% fuel efficiency you can probably sustain 1G for long enough to reach the nearest stars. You would need a very large spacecraft (on the order of kilometers) for a comparatively very small payload. And it would arrive completely empty at its destination, meaning no turning back. I think I saw someone do the math, but can't find it anymore. Anyway, there are other difficulties. Travelling at .99c means tiny space dust now becomes very dangerous. So does radiations, all made extremely energetic by the Doppler effect. On the plus side, continous 1G means you have artifical gravity for the whole trip.
- Reubachi 1y ago
- clocker 1y ago> Lightly is incredibly slow Its relative! Sitting on a couch and watching the pixel move from the sun to the earth for 8 minutes feels incredibly slow but if you are actually traveling in a light speed aircraft then it won’t feel that slow.
- quchen 1y agoQuite the opposite, much like when skydiving, going really fast without any close reference point makes everything stand still. And in space, there wouldn’t even be (very loud) atmospheric drag to physically remind you about what speed you’re actually going.
- jjbinx007 1y agoI believe the OP was referring to relativity - the closer to the speed of light you get the slower time appears to tick. So if you could travel at light speed you'd arrive at your destination immediately from your reference frame, but much slower from another person's.
- dylan604 1y agoThen what’s up with all of those sci-fi chows where using FTL still takes some amount of time to arrive?
- krapp 1y ago1) it's better for the plot and drama to have travel time. FTL in fiction is always analagous to some known terrestrial form of travel (usually ships and boats) and the limitations and parameters of FTL in a fictional universe shape the narrative in necessary ways. 2) it's assumed within the framework of the fictional universe that time dilation isn't taking place because the actual travel is occurring within an external frame of reference like "hyperspace" or a "warp field."
- mr_toad 1y agoScreenwriters don’t understand much science.
- baxtr 1y agoMe scrolling is faster than the speed of light! Nice.
- schaefer 1y agoDude, chill. We’ve got to preserve causality. :P
- philwelch 1y agoWe’re barely even using our first solar system, it’s way too early to be worried about reaching other stars.
- ClumsyPilot 1y agoExactly, there is free fuel and aluminium just floating by, and we are unable to use them to upgrade our ships or refuel them. Until we make full use of robotics and 3D printing, there is no point of heading far. And we have all the tools. Distant stars will not be settled by a fast small ship travelling from earth. They will be settled by a city sized monolith produced by harvesting and smelting an entire small moon
- philwelch 1y ago> Distant stars will not be settled by a fast small ship travelling from earth. They will be settled by a city sized monolith produced by harvesting and smelting an entire small moon I don’t even think you’d need a whole moon unless it was a tiny one. Nonetheless, by the time we send a ship to another star, building these kinds of large self-contained habitats will be old hat.
- ClumsyPilot 1y agoAll of fiction and discourse fails to consider that the Solar System is actually a huge place and just the period of settling and industrialising it will take hundreds of years. Everyone things that a game breaker technology is better engines, or fusion, or FTL, but they are wrong, the game breaker technology has already happened: 3D printing. If we can manufacture things with minimal infrastructure using local resources, we can that is all we need. And all of it reachable with simple nuclear power and technology we have today.
- ck2 1y agoAlternate view: be thankful things are far apart a gamma-ray burst from a collapsing star closer than 200 light years away would destroy ALL life on earth
- johnnyjeans 1y agoIs light slow? Or is the human perception of time just scaled down as a result of our rapid metabolism and infinitesimality? People historically mistake plants for being inanimate things with no reactivity, that they are far more simple and stupid than they truly are. Outside of a few exotic examples, plants simply operate on a wider timescale that's basically imperceptible without careful and particular observation. It becomes much more apparent how alive plants are when we observe them in a time-lapse. Now realize that plants are still relatively short-lived. The absolute oldest ones only go back to the early neolithic, that's only 14000 years or so. 1000 years is a long time for humans, but probably not for the trees where a single one can live 10x that. From the hypothetical perspective of a star, with a lifespan measured in billions upon billions of years, the entire ecoscape of the world changes in a blink. From the sun's perspective, MENA was green just a very short while ago. Hell, Pangea wasn't that long ago. At this timescale, continental drift would be as apparent as the movement of boats are to humans. Anything that's working at the cosmic scale where the seemingly low speed of light sounds exhausting is most definitely working at this stellar perspective at the minimum. 14000 years of travel might as well be the equivalent of a 10 minute commute to the store. Philosophically speaking, of course.
- eddd-ddde 1y agoI always think of those motor proteins moving along slowly inside our bodies, and wonder if maybe we are just the motor proteins of the cosmic scale.
- M95D 1y agoWe have a long way to go before we learn to move a star (or a rosette). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stellar_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stellar_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klemperer_rosette https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klemperer_rosette
- IAmBroom 1y agoDude, pass the duchy.
- davidee 1y ago
- mr_toad 1y ago> I think we'll have a holodeck before we reach another star. And maybe that'll be enough. I agree, but not because of the relative difficulty of the technology, but because we spend way more on entertainment than space exploration.
- smeeger 1y agoyou would need a ship that is also a city. a traveling space station. or probes. if humanity decided to send a small probe to the nearest foreign star, i wonder how many km/h current infrastructure could accomplish
- lisper 1y agoIt only seems incredibly slow in this model because it doesn't take special relativity into account. If it did, then as you approached the speed of light the Lorentz contraction would make wherever you are heading appear less far away. You can in theory get anywhere in the universe in an arbitrarily short amount of proper time your own reference frame. Of course, you might not survive the G-forces, but that's another matter.
- wafflemaker 1y agoDon't forget gravity drive. No more Gs. And the same technology would give us real artificial gravity, not this nauseous rotation artificial gravity.
- dyauspitr 1y agoYou can accelerate continuously at a comfortable 1g and get to 0.5c in about 5 months. G forces are not the issue.
- lisper 1y agoThe Lorentz factor at 0.5 c is 0.86 so this only reduces your proper travel time by about 15%. Even at 0.9c the LF is only 0.43, so it would still take you 2 years just to get to Proxima Centauri. And as you approach c, 1G acceleration speeds you less and less. And you also have to slow down at your destination.
- munchler 1y agoNot to mention that you also have to survive any collisions with specks of dust in between.
- aledalgrande 1y agoNeed that warp drive
- swyx 1y agowhat's your definition of a holodeck? i only know the one from star wars and thats kind of a toy
- UltraSane 1y agoStephen Baxter wrote a story named The Gravity Mine about the descendants of humanity living after all stars have died. They get energy from black holes but even they are starting to noticeably shrink. Their perception of time is billions of times slower than humans and the upshot of this is that the speed of light would actually seem pretty fast. https://www.infinityplus.co.uk/stories/gravitymine.htm https://www.infinityplus.co.uk/stories/gravitymine.htm
- somenameforme 1y agoDepends on who you mean by we. The universe is weird and it's entirely possible for you or I to travel essentially arbitrarily far in a single human lifetime, easily billions of light years. Relativity doesn't simply work as a speed limit; instead when things approach velocities anywhere near the speed of light, the universe starts contorting itself in really weird ways to maintain the perceived consistency of the speed of light. From the perspective of somebody in a ship moving at relativistic rates, distances would begin to physically contract, and time itself would begin to speed up relative to an at rest observer. Here [1] is a calculator to see what this all mathematically works out to. For instance, you could travel to Andromeda, some 2 million light years away, in about 28 years in a ship that was capable of sustaining acceleration at 1g for 28 years. Of course for everybody back home 2 million years would pass. So if we ever achieve ships capable of this sort of acceleration, life is going to get really weird and non-linear, so far as time is concerned. And this isn't some just some weird fringe theoretical/mathematical thing. For instance GPS satellites have to compensate for time dilation because relativistic effects, though small in this case, would otherwise have a substantial effect. Another example is at things like the large hadron collider. As a convenient effect of relativistic effects, emergent unstable particles exist far longer than they 'normally' would before decaying due to the fact they're moving at relativistic rates. In other words, this is all very real. The only questionable issue is whether we can discover some sort of an energy source capable of accelerating a ship at 1g for tens of years, and develop sufficient shielding for such a vessel. That's still very much in the domain of sci-fi, but simultaneously seems like something that one wouldn't be entirely surprised to see was discovered just a century from now. This was the most tantalizing possibility behind the EMDrive stuff. [2] Well that or infinite energy, but it seems that universe won't be broken quite so easily just yet. [1] - http://www.convertalot.com/relativistic_star_ship_calculator.html http://www.convertalot.com/relativistic_star_ship_calculator... [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EmDrive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EmDrive