10 ms·
Gentle tip from a lifelong aviation enthusiast: wait one week before reading on causation. Exposing yourself to first-week speculation isn’t just unproductive,
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
Gentle tip from a lifelong aviation enthusiast: wait one week before reading on causation.
Exposing yourself to first-week speculation isn’t just unproductive, it’s often counterproductive since the actual findings can rhyme with the false speculation closely enough that you wind up muddling the two in your mind.
- snickerbockers 1y agoI hate so much how whenever something bad happens there's a huge rush to come up with theories that place the blame on some group or ideology you already hated for unrelated reasons. I've stopped paying attention to the news in part because I don't like how disingenuously giddy people get whenever there's a mass-casualty event. I don't even mind morbid curiosity about death and suffering but nobody should ever see it as a benefit to their chosen group-identity.
- bell-cot 1y agoYeah. But jumping to conclusions serves a variety of human emotional needs. And in an attention economy, that means it also serves a large industry's economic needs.
- randomNumber7 1y agoIt speaks for itself that this gets down voted. The game theory problem is probably that if everyone does it you have to do it too. Like I strongly support equals chances, but if I e.g. get discriminated against for being a white heterosexual male -> it kinda forces me to vote against it
- gosub100 1y agoThis is why I despise Trump-bashing. Not that I think he's a particularly great person or leader, but when everything going wrong in the world gets tied back to him, I know it's ideologically driven.
- mattbrewsbytes 1y agoI was just watching something the other day about how jet engines have gotten more efficient and powerful over the last 50 years where commercial airliners really only need 2 engines. All 2 engine aircraft also have to be able to operate on 1 engine as well if there is a failure. One has to wonder if this was a bird strike incident on both engines that maybe having 4 engines would have allowed the plane to circle back around.
- Ichthypresbyter 1y agoWhy would a flock of birds large enough to be ingested by both engines of a two-engined plane not also be large enough to be ingested by all four engines of a four-engined plane?
- Waterluvian 1y agoGood point. We should be discussing eight-engine planes.
- ivan_gammel 1y agoWe should be discussing no-engine planes, since they are obviously safer in such situations.
- FridayoLeary 1y ago
- bartread 1y agoYeah, I think I might wait for the MentourPilot take on this one. I can't see any benefit in speculating. Horrifying that it came down in a residential area with almost all its fuel still on board though. The aftermath is beyond belief.
- FridayoLeary 1y agoYes. Unfortunately this year alone will give him quite a backlog. Every month there's been a couple of disasters or near disasters and there's no apparent connection between any of them.
- bartread 1y agoI haven't by any means been keeping count but it does feel like there have been a lot more incidents that usual this year, and certainly a lot more fatalities. What I can't work out whether that's recency bias, or because I've been watching a lot of MentourPilot with our daughters so I'm simply more attuned to this kind of news, or if there really are more of them. I certainly don't know if the rate of incidents per passenger mile flown is higher than usual.
- jordanb 1y agoProbably chickens coming home to roost on the 2000s-era "flying is ultra-safe now, time to deregulate, disinvest, and capture value from efficiencies"
- 1y ago
- tusim 1y agoI've seen so many speculations from blurry video, spotty adsb data en straight up racism about this crash.
- blitzar 1y agoPro tip from a lifelong life enthusiast: if its breaking news, wait one week - first-week speculation isn’t just unproductive, it’s often counterproductive. Flick through last weeks newspaper if you need reassurance.
- jen729w 1y agoJust read The Economist. Only comes out weekly!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- arjunaaqa 1y ago[flagged]
- Litost 1y agoSimilarly The Guardian has a weekly publication - https://support.theguardian.com/uk/subscribe/weekly https://support.theguardian.com/uk/subscribe/weekly Unfortunately it doesn't appear to have a digital option?
- treetalker 1y agoI can access a digital Guardian Weekly through my public library's online magazines (Hoopla or Libby or some such).
- Litost 1y agoThanks, that's good to know. And I've just seen that you CAN get The Guardian Weekly digital subscription here, free if you've got a print subscription? Though obviously I'm wondering why the Guardian don't advertise this? https://theguardianweekly.pressreader.com/ https://theguardianweekly.pressreader.com/
- 1y ago
- SecretDreams 1y agoThere's footage after takeoff of it descending with the air ram deployed, no engine power, gears down, and flaps up. TBD on the cause, but loss of engines for some reason seems to be the case. I do agree that a lot of info comes out first week that isn't all right. I'm just reciting what's been shown in videos.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> I'm just reciting what's been shown in videos Of unknown provenance, with unknown visual artefacts, et cetera. Even if completely legit, with context and thus chain of causation obscured to the point that discerning ultimate and proximate causes is impossible.
- perching_aix 1y agoI wish every news was held to this standard.
- potato3732842 1y agoThe industry would be substantially smaller. This runs counter to the interested of every existing industry participant.
- perching_aix 1y agoI agree. Not sure if there's any possible alternative worlds where the checks and balances shake out something better either sadly.
- SecretDreams 1y agoAgreed, but it doesn't look like AI. Video(s) look real to my untrained eyes. Everyone is going to speculate regardless of the top level disclaimer. I rather just at least present what data is available as of now. The city the incident took place in has a subreddit. Feel free to go take a look and judge for yourself. It's a bit NSFW at the moment.
- account42 1y agoGentle tip from a lifelong speculation enthusiast: if speculating now is fun for you don't let party poopers stop you.
- jgwil2 1y agoCall me a "party pooper" if you will but maybe you shouldn't be having "fun" with an accident that will have killed hundreds of people.
- randomNumber7 1y agoI think boing messed up the service. They did this because they are parasites that value a few $$ over human life. Everyone knows it after the MAX. Everyone involved in MAX (including engineerings) should get a live in prison without pardon. Sincerely, A fellow engineer
- p3rls 1y ago[flagged]
- fortran77 1y agoAs I've learned from years of reading Hacker News, people who program computers are experts in _everything_!
- M95D 1y agoIf we program computers, it doesn't mean we don't have other jobs unrelated to programming. (At least for some of us.)
- traceroute66 1y ago> Gentle tip from a lifelong aviation enthusiast: wait one week before reading on causation. One week ? Wait until the damn official report comes out. That's how long you should wait. The investigators have access to more than you or any other armchair investigator or journalist will ever do.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Wait until the damn official report comes out. That's how long you should wait For public discourse, one week is fine. At that point you usually have ground facts established. A common official understanding of the known knowns and unknowns is available, together with a good profile of the leading conspiracy theories that one can filter out.
- dylan604 1y agoYou mean like the official report that gave us the magic bullet theory?
- FuriouslyAdrift 1y agoThere's already conspiracy theory crap on social media in India and Pakistan going around. Pretty nasty stuff already.
- dingaling 1y agoA week isn't long enough. Just wait for the official report.
- LanceH 1y agoI mentally earmark a month and wait for something "official" or at least some expert analysis which can be confirmed. I'm not sure what the experts could discern from any video that's out there, but sometimes it's a lot. I'm reminded of the crane collapse in Seattle that had pictures afterward and the pins were no longer in it. The expert analysis I had seen discussing it had said the pins don't just come out in a crane collapse, and where the join the sections the crane would be at its strongest. He was, of course, lit up by those with possible agendas saying "you can't speculate". He was right in the end. So with the crane collapse it was interesting to see it all play out, but it's a matter of keeping perspective. There were literal pictures of the pins not being in place. Explanation that those pins should not be removed until later in the disassembly of the crane. Then there was the other "side" hurling accusations at him. Finally the official report. Keeping perspective to me is that yes, I want to know what caused it. But I'm also interested along the way that some people/companies/govts seem to have a vested interest in shaping the story. So I don't run with any of it, but I try to remember who said what, even though nobody ever seems to be responsible for being batshit crazy.
- gejose 1y agoThe source is a lot more important than the timing. Whenever Pilot Debrief or the AOPA comments on it you know it's going to be reliable. https://www.youtube.com/@pilot-debrief/videos https://www.youtube.com/@pilot-debrief/videos https://www.youtube.com/@AirSafetyInstitute/videos https://www.youtube.com/@AirSafetyInstitute/videos
- Simon_O_Rourke 1y agoCounterproductive towards what end? It's not as if anyone on here is going to be invited to present before the air accident board?
- platevoltage 1y agoThis tip goes for pretty much any non-aviation breaking news as well.
- wkat4242 1y agoIt depends. It also gives the spin doctors time to do their thing, remove tracks etc. For example, when MH17 was shot down by the Russian-backed rebels, they posted celebratory posts to twitter (they thought it was a Ukrainian military transport). Also, pictures of the actual SAM battery were taken as it was rushed back to Russia in the coverup. A few hours later all that got deleted and the spin machine started. "No, there were no Russian SAMs there", "it was a Ukraine fighter jet that shot it down", etc. They even fabricated fake radar tracks. People saying it was a SAM were denounced as conspiracy theorists, stuff like that. Only a year or so later when the official investigation started finishing up, the truth was confirmed. In that case (as the investigation later proved) the earliest information was the most accurate. This is especially the case when there are powerful interests that don't want the truth to come out. Even Boeing covered up the first 737MAX crash. That's why I think it's not a bad idea to read all the speculation. But keeping in mind that there is no definitive answer until the official accident report comes out. Any of the speculation could be true. Or even none of it. And really, getting it 100% accurate in my mind is not something that matters. I just read it as an aviation enthusiast (and ex-pilot). What matters is that the experts writing the report are accurate. And later admiral cloudberg who expertly translates all that into normal-people language :) Whether I have an accurate view of what exactly happened really does not matter in this world. Also, in many cases it is already clear what happened, like that ATR recently that was in a flat spin. The part that isn't clear is how it got into that situation. But the "what happened" is also important and that is one of the things you can often read about early.
- timnetworks 1y agorussia is a tryharderist state
- tim333 1y agoThis is true. I don't entirely trust Boeing, especially since this is looking like a failure of the aircraft systems. If a thousand randos speculate one may guess the right answer.
- hoti232j4324234 1y agoI'm fairly sure a fraction of the "techbro" community has already decided its due to Indian programmers at Boeing, or Indian managers at AI, or some other Indian voodoo in India.